Genetic studies of B-lymphocyte deficiency and mastocytosis in strain A/WySnJ mice

Altered BAFF-receptor signaling and additional modifier loci contribute to systemic autoimmunity in A/WySnJ mice

Systemic lupus erythematosus pathology reflects autoantibody-mediated damage due to a failure of B-lymphocyte tolerance. We previously reported that B-lymphopenic A/WySnJ mice develop a lupus-like syndrome and linked this syndrome to the B-cell maturation defect-1 (Bcmd-1) mutant allele of the B-cell-activating factor belonging to the TNF family-receptor (Baffr) gene. Here, we further evaluate the genetic basis for autoimmunity in A/WySnJ mice. We produced B6.Bcmd-1 and AW.Baffr(-/-) congenic mice (N5), and compared them with B6.Baffr(-/-) and A/WySnJ mice with respect to B-lymphocyte development. Bcmd-1-expressing mice had more B cells with greater maturity than Baffr(-/-) mice regardless of genetic background, indicating that Bcmd-1 encodes a partially functional BAFF-R. We also compared these mice for lupus phenotypes to determine whether Bcmd-1 is necessary and sufficient for disease, or whether the Baffr(-/-) (-) allele can also cause autoimmunity. The Baffr(-/-) allele did not lead to autoimmunity on either genetic background. In contrast, the Bcmd-1 allele was necessary and sufficient for development of low levels of IgM autoantibodies in B6.Bcmd-1 mice. However, Bcmd-1 plus unidentified A/WySnJ modifier genes were necessary for development of IgG autoantibodies and renal pathology. We propose that in A/WySnJ mice an excess of BAFF per B cell rescues self-reactive B cells through a partially functional BAFF-R in a B-lymphopenic environment.

Systemic autoimmunity in BAFF-R-mutant A/WySnJ strain mice

Systemic lupus erythematosis is an autoimmune disease of unknown etiology. Lupus pathology is thought to reflect autoantibody-mediated damage due to a failure of B lymphocyte tolerance. Since excessive B cell-activating factor belonging to the TNF family (BAFF) expression correlates with human and murine lupus, and BAFF signals B cell survival through BAFF-R, it is believed that excessive BAFF-R signaling can subvert B cell tolerance and facilitate lupus development. Here we report the unexpected finding that BAFF-R-mutant A/WySnJ mice develop a lupus-like syndrome. These mice carry the B cell maturation defect-1 (Bcmd-1) mutant allele of the Baffr gene. Bcmd-1 causes premature B cell death and profound B cell deficiency. Despite having 90% fewer splenic B cells than normal mice, A/WySnJ mice had an 18-fold increased frequency of splenocytes secreting IgM antibodies to dsDNA, and increased amounts of circulating IgM and IgG to dsDNA by 9 months of age. By age 11 months, most A/WySnJ mice displayed renal pathology characteristic of lupus, including proteinuria as well as periodic acid-Schiff-positive deposits and glomerular capillary bed destruction. Importantly, we genetically linked this autoimmunity to Bcmd-1, since congenic AW.Baffr(+/+) mice carrying a wild-type allele developed none of these phenotypes. Our data provide the first evidence linking altered BAFF-R signaling to the development of B cell-mediated autoimmunity.

Regulation of constitutive p50/c-Rel activity via proteasome inhibitor-resistant IkappaBalpha degradation in B cells

Constitutive NF-kappaB activity has emerged as an important cell survival component of physiological and pathological processes, including B-cell development. In B cells, constitutive NF-kappaB activity includes p50/c-Rel and p52/RelB heterodimers, both of which are critical for proper B-cell development. We previously reported that WEHI-231 B cells maintain constitutive p50/c-Rel activity via selective degradation of IkappaBalpha that is mediated by a proteasome inhibitor-resistant, now termed PIR, pathway. Here, we examined the mechanisms of PIR degradation by comparing it to the canonical pathway that involves IkappaB kinase-dependent phosphorylation and beta-TrCP-dependent ubiquitylation of the N-terminal signal response domain of IkappaBalpha. We found a distinct consensus sequence within this domain of IkappaBalpha for PIR degradation. Chimeric analyses of IkappaBalpha and IkappaBbeta further revealed that the ankyrin repeats of IkappaBalpha, but not IkappaBbeta, contained information necessary for PIR degradation, thereby explaining IkappaBalpha selectivity for the PIR pathway. Moreover, we found that PIR degradation of IkappaBalpha and constitutive p50/c-Rel activity in primary murine B cells were maintained in a manner different from B-cell-activating-factor-dependent p52/RelB regulation. Thus, our findings suggest that nonconventional PIR degradation of IkappaBalpha may play a physiological role in the development of B cells in vivo.

Peripheral B-cell maturation: the intersection of selection and homeostasis

B cells complete maturation after migrating to the periphery, where they transit several intermediate developmental stages prior to recruitment into the long-lived primary pool. Because B-lineage commitment is not regulated by peripheral pool size and most peripheral B cells are quiescent, the primary factors governing steady-state numbers are the proportion of immature B cells surviving transit through later developmental stages and the longevity of mature B cells themselves. Substantial evidence indicates that the B-cell receptor (BCR) plays an essential role in all these processes, but recent findings suggest a central role for the recently described tumor necrosis factor (TNF) family member, B-lymphocyte stimulator (BLyS). Signaling through one of the BLyS receptors, BLyS receptor 3 (BR3), controls B-cell numbers in two ways: by varying the proportion of cells that complete transitional B-cell development and by serving as the primary determinant of mature B-cell longevity. The recent discovery that BCR signaling is selectively coupled to BR3 expression in a developmentally regulated fashion links BCR- and BLyS-mediated events, suggesting that specificity-based selection and survival may be mechanistically similar processes.

DeltaBAFF, an alternate splice isoform that regulates receptor binding and biopresentation of the B cell survival cytokine, BAFF

The tumor necrosis family member BAFF is limiting for the survival of follicular B lymphocytes, but excessive BAFF signaling can lead to autoimmunity, suggesting that its activity must be tightly regulated. We have identified a conserved alternate splice isoform of BAFF, called deltaBAFF, which lacks 57 nt encoding the A-A1 loop and is co-expressed with BAFF in many mouse and human myeloid cells. Mouse deltaBAFF appears on the plasma membrane, but unlike BAFF it is inefficiently released by proteolysis. DeltaBAFF can associate with BAFF in heteromultimers and diminish BAFF bioactivity and release. Thus, alternative splicing of the BAFF gene suppresses BAFF B cell stimulatory function in several ways, and deltaBAFF may promote other functions as well.

Enforced bcl-xL gene expression restored splenic B lymphocyte development in BAFF-R mutant mice

The TNFR family member BAFF-R facilitates peripheral B cell development, although it is unclear whether it promotes survival of B cells, or also initiates a differentiation program. We show that disruption of the BAFF-R encoding gene Tnfrsf13c in strain A/WySnJ mice causes a progressive decline in peripheral B cell numbers, beginning at the transitional 1 developmental stage and continuing through the mature peripheral B cell stage. Bcl-x(L) overexpression in A/WySnJ B cells decreased the turnover of transitional B cells, as determined by 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine labeling, and restored follicular B cell development. We conclude that the mutant A/WySnJ allele of Tnfrsf13c can be complemented through the survival signal provided by Bcl-x(L).

Cutting edge: A/WySnJ transitional B cells overexpress the chromosome 15 proapoptotic Blk gene and succumb to premature apoptosis

Better knowledge of peripheral B lymphocyte homeostasis is needed to address the human hypogammaglobulinemia diseases. A defect in the Bcmd gene shortens the B cell life span and causes B cell deficiency in A/WySnJ mice. Previous genetic mapping placed Bcmd near Srebf2 on chromosome 15. Inspection of the human chromosome 22 syntenic region identified the proapoptotic Bik gene as a candidate. Two mapping methods placed the homologous mouse gene, Blk, near Srebf2. The Blk genomic structure was highly homologous to BIK: Sequence analysis ruled out coding region mutations, but Blk transcripts were overly abundant in sorted A/WySnJ T1 B cells. Moreover, enriched transitional B cells showed a cell-autonomous defect leading to excessive apoptosis. Thus, Bcmd may be a direct mutation in Blk, or in a gene involved in Blk regulation, such that excess expression pushes the A/WySnJ transitional B cells past the apoptosis checkpoint to cell death.