Correct Expression of spec2a in the sea urchin embryo requires both Otx and other cis-regulatory elements

Single-cell RNA sequencing of the Strongylocentrotus purpuratus larva reveals the blueprint of major cell types and nervous system of a non-chordate deuterostome

Identifying the molecular fingerprint of organismal cell types is key for understanding their function and evolution. Here, we use single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) to survey the cell types of the sea urchin early pluteus larva, representing an important developmental transition from non-feeding to feeding larva. We identify 21 distinct cell clusters, representing cells of the digestive, skeletal, immune, and nervous systems. Further subclustering of these reveal a highly detailed portrait of cell diversity across the larva, including the identification of neuronal cell types. We then validate important gene regulatory networks driving sea urchin development and reveal new domains of activity within the larval body. Focusing on neurons that co-express Pdx-1 and Brn1/2/4, we identify an unprecedented number of genes shared by this population of neurons in sea urchin and vertebrate endocrine pancreatic cells. Using differential expression results from Pdx-1 knockdown experiments, we show that Pdx1 is necessary for the acquisition of the neuronal identity of these cells. We hypothesize that a network similar to the one orchestrated by Pdx1 in the sea urchin neurons was active in an ancestral cell type and then inherited by neuronal and pancreatic developmental lineages in sea urchins and vertebrates.

The developmental transcriptome for Lytechinus variegatus exhibits temporally punctuated gene expression changes

Embryonic development is arguably the most complex process an organism undergoes during its lifetime, and understanding this complexity is best approached with a systems-level perspective. The sea urchin has become a highly valuable model organism for understanding developmental specification, morphogenesis, and evolution. As a non-chordate deuterostome, the sea urchin occupies an important evolutionary niche between protostomes and vertebrates. Lytechinus variegatus (Lv) is an Atlantic species that has been well studied, and which has provided important insights into signal transduction, patterning, and morphogenetic changes during embryonic and larval development. The Pacific species, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus (Sp), is another well-studied sea urchin, particularly for gene regulatory networks (GRNs) and cis-regulatory analyses. A well-annotated genome and transcriptome for Sp are available, but similar resources have not been developed for Lv. Here, we provide an analysis of the Lv transcriptome at 11 timepoints during embryonic and larval development. Temporal analysis suggests that the gene regulatory networks that underlie specification are well-conserved among sea urchin species. We show that the major transitions in variation of embryonic transcription divide the developmental time series into four distinct, temporally sequential phases. Our work shows that sea urchin development occurs via sequential intervals of relatively stable gene expression states that are punctuated by abrupt transitions.

The Functionality and Evolution of Eukaryotic Transcriptional Enhancers

Enhancers regulate precise spatial and temporal patterns of gene expression in eukaryotes and, moreover, evolutionary changes in these modular cis-regulatory elements may represent the predominant genetic basis for phenotypic evolution. Here, we review approaches to identify and functionally analyze enhancers and their transcription factor binding sites, including assay for transposable-accessible chromatin-sequencing (ATAC-Seq) and clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/Cas9, respectively. We also explore enhancer functionality, including how transcription factor binding sites combine to regulate transcription, as well as research on shadow and super enhancers, and how enhancers can act over great distances and even in trans. Finally, we discuss recent theoretical and empirical data on how transcription factor binding sites and enhancers evolve. This includes how the function of enhancers is maintained despite the turnover of transcription factor binding sites as well as reviewing studies where mutations in enhancers have been shown to underlie morphological change.

New regulatory circuit controlling spatial and temporal gene expression in the sea urchin embryo oral ectoderm GRN

The sea urchin oral ectoderm gene regulatory network (GRN) model has increased in complexity as additional genes are added to it, revealing its multiple spatial regulatory state domains. The formation of the oral ectoderm begins with an oral-aboral redox gradient, which is interpreted by the cis-regulatory system of the nodal gene to cause its expression on the oral side of the embryo. Nodal signaling drives cohorts of regulatory genes within the oral ectoderm and its derived subdomains. Activation of these genes occurs sequentially, spanning the entire blastula stage. During this process the stomodeal subdomain emerges inside of the oral ectoderm, and bilateral subdomains defining the lateral portions of the future ciliary band emerge adjacent to the central oral ectoderm. Here we examine two regulatory genes encoding repressors, sip1 and ets4, which selectively prevent transcription of oral ectoderm genes until their expression is cleared from the oral ectoderm as an indirect consequence of Nodal signaling. We show that the timing of transcriptional de-repression of sip1 and ets4 targets which occurs upon their clearance explains the dynamics of oral ectoderm gene expression. In addition two other repressors, the direct Nodal target not, and the feed forward Nodal target goosecoid, repress expression of regulatory genes in the central animal oral ectoderm thereby confining their expression to the lateral domains of the animal ectoderm. These results have permitted construction of an enhanced animal ectoderm GRN model highlighting the repressive interactions providing precise temporal and spatial control of regulatory gene expression.

Intragenomic evolution of a transcriptional enhancer in the genome of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus

General principles for how genomic regulatory elements evolve to alter patterns of gene expression remain vague. The purpose of this study was to gain insights into the evolution of genomic regulatory elements by investigating the unique features of a transcriptional enhancer that directs Spec2a gene expression in Strongylocentrotus purpuratus. The Spec2a enhancer is embedded in a repetitive sequence family interspersed throughout the genome. We surveyed the genome and identified 274 of these sequences. They displayed a continuum of sequence divergence defining high and low divergence classes. Alignment of 52 most related to the Spec2a sequence revealed a complex pattern of rearrangements, insertions and deletions, and base-pair changes. A distance tree for the 52 sequences was constructed and correlated with enhancer activity. Unexpectedly, we found a wide range of activities. Notably, repetitive sequences lacking essential cis-elements found in the Spec2a enhancer still had strong activity. We identified short, conserved motifs within the repetitive sequences that may represent novel cis-regulatory elements. Many repetitive sequences with enhancer activity were found nearby genes, suggesting that they regulate gene expression. The results show that the repetitive sequences are rapidly evolving in the S. purpuratus genome and may serve as a renewable pool of transcriptional enhancers.

A perturbation model of the gene regulatory network for oral and aboral ectoderm specification in the sea urchin embryo

The current gene regulatory network (GRN) for the sea urchin embryo pertains to pregastrular specification functions in the endomesodermal territories. Here we extend gene regulatory network analysis to the adjacent oral and aboral ectoderm territories over the same period. A large fraction of the regulatory genes predicted by the sea urchin genome project and shown in ancillary studies to be expressed in either oral or aboral ectoderm by 24 h are included, though universally expressed and pan-ectodermal regulatory genes are in general not. The loci of expression of these genes have been determined by whole mount in situ hybridization. We have carried out a global perturbation analysis in which expression of each gene was interrupted by introduction of morpholino antisense oligonucleotide, and the effects on all other genes were measured quantitatively, both by QPCR and by a new instrumental technology (NanoString Technologies nCounter Analysis System). At its current stage the network model, built in BioTapestry, includes 22 genes encoding transcription factors, 4 genes encoding known signaling ligands, and 3 genes that are yet unknown but are predicted to perform specific roles. Evidence emerged from the analysis pointing to distinctive subcircuit features observed earlier in other parts of the GRN, including a double negative transcriptional regulatory gate, and dynamic state lockdowns by feedback interactions. While much of the regulatory apparatus is downstream of Nodal signaling, as expected from previous observations, there are also cohorts of independently activated oral and aboral ectoderm regulatory genes, and we predict yet unidentified signaling interactions between oral and aboral territories.

SpGataE, a Strongylocentrotus purpuratus ortholog of mammalian Gata4/5/6: protein expression, interaction with putative target gene spec2a, and identification of friend of Gata factor SpFog1

In the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuatus, SpGataE, an ortholog of the vertebrate zinc-finger transcription factors Gata4/5/6, occupies a key position in the gene regulatory network for endomesoderm specification. We have posited that in addition to regulating gene activity required for endomesoderm specification, SpGataE also represses the expression of the aboral ectoderm-specific spec2a gene in endomesoderm territories. Although the expression pattern of spgatae and its role in endomesoderm specification have been described in considerable detail, little is known about SpGataE protein accumulation and its interactions with target genes and coregulatory factors. Our purpose here was to gain further insight into the mechanisms by which SpGataE functions as a transcriptional regulator. To achieve this, we generated an anti-SpGataE antibody to determine the spatiotemporal expression pattern of SpGataE protein and establish whether it plays a role in repressing spec2a by binding to gata cis-regulatory elements within the endogenous spec2a enhancer. Because Gata proteins often associate with friend of Gata (Fog) coregulators, we identified an S. purpuratus fog ortholog, spfog1, and showed that SpGataE and SpFog1 physically interacted. Spfog1 transcripts were maximal by early blastula stage but continued thereafter to be expressed at low levels. Knockdown of spfog1 using antisense morpholino oligonucleotides did not produce notable effects on endomesoderm specification or spec2a enhancer activity, suggesting that SpGataE exerts these functions independently of SpFog1. In addition to providing new information on Gata and Fog proteins in sea urchins, the anti-SpGataE antibody developed here should be a useful reagent for future analysis of SpGataE function.

Gene regulation: gene control network in development

Controlling the differential expression of many thousands of genes is the most fundamental task of a developing organism. It requires an enormous computational device that has the capacity to process in parallel a vast number of regulatory inputs in the various cells of the embryo and come out with regulatory outputs that are tissue specific. The regulatory genome constitutes this computational device, comprising many thousands of processing units in the form of cis-regulatory modules. The interconnected cis-regulatory modules that control regulatory gene expression create a network that is the underlying mechanism of specification. In this review we use the gene regulatory network that governs endomesoderm specification in the sea urchin embryo to demonstrate the salient features of developmental gene regulatory networks and illustrate the information processing that is done by the regulatory sequences.

HeOtx expression in an indirectly developing polychaete correlates with gastrulation by invagination

The expression of an Otx homolog in the indirectly developing polychaete Hydroides elegans was characterized during embryo, trochophore, and feeding-larva stages. In the animal hemisphere, HeOtx is first expressed in 1q(12) blastomeres and their immediate descendants. Such discrete embryonic animal hemisphere Otx expression perhaps relates to cell-type specification functions of the larva. During feeding stages, transcripts are detected in adult cerebral ganglia precursors and putative adult eye precursors, where it may have adult brain regionalization functions. HeOtx is not expressed in primary trochoblast precursors, but it is expressed in cells adjacent to the ciliary band. HeOtx is also expressed in a group of cells in the dorsal midline of the early trochophore larva in putative posterior sensory organ precursors. The vegetal hemisphere expression starts in oral and lateral sides of the blastopore and later expands to central blastomeres that lead the gastrulation movements. During late gastrulation stages, the expression declines in foregut precursors, but it is maintained in midgut precursors, suggesting its involvement in tripartite gut subdivision functions. HeOtx broader and earlier endoderm expression correlates with gastrulation by invagination associated with the formation of the feeding trochophore, in contrast with a later and orally restricted Otx expression found in a polychaete that gastrulates by epiboly and forms a non-feeding trochophore. The endoderm expression and functional roles in other bilaterians suggest an ancestral role of Otx related to gastrulation by invagination.

Strongylocentrotus purpuratus transcription factor GATA-E binds to and represses transcription at an Otx-Goosecoid cis-regulatory element within the aboral ectoderm-specific spec2a enhancer

During Strongylocentrotus purpuratus embryogenesis, aboral ectoderm-specific expression of spec2a relies on an upstream enhancer that confers its spatial specificity largely through repression. The purpose of this study was to determine how spec2a expression is repressed in endoderm and oral ectoderm territories. A 78-base pair DNA sequence within the enhancer contains five tightly spaced cis-regulatory elements including proximal (TAATCT) and distal (TAATCC) elements that bind to both SpOtx, a broadly distributed transcriptional activator, and SpGoosecoid (SpGsc), an oral ectoderm-restricted transcriptional repressor. We show here that these two seemingly redundant Otx/Gsc elements have distinct functions. The proximal element bound to SpGATA-E, an endomesoderm-specific transcription factor. Treatment with SpGATA-E and SpGsc morpholino antisense oligonucleotides (MASOs) resulted in enhanced transcriptional activity from the proximal element, suggesting that both factors functioned as repressors at this site. SpGATA-E MASO-treated embryos failed to express ectoderm markers, indicating a role for SpGATA-E in ectoderm differentiation. The spec2a proximal element was distinct from the corresponding element in the related spec1 enhancer, and swaps between spec1 and spec2a cis-regulatory elements indicated, that for optimal repression, the proximal element had to interact with a nearby CCAAT-binding factor element. Our results show that the recently evolved proximal element contributes to the repression of spec2a in endomesoderm and oral ectoderm territories.

Structure, expression, and transcriptional regulation of the Strongylocentrotus franciscanus spec gene family encoding intracellular calcium-binding proteins

The mechanisms by which gene expression patterns emerge during evolution are poorly understood. The sea urchin spec genes offer a useful means to investigate evolutionary mechanisms. Genes of the spec family from Strongylocentrotus purpuratus and Lytechinus pictus have identical patterns of aboral ectoderm-specific expression but exhibit species-specific differences in copy number, genomic structure, temporal expression, and cis-regulatory architecture. Here, we identify spec genes from a phylogenetic intermediate, Strongylocentrotus franciscanus, to gain insight into the evolution of the spec gene family and its transcriptional regulation. We identified two spec genes in the S. franciscanus genome, sfspec1a and sfspec1b, that were orthologous to spec1 from S. purpuratus. sfspec1b transcripts began to accumulate at the blastula stage and became progressively more abundant; this was reminiscent of spec expression in L. pictus but different from that in S. purpuratus. As expected, sfspec1b expression was restricted to aboral ectoderm cells. The six-exon structure of the sfspec1b genomic locus was identical to that of the S. purpuratus spec genes and was bounded by two repeat-spacer-repeat (RSR) repetitive sequence elements, which are conserved features of S. purpuratus spec genes and function as transcriptional enhancers. The enhancer activity of the sfspec1b RSRs was comparable to that of their S. purpuratus counterparts, although the placement and orientation of crucial cis-regulatory elements within the RSRs differed. We discovered a spec gene in S. franciscanus that was only distantly related to other spec genes but was highly conserved in S. purpuratus. Unexpectedly, this gene was expressed exclusively in endoderm lineages. Our results show that the evolution of spec cis-regulatory elements is highly dynamic and that substantial alterations can occur when maintaining or grossly modifying gene expression patterns.

Oral-aboral axis specification in the sea urchin embryo II. Mitochondrial distribution and redox state contribute to establishing polarity in Strongylocentrotus purpuratus

The initial asymmetry that specifies the oral-aboral (OA) axis of the sea urchin embryo has long been a mystery. It was shown previously that OA polarity can be entrained in embryos by imposing a respiratory asymmetry, with the most oxidizing side of the embryo tending to develop as the oral pole. This suggests that one of the earliest observable asymmetries along the incipient OA axis, a redox gradient established by a higher density and/or activity of mitochondria on the prospective oral side of the embryo, might play a causal role in establishing the axis. Here, we examine the origin and functional significance of this early redox gradient. Using MitoTracker Green, we show that mitochondria are asymmetrically distributed in the unfertilized egg of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, and that the polarity of the maternal asymmetry is maintained in the zygote. Vital staining indicates that the side of the embryo that inherits the highest density of mitochondria tends to develop into the oral pole. This correlation holds when mitochondria are redistributed by centrifugation of eggs or by transfer of purified mitochondria into zygotes, indicating that an asymmetric mitochondrial distribution can entrain OA polarity, possibly through effects on intracellular redox state. In support of this possibility, we find that specification of oral ectoderm is suppressed when embryos are cultured under hypoxic conditions that enforce a relatively reducing redox state. This effect is reversed by overexpression of nodal, an early zygotic marker of oral specification whose localized expression suffices to organize the entire OA axis, indicating that redox state is upstream of nodal expression. We therefore propose that a threshold level of intracellular oxidation is required to effectively activate nodal, and that precocious attainment of this threshold within the blastomeres containing the highest density of mitochondria results in asymmetric nodal activity and consequent specification of the OA axis.

Creation of cis-regulatory elements during sea urchin evolution by co-option and optimization of a repetitive sequence adjacent to the spec2a gene

The creation, preservation, and degeneration of cis-regulatory elements controlling developmental gene expression are fundamental genome-level evolutionary processes about which little is known. Here, we identify critical differences in cis-regulatory elements controlling the expression of the sea urchin aboral ectoderm-specific spec genes. We found multiple copies of a repetitive sequence element termed RSR in genomes of species within the Strongylocentrotidae family, but RSRs were not detected in genomes of species outside Strongylocentrotidae. spec genes in Strongylocentrotus purpuratus are invariably associated with RSRs, and the spec2a RSR functioned as a transcriptional enhancer and displayed greater activity than did spec1 or spec2c RSRs. Single-base pair differences at two cis-regulatory elements within the spec2a RSR increased the binding affinities of four transcription factors, SpCCAAT-binding factor at one element and SpOtx, SpGoosecoid, and SpGATA-E at another. The cis-regulatory elements to which these four factors bound were recent evolutionary acquisitions that acted to either activate or repress transcription, depending on the cell type. These elements were found in the spec2a RSR ortholog in Strongylocentrotus pallidus but not in RSR orthologs of Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis or Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus. Our results indicated that a dynamic pattern of cis-regulatory element evolution exists for spec genes despite their conserved aboral ectoderm expression.

An otx cis -regulatory module: a key node in the sea urchin endomesoderm gene regulatory network

An essential node in the gene regulatory network (GRN) for endomesoderm specification in the sea urchin embryo lies within the regulatory system of the otx gene. According to the predictions of the GRN, based on perturbation analysis and expression data, the beta1/2 transcription unit of this gene is engaged during specification in interactions with two other regulatory genes, krox and gatae. It is predicted to be driven into activity by the krox gene, to form a positively reinforcing functional loop with the gatae gene, and to respond to its own output as well. Here we isolate the relevant otx cis-regulatory element, and examine the specific input predictions of the GRN at the level of its genomic DNA sequence. This beta1/2-otx regulatory module performs the necessary functions, as shown by use of expression constructs. It requires gatae, otx, and krox inputs, as predicted, and it operates as an "AND" logic processor in that removal of any one of these inputs essentially destroys activity. The necessary target sites were identified in the module sequence, and mutation of these sites was demonstrated to produce the same respective effects on construct expression as does blocking its regulatory inputs by treatment with morpholino antisense oligonucleotides. For spatial expression in the endoderm, one particular pair of Gata sites is essential and these function synergistically with an adjacent Otx site. We thus demonstrate directly the structure/function relationships of the genomic regulatory code, at this key node of the endomesoderm GRN.

The Otx binding site is required for the activation of HpOtxL mRNA expression in the sea urchin, Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus

Two distinct types of orthodenticle-related (HpOtxE and HpOtxL) mRNA are transcribed from a single HpOtx gene by altering the transcription start site and by alternative splicing, and their expressions are differentially regulated during early development of the sea urchin Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus. To understand the mechanism of this regulation, we screened for the enhancer element involved in the stage-specific expression of HpOtxL mRNA. Different portions of the HpOtx gene, including the 5'-flanking region and the first intron, were ligated to the minimal HpOtxL promoter driving a luciferase gene, and their constructs were introduced into fertilized eggs using a particle gun. The enhancer element responsible for proper expression consistent with that of the endogenous HpOtxL was found in the first intron of the HpOtx gene. External and internal deletion analyses showed that the 334 bp region (from +8838 bp to +9171 bp) was required for enhancer activity. In addition, deletion of an Otx binding site within the 334 bp region markedly reduced reporter expression. These results suggest that the Otx binding site within the HpOtxL enhancer is required for the activation of HpOtxL mRNA expression. The promoter preference of the HpOtxL enhancer is also discussed.

Gene Regulatory Network Analysis in Sea Urchin Embryos

It may safely be predicted that GRN analysis will become increasingly important. It will come to underlie the causal study of development, the major effort underway to understand the regulatory code built into animal genomes and also the evolution of these genomes. Partly by serendipity, sea urchin embryos turn out to be a superb experimental material for GRN analysis. Their natural properties have, in turn, influenced the predilections of those who work on them, and between them and us, so to speak, this is now a developmental system of which we are rapidly gaining an unusually complete understanding. The causal linkages that control development of the whole embryo will be revealed, leading all the way from the heritable genomic regulatory code to the events of embryology. The fundamental experimental operation is the perturbation analysis: Here is where causality permeates the exploration. We have in this chapter summarized in some detail the requirements for perturbation GRN analysis in sea urchin embryos. But that is not all, nor is it enough to enable the assembly of a GRN: What is required is the combined application of elegant computational methods, of gene regulation molecular biology, of genomic sequence data, and of experimental embryology. As the results crystallize together, we can begin to see how far this powerful combination of methods and ideas is going to carry us.

Using reporter genes to study cis-regulatory elements

This chapter summarizes four powerful assays for analyzing gene expression in cis-regulatory studies. The enzymatic assays (CAT, luciferase, lacZ) are currently limited by their application to embryo homogenates or fixed samples, but offer more robust analysis of gene activity than GFP. Assays based on CAT enzymatic activity or on CAT mRNA detection by WMISH are laborious but are well established for accurately quantifying gene expression and to determine spatial patterns at defined timepoints during development. LacZ assays are the current standard for spatially visualizing gene products in whole-mount fixed embryos. They are very sensitive but they provide limited temporal or quantitative information due to the perdurance of beta-galactosidase and the subtleties of the staining technique. Recently developed luciferase assays promise to be even more sensitive and accurate than the CAT and lacZ assays, and applicable to living cells and embryos. But, they have not yet been well established in invertebrate deuterostome research. GFP allows visualization of gene expression within living embryos. But because this is not an enzymatic assay, sensitivity can be a problem, particularly for weak promoters. Furthermore, imaging live embryos and quantifying gene expression in space and time (due to scattering of light by tissue, the perdurance of GFP, and other experimental details) is currently fraught with challenges. Ongoing improvements in imaging technology and the advent of multiple fluorescent proteins, as well as fluorescent and luminescent assays for vital imaging, will dramatically facilitate studies of gene expression in the coming decade.

Promoter-specific function of the TATA element in undifferentiated P19 cells

P19 embryonal carcinoma cells differentiate into neuronal cells when treated with retinoic acid (RA). To explore the importance of core promoter structures in the regulation of gene expression during neuronal differentiation, the activities of three classes of modified or unmodified model promoters (Spec2a, OtxE, and Ars) were compared in P19 cells before and after RA treatment. The Spec2a promoter was activated in undifferentiated cells specifically when the E-box was located at a proximal position, whereas the OtxE promoter was activated when the E-box was in a distal position. The Ars promoter was only slightly activated by this element. In addition, the TATA element reduced the level of activation provided by the E-box, but only when it was located in the Spec2a core promoter. These results indicate that the core promoter structure may govern, at least in part, the stage-specific expression of endogenous genes involved in the neuronal differentiation of P19 cells.

Spdeadringer, a sea urchin embryo gene required separately in skeletogenic and oral ectoderm gene regulatory networks

The Spdeadringer (Spdri) gene encodes an ARID-class transcription factor not previously known in sea urchin embryos. We show that Spdri is a key player in two separate developmental gene regulatory networks (GRNs). Spdri is expressed in a biphasic manner, first, after 12 h and until ingression in the skeletogenic descendants of the large micromeres; second, after about 20 h in the oral ectoderm, where its transcripts remain present at 30-50 mRNA molecules/cell far into development. In both territories, the periods of Spdri expression follow prior territorial specification events. The functional significance of each phase of expression was assessed by determining the effect of an alphaSpdri morpholino antisense oligonucleotide (MASO) on expression of 17 different mesodermal genes, 8 different oral ectoderm genes, and 18 other genes expressed specifically during endomesoderm specification. These effects were measured by quantitative PCR, supplemented by whole-mount in situ hybridization and morphological observations. Spdri is shown to act in the micromere descendants in the pathways that result in the expression of batteries of terminal skeletogenic genes. But, in the oral ectoderm, the same gene participates in the central GRN controlling oral ectoderm identity. Spdri is linked in the oral ectoderm GRN with several other genes encoding transcriptional regulators that are expressed specifically in various regions of the oral ectoderm. If its expression is blocked by treatment with alphaSpdri MASO, oral-specific features disappear and expression of the aboral ectoderm marker spec1 encompasses the whole of the ectoderm. In addition to disappearance of the oral ectoderm, morphological consequences of alphaSpdri MASO treatment include failure of spiculogenesis and of correct primary mesenchyme cell (pmc) patterning in the postgastrular embryo, and also failure of gastrulation. To further analyze these phenotypes, chimeric embryos were constructed consisting of two labeled micromeres combined with micromereless 4th cleavage host embryos; either the micromeres or the hosts contained alphaSpdri MASO. These experiments showed that, while Spdri expression is required autonomously for expression of skeletogenic genes prior to ingression, complete skeletogenesis also requires the expression of oral ectoderm patterning information. Presentation of this information on the oral side of the blastocoel in turn depends on Spdri expression in the oral ectoderm. Failure of gastrulation is not due to indirect interference with endomesodermal specification per se, since all endomesodermal genes tested function normally in alphaSpdri MASO embryos. Part of its cause is interference by alphaSpdri MASO with a late signaling function on the part of the micromere descendants that is needed to complete clearance of the Soxb1 repressor of gastrulation from the prospective endoderm, but in addition there is a nonautonomous oral ectoderm effect.

Conservation of Endo16 expression in sea urchins despite evolutionary divergence in both cis and trans-acting components of transcriptional regulation

Evolutionary changes in transcriptional regulation undoubtedly play an important role in creating morphological diversity. However, there is little information about the evolutionary dynamics of cis-regulatory sequences. This study examines the functional consequence of evolutionary changes in the Endo16 promoter of sea urchins. The Endo16 gene encodes a large extracellular protein that is expressed in the endoderm and may play a role in cell adhesion. Its promoter has been characterized in exceptional detail in the purple sea urchin, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus. We have characterized the structure and function of the Endo16 promoter from a second sea urchin species, Lytechinus variegatus. The Endo16 promoter sequences have evolved in a strongly mosaic manner since these species diverged approximately 35 million years ago: the most proximal region (module A) is conserved, but the remaining modules (B-G) are unalignable. Despite extensive divergence in promoter sequences, the pattern of Endo16 transcription is largely conserved during embryonic and larval development. Transient expression assays demonstrate that 2.2 kb of upstream sequence in either species is sufficient to drive GFP reporter expression that correctly mimics this pattern of Endo16 transcription. Reciprocal cross-species transient expression assays imply that changes have also evolved in the set of transcription factors that interact with the Endo16 promoter. Taken together, these results suggest that stabilizing selection on the transcriptional output may have operated to maintain a similar pattern of Endo16 expression in S. purpuratus and L. variegatus, despite dramatic divergence in promoter sequence and mechanisms of transcriptional regulation.

Evolutionary convergence in Otx expression in the pentameral adult rudiment in direct-developing sea urchins

Convergence is a significant evolutionary phenomenon. Arrival at similar morphologies from different starting points indicates a strong role for natural selection in shaping morphological phenotypes. There is no evidence yet of convergence in the developmental mechanisms that underlie the evolution of convergent developmental phenotypes. Here we report the expression domains in sea urchins of two important developmental regulatory genes ( Orthodenticle and Runt), and show evidence of molecular convergence in the evolution of direct-developing sea urchins. Indirect development is ancestral in sea urchins. Evolutionary loss of the feeding pluteus stage and precocious formation of the radially symmetric juvenile has evolved independently in numerous sea urchin lineages, thus direct development is an evolutionary convergence. Indirect-developing species do not express Otx during the formation of their five primordial tube feet, the ancestral condition. However, each direct-developing urchin examined does express Otx in the tube feet. Otx expression in the radial arms of direct-developing sea urchins is thus convergent, and may indicate a specific need for Otx use in direct development, a constraint that would make direct development less able to evolve than if there were multiple molecular means for it to evolve. In contrast, Runt is expressed in tube feet in both direct- and indirect-developing species. Because echinoderms are closely related to chordates and postdate the protostome/deuterostome divergence, they must have evolved from bilaterally symmetrical ancestors. Arthropods and chordates use Otx in patterning their anterior axis, and Runt has multiple roles including embryonic patterning in arthropods, and blood and bone cell differentiation in vertebrates. Runt has apparently been co-opted in echinoderms for patterning of pentamery, and Otx in pentameral patterning among direct-developing echinoids. The surprisingly dynamic nature of Otx evolution reinvigorates debate on the role of natural selection vs shared ancestry in the evolution of novel features.

Molecular patterning along the sea urchin animal-vegetal axis

The molecular regulatory mechanisms underlying primary axis formation during sea urchin development have recently been identified. Two opposing maternally inherited systems, one animalizing and one vegetalizing, set up the animal-vegetal (A-V) axis. The vegetal system relies in part on the Wnt-beta-catenin-Tcf/Lef signaling pathway and the animal system is based on a cohort of animalizing transcription factors that includes members of the Ets and Sox classes. The two systems autonomously define three zones of cell-type specification along the A-V axis. The vegetalmost zone gives rise to the skeletogenic mesenchyme lineage; the animalmost zone gives rise to ectoderm; and the zone in which the two systems overlap generates endoderm, secondary mesenchyme, and ectoderm. Patterning along the A-V also depends on cellular interactions involving Wnt, Notch, and BMP signaling. We discuss how these systems impact the formation of the second axis, the oral-aboral axis; how they connect to later developmental events; and how they lead to cell-type-specific gene expression via cis-regulatory networks associated with transcriptional control regions. We also discuss how these systems may confer on the embryo its spectacular regulatory capacity to replace missing parts.

Conservation and diversity in the cis-regulatory networks that integrate information controlling expression of Hoxa2 in hindbrain and cranial neural crest cells in vertebrates

The Hoxa2 and Hoxb2 genes are members of paralogy group II and display segmental patterns of expression in the developing vertebrate hindbrain and cranial neural crest cells. Functional analyses have demonstrated that these genes play critical roles in regulating morphogenetic pathways that direct the regional identity and anteroposterior character of hindbrain rhombomeres and neural crest-derived structures. Transgenic regulatory studies have also begun to characterize enhancers and cis-elements for those mouse and chicken genes that direct restricted patterns of expression in the hindbrain and neural crest. In light of the conserved role of Hoxa2 in neural crest patterning in vertebrates and the similarities between paralogs, it is important to understand the extent to which common regulatory networks and elements have been preserved between species and between paralogs. To investigate this problem, we have cloned and sequenced the intergenic region between Hoxa2 and Hoxa3 in the chick HoxA complex and used it for making comparative analyses with the respective human, mouse, and horn shark regions. We have also used transgenic assays in mouse and chick embryos to test the functional activity of Hoxa2 enhancers in heterologous species. Our analysis reveals that three of the critical individual components of the Hoxa2 enhancer region from mouse necessary for hindbrain expression (Krox20, BoxA, and TCT motifs) have been partially conserved. However, their number and organization are highly varied for the same gene in different species and between paralogs within a species. Other essential mouse elements appear to have diverged or are absent in chick and shark. We find the mouse r3/r5 enhancer fails to work in chick embryos and the chick enhancer works poorly in mice. This implies that new motifs have been recruited or utilized to mediate restricted activity of the enhancer in other species. With respect to neural crest regulation, cis-components are embedded among the hindbrain control elements and are highly diverged between species. Hence, there has been no widespread conservation of sequence identity over the entire enhancer domain from shark to humans, despite the common function of these genes in head patterning. This provides insight into how apparently equivalent regulatory regions from the same gene in different species have evolved different components to potentiate their activity in combination with a selection of core components.

Ectoderm gene activation in sea urchin embryos mediated by the CCAAT-binding factor

Transcriptional enhancers are short stretches of DNA that function to achieve highly specific patterns of gene expression. To identify the mechanisms by which enhancers achieve their specificity, we made use of an enhancer from the aboral ectoderm-specific spec2a gene of the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus. The spec2a enhancer contains five cis-regulatory elements within 78 base pairs that interact with five distinct DNA-binding proteins to confer aboral ectoderm expression. Here, we present an analysis of the sea urchin CCAAT binding factor (CBF), which binds to a CCAAT motif within the spec2a enhancer. S. purpuratus CBF and SpOtx, a ubiquitously expressed factor, act together at closely placed cis-regulatory elements to mediate spec2a transcription in the ectoderm. SpCBF was the sole factor that bound to the spec2a CCAAT element, and two of the three subunits that make up the CBF holoprotein were cloned and shown to have high sequence conservation with their vertebrate orthologs. Based on its involvement in the regulation of several other sea urchin genes, SpCBF appears to be a major transcription factor in the sea urchin embryo for positive regulation of ectoderm gene expression. In addition to its role in vertebrate cell growth and proliferation, our results indicate that CBF also functions at the early stages of germ layer formation, namely ectoderm differentiation.

Sea urchin goosecoid function links fate specification along the animal-vegetal and oral-aboral embryonic axes

We have identified a single homolog of goosecoid, SpGsc, that regulates cell fates along both the animal-vegetal and oral-aboral axes of sea urchin embryos. SpGsc mRNA is expressed briefly in presumptive mesenchyme cells of the ∼200-cell blastula and, beginning at about the same time, accumulates in the presumptive oral ectoderm through pluteus stage. Loss-of-function assays with morpholine-substituted antisense oligonucleotides show that SpGsc is required for endoderm and pigment cell differentiation and for gastrulation. These experiments and gain-of-function tests by mRNA injection show that SpGsc is a repressor that antagonizes aboral ectoderm fate specification and promotes oral ectoderm differentiation. We show that SpGsc competes for binding to specific cis elements with SpOtx, a ubiquitous transcription activator that promotes aboral ectoderm differentiation. Moreover, SpGsc represses transcription in vivo from an artificial promoter driven by SpOtx. As SpOtx appears long before SpGsc transcription is activated, we propose that SpGsc diverts ectoderm towards oral fate by repressing SpOtx target genes. Based on the SpGsc-SpOtx example and other available data, we propose that ectoderm is first specified as aboral by broadly expressed activators, including SpOtx, and that the oral region is subsequently respecified by the action of negative regulators, including SpGsc. Accumulation of SpGsc in oral ectoderm depends on cell-cell interactions initiated by nuclear β-catenin function, which is known to be required for specification of vegetal tissues, because transcripts are undetectable in dissociated or in cadherin mRNA-injected embryos. This is the first identified molecular mechanism underlying the known dependence of oral-aboral ectoderm polarity on intercellular signaling.

Evidence for a mesodermal embryonic regulator of the sea urchin CyIIa gene

The CyIIa gene of the sea urchin embryo is a model for study of cis-regulation downstream of cell-type specification, as CyIIa transcription follows the specification and initial differentiation of the embryonic domains in which it is expressed. These are the skeletogenic and secondary mesenchyme and gut. We carried out a detailed structural and functional analysis of a cis-regulatory region of this gene, extending 780 bp upstream and 125 bp downstream of the transcription start site, that had been shown earlier to reproduce faithfully the complex and dynamic CyIIa pattern of expression. This analysis revealed that the overall pattern of expression of the CyIIa gene appears to be governed mainly by two independent sets of DNA elements, which are target sites for specific proteins present in blastula-stage nuclear extract. One type of element, which controls a dynamic program of expression in both skeletogenic and secondary mesenchyme cells, contains the consensus-binding site for a member of the ets transcription factor family. The other, which is responsible for the terminal or permanent phase of CyIIa expression in the gut, shares homologies with the late module of the endoderm-specific Endo16 gene (endo16 Module B). Oligonucleotides containing replicas of these two target sites fused upstream of a sea urchin basal promoter are sufficient to confer accurate mesenchyme and late gut expression of an injected GFP construct. The finding of a single protein target site that recapitulates CyIIa expression in both primary and secondary mesenchyme cells suggests the existence of a pan-mesodermal gene expression program in the sea urchin embryo.