Are changes in breast self-exam recommendations and early misperceptions of breast cancer risk increasing women's future risks?

Employing a Risk Assessment Tool for Shared Decision-Making in Breast Cancer Screening

Background: The existing guidelines for breast cancer screening incorporate assessing individual risk but contain no universally recommended risk assessment tool in the primary care setting. Local Problem: A family planning program utilizing nurses and nurse practitioners for assessment, education, and referral lacked a risk assessment tool for assessing breast cancer risk. Methods: A breast cancer risk assessment tool was implemented in practice. Interventions: The interventions involved assessing the patient's risks, providing education on risk reduction strategies, and determining the need for clinical breast exams and referrals for mammography. Results: The study demonstrated a clear correlation between the number of breast cancer risks identified and the extent of education provided to patients based on their specific risk profiles (0 vs. 1.5 risks; 2 vs. 4.6 educational components). Among patients under age 35, 80% opted for a clinical breast exam, while 100% of patients age 40 and above agreed to both clinical breast exams and referrals for mammography after discussing individual risks. Conclusions: The use of a breast cancer risk assessment tool provided an evidence-based foundation for the shared decision-making conversation between patient and nurse/provider on risk reduction. The discussion included current evidence on the risk versus benefit of age-based screening options for breast cancer, allowing for an informed decision made jointly between the patient and provider.

Learning, Life, and Lactation: Knowledge of Breastfeeding's Impact on Breast Cancer Risk Reduction and Its Influence on Breastfeeding Practices

Introduction: The protective effects of breastfeeding against developing breast cancer are well known; however, it is unknown whether women are aware of this breastfeeding benefit. Research Aim/Questions: The aim of this investigation was to determine whether mothers received information about breast cancer risk reduction during breastfeeding counseling and whether this knowledge affected their decision to initiate and sustain breastfeeding. Materials and Methods: The survey was conducted at The Ohio State University Comprehensive Cancer Center with women aged 18-50 who had at least one live birth. Participants were recruited through primary care practice and a national clinical research registry. Results: Six hundred sixty-seven (92%) of the 724 respondents breastfed. Over half of them (56%), that is, 407 women (60.4% Caucasian, 46.9% African American), were aware before their most recent childbirth that breastfeeding reduced the risk of breast cancer. Of the 407 women, 36.4% said this knowledge affected their decision to breastfeed. Of the 39 who did not breastfeed, 23 women (59.0%) responded that awareness of risk reduction would have influenced their decision to breastfeed. Only 120 of 724 respondents (16.6%) received this information from healthcare providers. Women with this knowledge breastfed longer than those without this knowledge (13.2 versus 9.3 months; p < 0.001). More Caucasian women (76.4%) breastfed any one child for more than 6 months compared with African American women (63.2%; p = 0.011; chi-squared test). Conclusion: While several factors affect the initiation and duration of breastfeeding, this study demonstrates that knowledge of association between breastfeeding and breast cancer risk reduction may influence breastfeeding practices. Our study illustrates the need for improved counseling for mothers by healthcare providers regarding this benefit.