Biospecific detection in liquid chromatography

Development of on-line high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-biochemical detection methods as tools in the identification of bioactives

Biochemical detection (BCD) methods are commonly used to screen plant extracts for specific biological activities in batch assays. Traditionally, bioactives in the most active extracts were identified through time-consuming bio-assay guided fractionation until single active compounds could be isolated. Not only are isolation procedures often tedious, but they could also lead to artifact formation. On-line coupling of BCD assays to high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is gaining ground as a high resolution screening technique to overcome problems associated with pre-isolation by measuring the effects of compounds post-column directly after separation. To date, several on-line HPLC-BCD assays, applied to whole plant extracts and mixtures, have been published. In this review the focus will fall on enzyme-based, receptor-based and antioxidant assays.

Effect-directed analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography with gas-segmented enzyme inhibition

A reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography system with UV-detector was equipped with an on-line acetylcholinesterase inhibition assay to achieve effect-directed analysis of potentially toxic samples. The enzyme activity was detected colorimetrically using Ellman's reagent. The inhibition and substrate conversion took place in glass capillaries at a 100 microL/min flow rate. Extra-column band spreading in the reaction coils reduces the sensitivity and separation power of biochemical detectors severely. Knitted reactors exhibited no reduction of longitudinal dispersion in the tested flow range. The implementation of air-segmentation allowed an extended inhibition and substrate conversion time without a significant loss of chromatographic resolution. The limit of detection of two model compounds carbofuran (carbamate) and paraoxon-ethyl (organophosphate) was determined to be 13 ng (injected mass) and 7.4 ng, respectively, applying an isocratic chromatography method. A mixture of five insecticides was separated by a gradient elution and the inhibitory effect on the enzyme activity could be detected with high resolution. The band width at half height of the enzyme inhibition detector signal after a reaction time of about 8 min or 4.2 m of capillary, respectively, increased only by a factor of 1.4 compared to the UV-detector signal.

Application of immobilized enzyme reactor in on-line high performance liquid chromatography: A review

This review summarizes all the research efforts in the last decade (1994-2003) that have been spent to the various application of immobilized enzyme reactor (IMER) in on-line high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). All immobilization procedures including supports, kind of assembly into chromatographic system and methods are described. The effect of immobilization on enzymatic properties and stability of biocatalysts is considered. A brief survey of the main applications of IMER both as pre-column, post-column or column in the chemical, pharmaceutical, clinical and commodities fields is also reported.

Immobilized enzyme reactors based upon the flavoenzymes monoamine oxidase A and B

Monoamine oxidase (MAO) catalyzes the oxidative deamination of amines. The enzyme exists in two forms, MAO-A and MAO-B, which differ in substrate specificity and sensitivity to various inhibitors. Membrane fractions containing either expressed MAO-A or MAO-B have been non-covalently immobilized in the hydrophobic interface of an immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) liquid chromatographic stationary phase. The MAO-containing stationary phases were packed into glass columns to create on-line immobilized enzyme reactors (IMERs) that retained the enzymatic activity of the MAO. The resulting MAO-IMERs were coupled through a switching valve to analytical high performance liquid chromatographic columns. The multi-dimensional chromatographic system was used to characterize the MAO-A (MAO-A-IMER) and MAO-B (MAO-B-IMER) forms of the enzyme including the enzyme kinetic constants associated with enzyme/substrate and enzyme/inhibitor interactions as well as the determination of IC(50) values. The results of the study demonstrate that the MAO-A-IMER and the MAO-B-IMER can be used for the on-line screening of substances for MAO-A and MAO-B substrate/inhibitor properties.

On-Line Continuous-Flow, Multi-Protein Biochemical Assays for the Characterization of Bioaffinity Compounds Using Electrospray Quadrupole Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry

The applicability of a homogeneous on-line continuous-flow, multi-protein biochemical assay was demonstrated for the interaction between fluorescein-biotin and streptavidin and for digoxin and anti-digoxigenin using electrospray quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (Q-TOF MS). In the on-line continuous-flow biochemical MS-based system several receptors (e.g., streptavidin and anti-digoxigenin, respectively) were allowed to react with corresponding reporter ligands (e.g.,fluorescein-biotin and digoxin, respectively). The methodology presented allows the simultaneous measurement of affinity and molecular mass of an active compound. By using automated MS and MS-MS switching functions of the Q-TOF, structure information is obtained allowing the characterization of bioactive compounds. No cross-reactivities were observed between the two model systems fluorescein-biotin/streptavidin and digoxin/anti-digoxigenin.

Optical photothermal detection in HPLC

A mode-mismatched parallel dual-beam thermal lens spectrometer with a far-field single-channel detector system was used as a detector in HPLC. An expert estimation of the measurement results was applied to optimize the optical-scheme configuration of the spectrometer to achieve the longest linear calibration range and highest repeatability under chromatographic flow conditions. Chelates with 4-(2-pyridylazo)resorcinol were separated and determined with the limits of detection of n x 10(-8)- n x 10(-7) mol L(-1); the relative standard deviation of measurements was 46%. Xylenol Orange, 4-(2-thiazolylazo)resorcinol, and dithizone were studied as post-column reagents in thermal lens detection in ion chromatography. The limits of detection were n x 10(-8)- n x 10(-7) mol L(-1); the linear calibration ranges were about three orders; the relative standard deviation of measurements was 3-7%. A combined photothermal-refractometric detector for HPLC based on a polarization interferometer is proposed. Metal complexes as 4-(pyridylazo)resorcinol chelates (limits of detection of n x 10(-8)- n x 10(-7) mol L(-1)) and sugars (limits of detection of 10-20 ng L(-1)) were investigated as model substances. Obtained results were compared with results for traditional detectors, which show that photothermal detection has higher sensitivity than photometric and other absorption detectors.

Potential of on-line micro-LC immunochemical detection in the bioanalysis of cytokines

An on-line liquid chromatography-immunochemical detection (LC-ICD) system for the quantification of cytokines in cell extracts has been developed using a post-column continuous-flow reaction detection system using fluorescence labelled antibodies. Cytokines eluting from the micro-HPLC column react with antibodies to form fluorescent complexes. In a second step the excess of free antibody is trapped on a cytokine bound support prior to fluorescence detection. The concentration detection limit of the flow injection-ICD system was 50 pM (20 microl injection volume) for interleukin 4 (IL-4). An absolute detection limit of 1 fmol was obtained for IL-4. Similar to ICD systems for small non-protein analytes developed earlier, reaction times were in the order of 1 minute. The immobilised cytokine affinity columns can easily be regenerated and used for months. The present ICD system for interleukins 4, 6, 8 and 10 was coupled to ion exchange-, size exclusion- and reversed phase chromatography. Important parameters (reaction times, reaction conditions) were investigated to get a better understanding of post-column ICD systems for macromolecules.

Continuous-flow, on-line monitoring of biospecific interactions using electrospray mass spectrometry

A continuous-flow analytical screening system is presented using electrospray mass spectrometry to measure the interaction of biologically active compounds with soluble affinity proteins. The biochemical detection system is based on a solution-phase, homogeneous assay. In a first step, compounds to be screened (e.g., biotinylated compounds, concentration range 10-1,000 nmol/L) are injected into a continuous-flow reaction system and allowed to react with the affinity protein (e.g., streptavidin, concentration range 3-48 nmol/L). Subsequently, a reporter ligand (fluorescein-labeled biotin 96 nmol/L) is added to saturate the remaining free binding sites of the affinity protein and the concentration of unbound reporter ligand is measured using electrospray MS in the selectedion monitoring mode. The presence of active compounds in the sample results in an increase of the concentration of unbound reporter ligands. The feasibility of a homogeneous MS-based biochemical assay is demonstrated using streptavidin/biotin and anti-digoxigenin/digoxin as model systems. Compared to radioactive or fluorescence-based biochemical assays, the present assay format does not require the synthesis and purification of labels. Various analytical conditions were investigated to determine the ability of MS to measure the biochemical interactions. The availability of a single ligand that can be detected at 10-50 nmol/L concentrations by electrospray MS is sufficient to set up the biochemical assay. For the biospecific interactions studies, detection limits of 10-100 nmol/L were obtained.

Nonionic micellar liquid chromatography coupled to immobilized enzyme reactors

Immobilized enzyme reactors are used as post-column reactors to modify the detectability of analytes. An immobilized amino acid oxidase reactor was prepared and coupled to an immobilized peroxidase reactor to detect low level of amino acids by fluorescence of the homovanilic dimer produced. A cholesterol oxidase reactor was prepared to detect cholesterol and metabolites by 241 nm UV absorbance of the enone produced. The preparation of the porous glass beads with the immobilized enzymes is described. Micellar liquid chromatography is used with non-ionic micellar phases to separate the amino acids or cholesterol derivatives. It is demonstrated that the non ionic Brij 35 micellar phases are very gentle for the enzyme activity allowing the reactor activity to remain at a higher level and for a much longer time than with hydro-organic classical chromatographic mobile phases or aqueous buffers. The coupling of nonionic micellar phases with enzymatic detection gave limits of detection of 32 pmol (4.8 ng injected) of methionine and 50 pmol (19 ng injected) of 20alpha-hydroxy cholesterol. The immobilized enzyme reactors could be used continuously for a week without losing their activity. It is shown that the low efficiency obtained with micellar liquid chromatography is compensated by the possibility offered by the technique to easily adjust selectivity.

An acetylcholinesterase/choline oxidase-based amperometric biosensors as a liquid chromatography detector for acetylcholine and choline determination in brain tissue homogenates

A liquid chromatography (LC) detector based on a fast response and sensitive bienzyme amperometric biosensor for acetylcholine (ACh) and choline (Ch) is described. The detector fabrication consisted of glutaraldehyde co-crosslinking of acetylcholinesterase and choline oxidase with bovine serum albumin on the Pt working electrode of a conventional thin-layer electrochemical flow cell. The influence of some experimental parameters (e.g., enzyme loading, thickness of the bienzyme layer, flow rate) on the detector characteristics has been studied in order to optimize the analyte response while minimizing band-broadening and distortion. A mobile phase consisting of a phosphate buffer (I, 0.1 M; pH, 6.5) containing 5 mM sodium hexane sulfonate and 10 mM tetramethylammonium phosphate was found to give very satisfactory resolution and peak shape in ion-pair, reversed-phase LC. Linear responses were observed over at least four decades and absolute detection limits (at a signal-to-noise ratio of 3) were 12 and 27 fmol injected for Ch and ACh, respectively. After one month of intensive use in the LC system, the detector retained about 70% of its initial sensitivity. The potential of the described approach is demonstrated by the simultaneous determination of Ch and ACh in rat brain tissue homogenates.

Flow immunochemical bio-recognition detection for the determination of interleukin-10 in cell samples

On- and off-line heterogeneous non-competitive flow immunoassays for the determination of Interleukin-10 are described. The sample containing IL-10 is mixed, either on-line in a reaction coil or off-line in a test tube, with fluorescent labelled anti-IL-10 antibodies to form an antibody-antigen complex. The labelled unbound antibodies are trapped on an immobilized IL-10 column whereas the IL-10-antibody complexes are eluted and detected downstream by a fluorescence detector. The optimization of the systems was performed with respect to choice of affinity support, flow rate, carrier buffer additives, pH and antibody-antigen association. Both bio recognition assays were tested with a spiked cell medium and the IL-10 detection limits in this matrix was found to be 8 fmol using the off-line incubation mode and 40 fmol using the on-line incubation mode. The sample through-put was 26 and 40 samples per hour in the on-line and off-line incubation modes, respectively. IL-10 identification in the sample fractions was achieved using MALDI-TOF MS.

Label-free biochemical detection coupled on-line to liquid chromatography

The on-line coupling of a label-free optical biosensor to a HPLC system is described by combining the separation power of HPLC with the specificity of the biosensor system. A highly cross-reactive antibody against the pesticide isoproturon was used as model for affinity proteins. The binding strength of the antibody to the utilized pesticides was characterized with the biosensor, first. In the on-line coupling setup, the eluate of the HPLC was mixed continuously with the antibodies. The presence of antigens was detected by a reduction of the antibody binding to the transducer. This reduced binding was quantified by a differentiation of the sensor signal by applying a Savitzky-Golay algorithm. Limits of detection were found to be in the femtomole range without preconcentration, which is comparable to a study using fluorescence-based biochemical detection.

High-performance liquid chromatography coupled to enzyme-amplified biochemical detection for the analysis of hemoglobin after pre-column biotinylation

The determination of proteins with enzyme-amplified biochemical detection (EA-BCD) coupled on-line with high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is demonstrated. The EA-BCD system was developed to detect biotin-containing compounds. Hemoglobin, which was used as a model compound, was biotinylated prior to sample introduction. Several biotinylation parameters, such as pH and removal of excess biotinylation reagent, were investigated. After biotinylation samples were introduced to HPLC followed by EA-BCD. To the HPLC effluent, alkaline phosphatase label streptavidin (S-AP) was added, which possesses high affinity to biotin and biotin-containing compounds. Excess S-AP was removed by means of an immobilized biotin column followed by substrate addition. The non-fluorescent substrate is converted to a highly fluorescent product by the enzyme label. A detection limit of 2 femtomol biotinylated Hb was achieved with good reproducibility and linearity. However, biotinylation at low analyte concentration suffers from low yield due to slow reaction kinetics. Finally, Hb was successfully extracted from urine with a recovery of 94%.

Enzyme amplification as detection tool in continuous-flow systems. I. Development of an enzyme-amplified biochemical detection system coupled on-line to flow-injection analysis

The on-line coupling of flow-injection analysis (FIA) to an enzyme-amplified biochemical detection (EA-BCD) system is described. The aim of this study is the development of a detection system able to detect biotin-containing compounds at low concentration levels. The detection system is based on the interaction of biotin with enzyme-labeled affinity proteins. Biotin possesses a high affinity to both streptavidin and anti-biotin Fab fragments, which are both tested. Several biotin derivatives are available with different reactive probes, which can be used to label analytes of interest. Therefore, biotin acts as a universal probe for the enzyme-amplified biochemical detection. Alkaline phosphatase (AP) was used as enzyme label. Several parameters, such as substrate type and concentration, concentration of enzyme-labeled affinity protein, reaction time and reaction temperature were examined. Biotin aminocaproic acid was used as a model compound. In addition to biotin aminocaproic hydrazide, other biotinylation reagents were also examined. With fluorescence detection of the enzyme-generated product, a mass detection limit of 1 fmol was achieved.

Rapid alcohol determination in plasma and urine by column liquid chromatography with biosensor detection

An enzyme based amperometric biosensor used as a selective and sensitive detection unit in column liquid chromatography for the determination of ethanol and methanol in biological fluids such as plasma and urine is described. The reagentless enzyme electrode is based on the co-immobilisation of alcohol oxidase and horseradish peroxidase in carbon paste. The selectivity of the biosensor was found to vary when four various alcohol oxidase enzyme preparations from Candida boidinii, Pichia pastoris, and Hansenula polymorpha were used in the biosensors described. High sensitivity could be obtained for a number of alcohols, organic acids, and aldehydes. Optimisation regarding the sensitivity and selectivity of the four alcohol oxidase co-immobilised biosensors are outlined. A fast and reliable liquid chromatographic separation system with a PLRP-S polymer based separation column used with a phosphate buffer as the mobile phase was optimised using the best biosensor which was based on alcohol oxidase from P. pastoris and which showed the highest turnover rate for alcohols, as the detector for the determination of ethanol and methanol in human urine and plasma samples. The selectivity and stability of the biosensor were retained by working at an applied potential of -50 mV versus Ag/AgCl, the optimal operational potential, and by the casting of a protective membrane on the electrode surface. High selectivity of the enzyme electrode was also found towards other easily oxidisable interfering species normally present in biological fluids. It was found that stable and reliable determinations of ethanol and methanol in plasma and urine could be performed with only a simple dilution and centrifugation step prior to injection into the liquid chromatographic system. An analysis time of 4 min was required for the assay, with a sample throughput of 13 samples h(-1).

Biosensors in chemical separations

Identification of biomolecules in complex biological mixtures represents a major challenge in biomedical, environmental, and chemical research today. Chemical separations with traditional detection schemes such as absorption, fluorescence, refractive index, conductivity, and electrochemistry have been the standards for definitive identifications of many compounds. In many instances, however, the complexity of the biomixture exceeds the resolution capability of chemical separations. Biosensors based on molecular recognition can dramatically improve the selectivity of and provide biologically relevant information about the components. This review describes how coupling chemical separations with online biosensors solves challenging problems in sample analysis by identifying components that would not normally be detectable by either technique alone. This review also presents examples and principles of combining chemical separations with biosensor detection that uses living systems, whole cells, membrane receptors, enzymes, and immunosensors.

Optimal membrane choice for microdialysis sampling of oligosaccharides

An analytical methodology based on microdialysis sampling, high-performance anion-exchange chromatography and integrated pulsed electrochemical detection for the monitoring of oligosaccharides in bioprocesses is presented. Amylopectin and model maltooligosaccharide standards; glucose, maltose, maltotriose, maltotetraose, maltopentaose, maltohexaose and maltoheptaose were used to demonstrate its versatility in view to sampling in enzymatic bioprocesses. The performance and characteristics of membranes with the same cut-off ranging between 3 and 100 kDa, were evaluated with respect to their extraction fraction (EF), permeability factors, temperature stability and protein (enzyme) interaction. All investigated membranes showed some non-specific interaction with enzymes. The EF and non-specific membrane-enzyme interactions were higher for the polysulfone membranes compared with the polyamide and polyethersulfone membranes. For all saccharides, the EF was independent of the concentration even for a 250-fold change in concentration. The EF and morphology of the membranes in their dehydrated state, as observed using scanning electron microscopy did not show any significant difference between membranes exposed to a 90 degrees C temperature for 3 and 24 h indicating their applicability to the study of high temperature bioprocesses.

High sample throughput flow immunoassay utilising restricted access columns for the separation of bound and free label

A flow immunodetection system with high sample throughput capacity is described for the screening of various analytes. The immunochemical detection principle is based on the chromatographic separation of the formed immunocomplex (AbAg or AbAg*) and the free antigen (Ag) by a restricted access (RA) column, utilising size-exclusion and reversed-phase mechanism. A fluorescein labelled analyte (Ag*) was used in the competitive assay format with fluorescence detection. The speed and simplicity of the assay were the greatest advantages, allowing measurement of the analyte to be carried out in less than 1 min. The biocompatibility and capacity of the restricted access material allowed multiple injections of up to 5000, without any breakthrough of the fluorescent tracer molecule and thus need for regeneration. The flow immunoassay was developed using the well-known atrazine herbicide and some transformation products as model compounds, due to their human toxicity and widespread use. The sample throughput was 80 samples per hour and the detection limits were 1.4 nM (300 pg/ml) for atrazine (Ab I) and 2.3 nM (500 pg/ml) for the sum of triazines (Ab II-III). Different sample matrices, PBS buffer, creek water, and urine were successfully applied in the flow system without the need for any sample handling step. For plasma samples an additional clean-up step using solid-phase extraction had to be included. The resulting detection limits for atrazine in plasma and water samples using this clean-up and trace enrichment procedure were found to be 2 ng/ml and 20 pg/ml, respectively. The analysis could be performed at a sample throughput rate of 400 per 6-h working shift.

Optimisation of a heterogeneous non-competitive flow immunoassay comparing fluorescein, peroxidase and alkaline phosphatase as labels

Off- and on-line strategies for a non-competitive heterogeneous flow immunoassay were developed comparing three different labels. The samples, containing the model compounds digoxin or digoxigenin, were either pre-incubated off-line or on-line in a mixing coil with excess of labelled anti-digoxigenin Fab-fragments. The excess of Fab-fragments was then separated from the digoxin bound Fab-fragments by passing the sample through a column with immobilised digoxin. The off-line immunochemical detection system is suitable for sensitive high through-put screening of the analytes, whereas the on-line system is more suitable for coupling as a post-column detection unit to liquid chromatography. The digoxin and digoxigenin content in the sample were quantified using fluorescein (F) and enzyme (peroxidase (POD), alkaline phosphatase (AP)) labelled Fab-fragments. The fluorescein label was directly measured with the fluorescence detector, whereas a fluorescent enzyme product was measured in the two enzyme based systems, using 3-(p-hydroxyphenyl)-propionic acid (HPPA) and hydrogen peroxide for POD and, and 4-methylumbelliferyl phosphate (4-MUP) for AP. The highest sensitivity and lowest limit of detection (LOD) was obtained with the Fab-POD system with LODs for digoxin and digoxigenin in the off- and on-line configurations of 0.025 and 0.01 nM, respectively. The sample through-put for the off- and on-line systems were 43 and 32 samples per hour, respectively.

Separation used for purification of recombinant proteins

The purification of molecules from recombinant cells may be strongly influenced by the molecular biology of gene isolation and expression. At the beginning of the process there may be a demand for information on the minute amounts of proteins and thus for ever increasingly sensitive techniques. Purification of recombinant proteins can differ from conventional purifications in several ways, depending on the solubility of the protein, occurrence in inclusion bodies, creation of fusion proteins with tags that enable simpler purification. Sometimes a (re)naturation step is required to get a bioactive protein. On the other hand, the techniques used in separation are essentially the same as for purification from the natural source and environment.

Determination of minute enzymatic activities by means of capillary electrophoretic techniques

Capillary electrophoretic analysis of enzymes, co-enzymes, substrates and other chemical species that can be linked to an enzymatic reaction is reviewed with 80 references. Both off-line and on-line assays of minute enzymatic activities are discussed. In addition to heterogeneous on-line enzyme assays, a special emphasis is given to a newly established on-line technique called electrophoretically mediated microanalysis (EMMA). The basic principle, procedure, and various detection modes of EMMA are discussed. The recent developments in on-line determination of various enzyme substrates as well as on-line enzyme kinetic studies are also summarized. Some potential future developments in the determination of enzymatic activities by means of CE are also presented.