Characterization of an RNA "binding site" for a specific ribosomal protein of Escherichia coli

Cloning, Escherichia coli expression, purification, characterization, and enzyme assay of the ribosomal protein S4 from wheat seedlings (Triticum vulgare)

S4 is a paradigm of ribosomal proteins involved in multifarious activities both within and outside the ribosome. For a detailed biochemical and structural investigations of eukaryotic S4, the wheat S4 gene has been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and the protein purified to a high degree of homogeneity. The 285-residue recombinant protein containing an N-terminal His(6) tag along with fourteen additional residues derived from the cloning vector is characterized by a molecular mass of 31981.24 Da. The actual sequence of 265 amino acids having a molecular mass of 29931 Da completely defines the primary structure of wheat S4. Homology modeling shows a bi-lobed protein topology arising from folding of the polypeptide into two domains, consistent with the fold topology of prokaryotic S4. The purified protein is stable and folded since it can be reversibly unfolded in guanidinium hydrochloride, and is capable of hydrolyzing cysteine protease-specific peptide-based fluorescence substrates, including Ac-DEVD-AFC (N-acetyl-Asp-Glu-Val-Asp-7-amino-4-trifluoromethylcoumarin) and Z-FR-AMC (N-CBZ-Phe-Arg-aminomethylcoumarin).

Directed hydroxyl radical probing of 16S rRNA using Fe(II) tethered to ribosomal protein S4

Localized hydroxyl radical probing has been used to explore the rRNA neighborhood around a unique position in the structure of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit. Fe(II) was attached to ribosomal protein S4 at Cys-31 via the reagent 1-(p-bromoacetamidobenzyl)-EDTA. [Fe-Cys31]S4 was then complexed with 16S rRNA or incorporated into active 30S ribosomal subunits by in vitro reconstitution with 16S rRNA and a mixture of the remaining 30S subunit proteins. Hydroxyl radicals generated from the tethered Fe resulted in cleavage of the 16S rRNA chain in two localized regions of its 5' domain. One region spans positions 419-432 and is close to the multihelix junction previously placed at the RNA binding site of S4 by chemical and enzymatic protection (footprinting) and crosslinking studies. A second site of directed cleavage includes nucleotides 297-303, which overlap a site that is protected from chemical modification by protein S16, a near neighbor of S4 in the ribosome. These results provide useful information about the three-dimensional organization of 16S rRNA and indicate that these two regions of its 5' domain are in close spatial proximity to Cys-31 of protein S4.

A temperature-dependent conformational rearrangement in the ribosomal protein S4.16 S rRNA complex

Ribosomal protein S4 protects a characteristic set of bases in 16 S rRNA from attack by chemical probes. Use of hydroxyl radical as a probe of the RNA backbone shows that ribose residues in these same regions are also protected by S4, confirming the localization of its interactions with 16 S rRNA to the junction of five helical elements in the proximal region of the 5' domain. At 0 degrees C, the nucleotides protected by S4 from base-specific probes are confined almost exclusively to the two compound helices formed by residues 404-499. After subsequent heating of the complex briefly at 30 or 42 degrees C, nucleotides in the three adjacent helices are additionally protected, resulting in a pattern of protection that is identical to that which is observed when S4 is incubated with 16 S rRNA under in vitro reconstitution conditions. Preincubation of the protein or the RNA (or both) separately at elevated temperature does not substitute for heating the S4.RNA complex. The regions in the RNA affected by the heat step are known to interact with proteins S12 and S16, both of which depend upon S4 for their binding to the RNA. Thus, the finding that S4 recruits additional sites of interaction in the RNA following its initial binding suggests a possible mechanism to insure the sequential addition of proteins during ribosomal assembly.

Localization of the binding site for protein S4 on 16 S ribosomal RNA by chemical and enzymatic probing and primer extension

We have examined the effect of binding ribosomal protein S4 to 16 S rRNA on the susceptibility of the RNA to a variety of chemical and enzymatic probes. We have used dimethyl sulfate to probe unpaired adenines (at N-1) and cytosines (at N-3), kethoxal to probe unpaired guanines (at N-1 and N-2) and cobra venom (V1) ribonuclease as a probe of base-paired regions of 16 S rRNA. Sites of attack by the probes were identified by primer extension using synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides. Comparison of probing results for naked and S4-bound rRNA shows: Protein S4 protects a relatively compact region of the 5' domain of 16 S rRNA from chemical and enzymatic attack. This region is bounded by nucleotides 27 to 47 and 394 to 556, and has a secondary structure characterized by the junction of five helical elements. Phylogenetically conserved irregular features (bulged nucleotides, internal loops and flanking unpaired nucleotides) and helical phosphodiester bonds of four of the helices are specifically protected in the S4-RNA complex. We conclude that this is the major, and possibly sole region of contact between 16 S rRNA and S4. Many of the S4-dependent changes mimic those observed on assembly of 16 S rRNA into 30 S ribosomal subunits. Binding of S4 causes enhanced chemical reactivity coupled with protection from V1 nuclease outside the S4 junction region in the 530, 720 and 1140 loops. We interpret these results as indicative of loss of structure, and suggest that S4 binding causes disruption of adventitious pairing in these regions, possibly by stabilizing the geometry of the RNA such that these interactions are prevented from forming.

Detailed analysis of the higher-order structure of 16S-like ribosomal ribonucleic acids

Images

Binding sites for ribosomal proteins S8 and S15 in the 16 S RNA of Escherichia coli

A fragment of the 16 S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli that contains the binding sites for proteins S8 and S15 of the 30 S ribosomal subunit has been isolated and characterized. The RNA fragment, which sediments as 5 S, was partially protected from pancreatic RNAase digestion when S15 alone, or S8 and S15 together, were bound to the 16 S RNA. Purified 5 S RNA was shown to reassociate specifically with protein S15 by analysis of binding stoichiometry. Although interaction between the fragment and protein S8 alone could not be detected, the 5 S RNA selectively bound both S8 and S15 when incubated with an unfractionated mixture of 30-S subunit proteins. Nucleotide sequence analysis demonstrated that the 5 S RNA arises from the middle of the 16 S RNA molecule and encompasses approximately 150 residues from Sections C, C'1 and C'2. Section C consists of a long hairpin loop with an extensively hydrogen-bonded stem and is contiguous with Section C'1. Sections C'1 and C'2, although not contiguous, are highly complementary and it is likely that together they comprise the base-paired stem of an adjacent loop.

Analysis of rpsD mutations in Escherichia coli. I. Comparison of mutants with various alterations in ribosomal protein S4

Streptomycin-independent revertants were selected from streptomycin-dependent mutants. Twenty-five out of 150 such revertants were temperature sensitive. Ribosomal proteins from 18 temperature-sensitive and 10 temperature-insensitive revertants were analysed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Seventeen of the former but none of the latter category showed an alteration of protein S4. The mutated rpsD allele of 6 temperature-sensitive revertants was transduced into a rpsL+ strain. In all cases an increased suppressibility of T4 amber phages was observed. Such suppressibility was not observed in the original rpsD, rpsL strains. All 18 temperature-sensitive mutants were disturbed in the processing of 17s to 16s RNA at non-permissive temperature and the accumulated 17s RNA was degraded. Temperature-insensitive rpsD revertants could be isolated, which had gained a second alteration in S4. Such revertants, which had lost the temperature-sensitive property, were also unable to suppress growth of T4 amber phages. It is concluded that temperature-sensitive growth, inability to process 17s RNA and to assemble 30S ribosomes at non-permissive temperature as well as increased translational ambiguity are highly correlated properties in rpsD mutants.

Physical studies on the conformation of ribosomal protein S4 from Escherichia coli

Proton magnetic resonance, circular dichroism and infrared spectroscopy were used to investigate the secondary and tertiary structure of the 16-S RNA binding protein S4 from Escherichia coli ribosomes. The proton magnetic resonance spectra of protein S4 in ribosomal reconstitution and low-salt buffers were identical and showed little dipolar broadening of the peaks, suggesting that the protein had an open extended structure. A ring-current-shifted apolar methyl resonance in the high-field region of the spectrum, together with a perturbation of the tyrosine ring proton resonance in the low-field region, indicated the existence of a specific tertiary fold in the polypeptide chain. This structure disappeared on lowering the pH below 5 or on heating above 30 degrees C, both processes being reversible. Circular dichroism measurements on protein S4 showed an alpha-helix content of 32% in reconstitution buffer compared with 26% in low-salt buffer. Heating the protein solution in reconstitution buffer above 35 degrees C reversibly disrupted this extra helix. Infrared studies on both solid films and solutions of protein S4 indicated the presence of little or no beta-structure. These results correlate well with the known RNA binding properties of protein S4.

Localisation of part of the binding sites of 30S ribosomal proteins S4 and S20 in a small uninterrupted fragment of 16S RNA

Analyses of the T1 ribonuclease-alkaline phosphatase fingerprint of a continuous fragment of the 16S rRNA, 170-230 nucleotides long, isolated from the products of autodigestion of 30S ribosome subunits show that it contains a sequence near the 5'-phosphate terminus of intact 16S rRNA and corresponds to segment H'-M of this molecule as defined by Ehresmann et al [29]. Incubation of this fragment with total 30S ribosomal proteins under reconstitution conditions leads to the formation of a complex containing proteins S4, S20, and one or both of proteins S16 and S17. The stoichiometry of these proteins in the complex is discussed.

The binding site of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S4 on 16-S ribosomal RNA from different bacterial species

Ribosomal protein S4 of Escherichia coli was bound to 16-S ribosomal RNAs from several bacterial species and the complexes digested with pancreatic ribonuclease in an effort to isolate heterologous RNA binding sites for protein S4. 16-S RNAs from Aeromonas punctata, Pseudomonas fluorescens and Vibrio cuneatus each gave rise to protected fragments whose electrophoretic mobility was 7S, i.e. similar to that of the fragment generated from E. coli 16-S RNA using the same conditions. No comparable fragment was obtained from 16-S RNA of either Bacillus subtilis or Bacillus stearothermophilus, if E. coli protein S4 was present prior to digestion. The protected 7-S RNA fragment from A. punctata and the subfragments obtained from it by gel electrophoresis under denaturing conditions were characterized further by fingerprinting and nucleotide sequence analysis. The sequence of many of the T1 ribonuclease oligonucleotides was obtained and compared to those from the E. coli 7-S fragment. This has permitted a tentative identification of the sequences of A. punctata 16-S RNA which are protected by E. coli protein S4, namely, the regions homologous to the E. coli sequence from section M through C''. The fingerprints of the protected 7-S fragments from both P. fluorescens and V. cuneatus were sufficiently different from that of the E. coli 7-S fragment that no conclusions regarding sequence homologies could be drawn.

Geometry of the protein S4 from Escherichia coli ribosomes

The shape of protein S4 from Escherichia coli ribosomes in solution was determined by hydrodynamic methods and low-angle X-ray scattering. The molecular weight of 24000 determined by low-angle X-ray scattering is within 3% of that found by sedimentation equilibrium analysis and 8% of that determined by amino acid sequence work. The radius of gyration of 3.36 nm, the radius of gyration of the cross section of 0.41 nm and the hydrodynamic studies revealed that protein S4 is not spherical, but rather has a markedly extended shape. Calculations of different conformations, e.g. random coil, based on the parameters evaluated from hydrodynamic methods, revealed a rod-like structure of S4 with a length of 14 nm and a diameter of 1 nm. This is supported by a model of an equivalent scattering particle of uniform density based on all parameters obtained in this study.

Studies on the environment of protein S7 within the 30-S subunit Escherichia coli ribosomes

Analyses are described of three types of ribosomal fragment, all derived from the well-characterized ribonucleoprotein species consisting of proteins S7, S9, S10, S14 AND S19, together with RNA from sections O'-D-E'-K-P-P'-E-A of the 16-S sequence. 1. When 30-S subunits were hydrolysed with ribonuclease T1 in presence of deoxycholate in addition to the components previously described, a fragment could be isolated which contained only proteins S7 and S19, together with minor amounts of S13 or S14. Oligonucleotide analysis of this fragment showed that it contained RNA from sections O'-E' and P-A of the 16-S RNA, but that section K (from the middle of this area) was missing. 2. It has previously been shown that when 30-S subunits are irradiated with ultraviolet light, protein S7 is the primary target of cross-linking of protein to RNA. By making use of this reaction, ribonucleoprotein fragments were isolated from irradiated 30-S subunits the unbound proteins were removed, and RNA fragments containing covalently linked protein S7 were identified. It was possible to demonstrate that the site of cross-linking lies within the O'-A region of the 16-S RNA, and more precise experiments showed that this site almost certainly is in the P-A region. 3. When the parent five-protein ribonucleoprotein fragment (above) was deproteinized under very mild conditions, RNA complexes could be isolated which consisted of non-contiguous sequences, but which migrated as a single species into a polyacrylamide gel. Analysis of one of these complexes showed that it contained sequences from sections O'-E' and P-A, but that section K was missing (cf. first paragraph above). This demonstrated that these two separate regions of RNA interact within the 30-S subunit, independently of the presence of protein.

Interactions between 30s ribosomal proteins and 50s subunits of Escherichia coli

The interaction between ribosomal proteins of the 30s subunit with intact 50s subunits was investigated. Experiments with mixtures of total 30s proteins indicated that several 30s proteins including protein s4 would form a stable complex with 50s subunits. Further work with pure s4 indicates that this protein binds stoichiometrically to the 50s subunits, probably through protein-nucleic acid interaction. The possible significance of this interaction is discussed.

Localization of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S4 on the surface of the 30S ribosomal subunit by immuno electron microscopy. I. Distribution of antibody-binding sites as obtained with immunoglobulins and monovalent antibody fragments from various S4-specific antisera

The location of the ribosomal protein S4 on the surface of the 30S subunit of E. coli ribosomes was determined by immuno electron microscopy. Immunoglobulins from six separate S4-specific antisera were investigated. In accordance with earlier findings protein S4 was shown to have an elongated conformation within the antisera. Protein S4 has therefore definitely an extended or fibrous shape in the intact ribosome (Lake et al., 1974; Stöffler and Tischendorf, 1975; Tischendorf et al., 1975). S4 specific antibodies bind at four distinct sites of 30S ribosomal subunits, designated A, B, C and D. Two antibody binding sites (A and B) are located on the "head", they were shown to be separated by 70-85 A. The distance between these sites and the two sites C and D on the "body" of the subunit amounts to at least 90-125 A; hence protein S4 should be extended to a total length of approximately 160-200 A. At least three of the four S4-specific antibody binding sites were observed with antibodies from each of the six investigated. These sites were observed independently of whether isolated S4 protein, an S4-16S rRNA complex or 30S ribosomes were used as the antigen. They could also be visualized with monovalent antibody fragments (Fab). S4-specific antibodies enriched by affinity chromatography bound at identical sites which conclusively ensures that antibody binding at these sites is specific for protein S4 and is not due to the presence of contaminating antibodies in the intact ribosome. The implications of these results with respect of the correlation of each of the sites to their respective antigenically active fragments within protein S4 are discussed.

Determination of the complete amino-acid sequence of protein S4 from Escherichia coli ribosomes

After digestion of protein S4 with trypsin, all 32 tryptic peptides were isolated. Their amino acid compositions were analyzed and the sequence of the amino acids within the tryptic peptides was determined by means of a solid-phase peptide sequenator and by exopeptidases. Alignment of the tryptic peptides was established by analyzing and partially sequencing peptides isolated after digestion of the S4 protein with chymotrypsin, thermolysin and a glutamic-acid-specific protease. Further information about the alignment of peptides came from treatment of S4 with CNBr and with a lysine-modifying reagent.

Nucleotide sequences of Escherichia coli 16-S RNA associated with ribosomal proteins S7, S9, S10, S14 and S19

1. A ribonucleoprotein fragment containing proteins S7, S9, S10, S14, and S19 was isolated in high yield from Escherichia coli 30-S ribosomal sub-particles. The same fragment was obtained whether ribosomes from E. coli strain A19 or MRE 600 were used, despite the fact that protein S7 differs widely between the two strains. RNA was extracted from this fragment and fractionated on gels containing 7 M urea, to reveal "hidden breaks". A well-defined and reporducible pattern of RNA fragments was obtained, with the main components being approximately 300, 240, 130, 115 and 75 nucleotides in length, respectively. The pattern of RNA fragments obtained was also independent of the strain of E. coli used. 2. Two-dimensional fingerprints were made from ribonuclease T1 hydrolysates of these RNA fragments, labelled with 32P, and the oligonucleotides were further analysed by digestion with either ribonuclease A or U2. The data obtained were fitted in detail to the new 16-S RNA sequence map of Ehresmann et al. (1975). Again no significant differences were observed between the RNA from E. coli A19 or MRE 600. The RNA sequences found lay in the region O'-D-E'-K-P-P'-E-A of the 16-S RNA, with a clear excision of several nucleotides in section E'-K. The total sequence length covered was approximately 430 nucleotides.

Chemical determination of protein neighbourhoods in a cellular organelle

Experimental procedures developed for the identification of near-neighboring proteins in a complicated organelle are described in this paper. The specific system studied here is the ribosome of Escherichia coli; however, the techniques and reagents described should have a wide range of applications. We have used three kinds of cross-linking agents: noncleavable maleimide reagents which react with free SH groups; noncleavable diimidoesters which react with free amino groups, and cleavable diazide agents that also react with free amino groups. The combination of immunological and isotopic labelling techniques used to identify proteins cross-linked by noncleavable reagents, as well as the special electrophoretic techniques used with the cleavable reagents are described. We show that the neighborhoods detected by the crosslink technology are functionally meaningful ones, and also discuss the ambiguities inherent in the structural interpretation of such protein neighborhoods.

An investigation of the 16-S RNA binding sites of ribosomal proteins S4, S8, S15, and S20 FROM Escherichia coli

The RNA binding sites of four 30-S ribosomal subunit proteins from Escherichia coli, namely S4, S8, S15, and S20 were prepared from reconstituted single protein - 16-S-RNA complexes by mild enzymic digestion of non-protected RNA regions. Oligonucleotide fingerprints of the protected RNA regions were obtained and their positions were located within the 16-S-RNA sequence. They were not completely contiguous regions of RNA; oligonucleotides had been excised from each of them. The binding sites of S4 and S20, and those of S8 and S15 showed overlapping. The specificity of the RNA binding sites was confirmed by a reconstitution method.

Location and characteristics of ribosomal protein binding sites in the 16S RNA of Escherichia coli

Specific binding sites for five proteins of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit have been located within the 16S RNA. The sites are structurally diverse and range in size from 40 to 500 nucleotides; their functional integrity appears to depend upon both the secondary structure and conformation of the RNA molecule. Evidence is presented which indicates that additional proteins interact with the RNA at later stages of subunit assembly.

Action of ribonuclease T1 on 30S ribosomes of Escherichia coli and its role in sequence studies on 16S ribonucleic acid

Two large ribonucleic acid (RNA) fragments have been obtained from T1-RNase-treated 30S ribosomes of Escherichia coli. One fragment, about 475 nucleotides long, contains all the unique oligonucleotides found by Fellner and associates in sections of 16S RNA designated P, E, E', and K, and one-half the large oligonucleotides of section A. The other large fragment is about 300 nucleotides long and contains the oligonucleotides found in sections C, C', C''. The isolation of these large fragments seems to confirm the arrangement of sections within 16S RNA. There are also recovered from nuclease-treated ribosomes three small fragments, one (120 nucleotides long) from the 5' end, one (26 nucleotides long) from the 3' OH end of the chain, and another section (66 nucleotides long) from the middle of the 16S RNA chain. Small molecular weight material is also generated by nuclease treatment, and about half this material is derived from a region close to the 3' OH end of the 16S RNA chain. This indicates that the most accessible part of the rRNA of E. coli 30S ribosomes is a region 100 to 150 nucleotides long near the 3' end of the chain. A general scheme is proposed to explain the generation of the various-sized RNA products from the rRNA of the 30S ribosome.

Localization of a binding site for ribosomal protein S8 within the 16S ribosomal ribonucleic acid of Escherichia coli

A region of 16S ribosomal ribonucleic acid that binds Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S8 has been isolated and characterized. It corresponds to what has been designated as fragment C of the ribonucleic acid.

Assembly of bacterial ribosomes

I have not mentioned the remarkable progress made mainly by Fellner and his co-workers (86) in the elucidation of the primary structure of rRNA's and by Wittmann and his co-workers (87) in determining the structure of several ribosomal proteins. Such knowledge of primary structures is certainly the basis of complete understanding of the structure of the ribosome. With the current progress in technology, complete elucidation of the primary structure of all the ribosomal components is probably a matter of time. As indicated in this article, a rough approximation of the three-dimensional structure of ribosomes is likely to emerge soon. Although not mentioned in this article, studies of ribosomes from higher organisms are also progressing. We must, therefore, consider what further studies should be conducted and what kinds of questions we would like to solve. Some groups of investigators aim to elucidate the complete three-dimensional structure of ribosomes and to find out how these complex cell organelles function; they hope to determine the conformational changes of many of the component molecules within the ribosome structure in response to external macromolecules and cofactors engaged in protein synthesis. Such knowledge will also be important in enabling us to understand the regulation of translation of genetic messages. Other groups of investigators aim to elucidate the complex series of events which originate in the transcription of the more than 60 genes and culminate in the formation of the specific structure of the organelle. Complete reproduction in vitro of all the assembly events that occur in vivo should not be difficult to achieve in principle. It should then become possible to study in vitro any factor regulating the biogenesis of the organelle. Although we do not know whether such studies would reveal any new fundamental principle that governs the complex circuits of interconnected macromolecular interactions, the achievement of such a complete in vitro system would represent a necessary step in the comprehensive understanding of biogenesis of organelles, and eventually, of the more complex behavior and genesis of cells (89).