Karyotypic evolution of human meningioma. Progression through malignancy

Histologic and Cytogenetic Patterns in Benign, Atypical, and Malignant Meningiomas

Atypical meningiomas comprise an intermediate category of meningeal neoplasmas with some microscopic features of aggressivity and a capacity for recurrence. We present a clin ical, morphologic, and cytogenetic study of 15 meningiomas. Morphologic and cytogenetic analysis suggested the existence of morphologically typical meningiomas with normal karyotype or monosomy 22 and morphologically atypical meningiomas, with increasing chromosomal abnormalities (complex karyotype) between these two types. Present results suggest the existence of a third type of morphologically typical meningioma that lacks a phenotypical aggressivity but has a complex karyotype. These genotypical characteristics may be related to the aggressivity of these neoplasms. Int J Surg Pathol 2(4):301-310, 1995

Malignant progression in meningioma: documentation of a series and analysis of cytogenetic findings

Object. The malignant progression of benign tumors is well documented in gliomas and other systemic lesions. It is also well known that some meningiomas become progressively aggressive despite their original benign status. The theory of clonal evolution is widely believed to explain malignant progression in meningioma; however, the data used to explain stepwise progression have typically been derived from the cytogenetic analysis of different types of tumors of different grades and in different patients. In this study, the authors examined the data obtained in a group of patients with meningiomas that showed clear histopathological progression toward a higher grade of malignancy and then analyzed the underlying cytogenetic findings.

Methods. Among 175 patients with recurrent meningiomas, 11 tumors showed a histopathological progression toward a higher grade that was associated with an aggressive clinical course. Six tumors progressed to malignancy and five to the atypical category over a period averaging 112 months. Tests for MIB-1 and p53 and cytogenetic studies with the fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) method were performed in successive specimens obtained in four patients.

The MIB-1 value increased in subsequent samples of tumors. Cytogenetic analysis with FISH showed deletions of 22, 1p, and 14q. In all but one case, these aberrations were also present in the previous specimen despite its lower hispathological grade.

Conclusions. The authors documented the progression of meningiomas from benign to a higher histological grade. These tumors were associated with a complex karyotype that was present ab initio in a histologically lower-grade tumor, contradicting the stepwise clonal evolution model. Although it was limited to the tested probes, the FISH method appears to be more accurate than the standard cytogenetic one in detecting these alterations. Tumors that present with complex genetic alterations, even those with a benign histological grade, are potentially aggressive and require closer follow up.

Histologically benign metastatic meningioma: morphological and cytogenetic study. Case report

The authors report on a 75-year-old man with histologically benign fibroblastic meningioma metastasizing to the lung, liver, spleen, and kidney. The original tumor exhibited a complex karyotype involving different structural and numerical anomalies associated with monosomy of chromosome 22. The implication of chromosome 1p36 was confirmed by fluorescence in situ hybridization in most interphase nuclei. Metastases occurred 4 months after incomplete resection with prior therapeutic embolization. The recurrent tumor in turn displayed anaplastic features and an increased Ki-67 labeling index. Genetic alterations in such morphologically benign meningiomas have been implicated in the malignant development and progression of these tumors.

Meningioma: Un modelo de evolución citogenética en la iniciación y progresión tumoral

Meningiomas are tumors of the central nervous system with a great morphological heterogeneity. They are generally benign, and have the capacity to progress to a higher histological grade (atypical and anaplastic), which is associated with an increase in biological aggressivity and/or capacity to recur. Citogenetically this evolution is characterized by total or partial monosomy 22 in the early phase, continued by numerical and structural changes during tumor progression. In this study, we present a review of 85 cases of meningiomas: 43 benign, 28 atypical and 14 anaplastic. We study the clinical and histopathological features, and their correlation with cytogenetie abnormalities present in these tumors. Numerical aberrations such as monosomy of chromosome 10, 14 and 18, and structural abnormalities such as deletions on 1p are directly associated with a higher agressivity of tumors. An association of aberatons on 1p and chromosome 14 are more commonly found in atypical and anaplastic meningiomas. These facts imply that the presence of complex karyotypes progressively increases from grade I to grade III meningiomas. Furthermore, these karyotypes are common in recurrent tumors.

Evaluation of relationship between chromosome 22 and p53 gene alterations and the subtype of meningiomas by the interphase-FISH technique

In this study, we investigated the relationship between genetic alterations such as chromosome 22 aneuploidy and p53 gene deletion, and the pathological types of meningioma of typical and aggressive forms. Thirty-four meningiomas (23 typical and 11 aggressive) were examined by application of fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with chromosome 22 specific alpha satellite probe and a combination of p53 locus specific and chromosome 17 centromere specific alpha satellite probes, to evaluate the chromosome 22 aneuploidy and gain or loss of p53 gene along with chromosome 17. The results showed that, although chromosome 22 aneuploidy was seen in 7 out of 23 typical (30.4%) and 4 out of 11 aggressive meningiomas (36.3%), no p53 deletion was detected in typical meningiomas, and p53 deletion was detected in 3 out of 11 aggressive meningiomas (1 atypical and 2 malignant), which had recurrence. There were no simultaneous occurrences of p53 gene deletions between typical and aggressive meningiomas. The present findings indicate that the loss of chromosome 22 may be involved with tumorogenesis of typical and aggressive meningiomas, while p53 gene deletions may be involved with malignant progression and recurrence in the aggressive meningiomas.

Translocation (1;19)(q21;q13.3) is a recurrent reciprocal translocation in meningioma

Benign meningiomas are characterized by a normal karyotype or loss of all or part of chromosome 22. Histologically higher grade tumors are typically characterized by a pattern of increasing chromosome loss and instability. This characteristic pattern of unbalanced chromosome aberrations is punctuated in the literature by several intriguing reports of a reciprocal t(1;19)(q21;q13.3) as the sole cytogenetic aberration. We report a third case showing the t(1;19)(q21;q13.3) with additional unstable secondary aberrations of a dic(18;22)(p11;p11) and telomeric fusions.

Analysis of p73 gene in meningiomas with deletion at 1p

The p73 gene has been mapped to 1p36.33, a chromosome region that is frequently deleted in a wide variety of neoplasms including meningiomas. The protein encoded by p73 shows structural and functional similarities to p53 and may thus represent a candidate tumor suppressor gene. To determine whether p73 is involved in the development of meningiomas, we examined 30 meningioma samples with proven 1p deletion for mutations of p73. Sequence analysis of the entire coding region of the p73 gene revealed previously reported polymorphisms in eight cases. A tumor-specific missense mutation as a result of an A-to-G transition with an Asn204Ser change was found in one meningioma that nevertheless retained the normal allele. These results suggest that if p73 plays a role in meningioma carcinogenesis, it must be in a manner different from the Knudson two-hit model.

Loss of 1p in recurrent meningiomas

Deletion of 1p is associated with histological progression to meningiomas. Detection of this alteration may be a predicting factor for recurrences in this tumor. We present 8 meningiomas from four patients: the original tumor and the first recurrence in one patient, and the first and second recurrences in the other three were studied. We compared results of monosomy 22 and deletion of chromosome 1p with cytogenetic methods and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis obtained from slides of direct preparations, of cultured cells and slides of touch preparations. The cytogenetic study showed normal chromosome 22 and deletion on 1p32 in both samples of one patient; only monosomy 22 in both recurrences in another patient, and normal karyotypes with different non-clonal anomalies in the other tumors. However, with FISH analysis, monosomy 22 in both recurrences of three patients was demonstrated, as well as the loss of 1p in all tumors. These results were more evident in the analysis of direct and touch preparations than in those of cultured cells.

High-resolution analysis of chromosome arm 1p alterations in meningioma

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for loci on chromosome arm 1p is a relatively common event in human meningioma, and this anomaly has been proposed to be associated with the development of grade II or grade III forms (atypical and anaplastic meningiomas). Nevertheless, the limited data available do not allow the establishment of the frequency and the extent of the affected 1p regions. To determine the status of chromosome 1p in meningiomas, we have performed a comprehensive analysis of LOH on 1p in 100 meningiomas using a high density of 1p-marker loci. Allelic loss was found in 35% of tumors, most corresponding to nontypical meningiomas that also displayed losses for loci on chromosome 22. Although some tumors displayed complex rearrangements leading to distinct 1p deletions, the patterns of loss indicated two main target regions: 1p36 and 1p34-p32, which represent the most frequently involved regions, whereas 1p22 and 1p21.1-1p13 regions appeared deleted in some tumors. These results suggest that there may be several putative tumor suppressor genes on 1p, the inactivation of which may be important in the pathogenesis of meningiomas, as well as in other tumor types.

A case of papillary meningioma with a t(1;4)(q44;q21)

We report the results of cytogenetic analyses of three cases of meningiomas. The first case, a papillary meningioma, showed only one cytogenetic abnormality, 46,XX,t(1;4)(q44;q21). In contrast, the other two benign fibroblastic meningiomas showed loss of chromosome 22. Loss and/or rearrangement of chromosomes other than chromosome 22 appears to be associated with a more aggressive clinical course. It is suggested that a sole cytogenetic abnormality with a normal chromosome 22 indicates an atypical nature of meningioma.

Histopathological and cytogenetic findings in benign, atypical and anaplastic human meningiomas: a study of 60 tumors

Meningiomas may display benign (Grade I), atypical (Grade II) and anaplastic (Grade III) histopathological findings. The cytogenetic studies strongly suggest that secondary changes (moreover loss of chromosome 22) appear to be associated with more atypical features and with greater clinical aggressivity. We studied 60 tumors from 52 patients. Histopathological features such as nuclear pleomorphism, nucleolar prominence, mitosis, necrosis, cellular density, PCNA labeling index, and karyotype have been evaluated. Nuclear pleomorphism and nucleolar prominence showed a progressive increase in Grades I-III. Multifocal micronecrosis was considered a criterion of malignancy. A significant correlation was observed between PCNA-LI, mitotic index and grades. Complex karyotypes increased progressively: benign (34% of cases), atypical (45% of cases) and anaplastic (70% of cases). The most common numerical alterations were losses of chromosomes 10, 14, 18 and 22. The chromosomes most often involved in structural anomalies were: 1, 4, 7, 14 and 22. Telomeric associations was present in four cases and double minutes in two cases. Prognostic criteria for these tumors have been analyzed on the basis of these data.

NF2 gene mutations and allelic status of 1p, 14q and 22q in sporadic meningiomas

Formation of meningiomas and their progression to malignancy may be a multi-step process, implying accumulation of genetic mutations at specific loci. To determine the relationship between early NF2 gene inactivation and the molecular mechanisms that may contribute to meningioma tumor progression, we have performed deletion mapping analysis at chromosomes 1, 14 and 22 in a series of 81 sporadic meningiomas (54 grade I (typical), 25 grade II (atypical) and two grade III (anaplastic)), which were also studied for NF2 gene mutations. Single-strand conformational polymorphism analysis was used to identify 11 mutations in five of the eight exons of the NF2 gene studied. All 11 tumors displayed loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for chromosome 22 markers; this anomaly was also detected in 33 additional tumors. Twenty-nine and 23 cases were characterized by LOH at 1p and 14q, respectively, mostly corresponding to aggressive tumors that also generally displayed LOH 22. All three alterations were detected in association in seven grade II and two grade III meningiomas, corroborating the hypothesis that the formation of aggressive meningiomas follows a multi-step tumor progression model.

Pathological analyses of early recurrence and malignant transformation in meningiomas

We investigated factors of the early recurrence and malignant transformation of histologically benign meningiomas using immunohistochemistry for MIB-1 positive indices (PI) and p53 protein expression, a flow cytometric DNA analysis, and the examination of numerical chromosomal aberrations detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization using an alpha-satellite DNA probe and a bcr gene locus-specific probe. Twenty-six meningiomas of 23 patients were classified into two groups: the 3 patients in whom a recurrence was defined within two years after initial surgery and who showed histologically malignant features were classified as the early recurrent group, and the other 20 patients in whom recurrence did not develop during the same period were classified as the nonrecurrent group. DNA aneuploidy was observed in 40% of the nonrecurrent patients and in 67% of the early recurrent patients. Loss of chromosome 22 was the most common numerical aberration, but the aberrations characteristic of early recurrent meningiomas were not detected. The MIB-1 PI values of the early recurrent meningiomas were higher than those of nonrecurrent meningiomas, suggesting that MIB-1 PI is very important for biological and histopathological analyses and prediction of the future recurrence of meningiomas.

Dosimetric and cytogenetic studies of multiple radiation-induced meningiomas for a single patient

No criteria are currently available to determine the spontaneous or radiation-induced origin of a malignant tumor occurring in a previously irradiated area. This study presents the dosimetric and cytogenetic analysis of meningiomas diagnosed in irradiated brain areas from a single patient and a discussion of the karyotypes of spontaneous meningiomas and radiation-induced tumors published in the literature.

Cytogenetical findings of recurrent meningiomas. A study of 10 tumors

Cytogenetic analyses of 10 cases of recurrent meningiomas growing in culture between 1-10 days are reported, of which seven showed benign morphology, one atypical, and two, malignant features. Normal karyotypes with nonclonal alterations were found in three cases, one case with only monosomy 22, and complex karyotypes in the remaining six. Four cases were hypodiploid, one pseudodiploid, and one hyperdiploid. The chromosomes most often involved in structural rearrangements were 1, 7, and 14 and the losses were chromosomes 7, 10, 14, 15, 18, and 22. Ring chromosome, dicentrics, double minutes, and association between satellites were found in one case. These complex karyotypes with hypodiploidy, structural rearrangements, and other markers in recurrent meningiomas may indicate aggressive tumor characteristics.

Monosomy 1p is correlated with enhanced in vivo glucose metabolism in meningiomas

The 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) uptake of 25 human meningiomas was preoperatively evaluated in vivo by positron-emission tomography (PET). After surgery, meningioma biopsies were analyzed cytogenetically. Five meningiomas showed partial monosomy for chromosome 1p additional to other typical chromosome aberrations. This aberrant karyotype was correlated with increased FDG uptake. Three of five meningiomas with monosomy 1p were classified as grade II according to WHO, while only one of 20 tumors without monosomy 1p was classified as grade II. Thus, monosomy 1p and elevated FDG uptake in PET are to be regarded as cytogenetic and metabolic parameters for the aggressiveness of meningiomas.

In vitro karyotype evolution and cytogenetic instability in the non-tumorigenic human breast epithelial cell line HMT-3522

The "spontaneously" immortalized cell line HMT-3522, derived from a fibrocystic breast lesion, is used as a model for premalignant breast epithelium. During 205 passages the cytogenetic evolution was followed. The results were compared with our earlier results on oncogene expression and growth factor requirements. During in vitro growth, gain and loss of markers, loss of normal chromosomes, and duplication of the chromosome complement could be demonstrated. The variability increased during in vitro growth. This variability, probably created randomly, leads to cells with different growth capacities, from which sidelines may be selected and become stemlines. The karyotypic evolution (including polyploidization) demonstrated here may be a result of genetic instability and heterogeneity. Although tumorigenicity was not achieved, either due to lack of cancer-specific gene alterations or to lack of proper selection pressure, the results suggest an ongoing process towards malignancy.

Chromosome abnormalities in meningeal neoplasms: do they correlate with histology?

Thirty-three meningeal neoplasms were karyotyped, and the results were compared with histologic features. Thirteen neoplasms had no discernible abnormality or sex chromosome loss only; nine had monosomy or structural abnormality involving only chromosome 22; and 11 had other chromosome abnormalities with or without chromosome 22 involvement. Histologic evidence of invasion was not associated with an abnormal karyotype in the three angioblastic tumors examined. All seven fibroblastic meningiomas had abnormal karyotypes, with monosomy 22 the most common change. Abnormal karyotypes were detected in 76% of syncytial and 55% of transitional meningiomas. When these results were combined with those from 259 meningeal tumors reported since 1987, abnormal karyotypes were detected in at least half of all histologic types. Chromosome changes secondary to those involving chromosome 22 may indicate additional areas of the genome that play a role in tumor progression. In the combined series, chromosome losses were most frequently observed in meningiomatous and transitional histologies; chromosomes 1, 6, 14, 18, and Y each were lost in 10 or more meningiomas, whereas only chromosome 20 was gained at the same frequency. Structural abnormalities most frequently involved chromosome 1. These changes are distinctly different from those observed in other common intracranial neoplasms, specifically astrocytic neoplasms.

Abnormalities of chromosome 22 in pediatric meningiomas

Cytogenetic studies of eight meningiomas in young children or adolescents were performed. Two tumors exhibited normal karyotypes. Two tumors from patients with bilateral acoustic neurofibromatosis demonstrated monosomy 22 as the only abnormality. Four patients had more complicated karyotypes in which one or both of the chromosomes 22 were missing or structurally altered. The most common secondary changes in these four tumors involved monosomy or structural abnormalities of chromosome 6. These findings confirm that the primary cytogenetic changes in meningioma are similar in children and adults. Molecular analyses of pediatric meningiomas with deletions or translocations of chromosome 22 will be useful for identifying the role of chromosome 22 tumor suppressor genes in this disease.

Case of meningioma with del(1)(p32) as sole anomaly

We studied a case of typical syncytial meningioma. Cytogenetic analysis of the tumor cells showed a karyotype with normal chromosomes 22 and only one anomaly, del(1)(p32). Cases of meningiomas with normal chromosomes 22 and other anomalies are rare, and it is difficult to correlate their histologic characteristics and biologic behavior.

Correlation between cytogenetic and histopathological findings in 75 human meningiomas

The correlations between cytogenetic and histopathological findings were analyzed in 75 human meningiomas. The tumors were classified according to increasing degrees of anaplasia into three grades: Grade I, benign; Grade II, atypical; Grade III, anaplastic. In 45 tumors of Grade I (benign), we more often observed a normal karyotype or monosomy 22. In 23 tumors of Grade II (atypical), we observed karyotypes with structural and/or numerical abnormalities with the presence of telomeric associations in 8 of them. These last tumors were fibroblastic. In seven Grade III tumors (anaplastic), we also observed complex abnormalities, and in one case, we observed telomeric associations. Our observations show that complex chromosome abnormalities and telomeric associations are observed in tumors that histologically display a certain degree of anaplasia. It is possible that the result of histopathological and cytogenetic correlations might represent a prognostic factor in meningiomas.

Meningiomas

This article reviews the recent literature on the pathogenesis and pathology of meningiomas, contemporary techniques of surgical resection, and new nonsurgical treatments, including radiation and hormone therapy. Factors predisposing to meningioma formation include female sex, previous ionizing radiation, and Type 2 neurofibromatosis. The first factor may act through the expression of sex hormone receptors, especially the progesterone receptor, in these tumors; the other two probably act by causing a deletion on Chromosome 22. The pathological classifications of meningiomas include the traditional division into histological subtypes and the World Health Organization classification that selects characteristics that may lead to recurrence. There is an increasing emphasis on proliferative indices and other characteristics that may predict aggressive behavior in these tumors. On computed tomography, meningiomas are enhancing, well-marginated, dural-based lesions that may have considerable surrounding edema; the cause of the edema is uncertain but may result from secretory products of the tumor. Magnetic resonance imaging with enhancement will demonstrate these lesions accurately and can be used for three-dimensional reconstruction as well. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging have largely replaced angiography in the preoperative diagnosis of meningiomas, but angiographic embolization may be a useful operative adjunct. Although meningioma surgery is sometimes thought of as benign and curative, the reported surgical mortality rate is as high as 14.3% and the reported 10-year survival rate after surgery varies from 43 to 77%. Surgery has advanced most in the management of suprasellar, cavernous sinus, clivus, tentorial, and posterior fossa meningiomas, because new approaches and a better understanding of anatomy have allowed more radical resection. There is still substantial morbidity associated with surgery in these regions, however, and the long-term recurrence rates are still unknown for these new radical techniques. For convexity, parasagittal, lateral sphenoid wing, and olfactory groove meningiomas, complete resection should be the goal and operative morbidity appears to be low. There is a high recurrence rate after surgery. With apparent total removal, the recurrence rate varies from 9 to 20% at 10 years, with subtotal resection varying from 18.4 to 50%. The degree of resection appears to be most important in recurrence, but histopathological features are also important. Recently, radiation therapy has been recognized as a useful adjunct to surgery, and with radiosurgical techniques may become more important in the future. Antiprogesterone therapy appears to have had some success as well, and it or other hormonal therapy may be another future option for residual or recurrent meningiomas.

1;19 translocation in human meningioma

BACKGROUND

Loss of chromosome 22 represents the most common chromosome abnormality (70%) in meningiomas. The remainder (30%) have a normal karyotype. Not only are the structural changes rare, they also occur simultaneously with various chromosome losses.

METHODS

The authors identified and studied the meningiomas of two patients with standard tumor cell culture technique and chromosome preparation.

RESULTS

Twenty karyotypes from each meningioma had a 46 modal chromosome number with t(1;19) (q21;p13) in all cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The sole change of the (1;19) translocation in meningioma, without any other changes such as chromosome loss, as shown in this study, is unique and has never been reported before in the literature, to the knowledge of the authors. Additional study is needed to learn more about the rate of occurrence and the significant impact on meningeal tumor genesis.

Abnormalities of chromosome 22 in human brain tumors determined by combined cytogenetic and molecular genetic approaches

Southern blot hybridization studies were performed on a panel of 130 blood/tumor samples from brain neoplasms including all major histologic subtypes: 50 meningiomas, 18 neurinomas, 56 gliomas, and six others. To detect abnormalities involving chromosome 22, polymorphic probes were used to analyze eight loci located in this chromosome: D22S9, IGLV, D22S20, D22S32, MB, PDGF-B, D22S80, and D22S171. Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) was observed in 40 cases including monosomy, terminal, and interstitial deletions, which suggest the location of recessive tumor genes in certain chromosome 22 subregions (22q11.3-q12 in neurinomas and meningiomas, and 22q13 in malignant gliomas). Cytogenetic studies were performed in parallel on the same tumors, in most instances corroborating the presence of abnormalities for chromosome 22. Nevertheless, discrepancies between the cytogenetic and molecular findings were observed in several cases, suggesting that the use of both methodologies in combination might provide key information on the incidence and extent of the abnormalities involving chromosome 22 in human brain tumors.

Cytogenetic study of a pineocytoma

The cytogenetic findings based on G-banding in a pineocytoma detected in a 29-year-old woman are reported. The chromosomal study showed numerical alterations involving chromosomes X, 5, 8, 11, 14, and 22, structural alterations of chromosomes 1, 3, 12, and 22, as well as various markers. Tumors of the pineal region are infrequent, and this is the first report of a pineocytoma studied cytogenetically.

Abnormalities of chromosome 22 in meningiomas and confirmation of the origin of a dicentric 22 by in situ hybridization

We report three cases of meningioma. Case 1 had a dicentric chromosome number 22 resulting in partial monosomy for a portion of the q-arm, i.e., 46,XX,idic(22)(pter-->q11.2::q11.2-->pter) and 46,XX,psu dic(22)(pter-->q11.2::q11.2-->pter), which was the sole clonal abnormality. The origin of the dicentric chromosome from 22 was confirmed by in situ hybridization studies, using biotin-labeled alpha centromeric DNA probes for the acrocentric chromosomes. Case 2 had two distinct clonal abnormalities: deletion of 22q and monosomy of 22. Case 3 also had a deleted 22q.

Cytogenetic findings in typical and atypical meningioma

Comparative pathological and karyotypic findings of a typical and an atypical meningioma in two different patients are presented. The chromosomal abnormalities observed appeared unique for the histopathological subtype of the tumor. Cytogenetic analysis of atypical meningioma has not previously been reported.