Assessing variants of uncertain significance implicated in hearing loss using a comprehensive deafness proteome

Genetic testing for pediatric sensorineural hearing loss in the era of gene therapy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To summarize indications, methods, and diagnostic yields for genetic testing for pediatric hearing loss.

RECENT FINDINGS

Genetic testing has become a cornerstone of clinical care for children with sensorineural hearing loss. Recent studies have shown the efficacy of gene panels and exome sequencing for any child with sensorineural hearing loss. Recent findings have underscored the importance of a diagnosis in clinical care. Clinical trials for gene therapy for hearing loss have begun.

SUMMARY

Genetic testing has become critical for personalized care for children with hearing loss. Recent studies have shown a 43% overall diagnostic yield for genetic testing for pediatric hearing loss, though the diagnostic yield may range from 10 to 60% depending on clinical features. Syndromic diagnoses comprise 25% of positive genetic tests for pediatric sensorineural hearing loss. While diagnostic yield is lower for children with unilateral or asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss, the likelihood of syndromic hearing loss finding is higher. An early and accurate genetic diagnosis is required for participating in clinical trials for gene therapy for hearing loss.

METTL23 Variants and Patients With Normal-Tension Glaucoma

Importance

This research confirms and further establishes that pathogenic variants in a fourth gene, METTL23, are associated with autosomal dominant normal-tension glaucoma (NTG).

Objective

To determine the frequency of glaucoma-causing pathogenic variants in the METTL23 gene in a cohort of patients with NTG from Iowa.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This case-control study took place at a single tertiary care center in Iowa from January 1997 to January 2024, with analysis occurring between January 2023 and January 2024. Two groups of participants were enrolled from the University of Iowa clinics: 331 patients with NTG and 362 control individuals without glaucoma. Patients with a history of trauma; steroid use; stigmata of pigment dispersion syndrome; exfoliation syndrome; or pathogenic variants in MYOC, TBK1, or OPTN were also excluded.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Detection of an enrichment of METTL23 pathogenic variants in individuals with NTG compared with control individuals without glaucoma.

Results

The study included 331 patients with NTG (mean [SD] age, 68.0 [11.7] years; 228 [68.9%] female and 103 [31.1%] male) and 362 control individuals without glaucoma (mean [SD] age, 64.5 [12.6] years; 207 [57.2%] female and 155 [42.8%] male). There were 5 detected instances of 4 unique METTL23 pathogenic variants in patients with NTG. Three METTL23 variants-p.Ala7Val, p.Pro22Arg, and p.Arg63Trp-were judged to be likely pathogenic and were detected in 3 patients (0.91%) with NTG. However, when all detected variants were evaluated with either mutation burden analysis or logistic regression, their frequency was not statistically higher in individuals with NTG than in control individuals without glaucoma (1.5% vs 2.5%; P = .27).

Conclusion and Relevance

This investigation provides evidence that pathogenic variants in METTL23 are associated with NTG. Within an NTG cohort at a tertiary care center, pathogenic variants were associated with approximately 1% of NTG cases, a frequency similar to that of other known normal-tension glaucoma genes, including optineurin (OPTN), TANK-binding kinase 1 (TBK1), and myocilin (MYOC). The findings suggest that METTL23 pathogenic variants are likely involved in a biologic pathway that is associated with glaucoma that occurs at lower intraocular pressures.

A sensorineural hearing loss harboring novel compound heterozygous variant in the TRIOBP gene: A case report

Background

Autosomal recessive non-syndromic deafness-28 (DFNB28; OMIM #609823) specifically refers to prelingual sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) resulting from homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in the TRIO- and F-actin-binding protein, TRIOBP gene. In this report, we present a pediatric patient exhibiting novel compound heterozygous deleterious variants in the TRIOBP gene.

Methods

The auditory brainstem response result revealed both left- and right-sided deafness with a threshold of 20 dB normal hearing level in the proband. A comprehensive trio whole exome sequencing (WES) using the Celemics G-Mendeliome Whole Exome Sequencing Panel was employed.

Results

The WES analysis revealed compound heterozygous TRIOBP variants in the proband, namely c.1192_1195delCAACinsT/p.Gln398* classified as pathogenic and c.3661C > T/p.Arg1221Trp categorized as a variant of uncertain significance according to American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines. These variants are considered the most probable cause of the proband's SNHL.

Conclusion

TRIOBP isoforms are predominantly expressed in the inner ear, contributing to the formation of stereocilia rootlets. Further investigations are required to fully understand the phenotypic variability and establish the pathogenicity of the identified variant in relation to the TRIOBP gene and SNHL.

Implementing next-generation sequencing for diagnosis and management of hereditary hearing impairment: a comprehensive review

INTRODUCTION

Sensorineural hearing impairment (SNHI), a common childhood disorder with heterogeneous genetic causes, can lead to delayed language development and psychosocial problems. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) offers high-throughput screening and high-sensitivity detection of genetic etiologies of SNHI, enabling clinicians to make informed medical decisions, provide tailored treatments, and improve prognostic outcomes.

AREAS COVERED

This review covers the diverse etiologies of HHI and the utility of different NGS modalities (targeted sequencing and whole exome/genome sequencing), and includes HHI-related studies on newborn screening, genetic counseling, prognostic prediction, and personalized treatment. Challenges such as the trade-off between cost and diagnostic yield, detection of structural variants, and exploration of the non-coding genome are also highlighted.

EXPERT OPINION

In the current landscape of NGS-based diagnostics for HHI, there are both challenges (e.g. detection of structural variants and non-coding genome variants) and opportunities (e.g. the emergence of medical artificial intelligence tools). The authors advocate the use of technological advances such as long-read sequencing for structural variant detection, multi-omics analysis for non-coding variant exploration, and medical artificial intelligence for pathogenicity assessment and outcome prediction. By integrating these innovations into clinical practice, precision medicine in the diagnosis and management of HHI can be further improved.

Force Field X: A computational microscope to study genetic variation and organic crystals using theory and experiment

Force Field X (FFX) is an open-source software package for atomic resolution modeling of genetic variants and organic crystals that leverages advanced potential energy functions and experimental data. FFX currently consists of nine modular packages with novel algorithms that include global optimization via a many-body expansion, acid-base chemistry using polarizable constant-pH molecular dynamics, estimation of free energy differences, generalized Kirkwood implicit solvent models, and many more. Applications of FFX focus on the use and development of a crystal structure prediction pipeline, biomolecular structure refinement against experimental datasets, and estimation of the thermodynamic effects of genetic variants on both proteins and nucleic acids. The use of Parallel Java and OpenMM combines to offer shared memory, message passing, and graphics processing unit parallelization for high performance simulations. Overall, the FFX platform serves as a computational microscope to study systems ranging from organic crystals to solvated biomolecular systems.

Human Organoids for Rapid Validation of Gene Variants Linked to Cochlear Malformations

Developmental anomalies of the hearing organ, the cochlea, are diagnosed in approximately one-fourth of individuals with congenital deafness. Most patients with cochlear malformations remain etiologically undiagnosed due to insufficient knowledge about underlying genes or the inability to make conclusive interpretations of identified genetic variants. We used exome sequencing for genetic evaluation of hearing loss associated with cochlear malformations in three probands from unrelated families. We subsequently generated monoclonal induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) lines, bearing patient-specific knockins and knockouts using CRISPR/Cas9 to assess pathogenicity of candidate variants. We detected FGF3 (p.Arg165Gly) and GREB1L (p.Cys186Arg), variants of uncertain significance in two recognized genes for deafness, and PBXIP1(p.Trp574*) in a candidate gene. Upon differentiation of iPSCs towards inner ear organoids, we observed significant developmental aberrations in knockout lines compared to their isogenic controls. Patient-specific single nucleotide variants (SNVs) showed similar abnormalities as the knockout lines, functionally supporting their causality in the observed phenotype. Therefore, we present human inner ear organoids as a tool to rapidly validate the pathogenicity of DNA variants associated with cochlear malformations.

Genetic heterogeneity in hereditary hearing loss: Potential role of kinociliary protein TOGARAM2

Hearing loss (HL) is a heterogenous trait with pathogenic variants in more than 200 genes that have been discovered in studies involving small and large HL families. Over one-third of families with hereditary HL remain etiologically undiagnosed after screening for mutations in the recognized genes. Genetic heterogeneity complicates the analysis in multiplex families where variants in more than one gene can be causal in different individuals even in the same sibship. We employed exome or genome sequencing in at least two affected individuals with congenital or prelingual-onset, severe to profound, non-syndromic, bilateral sensorineural HL from four multiplex families. Bioinformatic analysis was performed to identify variants in known and candidate deafness genes. Our results show that in these four families, variants in a single HL gene do not explain HL in all affected family members, and variants in another known or candidate HL gene were detected to clarify HL in the entire family. We also present a variant in TOGARAM2 as a potential cause underlying autosomal recessive non-syndromic HL by showing its presence in a family with HL, its expression in the cochlea and the localization of the protein to cochlear hair cells. Conclusively, analyzing all affected family members separately can serve as a good source for the identification of variants in known and novel candidate genes for HL.

Improving the Yield of Genetic Diagnosis through Additional Genetic Panel Testing in Hereditary Ophthalmic Diseases

Numerous hereditary ophthalmic diseases display significant genetic diversity. Consequently, the utilization of gene panel sequencing allows a greater number of patients to receive a genetic diagnosis for their clinical manifestations. We investigated how to improve the yield of genetic diagnosis through additional gene panel sequencing in hereditary ophthalmic diseases. A gene panel sequencing consisting of a customized hereditary retinopathy panel or hereditary retinitis pigmentosa (RP) panel was prescribed and referred to a CAP-accredited clinical laboratory. If no significant mutations associated with hereditary retinopathy and RP were detected in either panel, additional gene panel sequencing was requested for research use, utilizing the remaining panel. After additional gene panel sequencing, a total of 16 heterozygous or homozygous variants were identified in 15 different genes associated with hereditary ophthalmic diseases. Of 15 patients carrying any candidate variants, the clinical symptoms could be tentatively accounted for by genetic mutations in seven patients. However, in the remaining eight patients, given the in silico mutation predictive analysis, variant allele frequency in gnomAD, inheritance pattern, and genotype-phenotype correlation, fully elucidating the clinical manifestations with the identified rare variant was challenging. Our study highlights the utility of gene panel sequencing in achieving accurate diagnoses for hereditary ophthalmic diseases and enhancing the diagnostic yield through additional gene panel sequencing. Thus, gene panel sequencing can serve as a primary tool for the genetic diagnosis of hereditary ophthalmic diseases, even in cases where a single genetic cause is suspected. With a deeper comprehension of the genetic mechanisms underlying these diseases, it becomes feasible.

The transcription factor Pou4f3 is essential for the survival of postnatal and adult mouse cochlear hair cells and normal hearing

Introduction

Hair cells (HCs) of the cochlea are responsible for sound transduction and hearing perception in mammals. Genetic mutations in the transcription factor Pou4f3 cause non-syndromic autosomal dominant hearing loss in humans (DFNA15) which varies in the age of onset depending on the individual mutation. Mouse models with germline deletion or mutations in Pou4f3 have previously demonstrated its critical role in the maturation and survival of cochlear HCs during embryonic development. However, the role of Pou4f3 in auditory function and in the survival or maintenance of cochlear HCs after birth and during adulthood has not been studied.

Methods

Therefore, using the inducible CreER-loxP system, we deleted Pou4f3 from mouse cochlear HCs at different postnatal ages, relevant to specific stages of HC maturation and hearing function.

Results and discussion

Elevated auditory brainstem response thresholds and significant HC loss were detected in mice with Pou4f3 deletion compared to their control littermates, regardless of the age when Pou4f3 was deleted. However, HC loss occurred more rapidly when Pou4f3 was deleted from immature HCs. Additionally, HC loss caused by Pou4f3 deletion did not affect the number of cochlear supporting cells, but caused a delayed loss of spiral ganglion neurons at 4 months after the deletion. In conclusion, Pou4f3 is necessary for the survival of cochlear HCs and normal hearing at all postnatal ages regardless of their maturation state. Our data also suggest that Pou4f3 indirectly regulates the survival of spiral ganglion neurons.

Functional Studies of Deafness-Associated Pendrin and Prestin Variants

Pendrin and prestin are evolutionary-conserved membrane proteins that are essential for normal hearing. Dysfunction of these proteins results in hearing loss in humans, and numerous deafness-associated pendrin and prestin variants have been identified in patients. However, the pathogenic impacts of many of these variants are ambiguous. Here, we report results from our ongoing efforts to experimentally characterize pendrin and prestin variants using in vitro functional assays. With previously established fluorometric anion transport assays, we determined that many of the pendrin variants identified on transmembrane (TM) 10, which contains the essential anion binding site, and on the neighboring TM9 within the core domain resulted in impaired anion transport activity. We also determined the range of functional impairment in three deafness-associated prestin variants by measuring nonlinear capacitance (NLC), a proxy for motor function. Using the results from our functional analyses, we also evaluated the performance of AlphaMissense (AM), a computational tool for predicting the pathogenicity of missense variants. AM prediction scores correlated well with our experimental results; however, some variants were misclassified, underscoring the necessity of experimentally assessing the effects of variants. Together, our experimental efforts provide invaluable information regarding the pathogenicity of deafness-associated pendrin and prestin variants.

Functional studies of deafness-associated pendrin and prestin variants

Pendrin and prestin are evolutionary conserved membrane proteins that are essential for normal hearing. Pendrin is an anion transporter required for normal development and maintenance of ion homeostasis in the inner ear, while prestin is a voltage-dependent motor responsible for cochlear amplification essential for high sensitivity and frequency selectivity of mammalian hearing. Dysfunction of these proteins result in hearing loss in humans, and numerous deafness-associated pendrin and prestin variants have been identified in patients. However, the pathogenic impacts of many of these variants are ambiguous. Here we report results from our ongoing efforts in experimentally characterizing pendrin and prestin variants using in vitro functional assays, providing invaluable information regarding their pathogenicity.