[Immunological aspects of kidney transplantation in Switzerland 1981-1992. Swiss Transplant Work Group Kidney Transplantation]

Every year some 200-260 kidney transplants are performed in Switzerland, improving the quality of life of patients with end stage renal disease. The current organ shortage is delaying transplantation of the 400 patients on the waiting list, a situation which calls for optimal utilization of the available donor kidneys. It is well established that AB0-compatibility, negative cytotoxic crossmatch, and optimal immunosuppressive therapy including cyclosporin A are important for a favorable clinical outcome. To identify further factors influencing transplant outcome, we undertook a retrospective study of all 1656 transplants to which the above criteria applied. We defined transplants matched for at least 1A, 1B, and 1DR HLA antigen as the better matched, and the remainder as the less well matched grafts. In patients who were not or only weakly immunized to alloantigens, the 5-year graft survival probability was 0.78 versus 0.69 for the better versus the less well matched transplants (p < 0.005). The strongly immunized patients did not, however, show a significant association between the degree of HLA matching and graft survival, presumably because there were more immunized patients in the HLA matched group. As expected, the patients previously immunized to alloantigens showed significantly reduced graft survival early after transplantation. Positive CMV serology, sex mismatch, and cold ischemia time did not correlate with graft survival. Compared to results obtained in the USA or Germany, the survival time of donor kidneys transplanted in Switzerland was significantly increased. Factors contributing to the good results in Switzerland are discussed. Future goals are reduction of alloimmunization and optimized HLA compatibility.

Sequential occurrence of IgM, IgM/IgG, and gp120-IgM/IgG complement complexes on CD4+ lymphocytes in relation to CD4+ blood lymphocyte depletion in HIV+ hemophilia patients: results of a 10-year study

The concept of autoimmune mechanisms playing an integral role in the pathogenesis of HIV disease is rapidly gaining ground. In this study, we determined IgM and IgG antibodies, complement fragments and gp120 on the surface of CD4+ lymphocytes using double-fluorescence flow cytometry. Sequential analysis demonstrated an inverse relationship of autoantibodies and CD4+ lymphocyte counts in the peripheral blood. HIV+ patients without autoantibodies (16/104 = 15%) had the highest CD4+ blood cell counts (324 +/- 264/microliters; mean +/- SD). CD4+ counts were successively lower in patients with complement-fixing IgM (243 +/- 240/microliter), complement-fixing IgG and IgM (139 +/- 138/microliter), or gp120-IgM/IgG complement complexes on the surface of CD4+ cells (38 +/- 45/microliter, P = 0.03). Individual patient profiles show that IgM autoantibodies typically are formed early after HIV infection and appear to deplete CD4+ lymphocytes very slowly, whereas complement-fixing IgG autoantibodies are generated at a later stage and deplete CD4+ lymphocytes more efficiently. The presence of both soluble gp120 and complement-fixing autoantibodies on CD4+ lymphocytes is associated with very low CD4+ cell counts and coincides with progression to terminal disease. Early during HIV infection autoantibody production is rather unstable, but it becomes more stable with disease progression and persists in advanced stages of the disease. These data suggest that autoantibody formation against CD4+ lymphocytes is a pathogenic mechanism for CD4+ cell depletion.

In vitro cytokine treatment of B cell defects in HIV-infected hemophilia patients

HIV-infected patients exhibit defects in B cell differentiation and in the IL-6 response of B cells, in association with autoantibody formation against T cells. These autoantibodies have been implicated as important factors in the development of immunodeficiency disease. As the restoration of defective B cell responses might prevent autoantibody formation and the resulting immunosuppression, we studied whether in vitro treatment with recombinant IL-2 (rIL-2), recombinant IL-4 (rIL-4) or recombinant IL-6 (rIL-6) might restore the response of B cells of HIV-infected patients. B cells of 6 HIV-negative hemophilia patients, 4 HIV-positive patients at CDC stage II, III, 4 HIV-positive patients at CDC stage IV, and 6 healthy controls were tested in Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I (SAC-I)-stimulated B cell cultures and Pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-stimulated allogeneic B and T cell cocultures. B cell differentiation was assessed in a reverse hemolytic plaque assay and by ELISA determination of IgM, IgG and IL-6 in culture supernatants. In vitro application of rIL-6 resulted in suppression of both elevated unstimulated and mitogen-stimulated B cell responses in a dose-dependent manner which was in part due to feedback inhibition. PWM- and SAC-I-stimulated IgG and IgM responses, respectively, could be restored after addition of 10 U/ml rIL-2 in HIV-negative patients, but not in HIV-positive patients. Addition of rIL-4 to cultures resulted in suppression of both unstimulated and mitogen-stimulated IL-6 secretion and B cell responses. Severely depressed B cell responses in CDC IV patients were not significantly affected by cytokine application. These results indicate that defective Ig responses in HIV-negative patients may be restored by rIL-2 treatment whereas HIV-induced B cell defects are not corrected by supply of T cell help or cytokines promoting B cell growth and differentiation.

Impaired in-vitro lymphocyte responses in patients with elevated pentachlorophenol (PCP) blood levels

Immune parameters were examined in 188 patients who were exposed for more than 6 mo to pentachlorophenol-containing pesticides. Blood levels of pentachlorophenol, lymphocyte subpopulations, in-vitro responses to mitogenic and allogeneic stimulation, plasma neopterin levels, and plasma cytokine and cytokine receptor levels were determined. Impaired in-vitro lymphocyte stimulation responses were impaired in 65% of the patients. The likelihood of impaired lymphocyte stimulation increased significantly with levels of pentachlorophenol that exceeded 10 microliters/l (p < .05). Patients who had high blood levels of pentachlorophenol and abnormal lymphocyte stimulation also had increased proportions of blood monocytes in blood (p < .05), as well as increased IL-8 serum levels (p < .02). Eleven patients who had abnormal mitogen stimulation experienced decreased CD4/CD8 ratios of < 1.0; 5 of these patients had decreased CD4+ lymphocyte counts of < 500/microliters, and 3 patients had increased plasma neopterin of > 15 nmol/l. These results indicate that increased levels of pentachlorophenol in blood can lead to severe T lymphocyte dysfunction.

[Cellular immune defect caused by postoperative irradiation in patients with squamous epithelial carcinomas of the upper aerodigestive tract]

The effect of locoregional postoperative radiation therapy on cellular immunity was investigated in 11 patients with head and neck cancer. During the course of the radiation therapy, total lymphocyte counts, CD8+ lymphocyte counts and especially CD4+ lymphocyte counts decreased significantly. The mean CD4+ lymphocyte counts dropped from 739/microliters to 183/microliters (p < 0.001) and the average CD4+/CD8+ ratio also decreased significantly. In addition all patients showed impaired in vitro lymphocyte stimulation responses to several mitogens, with reductions found to be 10% to 50% of normal responses. Within 3-4 weeks after radiation therapy there was a slight increase of CD4+ lymphocyte counts and the in vitro lymphocyte stimulation responses showed a tendency to normalization. These results indicate that locoregional postoperative radiation therapy in patients with head and neck cancer can induce a severe impairment of cellular immunity.

Striking inverse correlation between IgG anti-F(ab')2 and autoantibody production in patients with cold agglutination

Previous experiments showed that the physiologic IgG anti-F(ab')2 antibody suppresses the response of human autoreactive B cells. In the present study, we analyzed the IgG anti-F(ab')2 antibody in 293 patients with cold agglutination (CA). Their average IgG anti-F(ab')2 titer was not much different (211 +/- 8.3) from that of 279 healthy persons (195 +/- 6.7). However, CA patients with high anti-F(ab')2 titers had low CA autoantibody titers and vice versa (P = .0028; rho = -0.175). The stratification of patients according to the auto-antibody's specificity (anti-I, anti-i, anti-Pr) showed an inverse correlation between anti-F(ab')2 and CA in the anti-I group (P = .0057; rho = -0.180). Interestingly, the association was present only in patients whose disease was caused by noninfectious agents (P < .0001; rho = -0.423). The inverse correlation argues for an important role of the IgG anti-F(ab')2 in the regulation of autoantibody production in CA patients.

[Prognostic factors in the course of kidney transplantation]

The success rate of kidney transplants is influenced by many factors. Analysis of the largest available collection of transplant data shows a statistical influence of HLA compatibility, immunosuppression with cyclosporin, donor age, preservation solution with preservation times longer than 24 h, and prophylactic treatment with anti-CMV immunoglobulin in transplants from CMV-positive donors to CMV-negative recipients. Type and duration of pretransplant dialysis and recipient age were not shown to have a significant influence. These results demonstrate that the analysis of retrospective data allows a quantitative estimation of the influence of risk factors. This knowledge can be utilized prospectively to improve the transplant success rate.

Effect of the maintenance immunosuppressive drug regimen on kidney transplant outcome

Renal transplant recipients require long-term maintenance immunosuppression for prevention of graft rejection. To reduce harmful side effects, combinations of immunosuppressive drugs are used. The effect on long-term outcome of different drug regimen has not been established. Over 12,000 kidney recipients who initially received triple-drug immunosuppressive therapy (cyclosporine, steroids, and azathioprine) after transplantation were studied. Graft and patient survival rates were analyzed over a 5-year period in relation to the 1-year immunosuppressive regimen. Five-year graft survival was significantly higher in 1270 patients who were changed from triple-drug therapy to steroid-free maintenance with cyclosporine (with or without the addition of azathioprine) (87 +/- 1%) than in 8024 patients who remained on triple-drug therapy (76 +/- 1%, P < 0.0001), 2829 patients on cyclosporine and steroids (79 +/- 1%, P < 0.0001), and 830 patients on steroids and azathioprine (63 +/- 2%, P < 0.0001). Patient survival was also significantly higher in patients on steroid-free maintenance (P < 0.0001). Steroid-free patients received significantly higher doses of cyclosporine than patients on regimens containing steroids (P < 0.0001). The immunosuppressive maintenance protocols that are currently most widely used appear to give suboptimal results. We suggest that discontinuation of steroid therapy should be attempted in renal transplant recipients after they have experienced several months of stable graft function on triple-drug immunosuppression.

Complement activation by recombinant HIV-1 glycoprotein gp120

The mechanism of CD4+ cell depletion in HIV-infected patients is poorly understood. In this study we investigated whether rgp120 can activate the complement system in the absence of anti-gp120 Abs. We found that the complement proteins C4, C3d, C5b-9, and properdin bind to rgp 120-coated CD4+ T cells of healthy individuals when incubated in autologous serum. Activation of the complement system occurred primarily via the classical pathway and was abolished in sera deficient in C1q and C4 as well as in the presence of EDTA. No cell lysis was observed in a lymphocytotoxicity assay using human serum, possibly because of homologous restriction of complement lysis. In contrast, addition of rabbit sera induced lysis of the rgp 120-precoated cells. Cell lysis by rabbit serum was found to be because of naturally occurring IgM anti-gp 120 Abs. The rgp 120, which was immobilized on the surface of microtiter plates activated complement in the absence of lymphocytes. Complement activation by cell-bound HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120 with subsequent opsonization may be relevant for the elimination of noninfected CD4+ T cells in HIV-infected patients.

Complement activation by recombinant HIV-1 glycoprotein gp120

The mechanism of CD4+ cell depletion in HIV-infected patients is poorly understood. In this study we investigated whether rgp120 can activate the complement system in the absence of anti-gp120 Abs. We found that the complement proteins C4, C3d, C5b-9, and properdin bind to rgp 120-coated CD4+ T cells of healthy individuals when incubated in autologous serum. Activation of the complement system occurred primarily via the classical pathway and was abolished in sera deficient in C1q and C4 as well as in the presence of EDTA. No cell lysis was observed in a lymphocytotoxicity assay using human serum, possibly because of homologous restriction of complement lysis. In contrast, addition of rabbit sera induced lysis of the rgp 120-precoated cells. Cell lysis by rabbit serum was found to be because of naturally occurring IgM anti-gp 120 Abs. The rgp 120, which was immobilized on the surface of microtiter plates activated complement in the absence of lymphocytes. Complement activation by cell-bound HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120 with subsequent opsonization may be relevant for the elimination of noninfected CD4+ T cells in HIV-infected patients.

[Effect of HLA compatibility on kidney transplantation]

The influence of the HLA system on the success rate of kidney transplantations was evaluated in a worldwide collaborative study. The results confirm the influence of the HLA chromosome on transplants from related donors. Moreover, a highly significant effect of compatibility for the HLA-A, -B, -DR antigens was observed in cadaver transplants (p < 0.0001). The great importance of a good quality of tissue typing was emphasized by a) the observation that a significant influence of compatibility for the HLA-A, -B antigens was evident only if donors and recipients were typed for 'split' specificities and not when they were typed for 'broad' antigens, and b) an improved effect of HLA-DR compatibility when serological typing errors were corrected by molecular (DNA) typing. Computations show that kidney allocation according to the best possible HLA compatibility results in a gain of 800 transplant function years per 1,000 transplantations over a 10-year period.

Comparative study of antibodies that are associated with disease progression in HIV disease

Two types of antibodies which previously were found to be inversely associated with CD4+ cell counts and which may contribute to the progression of HIV disease were measured in parallel in 55 serum samples of 7 longitudinally tested HIV-infected patients (4 homosexual men, 3 haemophilic men) and in 15 serum samples from 15 patients with advanced AIDS. HIV-infection enhancing antibodies were determined in the presence of near-physiologic human complement concentration using a complement receptor type 2 (CR2) carrying HIV-target cell line. IgG and IgA class autoantibodies directed against human IgG-Fab fragments were measured in specific ELISA assays. In agreement with our previous studies obtained in HIV-seropositive haemophilic patients, significant negative correlations were found between CD4+ cell counts and IgG anti-Fab and IgA anti-Fab antibodies (Spearman correlation coefficient r = -0.587, P < 0.0001; and r = -0.269, P = 0.024, respectively). A significant positive correlation was observed between complement-dependent enhancing antibodies and IgA anti-Fab antibodies (r = 0.408, P = 0.003), whereas the correlation with IgG anti-Fab antibodies was only weak (r = 0.288, P = 0.034). Serum samples with high titres of complement-dependent enhancing antibodies had almost 3 times higher IgA anti-Fab autoantibody activity than sera with low titres (P = 0.0038). Our findings indicate that the two disease markers in HIV disease, enhancing antibodies and autoantibodies directed against the Fab moiety of IgG, are not identical. However, anti-Fab antibodies may contribute to complement-dependent HIV infection enhancement.

HLA class II associations with idiopathic nephrotic syndrome in children

The occasional familial occurrence of idiopathic nephrotic syndrome (NS) points to a genetic predisposition. Reports on associations with certain HLA class II antigens support this hypothesis. In order to define the immunogenetic background of NS more precisely, HLA class II allele frequencies in 161 children with NS were studied by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) typing. The patient cohorts consisted of 87 children from Southwest-France and 74 from Southwest-Germany. The control group consisted of 118 French and 101 German unrelated individuals from the same geographical areas. HLA alleles were defined in patients with steroid-sensitive (SS) and steroid-resistant (SR) NS and in controls. RFLP typing revealed that the previously reported association between SSNS and HLA-DR7 is confined to the RFLP split 7.1 (DRB1*07) with a combined relative risk (RRcomb) of 6.2. HLA-DQB typing showed an increased frequency of the allele DQB2b (DQB1*0201) (RRcomb = 7.8). HLA-DQA typing showed an association of SSNS with DQA3 (DQA1*0201,0301,0302) (RRcomb = 4.1). The highest RR (16.5) for SSNS was found in German patients who carried the two DRB1 specificities 17.1 (DRB1*0301) and 7.1 (DRB1*07). All associations were stronger in SS patients with frequent relapses or steroid dependency than in non- or infrequent relapsers. SR patients exhibited no significant associations with HLA class II alleles.

Association of IgA-anti-Fab autoantibodies with disease stage in head-and-neck cancer

Patients with head-and-neck cancer commonly have immune defects. It was reported that these patients have raised serum IgA levels. We investigated whether IgA-anti-Fab autoantibodies, which occur in association with immune dysfunction, are present in patients with head-and-neck cancer. Sera of 101 patients with squamous-cell carcinoma (SCCHN) and 8 patients with adenoid cystic carcinoma (ACCHN) of the head and neck were tested in ELISA for IgA-anti-Fab autoantibody activity. IgA-anti-Fab serum activity was significantly higher in both SCCHN and ACCHN patients than in healthy controls. In patients with SCCHN, an association between disease stage and IgA-anti-Fab activity was established. Stage-IV patients had significantly higher IgA-anti-Fab than stage-I patients or healthy controls. Stage-II and stage-III patients had intermediate levels. Extremely high IgA-anti-Fab activity was observed in 7 patients who died within 6 months following testing, suggesting a relationship of autoimmunity with terminal disintegration of physiological body functions. IgA-anti-Fab autoantibodies may explain the occurrence of immune defects in patients with head-and-neck cancer.

The influence of HLA compatibility on graft survival after heart transplantation. The Collaborative Transplant Study

BACKGROUND

In cardiac transplantation, it is standard practice for donor hearts to be allocated to recipients without consideration of the extent of HLA matching. Because the HLA system is highly polymorphic, the likelihood that donor hearts will be well matched to their recipients by chance alone is extremely small. It has therefore not been possible in the past to analyze adequately the success rate of transplantation with HLA-matched hearts.

METHODS

We initiated a collaborative study in 1985 to evaluate the influence of HLA compatibility on graft survival in heart transplantation. Data were collected from 104 centers in 24 countries.

RESULTS

Of the 8331 patients, 128 received a graft with no HLA-A, B, or DR mismatches or only one mismatch. This frequency (1.5 percent) corresponds to the rate that would be expected from a random allocation of donor organs. The three-year rate of graft survival correlated strongly with HLA compatibility, decreasing from a mean (+/- SE) of 83 +/- 4 percent for the 128 donor hearts with no mismatches or only one mismatch to 76 +/- 2 percent for the 439 hearts with two mismatches and 71 +/- 1 percent for the 7764 hearts with three to six mismatches (P < 0.001). Multifactorial Cox regression analysis showed that this effect was independent of the age and sex of the donor and recipient, the type of underlying disease, the duration of cold ischemia, and the use of prophylaxis with antilymphocyte antibodies (P = 0.005).

CONCLUSIONS

Graft survival in heart transplantation is significantly influenced by the extent of HLA compatibility.

Isotypes and IgG subclasses of anti-Fab antibodies in human immunodeficiency virus-infected hemophilia patients

We reported recently that anti-Fab autoantibodies of the IgG isotype are associated with the decrease of helper/inducer (CD4+) lymphocytes in human immunodeficiency virus-infected (HIV+) hemophilia patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) or AIDS-related complex (ARC). In the present study we investigated the subclass distribution of IgG-anti-Fab autoantibodies, and whether anti-Fab antibodies of the IgA and IgM isotypes also are associated with the development of AIDS. Sera of HIV+ patients with AIDS had significantly higher IgA-anti-Fab activity than HIV+ patients with ARC (p < 0.02), HIV+ patients without AIDS/ARC (p < 0.0001), HIV-negative (HIV-) patients (p < 0.001), or healthy controls (p < 0.0001). An inverse association was found between IgA-anti-Fab activity and CD4+ cell counts (r = -0.396, p < 10(-6)). In contrast, no association of CD4+ cell counts was observed with IgM-anti-Fab. However, IgM-anti-Fab was significantly increased in patients with thrombocytopenia. We found a significant association between IgA-anti-Fab activity and serum neopterin concentrations (r = 0.310, p < 10(-5)). IgG-anti-Fab activity was detected mainly in the IgG3 fraction, although in HIV+ patients with AIDS/ARC various IgG subclasses were present. Affinity-purified anti-Fab antibodies isolated from sera of AIDS patients bound to rgp120-preincubated CD4+ cells of a healthy individual, supporting our hypothesis that anti-Fab antibodies and free circulating gp120 molecules are involved in the elimination of uninfected CD4+ cells. Removal of anti-Fab autoantibodies from the circulation by immune adsorbance might be a useful approach in the treatment of AIDS.