A comparison of the HeLa DNA-synthesis inhibition test and the Ames test for screening of mutagenic carcinogens

Genotoxicity of dental materials

This study was performed to characterize the (possible) DNA-damaging properties of dental materials and to identify specific compounds that contribute to this genotoxicity. For screening, three tests that assay for different aspects of genotoxicity (i) the bacterial umu-test; (ii) the eucaryotic DNA synthesis inhibition test; and (iii) the in vivo alkaline filter elution technique were chosen. This investigation gives several lines of evidence that most dental materials tested (14 chemical monosubstances present in dental devices and 7 extracts of dental materials) yield 'positive' results in at least one of the genotoxicity tests, however, with effects ranging from 'borderline' to 'strong positive'. The extracts of the widely used dental materials Vitrebond and AH26 elicited clear concentration-related genotoxic responses in all test systems. On the basis of these data and public concern, more attention has to be given to local or systemic complications which may be associated with the use of dental materials.

[Neon-colored plastics for orthodontic appliances. Biocompatibility studies]

Public concern and issues of liability have made product safety a major concern throughout the medical field including orthodontics. The purpose of this study was to test the biocompatibility of the new neon colored plastic materials to be used for removable orthodontic appliances before they reach the market and are used in patient treatment. In addition, eight modifications of this synthetic material, which has been used in appliances for many years, were examined without neon color. The procedures established tested for: 1. mutagenicity, 2. toxicity, and 3. irritation of the mucous membrane. As alternatives to using animals the Ames Test, the Agar Overlay Assay, and the HET-CAM Test were employed to test for these properties. The tests revealed that, when the manufacturer's instructions are followed, neither the polymerized materials as used in patient appliances nor the shavings resulting from the orthodontist or the technician grinding the appliance exhibit mutagenic, toxic, or irritating properties.

Assessment of toxicity, clastogenicity, mutagenicity and transforming activity of pentoxifylline in mammalian cells cultured in vitro

We tested the possible cytotoxic, clastogenic and genotoxic effects of pentoxifylline on different lines of mammalian cells cultured in vitro. This study was part of the developmental research of agapurin, since pentoxifylline represents an effective compound of this drug. Cells treated for a short time manifested a relatively high resistance to the toxic effects of pentoxifylline. Generally, only cells treated for a long time (18 h) or a short time (2 h) with high concentrations of drug manifested sensitivity to the toxic effects of pentoxifylline. Although the tested drug induced DNA synthesis inhibition in V79 and EUE cells and clastogenic effects in V79 cells, it was not able to induce either 6-TGr mutations in the HGPRT locus of V79 cells or morphological transformation of Syrian hamster embryo cells. Adding of microsomal fraction S9 to the treated cells did not markedly change the effects of pentoxifylline on different studied endpoints. We suggest that pentoxifylline has no genotoxic effects, and that the cytotoxicity and induction of chromosomal aberrations were induced by inhibition of cellular DNA replication.

Application of the cell growth and DNA-inhibition tests for characterizing sulfate pulp mill waste waters

The evaluation of cytotoxic and genotoxic effects of selected technological samples from sulfate pulp mill waste waters by using the growing activity method for pseudodiploid fibroblasts V79 from lungs of the Chinese hamster and from human heteroploid fibroblasts EUE has been described along with the DNA-inhibition test for studying the synthesis of DNA after it has been influenced by the above-mentioned samples. Both the waste solution produced during the preparation of bleaching agents and the liquor generated after using hypochlorite (1st stage) as a fourth filter (after the production of paper pulp) are cytotoxic waste waters. Black liquor generated during the production of viscose pulp may have mutagenic effects and black liquor obtained from the production of paper pulp is characterized by mutagenic as well as carcinogenic effects.

A microplate version of the DNA-synthesis inhibition test for rapid detection of DNA-alteration potentials

A microplate version of the DNA-synthesis inhibition test (DIT) for fast detection of DNA-alteration potentials has been developed. The DIT is based on the concept that DNA damage causes inhibition of DNA synthesis that becomes detectable some time after replicating cells have been in contact with genotoxic agents. In this test procedure human tissue culture cells (HeLa S3), prelabeled with [14C]thymidine, arfe exposed for 90 min to the substances in question. After the cells are rinsed, they are allowed to recover for 2 1/2 h in fresh culture medium, thereby unspecific interactions interfering with DNA replication are practically eliminated. Next, [3H]thymidine is added for 30 min, and then the cells are harvested and thoroughly rinsed. Finally, incorporated radioactivity is determined by liquid scintillation counting for measurement of the 3H/14C ratio. This allows for the evaluation of DNA synthesis during the 3H-labeling period and of the extent of genotoxic damage. This microplate version of the DIT can be carried out fully automated in a laboratory workstation. The test is compared to other tests for genotoxicity. Its advantages are discussed.

Inhibition of DNA, RNA and protein synthesis and chromatin alteration by N-hydroxyphenacetin

The effects of N-hydroxyphenacetin on DNA function and structure were investigated to elucidate the involvement of phenacetin in analgesic nephropathy and transitional cell carcinoma. N-Hydroxyphenacetin or a metabolite inhibited synthesis of DNA, RNA and protein; DNA inhibition was greater at higher pH. No single-strand breaks were detectable in DNA after N-hydroxyphenacetin treatment and no appreciable effect on cell viability was observed at concentrations up to 5 mM. N-Hydroxyphenacetin-induced alteration to chromatin structure was detected using nucleoid sedimentation analysis. Direct binding to plasmid DNA was not observed. These observations are consistent with a role for phenacetin metabolites in renal disease.

Screening for carcinogens by the DNA synthesis inhibition test using human fibroblasts

The Ames test has probably been the most common prescreening test for potential carcinogens. This system, however, occasionally presents false-positive or false-negative results for certain kinds of chemicals. We chose 24 agents, most of which showed a discrepancy in their results with the animal carcinogenicity test and the Ames test, and screened them by the DNA synthesis inhibition test using human fibroblasts. Among 22 agents, 13 (59%) showed consistent results, 6 (27%) showed discrepant results with those obtained by animal tests and 3 (14%) showed ambiguous results. The majority of the DNA synthesis inhibition test results for these chemicals were consistent with the results obtained by whole animal tests, suggesting that the DNA synthesis inhibition test with mammalian cells in culture is a reasonably reliable prescreening test for potential carcinogens.

Results of genotoxicity testing of mazindol (degonan), lithium carbonicum (contemnol) and dropropizine (ditustat) in Chinese hamster V79 and human EUE cells

We studied inhibition of DNA synthesis, alkaline elution of DNA, cytotoxicity and occurrence of induced 6-thioguanine resistant mutants in mammalian cells, treated with mazindol, lithium carbonicum, and dropropizine, respectively, in the presence and in the absence of microsomal fraction S9. Among the above-mentioned clinically used drugs only dropropizine showed neither mutagenic nor clastogenic effects. Lithium carbonicum manifested a weak and mazindol a medium genotoxic response which was in both cases reduced in the presence of microsomal fraction S9.

Cholesterol epoxide is a direct-acting mutagen

A 24-hr treatment of V79 Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts with 12.4 microM cholesterol 5 alpha, 6 alpha-epoxide induced 8-azaguanine-resistant mutants at frequencies 4.6- to 11.8-fold higher than the spontaneous mutation rate. We show that cholesterol epoxide, which is produced by in vivo cholesterol oxidation, is a weak direct-acting mutagen. Cholesterol epoxide was found to be accumulated by cells and transformed to cholestane-3 beta, 5 alpha, 6 beta-triol, which was more toxic and a more potent inhibitor of DNA synthesis than the epoxide but, at concentrations less than 17.8 microM, was not significantly mutagenic. Consideration of the rates of cholesterol epoxide conversion to cholestane triol shows that this conversion can result in abolition of the mutagenicity of the epoxide. Conditions under which conversion of the epoxide to the triol is low, as in the case of low epoxide hydrolase activity, favor mutagenicity whereas rapid conversion to triol favors cytotoxicity.

Quantitative correlation with carcinogenic potency of different short term tests

The following short term parameters evaluating essentially genotoxic effects were considered: liver DNA alkaline fragmentation (DFI), morphological transformation in hamster embryo cells (TPI), and mutagenicity in the Ames' test (MPI). The internal consistency of the carcinogenicity data (OPI) was rather high (r approximately or equal to 0.8). The correlation with OPI of DFI and MPI was statistically significant but rather modest, about 0.4-0.5. The best correlation between OPI and TPI was 0.65. This level of correlation was observed only when some kind of dose-response relationship for transformation could be established. When comparisons were attempted for exactly the same 27 compounds for all three tests, a general decrease in predictability was observed. This could be mainly due to problems of representation of the ideal population of chemicals using small samples. The more general problem of the quantitative approach to the predictability of short term tests was also discussed.

Cellular toxicity in Chinese hamster ovary cell cultures. I. Analysis of cytotoxicity endpoints for twenty-nine priority pollutants

Chinese hamster ovary cells were exposed to 29 toxic chemical substances which were representative of several classes of compounds listed by the Natural Resources Defense Council Consent Decree as priority toxic pollutants. After cell cultures were exposed to the test substance, cell samples were assayed for protein and DNA synthesis, ATP, cell number, and viability. A filter-disk technique employing a batch-washing procedure was used for the determination of protein and DNA synthesis. Dose-response data were obtained for 15 of the more toxic agents including chlorinated aromatics, metallic compounds, phenols, and polychlorinated biphenyls. Estimates of the sample concentrations necessary to produce a 50% reduction in response were used to compare cytotoxicity endpoints. ATP and protein synthesis were approximately equally effective as indicators of cellular toxicity. Cadmium chloride, nickel nitrate, arsenic trioxide, and potassium chromate produced a more pronounced effect on DNA synthesis than on ATP or protein synthesis. The dose-response relationship for protein and DNA synthesis was a smooth, continuous function for responses as low as 1 to 2% of the control. On a log-log scale, the dose-response relation yielded a unique pattern for several chemical classes. A ranking of the compounds based on their inhibition of DNA synthesis was compared to a ranking obtained from the literature for whole-animal toxicity. With the exception of the polychlorinated biphenyls, the in vitro results correlated well with animal test data.

Quantitative predictivity of the transformation in vitro assay compared with the Ames test

For 59 chemical compounds, we have found homogeneous data on transformation in vitro, mutagenicity in the Ames test, and carcinogenicity. We have compared the potency in inducing transformation in vitro in hamster fibroblast cells with the carcinogenic potency and found a modest correlation coefficient between the two parameters (r = 0.37). For these same 59 compounds it was also possible to compare mutagenic potency in the Ames test with carcinogenic potency. The correlation level was very similar (r = 0.34). The predictivity of transformation in vitro increased significantly when only compounds for which some kind of dose-response relationship was available were utilized (r = 0.65). This result stresses the importance of the quantitative aspect of the response in predictivity studies. The present study is compared with previous studies on the quantitative predictivity of different short-term tests. Our work is not definitive, but gives an idea of the possible type of approach to the problem of comparing quantitative predictivities.

Quantitative correlation between carcinogenicity and sister chromatid exchange induction in vivo for a group of 11 N-nitroso derivatives

The quantitative correlation between induction of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in vivo and carcinogenic potency was examined for 11 nitroso derivatives and was compared with the correlation of alkaline DNA fragmentation in liver DNA in vivo and with the Ames test. The correlation between DNA adducts and SCEs was also evaluated. DNA damage was slightly more predictive and the Ames test less predictive than SCE evaluation. The predictivity of these tests for this class of compounds was compared with the predictivity shown for different classes of chemical compounds.

Carcinogen testing: current problems and new approaches

The classic procedures for testing potential carcinogens in animals have basically not changed in the past 50 years. Considerable knowledge of the mechanisms of carcinogenesis has accrued in the last 20 years, particularly concepts on the metabolic activation of chemicals to reactive electrophilic compounds that can interact with nucleophilic including DNA. These developments, in turn, have yielded a framework for integrating into carcinogen testing the determination of genetic effects of chemicals. A systematic decision point approach to carcinogen testing has been developed which entails a sequential decision-making process as specific tests are performed and evaluated prior to initiation of higher order, more complex tests. Compared to conventional bioassays in rodents, this approach provides knowledge based on mechanisms of carcinogenesis, yields a substantial amount of data at minimal cost, and forms a solid base for eventual heath risk assessment.

Inhibition of DNA synthesis in relation to enhanced survival of UV-damaged herpes virus in monkey cells treated by a variety of 2-nitronaphthofurans

Various 2-nitronaphthofuran derivatives (related to each other by simple structural modifications) were tested for 2 different effects in CV-1 monkey kidney cell cultures: the immediate inhibition of normal DNA synthesis and the capacity of pretreated cultures (40 h of contact) to support the replication of UV-damaged Herpes simplex virus (HSV). For all compounds tested, a fair correlation was found between their efficiencies to inhibit cellular DNA synthesis and to provoke an increase in UV-HSV production (virus reactivation). Virus reactivation was due to an increase in both the number of virus-producing cells and the amount of infectious particles produced per cell. The most efficient 2-nitronaphthofurans (particularly 2-nitro-7-methoxy-naphtho[2,1-b]furan-R 7000) were at least as potent as aflatoxin B1 in inducing virus reactivation.

DNA replication, repair, and repair tests

The rate of inhibition and recovery of DNA synthesis can be used in a rapid assay system to detect genotoxic potentials of chemicals. Also, the observation that an agent stimulates DNA repair in a test system indicates its ability to cause damage in DNA. Different experimental approaches to the study of repair synthesis are discussed.

Identifying environmental chemicals causing mutations and cancer

Damage to DNA appears to be the major cause of most cancer and genetic birth defects and may contribute to aging and heart disease as well. The agents that cause this damage must be identified. Many of these agents are natural chemicals present in the human diet as complex mixtures. The tens of thousands of man-made chemicals that have been introduced into the environment in the last few decades must also be tested for their ability to damage DNA. Existing animal tests and human epidemiology alone are inadequate for this task because of time, expense, and the difficulty of dealing with complex mixtures, Newly developed short-term tests, most of them assaying for mutagenicity, are discussed as key tools in identifying environmental mutagens and carcinogens.

Vitamin C is positive in the DNA synthesis inhibition and sister-chromatid exchange tests

Ascorbate caused a dose-dependent increase in sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and in human lymphocytes. Moreover, in the DNA synthesis inhibition test with HeLa cells, ascorbate gave results typical of DNA-damaging chemicals. Catalase reduced SCE induction by ascorbate, prevented its cytotoxicity in CHO cells, and prevented its effect on HeLa DNA synthesis. Ascorbate reduced induction of SCE in CHO cells by N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) by direct inactivation of MNNG.