Treatment of locoregional recurrence of carcinoma of the cervix by radiotherapy after primary surgery

Salvage image-guided freehand interstitial brachytherapy for pelvic sidewall recurrence after hysterectomy for uterine malignancies

PURPOSE

Pelvic sidewall recurrence after hysterectomy for uterine malignances has a poor prognosis, and the salvage therapy for this type of recurrence is still challenging. The purpose of this study was to investigate the efficacy of freehand high-dose-rate interstitial brachytherapy (HDR-ISBT) through the perineum using transrectal ultrasonography for this disease.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We retrospectively evaluated 42 patients with pelvic sidewall recurrence after hysterectomy for uterine cervical and endometrial cancers. We investigated patients' characteristics, the 2-year local control and survival rates, and late adverse events of the rectum and bladder.

RESULTS

The 2-year overall survival, local control, and progression-free survival rates were 73.7% (95% confidence interval [CI], 60.8-89.3%), 69.4% (95% CI, 55.4-80.1%), and 37.3% (95% CI, 24.6-56.5%), respectively. In Cox multivariate analysis, tumor size at recurrence (<45 mm vs. ≥45 mm) (p = 0.04) and disease-free periods after hysterectomy (<10 months vs. ≥10 months) (p < 0.01) were significant prognostic factors for overall survival. Lymph node metastasis at recurrence (p < 0.01) was also a significant prognostic factor for progression-free survival. Three patients experienced Grade 3-4 late proctitis (7%).

CONCLUSIONS

Transperineal freehand salvage HDR-ISBT using transrectal ultrasonography was demonstrated to be a curative treatment option for patients with pelvic sidewall recurrence following hysterectomy. Based on the findings of this study, we emphasize the importance of HDR-ISBT for pelvic sidewall recurrence.

Concurrent 5-Fluorouracil, Mitomycin C and Radiation with or without Brachytherapy in Recurrent Cervical Cancer: A Scoring System to Predict Clinical Response and Outcome

Aims and purpose

This is a prospective, phase II study aimed to evaluate the effect of concurrent 5-fluorouracil, mitomycin C, and radiation with or without brachytherapy on the clinical outcome of a series of recurrent cervical cancer patients and to determine the prognostic impact of a subset of factors.

Methods

Thirty-three patients with locally recurrent, non-metastatic cervical cancer received external beam radiation (4-week split course: 23.4 + 23.4 Gy) plus two courses of concomitant chemotherapy (5-fluorouracil, 96-h continuous infusion, days 1–4, 1 g/m2/day; mitomycin C, 10 mg/m2, bolus iv, day 1). Twelve patients with vaginal recurrence (36.4%) underwent endocavitary low-dose rate brachytherapy boost (20–25 Gy); 11 patients with lateral pelvic recurrence (33.3%) received external beam radiation boost (14–20 Gy).

Results

Fourteen complete responses (42.4%), 7 partial responses (21.2%), 5 disease stabilizations (15.1%) and 7 progressions (21.2%) were obtained. After a median follow-up of 34 months (range, 6–127), overall actuarial 3-year survival, progression-free survival and local progression-free survival were 59.7%, 48.1% and 51.7%, respectively. Patients with vaginal recurrence of less than 4 cm and negative lymph nodes proved to respond best to the treatment. Two patients (6.1%) experienced hematologic grade 3 toxicity. One patient had grade 3 intestinal toxicity (3.0%). No patient had major skin or urological acute toxicity. Severe late toxicity was infrequent Three patients had prolonged leukopenia (9.0%). Four patients showed severe vaginal stenosis (12.1%). A clinical score of 0 to 1 was assigned to each patient on the basis of the absence (score = 0) or presence (score = 1) of any of the following prognostic factors: time between surgery and recurrence shorter than 12 months, pelvic wall site of recurrence, positive lymph nodes, hemoglobin <11 g/dL. Using this system, it was clear that patients with a low total score had a significantly better outcome (clinical remission, 51% of patients with a score ≤2 vs 12% of patients with a score >2, P = 0.06), local control of the disease (65% vs 20% after 3 years, P = 0.001,) and overall survival (75% vs 30% after 3 years, P = 0.032).

Conclusions

Our data suggest that this combined modality therapy was relatively well tolerated and resulted in reasonable local control and survival. The scoring system proved to be helpful to identify patients with the greatest chance of benefiting from the treatment Further studies are probably needed to salvage the other patients, whose prognosis remains severe.

Feasibility and Outcome of Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy for Recurrent Cervical Carcinoma after Initial Surgery

Aims and background

The prognosis for recurrent cervical carcinoma following initial surgery is dismal even when aggressive radiotherapy or salvage surgery is used. We retrospectively reviewed hospital records to evaluate the efficacy and feasibility of concurrent chemoradiotherapy as a salvage treatment.

Methods

From 1999 to 2007, 47 patients received salvage chemoradiotherapy. Involved-field irradiation was delivered at a median dose of 64.8 Gy (range, 36–100.2), including brachytherapy boost in 10 patients. Pelvic re-irradiation was performed in 4 of the 12 women who had a previous history of pelvic radiotherapy. All but one patient received cisplatin-based concomitant chemotherapy during radiotherapy.

Results

The median overall follow-up period was 27 months and for surviving patients was 57 months. The interval between initial surgery and recurrence was 22 months (range, 4–203), and the median recurrent mass size was 4 cm (range, 0.5–11). In 34 patients, recurrent tumors were confined to the pelvis (21 central and 13 peripheral). Grade 3–4 acute hematologic toxicity was the most frequent toxicity and was observed in 29 (62%) women. Five-year actuarial cumulative incidence of severe gastrointestinal and genitourinary toxicity was 13% and 7%, respectively. Thirty-three patients (70%) showed a complete response and 9 (19%) a partial response following salvage chemoradiation. Five-year overall and disease-free survival rates were 44% and 41%, respectively.

Conclusions

Salvage chemoradiotherapy appears to be a feasible treatment option for women with recurrent cervical carcinoma following surgery. The treatment had a high salvage rate and acceptable late complication rate, despite being associated with substantial acute toxicity.

Outcome of patients with local recurrent gynecologic malignancies after resection combined with intraoperative electron radiation therapy (IOERT)

Background

Treatment of recurrent gynecologic cancer is a challenging issue. Aim of the study was to investigate clinical features and outcomes of patients with recurrent gynecologic malignancies who underwent resection including IOERT (intraoperative electron radiation therapy) with regard to clinical outcome and potential predictive factors or subgroups that benefit most from this radical treatment regime.

Methods

A total of 36 patients with recurrent gynecologic malignancies (cervical (n = 18), endometrial (n = 12) or vulvar cancer (n = 6)) were retrospectively identified through hospital databases in accordance with institutional ethical policies.

Patient characteristics and outcomes were assessed. Survival data was analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier-method and log-rank-test, categorical variables were analyzed with chi-square-method.

Results

For the entire cohort 1-/2-/5-year Overall Survival (OS) was 65.3 %/36.2 %/21.7 %. Patients with endometrial, cervical, and vulvar carcinoma had a 1-/2-/5-year OS of 83.3 %/62.5 %/50 %, 44.5 %/25.4 %/6.4 %, and 83.3 %/16.7 %/16.7 %, respectively. Patients with endometrial carcinoma showed a significantly better OS (p = 0.038).

1-/2-/5-year Local Progression-free Survival (LPFS) for the entire cohort was 44.1 %/28 %/21 % with 76.2 %/61 %/40.6 % for endometrial, 17.2 %/0 %/0 % for cervical, and 40 %/20 %/20 % for vulvar cancer, respectively. Patients with endometrial cancer showed a significantly (p = 0.017) and older patients a trend (p = 0.059) for a better LPFS.

1-/2-/5-year Distant Progression-free Survival (DPFS) for the entire cohort was 53.1 %/46.5 %/38.7 % with 74.1 %/74.1 %/74.1 % for endometrial, 36.7 %/36.7 %/0 % for cervical, and 60 %/30 %/30 % for vulvar cancer, respectively. There was a significantly better DPFS for older patients (p = 0.015) and a trend for a better DPFS for patients with endometrial carcinoma (p = 0.075).

Conclusion

The radical procedure of resection combined with IOERT seems to be a valid curative treatment option for patients with recurrent endometrial carcinoma with 5-year survival rates of 50 %. For patients with cervical or vulvar cancer this treatment should be considered a rather palliative one and must be weighted carefully against other treatment options like chemotherapy, targeted therapies or new highly conformal radiotherapy techniques.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13014-016-0622-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

RapidArc for centrally recurrent cervical cancer in the vaginal cuff following primary surgical therapy: a case report

Background

Pelvic recurrences of cervical cancer after primary surgical treatment can be potentially cured with radical hysterectomy or chemoradiation therapy. Combined radio-chemotherapy is believed to improve results compared to other option. Currently, RapidArc radiotherapy is considered an excellent technological advance that shows great potential for producing highly conformal doses to treatment volumes.

Case presentation

We present a case of a 67-year-old woman with history of early cervical cancer initially treated by radical laparoscopic hysterectomy. More than 5 years later, the patient presented with a central pelvic vaginal cuff recurrence that is histologically confirmed. Salvage radiotherapy using RapidArc with concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy was indicated. A high dose of 70 Gy was delivered to the gross recurrent disease with simultaneous integrated boost (SIB) to the subclinical disease and good sparing of organs at risk especially the rectum and sigmoid.

Conclusions

This case clearly demonstrates a large benefit for salvage RapidArc radiotherapy to central pelvic recurrences of gynecological cancers with an excellent rate of local control and less rate of toxicity.

Resection of the vaginal vault for vaginal recurrence of cervical cancer after hysterectomy and brachytherapy

BACKGROUND

We describe our experiences with vaginal vault resection for vaginal recurrence of cervical cancer after hysterectomy and radiotherapy. After operative treatment, the rate of vaginal vault recurrence of uterine cervical cancer is reported to be about 5%. There is no consensus regarding the treatment for these cases.

METHODS

Between 2004 and 2012, eight patients with vaginal vault recurrence underwent removal of the vaginal wall via laparotomy after hysterectomy and radiotherapy.

RESULTS

The median patient age was 45 years (range 35 to 70 years). The median operation time was 244.5 min (range 172 to 590 min), the median estimated blood loss was 362.5 mL (range 49 to 1,890 mL), and the median duration of hospitalization was 24.5 days (range 11 to 50 days). Two patients had intraoperative complications: a grade 1 bowel injury and a grade 1 bladder injury. The following postoperative complications were observed: one patient had vaginal vault bleeding, three patients developed vesicovaginal fistulae, and one patient had repeated ileus. Two patients needed clean intermittent catheterization. Local control was achieved in five of the eight cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Vaginal vault resection is an effective treatment for vaginal recurrence of cervical cancer after hysterectomy and radiotherapy. However, complications of this procedure can be expected to reduce quality of life. Therefore, this operation should be selected with great care.

3D radiation therapy or intensity-modulated radiotherapy for recurrent and metastatic cervical cancer: the Shanghai Cancer Hospital experience

We evaluate the outcomes of irradiation by using three-dimensional radiation therapy (3D-RT) or intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) for recurrent and metastatic cervical cancer. Between 2007 and 2010, 50 patients with recurrent and metastatic cervical cancer were treated using 3D-RT or IMRT. The median time interval between the initial treatment and the start of irradiation was 12 (6–51) months. Salvage surgery was performed before irradiation in 5 patients, and 38 patients received concurrent chemotherapy. Sixteen patients underwent 3D-RT, and 34 patients received IMRT. Median follow-up for all the patients was 18.3 months. Three-year overall survival and locoregional control were 56.1% and 59.7%, respectively. Three-year progression-free survival and disease-free survival were 65.3% and 64.3%, respectively. Nine patients developed grade 3 leukopenia. Grade 5 acute toxicity was not observed in any of the patients; however, 2 patients developed Grade 3 late toxicity. 3D-RT or IMRT is effective for the treatment of recurrent and metastatic cervical cancer, with the 3-year overall survival of 56.1%, and its complications are acceptable. Long-term follow-up and further studies are needed to confirm the role of 3D-RT or IMRT in the multimodality management of the disease.

Management of recurrent cervical cancer: a review of the literature

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this narrative review is to update the current knowledge on the treatment of recurrent cervical cancer based on a literature review.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A web based search in Medline and CancerLit databases has been carried out on recurrent cervical cancer management and treatment. All relevant information has been collected and analyzed, prioritizing randomized clinical trials.

RESULTS

Cervical cancer still represents a significant problem for public health with an annual incidence of about half a million new cases worldwide. Percentages of pelvic recurrences fluctuate from 10% to 74% depending on different risk factors. Accordingly to the literature, it is suggested that chemoradiation treatment (containing cisplatin and/or taxanes) could represent the treatment of choice for locoregional recurrences of cervical cancer after radical surgery. Pelvic exenteration is usually indicated for selected cases of central recurrence of cervical cancer after primary or adjuvant radiation and chemotherapy with bladder and/or rectum infiltration neither extended to the pelvic side walls nor showing any signs of extrapelvic spread of disease. Laterally extended endopelvic resection (LEER) for the treatment of those patients with a locally advanced disease or with a recurrence affecting the pelvic wall has been described.

CONCLUSIONS

The treatment of recurrences of cervical carcinoma consists of surgery, and of radiation and chemotherapy, or the combination of different modalities taking into consideration the type of primary therapy, the site of recurrence, the disease-free interval, the patient symptoms, performance status, and the degree to which any given treatment might be beneficial.

Stereotactic body radiotherapy for local boost irradiation in unfavourable locally recurrent gynaecological cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate outcome of radiotherapy for locally recurrent cervical and endometrial cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nineteen patients were treated for a locally recurrent cervical (n=12) or endometrial (n=7) cancer median 26 months after initial surgery (n=18) or radiotherapy (n=1). The whole pelvis was irradiated with 50Gy conventionally fractionated radiotherapy (n=16). Because of large size of the recurrent cancer (median 4.5 cm) and peripheral location (n=12), stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT; median 3 fractions of 5Gy to 65%) was used for local dose escalation instead of (n=16) or combined with (n=3) vaginal brachytherapy.

RESULTS

After median follow-up of 22 months, 3-year overall survival was 34% with systemic progression the leading cause of death (7/10). Median time to systemic progression was 16 months. Three local recurrences resulted in a local control rate of 81% at 3 years. No correlation between survival, systemic or local control and any patient or treatment characteristic was observed. The rate of late toxicity>grade II was 25% at 3 years: two patients developed a grade IV intestino-vaginal fistula and one patient suffered from a grade IV small bowel ileus.

CONCLUSION

Image-guided SBRT for local dose escalation resulted in high rates of local control but was associated with significant late toxicity.

Influence of margin status and radiation on recurrence after radical hysterectomy in Stage IB cervical cancer

PURPOSE

To examine the relationship between margin status and local recurrence (LR) or any recurrence after radical hysterectomy (RH) in women treated with or without radiotherapy (RT) for Stage IB cervical carcinoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This study included 284 patients after RH with assessable margins between 1980 and 2000. Each margin was scored as negative (> or =1 cm), close (>0 and <1 cm), or positive. The outcomes measured were any recurrence, LR, and relapse-free survival.

RESULTS

The crude rate for any recurrence was 11%, 20%, and 38% for patients with negative, close, and positive margins, respectively. The crude rate for LR was 10%, 11%, and 38%, respectively. Postoperative RT decreased the rate of LR from 10% to 0% for negative, 17% to 0% for close, and 50% to 25% for positive margins. The significant predictors of decreased relapse-free survival on univariate analysis were the depth of tumor invasion (hazard ratio [HR] 2.14/cm increase, p = 0.007), positive margins (HR 3.92, p = 0.02), tumor size (HR 1.3/cm increase, p = 0.02), lymphovascular invasion (HR 2.19, p = 0.03), and margin status (HR 0.002/increasing millimeter from cancer for those with close margins, p = 0.03). Long-term side effects occurred in 8% after RH and 19% after RH and RT.

CONCLUSION

The use of postoperative RT may decrease the risk of LR in patients with close paracervical margins. Patients with other adverse prognostic factors and close margins may also benefit from the use of postoperative RT. However, RT after RH may increase the risk of long-term side effects.

An evidence-based estimate of the appropriate rate of utilization of radiotherapy for cancer of the cervix

PURPOSE

Current estimates of the proportion of cancer patients who will require radiotherapy (RT) are based almost entirely on expert opinion. The objective of this study was to calculate the proportion of incident cases of cervical cancer that should receive RT by application of an evidence-based approach.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A systematic review of the literature was done to identify indications for RT for cervical cancer and to ascertain the level of evidence that supported each indication. A survey of Canadian gynecologic oncologists and radiation oncologists who treat cervical cancer was done to determine the level of acceptance of each indication among doctors who practice in the field. An epidemiologic approach was then used to estimate the incidence of each indication for RT in a typical North American population of patients with cervical cancer.

RESULTS

The systematic review of the literature identified 29 different indications for RT for cervical cancer. The majority of the 75 experts who responded to the mail survey stated that they "usually" or "always" recommended RT in all but one of the clinical situations that were identified as indications for RT on the basis of the systematic review. The analysis of epidemiologic data revealed that, in a typical North American population, 65.4% +/- 2.5% of cervical cancer cases will develop one or more indications for RT at some point in the course of the illness, 63.4% +/- 2.3% will develop indications for RT as part of their initial management, and 2.0% +/- 0.9% will develop indications for RT for progressive or recurrent disease. The effects of variations in case mix on the need for RT was examined by sensitivity analysis, which suggested that the maximum plausible range for the appropriate rate of utilization of RT was 54.3% to 67.9%. The proportion of cases that required RT was stage dependent: 10.6% +/- 1.2% in Stage IA, 74.9% +/- 1.3% in Stage IB, 100% in Stages II and III, and 97.2% +/- 1.1% in Stage IV.

CONCLUSIONS

This evidence-based estimate of the appropriate rate of use of RT for cervical cancer adds to the growing pool of knowledge about the need for RT that will ultimately provide a rational basis for long-term planning for RT programs and for auditing access to RT in the general population.

Phase I study of combined radiation, hyperthermia and intra-arterial carboplatin for local recurrence of cervical cancer

BACKGROUND

Patients with cervical cancer who develop pelvic recurrence after primary surgery are usually treated with radiation-based therapy. However, their prognoses are dismal. We conducted a phase I study of combined radiation, hyperthermia and intra-arterial (IA) carboplatin for local recurrence of cervical cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients with local recurrence of cervical cancer without extrapelvic recurrence were included in this study. Carboplatin was given as a 5-min IA infusion without hydration just before pelvic radiation every day. External pelvic irradiation (1.8 Gy/day for 28 days) was performed according to local standard schedules. After 20 Gy had been administered, hyperthermia was performed once a week with a radio frequency heating system for four cycles.

RESULTS

Fifteen patients were entered through the four dose levels of carboplatin. The maximum tolerated dose was determined to be 25 mg/m(2 )and the dose-limiting toxicities were leukocytopenia, neutrocytopenia and diarrhea. Grade 3/4 leukocytopenia and diarrhea were observed in nine (60%) and three (20%) of 15 patients. Tumor responses included five complete responses and nine partial responses, and the overall response rate was 93.3% (14 of 15) (95% confidence interval 59.4% to 100%). Tumor reductions were observed only at 20 Gy in 10 cases of 14 responders (71.4%).

CONCLUSION

The combination therapy of radiation, hyperthermia and IA carboplatin is safe and well-tolerated for locally recurrent cervical cancer.

Treatment of recurrent gynecologic malignancies with iodine-125 permanent interstitial irradiation

PURPOSE

To analyze the outcome of permanent 125I interstitial radiotherapy for unresectable retroperitoneal recurrences of gynecologic malignancies.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A retrospective review of 20 patients treated between 1979 and 1993 was performed to evaluate survival and morbidity associated with the interstitial 125I technique.

RESULTS

Nineteen tumors were located on the lateral pelvic wall and one in the para-aortic region. Eight patients, not previously irradiated, received external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) along with 125I interstitial implants placed at the time of celiotomy. Nineteen (95%) are dead of disease at 1-69 months of follow-up. The median survival was 7.7 months for patients treated with 125I alone and 25.4 months for those treated with both 125I and EBRT. One patient is alive without evidence of disease 69 months after 125I implantation. Fistulas, bowel obstructions, and fatal complications occurred only among patients previously irradiated.

CONCLUSIONS

When used in a previously irradiated field, 125I interstitial radiotherapy has major morbidity and is unlikely to be associated with cure or long-term survival. In radiotherapy-naive patients with unresectable isolated recurrent gynecologic malignancies, 125I implants and EBRT are feasible and occasionally may contribute to long-term disease-free survival.

Recurrent cervical carcinoma after primary radical surgery

OBJECTIVE

This study was undertaken to investigate prognostic factors in patients with recurrent cervical carcinoma who had undergone a primary radical hysterectomy and pelvic lymphadenectomy.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective analysis of 177 patients with recurrent cervical carcinoma after radical hysterectomy and pelvic lymphadenectomy for stage IB to II disease at a single institution was performed to evaluate clinicopathologic parameters, time to recurrence, pattern of failure, use of salvage therapy, and survival after recurrence.

RESULTS

The 5-year survival rate from diagnosis of recurrence in this series was 10.1%. Survival after recurrence was significantly decreased in patients with pelvic lymph node metastasis at primary surgery and adenocarcinoma-adenosquamous carcinoma histologic type. Patients with extravaginal recurrences receiving chemoradiation for recurrent cervical carcinoma had significantly better outcomes than those receiving radiation alone. Six patients who had a distant relapse at a sole site had prolonged survival after salvage therapy, which was accomplished by chemoradiation, surgery plus radiotherapy, or surgery alone.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate the benefit of adding chemotherapy to radiotherapy in the treatment of recurrent cervical carcinoma. Salvage multimodality treatment should be offered to selected patients who have isolated relapse at a single distant site.

Laterally extended endopelvic resection: surgical treatment of infrailiac pelvic wall recurrences of gynecologic malignancies

OBJECTIVE

My purpose was to treat infrailiac pelvic wall recurrences of gynecologic malignancies with extended radical surgery.

STUDY DESIGN

On the basis of cadaver dissection studies, I developed the laterally extended endopelvic resection techniques. The new operations were offered to patients with infrailiac sidewall disease during a 3-year feasibility study.

RESULTS

Laterally extended endopelvic resections extending the lateral resection plane of pelvic exenteration to the medial aspects of the acetabulum, obturator membrane, sacrospinous ligament, and sacral plexus/piriformis muscle were performed in 18 consecutive patients. After this procedure, all patients had tumor-free intraoperative biopsy specimens taken from the remaining pelvic wall structures within the tumor bed area. The final histopathologic report confirmed clean margins in 6 patients and margins with microscopic tumor extensions only in 12 patients. Severe complications occurred in 4 patients (22%), without treatment-related deaths.

CONCLUSION

Laterally extended endopelvic resection allows the complete surgical removal of infrailiac pelvic-side-wall tumors, the most frequent local recurrence of lower genital tract cancer, either with free margins or with potential microscopic residual tumor as a prerequisite for combined operative and radiation treatment.

Pulsed dose rate (PDR) brachytherapy as salvage treatment of locally advanced or recurrent gynecologic cancer

PURPOSE

Pulsed dose rate (PDR) brachytherapy is a new treatment option permitting dose distribution optimization in interstitial implants. It possesses the advantage of equipment simplification and radiation protection to the staff, compared to the manually afterloading technique. This study presents the first clinical results from The Finsen Center with PDR-brachytherapy in patients with locally advanced or recurrent gynecologic cancer.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between June 1993 and August 1996, 34 patients with gynecologic malignancies (22 pelvic recurrences, 12 primary locally advanced) have been treated with external irradiation, four-field box technique, to 46 Gy/23 fractions, 5 F/week and 192Ir-interstitial PDR-brachytherapy in pulses of 0.6 Gy, one pulse per hour to a total of 30 Gy. The Martinez Universal Perineal Interstitial Template applicator was used for all implantations.

RESULTS

The overall complete response rate was 74%. At median 14 months follow-up (range 3-40) 15 patients were alive with no evidence of disease. Seven of 14 patients with a second recurrence or progressive disease were still alive. The overall 1- and 2-year survival was 71% and 63%, respectively. There was no difference in survival probability when stratifying the patients by primary diagnosis (recurrent vs. primary advanced), relapse locations (central vs. central + pelvic wall mass) or treatment volume. Seventeen chronic grade III complications were observed in 10 patients. Large treatment volumes significantly correlated to severe gastrointestinal complications. Fifteen of 17 chronic grade III complications were observed in patients treated for recurrent disease.

CONCLUSION

PDR-brachytherapy in combination with external irradiation is an effective treatment option for patients with locally advanced or recurrent gynecologic cancer, although substantial toxicity is observed in patients with large treatment volumes and recurrent disease.

Radiation therapy of pelvic recurrence after radical hysterectomy for cervical carcinoma

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the efficacy of radiation therapy and potential prognostic factors in patients treated for pelvic recurrence of cervical carcinoma after radical hysterectomy.

MATERIALS

The records of 50 patients treated between 1964 and 1994 for an isolated pelvic recurrence of cervical carcinoma a median of 10.5 months after initial radical hysterectomy were retrospectively reviewed. Patients were categorized according to the extent of disease on clinical examination as group 1, mucosal involvement only (5); group 2, paravaginal extension (11); group 3, central recurrence with pelvic wall extension (13); and group 4, recurrences limited to the pelvic sidewall (21). Seven patients with group 3 or 4 disease who had a poor performance status were treated with palliative intent using hypofractionated radiotherapy. The remaining 43 patients were treated with curative intent, 33 with radiotherapy only and 10 with a combination of cisplatin-based chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Survival rates were calculated from the date of initial recurrence. Median follow-up of surviving patients was 109 months.

RESULTS

The overall 5-year survival rate was 33% for all 50 patients (median survival, 18 months), 39% for the 43 patients treated with curative intent, and 25% for patients with isolated sidewall recurrences treated with curative intent. The survival rate was 69% for patients with group 1 and 2 disease and 18% for those treated with curative intent for group 3 disease (P = 0.07). The survival rate was better for patients with recurrent squamous carcinomas (51%) than for those with adenocarcinomas (14%) (P = 0. 05). Three group 4 patients who survived more than 5 years were treated with external-beam radiation alone. Eight-one percent of patients who had a second recurrence had evidence of disease progression. Three patients experienced late treatment complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients who experience an isolated recurrence of cervical cancer after initial radical hysterectomy have an excellent prognosis if disease does not involve the pelvic wall. Occasional long-term survivors of recurrent disease involving the pelvic wall justify an aggressive treatment approach.

[Pelvic wall recurrence of cervix carcinomas. Combined surgical-radio-chemotherapeutic procedure (CORCT)]

PURPOSE

The prognosis of patients with pelvic wall recurrences after primary therapy of cervical cancer is bad. In selected patients treated exclusively by surgery as primary therapy the 5-year survival rate was between 5 and 25%. Additionally the combination of operation and radiotherapy (CORT) improved the survival so far. We developed a new concept for the treatment of pelvic wall recurrences. This concept includes the combination of radical surgery, interstitial radiation and chemotheray--CORCT (combined operative- and radiochemotherapy).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

After radical surgery, interstitial HDR (Ir-192) brachytherapy in afterloading technique (2.5 Gy, 2 fractions/day in 5 days) was performed. Additionally a chemotherapy with cisplatin 25 mg/m2/day in 5 days and 5-fluorouracil 1000 mg/day in 5 days was applicated.

RESULTS

After combined operative- and radiotherapy 3 of 3 patients died after treatment within 8 months (median) because of distant metastases. After additive radiochemotherapy 3 of 4 patients had no evidence of disease (NED) after a follow-up period of 14 (12 to 30) months.

CONCLUSION

The first treatment results of the new designed combined operative- and radiochemotherapy concept (CORCT) led us to expect an improvement of the prognosis of patients with recurrences of cervical cancer at the pelvic wall.

Radiotherapy for centrally recurrent cervical cancer of the vaginal stump following hysterectomy

PURPOSE

This study was performed to establish the classification and the treatment modality for recurrent cervical cancer of the vaginal stump after hysterectomy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Ninety patients with centrally recurrent cervical cancer of the vaginal stump following hysterectomy were treated with high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy with or without external irradiation. The intervals between primary surgery and vaginal recurrences varied from 3 months to 36 years. Tumor size of the vaginal stump was determined by bimanual rectovaginal examination at the time of recurrence and was classified into three groups, i.e., small (no palpable tumor), medium (less than 3 cm), and large (3 cm or more).

RESULTS

The 10-year survival rates for all patients were 52%. Survival was greatly influenced by the tumor sizes of the vaginal stump. The 10-year survival rates of patients with small, medium, and large size tumors were 72, 48, and 0%, respectively. All patients with large size tumors died within 5 years. Of 90 patients, 75 (83%) were determined by physical examination to be free of tumor on at least one visit within 2 months of the completion of treatment (CR). The remaining 15 patients (17%) had physical findings suggestive of residual tumor (Residual). The overall 10-year survival rate for all patients with CR was 63%, compared with 10% for the patients with Residual (P < 0.0001). The incidences of distant metastases of the patients with or without local failure were 55 and 13%, respectively (P < 0.0001). The patients with local failure had significantly higher incidence of metastases. Most patients with small size tumor were treated with brachytherapy alone, and the survival rates of these patients were not improved by combination with external irradiation.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that tumor size was a significant prognostic factor for recurrent cervical cancer of the vaginal stump. Patients with small size tumors were recommended to be treated with brachytherapy alone.

Five-year experience with combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment of recurrent gynecologic tumors infiltrating the pelvic wall

BACKGROUND

Whereas 25 to 50% of selected patients with gynecologic tumors who relapse centrally in an irradiated pelvis can be salvaged by exenteration, postirradiation recurrence infiltrating the pelvic side wall generally has been fatal. We have designed the combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment (CORT) procedure for the treatment of postirradiation recurrence infiltrating the pelvic wall and developed several new techniques for its realization. The aim of the surgery is as follows: (1) total resection of the tumor with only a microscopic margin (R1) at the pelvic wall, preserving the bony pelvis and the neurovascular support of the leg; (2) modulation of the therapeutic index for a second high-dose irradiation of the pelvic wall by transferring autologous tissue from the abdomen or the thigh, and (3) reconstruction of pelvic organ functions lost due to tumor resection. The tumor bed is irradiated postoperatively with brachytherapy through transcutaneous guide tubes implanted at the pelvic wall.

METHODS

Between April 1989 and December 1994, we treated 48 patients with postirradiation recurrent or persistent gynecologic malignancies infiltrating the pelvic wall with CORT and followed them prospectively with the following endpoints: tumor control, survival, complications, and quality of life.

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 33 months (range, 3-71 months), the 5-year survival probability calculated with the Kaplan-Meier method was 44%. The overall local control rate was 68%, and 85% in the last 25 patients in the series. The censored severe complication rate at 5 years was 33%. No patient died as a consequence of the treatment. Quality of life was self-assessed with a validated questionnaire by 15 patients without evidence of disease, and was rated with a total of 74% of the maximum score points. Age of the patient, state of resection at the pelvic wall (R1 vs. R2), and recurrent tumor size independently influenced tumor progression after CORT in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

CORT appears to be a feasible, innovative treatment with long term survival potential and acceptable quality of life for selected patients with postirradiation gynecologic tumor recurrence infiltrating the pelvic wall. R1 resection of the tumor at the pelvic wall is mandatory; however, the reconstruction options within the pelvis are limited.

The treatment of stage I carcinoma of the cervix in the west of Scotland 1980-1987

OBJECTIVE

To examine the results of different treatments for Stage IA and IB carcinoma of the cervix in patients treated in the West of Scotland between 1980 and 1987.

DESIGN

A retrospective review of case records.

SETTING

The Beatson Oncology Centre, Western Infirmary and Belvidere Hospital, Glasgow, and the departments of gynaecology of hospitals in the west of Scotland.

SUBJECTS

One hundred and five patients with Stage IA and 420 patients with Stage IB carcinoma of the cervix.

RESULTS

A variety of treatments were used for women with Stage IA disease, with an overall actuarial five year survival of 100%. The overall actuarial five year survival for women with Stage IB disease was 79.5%. Patients with Stage IB disease treated by radical hysterectomy (n = 123) or radical radiotherapy (n = 229) had similar five year survival rates (86.3% and 79.5%, respectively), whereas patients treated initially by nonradical surgery (n = 68) had a significantly worse five year survival (68.1%; P = 0.008).

CONCLUSIONS

These results emphasize the need for adequate and appropriate surgery and the centralisation of treatment for early cervical cancer.

The combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment (CORT) of recurrent tumors infiltrating the pelvic wall: first experience with 18 patients

CORT is a new radiosurgical treatment concept for patients with recurrent gynecologic malignancies infiltrating the pelvic wall. The operative part consists of (i) staging laparotomy; (ii) maximum debulking of the tumor from the pelvic wall and exenteration of infiltrated central pelvic organs; (iii) implantation of brachytherapy guiding tubes on the residual tumor/tumor bed at the pelvic wall; (iv) pelvic wall plasty with muscle and omentum flaps to create a protective distance between the tubes and the pelvic hollow organs and to induce therapeutic angiogenesis; and (v) surgical reconstruction of bowel, bladder, and vulvoperineovaginal functions. Radiation is given postoperatively as fractionated HDR brachytherapy via the implanted tubes. Patients without prior pelvic radiation also receive preoperative whole pelvis teletherapy. Eighteen patients with recurrent malignancies infiltrating one pelvic wall have been treated with CORT in a prospective phase I/II trial at the University of Mainz. Fourteen patients had a history of radiation therapy with midpelvic doses of 40-100 Gy (median, 65 Gy) as primary treatment. Eleven patients (61%) are without evidence of disease at 6-32 months (median, 15 months) follow-up. Four patients have died from pelvic progression and distant metastases, and two patients are alive with disease after 12 months. There was no operative mortality; however, one patient succumbed from fatal thromboembolism 6 months after therapy. Three patients with prior radiation of greater than 75 Gy had to be treated for intestinal fistulas. We conclude that CORT is feasible with encouraging preliminary results.