Sustained delivery of therapeutic concentrations of human clotting factor IX--a comparison of adenoviral and AAV vectors administered in utero

Acceptability of prenatal diagnosis and prenatal treatment of haemophilia using cell and gene therapies within US haemophilia community

BACKGROUND

The overall burden of disease in persons with haemophilia continues to be high despite the latest advancements in therapeutics. Clinical trials testing prenatal treatments for several genetic disorders are underway or are recruiting subjects, attesting to the much-needed change in paradigm of how patients with monogenic disorders can be treated. Here we investigate the overall attitude towards prenatal diagnosis, preferences on types of prenatal therapies for haemophilia, the level of 'acceptable' risk tolerated, and which social and moral pressures or disease personal experiences may predict willingness of individuals to consider foetal therapy in a future pregnancy.

RESULTS

A multidisciplinary team designed the survey, and the study was carried out using REDCap, and publicized through the National Haemophilia Foundation. Subjects ≥18 years of age were eligible to participate in the study. We assessed participants' attitudes towards prenatal therapy and their level of 'acceptable' risk towards the procedure and therapy. The survey was completed by 67 adults, the majority females. Respondents were willing to undergo prenatal diagnosis, and their main concerns related to the well-being of the pregnant woman and the foetus regarding lasting therapeutic efficacy, side effects of the therapy, and procedural risks, but they were likely to accept a wide range of prenatal therapeutic options, particularly if the foetal therapy proved to be long-lasting and safe.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate the willingness of persons with haemophilia, and the haemophilia community, to explore new treatment options beyond the currently offered approaches.

Gene modification therapies for hereditary diseases in the fetus

Proof-of-principle disease models have demonstrated the feasibility of an intrauterine gene modification therapy (in utero gene therapy (IUGT)) approach to hereditary diseases as diverse as coagulation disorders, haemoglobinopathies, neurogenetic disorders, congenital metabolic, and pulmonary diseases. Gene addition, which requires the delivery of an integrating or episomal transgene to the target cell nucleus to be transcribed, and gene editing, where the mutation is corrected within the gene of origin, have both been used successfully to increase normal protein production in a bid to reverse or arrest pathology in utero. While most experimental models have employed lentiviral, adenoviral, and adeno-associated viral vectors engineered to efficiently enter target cells, newer models have also demonstrated the applicability of non-viral lipid nanoparticles. Amelioration of pathology is dependent primarily on achieving sustained therapeutic transgene expression, silencing of transgene expression, production of neutralising antibodies, the dilutional effect of the recipient's growth on the mass of transduced cells, and the degree of pre-existing cellular damage. Safety assessment of any IUGT strategy will require long-term postnatal surveillance of both the fetal recipient and the maternal bystander for cell and genome toxicity, oncogenic potential, immune-responsiveness, and germline mutation. In this review, we discuss advances in the field and the push toward clinical translation of IUGT.

Safety and immunogenicity of Fc-EDA, a recombinant ectodysplasin A1 replacement protein, in human subjects

In X‐linked hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia, the most frequent ectodermal dysplasia, an inherited deficiency of the signalling protein ectodysplasin A1 (EDA1) impairs the development of the skin and its appendages, various eccrine glands, and dentition. The severe hypohidrosis common to X‐linked hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia patients may lead to life‐threatening hyperthermia, especially during hot weather or febrile illness. Fc‐EDA, an EDA1 replacement protein known to prevent the disease in newborn animals, was tested in 2 clinical trials (human adults and neonates) and additionally administered under compassionate use to 3 infants in utero. The data support the safety of Fc‐EDA and efficacy if applied prenatally. Anti‐drug antibodies were detected after intravenous administration in adult males and nonpregnant females, but not in pregnant women when Fc‐EDA was delivered intra‐amniotically. Most importantly, there was no detectable immune response to the investigational drug in neonates treated by intravenous infusions and in infants who had received Fc‐EDA in utero. In conclusion, the safety profile of this drug encourages further development of prenatal EDA1 replacement therapy.

Mechanistic Insights into Factor VIII Immune Tolerance Induction via Prenatal Cell Therapy in Hemophilia A

Purpose of Review

Prenatal stem cell and gene therapy approaches are amongst the few therapies that can promise the birth of a healthy infant with specific known genetic diseases. This review describes fetal immune cell signaling and its potential influence on donor cell engraftment, and summarizes mechanisms of central T cell tolerance to peripherally-acquired antigen in the context of prenatal therapies for Hemophilia A.

Recent Findings

During early gestation, different subsets of antigen presenting cells take up peripherally-acquired, non-inherited antigens and induce the deletion of antigen-reactive T-cell precursors in the thymus, demonstrating the potential for using prenatal cell and gene therapies to induce central tolerance to FVIII in the context of prenatal diagnosis/therapy of Hemophilia A.

Summary

Prenatal cell and gene therapies are promising approaches to treat several genetic disorders including Hemophilia A and B. Understanding the mechanisms of how FVIII-specific tolerance is achieved during ontogeny could help develop novel therapies for HA and better approaches to overcome FVIII inhibitors.

In utero stem cell transplantation and gene therapy: rationale, history, and recent advances toward clinical application

Recent advances in high-throughput molecular testing have made it possible to diagnose most genetic disorders relatively early in gestation with minimal risk to the fetus. These advances should soon allow widespread prenatal screening for the majority of human genetic diseases, opening the door to the possibility of treatment/correction prior to birth. In addition to the obvious psychological and financial benefits of curing a disease in utero, and thereby enabling the birth of a healthy infant, there are multiple biological advantages unique to fetal development, which provide compelling rationale for performing potentially curative treatments, such as stem cell transplantation or gene therapy, prior to birth. Herein, we briefly review the fields of in utero transplantation (IUTx) and in utero gene therapy and discuss the biological hurdles that have thus far restricted success of IUTx to patients with immunodeficiencies. We then highlight several recent experimental breakthroughs in immunology, hematopoietic/marrow ontogeny, and in utero cell delivery, which have collectively provided means of overcoming these barriers, thus setting the stage for clinical application of these highly promising therapies in the near future.

Hemophilia A: an ideal disease to correct in utero

Hemophilia A (HA) is the most frequent inheritable defect of the coagulation proteins. The current standard of care for patients with HA is prophylactic factor infusion, which is comprised of regular (2-3 times per week) intravenous infusions of recombinant or plasma-derived FVIII to maintain hemostasis. While this treatment has greatly increased the quality of life and lengthened the life expectancy for many HA patients, its high cost, the need for lifelong infusions, and the fact that it is unavailable to roughly 75% of the world's HA patients make this type of treatment far from ideal. In addition, this lifesaving therapy suffers from a high risk of treatment failure due to immune response to the infused FVIII. There is thus a need for novel treatments, such as those using stem cells and/or gene therapy, which have the potential to mediate long-term correction or permanent cure following a single intervention. In the present review, we discuss the clinical feasibility and unique advantages that an in utero approach to treating HA could offer, placing special emphasis on a new sheep model of HA we have developed and on the use of mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) as cellular vehicles for delivering the FVIII gene.

Role of antigen-specific regulatory CD4+CD25+ T cells in tolerance induction after neonatal IP administration of AAV-hF.IX

Neonatal AAV8-mediated Factor IX (F.IX) gene delivery was applied as a model for exploring mechanisms of tolerance induction during immune ontogeny. Intraperitoneal delivery of AAV8/ Factor IX (hF.IX) during weeks 1–4 of life, over a 20-fold dose range, directed stable hF.IX expression, correction of coagulopathy in F.IX-null hemophilia B mice, and induction of tolerance to hF.IX; however, only primary injection at 1–2 days of life enabled increasing AAV8-mediated hF.IX expression after re-administration, due to the absence of anti-viral capsid antibodies. Adoptive splenocyte transfer from tolerized mice demonstrated induction of CD4⁺CD25⁺ T regulatory (T_reg) populations that specifically suppressed anti-hF.IX antibody responses, but not responses to third party antigen. Induction of hF.IX antibodies was only observed in tolerized mice after in vivo CD4⁺CD25⁺ cell depletion and hF.IX challenge. Thus, primary injection of AAV during a critical period in the first week of life does not elicit antiviral responses, enabling re-administration of AAV and augmentation of hF.IX levels. Expansion of hF.IX-specific CD4⁺CD25⁺ T_regs has a major role in tolerance induction early in immune ontogeny. Neonatal gene transfer provides a useful approach for defining the ontogeny of immune responses and may suggest approaches for inducing tolerance in the context of genetic therapies.

Stem cell and genetic therapies for the fetus

The prenatal diagnosis and management of congenital disease has made significant progress over the previous decade. Currently, fetal therapy (including open surgery and fetoscopic intervention) provides therapeutic options for a range of congenital anomalies; however, it is restricted to the treatment of fetal pathophysiology. Improvements in prenatal screening and the early diagnosis of genetic disease allow for preemptive treatment of anticipated postnatal disease by stem cell or genetic therapy. While currently awaiting clinical application, in utero stem cell therapy has made significant advances in overcoming the engraftment and immunologic barriers in both murine and pre-clinical large animal models. Likewise, proof in principle for fetal gene therapy has been demonstrated in rodent and large animal systems as a method to prevent the onset of inherited genetic disease; however, safety and ethical risks still need to be addressed prior to human application. In this review, we examine the current status and future direction of stem cell and genetic therapy for the fetus.

Treatment of Hemophilia A in Utero and Postnatally using Sheep as a Model for Cell and Gene Delivery

Hemophilia A represents the most common inheritable deficiency of the coagulation proteins. Current state-of- the-art treatment consists of frequent prophylactic infusions of plasma-derived or recombinant FVIII protein to maintain hemostasis, and has greatly increased life expectancy and quality of life for many hemophilia A patients. This treatment approach is, however, far from ideal, due to the need for lifelong intravenous infusions, the high treatment cost, and the fact that it is unavailable to a large percentage of the world's hemophiliacs. There is thus a need for novel treatments that can promise long-term or permanent correction. In contrast to existing protein based therapeutics, gene therapy offers to provide a permanent cure following few, or even a single, treatment. In the present paper, we review ongoing work towards this end, focusing on studies we have performed in a large animal model. Some of the key topics covered in this review include the unique opportunities sheep offer as a model system, the re-establishment and clinical and molecular characterization of a line of sheep with severe hemophilia A, the advantages and feasibility of treating a disease like hemophilia A in utero, and the use of Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSC) as cellular delivery vehicles for the FVIII gene. The review finishes with a brief discussion of our recent success correcting ovine hemophilia A with a postnatal transplant with gene-modified MSC, and the limitations of this approach that remain to be overcome.

Fetal gene therapy: recent advances and current challenges

INTRODUCTION

Fetal gene therapy (FGT) can potentially be applied to perinatally lethal monogenic diseases for rescuing clinically severe phenotypes, increasing the probability of intact neurological and other key functions at birth, or inducing immune tolerance to a transgenic protein to facilitate readministration of the vector/protein postnatally. As the field is still at an experimental stage, there are several important considerations regarding the practicality and the ethics of FGT.

AREAS COVERED

Here, through a review of FGT studies, the authors discuss the role and applications of FGT, the progress made with animal models that simulate human development, possible adverse effects in the recipient fetus and the mother and factors that affect clinical translation.

EXPERT OPINION

Although there are valid safety and ethical concerns, the authors argue that there may soon be enough convincing evidence from non-human primate models to take the next step towards clinical trials in the near future.

Proteases as therapeutics

Proteases are an expanding class of drugs that hold great promise. The U.S. FDA (Food and Drug Administration) has approved 12 protease therapies, and a number of next generation or completely new proteases are in clinical development. Although they are a well-recognized class of targets for inhibitors, proteases themselves have not typically been considered as a drug class despite their application in the clinic over the last several decades; initially as plasma fractions and later as purified products. Although the predominant use of proteases has been in treating cardiovascular disease, they are also emerging as useful agents in the treatment of sepsis, digestive disorders, inflammation, cystic fibrosis, retinal disorders, psoriasis and other diseases. In the present review, we outline the history of proteases as therapeutics, provide an overview of their current clinical application, and describe several approaches to improve and expand their clinical application. Undoubtedly, our ability to harness proteolysis for disease treatment will increase with our understanding of protease biology and the molecular mechanisms responsible. New technologies for rationally engineering proteases, as well as improved delivery options, will expand greatly the potential applications of these enzymes. The recognition that proteases are, in fact, an established class of safe and efficacious drugs will stimulate investigation of additional therapeutic applications for these enzymes. Proteases therefore have a bright future as a distinct therapeutic class with diverse clinical applications.

Perinatal gene transfer to the liver

The liver acts as a host to many functions hence raising the possibility that any one may be compromised by a single gene defect. Inherited or de novo mutations in these genes may result in relatively mild diseases or be so devastating that death within the first weeks or months of life is inevitable. Some diseases can be managed using conventional medicines whereas others are, as yet, untreatable. In this review we consider the application of early intervention gene therapy in neonatal and fetal preclinical studies. We appraise the tools of this technology, including lentivirus, adenovirus and adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based vectors. We highlight the application of these for a range of diseases including hemophilia, urea cycle disorders such as ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency, organic acidemias, lysosomal storage diseases including mucopolysaccharidoses, glycogen storage diseases and bile metabolism. We conclude by assessing the advantages and disadvantages associated with fetal and neonatal liver gene transfer.

Stem cell and genetic therapies for the fetus

Advances in prenatal diagnosis have led to the prenatal management of a variety of congenital diseases. Although prenatal stem cell and gene therapy await clinical application, they offer tremendous potential for the treatment of many genetic disorders. Normal developmental events in the fetus offer unique biologic advantages for the engraftment of hematopoietic stem cells and efficient gene transfer that are not present after birth. Although barriers to hematopoietic stem cell engraftment exist, progress has been made and preclinical studies are now underway for strategies based on prenatal tolerance induction to facilitate postnatal cellular transplantation. Similarly, in-utero gene therapy shows experimental promise for a host of diseases and proof-in-principle has been demonstrated in murine models, but ethical and safety issues still need to be addressed. Here we review the current status and future potential of prenatal cellular and genetic therapy.

A new genetic vaccine platform based on an adeno-associated virus isolated from a rhesus macaque

We created a hybrid adeno-associated virus (AAV) from two related rhesus macaque isolates, called AAVrh32.33, and evaluated it as a vaccine carrier for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and type A influenza virus antigens. The goal was to overcome the limitations of vaccines based on other AAVs, which generate dysfunctional T-cell responses and are inhibited by antibodies found in human sera. Injection of a Gag-expressing AAVrh32.33 vector into mice resulted in a high-quality CD8(+) T-cell response. The resulting Gag-specific T cells express multiple cytokines at high levels, including interleukin-2, with many having memory phenotypes; a subsequent boost with an adenovirus vector yielded a brisk expansion of Gag-specific T cells. A priming dose of AAVrh32.33 led to high levels of Gag antibodies, which exceed levels found after injection of adenovirus vectors. Importantly, passive transfer of pooled human immunoglobulin into mice does not interfere with the efficacy of AAVrh32.33 expressing nucleoproteins from influenza virus, as measured by protection to a lethal dose of influenza virus, which is consistent with the very low seroprevalence to this virus in humans. Studies of macaques with vectors expressing gp140 from HIV-1 (i.e., with AAVrh32.33 as the prime and simian adenovirus type 24 as the boost) demonstrated results similar to those for mice with high-level and high-quality CD8(+) T-cell responses to gp140 and high-titered neutralizing antibodies to homologous HIV-1. The biology of this novel AAV hybrid suggests that it should be a preferred genetic vaccine carrier, capable of generating robust T- and B-cell responses.

Prenatal stem cell transplantation and gene therapy

At the present time, the most likely and eminent application of stem cell therapy to the fetus is in utero hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (IUHCT), and this stem cell type will be discussed as a paradigm for all prenatal stem cell therapy. The authors feel that the most likely initial application of IUHCT will use adult HSC derived from bone marrow (BM) or peripheral blood (PB), and will focus this article on this specific approach. The article also reviews the experimental data that support the capacity of IUHCT to induce donor-specific tolerance.

Biological function of laminin-5 and pathogenic impact of its deficiency

The basement membrane glycoprotein laminin-5 is a key component of the anchoring complex connecting keratinocytes to the underlying dermis. It is secreted by keratinocytes as a cross-shaped heterotrimer of alpha3, beta3 and gamma2 chains and serves as a ligand of various transmembrane receptors, thereby regulating keratinocyte adhesion, motility and proliferation. In intact skin, laminin-5 provides essential links to both the hemidesmosomal alpha6beta4 integrin and the collagen type VII molecules which form the anchoring fibrils inserting into the dermis. If the basement membrane is injured, laminin-5 production increases rapidly. It then serves as a scaffold for cell migration, initiates the formation of hemidesmosomes and accelerates basement membrane restoration at the dermal-epidermal junction. Mutations of the laminin-5 genes or auto-antibodies against one of the subunits of laminin-5 may lead to a significant lack of this molecule in the epidermal basement membrane zone. The major contributions of laminin-5 to the resistance of the epidermis against frictional stress but also for basement membrane regeneration and repair of damaged skin are reflected by the phenotype of Herlitz junctional epidermolysis bullosa, which is caused by an inherited absence of functional laminin-5. This lethal disease becomes manifest in widespread blistering of skin and mucous membranes, impaired wound healing and chronic erosions containing exuberant granulation tissue. Here, we discuss current understanding of the biological functions of laminin-5, the pathogenic impact of its deficiency and implications on molecular approaches towards a therapy of junctional epidermolysis bullosa.

Gene therapy for the fetus: is there a future?

Gene therapy uses the intracellular delivery of genetic material for the treatment of disease. A wide range of diseases - including cancer, vascular and neurodegenerative disorders and inherited genetic diseases - are being considered as targets for this therapy in adults. There are particular reasons why fetal application might prove better than application in the adult for treatment, or even prevention of early-onset genetic disorders such as cystic fibrosis and Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Research shows that gene transfer to the developing fetus targets rapidly expanding populations of stem cells, which are inaccessible after birth, and indicates that the use of integrating vector systems results in permanent gene transfer. In animal models of congenital disease such as haemophilia, studies show that the functionally immature fetal immune system does not respond to the product of the introduced gene, and therefore immune tolerance can be induced. This means that treatment could be repeated after birth, if that was necessary to continue to correct the disease. For clinicians and parents, fetal gene therapy would give a third choice following prenatal diagnosis of inherited disease, where termination of pregnancy or acceptance of an affected child are currently the only options. Application of this therapy in the fetus must be safe, reliable and cost-effective. Recent developments in the understanding of genetic disease, vector design, and minimally invasive delivery techniques have brought fetal gene therapy closer to clinical practice. However more research needs to be done in before it can be introduced as a therapy.

Persistent expression of hF.IX After tolerance induction by in utero or neonatal administration of AAV-1-F.IX in hemophilia B mice

The major complication associated with protein replacement therapy currently used in the treatment of hemophilia B (HB) is the development of antibodies to the infused human Factor IX (hF.IX). We hypothesized that vector-mediated expression of hF.IX, either at a prenatal stage or early in life may lead to tolerance to hF.IX and long-term transgene expression. Fetal, neonatal, and adult F.IX-deficient mice were injected with AAV-1-hF.IX, and the hF.IX levels as well as antibodies to hF.IX in the circulation were assayed. In utero injection followed by postnatal re-administration of adeno-associated virus 1 (AAV-1) vector achieved persistent expression of hF.IX in all animals, with no cellular or humoral immune response to F.IX. Similar results were seen after initial injection in neonatal mice followed by re-administration, whereas all mice injected at the adult stage developed antibodies to hF.IX. In contrast, after administration of AAV-2-hF.IX in the neonatal period, antibodies to hF.IX were formed in all the injected animals. We conclude that in utero or neonatal-stage injection of AAV-1-hF.IX can lead to long-term expression and absence of immune response. The differences in immune response between the AAV-1 and AAV-2 groups suggests that tolerance may be related to differences in bio-distribution, timing of expression, and/or the initial levels of hF.IX expression. This supports the concept of a narrow "window of opportunity" for tolerance induction.

Evaluation of prenatal intra-amniotic LAMB3 gene delivery in a mouse model of Herlitz disease

Prenatal gene therapy has been considered for Herlitz junctional epidermolysis bullosa (H-JEB), a lethal genodermatosis caused by the absence of any of the three subunits of laminin-5, resulting from birth in widespread blistering and erosions of skin and mucosae. To investigate this strategy in an animal model, adenovirus type 5- and adeno-associated virus (AAV) type 2-derived vectors carrying a beta-galactosidase reporter gene or LAMB3 cDNA encoding the beta3 chain of laminin-5 were generated, tested for stability in amniotic fluid and evaluated in vitro on murine H-JEB keratinocytes, and in vivo by prenatal injection into the amniotic cavities of laminin-5 beta3-deficient mice. The different vectors were administered individually or combined at maximum doses on day 14 post coitum. Adenoviral vectors infected preferentially the foetal epidermis, whereas AAV delivered the transgene mainly to mucous membranes of the airways and the upper digestive tract. The LAMB3 transgene was expressed in target epithelia of newborn laminin-5 beta3-deficient mice, and the transgenic beta3 chain was shown to assemble with its endogenous partner chains, resulting in detectable amounts of laminin-5 in the basement membranes of skin and mucosae and in a lower extent of tissue separation in the skin. However, only combined delivery of the two vector types led to a minor increase of the life span of H-JEB mice. Failure to rescue diseased animals was, at least in part, due to abandonment of any conspicuous pup by the heterozygous mother. This is the first study of a prenatal gene therapy approach to a heritable blistering disorder. Although our findings indicate that prenatal combined administration of adenoviral and adeno-associated LAMB3 vectors provides therapeutic benefit to H-JEB mice, this animal model appears unsuitable for long-term investigations of the therapeutic concept.

Utility of intraperitoneal administration as a route of AAV serotype 5 vector-mediated neonatal gene transfer

BACKGROUND

Gene transfer into a fetus or neonate can be a fundamental approach for treating genetic diseases, particularly disorders that have irreversible manifestations in adulthood. Although the potential utility of this technique has been suggested, the advantages of neonatal gene transfer have not been widely investigated. Here, we tested the usefulness of neonatal gene transfer using adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors by comparing the administration routes and vector doses.

METHODS

To determine the optimal administration route, neonates were subjected to intravenous (i.v.) or intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections of AAV5-based vectors encoding the human coagulation factor IX (hfIX) gene, and the dose response was examined. To determine the distribution of transgene expression, vectors encoding lacZ or luciferase (luc) genes were used and assessed by X-gal staining and in vivo imaging, respectively. After the observation period, the vector distribution across tissues was quantified.

RESULTS

The factor IX concentration was higher in i.p.-injected mice than in i.v.-injected mice. All transgenes administered by i.p. injection were more efficiently expressed in neonates than in adults. The expression was confined to the peritoneal tissue. Interestingly, a sex-related difference was observed in transgene expression in adults, whereas this difference was not apparent in neonates.

CONCLUSIONS

AAV vector administration to neonates using the i.p. route was clearly advantageous in obtaining robust transgene expression. Vector genomes and transgene expression were observed mainly in the peritoneal tissue. These findings indicate the advantages of neonatal gene therapy and would help in designing strategies for gene therapy using AAV vectors.

In vivo delivery of recombinant viruses to the fetal murine cochlea: transduction characteristics and long-term effects on auditory function

Congenital hearing deficits can be caused by a variety of genetic and acquired conditions. Complete reversal of deficits in the peripheral auditory system may require delivery of corrective genes to cochlear progenitor cells. We tested delivery of lentivirus and an array of recombinant adeno-associated viral (AAV) serotypes for efficiency and cellular specificity of transgene expression after in utero delivery to the developing mouse otocyst. Stability of expression and safety with respect to auditory function were then tested in those vectors that had the most favorable in utero cochlear transduction characteristics (AAV2/1, AAV2/8, and lentivirus). AAV2/1 was found to be the optimal vector for in utero cochlear gene transfer. It efficiently transduced progenitors giving rise to both inner and outer hair cells and supporting cells and had no adverse effect on cochlear cell differentiation. Further, it had no pathological effect on differentiated hair cells or the integrity of the auditory nerve or brain-stem nuclei as measured by auditory brain-stem response testing. AAV2/1 promises to be useful in further studies evaluating differentiation pathways of cochlear cells in health and disease and for developing gene-based therapies for congenital and acquired forms of peripheral hearing loss.

Widespread gene transduction to the central nervous system by adenovirus in utero: implication for prenatal gene therapy to brain involvement of lysosomal storage disease

BACKGROUND

In some lysosomal storage diseases, considerable alterations of the central nervous system (CNS) occur prior to birth and neurodegeneration progresses rapidly soon after birth causing early death in patients. No effective treatment is available after birth. Treatment may need to be initiated before birth to prevent the onset or progression of neurological changes and thereby irreversible brain damage. The aim of this study is to investigate the feasibility and effectiveness of brain-directed prenatal gene therapy for lysosomal storage diseases.

METHODS

Recombinant adenovirus encoding the lacZ gene was injected into the lateral ventricles of mouse embryos and the pattern of gene transduction to the CNS was investigated. In the therapeutic experiment, adenovirus expressing beta-glucuronidase was injected into the cerebral ventricles of the embryos of mucopolysaccharidosis VII mice and the therapeutic effects on the brain were evaluated.

RESULTS

Injection of adenoviral vectors to the cerebral ventricles of mouse embryos led to widespread gene transduction throughout the brain and the spinal cord and transgene expression persisted over 10 months in those surviving the procedure. The prenatal transduction of the therapeutic gene to the brain of the mucopolysaccharidosis VII mouse efficiently prevented lysosomal storage in most brain cells before birth until 4 months after birth.

CONCLUSIONS

Brain-directed in utero gene therapy through an intra-ventricular route would be an effective strategy to treat some lysosomal storage diseases with early and severe CNS alterations.

Patterns of gene expression from in utero delivery of adenoviral-associated vector serotype 1

Adenoviral-associated viral vectors (AAV) have shown significant promise for efficient gene delivery to multiple tissues. Studies of different serotypes of AAV revealed different expression patterns provided by gene delivery in postnatal mice. Previous in utero gene delivery studies of AAV serotype 2 (AAV2) demonstrated efficient gene expression in certain fetal tissues depending on route of administration. We studied the pattern of gene expression from AAV serotype 1 (AAV1) using intramuscular, intraperitoneal, and intravascular routes of administration in embryonic day 16 C57BL/6 mice. Limb skeletal muscle transduction was only achieved with AAV1 by intramuscular administration. The levels of gene expression were 20-fold higher than a comparable administration of AAV2. Diaphragm muscle transduction by AAV1 was achieved at the highest level by intraperitoneal administration, and to a lesser degree by intravascular administration. All delivery routes resulted in transgene expression in the lung. Our results indicate that AAV1 can offer higher transgene expression in fetal skeletal muscle than AAV2 with intramuscular administration. The transgene expression pattern in different tissues, which depends on vector serotype and route of administration, will need to be considered in planning therapeutic studies for specific disorders.

In utero gene therapy: current challenges and perspectives

Over the past few years, considerable progress in prenatal diagnosis and surgery combined with improvements in vector design vindicate a reappraisal of the feasibility of in utero gene therapy for serious monogenetic diseases. As adult gene therapy gathers pace, several apparent obstacles to its application as a treatment may be overcome by pre- or early postnatal treatment. This review will examine the concepts and practice of prenatal vector administration. We aim to highlight the advantages of early therapeutic intervention focusing on diseases that could benefit greatly from a prenatal gene therapy approach. We will pay special attention to the strategies and vectors that are most likely to be used for this application and will speculate on their expected developments for the near future.

Comparison of high-capacity and first-generation adenoviral vector gene delivery to murine muscle in utero

In utero gene delivery could offer the advantage of treatment at an early stage for genetic disorders such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) in which the inevitable process of muscle degeneration is already initiated at birth. Furthermore, treatment of fetal muscle with adenoviral (Ad) vectors is attractive because of a high density of Ad receptors, easy vector accessibility due to immaturity of the basal lamina and the possibility of treating stem cells. Previously, we demonstrated the efficient transduction of fetal muscle by high-capacity Ad (HC-Ad) vectors. In this study, we compared HC-Ad and first-generation Ad (FG-Ad) vectors for longevity of lacZ transgene expression, toxicity and induction of immunity after direct vector-mediated in utero gene delivery to fetal C57BL/6 mice muscle 16 days after conception (E-16). The total amount of beta-galactosidase (betagal) expressed from the HC-Ad vector remained stable for the 5 months of the study, although the concentration of betagal decreased due to muscle growth. Higher survival rates that reflect lower levels of toxicity were observed in those mice transduced with an HC-Ad vector as compared to an FG-Ad vector. The toxicity induced by FG-Ad vector gene delivery was dependent on mouse strain and vector dose. Animals treated with either HC-Ad and FG-Ad vectors developed non-neutralizing antibodies against Ad capsid and antibodies against betagal, but these antibodies did not cause loss of vector genomes from transduced muscle. In a mouse model of DMD, dystrophin gene transfer to muscle in utero using an HC-Ad vector restored the dystrophin-associated glycoproteins. Our results demonstrate that long-term transgene expression can be achieved by HC-Ad vector-mediated gene delivery to fetal muscle, although strategies of vector integration may need to be considered to accommodate muscle growth.

No evidence for germ-line transmission following prenatal and early postnatal AAV-mediated gene delivery

BACKGROUND

Recombinant adeno-associated viruses have been used successfully in a number of pre-clinical and clinical gene therapy studies. Since there is a broad consensus that gene therapy must not lead to germ-line transmission, the potential of such vectors for inadvertent gene transfer into germ cells deserves special attention. This applies in particular to pre- or perinatal vector application which has been considered for diseases presenting with morbidity already at birth.

METHODS

AAV serotype 2 derived vectors carrying a beta-galactosidase reporter gene or human clotting factor IX cDNA were injected intraperitoneally or via a yolk sac vein into mouse fetuses or administered intravascularly to newborn mice. Tissue samples of the treated animals including the gonads as well as sperm DNA, obtained by differential lysis of one testis of each male animal, and the offspring of all treated mice were investigated for the presence of vector DNA by nested PCR. In positive samples, the copy number of the vector was determined by quantitative real-time PCR.

RESULTS

AAV vectors administered intraperitoneally or intravascularly to fetal or newborn mice reached the gonads of these animals and persisted there for time periods greater than one year. Intravascular injection of the vector resulted more frequently in gene transfer to the gonads than intraperitoneal injection. Vector copy numbers in the gonads ranged from 0.3 to 74 per 10(4) cell equivalents. However, neither in isolated sperm DNA from the treated animals nor in their offspring were vector sequences detectable.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest the risk of inadvertent germ-line transmission following prenatal or early postnatal AAV type 2 mediated gene delivery to be very low.

In utero gene therapy rescues vision in a murine model of congenital blindness

The congenital retinal blindness known as Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) can be caused by mutations in the RPE65 gene. RPE65 plays a critical role in the visual cycle that produces the photosensitive pigment rhodopsin. Recent evidence from human studies of LCA indicates that earlier rather than later intervention may be more likely to restore vision. We determined the impact of in utero delivery of the human RPE65 cDNA to retinal pigment epithelium cells in a murine model of LCA, the Rpe65(-/-) mouse, using a serotype 2 adeno-associated virus packaged within an AAV1 capsid (AAV2/1). Delivery of AAV2/1-CMV-hRPE65 to fetuses (embryonic day 14) resulted in efficient transduction of retinal pigment epithelium, restoration of visual function, and measurable rhodopsin. The results demonstrate AAV-mediated correction of the deficit and suggest that in utero retinal gene delivery may be a useful approach for treating a variety of blinding congenital retinal diseases.

Rescue of enzyme deficiency in embryonic diaphragm in a mouse model of metabolic myopathy: Pompe disease

Several human genetic diseases that affect striated muscle have been modeled by creating knockout mouse strains. However, many of these are perinatal lethal mutations that result in death from respiratory distress within hours after birth. As the diaphragm muscle does not contract until birth, the sudden increase in diaphragm activity creates permanent injury to the muscle causing it to fail to meet respiratory demands. Therefore, the impact of these mutations remains hidden throughout embryonic development and early death prevents investigators from performing detailed studies of other striated muscle groups past the neonatal stage. Glycogen storage disease type II (GSDII), caused by a deficiency in acid alpha-glucosidase (GAA), leads to lysosomal accumulation of glycogen in all cell types and abnormal myofibrillogenesis in striated muscle. Contractile function of the diaphragm muscle is severely affected in both infantile-onset and late-onset individuals, with death often resulting from respiratory failure. The knockout mouse model of GSDII survives well into adulthood despite the gradual weakening of all striated muscle groups. Using this model, we investigated the delivery of recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors encoding the human GAA cDNA to the developing embryo. Results indicate specific high-level transduction of diaphragm tissue, leading to activity levels up to 10-fold higher than normal and restoration of normal contractile function. Up to an estimated 50 vector copies per diploid genome were quantified in treated diaphragms. Histological glycogen staining of treated diaphragms revealed prevention of lysosomal glycogen accumulation in almost all fibers when compared with untreated controls. This method could be employed with disease models where specific rescue of the diaphragm would allow for increased survival and thus further investigation into the impact of the gene deletion on other striated muscle groups.

Long-term transgene expression in cardiac and skeletal muscle following fetal administration of adenoviral or adeno-associated viral vectors in mice

BACKGROUND

In utero gene transfer may provide advantages for the correction of congenital genetic disorders. In the present study we compare the ability of adenovirus (AdCMVLacZ), and two serotypes of adeno-associated virus (AAVCMVLacZ serotypes 2 and 2/5), to target cardiac and skeletal muscle after prenatal systemic or intramuscular injection in mice and assess the immune response to the vectors.

METHODS

Day 14 gestation fetal mice underwent direct intraperitoneal or intramuscular injection of AdCMVLacZ, and AAVCMVLacZ serotypes 2 and 2/5 vectors. Tissues were processed for beta-galactosidase expression in frozen or high-resolution thin plastic sections at early and late time points. Neutralizing antibodies to Ad and AAV were analyzed in separate fetal experimental and neonatal or adult control groups after administration and re-administration of the vectors.

RESULTS

A single injection of each vector in utero resulted in sustained expression of beta-galactosidase transgene in skeletal and cardiac muscle. Transgene expression was detected for the length of the study, i.e. 86, 58, and 31 weeks after birth for AdCMVLacZ, and AAVCMVLacZ serotypes 2 and 2/5, respectively. High-level expression in the myocardium was observed independent of the vector or route of administration. Neutralizing antibody responses to AAV and Ad antigens were reduced and long-term expression in muscle was not ablated on postnatal re-administration of vector.

CONCLUSIONS

Sustained, high-level cardiac and skeletal muscle transgene expression can be obtained after prenatal gene transfer with each of these vectors. The potential for immune response to viral antigens is altered, but not entirely ablated after in utero exposure.

Recombinant adeno-associated virus type 2-mediated gene delivery into the Rpe65-/- knockout mouse eye results in limited rescue

BACKGROUND

Leber's congenital amaurosis (LCA) is a severe form of retinal dystrophy. Mutations in the RPE65 gene, which is abundantly expressed in retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cells, account for approximately 10-15% of LCA cases. In this study we used the high turnover, and rapid breeding and maturation time of the Rpe65^-/- knockout mice to assess the efficacy of using rAAV-mediated gene therapy to replace the disrupted RPE65 gene. The potential for rAAV-mediated gene treatment of LCA was then analyzed by determining the pattern of RPE65 expression, the physiological and histological effects that it produced, and any improvement in visual function.

METHODS

rAAV.RPE65 was injected into the subretinal space of Rpe65^-/- knockout mice and control mice. Histological and immunohistological analyses were performed to evaluate any rescue of photoreceptors and to determine longevity and pattern of transgene expression. Electron microscopy was used to examine ultrastructural changes, and electroretinography was used to measure changes in visual function following rAAV.RPE65 injection.

RESULTS

rAAV-mediated RPE65 expression was detected for up to 18 months post injection. The delivery of rAAV.RPE65 to Rpe65^-/- mouse retinas resulted in a transient improvement in the maximum b-wave amplitude under both scotopic and photopic conditions (76% and 59% increase above uninjected controls, respectively) but no changes were observed in a-wave amplitude. However, this increase in b-wave amplitude was not accompanied by any slow down in photoreceptor degeneration or apoptotic cell death. Delivery of rAAV.RPE65 also resulted in a decrease in retinyl ester lipid droplets and an increase in short wavelength cone opsin-positive cells, suggesting that the recovery of RPE65 expression has long-term benefits for retinal health.

CONCLUSION

This work demonstrated the potential benefits of using the Rpe65^-/- mice to study the effects and mechanism of rAAV.RPE65-mediated gene delivery into the retina. Although the functional recovery in this model was not as robust as in the dog model, these experiments provided important clues about the long-term physiological benefits of restoration of RPE65 expression in the retina.

A nonproliferating parvovirus vaccine vector elicits sustained, protective humoral immunity following a single intravenous or intranasal inoculation

An ideal vaccine delivery system would elicit persistent protection following a single administration, preferably by a noninvasive route, and be safe even in the face of immunosuppression, either inherited or acquired, of the recipient. We have exploited the unique life cycle of the autonomous parvoviruses to develop a nonproliferating vaccine platform that appears to both induce priming and continually boost a protective immune response following a single inoculation. A crippled parvovirus vector was constructed, based on a chimera between minute virus of mice (MVM) and LuIII, which expresses Borrelia burgdorferi outer surface protein A (OspA) instead of its coat protein. The vector was packaged into an MVM lymphotropic capsid and inoculated into naive C3H/HeNcr mice. Vaccination with a single vector dose, either intravenously or intranasally, elicited high-titer anti-OspA-specific antibody that provided protection from live spirochete challenge and was sustained over the lifetime of the animal. Both humoral and cell-mediated Th(1) immunity was induced, as shown by anti-OspA immunoglobulin G2a antibody and preferential gamma interferon production by OspA-specific CD4(+) T cells.

Fetal muscle gene transfer is not enhanced by an RGD capsid modification to high-capacity adenoviral vectors

High levels of alpha(v) integrin expression by fetal muscle suggested that vector re-targeting to integrins could enhance adenoviral vector-mediated transduction, thereby increasing safety and efficacy of muscle gene transfer in utero. High-capacity adenoviral (HC-Ad) vectors modified by an Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) peptide motif in the HI loop of the adenoviral fiber (RGD-HC-Ad) have demonstrated efficient gene transfer through binding to alpha(v) integrins. To test integrin targeting of HC-Ad vectors for fetal muscle gene transfer, we compared unmodified and RGD-modified HC-Ad vectors. In vivo, unmodified HC-Ad vector transduced fetal mouse muscle with four-fold higher efficiency compared to RGD-HC-Ad vector. Confirming that the difference was due to muscle cell autonomous factors and not mechanical barriers, transduction of primary myogenic cells isolated from murine fetal muscle in vitro demonstrated a three-fold better transduction by HC-Ad vector than by RGD-HC-Ad vector. We hypothesized that the high expression level of coxsackievirus and adenovirus receptor (CAR), demonstrated in fetal muscle cells both in vitro and in vivo, was the crucial variable influencing the relative transduction efficiencies of HC-Ad and RGD-HC-Ad vectors. To explore this further, we studied transduction by HC-Ad and RGD-HC-Ad vectors in paired cell lines that expressed alpha(v) integrins and differed only by the presence or absence of CAR expression. The results increase our understanding of factors that will be important for retargeting HC-Ad vectors to enhance gene transfer to fetal muscle.

The Hopes and Fears of In Utero Gene Therapy for Genetic Disease—A Review

Somatic gene delivery in utero is a novel approach to gene therapy for genetic disease. It is based on the concept that application of gene therapy vectors to the fetus in utero may prevent the development of early disease related tissue damage, may allow targeting of otherwise inaccessible organs, tissues and still expanding stem cell populations and may also provide postnatal tolerance against the therapeutic transgenic protein. This review outlines the hypothesis and scientific background of in utero gene therapy and addresses some of the frequently expressed concerns raised by this still experimental, potentially preventive gene therapy approach. We describe and discuss the choice of vectors, of animal models and routes of administration to the fetus. We address potential risk factors of prenatal gene therapy such as vector toxicity, inadvertent germ line modification, developmental aberration and oncogenesis as well as specific risks of this procedure for the fetus and mother and discuss their ethical implications.

Stem cell and genetic therapies for the fetus

In the near future, prenatal therapy may include stem cell-based cellular therapy or gene therapy. There is considerable overlap in the rationale and potential applications for these 2 approaches. The purpose of this manuscript is to consider current progress in both areas relevant to prenatal treatment. Although clinical application is currently limited to a few highly selected disorders that are amenable to cellular therapy, there is reason to believe that a dramatic increase in application will occur in the near future.

Long-term transgene expression by administration of a lentivirus-based vector to the fetal circulation of immuno-competent mice

Inefficient gene transfer, inaccessibility of stem cell compartments, transient gene expression, and adverse immune and inflammatory reactions to vector and transgenic protein are major barriers to successful in vivo application of gene therapy for most genetic diseases. Prenatal gene therapy with integrating vectors may overcome these problems and prevent early irreparable organ damage. To this end, high-dose attenuated VSV-G pseudotyped equine infectious anaemia virus (EIAV) encoding beta-galactosidase under the CMV promoter was injected into the fetal circulation of immuno-competent MF1 mice. We saw prolonged, extensive gene expression in the liver, heart, brain and muscle, and to a lesser extent in the kidney and lung of postnatal mice. Progressive clustered hepatocyte staining suggests clonal expansion of cells stably transduced. We thus provide proof of principle for efficient gene delivery and persistent transgene expression after prenatal application of the EIAV vector and its potential for permanent correction of genetic diseases.

Immune responses to adeno-associated virus and its recombinant vectors

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors have emerged as highly promising for use in gene transfer for a variety of reasons, including lack of pathogenicity and wide host range. In addition, all virus-encoded genes have been removed from standard rAAV vectors, resulting in their comparatively low intrinsic immunogenicity. For gene replacement strategies, transgenes encoded by rAAV vectors may induce less robust host immune responses than other vectors in vivo. However, under appropriate conditions, host immune responses can be generated against rAAV-encoded transgenes, raising the potential for their use in vaccine development. In this review, we summarize current understanding of the generation of both undesirable and beneficial host immune responses directed against rAAV and encoded transgenes, and how they might be exploited for optimal use of this promising vector system.

Immunity to adenovirus and adeno-associated viral vectors: implications for gene therapy

Viral vectors have provided effective methods for in vivo gene delivery for therapeutic purposes. The ability of viruses to infect a wide variety of cell types in vivo has been exploited for several applications, such as liver, lung, muscle, brain, eye and many others. Immune responses directed towards the viral capsids and the transgene products have severely affected the ability of these vectors to induce long-term gene expression. This paper reviews the influence of viral vectors on antigen-presenting cells (APC), which are central to the induction of innate as well as adaptive immune responses. In this respect, we have focused on adenovirus and adeno-associated viruses because of the polar responses these vector systems induce in vivo. While adenovirus vector can induce significant inflammatory responses, adeno-associated viral vectors are characterized by their inability to consistantly induce immune responses to the transgene product. Understanding the mechanism of infection, transduction and activation of APC by viral vectors will provide strategies to develop safe vectors and prevent immune responses in gene therapies.

Binding of adenoviral fiber knob to the coxsackievirus-adenovirus receptor is crucial for transduction of fetal muscle

Adenoviral (Ad) infection involves attachment mediated by the Ad fiber protein binding to the coxsackievirus-adenovirus receptor (CAR) of a target cell and internalization facilitated by the interaction of the Ad penton base protein with alpha(v) integrins. To understand the relative importance of the Ad binding and internalization steps for the transduction of fetal skeletal muscle, we used a panel of genetically modified vectors that specifically ablate the fiber-CAR interaction (AdL.F*), the penton base-alpha(v) integrin interaction (AdL.PB*), or both (AdL.PB*F*) to transduce embryonic day 16 (E-16) mouse muscle in vivo and primary E-16 muscle cells in vitro. Quantification of transgene expression and vector genome copies revealed a striking absence of E-16 muscle transduction by AdL.F* and AdL.PB*F*. In contrast, fetal muscle transduction with AdL.PB* was not significantly different than with the unmodified vector. Similar results were observed with in vitro Ad infection studies in primary E-16 muscle cells. From these data we conclude that the fiber-CAR interaction is important for the transduction of fetal muscle by Ad vectors. The high dependence on fiber-CAR binding will impact the development of strategies for Ad vector retargeting to achieve muscle-specific transduction in utero.

Haemophilia B: from molecular diagnosis to gene therapy

Thanks to its typical expression, haemophilia can be identified in writings from the second century AD. Haemophilia B, an X-linked recessive bleeding disorder due to factor IX (FIX) deficiency, has an incidence of about 1:30,000 live male births. The factor 9 (F9) gene was mapped in 1984 on Xq27.1. Haemophilia is diagnosed from prothrombin time, activated partial thromboplastin time, and FIX levels. Carrier females are usually asymptomatic and must be identified only with molecular analysis. Linkage analysis of F9 polymorphisms is rapid and inexpensive but limited by non-informative families, recombinant events, and the high incidence of germline mutations; thus, various procedures have been used for the direct scan of F9 mutations. We set up a novel denaturing high performance liquid chromatographic procedure to scan the F9 gene. This rapid, reproducible procedure detected F9 mutations in 100% of a preliminary cohort of 18 haemophilia B patients. Parallel to the development of more efficient diagnostic tools, the life expectancy and reproductive fitness of haemophilic patients have greatly improved and will continue to improve thanks to the use of less immunogenic recombinant FIX. Hopefully, new approaches based on gene therapy now being evaluated in clinical trials will revolutionise haemophilia B treatment.

Ultrasound-guided percutaneous delivery of adenoviral vectors encoding the beta-galactosidase and human factor IX genes to early gestation fetal sheep in utero

In utero gene therapy may provide treatment of genetic diseases before significant organ damage, allow permanent genetic correction by reaching stem cell populations, and provide immune tolerance against the therapeutic transgenes and vectors. We have used percutaneous ultrasound-guided injection as a minimally invasive fetal procedure. First-generation adenoviruses encoding the nuclear localizing beta-galactosidase reporter gene or the human factor IX (hFIX) gene, or colloidal carbon were delivered via the umbilical vein (UV, n = 4), heart (intracardiac [IC], n = 2), liver parenchyma (intrahepatic [HE], n = 11), peritoneal cavity (intraperitoneal [IP], n = 14), skeletal musculature ([intramuscular [IM], n = 11), or the amniotic cavity (intraamniotic [IA], n = 14) to early-gestation fetal sheep (0.3 gestation = day 33-61). Postmortem analysis was performed at 2, 9, or 28 days after injection. Although fetal survival was between 77% and 91% for IP, HE, IA, and IM routes, no fetuses survived UV or IC procedures. The hFIX levels reaching 1900 and 401 ng/ml (IP), 30 ng/ml (HE), 66.5 and 39 ng/ml (IA), and 83 and 65.5 ng/ml (IM), respectively, were determined 2 days after injection and decreased at birth to 16.5 ng/ml (IP), 7 ng/ml (HE), 4.5 ng/ml (IA), and 4 and 0 ng/ml (IM). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and immunohistochemistry showed broadest hFIX transgene spread and highest localised beta-galactosidase expression, respectively, after IP administration. Antibodies were observed against vector but not against hFIX.

In utero gene transfer of human factor IX to fetal mice can induce postnatal tolerance of the exogenous clotting factor

The fundamental hypotheses behind fetal gene therapy are that it may be possible (1) to achieve immune tolerance of transgene product and, perhaps, vector; (2) to target cells and tissues that are inaccessible in adult life; (3) to transduce a high percentage of rapidly proliferating cells, and in particular stem cells, with relatively low absolute virus doses leading to clonal transgene amplification by integrating vectors; and (4) to prevent early disease manifestation of genetic diseases. This study provides evidence vindicating the first hypothesis; namely, that intravascular prenatal administration of an adenoviral vector carrying the human factor IX (hFIX) transgene can induce immune tolerance of the transgenic protein. Following repeated hFIX protein injection into adult mice, after prenatal vector injection, we found persistence of blood hFIX and absence of hFIX antibodies in 5 of 9 mice. Furthermore, there was substantial hFIX expression after each of 2 reinjections of vector without detection of hFIX antibodies. In contrast, all adult mice that had not been treated prenatally showed a rapid loss of the injected hFIX and the development of high hFIX antibody levels, both clear manifestations of a strong immune reaction.

Efficient transduction of liver and muscle after in utero injection of lentiviral vectors with different pseudotypes

In this study we investigate the efficacy of lentiviral vectors of different pseudotypes for gene transfer to tissues of the preimmune fetus. BALB/c fetuses at 14-15 days' gestation received lentiviral vectors carrying the transgene lacZ under the control of the human cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter by intramuscular (i.m.) or intrahepatic (i.h.) injection. We pseudotyped the lentiviral vectors with vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV-G), with Mokola virus, or with Ebola virus envelope glycoproteins. We harvested the pups at time points between 5 days and 9 months following injection and performed a detailed histologic assessment. The efficiency and distribution of transduction after in utero administration was highly dependent upon the route of administration and the pseudotype of vector used. Biodistribution studies showed widespread distribution of vector sequences in multiple tissues, albeit at very low levels, and transduced cells were found in significant numbers only in liver, heart, and muscle. Overall, VSV-G was the most efficient in transducing hepatocytes, whereas Mokola and Ebola were more efficient in transducing myocytes. Transduction of cardiomyocytes was observed after both i.m. and i.h. injection of all three vectors. Our findings of long-term transduction of skeletal myocytes and cardiomyocytes after in utero administration suggest a novel strategy for the treatment of congenital muscular dystrophies.

On the scientific and ethical issues of fetal somatic gene therapy

Fetal somatic gene therapy is often seen as an ethically particularly controversial field of gene therapy. This review outlines the hypothesis and scientific background of in utero gene therapy and addresses some of the frequently raised questions and concerns in relation to this still experimental, potentially preventive gene therapy approach. We discuss here the choice of vectors, of animal models and routes of administration to the fetus. We address the relation of fetal gene therapy to abortion, to post-implantation selection and postnatal gene therapy and the concerns of inadvertent germ-line modification. Our views on the specific risks of prenatal gene therapy and on the particular prerequisites that have to be met before human application can be considered are presented.