Solid-state NMR approaches to study protein structure and protein-lipid interactions

Structural analysis of the NK-lysin-derived peptide NK-2 upon interaction with bacterial membrane mimetics consisting of phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylglycerol

NK-2 is an antimicrobial peptide derived from helices 3 and 4 of the pore-forming protein of natural killer cells, NK-lysin. It has potent activities against Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, fungi and protozoan parasites without being toxic to healthy human cells. In biophysical assays its membrane activities were found to require phosphatidylglycerol (PG) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), lipids which dominate the composition of bacterial membranes. Here the structure and activities of NK-2 in binary mixtures of different PE/PG composition were investigated. CD spectroscopy reveals that a threshold concentration of 50 % PG is needed for efficient membrane association of NK-2 concomitant with a random coil - helix transition. Association with PE occurs but is qualitatively different when compared to PG membranes. Oriented solid-state NMR spectroscopy of NK-2 specifically labelled with 15N indicates that the NK-2 helices are oriented parallel to the PG bilayer surface. Upon reduction of the PG content to 20 mol% interactions are weaker and/or an in average more tilted orientation is observed. Fluorescence spectroscopy of differently labelled lipids is in agreement of an interfacial localisation of both helices where the C-terminal end is in a less hydrophobic environment. By inserting into the membrane interface and interacting differently with PE and PG the peptides probably induce high curvature strain which result in membrane openings and rupture.

Investigation of the Action of Peptides on Lipid Membranes

Calorimetric and incoherent neutron scattering methods were employed to investigate the action of magainin 2 and PGLa peptides on the phase behavior and molecular dynamics of lipids mimicking cytoplasmic membranes of Gram-negative bacteria. The impact of the peptides, tested individually and cooperatively by differential scanning calorimetry, presented a broadened peak, sometimes with a second shoulder, depicting the phase transition temperature around 21 °C. Neutron scattering revealed a small but significant variation of the membrane dynamics due to the peptides in both in-plane and out-of-plane directions. Although we did not find a clear hint for synergy in the interplay of the two peptides, the calorimetric and neutron data give compatible results in terms of a decrease of the enthalpy due to the presence of the peptides, which destabilize the membrane. The dynamics in the two directions was differentiated when the individual peptides were added to the membranes, but the impact was smaller when both peptides were added together.

Solid-State NMR of Membrane Proteins in Lipid Bilayers: To Spin or Not To Spin?

Membrane proteins mediate a plethora of cellular functions and represent important targets for drug development. Unlike soluble proteins, membrane proteins require native-like environments to fold correctly and be active. Therefore, modern structural biology techniques have aimed to determine the structure and dynamics of these membrane proteins at physiological temperature and in liquid crystalline lipid bilayers. With the flourishing of new NMR methodologies and improvements in sample preparations, magic angle spinning (MAS) and oriented sample solid-state NMR (OS-ssNMR) spectroscopy of membrane proteins is experiencing a new renaissance. Born as antagonistic approaches, these techniques nowadays offer complementary information on the structural topology and dynamics of membrane proteins reconstituted in lipid membranes. By spinning biosolid samples at the magic angle (θ = 54.7°), MAS NMR experiments remove the intrinsic anisotropy of the NMR interactions, increasing spectral resolution. Internuclear spin interactions (spin exchange) are reintroduced by RF pulses, providing distances and torsion angles to determine secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structures of membrane proteins. OS-ssNMR, on the other hand, directly detects anisotropic NMR parameters such as dipolar couplings (DC) and anisotropic chemical shifts (CS), providing orientational constraints to determine the architecture (i.e., topology) of membrane proteins relative to the lipid membrane. Defining the orientation of membrane proteins and their interactions with lipid membranes is of paramount importance since lipid-protein interactions can shape membrane protein conformations and ultimately define their functional states.In this Account, we report selected studies from our group integrating MAS and OS-ssNMR techniques to give a comprehensive view of the biological processes occurring at cellular membranes. We focus on the main experiments for both techniques, with an emphasis on new implementation to increase both sensitivity and spectral resolution. We also describe how the structural constraints derived from both isotropic and anisotropic NMR parameters are integrated into dynamic structural modeling using replica-averaged orientational-restrained molecular dynamics simulations (RAOR-MD). We showcase small membrane proteins that are involved in Ca²⁺ transport and regulate cardiac and skeletal muscle contractility: phospholamban (PLN, 6 kDa), sarcolipin (SLN, 4 kDa), and DWORF (4 kDa). We summarize our results for the structures of these polypeptides free and in complex with the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) Ca²⁺-ATPase (SERCA, 110 kDa). Additionally, we illustrate the progress toward the determination of the structural topology of a six transmembrane protein associated with succinate and acetate transport (SatP, hexamer 120 kDa). From these examples, the integrated MAS and OS-ssNMR approach, in combination with modern computational methods, emerges as a way to overcome the challenges posed by studying large membrane protein systems.

Investigations of the Structure, Topology, and Interactions of the Transmembrane Domain of the Lipid-Sorting Protein p24 Being Highly Selective for Sphingomyelin-C18

The p24 proteins play an important role in the secretory pathway where they selectively connect various cargo to other proteins, thereby being involved in the controlled assembly and disassembly of the coat protein complexes and lipid sorting. Recently, a highly selective lipid interaction motif has been identified within the p24 transmembrane domain (TMD) that recognizes the combination of the sphingomyelin headgroup and the exact length of the C18 fatty acyl chain (SM-C18). Here, we present investigations of the structure, dynamics, and sphingomyelin interactions of the p24 transmembrane region using circular dichroism, tryptophan fluorescence, and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopies of the polypeptides and the surrounding lipids. Membrane insertion and/or conformation of the TMD is strongly dependent on the membrane lipid composition where the transmembrane helical insertion is strongest in the presence of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and SM-C18. By analyzing solid-state NMR angular restraints from a large number of labeled sites, we have found a tilt angle of 19° for the transmembrane helical domain at a peptide-to-lipid ratio of 1 mol %. Only minor changes in the solid-state NMR spectra are observed due to the presence of SM-C18; the only visible alterations are associated with the SM-C18 recognition motif close to the carboxy-terminal part of the hydrophobic transmembrane region in the proximity of the SM headgroup. Finally, the deuterium order parameters of POPC- d₃₁ were nearly unaffected by the presence of SM-C18 or the polypeptide alone but decreased noticeably when the sphingomyelin and the polypeptide were added in combination.

Lipid-Mediated Interactions between the Antimicrobial Peptides Magainin 2 and PGLa in Bilayers

A synergistic enhancement of activities has been described for the amphipathic cationic antimicrobial peptides magainin 2 and PGLa when tested in antimicrobial assays or in biophysical experiments using model membranes. In the presence of magainin 2, PGLa changes from an in-planar alignment parallel to the membrane surface to a more transmembrane orientation when investigated in membranes made from fully saturated PC or PC/PG, but not when one of the fatty acyl chains is unsaturated. Such lipid-mediated changes in the membrane topology of polypeptide domains could provide an interesting mechanism for the regulation of membrane proteins. Here we investigated the PGLa topology in a wide variety of membranes made of saturated or unsaturated PE, PC, and/or PG using ¹⁵N solid-state NMR spectroscopy. In contrast to predictions made by previous models the data show that membrane curvature has only a minor effect on PGLa realignment. Furthermore, using ²H solid-state NMR spectroscopy of deuterated phospholipid fatty acyl chains the order parameters of the lipids were investigated in the presence of PGLa, magainin, or equimolar peptide mixtures. Both peptides cause a pronounced decrease in the order parameters when oriented parallel to the membrane surface, an effect that reverts when PGLa flips into transmembrane alignments. Taken together, these data are suggestive that the magainin-induced disordering of fatty acyl chains provides an important driving force for PGLa realignment.

Supramolecular Organization of Apolipoprotein-A-I-Derived Peptides within Disc-like Arrangements

Apolipoprotein A-I is the major protein component of high-density lipoproteins and fulfils important functions in lipid metabolism. Its structure consists of a chain of tandem domains of amphipathic helices. Using this protein as a template membrane scaffolding protein, class A amphipathic helical peptides were designed to support the amphipathic helix theory and later as therapeutic tools in biomedicine. Here, we investigated the lipid interactions of two apolipoprotein-A-I-derived class A amphipathic peptides, 14A (Ac-DYLKA FYDKL KEAF-NH₂) and 18A (Ac-DWLKA FYDKV AEKLK EAF- NH₂), including the disc-like supramolecular structures they form with phospholipids. Thus, the topologies of 14A and 18A in phospholipid bilayers have been determined by oriented solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Whereas at a peptide-to-lipid ratio of 2 mol% the peptides align parallel to the bilayer surface, at 7.5 mol% disc-like structures are formed that spontaneously orient in the magnetic field of the NMR spectrometer. From a comprehensive data set of four ¹⁵N- or ²H-labeled positions of 14A, a tilt angle, which deviates from perfectly in-planar by 14°, and a model for the peptidic rim structure have been obtained. The tilt and helical pitch angles are well suited to cover the hydrophobic chain region of the bilayer when two peptide helices form a head-to-tail dimer. Thus, the detailed topology found in this work agrees with the peptides forming the rim of nanodiscs in a double belt arrangement.

Impact of membrane curvature on amyloid aggregation

The misfolding, amyloid aggregation, and fibril formation of intrinsically disordered proteins/peptides (or amyloid proteins) have been shown to cause a number of disorders. The underlying mechanisms of amyloid fibrillation and structural properties of amyloidogenic precursors, intermediates, and amyloid fibrils have been elucidated in detail; however, in-depth examinations on physiologically relevant contributing factors that induce amyloidogenesis and lead to cell death remain challenging. A large number of studies have attempted to characterize the roles of biomembranes on protein aggregation and membrane-mediated cell death by designing various membrane components, such as gangliosides, cholesterol, and other lipid compositions, and by using various membrane mimetics, including liposomes, bicelles, and different types of lipid-nanodiscs. We herein review the dynamic effects of membrane curvature on amyloid generation and the inhibition of amyloidogenic proteins and peptides, and also discuss how amyloid formation affects membrane curvature and integrity, which are key for understanding relationships with cell death. Small unilamellar vesicles with high curvature and large unilamellar vesicles with low curvature have been demonstrated to exhibit different capabilities to induce the nucleation, amyloid formation, and inhibition of amyloid-β peptides and α-synuclein. Polymorphic amyloidogenesis in small unilamellar vesicles was revealed and may be viewed as one of the generic properties of interprotein interaction-dominated amyloid formation. Several mechanical models and phase diagrams are comprehensively shown to better explain experimental findings. The negative membrane curvature-mediated mechanisms responsible for the toxicity of pancreatic β cells by the amyloid aggregation of human islet amyloid polypeptide (IAPP) and binding of the precursors of the semen-derived enhancer of viral infection (SEVI) are also described. The curvature-dependent binding modes of several types of islet amyloid polypeptides with high-resolution NMR structures are also discussed.

Alanine scan and (2)H NMR analysis of the membrane-active peptide BP100 point to a distinct carpet mechanism of action

The short membrane-active peptide BP100 [KKLFKKILKYL-NH2] is known as an effective antimicrobial and cell penetrating agent. For a functional alanine scan each of the 11 amino acids was replaced with deuterated Ala-d3, one at a time. MIC assays showed that a substitution of Lys did not affect the antimicrobial activity, but it decreased when a hydrophobic residue was replaced. In most cases, a reduction in hydrophobicity led to a decrease in hemolysis, and some peptide analogues had an improved therapeutic index. Circular dichroism showed that BP100 folds as an amphiphilic α-helix in a bilayer. Its alignment was determined from (2)H NMR in oriented membranes of different composition. The azimuthal rotation angle was the same under all conditions, but the average helix tilt angle and the dynamical behavior of the peptide varied in a systematic manner. In POPC/POPG bilayers, with a negative spontaneous curvature, the peptide was found to lie flat on the bilayer surface, and with little wobble. In DMPC/DMPG, with a positive spontaneous curvature, BP100 at higher concentrations became tilted obliquely into the membrane, with the uncharged C-terminus inserted more deeply into the lipid bilayer, experiencing significant fluctuations in tilt angle. In DMPC/DMPG/lyso-MPC, with a pronounced positive spontaneous curvature, the helix tilted even further and became even more mobile. The 11-mer BP100 is obviously too short to form transmembrane pores. We conclude that BP100 operates via a carpet mechanism, whereby the C-terminus gets inserted into the hydrophobic core of the bilayer, which leads to membrane perturbation and induces transient permeability.

Membrane topologies of the PGLa antimicrobial peptide and a transmembrane anchor sequence by Dynamic Nuclear Polarization/solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Dynamic Nuclear Polarization (DNP) has been introduced to overcome the sensitivity limitations of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy also of supported lipid bilayers. When investigated by solid-state NMR techniques the approach typically involves doping the samples with biradicals and their investigation at cryo-temperatures. Here we investigated the effects of temperature and membrane hydration on the topology of amphipathic and hydrophobic membrane polypeptides. Although the antimicrobial PGLa peptide in dimyristoyl phospholipids is particularly sensitive to topological alterations, the DNP conditions represent well its membrane alignment also found in bacterial lipids at ambient temperature. With a novel membrane-anchored biradical and purpose-built hardware a 17-fold enhancement in NMR signal intensity is obtained by DNP which is one of the best obtained for a truly static matrix-free system. Furthermore, a membrane anchor sequence encompassing 19 hydrophobic amino acid residues was investigated. Although at cryotemperatures the transmembrane domain adjusts it membrane tilt angle by about 10 degrees, the temperature dependence of two-dimensional separated field spectra show that freezing the motions can have beneficial effects for the structural analysis of this sequence.

Solid-State NMR/Dynamic Nuclear Polarization of Polypeptides in Planar Supported Lipid Bilayers

Dynamic nuclear polarization has been developed to overcome the limitations of the inherently low signal intensity of NMR spectroscopy. This technique promises to be particularly useful for solid-state NMR spectroscopy where the signals are broadened over a larger frequency range and most investigations rely on recording low gamma nuclei. To extend the range of possible investigations, a triple-resonance flat-coil solid-state NMR probe is presented with microwave irradiation capacities allowing the investigation of static samples at temperatures of 100 K, including supported lipid bilayers. The probe performance allows for two-dimensional separated local field experiments with high-power Lee-Goldberg decoupling and cross-polarization under simultaneous irradiation from a gyrotron microwave generator. Efficient cooling of the sample turned out to be essential for best enhancements and line shape and necessitated the development of a dedicated cooling chamber. Furthermore, a new membrane-anchored biradical is presented, and the geometry of supported membranes was optimized not only for good membrane alignment, handling, stability, and filling factor of the coil but also for heat and microwave dissipation. Enhancement factors of 17-fold were obtained, and a two-dimensional PISEMA spectrum of a transmembrane helical peptide was obtained in less than 2 h.

Simultaneous acquisition of 2D and 3D solid-state NMR experiments for sequential assignment of oriented membrane protein samples

We present a new method called DAISY (Dual Acquisition orIented ssNMR spectroScopY) for the simultaneous acquisition of 2D and 3D oriented solid-state NMR experiments for membrane proteins reconstituted in mechanically or magnetically aligned lipid bilayers. DAISY utilizes dual acquisition of sine and cosine dipolar or chemical shift coherences and long living (15)N longitudinal polarization to obtain two multi-dimensional spectra, simultaneously. In these new experiments, the first acquisition gives the polarization inversion spin exchange at the magic angle (PISEMA) or heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) spectra, the second acquisition gives PISEMA-mixing or HETCOR-mixing spectra, where the mixing element enables inter-residue correlations through (15)N-(15)N homonuclear polarization transfer. The analysis of the two 2D spectra (first and second acquisitions) enables one to distinguish (15)N-(15)N inter-residue correlations for sequential assignment of membrane proteins. DAISY can be implemented in 3D experiments that include the polarization inversion spin exchange at magic angle via I spin coherence (PISEMAI) sequence, as we show for the simultaneous acquisition of 3D PISEMAI-HETCOR and 3D PISEMAI-HETCOR-mixing experiments.

Membrane interactions of phylloseptin-1, -2, and -3 peptides by oriented solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Phylloseptin-1, -2, and -3 are three members of the family of linear cationic antimicrobial peptides found in tree frogs. The highly homologous peptides encompass 19 amino acids, and only differ in the amino acid composition and charge at the six most carboxy-terminal residues. Here, we investigated how such subtle changes are reflected in their membrane interactions and how these can be correlated to their biological activities. To this end, the three peptides were labeled with stable isotopes, reconstituted into oriented phospholipid bilayers, and their detailed topology determined by a combined approach using (2)H and (15)N solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Although phylloseptin-2 and -3 adopt perfect in-plane alignments, the tilt angle of phylloseptin-1 deviates by 8° probably to assure a more water exposed localization of the lysine-17 side chain. Furthermore, different azimuthal angles are observed, positioning the amphipathic helices of all three peptides with the charged residues well exposed to the water phase. Interestingly, our studies also reveal that two orientation-dependent (2)H quadrupolar splittings from methyl-deuterated alanines and one (15)N amide chemical shift are sufficient to unambiguously determine the topology of phylloseptin-1, where quadrupolar splittings close to the maximum impose the most stringent angular restraints. As a result of these studies, a strategy is proposed where the topology of a peptide structure can be determined accurately from the labeling with (15)N and (2)H isotopes of only a few amino acid residues.

Sensitivity and resolution enhancement of oriented solid-state NMR: application to membrane proteins

Oriented solid-state NMR (O-ssNMR) spectroscopy is a major technique for the high-resolution analysis of the structure and topology of transmembrane proteins in native-like environments. Unlike magic angle spinning (MAS) techniques, O-ssNMR spectroscopy requires membrane protein preparations that are uniformly oriented (mechanically or magnetically) so that anisotropic NMR parameters, such as dipolar and chemical shift interactions, can be measured to determine structure and orientation of membrane proteins in lipid bilayers. Traditional sample preparations involving mechanically aligned lipids often result in short relaxation times which broaden the (15)N resonances and encumber the manipulation of nuclear spin coherences. The introduction of lipid bicelles as membrane mimicking systems has changed this scenario, and the more favorable relaxation properties of membrane protein (15)N and (13)C resonances make it possible to develop new, more elaborate pulse sequences for higher spectral resolution and sensitivity. Here, we describe our recent progress in the optimization of O-ssNMR pulse sequences. We explain the theory behind these experiments, demonstrate their application to small and medium size proteins, and describe the technical details for setting up these new experiments on the new generation of NMR spectrometers.

Structure and topology of the huntingtin 1-17 membrane anchor by a combined solution and solid-state NMR approach

The very amino-terminal domain of the huntingtin protein is directly located upstream of the protein's polyglutamine tract, plays a decisive role in several important properties of this large protein and in the development of Huntington's disease. This huntingtin 1-17 domain is on the one hand known to markedly increase polyglutamine aggregation rates and on the other hand has been shown to be involved in cellular membrane interactions. Here, we determined the high-resolution structure of huntingtin 1-17 in dodecyl phosphocholine micelles and the topology of its helical domain in oriented phosphatidylcholine bilayers. Using two-dimensional solution NMR spectroscopy the low-energy conformations of the polypeptide were identified in the presence of dodecyl phosphocholine detergent micelles. In a next step a set of four solid-state NMR angular restraints was obtained from huntingtin 1-17 labeled with (15)N and (2)H at selected sites. Of the micellar ensemble of helical conformations only a limited set agrees in quantitative detail with the solid-state angular restraints of huntingtin 1-17 obtained in supported planar lipid bilayers. Thereby, the solid-state NMR data were used to further refine the domain structure in phospholipid bilayers. At the same time its membrane topology was determined and different motional regimes of this membrane-associated domain were explored. The pronounced structural transitions of huntingtin 1-17 upon membrane-association result in a α-helical conformation from K6 to F17, i.e., up to the very start of the polyglutamine tract. This amphipathic helix is aligned nearly parallel to the membrane surface (tilt angle ∼77°) and is characterized by a hydrophobic ridge on one side and an alternation of cationic and anionic residues that run along the hydrophilic face of the helix. This arrangement facilitates electrostatic interactions between huntingtin 1-17 domains and possibly with the proximal polyglutamine tract.