Bolt: a New Age Peptide Search Engine for Comprehensive MS/MS Sequencing Through Vast Protein Databases in Minutes

Critical steps in an environmental metaproteomics workflow

Environmental metaproteomics is a rapidly advancing field that provides insights into the structure, dynamics, and metabolic activity of microbial communities. As the field is still maturing, it lacks consistent workflows, making it challenging for non-expert researchers to navigate. This review aims to introduce the workflow of environmental metaproteomics. It outlines the standard practices for sample collection, processing, and analysis, and offers strategies to overcome the unique challenges presented by common environmental matrices such as soil, freshwater, marine environments, biofilms, sludge, and symbionts. The review also highlights the bottlenecks in data analysis that are specific to metaproteomics samples and provides suggestions for researchers to obtain high-quality datasets. It includes recent benchmarking studies and descriptions of software packages specifically built for metaproteomics analysis. The article is written without assuming the reader's familiarity with single-organism proteomic workflows, making it accessible to those new to proteomics or mass spectrometry in general. This primer for environmental metaproteomics aims to improve accessibility to this exciting technology and empower researchers to tackle challenging and ambitious research questions. While it is primarily a resource for those new to the field, it should also be useful for established researchers looking to streamline or troubleshoot their metaproteomics experiments.

Analyzing Posttranslational Modifications in Single Cells

With the rapid expansion of capabilities in the analysis of proteins in single cells, we can now identify multiple classes of protein posttranslational modifications on some of these proteins. Each new technology that has increased the number of proteins measured per cell has likewise increased our ability to identify and quantify modified peptides. In this chapter, I will discuss our current capabilities, concerns, and challenges specific to this emerging field of study and the inevitable demand for services, providing a general review of concepts that should be considered.

Database Creator for Mass Analysis of Peptides and Proteins, DC-MAPP: A Standalone Tool for Simplifying Manual Analysis of Mass Spectral Data to Identify Peptide/Protein Sequences

Proteomic studies typically involve the use of different types of software for annotating experimental tandem mass spectrometric data (MS/MS) and thereby simplifying the process of peptide and protein identification. For such annotations, these softwares calculate the m/z values of the peptide/protein precursor and fragment ions, for which a database of protein sequences must be provided as an input file. The calculated m/z values are stored as another database, which the user usually cannot view. Database Creator for Mass Analysis of Peptides and Proteins (DC-MAPP) is a novel standalone software that can create custom databases for "viewing" the calculated m/z values of precursor and fragment ions, prior to the database search. It contains three modules. Peptide/Protein sequences as per user's choice can be entered as input to the first module for creating a custom database. In the second module, m/z values must be queried-in, which are searched within the custom database to identify protein/peptide sequences. The third module is suited for peptide mass fingerprinting, which can be used to analyze both ESI and MALDI mass spectral data. The feature of "viewing" the custom database can be helpful not only for better understanding the search engine processes, but also for designing multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) methods. Post-translational modifications and protein isoforms can also be analyzed. Since, DC-MAPP relies on the protein/peptide "sequences" for creating custom databases, it may not be applicable for the searches involving spectral libraries. Python language was used for implementation, and the graphical user interface was built with Page/Tcl, making this tool more user-friendly. It is freely available at https://vit.ac.in/DC-MAPP/.

Optimizing single cell proteomics using trapped ion mobility spectrometry for label-free experiments

Although single cell RNA-seq has had a tremendous impact on biological research, a corresponding technology for unbiased mass spectrometric analysis of single cells has only recently become available. Significant technological breakthroughs including miniaturized sample handling have enabled proteome profiling of single cells. Furthermore, trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) in combination with parallel accumulation-serial fragmentation operated in data-dependent acquisition mode (DDA-PASEF) allowed improved proteome coverage from low-input samples. It has been demonstrated that modulating the ion flux in TIMS affects the overall performance of proteome profiling. However, the effect of TIMS settings on the analysis of low-input samples has been less investigated. Thus, we sought to optimize the conditions of TIMS with regard to ion accumulation/ramp times and ion mobility range for low-input samples. We observed that an ion accumulation time of 180 ms and monitoring a narrower ion mobility range from 0.7 to 1.3 V s cm-2 resulted in a substantial gain in the depth of proteome coverage and in detecting proteins with low abundance. We used these optimized conditions for proteome profiling of sorted human primary T cells, which yielded an average of 365, 804, 1116, and 1651 proteins from single, five, ten, and forty T cells, respectively. Notably, we demonstrated that the depth of proteome coverage from a low number of cells was sufficient to delineate several essential metabolic pathways and the T cell receptor signaling pathway. Finally, we showed the feasibility of detecting post-translational modifications including phosphorylation and acetylation from single cells. We believe that such an approach could be applied to label-free analysis of single cells obtained from clinically relevant samples.

Peptide Utility (PU) search server: A new tool for peptide sequence search from multiple databases

Proteins are essential building blocks in humans that have garnered huge attention from researchers worldwide due to their numerous therapeutic applications. To date, different computational tools have been developed to extract pre-existing information on these biological molecules, but most of these tools suffer from limitations such as non-user friendly interface, redundancy of data, etc. To overcome these limitations, a user-friendly interface, the Peptide Utility (PU) webserver (https://chain-searching.herokuapp.com/) has been developed for searching and analyzing homologous and identical protein/peptide sequences that can be searched from approximately 0.4 million sequences (structural and sequence information) in both online and offline modes. The PU web server can also be used to study different types of interactions in PDBSum, identifying the most dominating interface residues, the most prevalent interactions, and the interaction preferences of different residues. The webserver would also pave way for the design of novel therapeutic peptides and folds by identifying conserved residues in the three-dimensional structure space of proteins.

Reinspection of a Clinical Proteomics Tumor Analysis Consortium (CPTAC) Dataset with Cloud Computing Reveals Abundant Post-Translational Modifications and Protein Sequence Variants

The Clinical Proteomic Tumor Analysis Consortium (CPTAC) has provided some of the most in-depth analyses of the phenotypes of human tumors ever constructed. Today, the majority of proteomic data analysis is still performed using software housed on desktop computers which limits the number of sequence variants and post-translational modifications that can be considered. The original CPTAC studies limited the search for PTMs to only samples that were chemically enriched for those modified peptides. Similarly, the only sequence variants considered were those with strong evidence at the exon or transcript level. In this multi-institutional collaborative reanalysis, we utilized unbiased protein databases containing millions of human sequence variants in conjunction with hundreds of common post-translational modifications. Using these tools, we identified tens of thousands of high-confidence PTMs and sequence variants. We identified 4132 phosphorylated peptides in nonenriched samples, 93% of which were confirmed in the samples which were chemically enriched for phosphopeptides. In addition, our results also cover 90% of the high-confidence variants reported by the original proteogenomics study, without the need for sample specific next-generation sequencing. Finally, we report fivefold more somatic and germline variants that have an independent evidence at the peptide level, including mutations in ERRB2 and BCAS1. In this reanalysis of CPTAC proteomic data with cloud computing, we present an openly available and searchable web resource of the highest-coverage proteomic profiling of human tumors described to date.

The utilization of the search engine, Bolt, to decrease search time and increase peptide identifications in hydroxyl radical protein footprinting-based workflows

Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting (HRPF) utilizes hydroxyl radicals to covalently modify solvent exposed regions of proteins. When coupled with mass spectrometry, HRPF can provide insightful information on protein structural changes including inside cells. However, the complex mixture of proteins and modifications makes identification a complicated task. To search all of the HRPF-induced modification combinations across the full proteome, requires substantial computational power and still can take days to search. To drastically decrease processing time and improve identifications, a novel cloud-based search engine, Bolt, was used to search for HRPF modifications in comparison to a commonly used search engine, Sequest. A 35% increase in the identification of modified peptides was observed in Bolt compared to Sequest with a decrease in computation time.

Proteomes Are of Proteoforms: Embracing the Complexity

Proteomes are complex-much more so than genomes or transcriptomes. Thus, simplifying their analysis does not simplify the issue. Proteomes are of proteoforms, not canonical proteins. While having a catalogue of amino acid sequences provides invaluable information, this is the Proteome-lite. To dissect biological mechanisms and identify critical biomarkers/drug targets, we must assess the myriad of proteoforms that arise at any point before, after, and between translation and transcription (e.g., isoforms, splice variants, and post-translational modifications [PTM]), as well as newly defined species. There are numerous analytical methods currently used to address proteome depth and here we critically evaluate these in terms of the current 'state-of-the-field'. We thus discuss both pros and cons of available approaches and where improvements or refinements are needed to quantitatively characterize proteomes. To enable a next-generation approach, we suggest that advances lie in transdisciplinarity via integration of current proteomic methods to yield a unified discipline that capitalizes on the strongest qualities of each. Such a necessary (if not revolutionary) shift cannot be accomplished by a continued primary focus on proteo-genomics/-transcriptomics. We must embrace the complexity. Yes, these are the hard questions, and this will not be easy…but where is the fun in easy?

High Performance Computing Framework for Tera-Scale Database Search of Mass Spectrometry Data

Database peptide search algorithms deduce peptides from mass spectrometry (MS) data. There has been substantial effort in improving their computational efficiency to achieve larger and more complex systems biology studies. However, modern serial and high-performance computing (HPC) algorithms exhibit sub-optimal performance mainly due to their ineffective parallel designs (low resource utilization), and high overhead costs. We present an HPC framework, called HiCOPS, for efficient acceleration of the database peptide search algorithms on distributed-memory supercomputers. HiCOPS provides, on average, more than 10-fold improvement in speed, and superior parallel performance over several existing HPC database search software. We also formulate a mathematical model for performance analysis and optimization, and report near-optimal results for several key metrics including strong-scale efficiency, hardware utilization, load-balance, inter-process communication and I/O overheads. The core parallel design, techniques, and optimizations presented in HiCOPS are search-algorithm independent and can be extended to efficiently accelerate the existing and future algorithms and software.

Cloud Computing Based Immunopeptidomics Utilizing Community Curated Variant Libraries Simplifies and Improves Neo-Antigen Discovery in Metastatic Melanoma

Unique peptide neo-antigens presented on the cell surface are attractive targets for researchers in nearly all areas of personalized medicine. Cells presenting peptides with mutated or other non-canonical sequences can be utilized for both targeted therapies and diagnostics. Today's state-of-the-art pipelines utilize complementary proteogenomic approaches where RNA or ribosomal sequencing data helps to create libraries from which tandem mass spectrometry data can be compared. In this study, we present an alternative approach whereby cloud computing is utilized to power neo-antigen searches against community curated databases containing more than 7 million human sequence variants. Using these expansive databases of high-quality sequences as a reference, we reanalyze the original data from two previously reported studies to identify neo-antigen targets in metastatic melanoma. Using our approach, we identify 79 percent of the non-canonical peptides reported by previous genomic analyses of these files. Furthermore, we report 18-fold more non-canonical peptides than previously reported. The novel neo-antigens we report herein can be corroborated by secondary analyses such as high predicted binding affinity, when analyzed by well-established tools such as NetMHC. Finally, we report 738 non-canonical peptides shared by at least five patient samples, and 3258 shared across the two studies. This illustrates the depth of data that is present, but typically missed by lower statistical power proteogenomic approaches. This large list of shared peptides across the two studies, their annotation, non-canonical origin, as well as MS/MS spectra from the two studies are made available on a web portal for community analysis.

Evaluation of the Sensitivity of Proteomics Methods Using the Absolute Copy Number of Proteins in a Single Cell as a Metric

Proteomic technology has improved at a staggering pace in recent years, with even practitioners challenged to keep up with new methods and hardware. The most common metric used for method performance is the number of peptides and proteins identified. While this metric may be helpful for proteomics researchers shopping for new hardware, this is often not the most biologically relevant metric. Biologists often utilize proteomics in the search for protein regulators that are of a lower relative copy number in the cell. In this review, I re-evaluate untargeted proteomics data using a simple graphical representation of the absolute copy number of proteins present in a single cancer cell as a metric. By comparing single-shot proteomics data to the coverage of the most in-depth proteomic analysis of that cell line acquired to date, we can obtain a rapid metric of method performance. Using a simple copy number metric allows visualization of how proteomics has developed in both sensitivity and overall dynamic range when using both relatively long and short acquisition times. To enable reanalysis beyond what is presented here, two available web applications have been developed for single- and multi-experiment comparisons with reference protein copy number data for multiple cell lines and organisms.

Cloudy with a Chance of Peptides: Accessibility, Scalability, and Reproducibility with Cloud-Hosted Environments

Cloud-hosted environments offer known benefits when computational needs outstrip affordable local workstations, enabling high-performance computation without a physical cluster. What has been less apparent, especially to novice users, is the transformative potential for cloud-hosted environments to bridge the digital divide that exists between poorly funded and well-resourced laboratories, and to empower modern research groups with remote personnel and trainees. Using cloud-based proteomic bioinformatic pipelines is not predicated on analyzing thousands of files, but instead can be used to improve accessibility during remote work, extreme weather, or working with under-resourced remote trainees. The general benefits of cloud-hosted environments also allow for scalability and encourage reproducibility. Since one possible hurdle to adoption is awareness, this paper is written with the nonexpert in mind. The benefits and possibilities of using a cloud-hosted environment are emphasized by describing how to setup an example workflow to analyze a previously published label-free data-dependent acquisition mass spectrometry data set of mammalian urine. Cost and time of analysis are compared using different computational tiers, and important practical considerations are described. Overall, cloud-hosted environments offer the potential to solve large computational problems, but more importantly can enable and accelerate research in smaller research groups with inadequate infrastructure and suboptimal local computational resources.

Proteome Discoverer-A Community Enhanced Data Processing Suite for Protein Informatics

Proteomics researchers today face an interesting challenge: how to choose among the dozens of data processing and analysis pipelines available for converting tandem mass spectrometry files to protein identifications. Due to the dominance of Orbitrap technology in proteomics in recent history, many researchers have defaulted to the vendor software Proteome Discoverer. Over the fourteen years since the initial release of the software, it has evolved in parallel with the increasingly complex demands faced by proteomics researchers. Today, Proteome Discoverer exists in two distinct forms with both powerful commercial versions and fully functional free versions in use in many labs today. Throughout the 11 main versions released to date, a central theme of the software has always been the ability to easily view and verify the spectra from which identifications are made. This ability is, even today, a key differentiator from other data analysis solutions. In this review I will attempt to summarize the history and evolution of Proteome Discoverer from its first launch to the versions in use today.

Methods for Proteogenomics Data Analysis, Challenges, and Scalability Bottlenecks: A Survey

Big Data Proteogenomics lies at the intersection of high-throughput Mass Spectrometry (MS) based proteomics and Next Generation Sequencing based genomics. The combined and integrated analysis of these two high-throughput technologies can help discover novel proteins using genomic, and transcriptomic data. Due to the biological significance of integrated analysis, the recent past has seen an influx of proteogenomic tools that perform various tasks, including mapping proteins to the genomic data, searching experimental MS spectra against a six-frame translation genome database, and automating the process of annotating genome sequences. To date, most of such tools have not focused on scalability issues that are inherent in proteogenomic data analysis where the size of the database is much larger than a typical protein database. These state-of-the-art tools can take more than half a month to process a small-scale dataset of one million spectra against a genome of 3 GB. In this article, we provide an up-to-date review of tools that can analyze proteogenomic datasets, providing a critical analysis of the techniques' relative merits and potential pitfalls. We also point out potential bottlenecks and recommendations that can be incorporated in the future design of these workflows to ensure scalability with the increasing size of proteogenomic data. Lastly, we make a case of how high-performance computing (HPC) solutions may be the best bet to ensure the scalability of future big data proteogenomic data analysis.

PRiSM: A prototype for exhaustive, restriction-free database searching for mass spectrometry-based identification

RATIONALE

The current methods for identifying peptides in mass spectral product ion data still struggle to do so for the majority of spectra. Based on the experimental setup and other assumptions, such methods restrict the search space to speed up computations, but at the cost of creating blind spots. The proteomics community would greatly benefit from a method that is capable of covering the entire search space without using any restrictions, thus establishing a baseline for identification.

METHODS

We conceived the "mass pattern paradigm" (MPP) that enables the creation of such an identification method, and we implemented it into a prototype database search engine "PRiSM" (PRotein-Spectrum Matching). We then assessed its operational characteristics by applying it to publicly available high-precision mass spectra of low and high identification difficulty. We used those characteristics to gain theoretical insights into trade-offs between sensitivity and speed when trying to establish a baseline for identification.

RESULTS

Of 100 low difficulty spectra, PRiSM and SEQUEST agree on 84 identifications (of which 75 are statistically significant). Of 15 of 100 spectra not identified in a previous study (using SEQUEST), 13 are considered reliable after visual inspection and represent 3 proteins (out of 9 in total) not detected previously.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite leaving noise intact, the simple PRiSM prototype can make statistically reliable identifications, while controlling the false discovery rate by fitting a null distribution. It also identifies some spectra previously unidentifiable in an "extremely open" SEQUEST search, paving the way to establishing a baseline for identification in proteomics.

Detection and verification of 2.3 million cancer mutations in NCI60 cancer cell lines with a cloud search engine

Today we have unprecedented access to human genomic and proteomic data that appear to be rapidly approaching our current understanding of comprehensive coverage. Combining genomic information with shotgun proteomics remains challenging due to the large increase in proteomics search space. However, making this connection between genomic and proteomic information is critical for cancer studies to vaccine development. Furthermore, as we progress towards personalized medicine, it will be essential for proteomics analysis to identify individual mutations and variants in order to fully understand protein networks and to develop personalized therapies. While these advantages are well-established, only a few studies have demonstrated the successful integration of proteomic data with large genomic input. We present and examine the abilities of Bolt, a new cloud-based proteomics search engine to search for the presence of over 2.3 million known cancer mutations in a matter of minutes while still performing a standard proteomics search that includes 31 post translational modifications. We use previously published proteomics data sets and identify mutations that are verified using genomic studies as well as previous proteomics efforts. Our results also emphasize the need to search for mutations in a comprehensive manner while still searching for both common and rare PTMs. SIGNIFICANCE: We present and examine the abilities of Bolt, a new cloud-based proteomics search engine to search for the presence of over 2.3 million known cancer mutations in a matter of minutes while still performing a standard proteomics search that includes 31 post translational modifications. No other proteomics search software can do so.