Missense mutations that inactivate Escherichia coli lac permease

Identification of molecular hinge points mediating alternating access in the vesicular monoamine transporter VMAT2

Vesicular monoamine transporter 2 (VMAT2) catalyzes transport of monoamines into storage vesicles in a process that involves exchange of the charged monoamine with two protons. VMAT2 is a member of the DHA12 family of multidrug transporters that belongs to the major facilitator superfamily (MFS) of secondary transporters. Here we present a homology model of VMAT2, which has the standard MFS fold, that is, with two domains of six transmembrane helices each which are related by twofold pseudosymmetry and whose axis runs normal to the membrane and between the two halves. Demonstration of the essential role of a membrane-embedded glutamate and confirmation of the existence of a hydrogen bond probably involved in proton transport provide experimental evidence that validates some of the predictions inherent to the model. Moreover, we show the essential role of residues at two anchor points between the two bundles. These residues appear to function as molecular hinge points about which the two six transmembrane-helix bundles flex and straighten to open and close the pathways on either side of the membrane as required for transport. Polar residues that create a hydrogen bond cluster form one of the anchor points of VMAT2. The other results from hydrophobic interactions. Residues at the anchor points are strongly conserved in other MFS transporters in one way or another, suggesting that interactions at these locations will be critical in most, if not all, MFS transporters.

Independent inactivation of arginine decarboxylase genes by nonsense and missense mutations led to pseudogene formation in Chlamydia trachomatis serovar L2 and D strains

BACKGROUND

Chlamydia have reduced genomes that reflect their obligately parasitic lifestyle. Despite their different tissue tropisms, chlamydial strains share a large number of common genes and have few recognized pseudogenes, indicating genomic stability. All of the Chlamydiaceae have homologs of the aaxABC gene cluster that encodes a functional arginine:agmatine exchange system in Chlamydia (Chlamydophila)pneumoniae. However, Chlamydia trachomatis serovar L2 strains have a nonsense mutation in their aaxB genes, and C. trachomatis serovar A and B strains have frameshift mutations in their aaxC homologs, suggesting that relaxed selection may have enabled the evolution of aax pseudogenes. Biochemical experiments were performed to determine whether the aaxABC genes from C. trachomatis strains were transcribed, and mutagenesis was used to identify nucleotide substitutions that prevent protein maturation and activity. Molecular evolution techniques were applied to determine the relaxation of selection and the scope of aax gene inactivation in the Chlamydiales.

RESULTS

The aaxABC genes were co-transcribed in C. trachomatis L2/434, during the mid-late stage of cellular infection. However, a stop codon in the aaxB gene from this strain prevented the heterologous production of an active pyruvoyl-dependent arginine decarboxylase. Replacing that ochre codon with its ancestral tryptophan codon rescued the activity of this self-cleaving enzyme. The aaxB gene from C. trachomatis D/UW-3 was heterologously expressed as a proenzyme that failed to cleave and form the catalytic pyruvoyl cofactor. This inactive protein could be rescued by replacing the arginine-115 codon with an ancestral glycine codon. The aaxC gene from the D/UW-3 strain encoded an active arginine:agmatine antiporter protein, while the L2/434 homolog was unexpectedly inactive. Yet the frequencies of nonsynonymous versus synonymous nucleotide substitutions show no signs of relaxed selection, consistent with the recent inactivation of these genes.

CONCLUSION

The ancestor of the Chlamydiaceae had a functional arginine:agmatine exchange system that is decaying through independent, parallel processes in the C. trachomatis lineage. Differences in arginine metabolism among Chlamydiaceae species may be partly associated with their tissue tropism, possibly due to the protection conferred by a functional arginine-agmatine exchange system against host nitric oxide production and innate immunity. The independent loss of AaxB activity in all sequenced C. trachomatis strains indicates continual gene inactivation and illustrates the difficulty of recognizing recent bacterial pseudogenes from sequence comparison, transcriptional profiling or the analysis of nucleotide substitution rates.

Missense mutations that inactivate the Aspergillus nidulans nrtA gene encoding a high-affinity nitrate transporter

The transport of nitrate into prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, of considerable interest to agriculture, ecology, and human health, is carried out by members of a distinct cluster of proteins within the major facilitator superfamily. To obtain structure/function information on this important class of nitrate permeases, a collection of chemically induced mutations in the nrtA gene encoding a 12-transmembrane domain, high-affinity nitrate transporter from the eukaryote Aspergillus nidulans was isolated and characterized. This mutational analysis, coupled with protein alignments, demonstrates the utility of the approach to predicting peptide motifs and individual residues important for the movement of nitrate across the membrane. These include the highly conserved nitrate signature motif (residues 166-173) in Tm 5, the conserved charged residues Arg87 (Tm 2) and Arg368 (Tm 8), as well as the aromatic residue Phe47 (Tm 1), all within transmembrane helices. No mutations were observed in the large central loop (Lp 6/7) between Tm 6 and Tm 7. Finally, the study of a strain with a conversion of Trp481 (Tm 12) to a stop codon suggests that all 12 transmembrane domains and/or the C-terminal tail are required for membrane insertion and/or stability of NrtA.

The kamikaze approach to membrane transport

Membrane transport proteins catalyse the movement of molecules into and out of cells and organelles, but their hydrophobic and metastable nature often makes them difficult to study by traditional means. Novel approaches that have been developed and applied to one membrane transport protein, the lactose permease from Escherichia coli, are now being used to study various other membrane proteins.

Functional estimation of loop-helix boundaries in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli by single amino acid deletion analysis

Mutants with single amino acid deletions in the loops of lactose permease retain activity, while mutants with single deletions in transmembrane helices are inactive, and the loop--helix boundaries of helices IV, V, VII, VIII, and IX have been approximated functionally by the systematic deletion of single residues [Wolin, C. D., and Kaback, H. R. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 8590-8597]. The experimental approach is applied here to the remainder of the permease. Periplasmic and cytoplasmic loop-helix boundaries for helices I, II, X, XI, and XII and the cytoplasmic boundary of helix III are in reasonable agreement with structural predictions. In contrast, the periplasmic end of helix III appears to be five to eight residues further into the transmembrane domain than predicted. Taken together with the previous findings, the analysis estimates that 11 of the 12 transmembrane helices have an average length of 21 residues. Surprisingly, deletion analysis of loop V/VI, helix VI, and loop VI/VII does not yield an activity profile typical of the rest of the protein, as individual deletion of only three residues in this region abolishes activity. Thus, transmembrane domain VI which is probably on the periphery of the 12-helix bundle may make few functionally important contacts.

Insertion of in-frame sequence tags into proteins using transposons

Several methods based on the use of transposons allow the efficient generation of relatively short (e.g., <35 residues) in-frame insertions in proteins. The analysis of such insertions has provided a simple means to identify sites that tolerate dramatic sequence changes without loss of function ("permissive" sites) and to dissect protein structure-function relationships. In addition, epitope and protease cleavage site "tags" introduced in such insertions have made it possible to analyze the oligomerization state and transmembrane topologies of several proteins. Finally, the DNA inserted by these methods generally carries restriction sites which may facilitate the construction of in-frame deletions and gene fusions encoding a variety of chimeric proteins.

Mutant membrane protein toxicity

This report describes an extensive mutational analysis of the most carboxyl-terminal membrane-spanning sequence of Escherichia coli lac permease (TM12). In addition to identifying residues important for lactose transport function, the analysis revealed that numerous mutations made lac permease highly toxic to cells. In the most extreme cases, production of such proteins at very low steady-state levels reduced cell viability greater than 10(4)-fold. Both frameshift and missense mutations led to toxicity, with the frameshift mutations having the strongest effects observed. The toxic missense mutations corresponded to changes in TM12 expected to interfere with membrane insertion or folding, such as the introduction of charged residues or prolines in the putative helix. The results suggest that cellular toxicity may be a relatively common consequence of mutations altering integral membrane protein folding. An analogous toxicity might contribute to the pathogenesis of several degenerative diseases caused by mutant membrane proteins, such as retinitis pigmentosa, Charcot-Marie-Tooth syndrome, and Alzheimer's disease.