Focal irradiation of the brain: an alternative to temporal lobe resection in intractable focal epilepsy?

Surgical strategies for pediatric epilepsy

Pediatric epilepsy is a debilitating condition that impacts millions of patients throughout the world. Approximately 20-30% of children with recurrent seizures have drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE). For these patients, surgery offers the possibility of not just seizure freedom but significantly improved neurocognitive and behavioral outcomes. The spectrum of surgical options is vast, ranging from outpatient procedures such as vagus nerve stimulation to radical interventions including hemispherectomy. The thread connecting all of these interventions is a common goal-seizure freedom, an outcome that can be achieved safely and durably in a large proportion of patients. In this review, we discuss many of the most commonly performed surgical interventions and describe the indications, complications, and outcomes specific to each.

[Radiosurgery for drug-resistant epilepsies: state of the art, results and perspectives]

BACKGROUND

There is growing interest in the use of radiosurgery in epilepsy. We analyzed our experience in this field in an attempt to define the potential of radiosurgery in epileptology.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

[corrected] Our local clinical experience (134 patients), accumulated over the last 15 years, mainly includes treatment of temporal lobe epilepsy without space-occupying lesions (59 patients), including 53 with pure MTLE, 61 cases of hypothalamic hamartoma, two cases of callosotomy, and 12 other types of epilepsy.

RESULTS

The analysis of our material, as well as other clinical and experimental data, suggest that the use of radiosurgery is beneficial only to patients in whom a strict preoperative definition of the extent of the epileptogenic zone (or network) has been achieved and strict rules of dose planning have been applied. As soon as these principles are not observed, the risk of treatment failure and/or side effects increases dramatically. Long-term outcome data are now available and published for MTLE but not yet for other types of epilepsy. Long-term safety and efficacy in MTLE are comparable to surgical resection but radiosurgery has the advantage of sparing verbal memory in patients operated by Gamma Knife (GK) on the dominant side. In small hamartomas, the efficacy is comparable to microsurgery but with a dramatic reduction in risk.

CONCLUSION

The vast amount of clinical materiel and long-term evaluation now support the use of GK surgery in small hypothalamic hamartomas and MTLE when the patient is at risk of verbal memory loss.

Anticonvulsant effects of gamma surgery in a model of chronic spontaneous limbic epilepsy in rats

OBJECT

The management of intractable epilepsy remains a challenge, despite advances in its surgical and nonsurgical treatment. The identification of low-risk, low-cost therapeutic strategies that lead to improved outcome is therefore an important ongoing goal of basic and clinical research. Single-dose focal ionizing beam radiation delivered at necrosis-inducing and subnecrotic levels was investigated for its effects on seizure activity by using an established model of chronic recurrent spontaneous limbic seizures in rats.

METHODS

A single 90-minute period of repetitive electrical stimulation (inducing stimulus) of the hippocampus in rats elicited a single episode of status epilepticus, followed by a 2- to 4-week seizure-free period. Spontaneous recurrent seizures developed subsequently and persisted for the duration of monitoring (2-10 months). Simultaneous computerized electroencephalography and video recording were used to monitor the animals. After the establishment of spontaneous recurrent seizures, bilateral radiation centered in the ventral hippocampal formation was administered with the Leksell gamma knife, aided by a stereotactic device custom made for small animals. A center dose of 10, 20, or 40 Gy was administered using a 4-mm collimator. Control animals were subjected to the same seizure-inducing stimulus but underwent a sham treatment instead of gamma irradiation. In a second experiment, the authors examined the effects of gamma irradiation on the proclivity of hippocampal neurons to display epileptiform discharges. Naive animals were irradiated with a single 40-Gy dose, as already described. Slices of the hippocampus were prepared from animals killed between 1 and 178 days postirradiation. Sensitivity to penicillin-induced epileptiform spiking was examined in vitro in slices prepared from control and irradiated rat brains.

CONCLUSIONS

In the first experiment, single doses of 20 or 40 Gy (but not 10 Gy) reduced substantially, and in some cases eliminated, behaviorally and electrographically recognized seizures. Significant reductions in both the frequency and duration of spontaneous seizures were observed during a follow-up period of up to 10 months postradiation. Histological examination of the targeted region did not reveal signs of necrosis. These findings indicate that single-dose focal ionizing beam irradiation at subnecrotic dosages reduces or eliminates repetitive spontaneous seizures in a rat model of temporal lobe epilepsy. In the second experiment, synaptically driven neuronal firing was shown to be intact in hippocampal neurons subjected to 40-Gy doses. However, the susceptibility to penicillin-induced epileptiform activity was reduced in the brain slices of animals receiving 40-Gy doses, compared with those from control rats that were not irradiated. The results provide rational support for the utility of subnecrotic gamma irradiation as a therapeutic strategy for treating epilepsy. These findings also provide evidence that a functional increase in the seizure threshold of hippocampal neurons contributes to the anticonvulsant influence of subnecrotic gamma irradiation.

Reduction of hippocampal-kindled seizure activity in rats by stereotactic radiosurgery

Radiosurgery may provide an alternative therapy for intractable epilepsy by eliminating or modifying abnormally active pacemaker neurons in epileptic foci. In the present study, the effect of radiosurgery on rat hippocampal kindling was examined. Rats received daily hippocampal stimulus trains until they were fully kindled. They then underwent radiosurgery of the kindled focus, receiving a single-dose of 0-, 10-, or 40-Gy. The 40-Gy group demonstrated an acute decrease in seizure threshold (3-5 days). Three months after radiosurgery, the threshold for seizures increased and the duration of afterdischarges decreased in the 40-Gy radiosurgery group compared to controls. The changes to both seizure threshold and afterdischarge duration were not significant in the 10-Gy group. These data suggest that radiosurgery is an effective means of reducing the epileptogenic activity of seizure foci.

Experimental and clinical studies on the putative therapeutic efficacy of cerebral irradiation (radiotherapy) in epilepsy

1. The majority of the published literature on the radiotherapeutic treatment of epilepsy suffers because it has involved neither radiotherapists nor epileptologists. 2. Papers have either been written describing an incidental beneficial effect (these suffer from being retrospective analyses) or by enthusiasts (where one must question patient selection). In addition there are a small number of very detailed and useful individual case reports. 3. Despite the reservations it would appear that radiation can have beneficial effects on seizures, and this effect has been described for a wide variety of conditions using a wide variety of treatment modalities. 4. There are grounds for prospective clinical trials to test the putative therapeutic efficacy of cerebral irradiation. However, it is essential that these are carried out by a group involving an established epilepsy surgery programme and a radiotherapy department conversant with the complex issues involved in focussed radiation treatment.

MEG localization of interictal epileptic focal activity and concomitant stereotactic radiosurgery. A non-invasive approach for patients with focal epilepsy

Two patients with complex partial epilepsy and tumour of the temporal lobe scheduled for gamma knife radiosurgery were evaluated pre- and postoperatively by multichannel magnetoencephalography (MEG). Centers of epileptic dipole activity found preoperatively disappeared after the focal irradiation as did the epileptic seizures. Thus, to combine stereotactic MEG and gamma knife radiosurgery seems to be a non-invasive alternative to the conventional neurosurgery in focal epilepsy.

Radiosurgery of epilepsy

Since 1982 a series of 11 epileptic patients have been treated with stereotactic radiosurgery. Patients were intracranially recorded with cortical and deep electrodes until the location of the epileptogenic focus was determined. A deep electrode was stereotactically placed at this point to confirm the accuracy of the location. All patients received radiosurgery with a gamma source and a dose of 10 to 20 Gy, except two of them in which a betatron was used. The results were: Total disappearance of the crises and withdrawal of medication: 4 cases (36%). More than 80% reduction of crises: 3 cases (27%). More than 50% reduction of crises: 2 cases (18%). Less than 50% reduction of crises: 2 cases (18%). No complications were observed, even in those cases in which the focus was located near critical areas of the brain. The efficacy of the low doses used accounts for non-destructive mechanisms, probably mediated by a neuronal plasticity phenomenon, as experimental studies suggest. The lack of complications can make this therapeutic approach an alternative to be considered when critical areas are involved.

Clinical outcome of radiosurgery for cerebral arteriovenous malformations

The clinical outcomes are described for 247 consecutive cases of arteriovenous malformation (AVM) treated with the gamma knife between April, 1970, and December 31, 1983. Headache resolved in 65 (66.3%) of the 98 patients presenting with this symptom and improved in an additional nine (9.2%). Of 59 patients admitted with seizures, 11 (18.6%) became seizure-free without anticonvulsant medication and an additional 30 patients (50.8%) became seizure-free with anticonvulsant medication. Pre-existing neurological deficits improved or totally disappeared following radiosurgery in 56.7% of affected cases. This improvement presumably occurred within the frame of the natural history. The protective effect of the ionizing beams against hemorrhage in incompletely obliterated AVM's is analyzed. To assess the rate of rebleeding, probability estimates were calculated using both the person-year method and the Kaplan-Meier life table. With the person-year method the actual rebleed rate is not too different from the values observed in the natural history of the disease (2% to 3%/yr). Analysis by Kaplan-Meier life-table estimates demonstrated a risk of nearly 3.7%/yr until 60 months after radiosurgery. Five years following treatment, the life table ends in a plateau which could be interpreted as an indication of decrease in the risk of hemorrhage. However, long flat regions at the right end of the life table do not imply that the real risk of rebleeding is negligible unless a large number of patients have been followed well into or beyond the flat region.

Stereotactic radiotherapy instead of conventional epilepsy surgery. A case report

A case report is made on a 29 year old male suffering from drug resistant epilepsy with a left temporal focus and normal neuroradiological findings. Instead of the conventional partial temporal resection, the focus was stereotactically irradiated in five fractions using a standard linear accelerator (6 MeV), to a total dose equivalent of 10 Gy in a single shot. Two months after the treatment the frequency of seizures decreased and the patient has been free of attacks since the seventh postirradiation month, up to 27 months by now, and in excellent condition. Noninvasive stereotactic radiotherapy may turn out to be a rational way to eliminate an epileptic focus.