Single-cell analyses of CD4+ T cells from alpha beta T cell receptor-transgenic mice: a distinct mucosal cytokine phenotype in the absence of transgene-specific antigen

Neuroantigen-Specific CD4 Cells Expressing Interferon-γ (IFN-γ), Interleukin (IL)-2 and IL-3 in a Mutually Exclusive Manner Prevail in Experimental Allergic Encephalomyelitis (EAE)

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is mediated by neuroantigen-specific pro-inflammatory T cells of the Th1 and Th17 effector class. Th-17 cells can be clearly defined by expression of IL-17, but not IFN-γ, IL-2 or IL-3. Th1 cells do not express IL-17, but it is unclear presently to what extent they co-express the cytokines canonically assigned to Th1 immunity (i.e., IFN-γ, IL-2 and IL-3) and whether CD4 cells producing these cytokines indeed belong to a single Th1 lineage. It is also unclear to what extent the Th1 response in EAE entails polyfunctional T cells that co-express IFN-γ and IL-2. Therefore, we dissected the Th1 cytokine signature of neuroantigen-specific CD4 cells studying at single cell resolution co-expression of IFN-γ, IL-2 and IL-3 using dual color cytokine ELISPOT analysis. Shortly after immunization, in the draining lymph nodes (dLN), the overall cytokine signature of the neuroantigen-specific CD4 cells was highly type 1-polarized, but IFN-γ, IL-2, and IL-3 were each secreted by different CD4 cells in a mutually exclusive manner. This single cell - single cytokine profile was stable through the course of chronic EAE-polyfunctional CD4 cells co-expressing IL-2 and IFN-γ presented less than 5% of the neuroantigen-specific T cells, even in the inflamed CNS itself. The neuroantigen-specific CD4 cells that expressed IFN-γ, IL-2 and IL-3 in a mutually exclusive manner exhibited similar functional avidities and kinetics of cytokine production, but showed different tissue distributions. These data suggest that Th1 cells do not belong to a single lineage, but different Th1 subpopulations jointly mediate Th1 immunity.

Naïve CD4+ T cells of Peyer's patches produce more IL-6 than those of spleen in response to antigenic stimulation

Peyer's patches (PPs) are potential sites where specific mucosal immune responses and oral tolerance are induced. The unique features of these immune responses are thought to occur in micromilieu and are largely affected by antigen-presenting cells (APCs) such as dendritic cells. In this study, we investigated the cytokine profiles induced by the activation of CD4(+) T cells of PPs. PP cells from TCR transgenic mice secreted greater amounts of IL-5 and IL-6 than spleen cells after antigenic stimulation. IL-5 was mainly produced by PP non-T cells, whereas IL-6 was secreted by PP CD4(+) cells. PPs contained two major populations including naïve and memory/activated CD4(+) cells; both populations secreted IL-6 upon activation. We also found that CD4(+)/CD62L(hi) naïve cells from PPs secreted a greater amount of IL-6 after stimulation than those from the spleen. Furthermore, subtraction and qPCR analyses revealed that PP CD4(+)/CD62L(hi) cells express a greater amount of transcripts of GA-binding protein β subunit 1 than those of the spleen. These results suggest that naïve T cells as well as non-T cells and activated/memory T cells from PPs are distinct from their splenic counterparts and thus cause unique immune responses the in intestine.

Oral antigen induces antigen-specific activation of intraepithelial CD4+ lymphocytes but suppresses their activation in spleen

Intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) are considered to drive immune surveillance of the epithelial layer to the mucosa, which is initially exposed to exogenous antigens. However, how IELs are activated by orally administered antigens remains unclear. To clarify this mechanism, we fed ovalbumin (OVA) to T cell receptor transgenic (TCR-Tg) mice with OVA-specific MHC class II-restricted TCR and found that the cytotoxic activity of IELs was increased against both NK and LAK target cells, but notably reduced after depleting CD8 + IELs. Cytoplasmic staining showed that the production of IFN-gamma and IL-2 was increased in mice fed with OVA both in the supernatant of cultured IELs with immobilized anti-CD3 mAb and in fresh CD4+ IELs. In contrast, the cytotoxic activity against NK and LAK target cells and the production of IL-2 and IFN-gamma was decreased in splenic T cells from mice fed with OVA. However, when the splenic T cells from these mice were cultured with OVA and IL-2, IFN-gamma production recovered. The decreased response demonstrated the clonal anergy of T cells. Furthermore, tumor growth was enhanced in TCR-Tg mice carrying an OVA-transfected counterpart A20 B cell lymphoma (OVA-A20) and fed with OVA. These results indicate that the oral administration of soluble antigens can activate CD4+ IELs in an antigen-specific manner but induces hyporesponsiveness in the spleen. In addition, Th1-type cytokines produced by activated CD4+ IEL might provide a bystander effect on the cytotoxic activity of IELs.

Experimental models of inflammatory bowel disease reveal innate, adaptive, and regulatory mechanisms of host dialogue with the microbiota

There are now many experimental models of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), most of which are due to induced mutations in mice that result in an impaired homeostasis with the intestinal microbiota. These models can be clustered into several broad categories that, in turn, define the crucial cellular and molecular mechanisms of host microbial interactions in the intestine. The first of these components is innate immunity defined broadly to include both myeloid and epithelial cell mechanisms. A second component is the effector response of the adaptive immune system, which, in most instances, comprises the CD4+ T cell and its relevant cytokines. The third component is regulation, which can involve multiple cell types, but again particularly involves CD4+ T cells. Severe impairment of a single component can result in disease, but many models demonstrate milder defects in more than one component. The same is true for both spontaneous models of IBD, C3H/HeJBir and SAMPI/Yit mice. The thesis is advanced that 'multiple hits' or defects in these interacting components is required for IBD to occur in both mouse and human.

Molecular mechanisms regulating Th1 immune responses

The T helper lymphocyte is responsible for orchestrating the appropriate immune response to a wide variety of pathogens. The recognition of the polarized T helper cell subsets Th1 and Th2 has led to an understanding of the role of these cells in coordinating a variety of immune responses, both in responses to pathogens and in autoimmune and allergic disease. Here, we discuss the mechanisms that control lineage commitment to the Th1 phenotype. What has recently emerged is a rich understanding of the cytokines, receptors, signal transduction pathways, and transcription factors involved in Th1 differentiation. Although the picture is still incomplete, the basic pathways leading to Th1 differentiation can now be understood in in vitro and a number of infection and disease models.

Bacterial-reactive T regulatory cells inhibit pathogenic immune responses to the enteric flora

We showed previously that cecal bacterial Ag (CBA)-specific CD4(+) T cells induce colitis when transferred into SCID mice. The purpose of this study was to generate and characterize CBA-specific regulatory T cells in C3H/HeJBir (Bir) mice. CD4(+) T cells were stimulated with CBA-pulsed APC in the presence of IL-10 every 10-14 days. After four or more cycles, these T cells produced high levels of IL-10, low levels of IL-4 and IFN-gamma, and no IL-2, consistent with the phenotype of T regulatory-1 (Tr1) cells. Bir Tr1 cells proliferated poorly, but their proliferation was dependent on CD28-B7 interactions and was MHC class II-restricted. Transfer of Bir Tr1 cells into SCID mice did not result in colitis, and cotransfer of Bir Tr1 T cells with pathogenic Bir CD4(+) Th1 cells prevented colitis. Bir Tr1 cells inhibited proliferation and IFN-gamma production of a CBA-specific Th1 cell line in vitro. Such inhibition was partly due to IL-10 and TGFbeta1, but cognate interactions with either APCs or Th1 cells were also involved. Normal intestinal lamina propria CD4(+) T cells had Tr1-like activity when stimulated with CBA-pulsed APCs. We conclude that CD4(+) T cells with the properties of Tr1 cells are present in the intestinal lamina propria and hypothesize that these cells maintain intestinal immune homeostasis to the enteric flora.

The state of CD4+ T cell activation is a major factor for determining the kinetics and location of T cell responses to oral antigen

Current models suggest that inductive immune responses to enteric Ag are initiated in Peyer's patches (PP) and mesenteric lymph nodes (MLN) followed by migration of activated, memory-like CD4(+) T cells to extralymphoid sites in the intestinal lamina propria (LP). The resultant immune system contains both naive and activated T cells. To examine the differential responses of naive and memory-like T cells to oral Ag, bone marrow chimeras (BMC) were generated. Irradiated BALB/c hosts were reconstituted with a mix of DO11.10 x RAG-1(-/-) and BALB/c bone marrow. In unprimed DO11.10 and BMC models, LP and PP DO11.10 T cells responded to oral Ag with similar kinetics. Responses of activated, memory-like T cells to oral Ag were examined in thymectomized BMC 60 days after i.p. immunization with OVA peptide in Freund's adjuvant (OVA(323-339)/CFA). Results indicate that i.p. OVA(323-339)/CFA generated a high proportion of memory-like CD45RB(low) DO11.10 T cells in peripheral lymphoid (40%) and intestinal LP (70%) tissue. Previously activated DO11.10 T cells in the LP responded to oral Ag earlier and at 50% higher levels compared with memory CD4(+) T cells localized to PP tissue. These data indicate that responses to oral Ag in antigenically naive animals are initiated in PP whereas in Ag-experienced animals LP T cells respond earlier and more vigorously than cells in PP. Taken together, these data suggest that previous activation alters the hierarchy of T cell responses to oral Ag by enhancing the efficiency of LP T cell activation.

Immuno-bacterial homeostasis in the gut: new insights into an old enigma

The intestinal mucosa is the interface between the immune system and the massive antigenic load represented by the commensal enteric bacteria. These commensal bacteria drive the development of the mucosal immune system, and in turn most of the lymphocytes in the intestinal mucosa appear to be specific for enteric bacteria antigens. Proper regulation of the responses of these anti-bacterial lymphocytes are extremely important because T cell effectors reactive to enteric bacterial antigens have been shown to cause chronic intestinal inflammation in an adoptive transfer system. The cells and molecules important in regulating mucosal immune response are now being identified. Insights into the mechanisms of mucosal regulation have come from a number of genetically manipulated mouse strains which develop inflammatory bowel disease in response to the enteric bacterial flora. CD4(+)T cells with regulatory function in the mucosa are being identified; other cell types such as CD8(+)T cells. NK cells, and B cells may also have a role in mucosal immune regulation. A model for T cell-immune homeostasis in the intestinal mucosa is presented.

IL-12 and Th1 immune responses in human Peyer's patches

Oral tolerance is a well-characterized phenomenon in animals and is highly effective when induced as a treatment for experimental autoimmune disease. However, its use as a therapeutic modality for the treatment of autoimmune disease in humans has been disappointing. Much of the rationale for its use in humans is based on the finding that feeding antigen to rodents elicits regulatory T cells in Peyer's patches (PPs) that secrete immunosuppressive cytokines such as transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta. By contrast, human antigen-specific PP T-cell responses, and mucosal T-cell responses in general, are strongly biased towards T helper 1 (Th1) cells, which are pro-inflammatory rather than immunosuppressive. This is caused by the high local levels of interleukin (IL)-12 in PPs.

Probability in transcriptional regulation and its implications for leukocyte differentiation and inducible gene expression

The phenotype of individual hematopoietic cells, like all other differentiated mammalian cells, is determined by selective transcription of a subset of the genes encoded within the genome. This overview summarizes the recent evidence that transcriptional regulation at the level of individual cells is best described in terms of the regulation of the probability of transcription rather than the rate. In this model, heterogeneous gene expression among populations of cells arises by chance, and the degree of heterogeneity is a function of the stability of the mRNA and protein products of individual genes. The probabilistic nature of transcriptional regulation provides one explanation for stochastic phenomena, such as stem cell lineage commitment, and monoallelic expression of inducible genes, such as lymphokines and cytokines.

Probability in transcriptional regulation and its implications for leukocyte differentiation and inducible gene expression

The phenotype of individual hematopoietic cells, like all other differentiated mammalian cells, is determined by selective transcription of a subset of the genes encoded within the genome. This overview summarizes the recent evidence that transcriptional regulation at the level of individual cells is best described in terms of the regulation of the probability of transcription rather than the rate. In this model, heterogeneous gene expression among populations of cells arises by chance, and the degree of heterogeneity is a function of the stability of the mRNA and protein products of individual genes. The probabilistic nature of transcriptional regulation provides one explanation for stochastic phenomena, such as stem cell lineage commitment, and monoallelic expression of inducible genes, such as lymphokines and cytokines.

Differential effect of cholera toxin on CD45RA+ and CD45RO+ T cells: specific inhibition of cytokine production but not proliferation of human naive T cells

We have studied how cholera toxin (CT) and its non-toxic cell-binding B-subunit (CTB) affect the activation of pure human T cells in an anti-CD3-driven system. CT, as opposed to CTB, strongly suppressed the proliferative responses as well as cytokine production in CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. CT however, had a differential effect on naive and activated/memory T cell subsets. Costimulation through exogenous IL-2 or through CD28 cross-linking rescued the proliferation of CT-treated naive CD45RA+ T cells, but not of activated/memory CD45RO+ cells. IL-2 production and IL-2 receptor expression were markedly reduced by CT in all T cell fractions, i.e. also in CD45RA+ cells which had maintained proliferative responses. However, the proliferative responses of CT-treated CD45RA+ T cells were IL-2-dependent, as shown by blocking experiments using anti-IL-2 antibodies. These results indicate (i) that CTB has no cytostatic effect on human T cells, (ii) that CT affects proliferation and cytokine production by two different signal pathways, and (iii) that CT might interact with a signal pathway generated through or influenced by CD45.

Increased frequency of surface IgA-positive plasma cells in the intestinal lamina propria and decreased IgA excretion in hyper IgA (HIGA) mice, a murine model of IgA nephropathy with hyperserum IgA

Because abnormalities of mucosal immunity have been suggested in human IgA nephropathy, we examined the involvement of mucosal immunity in IgA deposition to the kidney in hyper IgA (HIGA) mice, which was established as a mouse model for human IgA nephropathy with hyperserum IgA. The number of surface IgA+B220- lymphocytes in the intestinal lamina propria (LP) of HIGA mice increased 2.7-fold at 30 wk of age as compared with those at 10 wk of age, whereas normal mice did not show such increase. The surface IgA+B220- LP lymphocytes spontaneously secreted IgA in culture. Morphological studies showed that the surface IgA+B220- lymphocytes of murine intestinal LP are identical with plasma cells (PCs). About 20% of IgA+B220- PC in LP expressed both Mac-1 and CD19, suggesting that they may derive from peritoneal B-1 cells. Cell cycle study on intestinal IgA-PCs using bromodeoxyuridine revealed no difference between HIGA mice and normal mice, suggesting that the high frequency of IgA-producing PCs in HIGA mice is not due to enhanced proliferation or prolonged survival of IgA-producing PCs in LP. In addition, IgA secretion into the gut lumen of HIGA mice decreased drastically (to one forth) with aging. These data suggest that the increased number of intestinal IgA-producing PCs and the down-regulation of IgA excretion into the intestinal lumen might synergistically contribute to the hyperserum IgA in HIGA mice and resultant IgA deposition to the kidney.

Interferon gamma induction during oral tolerance reduces T-cell migration to sites of inflammation

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Previous data suggest that oral antigen induces interferon (IFN)-gamma production in intestinal T cells. However, oral tolerance is associated with decreased production of IFN-gamma by T cells after antigen sensitization. The aim of this study was to examine the role of IFN-gamma in oral tolerance.

METHODS

Oral tolerance was examined in BALB/c mice after the adoptive transfer of T cells from chicken ovalbumin (OVA(323-339))-specific, DO11.10 x RAG-1(-/-) T-cell receptor transgenic mice.

RESULTS

OVA feeding induced systemic tolerance of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and antibody responses. OVA feeding up-regulated IFN-gamma production by transgenic T cells in Peyer's patch and mesenteric lymph node but not splenic tissues. Treatment of OVA-fed mice with neutralizing monoclonal antibody to IFN-gamma prevented tolerance of DTH responses. Analysis of transgenic T-cell numbers in DTH sites by immunohistochemical staining suggested that induction of IFN-gamma by oral antigen decreased accumulation of transgenic T cells in cutaneous sites of antigen injection. IFN-gamma-deficient or wild-type DO11.10 and BALB/c mice were used to show that IFN-gamma production by donor transgenic T cells was critical for oral tolerance.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that the induction of IFN-gamma by oral antigen contributes to systemic tolerance by decreasing migration of T cells to peripheral sites of inflammation.

Single-cytokine-producing CD4 memory cells predominate in type 1 and type 2 immunity

The patterns of Ag-induced cytokine coexpression in normal, in vivo-primed CD4 memory T cells has remained controversial because the low frequency at which these cells occur has effectively prevented direct ex vivo measurements. We have overcome this limitation by using two-color cytokine enzyme-linked immunospot assays and computer-assisted image analysis. We found CD4 memory cells that simultaneously expressed IL-2, IL-3, IL-4, IL-5, and IFN-gamma to be rare (0-10%). This cytokine segregation was seen in adjuvant-induced type 1, type 2, and mixed immunity to OVA, in Leishmania infection regardless of the Ag dose used or how long after immunization the assay was performed. The data suggest that type 1 and type 2 immunity in vivo is not mediated by classic Th1 or Th2 cells but by single-cytokine-producing memory cells.

The Differentiated State of Intestinal Lamina Propria CD4+ T Cells Results in Altered Cytokine Production, Activation Threshold, and Costimulatory Requirements

Intestinal lamina propria (LP) CD4+ T cells are memory-like effector cells that proliferate at relatively low levels and require high levels of TCR signaling and costimulation for full activation in vitro. To study LP CD4+ T cell functional potential we used DO11.10 TCR transgenic (Tg) mice specific for the class II MHC-restricted OVA323–339 peptide and nontransgenic BALB/c mice. Activation of LP Tg+ T cells with Ag using mucosal explants induced high levels of IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-γ. Culturing isolated LP cells with IL-12 enhanced IFN-γ production and down-regulated IL-4 and IL-2, whereas addition of IL-4 maintained IL-4 production without inhibiting IFN-γ production. Systemic administration of relatively high dose (HD; 100 nM) OVA323–339 peptide induced similar levels of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) incorporation by LP and splenic Tg+ T cells in vivo, whereas low dose (LD; 4.5 nM) peptide injections induced 4-fold greater levels of BrdU incorporation for LP compared with splenic Tg+ T cells. Coadministration of CTLA-4Ig reduced BrdU incorporation for splenic cells by 70% with HD and LD stimulation, but had little effect on LP responses to HD stimulation. Results of in vivo studies were confirmed in nontransgenic BALB/c mice using HD (200 μg) and LD (10 μg) anti-CD3 mAb+/− CTLA-4Ig. These results suggest that LP T cells are differentiated effector cells that respond at high levels when activated with relatively low levels of Ag- and B7-mediated costimulation in vivo. The reduced activation threshold of LP T cells may facilitate responses to low levels of Ag derived from mucosal pathogens.

Effector and regulatory lymphoid cells and cytokines in mucosal sites

In this review, I hope to have highlighted that cytokines are of crucial importance in the normal homeostasis of the gut immune system, the interactions of the gut immune system with enteric antigens and also in tissue injury associated with IBD. There is evidence from a number of different systems that the response to nominal non-replicating antigens, administered nasally or orally, is skewed towards a non-Th1 type of response. To say that the response is Th2, Th3 or Tr is premature. IL-10 and TGF beta seem to be important in downregulating potentially tissue-damaging Th1 responses to the normal flora and possibly food antigens. However, it need to be seen whether the mouse results also apply to humans. A consistent pattern in disease states, whether it be human or mouse, is an exaggerated Th1 type response with excess local production of IFN-gamma and TNF alpha, and its association with tissue injury. An important question to address is whether this represents a switch from the Th2, Th3, or Tr pathway towards a Th1 pathway, or whether the Th1 pathway is in fact always present in the gut, but is kept in check and non-pathogenic by regulatory cells. Equally important is the need to discover where regulation occurs: is it in the PP or the lamina propria? Intriguing results from Kronenberg and colleagues have shown that SCID mice reconstituted with CD45RBhi or CD45RBlo cells show no difference in the re-population of the gut prior to disease (ARANDA et al. 1997). The reason for colitis developing in those mice reconstituted with CD45RBhi cells is therefore more complex than merely differential re-population kinetics. No matter what the outcome is, these and other related questions dealing with the induction and expression of mucosal T-cell responses are going to produce some surprises in the next few years.

Heterogeneity in the clonal T cell response. Implications for models of T cell activation and cytokine phenotype development

The T cell can be defined in the context of two properties--the recognition specificity of the T cell receptor (TCR) heterodimer and the functional response of the T cell after TCR stimulation. Once a particular TCR heterodimer is expressed and successfully selected during thymic development, the antigen specificity is fixed for all the clonal progeny of that cell. In contrast, the potential functional responses that may be generated in response to specific antigen in the postthymic environment are quite extensive. These range from programmed cell death to initiation of alternate programs of phenotype development that generate effector populations with distinct cytokine expression patterns and regulatory properties. Recent advances in analytical methods that have permitted multiparametric characterizations of the T cell response at the single cell, rather than population level, have necessitated a modified view of T cell activation and the clonal T cell response, and have generated new insights into the regulation of immunity. In this brief review, we highlight studies that have characterized heterogeneity of the CD4+ T cell clonal response based on single-cell analyses, and discuss implications for models of T cell activation and cytokine phenotype development.