Local distribution of collagen fibers determines crack initiation site and its propagation direction during aortic rupture

Local Characterization of Collagen Architecture and Mechanical Failure Properties of Fibrous Plaque Tissue of Atherosclerotic Human Carotid Arteries

Atherosclerotic plaque rupture in carotid arteries is a major cause of cerebrovascular events. Plaque rupture is the mechanical failure of the heterogeneous fibrous plaque tissue. Local characterization of the tissue's failure properties and the collagen architecture are of great importance to have insights in plaque rupture for clinical event prevention. Previous studies were limited to average rupture properties and global structural characterization, and did not provide the necessary local information. In this study, we assessed the local collagen architecture and failure properties of fibrous plaque tissue, by analyzing 30 tissue strips from 18 carotid plaques. Our study framework entailed second harmonic generation imaging for local collagen orientation and dispersion, and uniaxial tensile testing and digital image correlation for local tissue mechanics. The results showed that 87% of the imaged locations had collagen orientation close to the circumferential direction (0°) of the artery, and substantial dispersion locally. All regions combined, median [Q1:Q3] of the predominant angle measurements was -2° [-16°:16°]. The stretch ratio measurements clearly demonstrated a nonuniform stretch ratio distribution in the tissue under uniaxial loading. The rupture initiation regions had significantly higher stretch ratios (1.26 [1.15-1.40]) than the tissue average stretch ratio (1.11 [1.10-1.16]). No significant difference in collagen direction and dispersion was identified between the rupture regions and the rest of the tissue. The presented study forms an initial step towards gaining better insights into the characterization of local structural and mechanical fingerprints of fibrous plaque tissue in order to aid improved assessment of plaque rupture risk. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Plaque rupture risk assessment, critical to prevent cardiovascular events, requires knowledge on local failure properties and structure of collagenous plaque tissue. Our current knowledge is unfortunately limited to tissue's overall ultimate failure properties with scarce information on collagen architecture. In this study, local failure properties and collagen architecture of fibrous plaque tissue were obtained. We found predominant circumferential alignment of collagen fibers with substantial local dispersion. The tissue showed nonuniform stretch distribution under uniaxial tensile loading, with high stretches at rupture spots. This study highlights the significance of local mechanical and structural assessment for better insights into plaque rupture and the potential use of local stretches as risk marker for plaque rupture for patient-specific clinical applications.

Uniaxial properties of ascending aortic aneurysms in light of effective stretch

A constitutive model that explicitly considers the gradual recruitment of collagen fibers is applied to investigate the uniaxial properties of human ascending aortic aneurysms. The model uses an effective stretch, which is a continuum scale kinematic variable measuring the true stretch of the tissue, to formulate the fiber stress. The constitutive equation contains two shape parameters characterizing the stochastic distribution of fiber waviness, and two elastic parameters accounting for, respectively, the elastic properties of ground substance and the straightened collagen fibers. The model is applied to 156 sets of uniaxial stress-stretch data obtained from 52 aneurysm samples. Major findings include (1) the uniaxial response can be well described by a quadratic strain energy function of the effective strain; (2) the ultimate stretches, when measured in terms of the effective stretch, are closely clustered around 1.1, in contrast to a much wider range in the original stretch; and (3) the ultimate stress correlates positively with the fiber stiffness. The age dependence and directional differences of constitutive parameters are also investigated. Results indicate that only the waviness depends strongly on age; no clear alterations occur in elastic parameters. Further, the fibers are wavier and stiffer in the circumferential direction than in the longitudinal direction. No other parameters exhibit significant direction difference. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: We introduced a constitutive model which explicitly accounts for collagen fiber recruitment to investigate the uniaxial properties of human ascending aortic aneurysm tissues. Uniaxial response data from 156 specimens were considered in the study. It was found that the seemingly dissimilar response curves are, in fact, similar if we measure the deformation using an effective stretch which factors out the uncrimping deformation. The rupture stretches in terms of the effective stretch are closely packed around 1.1. And the stress-stretch curves collapse to a canonical curve after a transformation.

Comparison of the histology and stiffness of ventricles in Anura of different habitats

Vertebrate hearts have undergone marked morphological and structural changes to adapt to different environments and lifestyles as part of the evolutionary process. Amphibians were the first vertebrates to migrate to land. Transition from aquatic to terrestrial environments required the ability to circulate blood against the force of gravity. In this study, we investigated the passive mechanical properties and histology of the ventricles of three species of Anura (frogs and toads) from different habitats, Xenopus laevis (aquatic), Pelophylax nigromaculatus (semiaquatic), and Bufo japonicus formosus (terrestrial). Pressure-loading tests demonstrated stiffer ventricles of P. nigromaculatus and B. j. formosus compared X. laevis ventricles. Histological analysis revealed a remarkable difference in the structure of cardiac tissue: thickening of the compact myocardium layer of P. nigromaculatus and B. j. formosus and enrichment of the collagen fibers of B. j. formosus. The amount of collagen fibers differed among the species, as quantitatively confirmed by second-harmonic generation light microscopy. No significant difference was observed in cardiomyocytes isolated from each animal, and the sarcomere length was almost the same. The results indicate that the ventricles of Anura stiffen during adaptation to life on land.

Second harmonic generation light quantifies the ratio of type III to total (I + III) collagen in a bundle of collagen fiber

The ratio of type III to type I collagen is important for properly maintaining functions of organs and cells. We propose a method to quantify the ratio of type III to total (type I + III) collagen (λ_III) in a given collagen fiber bundle using second harmonic generation (SHG) light. First, the relationship between SHG light intensity and the λ_III of collagen gels was examined, and the slope (k₁) and SHG light intensity at 0% type III collagen (k₂) were determined. Second, the SHG light intensity of a 100% type I collagen fiber bundle and its diameter (D) were measured, and the slope (k₃) of the relationship was determined. The λ_III in a collagen fiber bundle was estimated from these constants (k_1-3) and SHG light intensity. We applied this method to collagen fiber bundles isolated from the media and adventitia of porcine thoracic aortas, and obtained λ_III = 84.7% ± 13.8% and λ_III = 17.5% ± 15.2%, respectively. These values concurred with those obtained with a typical quantification method using sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The findings demonstrated that the method proposed is useful to quantify the ratio of type III to total collagen in a collagen fiber bundle.

Mechanical and structural contributions of elastin and collagen fibers to interlamellar bonding in the arterial wall

The artery relies on interlamellar structural components, mainly elastin and collagen fibers, for maintaining its integrity and resisting dissection propagation. In this study, the contribution of arterial elastin and collagen fibers to interlamellar bonding was studied through mechanical testing, multiphoton imaging and finite element modeling. Steady-state peeling experiments were performed on porcine aortic media and the purified elastin network in the circumferential (Circ) and longitudinal (Long) directions. The peeling force and energy release rate associated with mode-I failure are much higher for aortic media than for the elastin network. Also, longitudinal peeling exhibits a higher energy release rate and strength than circumferential peeling for both the aortic media and elastin. Multiphoton imaging shows the recruitment of both elastin and collagen fibers within the interlamellar space and points to in-plane anisotropy of fiber distributions as a potential mechanism for the direction-dependent phenomena of peeling tests. Three-dimensional finite element models based on cohesive zone model (CZM) of fracture were created to simulate the peeling tests with the interlamellar energy release rate and separation distance at damage initiation obtained directly from peeling test. Our experimental results show that the separation distance at damage initiation is 80 μm for aortic media and 40 μm for elastin. The damage initiation stress was estimated from the model for aortic media (Circ: 60 kPa; Long: 95 kPa) and elastin (Circ: 9 kPa; Long: 14 kPa). The interlamellar separation distance at complete failure was estimated to be 3 - 4 mm for both media and elastin. Furthermore, elastin and collagen fibers both play an important role in bonding of the arterial wall, while collagen has a higher contribution than elastin to interlamellar stiffness, strength and toughness. These results on microstructural interlamellar failure shed light on the pathological development and progression of aortic dissection.

Computational modeling of the strength of the ascending thoracic aortic media tissue under physiologic biaxial loading conditions

Type A Aortic Dissection (TAAD) is a life-threatening condition involving delamination of ascending aortic media layers. While current clinical guidelines recommend surgical intervention for aneurysm diameter > 5.5 cm, high incidence of TAAD in patients below this diameter threshold indicates the pressing need for improved evidence-based risk prediction metrics. Construction of such metrics will require the knowledge of the biomechanical failure properties of the aortic wall tissue under biaxial loading conditions. We utilized a fiber-level finite element based structural model of the aortic tissue to quantify the relationship between aortic tissue strength and physiologically relevant biaxial stress state for nonaneurysmal and aneurysmal patient cohorts with tricuspid aortic valve phenotype. We found that the model predicted strength of the aortic tissue under physiologic biaxial loading conditions depends on the stress biaxiality ratio, defined by the ratio of the longitudinal and circumferential components of the tissue stress. We determined that predicted biaxial tissue strength is statistically similar to its uniaxial circumferential strength below biaxiality ratios of 0.68 and 0.69 for nonaneurysmal and aneurysmal cohorts, respectively. Beyond this biaxiality ratio, predicted biaxial strength for both cohorts reduced drastically to a magnitude statistically similar to its longitudinal strength. We identified fiber-level failure mechanisms operative under biaxial stress state governing aforementioned tissue failure behavior. These findings are an important first step towards the development of mechanism-based TAAD risk assessment metrics for early identification of high-risk patients.

Connectivity and plasticity determine collagen network fracture

Collagen forms the structural scaffold of connective tissues in all mammals. Tissues are remarkably resistant against mechanical deformations because collagen molecules hierarchically self-assemble in fibrous networks that stiffen with increasing strain. Nevertheless, collagen networks do fracture when tissues are overloaded or subject to pathological conditions such as aneurysms. Prior studies of the role of collagen in tissue fracture have mainly focused on tendons, which contain highly aligned bundles of collagen. By contrast, little is known about fracture of the orientationally more disordered collagen networks present in many other tissues such as skin and cartilage. Here, we combine shear rheology of reconstituted collagen networks with computer simulations to investigate the primary determinants of fracture in disordered collagen networks. We show that the fracture strain is controlled by the coordination number of the network junctions, with less connected networks fracturing at larger strains. The hierarchical structure of collagen fine-tunes the fracture strain by providing structural plasticity at the network and fiber level. Our findings imply that low connectivity and plasticity provide protective mechanisms against network fracture that can optimize the strength of biological tissues.

Quantification of the regional bioarchitecture in the human aorta

Regional variance in human aortic bioarchitecture responsible for the elasticity of the vessel is poorly understood. The current study quantifies the elements responsible for aortic compliance, namely, elastin, collagen and smooth muscle cells, using histological and stereological techniques on human tissue with a focus on regional heterogeneity. Using donated cadaveric tissue, a series of samples were excised between the proximal ascending aorta and the distal abdominal aorta, for five cadavers, each of which underwent various staining procedures to enhance specific constituents of the wall. Using polarised light microscopy techniques, the orientation of collagen fibres was studied for each location and each tunical layer of the aorta. Significant transmural and longitudinal heterogeneity in collagen fibre orientations were uncovered throughout the vessel. It is shown that a von Mises mixture model is required accurately to fit the complex collagen fibre distributions that exist along the aorta. Additionally, collagen and smooth muscle cell density was observed to increase with increasing distance from the heart, whereas elastin density decreased. Evidence clearly demonstrates that the aorta is a highly heterogeneous vessel which cannot be simplistically represented by a single compliance value. The quantification and fitting of the regional aortic bioarchitectural data, although not without its limitations, including mean cohort age of 77.6 years, facilitates the development of next-generation finite element models that can potentially simulate the influence of regional aortic composition and microstructure on vessel biomechanics.

Biomechanics of aortic wall failure with a focus on dissection and aneurysm: A review

Aortic dissections and aortic aneurysms are fatal events characterized by structural changes to the aortic wall. The maximum diameter criterion, typically used for aneurysm rupture risk estimations, has been challenged by more sophisticated biomechanically motivated models in the past. Although these models are very helpful for the clinicians in decision-making, they do not attempt to capture material failure. Following a short overview of the microstructure of the aorta, we analyze the failure mechanisms involved in the dissection and rupture by considering also traumatic rupture. We continue with a literature review of experimental studies relevant to quantify tissue strength. More specifically, we summarize more extensively uniaxial tensile, bulge inflation and peeling tests, and we also specify trouser, direct tension and in-plane shear tests. Finally we analyze biomechanically motivated models to predict rupture risk. Based on the findings of the reviewed studies and the rather large variations in tissue strength, we propose that an appropriate material failure criterion for aortic tissues should also reflect the microstructure in order to be effective. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Aortic dissections and aortic aneurysms are fatal events characterized by structural changes to the aortic wall. Despite the advances in medical, biomedical and biomechanical research, the mortality rates of aneurysms and dissections remain high. The present review article summarizes experimental studies that quantify the aortic wall strength and it discusses biomechanically motivated models to predict rupture risk. We identified contradictory observations and a large variation within and between data sets, which may be due to biological variations, different sample sizes, differences in experimental protocols, etc. Based on the findings of the reviewed literature and the rather large variations in tissue strength, it is proposed that an appropriate criterion for aortic failure should also reflect the microstructure.

Modeling lamellar disruption within the aortic wall using a particle-based approach

Aortic dissections associate with medial degeneration, thus suggesting a need to understand better the biophysical interactions between the cells and matrix that constitute the middle layer of the aortic wall. Here, we use a recently extended "Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics" formulation to examine potential mechanisms of aortic delamination arising from smooth muscle cell (SMC) dysfunction or apoptosis, degradation of or damage to elastic fibers, and pooling of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs), with associated losses of medial collagen in the region of the GAGs. First, we develop a baseline multi-layered model for the healthy aorta that delineates medial elastic lamellae and intra-lamellar constituents. Next, we examine stress fields resulting from the disruption of individual elastic lamellae, lost SMC contractility, and GAG production within an intra-lamellar space, focusing on the radial transferal of loading rather than on stresses at the tip of the delaminated tissue. Results suggest that local disruptions of elastic lamellae transfer excessive loads to nearby intra-lamellar constituents, which increases cellular vulnerability to dysfunction or death. Similarly, lost SMC function and accumulations of GAGs increase mechanical stress on nearby elastic lamellae, thereby increasing the chance of disruption. Overall these results suggest a positive feedback loop between lamellar disruption and cellular dropout with GAG production and lost medial collagen that is more pronounced at higher distending pressures. Independent of the initiating event, this feedback loop can catastrophically propagate intramural delamination.

Investigation of the observed rupture lines in abdominal aortic aneurysms using crack propagation simulations

OBJECTIVE

To use crack propagation simulation to study the rupture site characteristics in ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA).

METHODS

Rupture lines were precisely documented in four ruptured AAA harvested whole from cadavers. Wall thickness and material parameters were experimentally determined. Using subject-specific 3D geometry and subject-specific finite elastic model parameters, crack propagation simulations were conducted based on basic fracture mechanics principles to investigate if and how localized weak spots may have led to the observed rupture lines.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

When an initial crack was imposed at the site of peak wall stress, the propagated path did not match the observed rupture line. This indicates that in this study population, the peak wall stress was unlikely to have caused the observed rupture. When cracks were initiated at random locations in the AAA along random orientations for random initial lengths, the orientation of the resulting propagated rupture line was consistently longitudinal. This suggests that the AAA morphology predisposes the AAA to rupture longitudinally, which is consistent with observations. It was found that, in this study population, rupture may have initiated at short segments of less than about 1 cm that then propagated to form the observed rupture lines. This suggests that ex vivo experimental and in vivo elastography studies should seek a spatial resolution (approx. 1 cm) to reliably identify weak spots in AAA. The small study population and lack of a reliable failure model for AAA tissue make these findings preliminary.

Photoelasticity-based evaluation of cellular contractile force for phenotypic discrimination of vascular smooth muscle cells

Vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) have two distinct phenotypes: contractile and synthetic. The major difference between these phenotypes lies in the magnitude of the contractile force produced by the cell. Although traction force microscopy (TFM) is often used to evaluate cellular contractile force, this method requires complex preprocessing and a sufficiently compliant substrate. To evaluate the contractile force and the phenotype of living VSMCs with minimal effort and in a manner independent of the substrate stiffness, we propose a photoelasticity-based method using retardation, which is related to the difference between the first and second principal stresses and their orientation. The results demonstrate that actin filaments co-localize with areas of high retardation in cells, indicating that the retardation of VSMCs is promoted by actin filaments. The retardation of cells treated with calyculin A and Y-27632 tended to be larger and smaller, respectively, than that of control cells. Cell traction force significantly correlates with total cell retardation (r² = 0.38). The retardation of contractile VSMCs (passage 2) was significantly higher than that of synthetic VSMCs (passage 12). These results indicate that cell retardation can be used to assess cell contractile force and, thus, determine the phenotype of VSMCs.