Compliance with Asthma Therapy

Improving patient compliance with asthma therapy

Patients fail to comply with asthma medication for a variety of reasons. These range from physical inability to use an inhaler, through simple forgetfulness, to a conscious decision not to use medication as prescribed due to internal or cultural health beliefs or socioeconomic factors. In some patients, poor self-care because of deep-rooted psychological factors (i.e. factors of which patients have only limited awareness) can affect compliance. Poor doctor-patient communication can be the cause in many other individuals. Thus, there is no single solution that will improve compliance in all patients. Simplifying the regimen or providing memory aids will be sufficient for some patients, while education or psychological counselling will be more appropriate for others. Doctors can also use a range of communication skills to improve the way in which they present information, motivate patients and reinforce progress. These approaches, plus respect for patients' health beliefs and involving them in treatment decisions, can help foster an atmosphere of mutual responsibility and concordance over medicine taking.

Psychological factors associated with medication nonadherence in asthmatic children

Adherence with inhaled beta-agonists and corticosteroids in 24 asthmatic children was tracked over 3 months utilizing the metered-dose inhaler chronolog (MDIC). Patients seldom took all of their medications as prescribed, and failed to take any inhaled corticosteroid doses on a median of 41.8% of days or inhaled beta-agonists on 28.1% of days despite prescribed daily use. Medication nonadherence was correlated with lower levels of asthma knowledge (Asthma Knowledge Questionnaire) and family dysfunction (Family Assessment Device), but not child behavior disorder (Child Behavior Checklist). Patients tended to dramatically over-report medication use. Improved identification of the markers of nonadherence can directly facilitate more efficient targeting of behavioral interventions, resulting in improved adherence, better illness control, and less requirement of urgent medication intervention.

Nonadherence in asthmatic patients: is there a solution to the problem?

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

Reading this article will reinforce the reader's awareness of the relationship between adherence and treatment outcome, of the causes of nonadherence, of methods of measurement, and of steps toward successful intervention.

DATA SOURCES

Articles on adherence to asthma therapy were reviewed. A MEDLINE database using subject keywords was searched from 1990 through 1997.

STUDY SELECTION

Pertinent articles were chosen, with preferential presentation of results from controlled studies.

RESULTS

There is no evidence of recent improvement in the rates of nonadherence, and patients continue on average to take about 50% of prescribed medication. Nonadherence assessment is most accurate when it can be measured objectively, and relies neither on patient report nor physician estimate. The consequences of nonadherence are measured in patient suffering, financial cost, and serious compromise of clinical trial outcomes. Underlying causes of nonadherence are traced to characteristics of the disease, treatment, patient, and caregiver system.

CONCLUSION

Improved adherence will lead to improved disease control, but only if medical care systems encourage and support the allocation of sufficient resources to allow barriers to self-management to be discussed and solutions negotiated. Attempts to improve adherence outside of the caregiver-patient relationship are less likely to succeed. Special programs for difficult-to-manage patients are necessary to change behavior, although significant illness improvement and cost savings are likely to result.