The pulsed dye laser and atherosclerotic vascular disease

Percutaneous laser recanalisation of femoropopliteal occlusions using continuous wave Nd-YAG laser and sapphire contact probe delivery system

A conventional continuous wave Nd-YAG medical laser system delivered by transparent sapphire tipped optical fibres was used for percutaneous recanalisation of 32 chronic femoropopliteal occlusions in 27 patients (19 men, eight women; median age 68 years, range 46-83 years). Twenty-four patients had severe intermittent claudication and three had critical ischaemia. The median occlusion length was 8 cm (range 3-35 cm) and lesions were not negotiable by guidewire. Laser energy was delivered at powers of 10-15 Watts using intermittent 1 second emissions (mean total energy 315 Joules, range 30-1015]). The sapphire tips used were 1.8 to 3.0 mm diameter. After laser recanalisation adjunctive balloon dilatation was necessary to widen the resulting lumen. All patients received anti-platelet therapy. Initial clinical success was achieved in 22 limbs (69%) with symptomatic relief and increase in mean (+/- S.D.) ankle-brachial pressure ratio from 0.52 (+/- 0.25) to 0.80 (+/- 0.21) [Mann-Whitney U, p < 0.001]. Recanalisation was unsuccessful in all calcified lesions (four cases). There was a high incidence of vessel perforation (28%) and wall dissection (25%). Emergency surgery was not required after failed procedures. The median follow-up was 12 months (range 6-20 months). By 6 months, 15 of 22 successfully recanalised lesions (68%) had reoccluded. The cumulative primary patency at 1 year was only 12%. These disappointing results do not support routine use of this system. Clearly, modifications of the laser/delivery system or the technique, or both, are required. The aim should be to achieve sole laser recanalisation without concomitant balloon dilatation.

Evaluation of a prototype steerable angioscopic laser catheter in a canine model: a feasibility study

To overcome some of the persisting technical problems related to laser angioplasty, a new catheter was designed and investigated in a canine model. This 5F catheter contained a deflectable tip for steerability, an angioscope, and a laser fiber. Catheter steerability, angioscopic function, and the effects of a 480 nm flash lamp pumped pulsed dye laser on normal canine vessel walls were evaluated. Steering, angioscopic guidance, and application of laser energy were easy and fast to perform in a bloodless vessel segment. Maintaining a condition of bloodlessness at the target site, critical to angioscopic guidance, proved to be the most difficult part in this prototype evaluation. It was noted that the 480 nm pulsed dye laser did not cause macroscopic alterations or perforations to the normal vessel wall. We conclude that a relatively simple deflection mechanism of a small-caliber angioscope provides the kind of aiming ability requisite for precise endovascular therapy. Complete bloodlessness of the area is necessary for both viewing and laser ablation at 480 nm.

Beta carotene uptake into atherosclerotic plaque: enhanced staining and preferential ablation with the pulsed dye laser

The yellow color of atherosclerotic plaque is due to the presence of carotenoids, which absorb light between 430-530 nm and account for the preferential ablation of plaque by the pulsed dye laser operating at 480 nm. This study was designed to examine tissue uptake of beta-carotene and the effect of uptake on arterial plaque ablation. Forty-two atherosclerotic NZW rabbits were given intravenous beta-carotene at a dose of 40 mg/kg, twice weekly and killed between 1 hour and 28 days after the initial injection. beta-carotene was not detected in control specimens but was significantly greater in plaque than in normal wall at all time points following beta-carotene injection (P < 0.04 Mann Whitney U test). The ablation threshold was significantly lower in beta-carotene treated plaque than in untreated plaque or normal arterial wall (P < 0.01, Fisher's exact test). In this model beta-carotene is preferentially taken up into arterial plaque, resulting in increased absorption of laser radiation at 480 nm and enhanced tissue ablation.

In vitro and clinical feasibility study with an over-the-wire delivery system for pulsed dye laser angioplasty

The suitability of a pulsed dye laser (504 nm) in experimental and clinical angioplasty was investigated. In an experimental study, the ablation thresholds were 3 J/cm2 +/- 8 (mean +/- standard deviation) for fibrofatty plaque and 25 J/cm2 for calcified tissues under saline. At a radiant exposure of 10 J/cm2 the etch rates were 1.7 microns per pulse +/- 0.3 for media, 2.8 microns/pulse +/- 0.4 for normal intima, and 3.9 microns/pulse +/- 1.1 for fibrofatty plaque (P less than .05). Pressure wave effects with a separation of tissue layers were predominantly localized at the internal elastic lamina. Thermal injury with vacuolations extended 15 microns +/- 6 into adjacent tissue. For clinical study, laser-assisted balloon angioplasty was performed in 10 patients (64 years +/- 14) with occlusions of peripheral arteries using a 9-F multifiber ring catheter. Lesion length ranged from 2 to 12 cm (mean, 7 cm). Laser angioplasty with an 80 mJ/pulse decreased the mean stenosis from 100% to 58% +/- 12% (P less than .005). The ankle-brachial index rose from a median of 0.48 to 0.88 (P less than .001). In 33% of patients, there were subintimal dissections after laser angioplasty. After a mean follow-up of 10.2 months, the overall clinical success was 70% with a primary patency of 78%. The over-the-wire approach with a pulsed dye laser may constitute a safe and feasible tool in laser angioplasty.

Initial clinical experience with a new pulsed dye laser device in angioplasty of limb ischemia and shunt fistula obstructions

Selective plaque ablation with laser radiation at 405-530 nm in vitro has been reported. We investigated the possibilities of a new pulsed dye laser device for in vivo recanalization of arteries in ischemic lower limbs and stenoses/occlusions of arterio-venous hemodialysis shunt fistulae. A specially designed 9F or 7F multifiber catheter was used for treatment of 10 patients with lower limb artery obliterations and 11 patients with malfunctioning hemodialysis access fistulae (HAF). The recanalization technical success was 5/5 in the iliac arteries (IA), 4/5 in the superficial femoral arteries (SFA), and 11/11 in the HAF. Early re-occlusions occurred in one SFA and one IA, respectively, caused by very bad run-off. There was one clinically insignificant SFA perforation. Additional balloon angioplasty was considered necessary in 10/16 lesions. Mean ankle-arm index increased from 0.68 to 0.97. With two exceptions all HAF patients were re-integrated in the dialysis program. Pulsed dye laser angioplasty promises to be an effective and fast method for plaque ablation/debulking. The first clinical experience confirms previous in vitro results. In particular laser recanalization may become the method of choice for treatment of rigid HAF obstructions and it seems to be superior to vascular surgery or balloon angioplasty alone.

Laser-assisted angioplasty for arterial occlusion of the lower limb: initial results and follow-up

A flashlamp-pumped pulsed dye laser operating at either 480 or 504 nm, coupled to an integral ball-tipped optical fibre, was used to recanalize occluded lower limb arteries. All channels created by the laser were augmented with balloon dilatation. We have treated 78 limbs in 71 patients; 46 limbs (59 per cent) had rest pain and 22 (48 per cent) of these had tissue loss. The median occlusion length was 18 (range 0.5-58) cm. Technical success was achieved in 58 limbs (74 per cent) with clinical success in 46 (59 per cent). Success rates fell with increasing length of occlusion. Two patients died in the perioperative period. A subgroup of 22 patients with marked discrete arterial calcification had a lower technical success rate than the subgroup without calcification (50 per cent versus 84 per cent, P less than 0.01). Both subgroups displayed a similar pattern of reclosure during follow-up. The cumulative patency rate after technical success was 67 per cent at 6 months and 45 per cent at 12 months. Forty-six (59 per cent) limbs avoided bypass surgery or amputation. Laser-assisted angioplasty may offer an alternative to femoropopliteal bypass, although the former procedure is not as durable.

Lasers in surgery

In January 1991 the winter meeting of the Surgical Research Society was held at St. Bartholomew's Hospital and the Institute of Education, London. During the meeting a symposium was held entitled 'Shedding light on lasers'. Speakers addressed the general principles of lasers, laser-tissue interactions and the applications of lasers in gastro-enterology and in vascular disease. This was followed by an open discussion of the current indications, complications and outcome, together with future possible applications for lasers in medicine.

Effects of laser-generated tissue debris on aggregation of human platelets

This study examined the effects of laser-generated tissue debris from thrombus, atheroma, and normal aorta on platelet aggregation. Debris supernatant and suspension from lased thrombus induced dose-related aggregation, maximal at 48 +/- 12% and 65 +/- 2%, respectively. Debris suspension from normal aorta induced maximal aggregation of 35 +/- 12%, but the debris from atheromatous aorta surprisingly had no effect on platelet aggregation. The debris particle count was in the range of 10(10) to 10(12) per liter. Aspirin, 0.2 and 2.0 mmol/L, only weakly inhibited the debris-induced aggregation, and heparin up to 10 U/ml was ineffective. However, iloprost reduced aggregation to 40 +/- 11% of control at 0.3 ng/ml, and totally abolished it at 3 ng/ml. Soluble and particulate laser-generated debris from vascular tissue and thrombus may cause platelet aggregation in vitro. This may have implications for laser coronary angioplasty.

Effect of blood upon the selective ablation of atherosclerotic plaque with a pulsed dye laser

Laser angioplasty systems with laser energy preferentially absorbed by atherosclerotic plaque may offer a safe method of plaque removal. This study evaluated the effect of blood upon selective energy absorption using a pulsed dye laser at 480 nm. Intra-arterial laser irradiation of normal rabbit femoral arteries demonstrated a perforation threshold energy with blood perfusion of 13.1 mJ per pulse compared to 87.9 mJ with saline (P less than .0001), indicating a deleterious effect in the presence of blood. An adverse effect upon arterial healing at 3 days was noted in sheep following intra-arterial irradiation during blood but not saline perfusion. Normal and atherosclerotic human aorta ablation thresholds differed significantly (P less than .0002) under saline (plaque: 20 mJ and normal: 120 mJ) but the difference under blood (plaque: 5 mJ and normal: 20 mJ) was not significant. We conclude that absorption of laser energy by blood can reduce the effect of differential absorption by endogenous chromophores in normal and pathologic vascular tissues and, therefore, removal of blood may be a prerequisite for selective ablation of atherosclerotic plaques.

Laser angioplasty with a pulsed NdYAG laser: early clinical experience

Since December 1986, 40 laser angioplasty procedures have been performed using the energy from a pulsed NdYAG laser, delivering near infrared light (1064 nm) in 100-microseconds pulses of approximately 300 mJ per pulse, directly through a transparent sapphire tipped device. All patients had total occlusion of the superficial femoral artery and symptoms severe enough to warrant surgery, with ulceration or gangrene in eight, rest pain in 14 and severe claudication interfering with life-style in the others. The device was introduced through an antegrade puncture of the superficial or common femoral artery and laser recanalization was followed by attempted balloon angioplasty in all cases. Occlusions were a median length of 15 cm (range 2-35 cm); ten patients had previously undergone failed attempts at conventional balloon angioplasty and four had occluded femoropopliteal grafts. Thirty-seven legs of 34 patients were treated with an average of 60 J (range 10-235 J) with successful recanalization in 27 and immediate reocclusion in seven. The 20 successful recanalizations have been followed up for up to 24 months (median 7 months) with only one late occlusion at 5 months. Failed recanalization was due to poor transmission by the delivery device in the early part of the series (five cases), repeated passage of the device down a collateral branch (four cases), dissection at the site of previous surgery (two cases) or no apparent reason (two cases). Immediate reocclusion was due to very poor run off in patients with severely ischaemic limbs (three cases) or technical difficulties with balloon dilatation (two cases). Complete symptomatic relief was obtained in all the cases of radiologically successful laser angioplasty. Early surgery was required in one case following reocclusion of the artery when an angioplasty balloon failed to deflate, and one patient suffered a skin reaction thought to be due to inadequate removal of the sterilizing solution. A different sterilizing procedure is now followed. Laser angioplasty can reduce the number of patients requiring bypass surgery and improvements in the device and access methods may reduce the number of untreatable cases.

Defining parameters for peripheral laser angioplasty

In vitro studies are reported using a Pulsed Dye laser at wavelengths of 440, 480, 504, 560 and 590 nm, to vaporise multiple samples of yellow, fibrous and calcified plaque. The threshold for crater production at 440 nm was 5 mJ/pulse and at 590 nm 65 mJ/pulse. Crater depth was significantly deeper at the short wavelengths (440, 480 and 504 nm) than at the longer (560 and 590 nm). Light microscopy confirmed the absence of thermal damage associated with continuous wave lasers. Electron microscopy revealed smooth-contoured craters and no disruption of subcellular elements at the crater margin. Samples of thrombus- and atheroma-occluded human femoral artery were successfully recanalised at the 480 nm wavelength with atraumatic spherical-tipped and modified spherical tipped optical fibres. The advantages of pulsed laser energy in peripheral vessel recanalisation are discussed.