Crystallization of a small fragment of an aminoacyl tRNA synthetase

Introduction of a leucine half-zipper engenders multiple high-quality crystals of a recalcitrant tRNA synthetase

Although Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase was among the first tRNA synthetases to be sequenced and extensively studied by functional analysis, it has proved to be recalcitrant to crystallization. This challenge remained even for crystallization of the catalytic fragment. By mutationally introducing three stacked leucines onto the solvent-exposed side of an alpha-helix, an engineered catalytic fragment of the synthetase was obtained that yielded multiple high-quality crystals and cocrystals with different ligands. The engineered alpha-helix did not form a leucine zipper that interlocked with the same alpha-helix from another molecule. Instead, using the created hydrophobic spine, it interacted with other surfaces of the protein as a leucine half-zipper (LHZ) to enhance the crystal lattice interactions. The LHZ made crystal lattice contacts in all crystals of different space groups. These results illustrate the power of introducing an LHZ into helices to facilitate crystallization. The authors propose that the method can be unified with surface-entropy reduction and can be broadly used for protein-surface optimization in crystallization.

Alanyl-tRNA synthetase crystal structure and design for acceptor-stem recognition

Early work on aminoacylation of alanine-specific tRNA (tRNA(Ala)) by alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AlaRS) gave rise to the concept of an early "second genetic code" imbedded in the acceptor stems of tRNAs. A single conserved and position-specific G:U base pair in the tRNA acceptor stem is the key identity determinant. Further understanding has been limited due to lack of a crystal structure of the enzyme. We determined a 2.14 A crystal structure of the 453 amino acid catalytic fragment of Aquifex aeolicus AlaRS. It contains the catalytic domain characteristic of class II synthetases, a helical domain with a hairpin motif critical for acceptor-stem recognition, and a C-terminal domain of a mixed alpha/beta fold. Docking of tRNA(Ala) on AlaRS shows critical contacts with the three domains, consistent with previous mutagenesis and functional data. It also suggests conformational flexibility within the C domain, which might allow for the positional variation of the key G:U base pair seen in some tRNA(Ala)s.

Synthetic peptide model of an essential region of an aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase

A 40 amino acid sequence of the unsolved structure of Escherichia coli alanine-tRNA synthetase is essential for tRNA binding and encodes an immunological determinant that cross-reacts with antibodies raised against a eukaryote (insect Bombyx mori) alanine enzyme. The secondary structure of this sequence is predicted to be an amphiphilic alpha-helix that includes one aspartyl and eight glutamyl side chain carboxyl groups. The antibody reactivity and the conformation of a synthetic peptide model of this region (Glu346 to Ser385) were investigated. In addition, double Arg----Gln and Leu----Ala substitutions were separately placed in the enzyme on the hydrophilic and hydrophobic face, respectively, of the predicted helix. These mutations conserve the polar/nonpolar character of each face and retain the potential for helix formation. Circular dichroism spectra of the synthetic peptide model demonstrate the potential for amphiphilic helix formation for the segment from Glu346 to Ser385. The behavior of the mutations in the enzyme, together with earlier data and immunological assays presented here, suggests that one face of the putative helix is an antigenic region of the surface of the enzyme where it contributes to the interaction with alanine tRNA and that the specific sequence of the helix is an important determinant of enzyme stability.

Evidence that a major determinant for the identity of a transfer RNA is conserved in evolution

We observed recently that a single G3.U70 base pair in the amino acid acceptor stem of an Escherichia coli alanine tRNA is a major determinant for its identity. Inspection of tRNA sequences shows that G3.U70 is unique to alanine in E. coli and is present in eucaryotic cytoplasmic alanine tRNAs. We show here that single nucleotide changes of G3.U70 to A3.U70 or to G3.C70 eliminate in vitro aminoacylation of an insect and of a human alanine tRNA by the respective homologous synthetase. Compared to the influence of G3.U70, other sequence variations in tRNAAla have a relatively small effect on aminoacylation by the insect and human enzymes. In addition, while these eucaryotic tRNAs have nucleotide differences from E. coli alanine tRNA, they are heterologously charged only with alanine when expressed in E. coli. The results indicate a functional role for G3.U70 that is conserved in evolution. They also suggest that the sequence differences between E. coli and the eucaryotic alanine tRNAs at sites other than the conserved G3.U70 do not create major determinants for recognition by any other bacterial enzyme.

A single base pair affects binding and catalytic parameters in the molecular recognition of a transfer RNA

A single G3.U70 base pair in the acceptor helix is a major determinant of the identity of an alanine transfer RNA. Alteration of this base pair to A.U or G.C prevents aminoacylation with alanine. We show here that, at approximate physiological conditions (pH 7.5, 37 degrees C), high concentrations of the mutant A3.U70 species do not inhibit aminoacylation of a wild-type alanine tRNA. The observation suggests that, under these conditions, the G3 to A3 substitution increases Km for tRNA by more than 30-fold. Other experiments at pH 7.5 show that no aminoacylation of A3.U70, G3.C70, or U3.G70 mutant tRNAs occurs with substrate levels of enzyme. This suggests that kcat for these mutant tRNAs is sharply reduced as well and that the catalytic defect is not due to slow release of charged mutant tRNAs from the enzyme. Investigations were also done at pH 5.5, where association of tRNAs with synthetases is generally stronger and where binding can be conveniently measured apart from aminoacylation. Under these conditions, the binding of the A3.U70 and G3.C70 species is readily detected and is only 3-5-fold weaker than the binding of the wild-type tRNA. Although the A3.U70 species was demonstrated to compete with the wild-type tRNA for the same site on the enzyme, no aminoacylation could be detected. Thus, even when conditions are adjusted to obtain strong competitive binding, a sharp reduction in kcat prevents aminoacylation of a tRNA(Ala) species with a substitution at position 3.70.

Evidence that the 3' end of a tRNA binds to a site in the adenylate synthesis domain of an aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase

Aminoacylation requires that an enzyme-bound aminoacyladenylate is brought proximal to the 3' end of a specific transfer RNA. In Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase, the first 368 amino acids encode a domain for adenylate synthesis while sequences on the carboxyl-terminal side of this domain are required for much of the enzyme-tRNAAla binding energy. The 3' end of E. coli tRNAAla has been cross-linked to the enzyme, and sequence analysis showed that Lys-73 is the major site of coupling. A mutant enzyme with a Lys-73----Gln replacement has a 50-fold reduced kcat/Km (with respect to tRNAAla) for aminoacylation but has a relatively small alteration of its kinetic parameters for ATP and alanine in the adenylate synthesis reaction. The data provide evidence that the 3' end of tRNAAla binds to a site in the enzyme domain responsible for adenylate synthesis and that a residue (Lys-73) in this domain is important for a tRNAAla-dependent step that is subsequent to the synthesis of the aminoacyladenylate intermediate.