Hypertension risk in idiopathic hyperCKemia

Extracellular creatine kinase may modulate purinergic signalling

Extracellular purine nucleotides and nucleosides including ADP and ATP regulate a wide array of physiological processes including platelet aggregation, vasomotor responses and inflammation through specific purinergic receptors. In the recent years, a strong association has been reported between circulating cytoplasmic-type creatine kinase and adverse clinical outcomes such as major bleeding, hypertension and obesity. Therefore, it is proposed that extracellular CK may modulate purinergic signalling through its ADP binding and/or ATP-generating effect.

CK (Creatine Kinase) Is Associated With Cardiovascular Hemodynamics: The HELIUS Study

The ATP-regenerating enzyme CK (creatine kinase) is strongly associated with blood pressure, which lowers upon experimental CK inhibition. The enzyme is thought to affect cardiovascular hemodynamics through enhanced systemic vascular resistance, stroke volume, and cardiac contractility, but data on these parameters are lacking. We hereby report hemodynamics by CK levels in the multiethnic, cross-sectional HELIUS study (Healthy Life in an Urban Setting). Physical examination included sitting brachial blood pressure and noninvasively assessed supine systemic vascular resistance, stroke volume, cardiac output, and cardiac contractility, which we associated with resting plasma CK. Data from 14 937 men and women (mean age, 43.3; SD, 12.9) indicated that per log CK increase, blood pressure increased with 20.2 (18.9-21.4) mm Hg systolic/13.0 (12.2-13.7) diastolic, an odds ratio for hypertension of 6.1 (5.1-7.2). Outcomes were similar by sex, body mass index, and ancestry, although higher blood pressures in men, with overweight/obesity, and West-African ancestry were partially explained by higher CK, with an adjusted increase in systolic/diastolic pressure of 10.5 (10.0-10.9)/6.4 (6.0-6.7) mm Hg per log CK increase. Systemic vascular resistance, stroke volume, cardiac output, and cardiac contractility (n=7876), increased by respectively 20%, 39%, 14%, and 23% SD per log CK increase. This study indicates that the association of CK with blood pressure likely results from an increase in systemic vascular resistance and stroke volume. These data expand the knowledge on the nature of hypertension associated with CK and may inform further experiments on CK inhibition as a means to lower blood pressure.

Significance of Asymptomatic Hyper Creatine-Kinase Emia

OBJECTIVES

Whether asymptomatic hyper-CKemia (AHCE) should prompt a thorough work-up for muscle disease or not is controversially discussed. This review aims at summarizing and discussing recent findings concerning the cause, frequency, evolution, and work-up of conditions manifesting as AHCE and normal or abnormal electromyography (EMG) respectively muscle biopsy.

METHODS

Systematic PubMed search.

RESULTS

There are numerous primary (hereditary) and acquired myopathies that manifest with permanent, recurrent, or temporary AHCE with/without myopathic EMG or muscle biopsy. AHCE particularly occurs at onset of these conditions, which include dystrophinopathies, myotilinopathies, calpainopathy, caveolinopathy, dysferlinopathy, central core disease, multicore disease, desminopathy, MD1, MD2, hypoPP, malignant hyperthermia susceptibility, Pompe disease, McArdle disease, myoadenylate deaminase-deficiency, CPT2-deficiency, mitochondrial disorders, or myopathy with tubular aggregates. Most likely, other primary myopathies manifest with AHCE as well, without having been reported. Patients with AHCE should be taken seriously and repeated CK determination must be conducted. If hyper-CKemia is persisting or recurrent, these patients should undergo an EMG and eventually muscle biopsy. If noninformative, genetic work-up by a panel or whole exome sequencing should be initiated, irrespective of the family history. Patients with AHCE should avoid excessive exercise, require sufficient hydration, require counseling with regard to the risk of malignant hyperthermia, and should inform anesthesiologists and surgeons about their condition before elective surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Recurrent AHCE should be taken seriously and managed with conventional work-up. If noninformative, genetic work-up should follow irrespective of the family history.

Creatine Kinase and Blood Pressure: A Systematic Review

Background: Hypertension is a main risk factor for premature death. Although blood pressure is a complex trait, we have shown that the activity of the ATP-generating enzyme creatine kinase (CK) is a significant predictor of blood pressure and of failure of antihypertensive drug therapy in the general population. In this report, we systematically review the evidence on the association between this new risk factor CK and blood pressure outcomes. Method: We used a narrative synthesis approach and conducted a systematic search to include studies on non-pregnant adult humans that address the association between plasma CK and blood pressure outcomes. We searched electronic databases and performed a hand search without language restriction. We extracted data in duplo. The main outcome was the association between CK and blood pressure as continuous measures. Other outcomes included the association between CK and blood pressure categories (normotension and hypertension, subdivided in treated controlled, treated uncontrolled, and untreated hypertension). Results: We retrieved 139 reports and included 11 papers from 10 studies assessing CK in 34,578 participants, men and women, of African, Asian, and European ancestry, aged 18 to 87 years. In 9 reports, CK was associated with blood pressure levels, hypertension (vs. normotension), and/or treatment failure. The adjusted increase in systolic blood pressure (mmHg/log CK increase) was reported between 3.3 [1.4 to 5.2] and 8.0 [3.3 to 12.7] and the odds ratio of hypertension with high vs. low CK ranged between 1.2 and 3.9. In addition, CK was a strong predictor of treatment failure in the general population, with an adjusted odds ratio of 3.7 [1.2 to 10.9]. Discussion: This systematic review largely confirms earlier reports that CK is associated with blood pressure and failure of antihypertensive therapy. Further work is needed to address whether this new risk factor is useful in clinical medicine.

Creatine kinase, energy reserve, and hypertension: from bench to bedside

We hypothesized that human variation in the activity of the ATP regenerating enzyme creatine kinase (CK) activity affects hypertension and cardiovascular disease risk. CK is tightly bound close to ATP-utilizing enzymes including Ca2+-ATPase, myosin ATPase, and Na+/K+-ATPase, where it rapidly regenerates ATP from ADP, H+, and phosphocreatine. Thus, relatively high CK was thought to enhance ATP-demanding processes including resistance artery contractility and sodium retention, and reduce ADP-dependent functions. In a series of studies of our group and others, CK was linked to hypertension and bleeding risk. Plasma CK after rest, used as a surrogate measure for tissue CK, was associated with high blood pressure and failure of antihypertensive therapy in case-control and population studies. Importantly, high tissue CK preceded hypertension in animal models and in humans, and human vascular tissue CK gene expression was strongly associated with clinical blood pressure. In line with this, CK inhibition substantially reduced the contractility of human resistance arteries ex vivo. We also presented evidence that plasma CK reduced ADP-dependent platelet aggregation. In subsequent intervention studies, the oral competitive CK inhibitor beta-guanidinopropionic acid (GPA) reduced blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHRs), and a 1-week trial of sub-therapeutic dose GPA in healthy men was uneventful. Thus, based on theoretical concepts, evidence was gathered in laboratory, case-control, and population studies that high CK is associated with hypertension and with bleeding risk, potentially leading to a new mode of cardiovascular risk reduction with CK inhibition.

CKM Glu83Gly Is Associated With Blunted Creatine Kinase Variation, but Not With Myalgia

BACKGROUND

To test the association of a recently reported variant in the creatine kinase (CK) muscle gene, CKM Glu83Gly (rs11559024) with constitutive creatine phosphokinase (CK) levels, CK variation, and inducibility. Given the diagnostic importance of CK in determining muscle damage, we tested the association of the variant with myalgia.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Meta-analysis between longitudinal cohort GoDARTS (Genetics of Diabetes Audit and Research, Tayside Scotland), minor allele frequency (=0.02), and randomized clinical trial (JUPITER [Justification for the Use of Statins in Primary Prevention: An Intervention Trial Evaluating Rosuvastatin], minor allele frequency=0.018) was used to replicate the association with baseline CK measures. GoDARTS was used to study the relationship with CK variability. Myalgia was studied in JUPITER trial participants. Baseline and SDs of CK were on average 18% (P value=6×10^-63) and 24% (P value=2×10^-5) lower for carriers of the variant, respectively. The variant was not associated with myalgia (odds ratio, 0.84; 95% confidence interval, 0.52-1.38).

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights that a genetic factor known to be associated with constitutive CK levels is also associated with CK variability and inducibility. This is discussed in the context of evidence to suggest that the variant has an impact on inducibility of CK by trauma through a previously reported case of a homozygous carrier. However, the lack of association between the variant and myalgia suggests that it cannot reliably be used as a biomarker for muscle symptoms.

Hemodynamic and Electrocardiographic Aspects of Uncomplicated Singleton Pregnancy

Pregnancy is associated with significant changes in maternal hemodynamics, which are triggered by profound systemic vasodilation and mediated through the autonomic nervous system as well as the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system. Vascular function changes to help accommodate an increase in intravascular volume due to blood volume expansion associated with pregnancy while maintaining the efficiency of ventricular-arterial coupling and diastolic perfusion pressure. The heart undergoes physiological (eccentric) hypertrophy due to increased volume load and cardiac stroke work, whereas the functional change of the left ventricle remains controversial. There are changes in cardiac electrical activity during pregnancy which can be detected in the electrocardiogram that are not related to disease. Sympathetic activation is a common phenomenon during uncomplicated pregnancy and may be a compensatory mechanism induced by profound systemic vasodilation and a decrease in mean arterial pressure. Despite marked sympathetic activation, vasoconstrictor responsiveness is blunted during uncomplicated pregnancy. There are race and ethnic differences in maternal hemodynamic adaptations to uncomplicated pregnancy, which may be attributed to differences in socioeconomic status or in prevalence rates of cardiovascular risk factors.

The acute effect of beta-guanidinopropionic acid versus creatine or placebo in healthy men (ABC-Trial): A randomized controlled first-in-human trial

Aims

Increasing evidence indicates that the ATP‐generating enzyme creatine kinase (CK) is involved in hypertension. CK rapidly regenerates ATP from creatine phosphate and ADP. Recently, it has been shown that beta‐guanidinopropionic acid (GPA), a kidney‐synthesized creatine analogue and competitive CK inhibitor, reduced blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats. To further develop the substance as a potential blood pressure‐lowering agent, we assessed the tolerability of a sub‐therapeutic GPA dose in healthy men.

Methods

In this active and placebo‐controlled, triple‐blind, single‐centre trial, we recruited 24 healthy men (18–50 years old, BMI 18.5–29.9 kg m⁻²) in the Netherlands. Participants were randomized (1:1:1) to one week daily oral administration of GPA 100 mg, creatine 5 g, or matching placebo. The primary outcome was the tolerability of GPA, in an intent‐to‐treat analysis.

Results

Twenty‐four randomized participants received the allocated intervention and 23 completed the study. One participant in the placebo arm dropped out for personal reasons. GPA was well tolerated, without serious or severe adverse events. No abnormalities were reported with GPA use in clinical safety parameters, including physical examination, laboratory studies, or 12‐Lead ECG. At day 8, mean plasma GPA was 213.88 (SE 0.07) in the GPA arm vs. 32.75 (0.00) nmol l⁻¹ in the placebo arm, a mean difference of 181.13 (95% CI 26.53–335.72).

Conclusion

In this first‐in‐human trial, low‐dose GPA was safe and well‐tolerated when used during 1 week in healthy men. Subsequent studies should focus on human pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic assessments with different doses.

Cardiovascular function is not associated with creatine kinase activity in a black African population: The SABPA study

Background

Higher creatine kinase (CK) activity is associated with the development of cardiovascular disease in black African populations. We compared CK activity and investigated associations of blood pressure with CK activity in black and white men as well as black and white women.

Methods

Ambulatory blood pressure, total peripheral resistance and pulse wave velocity of 197 black and 208 white participants were determined and serum CK activity was measured.

Results

Blood pressure and pulse wave velocity were higher in black men and women (all p < 0.001) when compared to their white counterparts. CK activity only varied between black and white women (75.9 U/l vs 62.8 U/l, p = 0.009), even after adjusting for age, body mass index and physical activity. Despite the worse cardiovascular profile of black men and women, and the higher CK activity in the black women, we were unable to link blood pressure, pulse wave velocity or total peripheral resistance with CK activity, in the black African population. In white men, total peripheral resistance was associated with CK activity (R² = 0.32; β = 0.25; p = 0.009), whereas systolic blood pressure (R² = 0.46; β = 0.17; p = 0.03) and pulse pressure (R² = 0.31; β = 0.21; p = 0.01) were associated with CK activity in white women.

Conclusions

The lack of associations in the black African population suggests that the link between a worse cardiovascular profile and CK activity may be overshadowed by other contributing factors. Whereas, the established link between cardiovascular function and CK activity in the white groups may be the result of enhanced smooth muscle cell contractility and/or attenuated nitric oxide synthesis capacity.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12872-016-0315-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The Effect of Creatine Kinase Inhibition on Contractile Properties of Human Resistance Arteries

BACKGROUND

Creatine kinase (CK) is a main predictor of blood pressure, and this is thought to largely depend on high resistance artery contractility. We previously reported an association between vascular contractility and CK in normotensive pregnancy, but pregnancy is a strong CK inducer, and data on human hypertension are lacking. Therefore, we further explored CK-dependency of vascular contractility outside the context of pregnancy in normotensive and hypertensive women.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Nineteen consecutive women, mean age 42 years (SE 1.3), mean systolic/diastolic blood pressure respectively 142.6 (SE 5.9)/85.6 (3.4) mm Hg (9 hypertensive), donated an omental fat sample during abdominal surgery. We compared vasodilation after the specific CK inhibitor 2,4-dinitro-1-fluorobenzene (DNFB; 10(-6) mol/l) to sodium nitroprusside (10(-6) mol/l) in isolated resistance arteries using a wire myograph. Additionally, we assessed predictors of vasoconstrictive force. DNFB reduced vascular contractility to 24.3% (SE 4.4), P < 0.001, compared to baseline. Sodium nitroprusside reduced contractility to 89.8% (SE 2.3). Maximum contractile force correlated with DNFB effect as a measure of CK (r = 0.8), and with vessel diameter (r = 0.7). The increase in contractile force was 16.5 mN [9.1-23.9] per unit DNFB effect in univariable and 10.35 mN [2.10-18.60] in multivariable regression analysis.

CONCLUSION

This study extends on our previous findings in pregnant normotensive women of CK-dependent microvascular contractility, indicating that CK contributes significantly to resistance artery contractility across human normotension and primary hypertension outside the context of pregnancy. Further studies should explore the effect of CK inhibitors on clinical blood pressure.

The acute effect of beta-guanidinopropionic acid versus creatine or placebo in healthy men (ABC Trial): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

Background

Despite adequate treatment, up to 30% of treated antihypertensive patients with primary, uncomplicated hypertension remain uncontrolled. We proposed that high intracellular activity of the ATP regenerating enzyme creatine kinase (CK) increases pressor responses and hypertension risk. In line with this, we found that plasma CK activity after rest, a surrogate measure of tissue activity, is the main predictor of blood pressure levels and failure of antihypertensive therapy in the general population. In addition, the creatine analog and competitive oral creatine kinase inhibitor beta-guanidinopropionic acid effectively and safely reduced blood pressure in the spontaneously hypertensive rat. However, to our knowledge there are no human data on the safety of oral supplementation with this substance. Therefore, we will assess the tolerability of beta-guanidinopropionic acid in men, compared to creatine and placebo.

Methods/Design

This is a randomized, active and placebo controlled, triple blind, double dummy, single center clinical intervention trial in 24 healthy male volunteers, 18 to 50 years old, recruited in the Netherlands. The intervention consists of one week of daily oral administration of beta-guanidinopropionic acid 100 mg, creatine 5 gram, or placebo. The primary outcome is the tolerability of beta-guanidinopropionic acid as a descriptive measure, in an intent-to-treat analysis. Other outcomes include the placebo-adjusted differences with baseline in biochemical and hemodynamic parameters, including plasma markers of muscle tissue damage, urine sodium excretion, resting sitting systolic and diastolic brachial blood pressure, supine systolic and diastolic central blood pressure, pulse wave velocity and augmentation index, heart rate, cardiac contractility, cardiac output, and total peripheral resistance.

Discussion

There is an unfulfilled need for new conservative options to treat resistant hypertension. This study will provide first-in-men data on creatine kinase inhibition as a potential new class of antihypertensive drugs.

Trial registration

The Netherlands National Trial Register Trialregister.nl (identifier NTR 4444), registered 9 March 2014.

Resistance Artery Creatine Kinase mRNA and Blood Pressure in Humans

Hypertension remains the main risk factor for cardiovascular death. Environmental and biological factors are known to contribute to the condition, and circulating creatine kinase was reported to be the main predictor of blood pressure in the general population. This was proposed to be because of high resistance artery creatine kinase-BB rapidly regenerating ATP for vascular contractility. Therefore, we assessed whether creatine kinase isoenzyme mRNA levels in human resistance arteries are associated with blood pressure. We isolated resistance-sized arteries from omental fat donated by consecutive women undergoing uterine fibroid surgery. Blood pressure was measured in the sitting position. Vessels of 13 women were included, 6 normotensive and 7 hypertensive, mean age 42.9 years (SE, 1.6) and mean systolic/diastolic blood pressure, 144.8 (8.0)/86.5 (4.3) mm Hg. Arteriolar creatine kinase isoenzyme mRNA was assessed using quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction. Normalized creatine kinase B mRNA copy numbers, ranging from 5.2 to 24.4 (mean, 15.0; SE, 1.9), showed a near-perfect correlation with diastolic blood pressure (correlation coefficient, 0.9; 95% confidence interval, 0.6–1.0) and were well correlated with systolic blood pressure, with a 90% relative increase in resistance artery creatine kinase B mRNA in hypertensives compared with normotensives, normalized copy numbers were, respectively, 19.3 (SE, 2.0) versus 10.1 (SE, 2.1), P =0.0045. To our knowledge, this is the first direct evidence suggesting that resistance artery creatine kinase mRNA expression levels concur with blood pressure levels, almost doubling with hypertension. These findings add to the evidence that creatine kinase might be involved in the vasculature’s pressor responses.

Creatine kinase is associated with failure of hypertension treatment

BACKGROUND

Failure of hypertension treatment is a major clinical issue because of the high prevalence and the associated mortality risk. We have reported evidence that creatine kinase increases blood pressure through greater sodium retention and cardiovascular contractility, by rapidly providing ATP for these functions. Therefore, we hypothesized that high creatine kinase is associated with failure of antihypertensive treatment.

METHOD

We analyzed a cross-sectional, random multiethnic sample of the general population (N = 1444), aged 34-60 years. The primary outcome was the independent association between resting serum creatine kinase and treated uncontrolled hypertension in the population, using multinomial logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

Hypertension prevalence was, respectively, 26.8; 30.8; and 41.2% for the lowest (<88  IU/l) through the highest population creatine kinase tertile (>145  IU/l; P < 0.001). Treatment failed in 72.9% of participants within the highest creatine kinase tertile vs. 46.7% within the lowest tertile (P = 0.004). In logistic regression analysis, creatine kinase was the main predictor of treatment failure (adjusted odds ratio 3.7; 95% confidence interval 1.2-10.9), independent of age, sex, BMI, fasting glucose, ethnicity, or education level.

CONCLUSION

Creatine kinase is associated with failure of antihypertensive therapy. Further investigations concerning this association might help improve treatment strategies for difficult-to-treat hypertension.

[Elevated plasma creatine kinase activity - does it always indicate muscle disease?]

Despite advanced diagnostic procedures in muscle disorders, creatine kinase (CK) activity is still one of the parameters most often investigated in serum. It is used mainly in neuromyology, and helps to differentiate between myogenic and neurogenic processes. Furthermore, it is applied to monitor the course of the disease and treatment results. Occasionally, marked elevated CK activity requires detailed diagnostic work-up, including electrophysiological, histopathological and genetic studies. In some cases, it enables the final diagnosis to be established. However, there is still a group of patients with so-called idiopathic hyper-CKemia and with no evidence of neuromuscular disorder. As little is known about potentially asymptomatic hyper-CK-emia, these patients should be carefully monitored.

Ethnic differences in resistance artery contractility of normotensive pregnant women

Black women are at a greater risk to develop hypertension during pregnancy, with a 4.5 times higher rate of fatal preeclampsia than white women. Therefore, it is important to identify factors that may affect this risk. Our group previously proposed that high activity of the central regulatory enzyme of energy metabolism, creatine kinase (CK), may increase ATP-buffering capacity and lead to enhanced vascular contractility and reduced nitric oxide bioavailability. Therefore, we assessed microvascular contractility characteristics in isolated resistance arteries from self-defined black and white normotensive pregnant women using a Mulvany-Halpern myograph. Additionally, morphology was assessed with electron microscopy. Resistance-sized arteries obtained from omentum donated during cesarean sections (11 black women and 20 white women, mean age: 34 yr) studied in series showed similar morphology but significantly greater maximum contractions to norepinephrine (10(-5) M) in blacks [14.0 mN (1.8 SE)] compared with whites [8.9 mN (1.4 SE), P = 0.02]. Furthermore, we found greater residual contractility after the specific CK inhibitor dinitrofluorobenzene (10(-6) M) in black women [55% (6 SE)] compared with white women [28% (4 SE), P = 0.001] and attenuated vasodilation after bradykinin (10(-7) M) in black women [103% (6 SE)] compared with white women [84% (5 SE), P = 0.023], whereas responses to sodium nitroprusside (10(-4) M) and amlodipine (10(-6) M) were similar. We conclude that compared with white women, normotensive pregnant black women display greater resistance artery contractility and evidence of higher vascular CK activity with attenuated nitric oxide synthesis. These findings in normotensives may imply that the black population is at risk for a further incline in pregnancy-related hypertensive disorders.

Distribution of creatine kinase in the general population: implications for statin therapy

BACKGROUND

Eligible subjects with mildly elevated serum creatine kinase (CK) activity are often excluded before randomization in statin trials, but patients may potentially be misclassified as having hyperCKemia when inappropriate reference limits are used. Little information is usually given regarding how reference limit data were established, although evidence suggests that the variation of CK activity in the general population is wider than reflected in reference intervals in current use.

METHODS

We determined reference intervals for serum CK according to National Committee on Clinical Laboratory Standards/Nordic Reference Interval Project guidelines, in a stratified random sample of the population, including 1444 individuals, aged 34 to 60 years, after 3 days of rest. Participants were mainly of white European (n = 503), South Asian (n = 292), or African descent (n = 580).

RESULTS

The calculated upper reference limits (97.5th percentile) for nonblack and black women and men were 2 to 5 times higher than recommended by the assay manufacturer. Respectively 13% of the white Europeans, 23% of South Asians, and 49% of the black people had serum CK activities above the manufacturer-provided limits.

CONCLUSION

The variation in CK activity within the population is wider than previously suggested in smaller, nonrandom samples, and relatively high values occur frequently in all subgroups studied after rest. Therefore, we infer that upward adjustment of the upper reference limit is necessary for all population subgroups studied. The use of appropriately established reference intervals may improve the use of statins and particularly benefit the control of dyslipidemia in those with relatively high baseline CK activity.