Phosphodiester cleavage of ribonucleoside monophosphates and polyribonucleotides by homo- and heterodinuclear metal complexes of a cyclohexane-based polyamino-polyol ligand

A novel 1,3,5-triaminocyclohexane-based tripodal ligand forms a unique tetra(pyrazolate)-bridged tricopper(ii) core: solution equilibrium, structure and catecholase activity

A polydentate tripodal ligand forms a series of tricopper(ii) complexes, that feature unique pyrazolate-bridged linear core. The Cu₃H₋₃L₂ complex is an efficient catecholase mimic with a surprisingly low pH optimum at pH = 5.6.

Bio-inspired approaches to accelerating metal ion-promoted reactions: enzyme-like rates for metal ion mediated phosphoryl and acyl transfer processes

Intense efforts by many research groups for more than 50 years have been directed at biomimetic approaches to understand how enzymes achieve their remarkable rate accelerations. Nevertheless, it was noted in 2003 that, despite numerous efforts to design models for catalyzing the cleavage of such species as phosphate diesters, “none of the several models so far described approaches the enormous catalytic efficiency of natural enzymes”. The same could be said for biomimetics of other enzymes promoting acyl or phosphoryl transfer reactions, particularly those mediated by metal ions such as Zn(II). Clearly other important factors were being overlooked or awaiting discovery. In this manuscript we describe two important effects that we have implemented to accelerate metal ion catayzed phosphoryl and acyl transfer reactions. The first of these relates to a medium effect where the polarity of the solution, as measured by dielectric constant, is reduced from that of water (ε = 78) to values of 31.5 and 24.3 when the solvent is changed to methanol or ethanol. Among organic solvents these light alcohols are closest to water in terms of structure and properties as well as retaining important H-bonding properties. The second important effect involves a known but difficult to demonstrate mode of catalysis where the leaving group (LG) in a solvolysis reaction is accelerated as it becomes progressively poorer. In the cases described herein, the LG’s propensity to depart from a substrate during the course of reaction is accelerated by coordination to a metal ion in a process known as leaving group assistance, or LGA. These two effects can each impart accelerations of 109–1017 for certain metal ion catalyzed reactions relative to the corresponding solvent, or base induced reactions.

The mechanism of cleavage and isomerisation of RNA promoted by an efficient dinuclear Zn2+ complex

The cleavage and isomerisation of uridine 3'-alkylphosphates was studied in the presence of a dinuclear Zn(2+) complex, 3. The rate acceleration of the cleavage by 1 mM 3 is approximately 10(6)-fold under neutral conditions. Most remarkably, the complex also promotes the isomerisation of phosphodiester bonds, although the rate-enhancement is more modest: under neutral conditions complex 3 (1 mM) catalyses isomerisation by about 500-fold. The observation of this reaction shows that the reactions of these substrates catalysed by 3 proceed through a stepwise mechanism involving an intermediate phosphorane. A β(lg) value of -0.92 was determined for the 3-promoted cleavage reaction, and modest kinetic solvent deuterium isotope effects ranging from 1.5 to 2.8 were observed. Isomerisation was less sensitive to the nature of the esterifying group, with a β value of -0.5, and the kinetic solvent deuterium isotope effects were less than 1.5. Most of these characteristics of the 3-promoted cleavage are very similar to those for the cleavage of nucleoside 3'-phosphotriesters. These data are explained by a mechanism in which the complex primarily acts as an electrophilic catalyst neutralising the charge on the phosphate and stabilising an intermediate phosphorane, with general acid catalysis promoting the cleavage reaction. In contrast to the behaviour of triesters, isomerisation is significantly slower than cleavage; this suggests that the changes in geometry that occur during isomerisation lead to a much less stable complex between 3 and the phosphorane intermediate.

Solvent induced cooperativity of Zn(II) complexes cleaving a phosphate diester RNA analog in methanol

The kinetics of cyclization of 2-hydroxypropyl p-nitrophenyl phosphate (1) promoted by two mononuclear Zn(II) catalytic complexes of bis(2-pyridylmethyl)benzylamine (4) and bis(2-methyl 6-pyridylmethyl)benzylamine (5) in methanol were studied under (s)(s)pH-controlled conditions (where (s)(s)pH refers to [H(+)] activity in methanol). Potentiometric titrations of the ligands in the absence and presence of Zn(2+) and a non-reactive model for 1 (2-hydroxylpropyl isopropyl phosphate (HPIPP, 6)) indicate that the phosphate is bound tightly to the 4:Zn(II) and 5:Zn(II) complexes as L:Zn(II):6(-), and that each of these undergoes an additional ionization to produce L:Zn(II):6(-):((-)OCH(3)) or a bound deprotonated form of the phosphate, L:Zn(II):6(2-). Kinetic studies as a function of [L:Zn(II)] indicate that the rate is linear in [L:Zn(II)] at concentrations well above those required for complete binding of the substrate. Plots of the second order rate constants (defined as the gradient of the rate constant vs. [complex] plot) vs. (s)(s)pH in methanol are bell-shaped with rate maxima of 23 dm mol(-1) s(-1) and 146 dm mol(-1) s(-1) for 4:Zn(II) and 5:Zn(II), respectively, at their (s)(s)pH maxima of 10.5 and 10. A mechanism is proposed that involves binding of one molecule of complex to the phosphate to yield a poorly reactive 1 : 1 complex, which associates with a second molecule of complex to produce a transient cooperative 2 : 1 complex within which the cyclization of 1 is rapid. The observations support an effect of the reduced polarity solvent that encourages the cooperative association of phosphate and two independent mononuclear complexes to give a reactive entity.

Hydrolysis of 5',5'-tri- or tetraphosphate-mRNA 5'-cap analogs promoted by Cu2+ or Zn2+ metal ions

Kinetics of the hydrolysis of a P(1)-(7-methylguanosinyl-5') P(3)-(guanosinyl-5') triphosphate (m(7)GpppG), P(1)-(7-methylguanosinyl-5') P(4)- (guanosinyl-5') tetraphosphate (m(7)GppppG), diadenosine-5',5'''-P(1),P(3)-triphosphate (ApppA), and diadenosine-5',5'''-P(1),P(4)-tetraphosphate (AppppA) promoted by Cu(2+) or Zn(2+) has been investigated. Time-dependent products distributions at various metal ion concentrations have been determined by CZE and HPLC-RP. The results show that in acidic conditions, in the presence of metal ion, the predominant hydrolytic reaction is the cleavage of 5',5'-oligophosphate bridge. The 5',5'-oligophosphate bridge of the dinucleotides studied is hydrolyzed by Cu(2+) more efficiently than by Zn(2+). At the catalyst concentration of 2 mM the cleavage of the 5',5'-triphosphate bridge of m(7)GpppG was ∼3.6 times faster, and that of the tetraphosphate bridge of m(7)GppppG ∼2.3-fold faster in the presence of Cu(2+) compared to the Zn(2+) ion, applied as catalysts. Dependence of the rates of hydrolysis on the catalyst concentration was in some instances not linear, interpreted as evidence for participation of more than one metal ion in the transition complex.

Base moiety selectivity in cleavage of short oligoribonucleotides by di- and tri-nuclear Zn(II) complexes of azacrown-derived ligands

Cleavage of 6-mer oligoribonucleotides by the dinuclear Zn2+ complex of 1,3-bis[(1,5,9-triazacyclododecan-3-yl)oxymethyl]benzene (L1) and the trinuclear Zn2+ complex of 1,3,5-tris[(1,5,9-triazacyclododecan-3-yl)oxymethyl]benzene (L3) has been studied. The dinuclear complex cleaves at sufficiently low concentrations ([(Zn2+)2L1] < or = 0.1 mmol L(-1)) the 5'NpU3' and 5'UpN3' bonds (N = G, C, A) much more readily than the other phosphodiester bonds, but leaves the 5'UpU3' site intact. The trinuclear (Zn2+)3L3 complex, in turn, cleaves the 5'UpU3' bond more readily than any other linkages, even faster than the 5'NpU3' and 5'UpN3' sites. Somewhat unexpectedly, the 5'UpNpU3' site is cleaved only slowly by both the di- and tri-nuclear complex. The base-moiety selectivity remains qualitatively similar, though slightly less pronounced, when the hexanucleotides are closed to hairpin loops by three additional CG-pairs of 2'-O-methylribonucleotides. Phosphodiester bonds within a double helical stem are not cleaved, not even the 5'UpU3' sites. Guanine base also becomes recognized by (Zn2+)2L1 and (Zn2+)3L3, but the affinity to G is clearly lower than to U. The trinuclear cleaving agent, however, cleaves the 5'GpG3' bond only 35% less readily than the 5'UpU3' bond.

Efficient and selective cleavage of RNA oligonucleotides by calix[4]arene-based synthetic metallonucleases

Di- and trinuclear copper(II) complexes of [12]aneN3 macrocycles anchored at the upper rim of cone calix[4]arenes in 1,2-, 1,3-, and 1,2,3-positions were investigated as cleaving agents of 6-, 7-, and 17-meric oligoribonucleotides. A kinetic investigation of the cleavage reactions was carried out using gel electrophoresis to separate and analyze reactants and products having a radioactive phosphate label in the terminal 5'-position. The degree of cooperation was assessed on the basis of a comparison with rates of cleavage by mononuclear controls. A remarkable selectivity of cleavage of the CpA phosphodiester bond was observed for all metal complexes, in sharp contrast with the UpU and UpG selectivity previously observed in the cleavage of diribonucleoside monophosphates by the same metal complexes. The highest rate acceleration, brought about in the cleavage of the 5'-pCpA bond in hexanucleotide 9 by 50 muM trinuclear complex 5-Cu3 (water solution, pH 7.4, 50 degrees C), amounts to 5 x 105-fold, as based on the estimated background reactivity of the CpA dimer. Selectivity in the cleavage of oligoribonucleotides by copper(II) complexes closely resembles that experienced by ribonuclease A and by a number of metal-independent RNase A mimicks. The possible role of the dianionic phosphate at the 5'-terminal positions as a primary anchoring site for the metal catalyst is discussed.

Zn(II) coordination to polyamine macrocycles containing dipyridine units. New insights into the activity of dinuclear Zn(II) complexes in phosphate ester hydrolysis

Zn(II) binding by the dipyridine-containing macrocycles L1-L3 has been analyzed by means of potentiometric measurements in aqueous solutions. These ligands contain one (L1, L2) or two (L3) 2,2'-dipyridine units as an integral part of a polyamine macrocyclic framework having different dimensions and numbers of nitrogen donors. Depending on the number of donors, L1-L3 can form stable mono- and/or dinuclear Zn(II) complexes in a wide pH range. Facile deprotonation of Zn(II)-coordinated water molecules gives mono- and dihydroxo-complexes from neutral to alkaline pH values. The ability of these complexes as nucleophilic agents in hydrolytic processes has been tested by using bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate (BNPP) as a substrate. In the dinuclear complexes the two metals play a cooperative role in BNPP cleavage. In the case of the L2 dinuclear complex [Zn(2)L2(OH)(2)](2+), the two metals act cooperatively through a hydrolytic process involving a bridging interaction of the substrate with the two Zn(II) ions and a simultaneous nucleophilic attack of a Zn-OH function at phosphorus; in the case of the dizinc complex with the largest macrocycle L3, only the monohydroxo complex [Zn(2)L3(OH)](3+) promotes BNPP hydrolysis. BNPP interacts with a single metal, while the hydroxide anion may operate a nucleophilic attack. Both complexes display high rate enhancements in BNPP cleavage with respect to previously reported dizinc complexes, due to hydrophobic and pi-stacking interactions between the nitrophenyl groups of BNPP and the dipyridine units of the complexes.

Synthetic metallonucleases for RNA cleavage

Synthetic metallonucleases are versatile metal ion catalysts that use multiple catalytic strategies for the cleavage of RNA. Recent work in the design of more active metallonucleases combines a single metal ion with functional groups that interact with RNA, including amino acid fragments or additional metal ions. Rate enhancements by multifunctional catalysts for cleavage of simple model substrates with good leaving groups are as high as 10(6) but somewhat lower (10(5)) for real RNA. However, cleavage of RNA substrates is complicated by different binding modes and steric interactions that can interfere with catalysis. Antisense oligonucleotides, peptides and small molecules that act as RNA recognition agents increase the strength of substrate binding, but not necessarily the catalytic rate constant. In general, catalytic strategies used by synthetic metallonucleases are probably not optimized. A better grasp of the mechanism of RNA cleavage by metal ions and more effort on positioning the metal ion complex with respect to the cleavage site may lead to improved catalysts.

Molecular design of an acid?base cooperative catalyst for RNA cleavage based on a dizinc complex

The effects of donor groups of dizinc complexes, formed from a 2:1 mixture of Zn(II) and a dinucleating ligand, on adenylyl(3'-5')adenosine (ApA) cleavage have been studied. Two dinucleating ligands were used: one had two 2-pyridylmethyl and two 2-hydroxyethyl moieties on the 1,3-diamino-2-propanol linker moiety (2), and the other had two 2-pyridylmethyl and two carboxymethyl moieties on the 1,3-diamino-2-propanol linker moiety (3(2-)). The dizinc complex with2 [(Zn(2+))(2)-2] showed higher activities toward ApA cleavage than the dizinc complex using an analogous dinucleating ligand having four 2-pyridylmethyl donor moieties [(Zn(2+))(2)-1] at pH 5-8. The former showed a bell-shaped pH-rate constant profile, whereas the latter showed a sigmoidal pattern. The differences in the pH-rate constant profile are attributable to the various distributions of the monohydroxo-dizinc species, i.e. dideprotonated species, which are responsible for ApA cleavage. The monohydroxo species of (Zn(2+))(2)-2 has two acidic protons, which are not present in the corresponding monohydroxo species of (Zn(2+))(2)-1. The existence of both intracomplex acid (ROH or H(2)O) and base catalysts (RO(-) or OH(-)) in (Zn(2+))(2)-2 can explain its higher activity toward ApA cleavage than that of (Zn(2+))(2)-1. In contrast, (Zn(2+))(2)-3(2-) showed lower activity toward ApA cleavage at pH 7.0, which can be ascribed to the absence of the monohydroxo-dizinc species under these conditions.