Gastrulation in birds: a model system for the study of animal morphogenesis

Emergence of a left-right symmetric body plan in vertebrate embryos

External bilateral symmetry is a prevalent feature in vertebrates, which emerges during early embryonic development. To begin with, vertebrate embryos are largely radially symmetric before transitioning to bilaterally symmetry, after which, morphogenesis of various bilateral tissues (e.g somites, otic vesicle, limb bud), and structures (e.g palate, jaw) ensue. While a significant amount of work has probed the mechanisms behind symmetry breaking in the left-right axis leading to asymmetric positioning of internal organs, little is known about how bilateral tissues emerge at the same time with the same shape and size and at the same position on the two sides of the embryo. By discussing emergence of symmetry in many bilateral tissues and structures across vertebrate model systems, we highlight that understanding symmetry establishment is largely an open field, which will provide deep insights into fundamental problems in developmental biology for decades to come.

Reduced heart rate and cardiac output differentially affect angiogenesis, growth, and development in early chicken embryos (Gallus domesticus)

An increase in both vascular circumferential tension and shear stress in the developing vasculature of the chicken embryo has been hypothesized to stimulate angiogenesis in the developing peripheral circulation chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). To test this hypothesis, angiogenesis in the CAM, development, and growth were measured in the early chicken embryo, following acute and chronic topical application of the purely bradycardic drug ZD7288. At hour 56, ZD7288 reduced heart rate (f(H)) by ~30% but had no significant effect on stroke volume (~0.19 ± 0.2 μL), collectively resulting in a significant fall in cardiac output (CO) from ~27 ± 3 to 18 ± 2 μL min(-1). Mean f(H) at 72 h of development was similarly significantly lowered by acute ZD7288 treatment (250 μM) to 128 ± 0.3 beats min(-1), compared with 174.5 ± 0.3 and 174.7 ± 0.8 beats min(-1) in control and Pannett-Compton (P-C) saline-treated embryos, respectively. Chronic dosing with ZD7288-and the attendant decreases in f(H) and CO-did not change eye diameter or cervical flexion (key indicators of development rate) at 120 h but significantly reduced overall growth (wet and dry body mass decreased by 20%). CAM vessel density index (reflecting angiogenesis) measured 200-400 μm from the umbilical stalk was not altered, but ZD7288 reduced vessel numbers-and therefore vessel density-by 13%-16% more distally (500-600 μm from umbilical stalk) in the CAM. In the ZD7288-treated embryos, a decrease in vessel length was found within the second branch order (~300-400 μm from the umbilical stock), while a decrease in vessel diameter was found closer to the umbilical stock, beginning in the first branch order (~200-300 μm). Paradoxically, chronic application of P-C saline also reduced peripheral CAM vessel density index at 500 and 600 μm by 13% and 7%, respectively, likely from washout of local angiogenic factors. In summary, decreased f(H) with reduced CO did not slow development rate but reduced embryonic growth rate and angiogenesis in the CAM periphery. This study demonstrates for the first time that different processes in the ontogeny of the early vertebrate embryo (i.e., hypertrophic growth vs. development) have differential sensitivities to altered convective blood flow.

Symmetry breaking and convergent extension in early chordate development

The initiation of axis, polarity, cell differentiation, and gastrulation in the very early chordate development is due to the breaking of radial symmetry. It is believed that this occurs by an external signal. We suggest instead spontaneous symmetry breaking through the agency of the Turing-Child field. Increased size or decreased diffusivity, both brought about by mitotic activity, cause the spontaneous loss of stability of the homogeneous state and the evolution of the metabolic pattern during development. The polar metabolic pattern is the cause of polar gene expression, polar morphogenesis (gastrulation), and polar mitotic activity. The Turing-Child theory explains not only the spontaneous formation of the invagination in gastrulation but also the coherent cell movement observed in convergence and extension during gastrulation and neurulation. The theory is demonstrated with respect to experimental observations on the early development of fish, amphibian, and the chick. The theory can explain a multitude of experimental details. For example, it explains the splayed polar progression of reduction in the fish blastoderm. Reduction starts on that side of the blastoderm margin, which will initiate invagination several hours later. It progresses toward the blastoderm center and somewhat laterally from this future "dorsal lip". This is precisely as predicted by a Turing-Child system in a circle. And for a fish like zebrafish with a blastoderm that is slightly oval, reduction is observed to progress along the long axis of the ellipse, which is what Turing-Child theory predicts. In general the shape and the chemical nature of the experimental patterns are the same as predicted by the Turing couple (cAMP, ATP). Embryological polarity and convergent extension are based on polar eigenfunction and saddle-shaped eigenfunction, respectively.

Morphological and molecular analysis of the early developing chick requires an expanded series of primitive streak stages

A detailed analysis of the gastrulating chick embryo was performed using three methods : time-lapse videotaping of embryos in culture, histological semithin sections, and in situ hybridization with 10 mRNA signals expressed during gastrulation. The results suggest that the gene expression pattern of Goosecoid, Hex, Crescent, and Bmp7 may be involved in the axial establishment of the temporal and spatial arrangement of cells forming the prechordal plate endoderm, and that Chordin, cNot1, Noggin, and Brachyury are precocious markers of cells coming from Hensen's node, which contribute to the rostralmost tip of the notochord, its arrowhead, the head process, and, later, the elongating notochord. These results explain several earlier descriptions based only on morphological analyses of the axial mesodermal structures characteristic of the gastrulation stages. The data, carefully observed and compared with the whole-mount observation in time-lapse video, show that the changes in cell populations, movements, and cell differentiation occur step-by-step over a precise temporal range, which requires the establishment of a subdivision of the stages usually employed. Knowledge of new aspects of avian gastrulation, including gene expression patterns, immunocytochemical analyses, and the great number of recent experiments based on microinjections or transplants of groups of cells to analyze processes of induction or regulation, need the support of a precisely defined scheme of primitive streak stages (PS-stages), and a correlation of these stages with other approaches to provide a finer resolution of the staging steps, and thus to facilitate a better understanding of the initial gastrulation period.

Dynamic imaging of cell, extracellular matrix, and tissue movements during avian vertebral axis patterning

Vertebrate axis patterning depends on cell and extracellular matrix (ECM) repositioning and proper cell-ECM interactions. However, there are few in vivo data addressing how large-scale tissue deformations are coordinated with the motion of local cell ensembles or the displacement of ECM constituents. Combining the methods of dynamic imaging and experimental biology allows both cell and ECM fate-mapping to be correlated with ongoing tissue deformations. These fate-mapping studies suggest that the axial ECM components "move" both as a composite meshwork and as autonomous particles, depending on the length scale being examined. Cells are also part of this composite, and subject to passive displacements resulting from tissue deformations. However, in contrast to the ECM, cells are self-propelled. The net result of cell and ECM displacements, along with proper ECM-cell adhesion, is the assembly of new tissue architecture. Data herein show that disruption of normal cell-ECM interactions during axis formation results in developmental abnormalities and a disorganization of the ECM. Our goal in characterizing the global displacement patterns of axial cells and ECM is to provide critical information regarding existing strain fields in the segmental plate and paraxial mesoderm. Deducing the mechanical influences on cell behavior is critical, if we are to understand vertebral axis patterning. Supplementary material for this article is available online at http://www.mrw.interscience.wiley.com/suppmat/1542-975X/suppmat/72/v72.266.html.

Extracellular matrix dynamics during vertebrate axis formation

The first evidence for the dynamics of in vivo extracellular matrix (ECM) pattern formation during embryogenesis is presented below. Fibrillin 2 filaments were tracked for 12 h throughout the avian intraembryonic mesoderm using automated light microscopy and algorithms of our design. The data show that these ECM filaments have a reproducible morphogenic destiny that is characterized by directed transport. Fibrillin 2 particles initially deposited in the segmental plate mesoderm are translocated along an unexpected trajectory where they eventually polymerize into an intricate scaffold of cables parallel to the anterior-posterior axis. The cables coalesce near the midline before the appearance of the next-formed somite. Moreover, the ECM filaments define global tissue movements with high precision because the filaments act as passive motion tracers. Quantification of individual and collective filament "behaviors" establish fate maps, trajectories, and velocities. These data reveal a caudally propagating traveling wave pattern in the morphogenetic movements of early axis formation. We conjecture that within vertebrate embryos, long-range mechanical tension fields are coupled to both large-scale patterning and local organization of the ECM. Thus, physical forces or stress fields are essential requirements for executing an emergent developmental pattern-in this case, paraxial fibrillin cable assembly.

Induction and patterning of the primitive streak, an organizing center of gastrulation in the amniote

The primitive streak is the organizing center for amniote gastrulation. It defines the future embryonic midline and serves as a conduit of cell migration for germ layer formation. The migration patterns of endodermal and mesodermal precursors through the streak have been studied in great detail. Additional new breakthroughs recently have revealed the cell biological and molecular mechanisms that govern streak induction and patterning. These findings include (1) identification of the ontogeny and inductive signals of streak precursors, (2) the potential cellular mechanism of streak extension, and (3) the molecular and functional diversification along the anterior-posterior and mediolateral axes within the primitive streak. These findings indicate that amniote embryos initiate gastrulation by using both evolutionarily conserved and divergent mechanisms. The data also provide a foundation for understanding how the midline axis is defined and maintained during gastrulation of the amniotes.

Cell populations and morphogenetic movements underlying formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer

The cell populations and morphogenetic movements that contribute to the formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer-Hensen's node-are poorly understood. We labeled selected groups of cells with fluorescent dyes and then followed them over time during formation and progression of the primitive streak and formation of Hensen's node. We show that (1) the primitive streak arises from a localized population of epiblast cells spanning the caudal midline of Koller's sickle, with the mid-dorsal cells of the primitive streak arising from the midline of the epiblast overlying Koller's sickle and the deeper and more lateral primitive streak cells arising more laterally within the epiblast overlying the sickle, from an arch subtending about 30 degrees; (2) convergent extension movements of cells in the epiblast overlying Koller's sickle contribute to formation of the initial primitive streak; and (3) Hensen's node is derived from a mixture of cells originating both from the epiblast just rostral to the incipient (stage 2) primitive streak and later from the epiblast just rostral to the elongating (stage 3a/b) primitive streak, as well as from the rostral tip of the progressing streak itself. Collectively, these results provide new information on the formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer, increasing our understanding of these important events of early development of amniotes.

New insights into critical events of avian gastrulation

The formation and progression of the primitive streak are key events of avian gastrulation. We examine these processes in detail, using various morphological approaches. We show that formation of the primitive streak occurs locally at the caudal midline of the area pellucida, as cells in the caudal midline undergo an epithelial-to-mesenchymal transformation, and that extensive migration of delaminated cells arising from more rostral or peripheral areas of the blastoderm is not involved in streak formation. Instead, such delamination occurs earlier and is restricted to the process of hypoblast formation. Moreover, we provide evidence that progression of the primitive streak involves two processes: convergent-extension movements within the streak per se, and progressive delamination of midline epiblast cells in a caudal-to-rostral sequence. We have identified a subpopulation of primitive-streak cells located at its dorsal midline surface that undergoes extensive rostral displacement concomitant with streak progression. The fact that these cells are located only dorsally and do not elongate ventrally as do adjacent ingressing cells, suggests that these cells retain their residency within the primitive streak, at least until regression of the primitive streak occurs. Finally, by following labeled cells over time we establish the timing of movement of epiblast cells toward and into the primitive streak, providing direct evidence that cell-cell intercalation occurs within the primitive streak during its progression. Collectively, our results provide new insight into complex and central events of avian gastrulation.

Regulation of epiblast cell movements by chondroitin sulfate during gastrulation in the chick

Avian gastrulation is dependent on the ingression of outer layer cells into the interior of the embryo by means of a transient structure referred to as the primitive streak. As the growing streak progresses through the central area pellucida of the blastoderm, selective de-epithelialization of epiblast cells results in the initial migratory cells of the primitive mesoderm and endoderm. Here, we have examined the possibility that extracellular matrix molecules of the epiblast basal lamina influence the selection of streak-specific epiblast cells. By using whole embryo culture, we have found that removal of chondroitin sulfate glycosaminoglycans at gastrulation stages leads to defective streak formation. In situ hybridization with streak-specific markers in these embryos reveals ectopic patterns of gene expression, suggesting that differentiation of primitive streak precursors in the pregastrula epiblast is independent of normal streak morphogenesis. In addition, in vitro assays with chondroitin sulfate containing matrices suggest that specific cells of the epiblast are inhibited from joining the streak during gastrulation. Taken together, these results indicate that the presence of chondroitin sulfate in the epiblast basal lamina facilitates the allocation of cells to the primary germ layers by preventing ectopic axis formation.

Getting organized: new insights into the organizer of higher vertebrates

The Organizer of higher vertebrates (e.g., Hensen's node in birds and the node in mammals) functions much like the Organizer of lower vertebrates (e.g., embryonic shield in fish and dorsal lip of the blastopore in amphibians). In all classes of vertebrates, the Organizer displays a number of unique properties including the fate, migratory patterns, morphogenetic movements, and the level of commitment of its cells; its pattern of gene expression; its ability to induce neural differentiation; and its ability to organize and regionalize a secondary embryo when grafted ectopically. The importance of Organizer activity to formation of the neuraxis is highlighted by results from studies in which the Organizer is eliminated experimentally. Such studies demonstrate that an auxiliary system is present that can generate a reconstituted Organizer, which completely mimics the activity of the original Organizer. For almost 50 years after the discovery of Spemann's Organizer, the molecular nature of Organizer activity was virtually unknown. However, recent progress in identifying the morphoregulatory molecules underlying Organizer activity has been substantial, and a full understanding of the molecular basis of this activity is imminent. Thus, the intriguing question of how the Organizer organizes, raised by the seminal experiments of Spemann and Mangold, is finally being answered in this exciting renaissance of developmental biology driven by new molecular and genetic approaches.

Hypoblast cells of chick pre-streak stage embryos invaded basement membrane analogues in vitro: implications for hypoblast layer formation

In early chick blastodermal morphogenesis, the hypoblast layer is organized beneath the epiblast and induces an axial structure. However, the origin of hypoblast cells and the mechanism of hypoblast layer formation are poorly understood. We hypothesized that the hypoblast layer is formed by an invasive process across the basement membrane of the juxtaposing epiblast, and tested the idea in vitro. Primary and secondary hypoblast cells from embryos at various pre-streak stages were dissociated into single cells and cultured on reconstituted basement membrane gel, laminin gel or fibronectin gel in the culture medium with or without serum for 24-48 h. As a result, we found that after 24h of serum-supplemented culture, up to 35% of the hypoblast cells dissolved the gel and made holes on it. Similarly, up to 36% of the hypoblast cells showed invasiveness after 48 h in the serum-free culture. Furthermore, it was observed that Koller's sickle cells, which are regarded to be the progenitors of secondary hypoblast cells, penetrated those gels on which they were seeded. The posterior epiblast cells covering Koller's sickle were also invasive. These results suggest that the presumptive primary hypoblast cells that are known to mingle with epiblast cells invade through the basement membrane to form the hypoblast layer. Furthermore, the present results imply that invasion through the basement membrane may be involved in the formation of Koller's sickle, the anlage of secondary hypoblast.

Cloning and characterization of chicken Paraxis: a regulator of paraxial mesoderm development and somite formation

To investigate the molecular regulation of embryonic somite formation and development, we have cloned the full-length cDNA and characterized the embryonic expression profile of chicken Paraxis, a member of a novel family of basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) proteins, which has been suggested to play a role in paraxial mesoderm development. Chicken Paraxis encodes a 1.35-kb mRNA and contains a 53-amino-acid residue bHLH domain, identical in sequence to that found in the mammalian Paraxis genes of mouse, hamster, and human. Northern analysis revealed significant Paraxis expression in the early embryo up to the 30- to 35-somite stage, declining from Incubation Day 4 on and becoming undetectable by Day 5. By whole-mount in situ hybridization, Paraxis expression is first seen distinctly in the emerging paraxial mesoderm of the primitive streak stage chick embryo. During gastrulation, Paraxis expression in the mesoderm defines bilaterally symmetric crescents located immediately rostral to Hensen's node and appears to pre-configure the emerging somitic mesoderm. During somite development, Paraxis expression is evident in the rostral segmental plate and the newly formed somites, although the level of expression clearly decreases in the more mature somites. By the 10-12th pair of somites, counting from the caudal end, Paraxis expression appears to be preferentially localized to the medial aspect of individual somites. Histological analysis showed that Paraxis expression is evenly distributed in the newly formed caudal epithelial somites, then localized to the medial portion of maturing somites, and preferentially localized in the dermomyotome of more rostral somites before diminishing to undetectable levels in the most cranial somites. The functional involvement of Paraxis in somite development was assessed by perturbing its expression in somitic stage chick embryos using a Paraxis-specific antisense oligonucleotide. Disruption of somite formation from the paraxial mesoderm was observed in 67% of the surviving topically treated embryos, whereas control embryos treated with sense or random sequence oligonucleotides did not show similar effects. In addition, direct injection of Paraxis-specific antisense oligonucleotide into the paraxial mesoderm produced discrete segmentation anomalies which correlated spatially with the site of injection. Whole-mount in situ hybridization revealed that the regions defective in somite formation displayed perturbed Paraxis expression and a reduction of Pax-1 expression, a marker for epithelial somites and sclerotome. Histological analysis indicated poor condensation and/or epithelization of the somitic mesoderm. Finally, embryos treated with valproic acid, a known teratogen which affects somite segmentation, showed perturbed Paraxis expression, suggesting that the mechanism of action of this teratogen involves a pathway(s) requiring Paraxis activity. These data provide evidence that Paraxis acts as an important regulator of paraxial mesoderm and somite development and functions in axial patterning of the chick embryo.

Fates and migratory routes of primitive streak cells in the chick embryo

We have used carbocyanine dyes to fate map the primitive streak in the early chick embryo, from stages 3+ (mid-primitive streak) to 9 (8 somites). We show that presumptive notochord, foregut and medial somite do not originate solely from Hensen's node, but also from the anterior primitive streak. At early stages (4- and 4), there is no correlation between specific anteroposterior levels of the primitive streak and the final position of their descendants in the notochord. We describe in detail the contribution of specific levels of the primitive streak to the medial and lateral halves of the somites. To understand how the descendants of labelled cells reach their destinations in different tissues, we have followed the movement of labelled cells during their emigration from the primitive streak in living embryos, and find that cells destined to different structures follow defined pathways of movement, even if they arise from similar positions in the streak. Somite and notochord precursors migrate anteriorly within the streak and pass through different portions of the node; this provides an explanation for the segregation of notochord and somite territories in the node.

Features of polyingression and primitive streak ingression through the basal lamina in the chicken blastoderm

The de-epithelialization of cells of the upper layer during the phenomena of polyingression and primitive streak ingression was studied by analyzing, from the time of laying to the end of gastrulation, the ultrastructure of the basal lamina underlying the upper layer. The electron density of the basal lamina and associated extracellular materials was enhanced by addition of tannic acid to the fixative. Special attention was also paid to the spatial and temporal distribution of blebs at the basal surface of the upper layer, and to the contribution of the de-epithelialized cells to the formation of the deep layer. The results indicate that a nascent basal lamina is already present at the time of laying, especially beneath regions of the area pellucida where polyingression is not apparent. From the onset of incubation, the basal lamina rapidly develops, and it is interrupted by a large number of blebs. However, during the first 6-8 h of incubation, i.e., stages 1-2 of Vakaet (Arch. Biol. (Liège) 81:387-426, 1970), a downward movement of de-epithelialized cells that insert into the deep layer and form the endophyll persists cranially. This phenomenon of polyingression, which starts during the intrauterine period, probably extends from caudal to cranial and comes to an end by stage 3. During these first three stages, the number of blebs progressively decreases, especially in the cranial part of the area pellucida, and a thicker, continuous basal lamina associated with numerous interstitial bodies is laid down. The caudal part of the upper layer is still actively blebbing at that time. Due to the convergence of this area toward the axis of the blastoderm, which leads to ingression at and elongation of the primitive streak up to and including stage 6, the number of blebs at the basal surface of the upper layer progressively decreases. From stage 7 on, blebs are virtually absent; shortening of the primitive streak and formation of the head process begin. At the level of the head process, primitive streak ingression has ceased and a novel basal lamina is progressively deposited beneath the upper layer. By stage 9, a thick, smooth basal lamina physically separates the upper layer from the head mesenchyme. Summarizing, at the time of gastrulation, the presence of blebs that perforate the basal lamina is correlated with the de-epithelialization of cells. Before incubation, however, de-epithelialization of upper-layer cells occurs before the assembly of the basal lamina.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Non-invasive monitoring of ionic current flow during development by SQUID magnetometry

The ionic currents flowing in developing organisms produce weak magnetic fields that can be detected using SQUID magnetometers. The method is non-invasive and dc recording is possible. To date SQUID magnetometers have mainly been used in human studies. The features of the technique are described and the prospects of extending its use to developmental studies are discussed. Feasible instrumental specifications are indicated. A recent SQUID magnetometer investigation of ionic current flow in the developing chick in ovo is summarised as an illustration of the magnetometer method. The paper as a whole argues that magnetometry is a useful alternative or adjunct to electrode-based experiments on the electrophysiology of developing organisms.