Immunostimulatory effects of thermal ablation: Challenges and future prospects

ABSTRACT

This literature explores the immunostimulatory effects of thermal ablation in the tumor microenvironment, elucidating the mechanisms such as immunogenic cell death, tumor-specific antigens, and damage-associated molecular patterns. Furthermore, it outlines critical issues associated with thermal ablation-induced immunostimulatory challenges and offers insights into future research avenues and potential therapeutic strategies.

Nanomaterials augmented bioeffects of ultrasound in cancer immunotherapy

Immunotherapy as a milestone in cancer treatment has made great strides in the past decade, but it is still limited by low immune response rates and immune-related adverse events. Utilizing bioeffects of ultrasound to enhance tumor immunotherapy has attracted more and more attention, including sonothermal, sonomechanical, sonodynamic and sonopiezoelectric immunotherapy. Moreover, the emergence of nanomaterials has further improved the efficacy of ultrasound mediated immunotherapy. However, most of the summaries in this field are about a single aspect of the biological effects of ultrasound, which is not comprehensive and complete currently. This review proposes the recent progress of nanomaterials augmented bioeffects of ultrasound in cancer immunotherapy. The concept of immunotherapy and the application of bioeffects of ultrasound in cancer immunotherapy are initially introduced. Then, according to different bioeffects of ultrasound, the representative paradigms of nanomaterial augmented sono-immunotherapy are described, and their mechanisms are discussed. Finally, the challenges and application prospects of nanomaterial augmented ultrasound mediated cancer immunotherapy are discussed in depth, hoping to pave the way for cancer immunotherapy and promote the clinical translation of ultrasound mediated cancer immunotherapy through the reasonable combination of nanomaterials augmented ultrasonic bioeffects.

Insights from in vivo preclinical cancer studies with histotripsy

Histotripsy is the first noninvasive, non-ionizing, and non-thermal ablation technique that mechanically fractionates target tissue into acellular homogenate via controlled acoustic cavitation. Histotripsy has been evaluated for various preclinical applications requiring noninvasive tissue removal including cancer, brain surgery, blood clot and hematoma liquefaction, and correction of neonatal congenital heart defects. Promising preclinical results including local tumor suppression, improved survival outcomes, local and systemic anti-tumor immune responses, and histotripsy-induced abscopal effects have been reported in various animal tumor models. Histotripsy is also being investigated in veterinary patients with spontaneously arising tumors. Research is underway to combine histotripsy with immunotherapy and chemotherapy to improve therapeutic outcomes. In addition to preclinical cancer research, human clinical trials are ongoing for the treatment of liver tumors and renal tumors. Histotripsy has been recently approved by the FDA for noninvasive treatment of liver tumors. This review highlights key learnings from in vivo shock-scattering histotripsy, intrinsic threshold histotripsy, and boiling histotripsy cancer studies treating cancers of different anatomic locations and discusses the major considerations in planning in vivo histotripsy studies regarding instrumentation, tumor model, study design, treatment dose, and post-treatment tumor monitoring.

Boiling Histotripsy Using Dual-Frequency Protocol on Murine Breast Tumor Model and Promotes Immune Activation

Histotripsy is an ultrasound-guided, noninvasive, nonthermal ablation therapy that can mechanically lyse target tissues. There have been no reports of enhanced histotripsy for large-volume triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC). This study aims to verify the ability of a novel approach of dual-frequency mode combined with two-stage millisecond-length ultrasound pulses (DF-TS) to accelerate the treatment of murine subcutaneous 4T1 tumors and determine immune changes after treatment. A custom-designed 1.1-/2.2-MHz two-element confocal-annular array was used to treat approximately 6-mm tumors under ultrasound guidance and real-time monitoring. Two-stage millisecond-length ultrasound pulses were used to generate approximate cuboid ablation volumes (diagonal 5-6 mm) within each tumor, with a dose of 100 pulses/point. Immune effects were characterized by changes of pro-inflammatory cytokine levels and infiltration levels of immune cells. In all targeted treatment areas, bubble cloud activity was visualized by ultrasound monitoring. The novel protocol resulted in elliptical and controllable sized lesions, reducing the number of scanning points, and was generally well tolerated. After treatment, tumor growth experienced a seven-day stagnation period, the survival period of mice was prolonged, and the levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines and immune cell infiltration increased. This study demonstrates that DF-TS boiling histotripsy (BH) has a noninvasive, efficient, and precise ablation ability for TNBC and potentially enhances immune responses.

Noninvasive mechanical destruction of liver tissue and tissue decellularisation by pressure-modulated shockwave histotripsy

Introduction

Boiling histotripsy (BH) is a promising High Intensity Focused Ultrasound (HIFU) technique that can be used to mechanically fractionate solid tumours at the HIFU focus noninvasively, promoting tumour immunity. Because of the occurrence of shock scattering phenomenon during BH process, the treatment accuracy of BH is, however, somewhat limited. To induce more localised and selective tissue destruction, the concept of pressure modulation has recently been proposed in our previous in vitro tissue phantom study. The aim of the present study was therefore to investigate whether this newly developed histotripsy approach termed pressure-modulated shockwave histotripsy (PSH) can be used to induce localised mechanical tissue fractionation in in vivo animal model.

Methods

In the present study, 8 Sprague Dawley rats underwent the PSH treatment and were sacrificed immediately after the exposure for morphological and histological analyses (paraffin embedded liver tissue sections were stained with H&E and MT). Partially exteriorised rat's left lateral liver lobe in vivo was exposed to a 2.0 MHz HIFU transducer with peak positive (P ₊) and negative (P _-) pressures of 89.1 MPa and -14.6 MPa, a pulse length of 5 to 34 ms, a pressure modulation time at 4 ms where P ₊ and P _- decreased to 29.9 MPa and - 9.6 MPa, a pulse repetition frequency of 1 Hz, a duty cycle of 1% and number of pulses of 1 to 20. Three lesions were produced on each animal. For comparison, the same exposure condition but no pressure modulation was also employed to create a number of lesions in the liver.

Results and Discussion

Experimental results showed that a partial mechanical destruction of liver tissue in the form of an oval in the absence of thermal damage was clearly observed at the HIFU focus after the PSH exposure. With a single pulse length of 7 ms, a PSH lesion created in the liver was measured to be a length of 1.04 ± 0.04 mm and a width of 0.87 ± 0.21 mm which was 2.37 times in length (p = 0.027) and 1.35 times in width (p = 0.1295) smaller than a lesion produced by no pressure modulation approach (e.g., BH). It was also observed that the length of a PSH lesion gradually grew towards the opposite direction to the HIFU source along the axial direction with the PSH pulse length, eventually leading to the generation of an elongated lesion in the liver. In addition, our experimental results demonstrated the feasibility of inducing partial decellularisation effect where liver tissue was partially destructed with intact extracellular matrix (i.e., intact fibrillar collagen) with the shortest PSH pulse length. Taken together, these results suggest that PSH could be used to induce a highly localised tissue fractionation with a desired degree of mechanical damage from complete tissue fractionation to tissue decellularisation through controlling the dynamics of boiling bubbles without inducing the shock scattering effect.

Combining energy-based focal ablation and immune checkpoint inhibitors: preclinical research and clinical trials

Energy-based focal therapy (FT) uses targeted, minimally invasive procedures to destroy tumors while preserving normal tissue and function. There is strong emerging interest in understanding how systemic immunity against the tumor can occur with cancer immunotherapy, most notably immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI). The motivation for combining FT and ICI in cancer management relies on the synergy between the two different therapies: FT complements ICI by reducing tumor burden, increasing objective response rate, and reducing side effects of ICI; ICI supplements FT by reducing local recurrence, controlling distal metastases, and providing long-term protection. This combinatorial strategy has shown promising results in preclinical study (since 2004) and the clinical trials (since 2011). Understanding the synergy calls for understanding the physics and biology behind the two different therapies with distinctive mechanisms of action. In this review, we introduce different types of energy-based FT by covering the biophysics of tissue-energy interaction and present the immunomodulatory properties of FT. We discuss the basis of cancer immunotherapy with the emphasis on ICI. We examine the approaches researchers have been using and the results from both preclinical models and clinical trials from our exhaustive literature research. Finally, the challenges of the combinatory strategy and opportunities of future research is discussed extensively.

Magic bubbles: utilizing histotripsy to modulate the tumor microenvironment and improve systemic anti-tumor immune responses

Focused Ultrasound (FUS) is emerging as a promising primary and adjunct therapy for the treatment of cancer. This includes histotripsy, which is a noninvasive, non-ionizing, non-thermal ultrasound guided ablation modality. As histotripsy has progressed from bench-to-bedside, it has become evident that this therapy has benefits beyond local tumor ablation. Specifically, histotripsy has the potential to shift the local tumor microenvironment from immunologically 'cold' to 'hot'. This is associated with the production of damage associated molecular patterns, the release of a selection of proinflammatory mediators, and the induction of inflammatory forms of cell death in cells just outside of the treatment zone. In addition to the induction of this innate immune response, histotripsy can also improve engagement of the adaptive immune system and promote systemic anti-tumor immunity targeting distal tumors and metastatic lesions. These tantalizing observations suggest that, in settings of widely metastatic disease burden, selective histotripsy of a limited number of accessible tumors could be a means of maximizing responsiveness to systemic immunotherapy. More work is certainly needed to optimize treatment strategies that best synergize histotripsy parameters with innate and adaptive immune responses. Likewise, rigorous clinical studies are still necessary to verify the presence and repeatability of these phenomena in human patients. As this technology nears regulatory approval for clinical use, it is our expectation that the insights and immunomodulatory mechanisms summarized in this review will serve as directional guides for rational clinical studies to validate and optimize the potential immunotherapeutic role of histotripsy tumor ablation.

Quantitative Assessment of Boiling Histotripsy Progression Based on Color Doppler Measurements

Boiling histotripsy (BH) is a mechanical tissue liquefaction method that uses sequences of millisecond-long high intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) pulses with shock fronts. The BH treatment generates bubbles that move within the sonicated volume due to acoustic radiation force. Since the velocity of the bubbles and tissue debris is expected to depend on the lesion size and liquefaction completeness, it could provide a quantitative metric of the treatment progression. In this study, the motion of bubble remnants and tissue debris immediately following BH pulses was investigated using high-pulse repetition frequency (PRF) plane-wave color Doppler ultrasound in ex vivo myocardium tissue. A 256-element 1.5 MHz spiral HIFU array with a coaxially integrated ultrasound imaging probe (ATL P4-2) produced 10 ms BH pulses to form volumetric lesions with electronic beam steering. Prior to performing volumetric BH treatments, the motion of intact myocardium tissue and anticoagulated bovine blood following isolated BH pulses was assessed as two limiting cases. In the liquid blood the velocity of BH-induced streaming at the focus reached over 200 cm/s, whereas the intact tissue was observed to move toward the HIFU array consistent with elastic rebound of tissue. Over the course of volumetric BH treatments tissue motion at the focus locations was dependent on the axial size of the forming lesion relative to the corresponding size of the HIFU focal area. For axially small lesions, the maximum velocity after the BH pulse was directed toward the HIFU transducer and monotonically increased over time from about 20-100 cm/s as liquefaction progressed, then saturated when tissue was fully liquefied. For larger lesions obtained by merging multiple smaller lesions in the axial direction, the high-speed streaming away from the HIFU transducer was observed at the point of full liquefaction. Based on these observations, the maximum directional velocity and its location along the HIFU propagation axis were proposed and evaluated as candidate metrics of BH treatment completeness.

Cancer therapeutics based on diverse energy sources

Light-based phototherapy has been developed for cancer treatment owing to its non-invasiveness and spatiotemporal control. Despite the unique merits of phototherapy, one critical disadvantage of light is its limited penetration depth, which restricts its application in cancer treatment. Although many researchers have developed various strategies to deliver light into deep-seated tumors with two-photon and near-infrared light irradiation, phototherapy encounters the peculiar limitations of light. In addition, high oxygen dependency is another limitation of photodynamic therapy to treat hypoxic tumors. To overcome the drawbacks of conventional treatments, various energy sources have been developed for cancer treatment. Generally, most energy sources, such as ultrasound, chemiluminescence, radiation, microwave, electricity, and magnetic field, are relatively free from the restraint of penetration depth. Combining other strategies or therapies with other energy-source-based therapies improves the strength and compensates for the weakness. This tutorial review focuses on recent advances in the diverse energy sources utilized in cancer treatment and their future perspectives.

Investigation of the long-term healing response of the liver to boiling histotripsy treatment in vivo

Boiling histotripsy (BH) is a promising High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound technique that can be employed to mechanically fractionate solid tumours. Whilst studies have shown the feasibility of BH to destroy liver cancer, no study has reported on the healing process of BH-treated liver tissue. We therefore extensively investigated the evolution of the healing response of liver to BH in order to provide an insight into the healing mechanisms. In the present study, 14 Sprague Dawley rats underwent the BH treatment and were sacrificed on days 0, 3, 7, 14, and 28 for morphological, histological, serological and qPCR analyses. The area of the treated region was 1.44 cm² (1.2 cm × 1.2 cm). A well-defined BH lesion filled with coagulated blood formed on day 0. A week after the treatment, fibroblast activation was induced at the treatment site, leading to the formation of extracellular matrix structure (ECM). The ECM was then disrupted for 7 to 28 days. Regenerated normal hepatocytes and newly formed blood vessels were found within the BH region with the absence of hepatic fibrosis. No significant morphological, histological and genetic changes around the BH lesion occurred. These results suggest that BH could be a safe and promising therapeutic tool for treating solid tumours without inducing any significant adverse effect such as the formation of liver fibrosis.

Chemotherapy and Physical Therapeutics Modulate Antigens on Cancer Cells

Cancer cells possess specific properties, such as multidrug resistance or unlimited proliferation potential, due to the presence of specific proteins on their cell membranes. The release of proliferation-related proteins from the membrane can evoke a loss of adaptive ability in cancer cells and thus enhance the effects of anticancer therapy. The upregulation of cancer-specific membrane antigens results in a better outcome of immunotherapy. Moreover, cytotoxic T-cells may also become more effective when stimulated ex-vivo toward the anticancer response. Therefore, the modulation of membrane proteins may serve as an interesting attempt in anticancer therapy. The presence of membrane antigens relies on various physical factors such as temperature, exposure to radiation, or drugs. Therefore, changing the tumor microenvironment conditions may lead to cancer cells becoming sensitized to subsequent therapy. This paper focuses on the therapeutic approaches modulating membrane antigens and enzymes in anticancer therapy. It aims to analyze the possible methods for modulating the antigens, such as pharmacological treatment, electric field treatment, photodynamic reaction, treatment with magnetic field or X-ray radiation. Besides, an overview of the effects of chemotherapy and immunotherapy on the immunophenotype of cancer cells is presented. Finally, the authors review the clinical trials that involved the modulation of cell immunophenotype in anticancer therapy.

Enhancing Cancer Immunotherapeutic Efficacy with Sonotheranostic Strategies

Immunotherapy has revolutionized the modality for establishing a firm immune response and immunological memory. However, intrinsic limitations of conventional low responsive poor T cell infiltration and immune related adverse effects urge the coupling of cancer nanomedicines with immunotherapy for boosting antitumor response under ultrasound (US) sensitization to mimic dose-limiting toxicities for safe and effective therapy against advanced cancer. US is composed of high-frequency sound waves that mediate targeted spatiotemporal control over release and internalization of the drug. The unconventional US triggered immunogenic nanoengineered arena assists the limited immunogenic dose, limiting toxicities and efficacies. In this Review, we discuss current prospects of enhanced immunotherapy using nanomedicine under US. We highlight how nanotechnology designs and incorporates nanomedicines for the reprogramming of systematic immunity in the tumor microenvironment. We also emphasize the mechanical and biological potential of US, encompassing sonosensitizer activation for enhanced immunotherapeutic efficacies. Finally, the smartly converging combinational platform of US stimulated cancer nanomedicines for amending immunotherapy is summarized. This Review will widen scientists' ability to explore and understand the limiting factors for combating cancer in a precisely customized way.

Therapeutic ultrasound-enhanced immune checkpoint inhibitor therapy

Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) are designed to reinvigorate antitumor immune responses by interrupting inhibitory signaling pathways and promoting the immune-mediated elimination of malignant cells. Although ICI therapy has transformed the landscape of cancer treatment, only a subset of patients achieve a complete response. Focused ultrasound (FUS) is a noninvasive, nonionizing, deep penetrating focal therapy that has great potential to improve the efficacy of ICIs in solid tumors. Five FUS modalities have been incorporated with ICIs to explore their antitumor effects in preclinical studies, namely, high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) thermal ablation, HIFU hyperthermia, HIFU mechanical ablation, ultrasound-targeted microbubble destruction (UTMD), and sonodynamic therapy (SDT). The enhancement of the antitumor immune responses by these FUS modalities demonstrates the great promise of FUS as a transformative cancer treatment modality to improve ICI therapy. Here, this review summarizes these emerging applications of FUS modalities in combination with ICIs. It discusses each FUS modality, the experimental protocol for each combination strategy, the induced immune effects, and therapeutic outcomes.