Lefty proteins are long-range inhibitors of squint-mediated nodal signaling

Models for the generation of the embryonic body axes: ontogenetic and evolutionary aspects

Coelenterates including hydra are assumed to be close to the last common ancestor before bilaterality evolved. Models based on local self-enhancement and long-range inhibition account for pattern formation and regeneration along this ancestral axis. The body of a hydra-like ancestor evolved into the brain and heart of higher organisms, accounting for the close relationship of both patterning processes. Bilateria require a long-extended organizing region to pattern their dorsoventral axis. Models reveal the difficulties in the generation of such a stripe-like organizer and account for different mechanisms realized in vertebrates and insects. Common pathways involved in hydra budding and in the formation of appendages in higher organisms suggest a possible link.

Nicalin and its binding partner Nomo are novel Nodal signaling antagonists

Nodals are signaling factors of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGFbeta) superfamily with a key role in vertebrate development. They control a variety of cell fate decisions required for the establishment of the embryonic body plan. We have identified two highly conserved transmembrane proteins, Nicalin and Nomo (Nodal modulator, previously known as pM5), as novel antagonists of Nodal signaling. Nicalin is distantly related to Nicastrin, a component of the Alzheimer's disease-associated gamma-secretase, and forms a complex with Nomo. Ectopic expression of both proteins in zebrafish embryos causes cyclopia, a phenotype that can arise from a defect in mesendoderm patterning mediated by the Nodal signaling pathway. Accordingly, downregulation of Nomo resulted in an increase in anterior axial mesendoderm and the development of an enlarged hatching gland. Inhibition of Nodal signaling by ectopic expression of Lefty was rescued by reducing Nomo levels. Furthermore, Nodal- as well as Activin-induced signaling was inhibited by Nicalin and Nomo in a cell-based reporter assay. Our data demonstrate that the Nicalin/Nomo complex antagonizes Nodal signaling during mesendodermal patterning in zebrafish.

Determination of embryonic polarity in a regulative system: evidence for endogenous inhibitors acting sequentially during primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

Avian embryos have a remarkable capacity to regulate: when a pre-primitive streak stage embryo is cut into fragments, each fragment can spontaneously initiate formation of a complete embryonic axis. We investigate the signalling pathways that initiate primitive streak formation and the mechanisms that ensure that only a single axis normally forms. As reported previously, an ectopic primitive streak can be induced by misexpression of Vg1 in the marginal zone. We now show that Vg1 induces an inhibitor that travels across the embryo (3 mm distance) in less than 6 hours. We provide evidence that this inhibitor acts early in the cascade of events downstream of Vg1. We also show that FGF signalling is required for primitive streak formation, in cooperation with Nodal and Chordin. We suggest that three sequential inhibitory steps ensure that a single axis develops in the normal embryo: an early inhibitor that spreads throughout the embryo (which can be induced by Vg1), a second inhibition by Cerberus from the underlying hypoblast, and finally a late inhibition from Lefty emitted by the primitive streak itself.

Organization of cardiac chamber progenitors in the zebrafish blastula

Organogenesis requires the specification of a variety of cell types and the organization of these cells into a particular three-dimensional configuration. The embryonic vertebrate heart is organized into two major chambers, the ventricle and atrium, each consisting of two tissue layers, the myocardium and endocardium. The cellular and molecular mechanisms responsible for the separation of ventricular and atrial lineages are not well understood. To test models of cardiac chamber specification, we generated a high-resolution fate map of cardiac chamber progenitors in the zebrafish embryo at 40% epiboly, a stage prior to the initiation of gastrulation. Our map reveals a distinct spatial organization of myocardial progenitors: ventricular myocardial progenitors are positioned closer to the margin and to the dorsal midline than are atrial myocardial progenitors. By contrast, ventricular and atrial endocardial progenitors are not spatially organized at this stage. The relative orientations of ventricular and atrial myocardial progenitors before and after gastrulation suggest orderly movements of these populations. Furthermore, the initial positions of myocardial progenitors at 40% epiboly indicate that signals residing at the embryonic margin could influence chamber fate assignment. Indeed, via fate mapping, we demonstrate that Nodal signaling promotes ventricular fate specification near the margin, thereby playing an important early role during myocardial patterning.

Nodal signaling and vertebrate germ layer formation

The understanding of germ layer formation in vertebrates began with classical experimental embryology. Early in the 20th century, Spemann and Mangold (1924) identified a region of the early embryo capable of inducing an entire embryonic axis. Termed the dorsal organizer, the tissue and the activity have been shown to exist in all vertebrates examined. In mice, for example, the activity resides in a region of the gastrula embryo known as the node. Experiments by the Dutch embryologist Nieuwkoop (1967a, 1967b, 1973, 1977) showed that a signal derived from the vegetal half of the amphibian embryo is responsible for the formation of mesoderm. Nieuwkoop's results allowed the development of in vitro assays that led, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, to the identification of growth factors essential for germ layer formation. Through more recent genetic investigations in mice and zebrafish, we now know that one class of secreted growth factor, called Nodal because of its localized expression in the mouse node, is essential for formation of mesoderm and endoderm and for the morphological rearrangements that occur during gastrulation.

Nodal Signaling: CrypticLefty Mechanism of Antagonism Decoded

The secreted TGFbeta factor Lefty antagonizes Nodal signaling during vertebrate embryogenesis, but how it does so has been a mystery. Recent analyses have elucidated the molecular mechanisms underlying this function of Lefty.

Two Modes by which Lefty Proteins Inhibit Nodal Signaling

During vertebrate embryogenesis, members of the Lefty subclass of Transforming Growth Factor-beta (TGFbeta) proteins act as extracellular antagonists of the signaling pathway for Nodal, a TGFbeta-related ligand essential for mesendoderm formation and left-right patterning. Genetic and biochemical analyses have shown that Nodal signaling is mediated by activin receptors but also requires EGF-CFC coreceptors, such as mammalian Cripto or Cryptic. Misexpression experiments in zebrafish and frogs have suggested that Lefty proteins can act as long-range inhibitors for Nodal, possibly through competition for binding to activin receptors. Here we demonstrate two distinct and unexpected mechanisms by which Lefty proteins can antagonize Nodal activity. In particular, using a novel assay for Lefty activity in mammalian cell culture, we find that Lefty can inhibit signaling by Nodal but not by Activin or TGFbeta1, which are EGF-CFC independent. We show that Lefty can interact with Nodal in solution and thereby block Nodal from binding to activin receptors. Furthermore, Lefty can also interact with EGF-CFC proteins and prevent their ability to form part of a Nodal receptor complex. Our results provide mechanistic insights into how Lefty proteins can achieve efficient and stringent regulation of a potent signaling factor.

Lefty blocks a subset of TGFbeta signals by antagonizing EGF-CFC coreceptors

Members of the EGF-CFC family play essential roles in embryonic development and have been implicated in tumorigenesis. The TGFβ signals Nodal and Vg1/GDF1, but not Activin, require EGF-CFC coreceptors to activate Activin receptors. We report that the TGFβ signaling antagonist Lefty also acts through an EGF-CFC-dependent mechanism. Lefty inhibits Nodal and Vg1 signaling, but not Activin signaling. Lefty genetically interacts with EGF-CFC proteins and competes with Nodal for binding to these coreceptors. Chimeras between Activin and Nodal or Vg1 identify a 14 amino acid region that confers independence from EGF-CFC coreceptors and resistance to Lefty. These results indicate that coreceptors are targets for both TGFβ agonists and antagonists and suggest that subtle sequence variations in TGFβ signals result in greater ligand diversity.

TGFβ family members and their receptors are involved in setting up the left-right body axis early in development. This article clarifies the role of Lefty and elucidates the molecular basis for signaling diversity between the family members

Nodal signaling in vertebrate development

TGFss signals belonging to the Nodal family set up the embryonic axes, induce mesoderm and endoderm, pattern the nervous system, and determine left-right asymmetry in vertebrates. Nodal signaling activates a canonical TGFss pathway involving activin receptors, Smad2 transcription factors, and FoxH1 coactivators. In addition, Nodal signaling is dependent on coreceptors of the EGF-CFC family and antagonized by the Lefty and Cerberus families of secreted factors. Additional modulators of Nodal signaling include convertases that regulate the generation of the mature signal, and factors such as Arkadia and DRAP1 that regulate the cellular responses to the signal. Complex regulatory cascades and autoregulatory loops coordinate Nodal signaling during early development. Nodals have concentration-dependent roles and can act both locally and at a distance. These studies demonstrate that Nodal signaling is modulated at almost every level to precisely orchestrate tissue patterning during vertebrate embryogenesis.

Developmental diorama

Spring meeting of the British Society for Developmental Biology, held April 2003 at the University of Warwick, UK.

Local tissue interactions across the dorsal midline of the forebrain establish CNS laterality

The mechanisms that establish behavioral, cognitive, and neuroanatomical asymmetries are poorly understood. In this study, we analyze the events that regulate development of asymmetric nuclei in the dorsal forebrain. The unilateral parapineal organ has a bilateral origin, and some parapineal precursors migrate across the midline to form this left-sided nucleus. The parapineal subsequently innervates the left habenula, which derives from ventral epithalamic cells adjacent to the parapineal precursors. Ablation of cells in the left ventral epithalamus can reverse laterality in wild-type embryos and impose the direction of CNS asymmetry in embryos in which laterality is usually randomized. Unilateral modulation of Nodal activity by Lefty1 can also impose the direction of CNS laterality in embryos with bilateral expression of Nodal pathway genes. From these data, we propose that laterality is determined by a competitive interaction between the left and right epithalamus and that Nodal signaling biases the outcome of this competition.

Lefty antagonism of Squint is essential for normal gastrulation

Activities of a variety of signaling proteins that regulate embryogenesis are limited by endogenous antagonists. The zebrafish Nodal-related ligands, Squint and Cyclops, and their antagonists, Lefty1 and Lefty2, belong to the TGFbeta-related protein superfamily, whose members have widespread biological activities. Among other activities, Nodals direct the formation of most mesendoderm. By inducing their own transcription and that of the Lefties, Nodal signals establish positive and negative autoregulatory loops. To investigate how these autoregulatory pathways regulate development, we depleted zebrafish embryos of Lefty1 and/or Lefty2 by using antisense morpholino oligonucleotides. Loss of Lefty1 causes aberrations during somitogenesis stages, including left-right patterning defects, whereas Lefty2 depletion has no obvious consequences. Depletion of both Lefty1 and Lefty2, by contrast, causes unchecked Nodal signaling, expansion of mesendoderm, and loss of ectoderm. The expansion of mesendoderm correlates with an extended period of rapid cellular internalization and a failure of deep-cell epiboly. The gastrulation defects of embryos depleted of Lefty1 and Lefty2 result from the deregulation of Squint signaling. In contrast, deregulation of Cyclops does not affect morphology or the transcription of Nodal target genes during gastrulation. Furthermore, we find that Cyclops is specifically required for the maintenance of lefty1 and lefty2 transcription.