The predictive value of positive and suspicious urine cytology: Are they different?

A Combination of Cell Findings Improves the Accuracy of Voided Urine Cytology

Introduction

Urine cytology is a morphological diagnostic test that is, patient-friendly and easy to sample but subjective in morphological evaluation. This study aims to evaluate the effect of combining cell findings to assess urine cytology.

Materials and Methods

Thirty cell findings found in high-grade urothelial carcinoma (HGUC) were selected for morphological abnormalities, each with detailed definitions. All 66 HGUC and 30 benign cases were examined for morphological abnormalities. The number of cases with at least one abnormal cell finding deviating from normal cells was used. The HGUC and benign cases were compared using significance difference tests. Using the cell findings extracted by the exact tests, discriminant analysis was performed to determine the valid cell findings for HGUC diagnosis.

Results

There was a difference in the detection rate of abnormal findings between HGUC and benign cases. Additionally, 20 cell findings were detected significantly more frequently in patients with HGUC. Furthermore, the discriminant analysis revealed that six cellular findings (high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio, hyperchromasia, eccentric nuclei, nuclear protrusion, unevenly distributed chromatin, and irregular nuclear shape) showed high accuracy in confirming the diagnosis of HGUC.

Conclusions

Five- to six-cell findings were individually valid; however, the combination of cell findings is crucial for an objective and accurate diagnosis of HGUC.

Impact of implementing the first edition of the Paris system for reporting: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Urine cytology is a noninvasive, widely used diagnostic tool for screening and surveillance of genitourinary tract neoplasms. However, the absence of unified terminology and clear objective morphological criteria limits the clinical benefit of urine cytology. The Paris System for Reporting Urine Cytology (TPS) was developed with the goal of standardizing reporting and improving urine cytology performance in detecting high-grade malignancy (HGM). We aimed to evaluate potential effects of TPS on improving urine cytology diagnostic performance and clinical utility by conducting a systematic review and meta-analysis. We searched six electronic databases to identify cross-sectional and cohort studies written in English assessing the accuracy of urine cytology in detecting genitourinary tract malignancies of patients under surveillance or with clinical suspicion of malignancy from January 2004 to December 2022. We extracted relevant data from eligible studies to calculate relative distribution of cytology diagnostic categories; ratio of atypical to HGM cytology diagnosis; and risk of HGM (ROHGM) and HGM likelihood ratio (HGM-LR) associated with cytology diagnostic categories. We used a generalized linear mixed model with logit transformation to combine proportions and multilevel mixed-effect logistic regression to pool diagnostic accuracy measurements. We performed meta-regression to evaluate any significant difference between TPS and non-TPS cohorts. We included 64 studies for 99,796 combined total cytology samples, across 31 TPS and 49 non-TPS cohorts. Pooled relative distribution [95% confidence interval (CI)] of negative for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (NHGUC)/negative for malignancy (NM); atypical urothelial cells (AUC); suspicious for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (SHGUC)/suspicious for malignancy (SM); low-grade urothelial neoplasm (LGUN); and HGM categories among satisfactory cytology cases were 83.8% (80.3%-86.9%), 8.0% (6.0%-10.6%), 2.2% (1.4%-3.3%), 0.01% (0.0%-0.1%), and 4.2% (3.2%-5.5%) in TPS versus 80.8% (76.8-2.7%), 11.3% (8.6%-14.7%), 1.8% (1.2%-2.7%), 0.01% (0.0%-0.1%), and 3.3% (2.5%-4.3%) in non-TPS cohorts. Adopting TPS classification resulted in a significant increase in the frequency of NHGUC and a reduction in AUC cytology diagnoses, respectively. The AUC/HGM ratio in TPS cohort was 2.0, which showed a statistically significant difference from the atypical/HGM ratio of 4.1 in non-TPS cohort (p-value: 0.01). Moreover, the summary rate (95% CI) of LGUN called AUC on cytology significantly decreased to 20.8% (14.9%-28.3%) in the TPS compared with 34.1% (26.4%-42.8%) in non-TPS cohorts. The pooled ROHGM (95% CI) was 20.4% (6.2%-50.0%) in nondiagnostic (NDX), 15.5% (9.6%-24.2%) in NHGUC, 40.2% (30.9%-50.2%) in AUC, 80.8% (72.9%-86.8%) in SHGUC, 15.1% (5.7%-34.3%) in LGUN, and 91.4% (87.3%-94.3%) in HGM categories in TPS studies. NHGUC, AUC, SHGUC, and HGM categories were associated with HGM-LR (95% CI) of 0.2 (0.1-0.3), 0.9 (0.6-1.3), 6.9 (2.4-19.9), and 16.8 (8.3-33.8). Our results suggest that TPS 1.0 has reduced the relative frequency of AUC diagnosis, AUC/HGM ratio, and the frequency of LGUNs diagnosed as AUC on cytology. Adopting this classification has improved the clinical utility of SHGUC and HGM cytology diagnoses in ruling in high-grade lesions. However, an NHGUC diagnosis does not reliably rule out the presence of a high-grade lesion.

The Role of Urine and Washing Cytology in Primary Transurethral Resection of Bladder Tumours

INTRODUCTION

Urine cytology (UC) is a recommended tool for the diagnosis of urothelial malignancies. Thus far, no specific recommendations regarding the role of washing cytology (WC) have been included in the guidelines. The goal of our study was to analyse the relationship between the histology of transurethrally (transurethral resection of the bladder [TURBT]) resected bladder tumours (BCa) and intraoperative UC or WC findings.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five hundred consecutive primary TURBT cases conducted between November 2010 and 2015 at our department of the University Hospital Luebeck were retrospectively analysed. Sensitivity, specificity, positive (PPV) and negative predictive values (NPV) of UC and WC were evaluated to detect BCa. Multivariate logistic regression models were fit to further examine associations between patient- and tumour-related factors and a bladder UC or WC positive for BCa.

RESULTS

UC was performed in 297 patients, WC in 294 patients, and both in 261 patients. Sensitivity was 50.7% in UC, 58.1% in WC, and 62.1% for both tests combined. Specificity was 97.8% for UC, 98.0% for WC, and 96.4% for the combined tests. PPV was 98.0% for UC, 98.1% for WC, and 97.2% for combined tests. NPV was 47.8% for UC, 54.5% for WC, and 55.9% for the combined tests. The multivariate analyses revealed no association between positive UC or WC results and subsequent radical cystectomy (UC OR 1.35, 95% CI: 0.3-5.7; WC OR 2.0, 95% CI: 0.4-11.4). Neither UC nor WC was significantly correlated with local recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

Cytologic testing is an important diagnostic tool in BCa detection, showing acceptable sensitivity of around 60% and excellent specificity of over 90%. UC and WC present similar sensitivity. Our results advocate, however, against cytologic testing during primary TURBT, especially with regard to the lack of value in assessing the risk of recurrence. The clinical benefit of taking both types of samples at once is minimal. Furthermore, intraoperative WC collection does not reliably predict subsequent cystectomies.

The Paris System for Reporting Urinary Cytology: A Meta-Analysis

The Paris System (TPS) for Reporting Urinary Cytology is a standardized, evidence-based reporting system, comprising seven diagnostic categories: nondiagnostic, negative for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (NHGUC), atypical urothelial cells (AUC), suspicious for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (SHGUC), HGUC, low-grade urothelial neoplasm (LGUN), and other malignancies. This study aimed to calculate the pooled risk of high-grade malignancy (ROHM) of each category and demonstrate the diagnostic accuracy of urine cytology reported with TPS. Four databases (PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science) were searched. Specific inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied, while data were extracted and analyzed both qualitatively and quantitatively. The pooled ROHM was 17.70% for the nondiagnostic category (95% CI, 0.0650; 0.3997), 13.04% for the NHGUC (95% CI, 0.0932; 0.1796), 38.65% for the AUC (95% CI, 0.3042; 0.4759), 12.45% for the LGUN (95% CI, 0.0431; 0.3101), 76.89 for the SHGUC (95% CI, 0.7063; 0.8216), and 91.79% for the HGUC and other malignancies (95% CI, 0.8722; 0.9482). A summary ROC curve was created and the Area Under the Curve (AUC) was 0.849, while the pooled sensitivity was 0.669 (95% CI, 0.589; 0.741) and false-positive rate was 0.101 (95% CI, 0.063; 0.158). In addition, the pooled DOR of the included studies was 21.258 (95% CI, 14.336; 31.522). TPS assigns each sample into a diagnostic category linked with a specific ROHM, guiding clinical management.