The presequence of a chimeric construct dictates which of two mechanisms are utilized for translocation across the thylakoid membrane: evidence for the existence of two distinct translocation systems

On the mode of integration of plastid-encoded components of the cytochrome bf complex into thylakoid membranes

Four distinct integration/translocation routes into/across thylakoid membranes have recently been deduced for nuclear-encoded polypeptides of the photosynthetic membrane. Corresponding information for the plastid-encoded protein complement is lacking. We have investigated this aspect with in-organello assays employing chimeric constructs generated with codoncorrect cassettes for genes of plastid-encoded thylakoid proteins, and appropriate transit peptides from six nuclear genes, representing three targeting classes, as a strategy. The three major plastid-encoded components of the cytochrome b (6)f complex, namely pre-apocytochrome f, (including apocytochrome f, and pre-apocytochrome f lacking the C-terminal transmembrane segment), cytochrome b(6), and subunit IV, which differ in the number of their transmembrane segments, were studied. Import into chloroplasts could be observed in all instances but with relatively low efficiency. Thylakoid integration can occurr post-translationally, but only components with secretory/secretory pathway (SEC)-route-specific epitopes were correctly assembled with the cytochrome complex, or competed with this process. Inhibitor studies were consistent with these findings. Imported cytochrome b(6) and subunit IV operated with uncleaved targeting signals for thylakoid integration. The corresponding determinant for cytochrome f is its signal peptide; its C-terminal hydrophobic segment did not, or did not appreciably, contribute to this process. The N-termini of cytochrome b(6) and subunit IV appear to reside on the same (lumenal) side of the membrane, consistent with the currently favored four-helix model for the cytochrome, but in disagreement with the topography proposed for both components. The impact of the findings for protein routing, including for applied approaches such as compartment-alien transformation, is discussed.

Targeting determinants and proposed evolutionary basis for the Sec and the Delta pH protein transport systems in chloroplast thylakoid membranes

Transport of proteins to the thylakoid lumen is accomplished by two precursor-specific pathways, the Sec and the unique Delta pH transport systems. Pathway selection is specified by transient lumen-targeting domains (LTDs) on precursor proteins. Here, chimeric and mutant LTDs were used to identify elements responsible for targeting specificity. The results showed that: (a) minimal signal peptide motifs consisting of charged N, hydrophobic H, and cleavage C domains were both necessary and sufficient for pathway-specific targeting; (b) exclusive targeting to the Delta pH pathway requires a twin arginine in the N domain and an H domain that is incompatible with the Sec pathway; (c) exclusive targeting to the Sec pathway is achieved by an N domain that lacks the twin arginine, although the twin arginine was completely compatible with the Sec system. A dual-targeting signal peptide, constructed by combining Delta pH and Sec domains, was used to simultaneously compare the transport capability of both pathways when confronted with different passenger proteins. Whereas Sec passengers were efficiently transported by both pathways, Delta pH passengers were arrested in translocation on the Sec pathway. This finding suggests that the Delta pH mechanism evolved to accommodate transport of proteins incompatible with the thylakoid Sec machinery.

Secretion of nuclease across the outer membrane of Serratia marcescens and its energy requirements

Extracellular secretion of Serratia marcescens nuclease occurs as a two-step process via a periplasmic intermediate. Unlike other extracellular proteins secreted by gram-negative bacteria by the general secretory pathway, nuclease accumulates in the periplasm in its active form for an unusually long time before its export into the growth medium. The energy requirements for extracellular secretion of nuclease from the periplasm were investigated. Our results suggest that the second step of secretion across the outer membrane is dependent upon the external pH; acidic pH effectively but reversibly blocks extracellular secretion. However, electrochemical proton gradient, and possibly ATP hydrolysis, are not required for this step. We suggest that nuclease uses a novel mechanism for the second step of secretion in S. marcescens.

Import and routing of nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins

Most chloroplast proteins are nuclear encoded, synthesized as larger precursor proteins in the cytosol, posttranslationally imported into the organelle, and routed to one of six different compartments. Import across the outer and inner envelope membranes into the stroma is the major means for entry of proteins destined for the stroma, the thylakoid membrane, and the thylakoid lumen. Recent investigations have identified several unique protein components of the envelope translocation machinery. These include two GTP-binding proteins that appear to participate in the early events of import and probably regulate precursor recognition and advancement into the translocon. Localization of imported precursor proteins to the thylakoid membrane and thylakoid lumen is accomplished by four distinct mechanisms; two are homologous to bacterial and endoplasmic reticulum protein transport systems, one appears unique, and the last may be a spontaneous mechanism. Thus chloroplast protein targeting is a unique and surprisingly complex process. The presence of GTP-binding proteins in the envelope translocation machinery indicates a different precursor recognition process than is present in mitochondria. Mechanisms for thylakoid protein localization are in part derived from the prokaryotic endosymbiont, but are more unusual and diverse than expected.

Protein targeting and translocation; a comparative survey

The last few years has seen enormous progress in understanding of protein targeting and translocation across biological membranes. Many of the key molecules involved have been identified, isolated, and the corresponding genes cloned, opening up the way for detailed analysis of the structure and function of these molecular machines. It has become clear that the protein translocation machinery of the endoplasmic reticulum is very closely related to that of bacteria, and probably represents an ancient solution to the problem of how to get a protein across a membrane. One of the thylakoid translocation systems looks as if it will also be very similar, and probably represents a pathway inherited from the ancestral endosymbiont. It is interesting that, so far, there is a perfect correlation between thylakoid proteins which are present in photosynthetic prokaryotes and those which use the sec pathway in chloroplasts; conversely, OE16 and 23 which use the delta pH pathway are not found in cyanobacteria. To date, no Sec-related proteins have been found in mitochondria, although these organelles also arose as a result of endosymbiotic events. However, virtually nothing is known about the insertion of mitochondrially encoded proteins into the inner membrane. Is the inner membrane machinery which translocates cytoplasmically synthesized proteins capable of operating in reverse to export proteins from the matrix, or is there a separate system? Alternatively, do membrane proteins encoded by mitochondrial DNA insert independently of accessory proteins? Unlike nuclear-encoded proteins, proteins encoded by mtDNA are not faced with a choice of membrane and, in principle, could simply partition into the inner membrane. The ancestors of mitochondria almost certainly had a Sec system; has this been lost along with many of the proteins once encoded in the endosymbiont genome, or is there still such a system waiting to be discovered? The answer to this question may also shed light on the controversy concerning the sorting of the inter-membrane space proteins cytochrome c1 and cytochrome b2, as the conservative-sorting hypothesis would predict re-export of matrix intermediates via an ancestral (possibly Sec-type) pathway. Whereas the ER and bacterial systems clearly share homologous proteins, the protein import machineries of mitochondria and chloroplasts appear to be analogous rather than homologous. In both cases, import occurs through contact sites and there are separate translocation complexes in each membrane, however, with the exception of some of the chaperone molecules, the individual protein components do not appear to be related. Their similarities may be a case of convergent rather than divergent evolution, and may reflect what appear to be common requirements for translocation, namely unfolding, a receptor, a pore complex and refolding. There are also important differences. Translocation across the mitochondrial inner membrane is absolutely dependent upon delta psi, but no GTP requirement has been identified. In chloroplasts the reverse is the case. The roles of delta psi and GTP, respectively, remain uncertain, but it is tempting to speculate that they may play a role in regulating the import process, perhaps by controlling the assembly of a functional translocation complex. In the case of peroxisomes, much still remains to be learned. Many genes involved in peroxisome biogenesis have been identified but, in most cases, the biochemical function remains to be elucidated. In this respect, understanding of peroxisome biogenesis is at a similar stage to that of the ER 10 years ago. The coming together of genetic and biochemical approaches, as with the other organelles, should provide many of the answers.

Transport of proteins in eukaryotic cells: more questions ahead

Some newly synthesized proteins contain signals that direct their transport to their final location within or outside of the cell. Targeting signals are recognized by specific protein receptors located either in the cytoplasm or in the membrane of the target organelle. Specific membrane protein complexes are involved in insertion and translocation of polypeptides across the membranes. Often, additional targeting signals are required for a polypeptide to be further transported to its site of function. In this review, we will describe the trafficking of proteins to various cellular organelles (nucleus, chloroplasts, mitochondria, peroxisomes) with emphasis on transport to and through the secretory pathway.

Common principles of protein translocation across membranes

Most major systems that transport proteins across a membrane share the following features: an amino-terminal transient signal sequence on the transported protein, a targeting system on the cis side of the membrane, a hetero-oligomeric transmembrane channel that is gated both across and within the plane of the membrane, a peripherally attached protein translocation motor that is powered by the hydrolysis of nucleoside triphosphate, and a protein folding system on the trans side of the membrane. These transport systems are divided into two families: export systems that export proteins out of the cytosol, and import systems that transport proteins into cytosol-like compartments.

Sec-dependent thylakoid protein translocation. Delta pH requirement is dictated by passenger protein and ATP concentration

A Sec-type system is responsible for the translocation of a subset of proteins across the thylakoid membrane in higher plant chloroplasts. Previous studies have suggested that the thylakoidal delta pH plays a minor role in this translocation mechanism, but we show here that it can be essential for the translocation process, depending on the identity of the passenger protein and the concentration of ATP. Studies using chimeric proteins show that, whereas the presequence dictates the translocation pathway, the delta pH requirement is dictated exclusively by the passenger protein; some passenger proteins are virtually delta pH-independent whereas others are absolutely dependent. delta pH requirement is not related to charge characteristics of the passenger proteins, ruling out an electrophoretic effect. Analysis of the 33-kDa photosystem II protein reveals an inverse relationship between delta pH requirement and ATP concentration; import into isolated thylakoids is inhibited 14-fold by nigericin at moderate ATP concentrations, and totally inhibited when the ATP concentration is reduced to 2 microM. The results indicate that the roles of the delta pH and ATP overlap and suggest that the delta pH may be obligatory when the passenger protein is abnormally difficult to translocate, possibly due to the folding of the polypeptide chain. We compare the energetics of this system with those of prokaryotic systems from which the chloroplast system is believed to have evolved.

Isolation and characterization of a cDNA encoding the SecA protein from spinach chloroplasts. Evidence for azide resistance of Sec-dependent protein translocation across thylakoid membranes in spinach

Thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts in higher plants harbor different pathways for the translocation of proteins. One of these routes is related to the prokaryotic Sec pathway, which mediates the secretion of particular proteins into the periplasmic space and involves the SecA protein as an essential component. We have isolated a full size cDNA of 3739 nucleotides encoding the SecA homologue from spinach. It contains an open reading frame of 1036 codons corresponding to a polypeptide with a calculated mass of 117 kDa. The deduced amino acid sequence shows between 43 and 49% identity to SecA proteins from bacteria and lower algae and 62% identity to SecA of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC7942. Compared with the Escherichia coli protein, spinach SecA carries an amino-terminal extension of approximately 80 residues. In organello experiments performed with the protein made in vitro by transcription of the cDNA and cell-free translation of the resulting RNA showed that this extension comprises a transit peptide that mediates the import of the protein into the chloroplast. The processed product of approximately 107 kDa accumulates predominantly in the stroma and to a lower extent associates with the thylakoid membrane. Comparably to E. coli, in which SecA activity can be inhibited by sodium azide, thylakoid translocation of a subset of lumenal proteins is sensitive to sodium azide in pea but not in spinach chloroplasts, suggesting that the latter contain an azide-resistant SecA variant.

A monomeric, tightly folded stromal intermediate on the delta pH-dependent thylakoidal protein transport pathway

Two distinct mechanisms have been previously identified for the transport of proteins across the chloroplast thylakoid membrane, one of which is unusual in that neither soluble factors nor ATP are required; the system requires only the transthylakoidal delta pH. We have examined this mechanism by studying the properties of one of its substrates: the extrinsic 23-kDa protein (23K) of photosystem II. Previous work has shown that this protein can be transported into isolated thylakoids as the full-length precursor protein; we show that the stromal import intermediate form of this protein is similarly translocation-competent. Gel filtration tests indicate that the stromal intermediate is probably monomeric. Protease sensitivity tests on both the initial in vitro translation product and the stromal import intermediate show that the presequence is highly susceptible to digestion whereas the mature protein is resistant to high concentrations of trypsin. The mature protein becomes very sensitive to digestion if unfolded in urea, or after heating, and we therefore propose that the natural substrate for this translocation system consists of a relatively unfolded presequence together with a tightly folded passenger protein. The ability of thylakoids to import pre-23K is destroyed by prior treatment of the thylakoids with low concentrations of trypsin, demonstrating the involvement of surface-exposed proteins in the import process. However, we can find no evidence for the binding of pre-23K or i23K to the thylakoid surface, and we therefore propose that the initial interaction of these substrates with the thylakoidal translocase is weak, reversible, and probably delta pH-independent. In the second phase of the translocation mechanism, the delta pH drives either the translocation and unfolding of proteins, or the translocation of a fully folded protein.

The delta pH-driven, ATP-independent protein translocation mechanism in the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. Kinetics and energetics

Previous studies have shown that proteins are transported across the chloroplast thylakoid membrane by two very different mechanisms, one of which requires stromal factors and ATP, whereas the other mechanism is ATP independent but completely reliant on the thylakoidal delta pH. We have examined the role of the delta pH in the latter mechanism by simultaneously monitoring the magnitude of delta pH (by 9-aminoacridine fluorescence quenching) and the rate of import of the 23-kDa photosystem II protein into isolated pea thylakoids. We show that protein import can take place, at low but significant rates, at very low values of delta pH (in the region of 1.2-1.4), and that plots of the rate of protein import against proton concentration gradient are probably hyperbolic in nature. There is no evidence for a threshold level of delta pH which is required to drive translocation of the 23-kDa protein. Addition of uncouplers midway during import incubations results in a rapid and complete inhibition of translocation, showing that the continuous presence of the delta pH is required for translocation to take place. During import into intact chloroplasts, the intermediate-size 23-kDa protein substrate for the thylakoidal protein transport machinery is found only in the stromal fraction at all values of delta pH, suggesting that the initial interaction with the machinery is relatively weak, reversible and delta pH-independent. We therefore propose that the delta pH is required for both the initiation and completion of translocation; these roles are in marked contrast to the roles of protonmotive force in mitochondrial and sec-dependent bacterial protein transport.

Post-translational protein import and folding

Significant advances have been made over the past year in analyzing the membrane machineries for the post-translational export of proteins in bacteria and for the import of proteins into mitochondria. Another important development is the identification in mitochondria of homologs of the bacterial heat-shock proteins DnaJ and GrpE, which function together with Hsp70 in membrane translocation and folding of imported proteins. A number of gene products involved in peroxisomal protein uptake have been identified, which are now awaiting biochemical analysis.