Numerical Simulation of Ion Transport in a Nano-Electrospray Ion Source at Atmospheric Pressure

Instrument-type effects on chemical isotope labeling LC-MS metabolome analysis: Quadrupole time-of-flight MS vs. Orbitrap MS

Chemical isotope labeling (CIL) LC-MS is a powerful tool for metabolome analysis with markedly improved metabolomic coverage and quantification accuracy over the conventional LC-MS technique. In addition, with differential isotope labeling, each labeled metabolite is detected as a peak pair in the mass spectra, offering the possibility of differentiating true metabolite peaks from the singlet noise or background peaks. In this study, we examined the effects of instrument type on the detectability of true metabolites with a focus on the comparison of quadrupole time-of-flight (QTOF) and Orbitrap mass spectrometers. Using the same ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography setup and optimized running conditions for QTOF and Orbitrap, we compared the total number of peak pairs detected and identified from the two instruments using human urine and serum as the test samples. Many common peak pairs were detected from the two instruments; however, there were a significant number of unique peak pairs detected in each type of instrument. By combining the datasets obtained using QTOF and Orbitrap, the total number of peak pairs detected could be significantly increased. We also examined the effect of mass resolving power on peak pair detection in Orbitrap (60,000 vs. 120,000 resolution). The observed differences in peak pair detectability were much less than those of QTOF vs. Orbitrap. However, the type of peak pairs detected using different resolutions could be somewhat different, offering the possibility of increasing the overall number of peak pairs by combining the two datasets obtained at two different resolutions. The results from this study clearly indicate that instrument type can have a profound effect on metabolite detection in CIL LC-MS. Therefore, comparison of metabolome data generated using different instruments needs to be carefully done. Moreover, future research (e.g., hardware modifications) is warranted to minimize the differences in order to generate more reproducible metabolome data from different types of instruments.

Observation of charged droplets from electrospray ionization (ESI) plumes in API mass spectrometers

Electrospray ionization (ESI) generates bare analyte ions from charged droplets, which result from spraying a liquid in a strong electric field. Experimental observations available in the literature suggest that at least a significant fraction of the initially generated droplets remain large, have long lifetimes, and can thus aspirate into the inlet system of an atmospheric pressure ionization mass spectrometer (API-MS). We report on the observation of fragment signatures from charged droplets penetrating deeply the vacuum stages of three commercial mass spectrometer systems with largely different ion source and spray configurations. Charged droplets can pass through the ion source and pressure reduction stages and even into the mass analyzer region. Since droplet signatures were found in all investigated instruments, the incorporation of charged droplets is considered a general phenomenon occurring with common spray conditions in ESI sources.

Fluorescence-Based Detection of the Desolvation Process of Protein Ions Generated in an Aqueous Electrospray Plume

A new experimental setup to study laser-induced fluorescence from analytes at different locations in an electrospray plume has been developed. The high fluorescence collection efficiency (∼2%) of the setup, along with a sensitive charge coupled device (CCD) detector, enabled the study of low ion concentrations (down to ∼fM) in the plume. The use of small electrospray tip inner diameters (<1 μm) facilitated the fast desolvation of gaseous protein ions in an aqueous electrospray plume. Fluorescence spectra were acquired from specific locations along the plume axis in different aqueous electrospray plumes with three different analytes: a rhodamine dye and two proteins (ubiquitin and apomyoglobin) labeled with rhodamine dyes. To confirm the presence of gaseous ions, pure gas-phase fluorescence spectra were acquired in the vacuum of a modified ion trap mass spectrometer. These spectra were used to fit to confirm the presence of gaseous species in the corresponding spectra obtained from the electrospray plume. This study shows that with small inner diameter spray capillaries, gaseous protein ions generated at atmospheric pressure in an electrospray plume can be detected with fluorescence-based techniques. Fluorescence measurements can be used to study their structure in the electrospray plume, and the dynamics as they transition from solution to the gas phase and in the early stages after desolvation from charged droplets. Other techniques can also be applied to further study gaseous biomolecular structures under ambient conditions immediately after desolvation.

Electrohydrodynamics of Gas-Assisted Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

Gas-flow assistance is commonly used in ESI-MS for improved transport and desolvation, and fundamental understanding of the underlying phenomena is essential for improvement of aerodynamic interfaces that couple ESI sources and MS. For this purpose, an electrohydrodynamic model is developed for simulation of charged droplet dynamics under the combined effects of gas flow and electric fields with consideration of space charge interactions within the charged aerosol plume. The model is implemented in COMSOL by exploiting a formalism for establishing the droplet trajectories as a sequence of successive droplets ejected at a frequency defined by the electrospray current. The model is used to assess the effect of two distinct flow configurations and compared to the baseline care of electrospray without assist gas. The simulated flows are jet flows oriented coaxially with the ESI spray, with and without imposed vorticity (swirling). Droplet trajectory simulations of a bimodal droplet population consisting of large primary droplets and small progeny droplets reveal a unique capability for vortical assist jet flow to selectively transmit smaller droplets into the MS due to inertial separation. ESI-MS analysis of fluorinated phosphazines subjected to the different gas flow conditions supports the model predictions. The electrohydrodynamic model developed in this work provides a versatile tool to analyze and design aerodynamic ESI interfaces with rigorous incorporation of drag, inertia, and space-charge repulsion and can be used as a powerful simulation methodology for optimizing charged droplet transmission and ultimately improved analytical performance of gas-assisted ESI-MS workflows.

Ion optics simulation of an ion beam setup coupled to an electrospray ionization source, strengths, and limitations

A unified approach to achieve a start-to-end ion optics simulation of an ion beam apparatus coupled to an electrospray ionization source is presented. We demonstrate that simulations enable reliable information on the behavior and operation of the apparatus to be obtained, but due to the collisions with the buffer gas in the initial stages of the setup, the results concerning the kinetic energy of the ion beam must be treated with care.

Numerical Simulation of Flow Field and Ion Transport for Different Ion Source Sampling Interfaces of a Mass Spectrometer

Understanding ion transport mechanisms in the flow expansion section of the first vacuum region of a mass spectrometer (MS) with an atmospheric pressure ionization source is essential for optimizing the MS sampling interface design. In this study, numerical simulations of three types of ions in two different MS interface designs have been carried out. In contrast to previously reported numerical studies, nonequilibrium gas dynamics due to rarefied gas effects has been considered in modeling the flow expansion and a realistic space charge effect has been considered in a continuous ion injection mode. Numerical simulations reveal that a flat plate interface has a higher peak buffer gas velocity but a narrower zone of silence compared to the conical interface. Shock wave structures are clearly captured, and the Knudsen number distribution is displayed. Simulation results show that in the axial direction the buffer gas effect is much stronger than the electric force effect in the current configuration. The conical interface leads to both a strong ion acceleration in the zone of silence and a strong ion deceleration downstream. In the radial direction, both the electric force and buffer gas drag force play an important role. The conical interface introduces a relatively stronger ion focusing effect from the radial buffer gas effect and a stronger ion dispersion from the radial electric force than the flat plate interface. The net effect for the current configuration is an increase in ion losses for the conical interface. Nanoelectrospray ionization experiments were carried out to validate the ion transmission efficiency.

Aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter and its application in cardiac proteome analysis

The emitter clogging is the most common hardware failure of nano-electrospray ionization, to improve the durability and electrospray stability of fused silica emitters, we demonstrate a means of fabricating nano-electrospray emitters with controllable aperture size and gradually-narrowed channel on the tip. We simulated the fluid morphologies in the emitter channels by computational fluid dynamics and found more stable flow on aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter. Besides, we found the unstable flow sections of commercial emitters match the actual clogging sections very well, indicating the main cause of emitter clogging is unstable flow. We further tested the emitters by nano-LC-MS based proteome analysis. Compared with the commercial emitter, aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitters promoted the total ion chromatogram intensity by 25%, the number of identified proteins by 6.58%, and the number of identified peptides by 7.87%. In total, 989 proteins were identified from 1 μg of extracted mouse cardiac proteins. After the optimization by using mouse samples, we analyzed clinical auricular dextral tissues from patients undergoing cardiac surgery and found 16 proteins related to atrial fibrillation. Overall, aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter exhibits better sensitivity and reproducibility in the application of nano-LC-MS cardiac proteome analysis.