Transmembrane orientation of α-helices and the organization of chlorophylls in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes

Tribute in memory of Jacques Breton (1942-2018)

Jacques Breton spent his 39 years of professional life at Saclay, a center of the French Atomic Energy Commission. He studied photosynthesis with various advanced biophysical tools, often developed by himself and his numerous coworkers, obtaining a large number of new information on the structure and the functioning of antenna and of reaction centers of plants and bacteria: excitation migration in the antenna, orientation of molecules, rate of primary reactions, binding of pigments and electron transfer cofactors. Although it is much too short to illustrate his impressive work, we hope that this contribution will help maintaining the souvenir of Jacques Breton as an active and enthusiastic person, full of qualities, devoted to research and to his family as well. We include personal comments from N. E. Geacintov, A. Dobek, W. Leibl, M. Vos and W. W. Parson.

Protein structure modelling of the bacterial light-harvesting complex

Protein structure modelling offers a method of obtaining 3-dimensional information that can be tested and used to plan mutagenesis experiments when a crystallographically determined structure is not available. At its simplest a model may consist of little more than a secondary structure prediction coupled with a determination of the likely regions of transmembrane/membrane surface/globular configuration. These methods can yield an interesting topology map of the protein, which places the residues in their likely positions with respect to, for example, the membrane interface. If it is a member of a large family of related proteins then aligned protein sequences can be used to predict the residues that have an important function as these will be largely conserved in the alignments. Using all these methods a model can be constructed (using for example, the Nicholson Molecular Modelling Kit) to visualize the proposed structure in three dimensions following the premise of good design, that is, avoiding obvious steric clashes, packing of helices in a realistic manner, observing the correct H-bond lengths, etc. In this latter exercise the review of Chothia (Annu. Rev. Biochem. 53, 537-572, 1984) of the principles of protein structure is particularly helpful as it clearly sets out how proteins pack and their preferred configuration. There is a wealth of information about individual amino acid conformational preferences and observed frequencies of occurrence in known protein structures, which can help decide how the residues in the model can be oriented. In this article we have collated the various protein models of the bacterial light-harvesting complexes and present our own model, which is a synthesis of the available biophysical data and theoretical predictions, and show its performance in explaining recent results of site-directed mutants of the LH1 and LH2 light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

Structure, function and organization of antenna polypeptides and antenna complexes from the three families of Rhodospirillaneae

Comparative primary structural analysis of polypeptides from antenna complexes from species of the three families of Rhodospirillaneae indicates the structural principles responsible for the formation of spectrally distinct light-harvesting complexes. In many of the characterized antenna systems the basic structural minimal unit is an alpha/beta polypeptide pair. Specific clusters of amino acid residues, in particular aromatic residues in the C-terminal domain, identify the antenna polypeptides to specific types of antenna systems, such as B880 (strong circular dichroism (CD)), B870 (weak CD), B800-850 (high), B800-850 (low) or B800-820. The core complex B880 (B1020) of species from Ectothiorhodospiraceae and Chromatiaceae apparently consists of four (alpha 1 alpha 2 beta 1 beta 2) or three (2 alpha beta 1 beta 2) chemically dissimilar antenna polypeptides respectively. There is good evidence that the so-called variable antenna complexes, such as the B800-850 (high), B800-850 (low) or B800-820 of Rp. acidophila, Rp. palustris and Cr. vinosum, are comprised of multiple forms of peripheral light-harvesting polypeptides. Structural similarities between prokaryotic and eukaryotic antenna polypeptides are discussed in terms of similar pigment organization. The structural basis for the strict organization of pigment molecules (bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) cluster) in the antenna system of purple bacteria is the hierarchical organization of the alpha- and beta-antenna polypeptides within and between the antenna complexes. On the basis of the three-domain structure of the antenna polypeptides with the central hydrophobic domain, forming a transmembrane alpha helix, possible arrangements of the antenna polypeptides in the three-dimensional structure of core and peripheral antenna complexes are discussed. Important structural and functional features of these polypeptides and therefore of the BChl cluster are the alpha/beta heterodimers, the alpha 2 beta 2 basic units and cyclic arrangements of these basic units. Equally important for the formation of the antenna complexes or the entire antenna are polypeptide-polypeptide, pigment-pigment and pigment-polypeptide interactions.

Protein and chlorophyll in photosystem II probed by infrared spectroscopy

The infrared spectra of photosystem II (PS II) enriched submembrane fractions isolated from spinach are obtained in water and in heavy water suspension Other spectra are obtained after a photooxidation reaction was performed on PS II to bleach the pigments. The water bands are removed by computer subtraction and the amide bands (A, B, I, II, and III) of the protein are identified. Computer enhancement techniques are used to narrow the bandwidth of the bands that the weak chlorophyll bands, buried in the much stronger protein bands, can be observed. Comparing the spectra of native and photooxidized PS II pr in water and in heavy water, we determine that three polypeptide domains are present in the native material. The first domain, which contains 22% of th is situated in the peripheral region of the PS II system. The polypeptides in this region are unfolded and devoid of chlorophyll. The second domain con of the polypeptides, is more organized, and contains the chlorophylls. The third domain has an alpha-helix configuration, does not contain chlorophyll, a affected by the photooxidation reaction or by the proton/deuteron exchange. Three different types of chlorophyll organisation are identified: two have carbonyl groups non-bonded, differing from one another only in their hydrophobic milieux; the third is weakly bonded to another unidentified group. Other forms of chlorophyll organisation are present but could not be observed because their absorption is buried in the protein amide I band.

Localization of reaction center and B800-850 antenna pigment proteins in membranes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The localization of the N- and C-terminal regions of pigment-binding polypeptides of the bacterial photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides was investigated by proteinase K treatment of chromatophore and spheroplast-derived vesicles and amino acid sequence determination. Under conditions of proteinase K treatment of chromatophores, which left the in vivo absorption spectrum and the membrane intact, 15 and 46 amino acyl residues from the N-terminal regions of the L and M subunits, respectively, of the reaction center polypeptides were removed. The N termini are therefore exposed on the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane. The C-terminal domain of the light-harvesting B800-850 alpha and B870 alpha polypeptides was found to be exposed on the periplasmic surface of the membrane. A total of 9 and 13 amino acyl residues were cleaved from the B800-850 alpha and B870 alpha polypeptides, respectively, when spheroplasts were treated with proteinase K. The N-terminal regions of the alpha polypeptides were not digested in either membrane preparation and were apparently protected from proteolytic attack. Seven N-terminal amino acyl residues of the B800-850 beta polypeptide were removed after the digestion of chromatophores. C-terminal residues were not removed after the digestion of chromatophores or spheroplasts. The C termini seem to be protected from protease attack by interaction with the membrane. Therefore, the N-terminal regions of the beta polypeptides are exposed on the cytoplasmic membrane surface. The C termini of the beta polypeptides are believed to point to the periplasmic space.

Orientational properties of biological pigments in ordered systems studied with polarized light: photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes in membranes

A discussion is presented of the problems involved in the interpretation of linear dichroism and fluorescence depolarization experiments on macroscopically ordered membrane systems. Particular attention has been paid to ordered membranes containing photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes, but the mathematical treatment can equally well be applied to other systems. The information about the orientational properties of the pigments is obtained by the application of the theories developed for the characterization of the molecular orientational order in liquid-crystalline materials. It is shown that while linear dichroism only yields the order parameter S mu of the absorption transition moment, fluorescence depolarization experiments yield in addition the order parameter Sv of the emission transition moment as well as three orientational correlation functions of the two transition moments. It is argued that in general the latter information can only be obtained on utilizing a number of experimental scattering geometries. In particular, the merits of angle-resolved experiments are illustrated.

Properties of the reaction center of the thermophilic purple photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium tepidum

Reaction centers were purified from the thermophilic purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium tepidum. The reaction center consists of four polypeptides L, M, H and C, whose apparent molecular masses were determined to be 25, 30, 34 and 44 kDa, respectively, by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The heaviest peptide corresponds to tightly bound cytochrome. The tightly bound cytochrome c contains two types of heme, high-potential c-556 and low-potential c-553. The low-potential heme is able to be photooxidized at 77 K. The reaction center exhibits laser-flash-induced absorption changes and circular dichroism spectra similar to those observed in other purple photosynthetic bacteria. Whole cells contain both ubiquinone and menaquinone. Reaction centers contain only a single active quinone; chemical analysis showed this to be menaquinone. Reaction center complexes without the tightly bound cytochrome were also prepared. The near-infrared pigment absorption bands are red-shifted in reaction centers with cytochrome compared to those without cytochrome.

Preparation and properties of the water-soluble chlorophyll-bovine serum albumin complexes

By mixing chlorophyll (Chl) a or b with a dense bovine serum albumin solution, the water-soluble Chl-bovine serum albumin complexes were prepared. These complexes, eluted near the void volume on a gel filtration, were separated well from unreacted bovine serum albumin, indicating an aggregation of such molecules in the complexes. Preparation of chlorophyllide (Chlide) a- or Chlide b-bovine serum albumin complex was unsuccessful, while the phytol-, and beta-carotene-bovine serum albumin complexes could be obtained. Chls in the Chl-bovine serum albumin complexes had the following characteristics. Main absorption peak of Chl a or b in the red region occurred at 675 nm or 652 nm, respectively. The Chl a-bovine serum albumin complex having absorption peak at 740 nm was also prepared. As compared with the stabilities of Chl a and b in Triton X-100. Both Chls in the bovine serum albumin-complexes were stable against oxidative stresses, such as photobleaching, Fenton reagent, peroxidase-H2O2 system. But they were easily hydrolyzed by chlorophyllase. These properties of Chls in the bovine serum albumin-complexes were similar to those of Chls in the isolated light-harvesting Chl a/b protein complex. A possible localization of Chls within the bovine serum albumin complexes was suggested that the porphyrin moiety of Chl was buried in bovine serum albumin; however, the hydrophilic edge of porphyrin ring, adjacent to the phytol group, occurred in the hydrophilic region of a bovine serum albumin molecule.