Preparation of DNA from fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue

Comparative analysis of four methods to extract DNA from paraffin-embedded tissues: effect on downstream molecular applications

Background

A large portion of tissues stored worldwide for diagnostic purposes is formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded (FFPE). These FFPE-archived tissues are an extremely valuable source for retrospective (genetic) studies. These include mutation screening in cancer-critical genes as well as pathogen detection. In this study we evaluated the impact of several widely used DNA extraction methods on the quality of molecular diagnostics on FFPE tissues.

Findings

We compared 4 DNA extraction methods from 4 identically processed FFPE mammary-, prostate-, colon- and lung tissues with regard to PCR inhibition, real time SNP detection and amplifiable fragment size. The extraction methods, with and without proteinase K pre-treatment, tested were: 1) heat-treatment, 2) QIAamp DNA-blood-mini-kit, 3) EasyMAG NucliSens and 4) Gentra Capture-Column-kit.

Amplifiable DNA fragment size was assessed by multiplexed 200-400-600 bp PCR and appeared highly influenced by the extraction method used. Proteinase K pre-treatment was a prerequisite for proper purification of DNA from FFPE. Extractions with QIAamp, EasyMAG and heat-treatment were found suitable for amplification of fragments up to 400 bp from all tissues, 600 bp amplification was marginally successful (best was QIAamp). QIAamp and EasyMAG extracts were found suitable for downstream real time SNP detection. Gentra extraction was unsuitable. Hands-on time was lowest for heat-treatment, followed by EasyMAG.

Conclusions

We conclude that the extraction method plays an important role with regard to performance in downstream molecular applications.

High sensitive mutation analysis on KRAS gene using LNA/DNA chimeras as PCR amplification blockers of wild-type alleles

The missense mutations at codons 12 and 13 of KRAS gene have been confirmed as a predictor of nonresponse to EGFR-targeted therapy with monoclonal antibodies cetuximab and panitumumab in patients with metastatic colorectal carcinoma (mCRC). Because of the intra-tumor heterogeneity at genetic levels, it is important to develop sensitive and selective assays to detect above KRAS mutation of rare mutated cells in the presence of large excess of wild-type cells. In the present study, wild-type blocking PCR (WTB-PCR) was developed to detect the aforementioned KRAS mutations, in which a chimera composed of locked nucleic acid (LNA) and DNA was used to inhibit with high sensitivity the amplification of wild-type KRAS alleles whereas it allowed the highly selective amplification of mutated KRAS alleles. Using mutated KRAS from HCT-116 as spiking DNA, the results showed that WTB-PCR could detect mutated alleles in a ratio of 1:10,000 (i.e., 0.01%) wild-type alleles and at a single copy level. For its further applications to detect aforementioned KRAS mutations in 20 cases of mCRC patients, the results showed that the detected mutation percentage of WTB-PCR (60%, 12/20) was higher than that of traditional PCR (45%, 9/20). Moreover, two patients respectively having synonymous mutated codons 13 (i.e., c.39C > T) and missense mutated codons 14 (i.e., c.40G > A) could be also only detected by WTB-PCR. In conclusion, the current WTB-PCR was a rapid, simple, and low-cost method to detect a trace amount of mutated KRAS gene.