Regulation on murine T cell responses to autologous antigens by alpha-fetoprotein

Embryonic antigens in malignancy and pregnancy: common denominators in immune regulation

There is mounting that the majority of malignant tumours of humans and rodents carry embryonic determinants (EA) associated with the cell membrane. The evolutionary and developmental purpose of these determinants seems to be related to their biochemical and structural role in the cell membrane. True EAs are uniquely expressed on germinal, embryonic and some fetal cell membranes and are not expressed in adult tissues nor in regenerating tissues. The immunological role of EA in fetal development in utero is still obscure. It is known that maternal IgG and cytotoxic T lymphocytes are produced in response to EA expressed in utero. Immunoregulatory interactions between suppressor, helper and cytotoxic T lymphocytes sensitized to EA during pregnancy have been detected in mice and hamsters bearing a variety of tumours. The same immunological events may occur in humans. The biological product of the retrogenic process that leads to the expression of EA in the emerging malignant cell clone seems to be intimately associated with the promotion of tumour-protective immune responses in the host which mimic the immune responses in pregnancy aimed at protecting the EA+ fetus from maternal immune attack. The description of the immunoregulatory perturbations generated by EA during the induction of cancer may eventually provide effective and predictable attack points for immunological intervention in the control of malignancy. This paper describes methods for detecting EA and considers some immunoregulatory traits found in response to EA expression.

Evidence that immunosuppression is an intrinsic property of the alpha-fetoprotein molecule

Among the proteins that comprise the albumin family, alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) is the only member which exhibits immunoregulatory properties. However, some investigations have argued that AFP-mediated immunosuppression is not an inherent property of the molecule itself, but is instead, hypothesized to be either a function of a low molecular weight inhibitor bound to AFP or to a post-translational modification of the protein. AFP cannot be isolated from natural sources in quantities sufficient for the detailed biochemical and functional analyses required to resolve these issues. We have therefore produced recombinant forms of the protein (rAFP) by cloning the cDNA's for mouse and human AFP in both eukaryotic and prokaryotic expression systems. As described in this report, we were able to abundantly express rAFP's in bacterial, baculovirus and yeast expression systems. Recombinant proteins derived from each expression system were recognized by polyclonal and monoclonal anti-AFP antibodies as determined by immunoblot analysis. Pure recombinant protein samples, as characterized by polyacrylamide gel analyses, N-terminal sequencing and FPLC and HPLC chromatography, were evaluated for their immunoregulatory properties in murine and human in vitro immunological assays. The results of these studies establish that rAFP is functionally equivalent to natural fetal derived AFP molecules. Importantly, the data reported here demonstrate that AFP-mediated immunoregulation is an activity intrinsic to the molecule itself and cannot be attributed to either putative non-covalently bound moieties or to post-translational modifications such as glycosylation and sialylation. These studies provide a basis for initiating detailed investigations into the potential clinical usefulness of AFP as an immunotherapeutic agent.

Modulation of restricted class II T cell responses by peptides derived from self class II molecule

We have explored the possibility of using peptides derived from a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II (I-Ab) molecule to modulate I-Ab-restricted T cell responses. Six peptides spanning the polymorphic regions of I-Ab were analyzed for competitive binding to the I-Ab molecule, and for efficacies in blocking I-Ab-specific T cell response. Only PB1 (residues 75-91 of beta chain) bound the I-Ab molecule with high affinity. When these MHC-derived peptides were administered simultaneously with antigen, PB1 effectively inhibited I-Ab-restricted T cell responses as well as another peptide PB2 (residues 59-78 of beta chain). PB2 inhibited specific T cell response only when it was administered simultaneously with antigen. Since PB2 is a weak binder of I-Ab, an additional mechanism must account for its inhibitory activity. Both PB1 and PB2 peptides elicited specific T cell responses, indicating that these peptides were not tolerogenic in syngeneic mice. However, the induction of T cells in response to PB1 and PB2 did not increase reactivity to I-Ab. MHC class II-derived peptides thus can be used to regulate T cell responses without the risk of autoreactivity.

Isolation and characterization of a distinct immunoregulatory isoform of alpha-fetoprotein produced by the normal fetus

In this report, we examine the functional significance of the molecular microheterogeneity of alpha-fetoprotein (AFP). In doing so, we have taken the direct approach of purifying the naturally occurring isomeric forms of fetal-derived AFP using a preparative anion exchange column linked to an automated fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC) system followed by parallel testing of each isolated molecular variant for in vitro immunoregulatory activity. The data obtained demonstrate the presence of seven distinct variants of AFP as defined by their retention volumes on FPLC elution profiles, by their pIs on analytical IEF gels, and by Western blot analysis. Molecular mass determination by SDS-PAGE showed each isomer to be equivalent in size to 69,000-dalton native unfractionated AFP molecules. All the immunosuppressive activity of AFP was localized to a single variant representing only 6% of the total composition of native AFP. The immunoregulating isomer termed AFP-1 was the least acidic of the seven isolated variants with a pI of 5.1 and displayed a sialic acid content of 1 mol/mol of protein. The inhibitory activity of AFP-1 could be readily measured on T cell-dependent antibody synthesis, Con A-induced stimulation of Lyt-1+23- thymocyte DNA synthesis, and lymphokine-activated NK cell activity. All other isomers were without effect in these test systems. The immunosuppressive AFP-1 isomer also displayed the strongest growth-promoting influence on cultured bone marrow lymphocytes. There was no correlation between functional activity and degree of expression of sialic acid residues on the AFP molecules. These findings demonstrate that the immunoregulating function of AFP is confined to a distinct and relatively small subpopulation of native AFP molecules and should therefore contribute to the resolution of outstanding questions regarding the structure/function relationship of this onco-fetal glycoprotein.

Anti-proliferative action of murine alpha-fetoprotein on activated T-lymphocytes

Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) is the dominant serum glycoprotein of fetal life but is expressed only in low nanogram levels in adult sera. A possible explanation for this is that AFP has immunoregulatory properties which may be essential during early ontogeny but unnecessary, if not harmful, in adulthood. The current study shows that the interleukin 2 (IL-2)-dependent division of Lyt 2- T blast cells previously activated in autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (AMLR) or by stimulation with concanavalin A (Con A) is susceptible to inhibition by AFP. This anti-proliferative activity appears to be independent of any competitive interaction with either IL-2 or I-A antigens and is therefore likely to result from a direct action of AFP on the T cells. These findings support the hypothesis that naturally occurring elevated levels of AFP may be involved in the protection of the conceptus from potentially harmful maternal anti-fetal reactivity and in the establishment and maintenance of T-helper cell tolerance to antigens encountered during early life.

Altered immune response patterns in murine syngeneic pregnancy: presence of natural null suppressor cells in maternal spleen identifiable by monoclonal antibodies

Expression of certain autologous lymphocyte-activating antigenic determinants on the developing embryo is known to provide a stimulus for maternal anti-fetal autoproliferative responses. If left unregulated these responses could exert negative influences on the reproductive process by converting to autoaggressive forms of immune reactivity. In normal circumstances, immunological reactions of this nature are therefore likely to be under the control of pregnancy-associated immunoregulatory elements found within the maternal/fetal environment. In the present investigation we describe a naturally occurring splenic inhibitory cell type devoid of conventional T, B, and macrophage surface markers associated with syngeneic murine pregnancy that is capable of exerting potent immunosuppressive effects on an in vitro expression of fetal/newborn T cell autoreactivity, namely the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). Maternal spleen cells inhibitory for AMLR were found to be highly resistant to cytotoxic pretreatment with a panel of conventional antisera directed against T cell-specific antigenic determinants. The non-T nature of the natural splenic suppressor cell was further indicated by experiments showing that purified spleen T cells had no inhibitory activity. Pregnancy spleen cell populations that were effectively depleted of macrophages retained full ability to inhibit AMLR. Maternal suppressor activity could be localized to the spleen cell population bearing receptors for the B cell-specific lectin, soybean agglutinin (SBA). A panel of monoclonal antibodies prepared against enriched populations of suppressor cells was screened and selected for specific reactivity using an ELISA against glutaraldehyde-fixed SBA+ spleen cell subpopulations from pregnant versus virgin animals. Several of the monoclonals developed against suppressor-enriched spleen cell populations from isopregnant as well as allopregnant animals were effective in reducing or eliminating suppressor cell activity following cytotoxic pretreatment in the presence of complement. The novel set of anti-suppressor monoclonal antibodies described here should prove useful in furthering the isolation and characterization of pregnancy-associated suppressor cells and in determining their relationship to natural suppressor cell populations described in other systems.

Antigen presentation by neonatal murine spleen cells

The ability of murine neonatal spleen cells to present soluble antigen to T-helper cells and to produce growth factors in response to subsequent cellular interactions was studied. The T-helper-cell line (D10-G4.1) (D10), which is specific for the soluble antigen conalbumin presented on H-2-matched (H-2k) antigen-presenting cells, was used as cooperating and indicator cells in these cellular interactions. The D10 cells are TH2 T-helper cells which secrete the autocrine growth factor IL-4 and can also respond to exogenous IL-2 (T. R. Mosmann and R. L. Coffmann, Immunol. Today 8, 223, 1987). D10 cells require exogenous IL-1 for their proliferation and secrete, in addition to IL-4, IL-1 inducer factor and GM-CSF. The ability of neonatal spleen cells to present antigen and to stimulate D10 cells to produce IL-4 and proliferate is low. During antigen presentation there is an augmentation of IL-1 and IL-2 production by the antigen-presenting spleen cell population. However, neonatal spleen cells do not respond to the same levels as do adult spleen cells. The addition of exogenous IL-1 cannot repair the antigen presentation by neonatal cells. Experiments in which the antigen processing and presentation steps were separated from those requiring growth factor induction and secretion demonstrate that neonatal spleen cells are impaired in their ability to perform adequate antigen processing and presentation. The neonatal spleen cells are as competent as adult cells to cooperate with T-helper cells and secrete growth factors, provided antigen processing and presentation is performed by fully competent adult spleen cells. Experiments in which neonatal and adult antigen-presenting spleen cell populations were mixed, and others in which plastic adherent and nonadherent cells were separated, could not detect any suppressor mechanisms responsible for the low antigen presentation of neonatal cells. Thus, neonatal spleen cells are impaired in the initial stages of antigen processing and presentation. This impairment which leads to low levels of growth factor production is the major determinant in the ineffectual stimulation of T-helper cells by neonatal spleen cells.

Specific helper T cell reactivity against autologous erythrocytes implies that self tolerance need not depend on clonal deletion

Using a culture system which supports primary T cell proliferative responses to various antigens we have detected mouse red blood cell (RBC)-reactive T cells in lymphoid tissues from untreated mice. The release of significant amounts of interleukin 2 (IL2) indicates that T helper (or helper/inducer) cells are activated by stimulation with RBC. Upon restimulation in vitro these cells proliferate specifically against mouse RBC with the kinetics and magnitude characteristic of a secondary response. Since autologous RBC are tolerated in vivo in spite of the presence of such specifically reactive T helper cells, these findings imply that self tolerance, even to certain nonsequestered antigens, may depend largely on regulatory mechanisms rather than on clonal deletion or inactivation.

Murine neonatal spleen contains natural T and non-T suppressor cells capable of inhibiting adult alloreactive and newborn autoreactive T-cell proliferation

The spleen of neonatal mice is known to be a rich source of cells capable of suppressing a variety of immune functions of adult lymphocytes in vitro. From such observations has emerged the concept that the gradual development in ability to express immune functions after birth is due in part to the parallel normal physiological decay of naturally occurring regulatory suppressor cells. There is, however, some confusion in the literature as to the exact nature of the newborn of the newborn inhibitory cell type(s). In contrast to most previous reports which detect only a single type of neonatal suppressor cell, usually a T cell, we show here that newborn spleen harbors both T and non-T inhibitory cells. Both types of suppressor cells could be shown to suppress the proliferative response of adult spleen to alloantigens as well as newborn T cells reacting against self-Ia antigen in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). Newborn suppressor T cells were characterized as being non-adherent to Ig-anti-Ig affinity columns, soybean agglutinin receptor negative (SBA-), and susceptible to lysis by anti-T-cell specific antiserum plus complement. Non-T suppressor cells were identified as non-phagocytic, SBA receptor positive (SBA+), and resistant to cytotoxic treatment with anti-T-cell antibodies and complement. The apparent controversy surrounding previous reports as to the T versus non-T nature of newborn suppressor cells can be reconciled by the present observation that both types of inhibitory cells coexist in the spleen. Furthermore, the demonstration that newborn suppressor cells can effectively regulate T-cell proliferative activity mediated by other newborn cells provides more direct support for the contention that such inhibitory cells play a physiological role in controlling immune responsiveness during early ontogeny.

Suppression by alpha-fetoprotein of murine natural killer cell activity stimulated in vitro and in vivo by interferon and interleukin 2

Natural killer (NK) cells are 'spontaneously' cytotoxic cells thought to be involved in surveillance against tumour cells, rejection of virally infected cells, and regulation of haematopoietic stem cell differentiation and antibody synthesis. Fetus-derived alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) has been shown to regulate certain T cell-mediated immune reactions in vitro and in vivo. The lack of NK activity in newborn mice with high endogenous levels of AFP, together with the presence of cells expressing NK surface markers, also suggests that AFP may regulate NK activity. In this study we compared the effects of AFP on spontaneous versus activated murine NK activity. The lytic ability of both freshly prepared splenic NK cells and those arising after incubation for 24 h with interferon, Poly I:C, or T-cell growth factor (TCGF) was not affected by AFP if the latter was present only during the killing phase. However, if AFP was added at the beginning and retained for the duration of the 24-h in vitro lymphokine stimulation, the subsequent NK activity induced by interferon, Poly I:C, and TCGF was found to be significantly suppressed. This inhibition is both dose- and time-dependent. Delayed addition experiments showed that when AFP is present during the first 6 h of in vitro stimulation it will suppress interferon and TCGF-boosted NK activity by 50-80%. The AFP-mediated inhibitory effect on lymphokine-stimulated NK activity is not the result of increased death of effector cells nor, in the case of interferon and polyribonucleotides, of non-specific binding of AFP to the enhancing agents. In vivo injections of Poly I:C or TCGF failed to increase neonatal NK function, while administration of interferon did cause slightly higher levels of NK activity. However, spleen cells from newborn animals cultured for 24 h in the presence of lymphokines resulted in markedly elevated NK function and this in vitro activation could be suppressed by purified fetus-derived AFP. Thus, the in vivo pattern of NK activation in newborns with high endogenous levels of AFP was very similar to that of adult NK stimulation in vitro when exogenous AFP was added.

Increased maternal T cell autoreactivity associated with syngeneic murine pregnancy

In this study T cells isolated from isopregnant and virgin CBA/J mice were examined for reactivity to self antigen(s) in vitro and in vivo. The autoproliferative capacity of maternal versus virgin T cells was tested in vitro using autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (AMLR). The popliteal lymph node (PLN) assay was used to compare the ability of maternal versus virgin T lymphocytes to mediate syngeneic graft-versus-host (SGvH) reactions in vivo. Splenic T cells obtained from pregnant animals near term were found to be approximately 10-fold more reactive towards syngeneic virgin non-T stimulator cells in AMLR than splenic T lymphocytes from age-matched virgin animals. In addition, T cells isolated from the spleens of gravid CBA/J mice displayed a significantly enhanced capacity to mediate SGvH reactions in virgin CBA/J females as measured by regional lymph node enlargement. These findings indicate that syngeneic murine pregnancy is accompanied by an increase in autoreactive T cell activity.

In vitro activation of bone marrow-derived T-and non-T-cell subsets by alpha-fetoprotein

Alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP) is a major serum glycoprotein during embryonic and early postnatal life. A number of diverse biologic functions have been attributed to AFP, including osmotic and carrier function and immunosuppressive activity. In this study we demonstrate that AFP selectively stimulates in vitro proliferation of two distinct subsets of adult murine bone marrow cells. One population of AFP-reactive bone marrow cells expresses surface receptors for soybean agglutinin (SBA) lectin. SBA+ bone marrow cells are resistant to cytotoxic pretreatment with T-cell-specific antisera and are not retained on Ig-anti-Ig affinity columns. The absence of conventional T- and B-cell markers, coupled with the presence of SBA receptors, suggests that AFP-activated non-T bone marrow cells may belong to an immature set of B lymphocytes. A second population of AFP-responsive bone marrow cells expresses the Thy-1+ Lyt 1+2- phenotype characteristic of conventional mature adult T helper cells. The potential physiological relevance of the mitogenic effects of AFP on bone marrow cells with respect to immunoregulatory processes in the fetal/newborn environments is discussed.

Quantitative variation in la antigen expression plays a central role in immune regulation

The analysis of la antigen function has focused primarily on allelic variants of Ia molecules. In this review Charles Janeway and his colleagues discuss evidence that quantitative rather than qualitative variation in Ia antigen expression had a major role in immunoregulation and immunologically mediated disease.

Investigations concerning the correlation between liver cell proliferation, production of alpha-fetoprotein, and DNA-synthesis of lymphocytes in the spleen of NMRI-mice. An autoradiographic and immunohistochemical study

To obtain more information concerning the correlation between liver cell proliferation, production of alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP) and DNA-synthesis of lymphocytes in the central and peripheral parts of periarteriolar lymphatic sheaths ( PALS ) of the spleen, these parameters were monitored in intervals of 12h after CCl4-poisoning of NMRI-mice using autoradiographic and immunohistochemical methods. The results indicate that synthesis of AFP is not linked closely to proliferation of hepatocytes because in contrast to DNA-synthesis the production of AFP was only detectable in a very small subpopulation of liver parenchymal cells reaching a peak before the majority of hepatocytes was found to enter the S-phase of the cell cycle. Beyond this, in vivo no general suppressive effect of AFP on proliferation of lymphocytes in preferably T-dependent areas of the spleen could be detected since the 3H-TdR-labeling index in these compartments increased, reaching a peak 48h after the maximum of hepatocytes producing AFP had occurred.

Regeneration and the immune system. II. Suppressor activities of lymphocytes activated in vivo by liver regeneration and their genetic control

The lymph node cells (LNC) activated in vivo by liver regeneration following partial hepatectomy of mice (primed lymph node cells) respond to regenerating liver cells in vitro with typical secondary immune response characteristics (Miyahara, S. et al., Eur. J. Immunol. 1983. 13: 878). These LNC activated in vivo suppress the proliferation of responder lymphocytes cultured with mitomycin C-treated regenerating syngeneic liver cells (sMLHLR). The suppressive activity was already present in LNC 4 days after partial hepatectomy and remained unchanged for at least 16 days. These primed LNC were effective not only on sMLHLR but also on syngeneic mixed lymphocyte culture (sMLR) and allogeneic mixed lymphocyte culture, of which responder cells share the I-A (I-B) subregions of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) with primed LNC. At least one cell in the suppressor circuit is a T cell. The primed LNC restimulates in vitro with regenerating liver cells (in vitro reactivated primed LNC) suppressed the proliferation of syngeneic responder cells in sMLR, but not of cells from congeneic mice differing from the in vitro reactivated primed LNC at a cluster of genes linked to the Ig locus. Thus the suppressive activity of primed LNC is controlled by the I-A (I-B) subregions of the MHC and that of in vitro reactivated primed LNC by genes in the Ig region. The role of these suppressive cells in liver regeneration is discussed.

Naturally occurring non-T suppressor cells in pregnant and neonatal mice: some functional and phenotypic characteristics

The mammalian fetus thrives in the presence of a maternal immune system which is considered capable of initiating an aggressive reaction against alloantigens expressed on fetal cells. The control of harmful immunological reactions during pregnancy may be due in part to the combined action of soluble immunoregulatory factors and suppressor cells in the maternal/fetal environments. In the present investigation, a comparison has been made between naturally occurring splenic suppressor cells isolated from neonatal and pregnant adult CBA/J mice. Functional analysis of inhibitory activity was carried out using conventional one-way allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) consisting of adult CBA/J spleen cells responding against mitomycin C-inactivated BALB/cJ spleen cells. Suppressor cells in the spleen of pregnant animals as well as a population of inhibitory cells in newborn spleen could be shown to be highly resistant to cytotoxic pretreatment with anti-T cell serum plus complement. Both newborn and pregnant non-T suppressor cells were shown to be agglutinated by the B cell-specific lectin soybean agglutinin. The densities of these two populations of non-T inhibitory cells, as determined by Percoll gradient centrifugation, were demonstrated to be very similar (ie, within the range of 1.067 to 1.043 g/ml). The striking parallels in the functional and phenotypic characteristics of the non-T suppressor lymphocytes found in the spleen of pregnant and neonatal animals suggest a common mechanism for their induction.