Effects of Caramel Colour III on the number of blood lymphocytes: a human study on Caramel Colour III immunotoxicity and a comparison of the results with data from rat studies

Caramel colors in terms of scientific research, with particular consideration of their toxicity

Caramel colors, the most common food additives in the world, are divided into four classes (IIV), marked with the symbols E150 a-d, respectively. Individual classes of caramel colors differ from each other in physico-chemical properties and the method of preparation, which affects the formation of various compounds that are important for the assessment of food safety A number of studies on all caramel classes of have been performed, including toxicokinetic, genotoxic, carcinogenic and reproductive and developmental toxicity studies, which have not shown harmful effects of these additives at doses not exceeding ADI. However, there is an increasing number of scientific reports of the possible toxic effects present in caramels of low-molecular compounds. Currently, three compounds are considered to be toxicologically important and resulting from the possible concentration in the final product: 5-HMF (present in all classes), 4(5)-MeI (present in caramel classes III and IV) or THI (present in caramel class III). 4(5)-MeI has a neurotoxic effect and was considered in 2011 as a possible human carcinogen (class 2B, according to IARC). In the case of THI, studies have confirmed its lymphopenic activity, probably secondary to its immunosuppressive effect. Consequently, in the 1980s, JECFA set acceptable levels 4(5)-MeI and THI, for the caramel classes in which these compounds may be present. The toxicity of 5-HMF has not been confirmed unequivocally, but studies have shown that this compound is not neutral to living organisms. Currently, most international organizations and scientific institutes recognize these additives as safe for consumers, but at the same time scientists emphasize the need for further research.

Sous-Vide Nonenzymatic Browning of Glucosamine at Different Temperatures

Sous-vide is an increasingly popular method of cooking under controlled conditions of temperature and time inside vacuumed pouches to preserve the nutritional and sensory qualities of food. Sous-vide nonenzymatic browning of glucosamine (GlcN) was investigated at 50, 60, and 70 °C for 12 h. Changes investigated were pH, color, level of browning, and the concentrations of the key Maillard and caramelization reaction products, including α-dicarbonyls and pyrazines. The concentrations of undesired 4-methylimidazole (4-MEI), 2-acetyl-4(5)-tetrahydroxybutyl imidazole (THI), and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (5-HMF) were also determined. Six types of caramels were produced of unique composition with no detectable levels of 4-MEI. GlcN caramels produced under vacuum were more acidic and lighter in color, containing significantly less flavorful diacetyl, but more fructosazine (FR) as compared to nonvacuum caramels. THI concentration was well below the toxicity levels for all studied caramels. Principal component analyses showed that the incubation temperature played a key role in determining the composition of caramels.

Determination of 2-Methylimidazole, 4-Methylimidazole, and 2-Acetyl-4-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxybutyl)imidazole in Licorice Using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry Stable-Isotope Dilution Analysis

A quick and selective analytical method was developed for the simultaneous quantitation of 2-methylimidazole, 4-methylimidazole, and 2-acetyl-4-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxybutyl)imidazole, which are known to be formed by Maillard reactions. The methodology reported here employs stable-isotope dilution analysis (SIDA) using 4-methylimidazole-d6 and [(13)C6]-2-acetyl-4-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxybutyl)imidazole as internal standards. It was successfully applied in a model assay to show that the addition of ammonium chloride during the manufacture of licorice promotes imidazole formation depending on the added amount of ammonium chloride without the well-known impact of present caramel food colorings. Furthermore, a monitoring assay of 29 caramel coloring-free licorice products showed that both 4-methylimidazole and 2-acetyl-4-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxybutyl)imidazole are endogenously generated in detectable quantities. None of the samples showed 2-methylimidazole levels above the limit of detection, 50 μg/kg.

Carcinogenic 4(5)-methylimidazole found in beverages, sauces, and caramel colors: chemical properties, analysis, and biological activities

Since the National Toxicology Program (NTP) identified 4(5)-methylimidazole [4(5)-MI] as a cancer causing chemical in 2007 and the State of California added it to the Proposition 65 list of compounds as a carcinogen on January 7, 2011, many researchers and regulatory agencies have become focused on the presence of 4(5)-MI in foods and beverages. 4(5)-MI has been known to form in the Maillard reaction system consisting of a sugar and ammonia-a typical caramel-color preparation method for beverages. 4(5)-MI is identified in various beverages and sauces, which are colored with caramel, as well as in caramel color itself. Analysis of 4(5)-MI is extremely difficult due to its high water solubility, but the analytical method for 4(5)-MI has progressed from conventional paper chromatography, gas chromatography, and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry to the most advanced high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Various studies indicate that caramel colors and carbonated beverages contain 4(5)-MI in levels ranging from 0 to around 1000 ppm and from 0 to about 500 ppm, respectively. Reports of the toxicity of 4(5)-MI at relatively high levels suggest that it may cause some adverse effects on human consumers.

Food caramels: a review

Caramel, defined as coloring agent and as an antioxidant, is being used in several kinds of food products. It has been classified into 4 classes to satisfy the requirement of several food and beverage systems. The variation in its consistency owing to its basic content of milk solids, sugars, and fat has been studied. Several methods have been found to estimate the amount of color provided by caramel in food products. Various formulations have been cited for the production of caramel by eradicating the frequent areas of problems during its processing. Caramel has been used as a synthetic colorant replacer in the baking and beverage industries. Researchers have aimed to ascertain the contribution to the antioxidant activity of some caramel-containing soft drinks. The Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) has established an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of Class I caramel color as "not specified"; that of Class II as 0-160 mg/kg body weight; that of Class III as 0-200 mg/kg body weight; and that of Class IV as 0-200 mg/kg body weight. This paper is an overview of the classification, physicochemical nature, formulations, coloring properties, antioxidant properties, and toxicity of caramel in different food systems.

The application of in vitro data in the derivation of the acceptable daily intake of food additives

The acceptable daily intake (ADI) for food additives is commonly derived from the NOAEL (no-observed-adverse-effect level) in long-term animal in vivo studies. To derive an ADI a safety or uncertainty factor (commonly 100) is applied to the NOAEL in the most sensitive test species. The 100-fold safety factor is considered to be the product of both species and inter-individual differences in toxicokinetics and toxicodynamics. Although in vitro data have previously been considered during the risk assessment of food additives, they have generally had no direct influence on the calculation of ADI values. In this review 18 food additives are evaluated for the availability of in vitro toxicity data which might be used for the derivation of a specific data-derived uncertainty factor. For the majority of the food additives reviewed, additional in vitro tests have been conducted which supplement and support the short- and long-term in vivo toxicity studies. However, it was recognized that these in vitro studies could not be used in isolation to derive an ADI; only when sufficient in vivo mechanistic data are available can such information be used in a regulatory context. Additional short-term studies are proposed for the food additives which, if conducted, would provide data that could then be used for the calculation of data-derived uncertainty factors.

The immunomodulatory compound 2-acetyl-4-tetrahydroxybutyl imidazole causes sequestration of lymphocytes in non-lymphoid tissues

2-Acetyl-4(5)-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxybutyl) imidazole (THI) is an immunomodulatory compound which causes a reversible lymphopenia in mice by an unknown mechanism. In this study, we investigated the whereabouts of cells lost from the blood and the spleen during THI treatment Homing studies following is injection of fluorescently labelled splenocytes into THI-pretreated recipients showed that THI increased labelled cells in the liver, lungs and kidneys of THI-treated mice. Furthermore, the sequestration in the liver occurred just 1.5 h after injection of labelled cells with the increase still being present at 24 h after injection. Microscopic examination of liver sections indicated that fluorescent lymphocytes were clustered within the liver sinusoids in THI-treated mice, possibly associated with endothelial cells. The liver retention of lymphocytes was confirmed by immunohistochemical studies which showed a significant increase of T cells in the liver of THI-treated mice. To determine the subset of lymphocytes which are lost from the spleen and sequestered in non-lymphoid organs, lymphocytes remaining in the spleen after THI treatment were characterized. Our results confirmed that THI reduced B cells, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells and cells expressing CD62L, CD44 and IL-2R in the spleen.

Immunotoxicity of the colour additive caramel colour III; a review on complicated issues in the safety evaluation of a food additive

Food additives can be regarded as the safest constituents of our daily food. Nevertheless, complicated issues with respect to their safety evaluation do also occur. In this review paper, some of these issues are illustrated by the description and evaluation of the research on the immunotoxicity of the food additive Caramel Colour III. Caramel Colour III is commonly used as a color additive in many products for human consumption. Toxicity studies conducted in the seventies demonstrated that administration of Caramel Colour III can cause a reduction in total white blood cell counts in rats, due to reduced lymphocyte counts. Studies reviewed in this paper demonstrated several other effects of Caramel Colour III on the immune system of rodents, including disturbed immune functions and changed resistance in infection models. In addition, studies in rats demonstrated that most of the effects occur only when the animals are fed a diet low in vitamin B6. The imidazole derivative 2-acetyl-4(5)-(1,2,3,4-tetrahydroxy-butyl)-imidazole (THI) was found to be responsible for the immunotoxicity. Issues such as the mechanism of action of THI and the role of vitamin B6 are discussed. Finally, the results of a human intervention study and the observed effect levels of THI in rats are discussed in terms of safety of the use of Caramel Colour III in our daily food supply.

Effects of subchronic exposure to Caramel Colour III on the immune system in mice

Administration of Caramel Colour III is associated with lymphopenia in laboratory animals, especially if the animals are fed a vitamin B6-deficient diet. Recently, functional immunological alterations in rats exposed to Caramel Colour III have been reported. The component of Caramel Colour III that is responsible for the immunological effects has been shown to be 2-acetyl-4-tetrahydroxybutyl imidazole (THI). In the present study, female Balb/c mice fed a diet with a relatively high vitamin B6 content were exposed to 2 or 10% of a commercial Caramel Colour III preparation with a low THI content (less than 25 ppm) in the drinking water for 9 wk. Although this treatment did not induce a lymphopenia in the exposed mice, flow cytometric analysis of lymphocyte subpopulations demonstrated reductions in the CD4+ and CD8+ cell populations. In addition, the proliferative response of spleen cells to B and T cell mitogens was significantly reduced in the mice exposed to 2% Caramel Colour III. No changes were observed in natural killer cell activity or in the humoral antibody response to a viral antigen. The results indicate that Caramel Colour III that meets the specified limit of less than 25 mg THI/kg may, nevertheless, interfere with the lymphoid system in mice with an adequate vitamin B6 status.

Toxicity studies of Caramel Colour III and 2-acetyl-4(5)-tetrahydroxybutylimidazole in F344 rats

Caramel Colour III is used as a colour additive in beers and a variety of foods. Beer is the most important single source of Caramel Colour III in the diet although consumption of dark beers has been decreasing in recent years. The Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) has established an acceptable daily intake of 200 mg/kg/day for Caramel Colour III. The safety of Caramel Colour III has been questioned during recent years following feeding studies in the rat that were associated with reduced white cell and lymphocyte counts. These effects have been attributed to the presence of 2-acetyl-4(5)-tetrahydroxybutylimidazole (THI) in this class of caramel colour. Short-term oral toxicity studies were conducted on low-THI and high-THI samples of Caramel Colour III (13 wk) and on a sample of THI (28 days). In both studies, the test materials were mixed with demineralized water and the solutions were given to the animals ad lib. in the drinking fluid. In the 13-wk subchronic toxicity study of Caramel Colour III, groups of 20 rats/sex were given concentrations of caramel colour equivalent to intakes of 0, 10, 15 or 20 g low-THI caramel colour/kg body weight/day or 20 g/kg of a high-THI caramel colour. In the 4-wk toxicity study with THI, groups of 20 rats/sex were given 0, 8 or 64 ppm THI (equivalent to approx. 0, 0.9 or 7.2 mg/kg/day) and 10 rats/sex were given 1, 2, 4, 16 or 32 ppm THI (equivalent to approx. 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 1.9 or 3.7 mg/kg/day) for 4 wk followed by a 2-wk recovery phase for 10 rats/sex in the 0, 8 and 64 ppm groups. Rats given Caramel Colour III had soft faeces; there were no other treatment-related clinical observations and no treatment-related deaths occurred. All treated groups given Caramel Colour III had lower food and fluid consumption than controls. Males given 15 or 20 g low-THI caramel colour/kg or 20 g high-THI caramel colour/kg and females given 20 g/kg of either type had lower body weights than controls. In the 4-wk toxicity study with THI, there were no treatment-related ante-mortem observations, and no effects on body weights or food consumption. Fluid consumption by males and females treated with 64 ppm THI was lower than that of controls.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)