Nucleotides that contribute to the identity of Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe)

Biochemistry of Aminoacyl tRNA Synthetase and tRNAs and Their Engineering for Cell-Free and Synthetic Cell Applications

Cell-free biology is increasingly utilized for engineering biological systems, incorporating novel functionality, and circumventing many of the complications associated with cells. The central dogma describes the information flow in biology consisting of transcription and translation steps to decode genetic information. Aminoacyl tRNA synthetases (AARSs) and tRNAs are key components involved in translation and thus protein synthesis. This review provides information on AARSs and tRNA biochemistry, their role in the translation process, summarizes progress in cell-free engineering of tRNAs and AARSs, and discusses prospects and challenges lying ahead in cell-free engineering.

Chemical and Conformational Diversity of Modified Nucleosides Affects tRNA Structure and Function

RNAs are central to all gene expression through the control of protein synthesis. Four major nucleosides, adenosine, guanosine, cytidine and uridine, compose RNAs and provide sequence variation, but are limited in contributions to structural variation as well as distinct chemical properties. The ability of RNAs to play multiple roles in cellular metabolism is made possible by extensive variation in length, conformational dynamics, and the over 100 post-transcriptional modifications. There are several reviews of the biochemical pathways leading to RNA modification, but the physicochemical nature of modified nucleosides and how they facilitate RNA function is of keen interest, particularly with regard to the contributions of modified nucleosides. Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are the most extensively modified RNAs. The diversity of modifications provide versatility to the chemical and structural environments. The added chemistry, conformation and dynamics of modified nucleosides occurring at the termini of stems in tRNA's cloverleaf secondary structure affect the global three-dimensional conformation, produce unique recognition determinants for macromolecules to recognize tRNAs, and affect the accurate and efficient decoding ability of tRNAs. This review will discuss the impact of specific chemical moieties on the structure, stability, electrochemical properties, and function of tRNAs.

Mapping hidden potential identity elements by computing the average discriminating power of individual tRNA positions

The recently published discrete mathematical method, extended consensus partition (ECP), identifies nucleotide types at each position that are strictly absent from a given sequence set, while occur in other sets. These are defined as discriminating elements (DEs). In this study using the ECP approach, we mapped potential hidden identity elements that discriminate the 20 different tRNA identities. We filtered the tDNA data set for the obligatory presence of well-established tRNA features, and then separately for each identity set, the presence of already experimentally identified strictly present identity elements. The analysis was performed on the three kingdoms of life. We determined the number of DE, e.g. the number of sets discriminated by the given position, for each tRNA position of each tRNA identity set. Then, from the positional DE numbers obtained from the 380 pairwise comparisons of the 20 identity sets, we calculated the average excluding value (AEV) for each tRNA position. The AEV provides a measure on the overall discriminating power of each position. Using a statistical analysis, we show that positional AEVs correlate with the number of already identified identity elements. Positions having high AEV but lacking published identity elements predict hitherto undiscovered tRNA identity elements.

Intercalation of daunomycin into d(CG)4 oligomer duplex containing G x T mismatches by vibrational circular dichroism and infrared absorption spectroscopy

The vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and infrared absorption (IR) spectra of the mismatched octamer oligonucleotides d(CGTGCGCG)(2) (CGT) and d(CGCGTGCG)(2) (CGC) and their complexes with the antitumor drug daunomycin were measured in D(2)O, interpreted, and compared to the octamer d(CGCGCGCG)(2) (CG). The IR spectra of the mismatched octamers in the carbonyl-stretching region are similar to those of the parent CG, whereas the VCD spectra differ in several respects between each other. The main VCD feature due to carbonyl stretching is informative for the mismatches and CG. Vibrational modes in the sugar-phosphate region remain essentially unchanged especially for PO(2) (-) symmetric stretching. Differences between the free and complexed mismatch octamers occurred mainly in the carbonyl-stretching region (1,700-1,600 cm(-1)). The absorption intensity of the C==O peak of G is more prominent for CGC than CGT and resembles CG in this respect. The detailed composition of this doublet is clearly visible, indicating the geometric rearrangement of the base pairs in the presence of the mismatch and upon forming the daunomycin complex.

A novel human tRNA-dihydrouridine synthase involved in pulmonary carcinogenesis

An increased level of dihydrouridine in tRNA(Phe) was found in human malignant tissues nearly three decades ago, but its biological significance in carcinogenesis has remained unclear. Through analysis of genome-wide gene-expression profiles among non-small cell lung carcinomas (NSCLC), we identified overexpression of a novel human gene, termed hDUS2, encoding a protein that shared structural features with tRNA-dihydrouridine synthases (DUS). The deduced 493-amino-acid sequence showed 39% homology to the dihydrouridine synthase 2 enzyme (Dus2) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and contained a conserved double-strand RNA-binding motif (DSRM). We found that hDUS2 protein had tRNA-DUS activity and that it physically interacted with EPRS, a glutamyl-prolyl tRNA synthetase, and was likely to enhance translational efficiencies. A small interfering RNA against hDUS2 transfected into NSCLC cells suppressed expression of the gene, reduced the amount of dihydrouridine in tRNA molecules, and suppressed growth. Immunohistochemical analysis showed significant association between higher levels of hDUS2 in tumors and poorer prognosis of lung cancer patients. Our data imply that up-regulation of hDUS2 is a relatively common feature of pulmonary carcinogenesis and that selective suppression of hDUS2 enzyme activity and/or inhibition of formation of the hDUS2-tRNA synthetase complex could be a promising therapeutic strategy for treatment of many lung cancers.

Predicting the Binding Affinities of Misacylated tRNAs forThermus thermophilusEF-Tu·GTP

The free energies for the binding of 20 different unmodified Escherichia coli elongator aminoacyl-tRNAs to Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) were determined. When combined with the binding free energies for the same tRNA bodies misacylated with either valine or phenylalanine determined previously [Asahara, H., and Uhlenbeck, O. C. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 99, 3499-3504], these data permit the calculation of the contribution of each esterified amino acid to the total free energy of binding of the complex. The two data sets can also be used to calculate the free energy of binding of EF-Tu to any misacylated E. coli tRNA, and the values agree well with previously published experimental values. In addition, a survey of active misacylated suppressor tRNAs suggests that a minimal threshold of binding free energy for EF-Tu is required for suppression to occur.

Hydrogen and hydration of DNA and RNA oligonucleotides

In this paper, hydrogen bonding interaction and hydration in crystal structures of both DNA and RNA oligonucleotides are discussed. Their roles in the formation and stabilization of oligonucleotides have been covered. Details of the Watson-Crick base pairs G.C and A.U in DNA and RNA are illustrated. The geometry of the wobble (mismatched) G.U base pairs and the cis and almost trans conformations of the mismatched U.U base pairs in RNA is described. The difference in hydration of the Watson-Crick base pairs G.C, A.U and the wobble G.U in different sequences of codon-anticodon interaction in double helical molecules are indicative of the effect of hydration. The hydration patterns of the phosphate, the 2'-hydroxyl groups, the water bridges linking the phosphate group, N7 (purine) and N4 of Cs or O4 of Us in the major groove, the water bridges between the 2'-hydroxyl group and N3 (purine) and O2 (pyrimidine) in the minor groove are discussed.

Determination of tRNA(Phe) nucleotides contacting the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase by photoaffinity crosslinking

The nucleotides of tRNA(Phe) interacting with the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (the alpha(2)beta(2) heterotetramer) have been determined by photoaffinity crosslinking of randomly s(4)U-monosubstituted tRNA(Phe) transcripts which retain aminoacylation parameters closely similar to those of the native tRNA(Phe). The thiolated transcripts have been fractionated by affinity electrophoresis and separately crosslinked to the enzyme. Sites of crosslinking to the beta subunit have been identified at positions 33 and 39 and crosslinking sites to the alpha subunit have been localized at positions 20, 45 and 47, using alkaline hydrolysis analysis of the crosslinked proteinase K-treated tRNAs. An additional crosslink to the beta subunit, not identified in the full-length crosslinked tRNAs, has been deduced to occur at position 12, based on the analysis of an unusual (fast migrating) crosslinked product. Nucleotide s(4)U8 of native tRNA(Phe) has been shown to form a minor crosslink to the alpha subunit. Four of the seven crosslinking sites, namely nucleotides 8, 12, 20 and 39, are among those shown to be protected against cleavage by iodine in footprinting experiments; in contrast, only nucleotide 12 is among the contact sites defined in the crystal structure. The data of independent biochemical approaches strongly suggest conformational flexibility of the complex under functional conditions, thus reflecting the importance of macromolecular dynamics for the interaction.

Synthesis and crystal structure of an octamer RNA r(guguuuac)/r(guaggcac) with G.G/U.U tandem wobble base pairs: comparison with other tandem G.U pairs

We have determined the crystal structure of the RNA octamer duplex r(guguuuac)/r(guaggcac) with a tandem wobble pair, G.G/U.U (motif III), to compare it with U.G/G.U (motif I) and G.U/U.G (motif II) and to better understand their relative stabilities. The crystal belongs to the rhombohedral space group R3. The hexagonal unit cell dimensions are a = b = 41.92 A, c = 56.41 A, and gamma = 120 degrees, with one duplex in the asymmetric unit. The structure was solved by the molecular replacement method at 1.9 A resolution and refined to a final R: factor of 19.9% and R(free) of 23.3% for 2862 reflections in the resolution range 10.0-1.9 A with F >/= 2sigma(F). The final model contains 335 atoms for the RNA duplex and 30 water molecules. The A-RNA stacks in the familiar head-to-tail fashion forming a pseudo-continuous helix. The uridine bases of the tandem U.G pairs have slipped towards the minor groove relative to the guanine bases and the uridine O2 atoms form bifurcated hydrogen bonds with the N1 and N2 of guanines. The N2 of guanine and O2 of uridine do not bridge the 'locked' water molecule in the minor groove, as in motifs I and II, but are bridged by water molecules in the major groove. A comparison of base stacking stabilities of motif III with motifs I and II confirms the result of thermodynamic studies, motif I > motif III > motif II.

Transfer RNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are an ancient group of enzymes that catalyze the covalent attachment of an amino acid to its cognate transfer RNA. The question of specificity, that is, how each synthetase selects the correct individual or isoacceptor set of tRNAs for each amino acid, has been referred to as the second genetic code. A wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data on this subject has accumulated over the past 40 years. Although there are now crystal structures of sixteen of the twenty synthetases from various species, there are only a few high resolution structures of synthetases complexed with cognate tRNAs. Here we review briefly the structural information available for synthetases, and focus on the structural features of tRNA that may be used for recognition. Finally, we explore in detail the insights into specific recognition gained from classical and atomic group mutagenesis experiments performed with tRNAs, tRNA fragments, and small RNAs mimicking portions of tRNAs.

Transfer RNA identity change in anticodon variants of E. coli tRNA(Phe) in vivo

The anticodon sequence is a major recognition element for most aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. We investigated the in vivo effects of changing the anticodon on the aminoacylation specificity in the example of E. coli tRNA(Phe). Constructing different anticodon mutants of E. coli tRNA(Phe) by site-directed mutagenesis, we isolated 22 anticodon mutant tRNA(Phe); the anticodons corresponded to 16 amino acids and an opal stop codon. To examine whether the mutant tRNAs had changed their amino acid acceptor specificity in vivo, we tested the viability of E. coli strains containing these tRNA(Phe) genes in a medium which permitted tRNA induction. Fourteen mutant tRNA genes did not affect host viability. However, eight mutant tRNA genes were toxic to the host and prevented growth, presumably because the anticodon mutants led to translational errors. Many mutant tRNAs which did not affect host viability were not aminoacylated in vivo. Three mutant tRNAs containing anticodon sequences corresponding to lysine (UUU), methionine (CAU) and threonine (UGU) were charged with the amino acid corresponding to their anticodon, but not with phenylalanine. These three tRNAs and tRNA(Phe) are located in the same cluster in a sequence similarity dendrogram of total E. coli tRNAs. The results support the idea that such tRNAs arising from in vivo evolution are derived by anticodon change from the same ancestor tRNA.

The reliability of in vivo structure-function analysis of tRNA aminoacylation

The G.U wobble base-pair in the acceptor helix of Escherichia coli tRNAAlais critical for aminoacylation by the alanine synthetase. Previous work by several groups probed the mechanism of enzyme recognition of G.U by a structure-function analysis of mutant tRNAs using either a cell assay (amber suppressor tRNA) or a test tube assay (phage T7 tRNA substrate and purified enzyme). However, the aminoacylation capacity of particular mutant tRNAs was about 10(4)-fold higher in the cell assay. This led us to scrutinize the cell assay to determine if any parameter exaggerates the extent of aminoacylation in mutants forming substantial amounts of alanyl-tRNAAla. In doing so, we have refined and developed experimental designs to analyze tRNA function. We examined the level of aminoacylation of amber suppressor tRNAAlawith respect to the method of isolating aminoacyl-tRNA, the rate of cell growth, the cellular levels of alanine synthetase and elongation factor TU (EF-Tu), the amount of tRNA and the characteristics of EF-Tu binding. Within the precision of our measurements, none of these parameters varied in a way that could significantly amplify cellular alanyl-tRNAAla. A key observation is that the extent of aminoacylation of tRNAAlawas independent of tRNAAlaconcentration over a 75-fold range. Therefore, the cellular assay of tRNAAlareflects the substrate quality of the molecule for formation of alanyl-tRNAAla. These experiments support the authenticity of the cellular assay and imply that a condition or factor present in the cell assay may be absent in the test tube assay.

Functional compensation by particular nucleotide substitutions of a critical G*U wobble base-pair during aminoacylation of transfer RNA

Expression of the genetic code depends on precise tRNA aminoacylation by cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase enzymes. The G.U wobble base-pair in the acceptor helix of Escherichia coli alanine tRNA is the primary aminoacylation determinant of this molecule. Previous work on the process of synthetase recognition of the G.U pair showed that replacing G.U by a G.C Watson-Crick base-pair inactivates alanine acceptance by the tRNA, but that C.A and G.A wobble pair replacements preserve acceptance. Work by another group reported that the effects of a G.C replacement were reversed by a distal wobble base-pair in the anticodon helix. This result is potentially interesting because it suggests that distant regions in alanine tRNA are functionally coupled during synthetase recognition and more generally because recognition determinants of many other tRNAs lie in both the acceptor helix and anticodon helix region. Here, we have conducted an extensive in vivo analysis of the distal wobble pair in alanine tRNA and report that it does not behave like a compensating mutation. Restoration of alanine acceptance was not detected even when the synthetase enzyme was overproduced. We discuss the previous experimental evidence and suggest how the distal wobble pair was incorrectly analyzed. The available data indicate that all principal recognition determinants of alanine tRNA lie in the molecule's acceptor helix.

Universal rules and idiosyncratic features in tRNA identity

Correct expression of the genetic code at translation is directly correlated with tRNA identity. This survey describes the molecular signals in tRNAs that trigger specific aminoacylations. For most tRNAs, determinants are located at the two distal extremities: the anticodon loop and the amino acid accepting stem. In a few tRNAs, however, major identity signals are found in the core of the molecule. Identity elements have different strengths, often depend more on k cat effects than on K m effects and exhibit additive, cooperative or anti-cooperative interplay. Most determinants are in direct contact with cognate synthetases, and chemical groups on bases or ribose moieties that make functional interactions have been identified in several systems. Major determinants are conserved in evolution; however, the mechanisms by which they are expressed are species dependent. Recent studies show that alternate identity sets can be recognized by a single synthetase, and emphasize the importance of tRNA architecture and anti-determinants preventing false recognition. Identity rules apply to tRNA-like molecules and to minimalist tRNAs. Knowledge of these rules allows the manipulation of identity elements and engineering of tRNAs with switched, altered or multiple specificities.

Species-specific differences in the operational RNA code for aminoacylation of tRNAPro

An operational RNA code relates amino acids to specific structural features located in tRNA acceptor stems. In contrast to the universal nature of the genetic code, the operational RNA code can vary in evolution due to coadaptations of the contacts between aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and the acceptor stems of their cognate tRNA substrates. Here we demonstrate that, for class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS), functional coadaptations have occurred in going from the bacterial to the human enzyme. Analysis of 20 ProRS sequences that cover all three taxonomic domains (bacteria, eucarya, and archaea) revealed that the sequences are divided into two evolutionarily distant groups. Aminoacylation assays showed that, while anticodon recognition has been maintained through evolution, significant changes in acceptor stem recognition have occurred. Whereas all tRNAPro sequences from bacteria strictly conserve A73 and C1.G72, all available cytoplasmic eukaryotic tRNAPro sequences have a C73 and a G1.C72 base pair. In contrast to the Escherichia coli synthetase, the human enzyme does not use these elements as major recognition determinants, since mutations at these positions have only small effects on cognate synthetase charging. Additionally, E. coli tRNAPro is a poor substrate for human ProRS, and the presence of the human anticodon-D stem biloop domain was necessary and sufficient to confer efficient aminoacylation by human ProRS on a chimeric tRNAPro containing the E. coli acceptor-TpsiC stem-loop domain. Our data suggest that the two ProRS groups may reflect coadaptations needed to accommodate changes in the operational RNA code for proline.

Amber suppression in Escherichia coli by unusual mitochondria-like transfer RNAs

The "cloverleaf" base-pairing pattern was established as the structural paradigm of active tRNA species some 30 years ago. Nevertheless, this pattern does not accommodate the folding of certain mitochondrial tRNAs. For these recalcitrant tRNAs, we have proposed structures having from 5 to 10 base pairs in the anticodon stem rather than the canonical 6. The absence of these types of tRNAs in cytoplasmic translation systems, however, raises the possibility that they may not be bona fide alternate folding patterns for active tRNA molecules. For this reason, we have designed new tRNA genes based on our model of unusual mitochondrial tRNAs, having 7, 8, 9, and 10 base pairs in the anticodon stem with other modifications to the D-stem and connector regions. We show here that these synthetic genes produce tRNAs that actively suppress amber codons in vivo.

Expansion of the genetic code: site-directed p-fluoro-phenylalanine incorporation in Escherichia coli

Site-directed incorporation of the amino acid analogue p-fluoro-phenylalanine (p-F-Phe) was achieved in Escherichia coli. A yeast suppressor tRNA(Phe)amber/phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase pair was expressed in an analogue-resistant E. coli strain to direct analogue incorporation at a programmed amber stop codon in the DHFR marker protein. The programmed position was translated to 64-75% as p-F-Phe and the remainder as phenylalanine and lysine. Depending on the expression conditions, the p-F-Phe incorporation was 11-21-fold higher at the programmed position than the background incorporation at phenylalanine codons, showing high specificity of analogue incorporation. Protein expression yields of 8-12 mg/L of culture, corresponding to about two thirds of the expression level of the wild-type DHFR protein, are sufficient to provide fluorinated proteins suitable for 19F-NMR spectroscopy and other sample-intensive methods. The use of a nonessential "21st" tRNA/synthetase pair will permit incorporation of a wide range of analogues, once the synthetase specificity has been modified accordingly.

Domains of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from Thermus thermophilus required for aminoacylation

The contribution of entire domains or particular amino acid residues of the phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (FRS) from Thermus thermophilus to the interaction with tRNA(Phe) was studied. Removal of domain 8 of the beta subunit resulted in drastic reduction of the dissociation constant of the FRS x tRNA(Phe) complex. Neither the removal of arginine 2 of the beta subunit, which makes the only major contact between domains beta1-5 and the tRNA, nor the replacement of the conserved proline 473 by glycine had an influence on the aminoacylation activity of the FRS. Thus, the body comprising domains 1-5 of the beta subunit may not be essential for efficient aminoacylation of tRNA(Phe) by the FRS and rather be involved in other functions.

Human lysyl-tRNA synthetase accepts nucleotide 73 variants and rescues Escherichia coli double-defective mutant

The nucleotide 73 (N73) "discriminator" base in the acceptor stem is a key element for efficient and specific aminoacylation of tRNAs and of microhelix substrates derived from tRNA acceptor stems. This nucleotide was possibly one of the first to be used for differentiating among groups of early RNA substrates by tRNA synthetases. In contrast to many other synthetases, we report here that the class II human lysyl-tRNA synthetase is relatively insensitive to the nature of N73. We cloned, sequenced, and expressed the enzyme, which is a close homologue of the class II yeast aspartyl-tRNA synthetase whose co-crystal structure (with tRNAAsp) is known. The latter enzyme has a strong requirement for G73, which interacts with 4 of the 14 residues within the "motif 2" loop of the enzyme. Even though eukaryotic lysine tRNAs also encode G73, the motif 2 loop sequence of lysyl-tRNA synthetase differs at multiple positions from that of the aspartate enzyme. Indeed, the recombinant human lysine enzyme shows little preference for G, and even charges human tRNA transcripts encoding the A73 found in E. coli lysine tRNAs. Moreover, while the lysine enzyme is the only one in E. coli to be encoded by two separate genes, a double mutant that disables both genes is complemented by a cDNA expressing the human protein. Thus, the sequence of the loop of motif 2 of human lysyl-tRNA synthetase specifies a structural variation that accommodates nucleotide degeneracy at position 73. This sequence might be used as a starting point for obtaining highly specific interactions with any given N73 by simple amino acid replacements.

Transfer RNA(Phe) isoacceptors possess non-identical set of identity elements at high and low Mg2+ concentration

Primary structures of phage T5- and Escherichia coli-encoded tRNA(Phe) are distinct at four out of 11 positions known as identity elements for E. coli phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (FRS). In order to reveal structural requirements for FRS recognition, aminoacylation of wild-type phage T5 tRNA(Phe) gene transcript and mutants containing substitutions of the identity elements at positions 20, 34, 35 and 36 was compared with E. coli tRNA(Phe) gene transcript. The wild-type phage T5 transcript can be aminoacylated with the same catalytic efficiency as the E. coli counterpart. However, the maximal aminoacylation rate for T5 and E. coli transcripts was reached at different Mg2+ concentrations: 4 and 15 mM, respectively. Aminoacylation assays with tRNA(Phe) mutants revealed that (i) phage transcripts with the substituted anticodon bases at positions 35 and 36 were efficient substrates for aminoacylation at 15 mM Mg2+ but not at optimal 4 mM Mg2+; (ii) any change of G34 in phage transcripts dramatically decreased the aminoacylation efficiency at both 4 and 15 mM Mg2+ whereas G34A mutation in the E. coli transcript exhibits virtually no influence on aminoacylation rate at 15 mM Mg2+; (iii) substitution of A20 with U in the phage transcript caused no significant change in the aminoacylation rate at both Mg2+ concentrations; (iv) phage transcripts with double substitutions A20U+A35C and A20U+A36C were very poor substrates for FRS. Collectively, the results indicate the non-identical mode of tRNA(Phe) recognition by E. coli FRS at low and high Mg2+ concentrations. Probably, along with identity elements, the local tRNA conformation is essential for recognition by FRS.

Crystal structure of an alternating octamer r(GUAUGUA)dC with adjacent G x U wobble pairs

The crystal structure of the RNA duplex, r(GUAUGUA)dC, with a 3'-terminal deoxy C residue, has been determined at 1.38 A resolution. The r(GUAUGU) hexameric consensus sequence is present at the exon-intron junction in pre-mRNAs of yeast and higher eukaryotic organisms. The crystal belongs to the rhombohedral space group R3. The hexagonal unit cell dimensions are a = b = 39.71 A, c = 68.15 A and gamma = 120 degrees with one duplex in the asymmetric unit. The structure was solved using the molecular replacement method. The final model contains 332 atoms of the duplex and 67 solvent molecules. The R-factor is 17.6% (Rfree of 23.1%) for 4035 reflections with F > or = 1.5sigma(F) in the resolution range 10.0 to 1.38 A. The duplex is of the A-type with a pseudodyad relating the two strands. The RNA helix is slightly distorted, in spite of the presence of two adjacent G x U wobble base-pairs located at the center of the helix. The twist angle between the wobble pairs, 38.1 degrees, is above the average value and those between the wobble base-pairs and the flanking Watson-Crick base-pairs, 26.7 degrees and 26.3 degrees, respectively, are lower than the average values. The twist between the junction base-pairs are about 24 degrees. The G x U wobble pairs are bridged by water molecules and solvated in the grooves. G x U base-pairs are as stable as the Watson-Crick A x U pairs and only slightly less stable than the G x C pairs accounting for their frequent occurrence in RNA.

A novel bacterial vector system for monitoring protein-protein interactions in the cAMP-dependent protein kinase complex

A bacterial expression vector is described for investigation of protein-protein interactions. Important features of the vector include partition of the cI repressor of bacteriophage lambda into two functional domains separated by a multicloning site, and low level auto-regulated expression of human genes as C-terminal fusions to the DNA-binding domain of cI. Two different reporter systems have been employed; expression of either a suppressor tRNA or the alkaline phosphatase gene is dependent in both cases on the extent of repression of the major leftward promoter of lambda (lambdaP(L)). The cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) has been used as a model protein complex because both homodimer and heterodimer interactions are known to occur and because cAMP acts as a modulator of these interactions. It has been shown that the product of the repressor gene with newly incorporated expressed polylinker restriction sites still functions as a repressor. Substitution of the dimerisation domain of the cI repressor with the regulatory subunit of PKA does not diminish the ability of a cI fusion protein to repress expression of the reporter gene from lambdaP(L), indicating that the regulatory subunit of PKA dimerises the fusion protein in the Escherichia coli cytoplasm. Substitution instead with the catalytic subunit of PKA destroys the repression ability of cI, which is partially restored by separate expression of the regulatory subunit within the same cell. Complete restoration is achieved using a host E. coli strain which has lost its ability to synthesise cAMP and again this can be reversed by the addition of exogenous cAMP to these cells. Human PKA has been reconstituted in the E. coli cytoplasm, where all subunit interactions appear functional and respond as expected to the allosteric modulator cAMP.

Functional evidence for indirect recognition of G.U in tRNA(Ala) by alanyl-tRNA synthetase

The structural features of the G.U wobble pair in Escherichia coli alanine transfer RNA (tRNA(Ala)) that are associated with aminoacylation by alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AlaRS) were investigated in vivo for wild-type tRNA(Ala) and mutant tRNAs with G.U substitutions. tRNA(Ala) with G.U, C.A, or G.A gave similar amounts of charged tRNA(Ala) and supported viability of E. coli lacking chromosomal tRNA(Ala) genes. tRNA(Ala) with G.C was inactive. Recognition of G.U by AlaRS thus requires more than the functional groups on G.U in a regular helix and may involve detection of a helical distortion.

Conservation in evolution for a small monomeric phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase of the tRNA(Phe) recognition nucleotides and initial aminoacylation site

We previously showed that yeast mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (MSF protein) is evolutionarily distant to the cytoplasmic counterpart based on a high degree of divergence in protein sequence, molecular mass, and quaternary structure. Using yeast cytoplasmic tRNA(Phe) which is efficiently aminoacylated by MSF protein, we report here the tRNA(Phe) primary site of aminoacylation and the identity determinants for MSF protein. As for the cytoplasmic phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (Sampson, J. R., Di Renzo, A. B., Behlen, L. S., & Uhlenbeck, O. C. (1989) Science 243, 1363-1366), MSF protein recognizes nucleotides from the anticodon and the acceptor end including base A73 and, as shown here, adjacent G1-C72 base pair or at least C72 base. This indicates that the way of tRNA(Phe) binding for the two phenylalanine enzymes is conserved in evolution. However, tRNA(Phe) tertiary structure seems more critical for the interaction with the cytoplasmic enzyme than with MSF protein, and unlike cytoplasmic phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase, the small size of the monomeric MSF protein probably does not allow contacts with residue 20 at the top corner of the L molecule. We also show that MSF protein preferentially aminoacylates the terminal 2'-OH group of tRNA(Phe) but with a catalytic efficiency for tRNA(Phe)-CC-3'-deoxyadenosine reduced 100-fold from that of native tRNA(Phe), suggesting a role of the terminal 3'-OH in catalysis. The loss is only 1.5-fold when tRNA(Phe)-CC-3'-deoxyadenosine is aminoacylated by yeast cytoplasmic PheRS (Sprinzl, M., & Cramer, F. (1973) Nature 245, 3-5), indicating mechanistic differences between the two PheRS's active sites for the amino acid transfer step.

Recognition of tRNAPhe by phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase of Thermus thermophilus

The tRNA(Phe) nucleotides required for recognition by phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase of Thermus thermophilus have been determined using Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe) transcripts with various mutations. The anticodon nucleotides are shown to be the most important recognition elements. The discriminator nucleotide, A73, involved in the recognition set of yeast, E. coli and human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases contributes only slightly to tRNA(Phe) recognition by Th. thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase. Nucleotide 20 and some tertiary nucleotides, including the conserved G19.C56 base pair, are proposed to participate in stabilization of the precise tRNA conformation required for efficient aminoacylation. The role of the 3'-CCA terminus, common to all tRNAs, in the specific interaction of tRNA with phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is discussed.

Footprinting of tRNA(Phe) transcripts from Thermus thermophilus HB8 with the homologous phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase reveals a novel mode of interaction

The phosphates of the tRNA(Phe) transcript from Thermus thermophilus interacting with the cognate synthetase were determined by footprinting. Backbone bond protection against cleavage by iodine of the phosphorothioate-containing transcripts was found in the anticodon stem-loop, the D stem-loop and the acceptor stem and weak protection was also seen in the variable loop. Most of the protected phosphates correspond to regions around known identity elements of tRNA(Phe). Enhancement of cleavage at certain positions indicates bending of tRNAPhe upon binding to the enzyme. When applied to the three-dimensional model of tRNA(Phe) from yeast the majority of the protections occur on the D loop side of the molecule, revealing that phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase has a rather complex and novel pattern of interaction with tRNAPhe, differing from that of other known class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases.

Use of semi-synthetic transfer RNAs to probe molecular recognition by Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase

BACKGROUND

The attachment of specific amino acids to the 3'-end of cognate transfer of RNAs (tRNAs) is catalyzed by a class of enzymes known as aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS). We have previously demonstrated that Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase (ProRS) can aminoacylate semi-synthetic tRNAs prepared by annealing two RNA oligonucleotides. We set out to examine the factors that are important in selective recognition of tRNAPro by ProRS, using semi-synthetic tRNAs and full-length tRNA transcripts.

RESULTS

Deletion of nucleotides A58, A59, and U60 in the T psi C-loop of semi-synthetic tRNAs has no adverse effect on aminoacylation. Nucleotide deletions that extend into the T psi stem, particularly beyond C61, significantly reduce the efficiency of aminoacylation, however. Site-directed mutagenesis of full-length tRNAPro transcripts shows that, although there is no strict sequence requirement at base pair 52.62 in the T psi C stem, helix destabilizing purine-purine mismatches at this position result in decreased aminoacylation activity. Moreover, aminoacylation is severely affected when a DNA-RNA hybrid helix is incorporated into the acceptor-T psi C stem domain.

CONCLUSIONS

At least three nucleotides in the T psi C-loop are dispensable for aminoacylation of E. coli tRNAPro. These results, combined with previous data, demonstrate that four out of five of the so-called 'variable pocket' nucleotides are not important for recognition of tRNAPro by E. coli ProRS. ProRS is also sensitive to changes that are likely to alter the helical conformation in the T psi C stem.

Analysis of sequence dependent variations in secondary and tertiary structure of tRNA molecules

The double helical regions of the five tRNA(Phe) and two tRNA(Asp) crystal structures have been analyzed using the local basepair step parameters. The sequence dependent effects in the mini double helices of tRNA are very similar to those observed in the crystal structures of oligonucleotides in the A-form, the purine-pyrimidine and purine-purine steps have small roll angles when compared to the fiber models of A-DNA as well as A-RNA, while the pyrimidine-purine doublet steps have large roll angles. The orientation of the basepairs in the D-stem is unusual and invariant i.e. they are different from the other three stems but are very similar in all the five tRNA(Phe) crystal structures, presumably due to tertiary interaction of the Watson-Crick basepairs with other bases, with all bases being highly conserved. The origin of the differences between the tertiary structures of tRNA(Phe) and tRNA(Asp) from yeast has also been investigated. It is found that even though the angle between the acceptor arm and the D-stem is very similar in the two structures, the angle subtended by the acceptor arm and the anticodon arm is smaller in the tRNA(Phe) structure (by more than 10 degrees). This is due to differences in the orientation of the two mini helices constituting the anticodon arm, which are inclined to each other by approximately 25 degrees in tRNA(Phe) and 16 degrees in tRNA(Asp). In addition, the acceptor arm, the D-stem and the anticodon stem are nearly coplanar in tRNA(Phe), while in tRNA(Asp) the anticodon stem projects out of the plane defined by the acceptor arm and the anticodon stem. These two features together lead to a larger separation between the acceptor and anticodon ends in tRNA(Asp) and indicate that the junction between the D-stem and the anticodon stem is quite variable, with features characteristic of a ball-and-socket type joint and determined for each tRNA molecule by the base sequence at the junction.

Distinctive acceptor-end structure and other determinants of Escherichia coli tRNAPro identity

The previously uncharacterized determinants of the specificity of tRNAPro for aminoacylation (tRNAPro identity) were defined by a computer comparison of all Escherichia coli tRNA sequences and tested by a functional analysis of amber suppressor tRNAs in vivo. We determined the amino acid specificity of tRNA by sequencing a suppressed protein and the aminoacylation efficiency of tRNA by examining the steady-state level of aminoacyl-tRNA. On substituting nucleotides derived from the acceptor end and variable pocket of tRNAPro for the corresponding nucleotides in a tRNAPhe gene, the identity of the resulting tRNA changed substantially but incompletely to that of tRNAPro. The redesigned tRNAPhe was weakly active and aminoacyl-tRNA was not detected. Ethyl methanesulfonate mutagenesis of the redesigned tRNAPhe gene produced a mutant with a wobble pair in place of a base pair in the end of the acceptor-stem helix of the transcribed tRNA. This mutant exhibited both a tRNAPro identity and substantial aminoacyl-tRNA. The results speak for the importance of a distinctive conformation in the acceptor-stem helix of tRNAPro for aminoacylation by the prolyl-tRNA synthetase. The anticodon also contributes to tRNAPro identity but is not necessary in vivo.

The transfer RNA identity problem: a search for rules

Correct recognition of transfer RNAs (tRNAs) by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases is central to the maintenance of translational fidelity. The hypothesis that synthetases recognize anticodon nucleotides was proposed in 1964 and had considerable experimental support by the mid-1970s. Nevertheless, the idea was not widely accepted until relatively recently in part because the methodologies initially available for examining tRNA recognition proved hampering for adequately testing alternative hypotheses. Implementation of new technologies has led to a reasonably complete picture of how tRNAs are recognized. The anticodon is indeed important for 17 of the 20 Escherichia coli isoaccepting groups. For many of the isoaccepting groups, the acceptor stem or position 73 (or both) is important as well.

Two novel pathogenic mitochondrial DNA mutations affecting organelle number and protein synthesis. Is the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene an etiologic hot spot?

We identified two patients with pathogenic single nucleotide changes in two different mitochondrial tRNA genes: the first mutation in the tRNA(Asn) gene, and the ninth known mutation in the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene. The mutation in tRNA(Asn) was associated with isolated ophthalmoplegia, whereas the mutation in tRNA(Leu(UUR)) caused a neurological syndrome resembling MERRF (myoclonus epilepsy and ragged-red fibers) plus optic neuropathy, retinopathy, and diabetes. Both mutations were heteroplasmic, with higher percentages of mutant mtDNA in affected tissues, and undetectable levels in maternal relatives. Analysis of single muscle fibers indicated that morphological and biochemical alterations appeared only when the proportions of mutant mtDNA exceeded 90% of the total cellular mtDNA pool. The high incidence of mutations in the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene suggests that this region is an "etiologic hot spot" in mitochondrial disease.

A 2-thiouridine derivative in tRNAGlu is a positive determinant for aminoacylation by Escherichia coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase

Early investigations into the interaction between Escherichia coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS) and tRNAGlu have implicated the modified nucleoside 5-[(methylamino)methyl]-2-thiouridine in the first position of the anticodon as an important contact for efficient aminoacylation. However, the experimental methods employed were not sufficient to determine whether the interaction was dependent on the presence of the modification or simply involved other anticodon loop-nucleotides, now occluded from interaction with the synthetase. Unmodified E. coli tRNA(Glu), derived by in vitro transcription of the corresponding gene, is a poor substrate for GluRS, exhibiting a 100-fold reduction in its specificity constant (kcat/KM) compared to that of tRNA(Glu) prepared from an overproducing strain. Through the use of recombinant RNA technology, we created several hybrid tRNAs which combined sequences from the in vitro transcript with that of the native tRNA, resulting in tRNA molecules differing in modified base content. By in vitro aminoacylation of these hybrid tRNA molecules and of tRNAs with base substitutions at positions of nucleotide modification, we show conclusively that the modified uridine at position 34 in tRNA(Glu) is required for efficient aminoacylation by E. coli GluRS. This is only the second example of a tRNA modification acting as a positive determinant for interaction with its cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase.

Association of tRNA(Gln) acceptor identity with phosphate-sugar backbone interactions observed in the crystal structure of the Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase-tRNA(Gln) complex

We isolated several mutants with nucleotide substitutions in alanine tRNA (tRNA(Ala)) that resulted in glutamine tRNA (tRNA(Gln)) acceptor identity in Escherichia coli. These substitutions were in three regions of tRNA structure not previously associated with tRNA(Gln) acceptor identity. Only the phosphate-sugar backbone moieties of these nucleotides interact with the enzyme in the previously determined X-ray crystal structure of the complex between tRNA(Gln) and glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase. We conclude that these sequence-dependent phosphate-sugar backbone interactions contribute to tRNA(Gln) identity, and argue that the interactions help communicate enzyme recognition of the anticodon to the acceptor end of the tRNA and the catalytic center of the enzyme.

A 15N-1H nuclear magnetic resonance study on the interaction between isoleucine tRNA and isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase from Escherichia coli

Imino 15N and 1H resonances of Escherichia coli tRNA(lIle) were observed in the absence and presence of E coli isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase. Upon complex formation of tRNA(lIle) with isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase, some imino 15N-1H resonances disappeared, and some others were significantly broadened and/or shifted in the 1H chemical shift, while the others were observed at the same 15N-1H chemical shifts. It was indicated that the binding of tRNA(lIle) with IleRS affect the following four regions: the anticodon stem, the junction of the acceptor and T stems, the middle of the D stem, and the region where the tertiary base pair connects the T, D, and extra loops. This result is consistent with those of chemical footprinting and site-directed mutagenesis studies. Taken together, these three independent results reveal the recognition mechanism of tRNA(lIle) by IleRS: IleRS recognizes all the identity determinants distributed throughout the tRNA(lIle) molecule, which induces changes in the secondary and tertiary structures of tRNA(lIle).

Synthetase competition and tRNA context determine the in vivo identify of tRNA discriminator mutants

The discriminator nucleotide (position 73) in tRNA has long been thought to play a role in tRNA identity as it is the only variable single-stranded nucleotide that is found near the site of aminoacylation. For this reason, a complete mutagenic analysis of the discriminator in three Escherichia coli amber suppressor tRNA backgrounds was undertaken; supE and supE-G1C72 glutamine tRNAs, gluA glutamate tRNA and supF tyrosine tRNA. The effect of mutation of the discriminator base on the identity of these tRNAs in vivo was assayed by N-terminal protein sequencing of E. coli dihydrofolate reductase, which is the product of suppression by the mutated amber suppressors, and confirmed by amino acid specific suppression experiments. In addition, suppressor efficiency assays were used to estimate the efficiency of aminoacylation in vivo. Our results indicate that the supE glutamine tRNA context can tolerate multiple mutations (including mutation of the discriminator and first base-pair) and still remain predominantly glutamine-accepting. Discriminator mutants of gluA glutamate tRNA exhibit increased and altered specificity probably due to the reduced ability of other synthetases to compete with glutamyl-tRNA synthetase. In the course of these experiments, a glutamate-specific mutant amber suppressor, gluA-A73, was created. Finally, in the case of supF tyrosine tRNA, the discriminator is an important identity element with partial to complete loss of tyrosine specificity resulting from mutation at this position. It is clear from these experiments that it may not be possible to assign a specific role in tRNA identity to the discriminator. The identity of a tRNA in vivo is determined by competition among aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, which is in turn modulated by the nucleotide substitution as well as the tRNA context.

The role of anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in the recognition of some E. coli tRNAs by their aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The T7 polymerase transcription system was used for in vitro synthesis of unmodified versions of the E. coli tRNA mutants that insert asparagine, cysteine, glycine, histidine, and serine. These tRNAs were used to qualitatively explore the role of some anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in the recognition of tRNA by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Coupled with data from earlier studies, these new results essentially complete a survey of all E. coli tRNAs with respect to the involvement of anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in tRNA recognition. It is found that in the vast majority of tRNAs both of these elements are significant components of tRNA identity. This is not universally true, however. Anticodon sequences are unimportant in tRNA(Ser), tRNA(Leu), and tRNA(Ala) while the discriminator base is inconsequential in tRNA(Ser) and tRNA(Thr). The significance of these results for origin-of-life studies is discussed.

Eight base changes are sufficient to convert a leucine-inserting tRNA into a serine-inserting tRNA

Each aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase must functionally distinguish its cognate tRNAs from all others. We have determined the minimum number of changes required to transform a leucine amber suppressor tRNA to serine identity. Eight changes are required. These are located in the acceptor stem and in the D stem.

Anticodon-independent aminoacylation of an RNA minihelix with valine

Minihelices mimicking the amino acid acceptor and anticodon branches of yeast tRNA(Val) have been synthesized by in vitro transcription of synthetic templates. It is shown that a minihelix corresponding to the amino acid acceptor branch and containing solely a valine-specific identity nucleotide can be aminoacylated by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase. Its charging ability is lost after mutating this nucleotide. This ability is stimulated somewhat by the addition of a second hairpin helix that mimicks the anticodon arm, which suggests that information originating from the anticodon stem-loop can be transmitted to the active site of the enzyme by the core of the protein.

Identity determinants of E. coli threonine tRNA

To investigate the identity determinants of E. coli threonine tRNA, various transcripts were prepared by in vitro transcription system with T7 RNA polymerase. Substitutions of the anticodon second letter G35 and the third letter U36 to other nucleotides led to a remarkable decrease of threonine charging activity. Charging experiments with a series of anticodon-deletion transcripts also suggest the importance of the G35U36 sequence. A mutation at either the G1-C72 or C2-G71 base pair in the acceptor stem seriously affected the threonine charging activity. These results indicate that the second and third positions of the anticodon and the first and second base pairs in the acceptor stem are the recognition sites of E. coli tRNA(THR) for threonyl-tRNA synthetase. Discriminator base, A73, is not involved in threonine charging activity.

Determination of tRNA(Phe) recognition nucleotides for phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from Thermus thermophilus

The tRNA(Phe) recognition nucleotides for phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from an extreme thermophile Thermus thermophilus were investigated. Using yeast tRNA(Phe) T7 transcripts with various point mutations it was shown that four recognition points (G34, A35, A36 from anticodon and A73 from acceptor stem) are important for aminoacylation at 37 degrees C. In the case of the 73rd discriminator base A----U, but not A----C, substitution suppresses aminoacylation. Position 20, which proved to be essential for all phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases so far studied, is not involved in the recognition of tRNA(Phe) by the T thermophilus enzyme.

Recognition nucleotides for human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase

The specificity of the interaction between tRNAPhe and phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase isolated from human placenta was investigated. Using yeast tRNAPhe transcripts with different point mutations it was shown that all the five recognition points for the yeast phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (G20, G34, A35, A36 and A73) are also important for the reaction catalyzed by the human enzyme. A set of mutations in nucleotides involved in tertiary interactions of tRNAPhe revealed that mutations which maintained the proper folding of the molecule had almost no influence on the efficiency of aminoacylation. The most striking difference between the yeast and human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases involved a mutation in the lower two base pairs of the anticodon stem. This mutation did not affect aminoacylation with the yeast enzyme, but greatly reduced activity with human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase.

Four sites in the acceptor helix and one site in the variable pocket of tRNA(Ala) determine the molecule's acceptor identity

The structural features that determine tRNA(Ala) acceptor identity have been studied with amber-suppressor tRNAs in Escherichia coli cells. Previous work established that a wobble pair composed of guanosine at position 3 and uridine at position 70 (G3-U70) in the acceptor helix of tRNA(Ala) is a determinant of the molecule's acceptor identity. We show that additional determinants are located at three other sites in the acceptor helix and at one site in the variable pocket of tRNA(Ala). These latter determinants are less important than G3.U70 since their individual alterations in mutants of tRNA(Ala) have smaller degrading effects on the functions of the molecules, and subsets of the determinants, when combined with G3.U70, are sufficient to switch the identities of several other tRNAs to that of tRNA(Ala). Other workers are using fragments of the tRNA(Ala) acceptor helix to study the molecule's acceptor identity. Our demonstration that the variable pocket contributes to tRNA(Ala) acceptor identity means that such fragments do not faithfully replicate the structure-function relationship of the cellular process.

Evolution of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase quaternary structure and activity: Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase

Phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases [L-phenylalanine:tRNAPhe ligase (AMP-forming), EC 6.1.1.20] from Escherichia coli, yeast cytoplasm, and mammalian cytoplasm have an unusual conserved alpha 2 beta 2 quaternary structure that is shared by only one other aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. Both subunits are required for activity. We show here that a single mitochondrial polypeptide from Saccharomyces cerevisiae is an active phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase. This protein (the MSF1 gene product) is active as a monomer. It has all three characteristic sequence motifs of the class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, and its activity may result from the recruitment of additional sequences into an alpha-subunit-like structure.