Large cell carcinoma of the lung: a highly aggressive tumor with dismal prognosis

Results of surgical resection for patients with large cell carcinoma of the lung

PURPOSE

The clinical features of large cell carcinoma (LCC) of the lung have remained unclear due to the low incidence of the disease. This study investigated the clinicopathological features and the surgical outcome in patients with LCC.

SUBJECTS

This study clinicopathologically evaluated 975 patients who had undergone a resection for non-small cell carcinoma between 1994 and 2007. There were 57 (5.8%) patients with LCC among them.

RESULTS

The LCC patients included 49 males and 8 females and included 9 patients with large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma. All patients excluding 1 had a smoking habit. The mean smoking pack-year index was 49.9 in the patients with LCC, 27.1 in 625 patients with adenocarcinoma, and 52.5 in 266 patients with squamous cell carcinoma, and this was significantly higher in the patients with LCC than in those with adenocarcinoma. The mean tumor diameter was 38 mm for LCC, 28 mm for adenocarcinoma, and 39 mm for squamous cell carcinoma. The pathological stage was IA in 11 patients, IB in 11, II in 12, IIIA in 16, IIIB in 5, and IV in 2. The post-operative 5-year survival rate was 60.5% for LCC, 64.3% for large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma, 67.0% for adenocarcinoma, and 50.1% for squamous cell carcinoma.

CONCLUSION

The tumor diameter was significantly larger for LCC than for adenocarcinoma at the time of diagnosis. The proportion of smokers and the smoking pack-year index in patients with LCC were significantly higher than those of adenocarcinoma. The surgical results were similar between LCC and other non-small cell lung carcinomas.

Clinical features of bronchogenic large cell carcinoma confirmed by surgical resection

BACKGROUND

To define the final outcome of large cell carcinomas (LCC) after surgical treatment, the histopathology, clinical features and follow-up results of 28 cases were reviewed.

METHODS

Twenty eight patients, with LCC that underwent a surgical resection between 1986 and 2001, at the Severance Hospital, were retrospectively reviewed. We analyzed clinical data, radiological findings, pathologic findings, treatment modalities, and survival.

RESULTS

The prevalence of LCC was 2.9% (29 cases) among the surgically resected primary lung cancer cases (1003 cases) during the 15 year period of the study. The mean age of the patients was 59 years old, with 25 male cases. There were 23 smokers, smoking an average of 33 pack years. A cough was the most frequent symptom. There were 15 cases located in the peripheral part of the lung and 26 consisted of a lobulated mass. From a chest CT scan, 26 cases had necrotic portions, which appeared to be low density. The postoperative stages were IA, IB, IIB, IIIA and IV in 1 (3.6%), 11 (39.3%) 8 (28.5%), 7 (25%), 1 case (3.6%), respectively. The concordance rate of the pre- and postoperative stage was 43%. The median survival time and 5 year-survival rate were 54.5 months and 45%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggested that a LCC in the lung was predominant in males, and equally located at the center and periphery of the lung in the surgically resected cases. To define the treatment outcome and risk factors of a LCC of the lung, further multicenter studies are needed.

Large cell carcinoma of the lung: results of resection for a cure

OBJECTIVE

The effectiveness of surgical resection of large cell undifferentiated carcinoma of the lung remains poorly defined because of the histology's relatively low frequency, the tendency for presentation with high-stage disease, and the failure in most published series to separate large cell carcinomas from the other variants of non-small cell lung carcinoma. To define the effectiveness of surgical treatment of large cell carcinoma, we reviewed the Mayo Clinic experience over a 5-year period.

METHODS

We have retrospectively reviewed the Mayo Clinic experience with 61 patients with large cell carcinoma and 17 patients with adenocarcinoma with focal mucin production who came to surgical resection during the 5-year period of January 1, 1982, through December 31, 1986.

RESULTS

One-hundred percent 5-year follow-up was obtained. For the 61 patients with large cell carcinoma, the overall 5-year survival was 37%. Five-year survival for those with stage I tumors was 58% (n = 31), stage II 33% (n = 6), stage IIIA 15% (n = 20), stage IIIB 0% (n = 2), and stage IV 0% (n = 2). No significant differences in survival were detected between the 61 patients with large cell carcinoma and the 17 patients with solid adenocarcinoma with mucin production.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that there is a subset of patients with large cell carcinoma of the lung who can undergo resection with a reasonable expectation of long-term survival and that this survival is, stage for stage, comparable to or only slightly less than that achieved with other non-small cell lung carcinomas.

Accelerated apoptosis and low bcl-2 expression associated with neuroendocrine differentiation predict shortened survival in operated large cell carcinoma of the lung

In order to test the hypothesis that increased apoptotic activity is connected with neuroendocrine differentiation and low differentiation degree in large cell carcinoma (LCLC) and is regulated by bcl-2 family proteins, we analysed the extent of apoptosis and tumor necrosis and their relation to the expression of bcl-2, bax, bak and mcl-1 in 35 LCLCs, of which 20 were classified as large cell neuroendocrine lung carcinomas (LCNEC) and 15 as large cell non-neuroendocrine lung carcinomas (LCNNEC). The extent of apoptosis was determined by detecting and counting the relative and absolute numbers of apoptotic cells and bodies using in situ 3 -end labelling of the apoptotic DNA. The extent and intensity of expression of the bcl-2, bax, bak and mcl-1 proteins were studied by immunohistochemistry. Also the relative volume density of necrosis was evaluated and correlated with the other parameters. Finally, all the parameters were evaluated as prognostic markers and correlated with data on the survival of the patients. Relatively high apoptotic indices were seen in both tumor types (average for both 2.53%, range 0.09 27.01%). Significantly higher bcl-2 and bak indices were detected more often in LCNECs than in LCNNECs. Immunohistochemically detected bax, bcl-2 and bak expression was independent of apoptotic index in both tumor types, while there was a statistically significant positive association between mcl-1 expression and apoptotic index in LCNNEC but not in LCNEC. There was a statistically significant association between high apoptotic index and shortened survival in LCLC. However, no association was found between tumor stage and apoptosis. The patients with LCNEC and low bcl-2 protein expression had a significantly shorter survival time than those with high bcl-2 indices. There was also a clear association between shortened survival and necrotic LCNNEC. LCLCs show relatively high apoptotic activity, which is associated with shortened survival. The expression of bcl-2, bak and mcl- 1 is associated with neuroendocrine differentiation in LCLC. Finally, our results support some previous reports suggesting that bcl-2 expression in combination with some other markers involved in apoptosis and/or proliferation may be of prognostic value in cases of lung carcinoma with neuroendocrine differentiation.

Survival after resection of stage II non-small cell lung cancer

From 1973 to 1989, 214 patients with stage II non-small cell lung cancer were treated by resection and complete mediastinal lymph node dissection. There were 116 adenocarcinomas and 98 squamous cancers. There were 35 T1 N1 and 179 T2 N1 tumors. Whereas T1 tumors were mainly adenocarcinomas (83%), this difference was not apparent in T2 lesions. Regardless of histology, half of the patients had a single involved N1 lymph node. Lobectomy was performed in 68% of the patients, pneumonectomy in 31%, and wedge resection or segmentectomy in 1%. Lobectomy was sufficient to encompass all disease in 34 of 35 T1 N1 tumors. Only 48 patients (22%) received postoperative external irradiation and 11 patients (5%) received chemotherapy. The overall 5-year disease-free survival was 39%. The best survival rates were in patients who had a single node involved and tumors 3 cm or less in diameter (48%). The pattern of recurrence differed by histology. Local or regional recurrence was more frequent in patients with squamous carcinoma whereas distant metastases were more commonly seen in adenocarcinomas (87%) with brain as the most frequent site (adenocarcinoma, 52%; squamous, 34%). It is concluded that in stage II carcinomas, resection remains the treatment of choice, that mediastinal lymph node dissection provides the most accurate staging, and that the best adjuvant treatment to improve survival is yet to be determined.