Role of the biomolecular energy gap in protein design, structure, and evolution

Opportunities and challenges in design and optimization of protein function

The field of protein design has made remarkable progress over the past decade. Historically, the low reliability of purely structure-based design methods limited their application, but recent strategies that combine structure-based and sequence-based calculations, as well as machine learning tools, have dramatically improved protein engineering and design. In this Review, we discuss how these methods have enabled the design of increasingly complex structures and therapeutically relevant activities. Additionally, protein optimization methods have improved the stability and activity of complex eukaryotic proteins. Thanks to their increased reliability, computational design methods have been applied to improve therapeutics and enzymes for green chemistry and have generated vaccine antigens, antivirals and drug-delivery nano-vehicles. Moreover, the high success of design methods reflects an increased understanding of basic rules that govern the relationships among protein sequence, structure and function. However, de novo design is still limited mostly to α-helix bundles, restricting its potential to generate sophisticated enzymes and diverse protein and small-molecule binders. Designing complex protein structures is a challenging but necessary next step if we are to realize our objective of generating new-to-nature activities.

Deep learning guided design of dynamic proteins

Deep learning has greatly advanced design of highly stable static protein structures, but the controlled conformational dynamics that are hallmarks of natural switch-like signaling proteins have remained inaccessible to de novo design. Here, we describe a general deep-learning-guided approach for de novo design of dynamic changes between intra-domain geometries of proteins, similar to switch mechanisms prevalent in nature, with atom-level precision. We solve 4 structures validating the designed conformations, show microsecond transitions between them, and demonstrate that the conformational landscape can be modulated by orthosteric ligands and allosteric mutations. Physics-based simulations are in remarkable agreement with deep-learning predictions and experimental data, reveal distinct state-dependent residue interaction networks, and predict mutations that tune the designed conformational landscape. Our approach demonstrates that new modes of motion can now be realized through de novo design and provides a framework for constructing biology-inspired, tunable and controllable protein signaling behavior de novo .

Protein Design Using Structure-Prediction Networks: AlphaFold and RoseTTAFold as Protein Structure Foundation Models

Designing proteins with tailored structures and functions is a long-standing goal in bioengineering. Recently, deep learning advances have enabled protein structure prediction at near-experimental accuracy, which has catalyzed progress in protein design as well. We review recent studies that use structure-prediction neural networks to design proteins, via approaches such as activation maximization, inpainting, or denoising diffusion. These methods have led to major improvements over previous methods in wet-lab success rates for designing protein binders, metalloproteins, enzymes, and oligomeric assemblies. These results show that structure-prediction models are a powerful foundation for developing protein-design tools and suggest that continued improvement of their accuracy and generality will be key to unlocking the full potential of protein design.

High-throughput system for the thermostability analysis of proteins

Thermal stability of proteins is a primary metric for evaluating their physical properties. Although researchers attempted to predict it using machine learning frameworks, their performance has been dependent on the quality and quantity of published data. This is due to the technical limitation that thermodynamic characterization of protein denaturation by fluorescence or calorimetry in a high-throughput manner has been challenging. Obtaining a melting curve that derives solely from the target protein requires laborious purification, making it far from practical to prepare a hundred or more samples in a single workflow. Here, we aimed to overcome this throughput limitation by leveraging the high protein secretion efficacy of Brevibacillus and consecutive treatment with plate-scale purification methodologies. By handling the entire process of expression, purification, and analysis on a per-plate basis, we enabled the direct observation of protein denaturation in 384 samples within 4 days. To demonstrate a practical application of the system, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of 186 single mutants of a single-chain variable fragment of nivolumab, harvesting the melting temperature (Tm) ranging from -9.3 up to +10.8°C compared to the wild-type sequence. Our findings will allow for data-driven stabilization in protein design and streamlining the rational approaches.

In silico design of misfolding resistant proteins: the role of structural similarity of a competing conformational ensemble in the optimization of frustration

Most state-of-the-art in silico design methods fail due to misfolding of designed sequences to a conformation other than the target. Thus, a method to design misfolding resistant proteins will provide a better understanding of the misfolding phenomenon and will also increase the success rate of in silico design methods. In this work, we optimize the conformational ensemble to be selected for negative design purposes based on the similarity of the conformational ensemble to the target. Five ensembles with different degrees of similarity to the target are created and destabilized and the target is stabilized while designing sequences using mean field theory and Monte Carlo simulation methods. The results suggest that the degree of similarity of the non-native conformations to the target plays a prominent role in designing misfolding resistant protein sequences. The design procedures that destabilize the conformational ensemble with moderate similarity to the target have proven to be more promising. Incorporation of either highly similar or highly dissimilar conformations to the target conformation into the non-native ensemble to be destabilized may lead to sequences with a higher misfolding propensity. This will significantly reduce the conformational space to be considered in any protein design procedure. Interestingly, the results suggest that a sequence with higher frustration in the target structure does not necessarily lead to a misfold prone sequence. A successful design method may purposefully choose a frustrated sequence in the target conformation if that sequence is even more frustrated in the competing non-native conformations.

Sparks of function by de novo protein design

Information in proteins flows from sequence to structure to function, with each step causally driven by the preceding one. Protein design is founded on inverting this process: specify a desired function, design a structure executing this function, and find a sequence that folds into this structure. This 'central dogma' underlies nearly all de novo protein-design efforts. Our ability to accomplish these tasks depends on our understanding of protein folding and function and our ability to capture this understanding in computational methods. In recent years, deep learning-derived approaches for efficient and accurate structure modeling and enrichment of successful designs have enabled progression beyond the design of protein structures and towards the design of functional proteins. We examine these advances in the broader context of classical de novo protein design and consider implications for future challenges to come, including fundamental capabilities such as sequence and structure co-design and conformational control considering flexibility, and functional objectives such as antibody and enzyme design.

Accelerating antibody discovery and design with artificial intelligence: Recent advances and prospects

Therapeutic antibodies are the largest class of biotherapeutics and have been successful in treating human diseases. However, the design and discovery of antibody drugs remains challenging and time-consuming. Recently, artificial intelligence technology has had an incredible impact on antibody design and discovery, resulting in significant advances in antibody discovery, optimization, and developability. This review summarizes major machine learning (ML) methods and their applications for computational predictors of antibody structure and antigen interface/interaction, as well as the evaluation of antibody developability. Additionally, this review addresses the current status of ML-based therapeutic antibodies under preclinical and clinical phases. While many challenges remain, ML may offer a new therapeutic option for the future direction of fully computational antibody design.

The design of functional proteins using tensorized energy calculations

In protein design, the energy associated with a huge number of sequence-conformer perturbations has to be routinely estimated. Hence, enhancing the throughput and accuracy of these energy calculations can profoundly improve design success rates and enable tackling more complex design problems. In this work, we explore the possibility of tensorizing the energy calculations and apply them in a protein design framework. We use this framework to design enhanced proteins with anti-cancer and radio-tracing functions. Particularly, we designed multispecific binders against ligands of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), where the tested design could inhibit EGFR activity in vitro and in vivo. We also used this method to design high-affinity Cu2+ binders that were stable in serum and could be readily loaded with copper-64 radionuclide. The resulting molecules show superior functional properties for their respective applications and demonstrate the generalizable potential of the described protein design approach.

De novo design of protein interactions with learned surface fingerprints

Physical interactions between proteins are essential for most biological processes governing life1. However, the molecular determinants of such interactions have been challenging to understand, even as genomic, proteomic and structural data increase. This knowledge gap has been a major obstacle for the comprehensive understanding of cellular protein-protein interaction networks and for the de novo design of protein binders that are crucial for synthetic biology and translational applications2-9. Here we use a geometric deep-learning framework operating on protein surfaces that generates fingerprints to describe geometric and chemical features that are critical to drive protein-protein interactions10. We hypothesized that these fingerprints capture the key aspects of molecular recognition that represent a new paradigm in the computational design of novel protein interactions. As a proof of principle, we computationally designed several de novo protein binders to engage four protein targets: SARS-CoV-2 spike, PD-1, PD-L1 and CTLA-4. Several designs were experimentally optimized, whereas others were generated purely in silico, reaching nanomolar affinity with structural and mutational characterization showing highly accurate predictions. Overall, our surface-centric approach captures the physical and chemical determinants of molecular recognition, enabling an approach for the de novo design of protein interactions and, more broadly, of artificial proteins with function.

De novo design of obligate ABC-type heterotrimeric proteins

The de novo design of three protein chains that associate to form a heterotrimer (but not any of the possible two-chain heterodimers) and that can drive the assembly of higher-order branching structures is an important challenge for protein design. We designed helical heterotrimers with specificity conferred by buried hydrogen bond networks and large aromatic residues to enhance shape complementary packing. We obtained ten designs for which all three chains cooperatively assembled into heterotrimers with few or no other species present. Crystal structures of a helical bundle heterotrimer and extended versions, with helical repeat proteins fused to individual subunits, showed all three chains assembling in the designed orientation. We used these heterotrimers as building blocks to construct larger cyclic oligomers, which were structurally validated by electron microscopy. Our three-way junction designs provide new routes to complex protein nanostructures and enable the scaffolding of three distinct ligands for modulation of cell signaling.

De novo-designed transmembrane domains tune engineered receptor functions

De novo-designed receptor transmembrane domains (TMDs) present opportunities for precise control of cellular receptor functions. We developed a de novo design strategy for generating programmed membrane proteins (proMPs): single-pass α-helical TMDs that self-assemble through computationally defined and crystallographically validated interfaces. We used these proMPs to program specific oligomeric interactions into a chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) that we expressed in mouse primary T cells and found that both in vitro CAR T cell cytokine release and in vivo antitumor activity scaled linearly with the oligomeric state encoded by the receptor TMD, from monomers up to tetramers. All programmed CARs stimulated substantially lower T cell cytokine release relative to the commonly used CD28 TMD, which we show elevated cytokine release through lateral recruitment of the endogenous T cell costimulatory receptor CD28. Precise design using orthogonal and modular TMDs thus provides a new way to program receptor structure and predictably tune activity for basic or applied synthetic biology.

Accurate positioning of functional residues with robotics-inspired computational protein design

SignificanceComputational protein design promises to advance applications in medicine and biotechnology by creating proteins with many new and useful functions. However, new functions require the design of specific and often irregular atom-level geometries, which remains a major challenge. Here, we develop computational methods that design and predict local protein geometries with greater accuracy than existing methods. Then, as a proof of concept, we leverage these methods to design new protein conformations in the enzyme ketosteroid isomerase that change the protein's preference for a key functional residue. Our computational methods are openly accessible and can be applied to the design of other intricate geometries customized for new user-defined protein functions.

What Have We Learned from Design of Function in Large Proteins?

The overarching goal of computational protein design is to gain complete control over protein structure and function. The majority of sophisticated binders and enzymes, however, are large and exhibit diverse and complex folds that defy atomistic design calculations. Encouragingly, recent strategies that combine evolutionary constraints from natural homologs with atomistic calculations have significantly improved design accuracy. In these approaches, evolutionary constraints mitigate the risk from misfolding and aggregation, focusing atomistic design calculations on a small but highly enriched sequence subspace. Such methods have dramatically optimized diverse proteins, including vaccine immunogens, enzymes for sustainable chemistry, and proteins with therapeutic potential. The new generation of deep learning-based ab initio structure predictors can be combined with these methods to extend the scope of protein design, in principle, to any natural protein of known sequence. We envision that protein engineering will come to rely on completely computational methods to efficiently discover and optimize biomolecular activities.

Accelerating therapeutic protein design

Protein structures provide for defined microenvironments that can support complex pharmacological functions, otherwise unachievable by small molecules. The advent of therapeutic proteins has thus greatly broadened the range of manageable disorders. Leveraging the knowledge and recent advances in de novo protein design methods has the prospect of revolutionizing how protein drugs are discovered and developed. This review lays out the main challenges facing therapeutic proteins discovery and development, and how present and future advancements of protein design can accelerate the protein drug pipelines.

Reconfigurable asymmetric protein assemblies through implicit negative design

Asymmetric multiprotein complexes that undergo subunit exchange play central roles in biology but present a challenge for design because the components must not only contain interfaces that enable reversible association but also be stable and well behaved in isolation. We use implicit negative design to generate β sheet-mediated heterodimers that can be assembled into a wide variety of complexes. The designs are stable, folded, and soluble in isolation and rapidly assemble upon mixing, and crystal structures are close to the computational models. We construct linearly arranged hetero-oligomers with up to six different components, branched hetero-oligomers, closed C4-symmetric two-component rings, and hetero-oligomers assembled on a cyclic homo-oligomeric central hub and demonstrate that such complexes can readily reconfigure through subunit exchange. Our approach provides a general route to designing asymmetric reconfigurable protein systems.

Altering the Double-Stranded DNA Specificity of the bZIP Domain of Zta with Site-Directed Mutagenesis at N182

Zta, the Epstein-Barr virus bZIP transcription factor (TF), binds both unmethylated and methylated double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) in a sequence-specific manner. We studied the contribution of a conserved asparagine (N182) to sequence-specific dsDNA binding to four types of dsDNA: (i) dsDNA with cytosine in both strands ((DNA(C|C)), (ii, iii) dsDNA with 5-methylcytosine (5mC, M) or 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC, H) in one strand and cytosine in the second strand ((DNA(5mC|C) and DNA(5hmC|C)), and (iv) dsDNA with methylated cytosine in both strands in all CG dinucleotides ((DNA(5mCG)). We replaced asparagine with five similarly sized amino acids (glutamine (Q), serine (S), threonine (T), isoleucine (I), or valine (V)) and used protein binding microarrays to evaluate sequence-specific dsDNA binding. Zta preferentially binds the pseudo-palindrome TRE (AP1) motif (T^-4G^-3A^-2G/_C ⁰T²C³A⁴ ). Zta (N182Q) changes binding to A³ in only one half-site. Zta(N182S) changes binding to G³ in one or both halves of the motif. Zta(N182S) and Zta(N182Q) have 34- and 17-fold weaker median dsDNA binding, respectively. Zta(N182V) and Zta(N182I) have increased binding to dsDNA(5mC|C). Molecular dynamics simulations rationalize some of these results, identifying hydrogen bonds between glutamine and A³ , but do not reveal why serine preferentially binds G³ , suggesting that entropic interactions may mediate this new binding specificity.

Protein Assembly by Design

Proteins are nature's primary building blocks for the construction of sophisticated molecular machines and dynamic materials, ranging from protein complexes such as photosystem II and nitrogenase that drive biogeochemical cycles to cytoskeletal assemblies and muscle fibers for motion. Such natural systems have inspired extensive efforts in the rational design of artificial protein assemblies in the last two decades. As molecular building blocks, proteins are highly complex, in terms of both their three-dimensional structures and chemical compositions. To enable control over the self-assembly of such complex molecules, scientists have devised many creative strategies by combining tools and principles of experimental and computational biophysics, supramolecular chemistry, inorganic chemistry, materials science, and polymer chemistry, among others. Owing to these innovative strategies, what started as a purely structure-building exercise two decades ago has, in short order, led to artificial protein assemblies with unprecedented structures and functions and protein-based materials with unusual properties. Our goal in this review is to give an overview of this exciting and highly interdisciplinary area of research, first outlining the design strategies and tools that have been devised for controlling protein self-assembly, then describing the diverse structures of artificial protein assemblies, and finally highlighting the emergent properties and functions of these assemblies.

Computationally designed peptide macrocycle inhibitors of New Delhi metallo-β-lactamase 1

The rise of antibiotic resistance calls for new therapeutics targeting resistance factors such as the New Delhi metallo-β-lactamase 1 (NDM-1), a bacterial enzyme that degrades β-lactam antibiotics. We present structure-guided computational methods for designing peptide macrocycles built from mixtures of l- and d-amino acids that are able to bind to and inhibit targets of therapeutic interest. Our methods explicitly consider the propensity of a peptide to favor a binding-competent conformation, which we found to predict rank order of experimentally observed IC₅₀ values across seven designed NDM-1- inhibiting peptides. We were able to determine X-ray crystal structures of three of the designed inhibitors in complex with NDM-1, and in all three the conformation of the peptide is very close to the computationally designed model. In two of the three structures, the binding mode with NDM-1 is also very similar to the design model, while in the third, we observed an alternative binding mode likely arising from internal symmetry in the shape of the design combined with flexibility of the target. Although challenges remain in robustly predicting target backbone changes, binding mode, and the effects of mutations on binding affinity, our methods for designing ordered, binding-competent macrocycles should have broad applicability to a wide range of therapeutic targets.

Extending the New Generation of Structure Predictors to Account for Dynamics and Allostery

Recent progress in structure-prediction methods that rely on deep learning suggests that the atomic structure of almost any protein may soon be predictable directly from its amino acid sequence. This much-awaited revolution was driven by substantial improvements in the reliability of methods for inferring the spatial distances between amino acid pairs from an analysis of homologous sequences. Improved reliability has been accompanied, however, by a reduced ability to detect amino acid relationships that are not due to direct spatial contacts, such as those that arise from protein dynamics or allostery. Given the central importance of dynamics and allostery to protein activity, we argue that an important future advance would extend modeling beyond predicting a single static structure. Here, we briefly review some of the developments that have led to the remarkable recent achievement in structure prediction and speculate what methods and sources of information may be leveraged in the future to develop a modeling framework that addresses protein dynamics and allostery.

Community-Wide Experimental Evaluation of the PROSS Stability-Design Method

Recent years have seen a dramatic improvement in protein-design methodology. Nevertheless, most methods demand expert intervention, limiting their widespread adoption. By contrast, the PROSS algorithm for improving protein stability and heterologous expression levels has been successfully applied to a range of challenging enzymes and binding proteins. Here, we benchmark the application of PROSS as a stand-alone tool for protein scientists with no or limited experience in modeling. Twelve laboratories from the Protein Production and Purification Partnership in Europe (P4EU) challenged the PROSS algorithm with 14 unrelated protein targets without support from the PROSS developers. For each target, up to six designs were evaluated for expression levels and in some cases, for thermal stability and activity. In nine targets, designs exhibited increased heterologous expression levels either in prokaryotic and/or eukaryotic expression systems under experimental conditions that were tailored for each target protein. Furthermore, we observed increased thermal stability in nine of ten tested targets. In two prime examples, the human Stem Cell Factor (hSCF) and human Cadherin-Like Domain (CLD12) from the RET receptor, the wild type proteins were not expressible as soluble proteins in E. coli, yet the PROSS designs exhibited high expression levels in E. coli and HEK293 cells, respectively, and improved thermal stability. We conclude that PROSS may improve stability and expressibility in diverse cases, and that improvement typically requires target-specific expression conditions. This study demonstrates the strengths of community-wide efforts to probe the generality of new methods and recommends areas for future research to advance practically useful algorithms for protein science.

Protein Structure Prediction Using Population-Based Algorithm Guided by Information Entropy

Ab initio protein structure prediction is one of the most challenging problems in computational biology. Multistage algorithms are widely used in ab initio protein structure prediction. The different computational costs of a multistage algorithm for different proteins are important to be considered. In this study, a population-based algorithm guided by information entropy (PAIE), which includes exploration and exploitation stages, is proposed for protein structure prediction. In PAIE, an entropy-based stage switch strategy is designed to switch from the exploration stage to the exploitation stage. Torsion angle statistical information is also deduced from the first stage and employed to enhance the exploitation in the second stage. Results indicate that an improvement in the performance of protein structure prediction in a benchmark of 30 proteins and 17 other free modeling targets in CASP.

De novo design of transmembrane β barrels

Transmembrane β-barrel proteins (TMBs) are of great interest for single-molecule analytical technologies because they can spontaneously fold and insert into membranes and form stable pores, but the range of pore properties that can be achieved by repurposing natural TMBs is limited. We leverage the power of de novo computational design coupled with a "hypothesis, design, and test" approach to determine TMB design principles, notably, the importance of negative design to slow β-sheet assembly. We design new eight-stranded TMBs, with no homology to known TMBs, that insert and fold reversibly into synthetic lipid membranes and have nuclear magnetic resonance and x-ray crystal structures very similar to the computational models. These advances should enable the custom design of pores for a wide range of applications.

Computational Ways to Enhance Protein Inhibitor Design

Two new computational approaches are described to aid in the design of new peptide-based drugs by evaluating ensembles of protein structures from their dynamics and through the assessing of structures using empirical contact potential. These approaches build on the concept that conformational variability can aid in the binding process and, for disordered proteins, can even facilitate the binding of more diverse ligands. This latter consideration indicates that such a design process should be less restrictive so that multiple inhibitors might be effective. The example chosen here focuses on proteins/peptides that bind to hemagglutinin (HA) to block the large-scale conformational change for activation. Variability in the conformations is considered from sets of experimental structures, or as an alternative, from their simple computed dynamics; the set of designe peptides/small proteins from the David Baker lab designed to bind to hemagglutinin, is the large set considered and is assessed with the new empirical contact potentials.

Prediction of Protein-Protein Binding Interactions in Dimeric Coiled Coils by Information Contained in Folding Energy Landscapes

Coiled coils represent the simplest form of a complex formed between two interacting protein partners. Their extensive study has led to the development of various methods aimed towards the investigation and design of complex forming interactions. Despite the progress that has been made to predict the binding affinities for protein complexes, and specifically those tailored towards coiled coils, many challenges still remain. In this work, we explore whether the information contained in dimeric coiled coil folding energy landscapes can be used to predict binding interactions. Using the published SYNZIP dataset, we start from the amino acid sequence, to simultaneously fold and dock approximately 1000 coiled coil dimers. Assessment of the folding energy landscapes showed that a model based on the calculated number of clusters for the lowest energy structures displayed a signal that correlates with the experimentally determined protein interactions. Although the revealed correlation is weak, we show that such correlation exists; however, more work remains to establish whether further improvements can be made to the presented model.

The AbDesign computational pipeline for modular backbone assembly and design of binders and enzymes

The functional sites of many protein families are dominated by diverse backbone regions that lack secondary structure (loops) but fold stably into their functionally competent state. Nevertheless, the design of structured loop regions from scratch, especially in functional sites, has met with great difficulty. We therefore developed an approach, called AbDesign, to exploit the natural modularity of many protein families and computationally assemble a large number of new backbones by combining naturally occurring modular fragments. This strategy yielded large, atomically accurate, and highly efficient proteins, including antibodies and enzymes exhibiting dozens of mutations from any natural protein. The combinatorial backbone‐conformation space that can be accessed by AbDesign even for a modestly sized family of homologs may exceed the diversity in the entire PDB, providing the sub‐Ångstrom level of control over the positioning of active‐site groups that is necessary for obtaining highly active proteins. This manuscript describes how to implement the pipeline using code that is freely available at https://github.com/Fleishman‐Lab/AbDesign_for_enzymes.

Practically useful protein-design methods combining phylogenetic and atomistic calculations

Our ability to design new or improved biomolecular activities depends on understanding the sequence-function relationships in proteins. The large size and fold complexity of most proteins, however, obscure these relationships, and protein-optimization methods continue to rely on laborious experimental iterations. Recently, a deeper understanding of the roles of stability-threshold effects and biomolecular epistasis in proteins has led to the development of hybrid methods that combine phylogenetic analysis with atomistic design calculations. These methods enable reliable and even single-step optimization of protein stability, expressibility, and activity in proteins that were considered outside the scope of computational design. Furthermore, ancestral-sequence reconstruction produces insights on missing links in the evolution of enzymes and binders that may be used in protein design. Through the combination of phylogenetic and atomistic calculations, the long-standing goal of general computational methods that can be universally applied to study and optimize proteins finally seems within reach.

Hydroxyl Radical-Coupled Electron-Transfer Mechanism of Flavin-Dependent Hydroxylases

Class A flavin-dependent hydroxylases (FdHs) catalyze the hydroxylation of organic compounds in a site- and stereoselective manner. In stark contrast, conventional synthetic routes require environmentally hazardous reagents and give modest yields. Thus, understanding the detailed mechanism of this class of enzymes is essential to their rational manipulation for applications in green chemistry and pharmaceutical production. Both electrophilic substitution and radical intermediate mechanisms have been proposed as interpretations of FdH hydroxylation rates and optical spectra. While radical mechanistic steps are often difficult to examine directly, modern quantum chemistry calculations combined with statistical mechanical approaches can yield detailed mechanistic models providing insights that can be used to differentiate reaction pathways. In the current work, we report quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations on the fungal TropB enzyme that shows an alternative reaction pathway in which hydroxylation through a hydroxyl radical-coupled electron-transfer mechanism is significantly favored over electrophilic substitution. Furthermore, QM/MM calculations on several modified flavins provide a more consistent interpretation of the experimental trends in the reaction rates seen experimentally for a related enzyme, para-hydroxybenzoate hydroxylase. These calculations should guide future enzyme and substrate design strategies and broaden the scope of biological spin chemistry.

Localizing Frustration in Proteins Using All-Atom Energy Functions

The problems of protein folding and protein design are two sides of the same coin. Protein folding involves exploring a protein's configuration space given a fixed sequence, whereas protein design involves searching in sequence space given a particular target structure. For a protein to fold quickly and reliably, its energy landscape must be biased toward the folded ensemble throughout its configuration space and must lack deep kinetic traps that would otherwise frustrate folding. Evolution has "designed" the sequences of many naturally occurring proteins, through an eons-long process of random mutation and selection, to yield landscapes with a minimal degree of frustration. The task facing humans hoping to design protein sequences that fold into particular structures is to use the available approximate energy functions to sculpt funneled landscapes that work in the laboratory. In this work, we demonstrate how to calculate several localized frustration measures using an all-atom energy function. Specifically, we employ the Rosetta energy function, which has been used successfully to design proteins and which has a natural pairwise decomposition that is suitably solvent-averaged. We calculate these newly developed frustration measures for both a mutated WW domain, FiP35, and a three-helix bundle that was designed completely by humans, Alpha3D. The structure of FiP35 exhibits less localized frustration than that of Alpha3D. A mutation toward the consensus sequence for WW domains in FiP35, which has been shown unexpectedly in experiment to disrupt folding, induces localized frustration by disrupting the hydrophobic core. By performing a limited redesign on the sequence of Alpha3D, we show that some, but not all, mutations that lower the energy also result in decreased frustration. The results suggest that, in addition to being useful for detecting residual frustration in protein structures, optimizing the localized frustration measures presented here may be a useful and automatic means of balancing positive and negative design in protein design tasks.

Computational design of structured loops for new protein functions

The ability to engineer the precise geometries, fine-tuned energetics and subtle dynamics that are characteristic of functional proteins is a major unsolved challenge in the field of computational protein design. In natural proteins, functional sites exhibiting these properties often feature structured loops. However, unlike the elements of secondary structures that comprise idealized protein folds, structured loops have been difficult to design computationally. Addressing this shortcoming in a general way is a necessary first step towards the routine design of protein function. In this perspective, we will describe the progress that has been made on this problem and discuss how recent advances in the field of loop structure prediction can be harnessed and applied to the inverse problem of computational loop design.

Third generation antibody discovery methods: in silico rational design

Owing to their outstanding performances in molecular recognition, antibodies are extensively used in research and applications in molecular biology, biotechnology and medicine. Recent advances in experimental and computational methods are making it possible to complement well-established in vivo (first generation) and in vitro (second generation) methods of antibody discovery with novel in silico (third generation) approaches. Here we describe the principles of computational antibody design and review the state of the art in this field. We then present Modular, a method that implements the rational design of antibodies in a modular manner, and describe the opportunities offered by this approach.

Ultrahigh specificity in a network of computationally designed protein-interaction pairs

Protein networks in all organisms comprise homologous interacting pairs. In these networks, some proteins are specific, interacting with one or a few binding partners, whereas others are multispecific and bind a range of targets. We describe an algorithm that starts from an interacting pair and designs dozens of new pairs with diverse backbone conformations at the binding site as well as new binding orientations and sequences. Applied to a high-affinity bacterial pair, the algorithm results in 18 new ones, with cognate affinities from pico- to micromolar. Three pairs exhibit 3-5 orders of magnitude switch in specificity relative to the wild type, whereas others are multispecific, collectively forming a protein-interaction network. Crystallographic analysis confirms design accuracy, including in new backbones and polar interactions. Preorganized polar interaction networks are responsible for high specificity, thus defining design principles that can be applied to program synthetic cellular interaction networks of desired affinity and specificity.

The molecular basis of ultrahigh specificity in protein-protein interactions remains obscure. The authors present a computational method to design atomically accurate new pairs exhibiting >100,000-fold specificity switches, generating a large and complex interaction network.

Principles of Protein Stability and Their Application in Computational Design

Proteins are increasingly used in basic and applied biomedical research. Many proteins, however, are only marginally stable and can be expressed in limited amounts, thus hampering research and applications. Research has revealed the thermodynamic, cellular, and evolutionary principles and mechanisms that underlie marginal stability. With this growing understanding, computational stability design methods have advanced over the past two decades starting from methods that selectively addressed only some aspects of marginal stability. Current methods are more general and, by combining phylogenetic analysis with atomistic design, have shown drastic improvements in solubility, thermal stability, and aggregation resistance while maintaining the protein's primary molecular activity. Stability design is opening the way to rational engineering of improved enzymes, therapeutics, and vaccines and to the application of protein design methodology to large proteins and molecular activities that have proven challenging in the past.

Principles for computational design of binding antibodies

Natural proteins must both fold into a stable conformation and exert their molecular function. To date, computational design has successfully produced stable and atomically accurate proteins by using so-called "ideal" folds rich in regular secondary structures and almost devoid of loops and destabilizing elements, such as cavities. Molecular function, such as binding and catalysis, however, often demands nonideal features, including large and irregular loops and buried polar interaction networks, which have remained challenging for fold design. Through five design/experiment cycles, we learned principles for designing stable and functional antibody variable fragments (Fvs). Specifically, we (i) used sequence-design constraints derived from antibody multiple-sequence alignments, and (ii) during backbone design, maintained stabilizing interactions observed in natural antibodies between the framework and loops of complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) 1 and 2. Designed Fvs bound their ligands with midnanomolar affinities and were as stable as natural antibodies, despite having >30 mutations from mammalian antibody germlines. Furthermore, crystallographic analysis demonstrated atomic accuracy throughout the framework and in four of six CDRs in one design and atomic accuracy in the entire Fv in another. The principles we learned are general, and can be implemented to design other nonideal folds, generating stable, specific, and precise antibodies and enzymes.

Harnessing self-assembled peptide nanoparticles in epitope vaccine design

Vaccination has been one of the most successful breakthroughs in medical history. In recent years, epitope-based subunit vaccines have been introduced as a safer alternative to traditional vaccines. However, they suffer from limited immunogenicity. Nanotechnology has shown value in solving this issue. Different kinds of nanovaccines have been employed, among which virus-like nanoparticles (VLPs) and self-assembled peptide nanoparticles (SAPNs) seem very promising. Recently, SAPNs have attracted special interest due to their unique properties, including molecular specificity, biodegradability, and biocompatibility. They also resemble pathogens in terms of their size. Their multivalency allows an orderly repetitive display of antigens on their surface, which induces a stronger immune response than single immunogens. In vaccine design, SAPN self-adjuvanticity is regarded an outstanding advantage, since the use of toxic adjuvants is no longer required. SAPNs are usually composed of helical or β-sheet secondary structures and are tailored from natural peptides or de novo structures. Flexibility in subunit selection opens the door to a wide variety of molecules with different characteristics. SAPN engineering is an emerging area, and more novel structures are expected to be generated in the future, particularly with the rapid progress in related computational tools. The aim of this review is to provide a state-of-the-art overview of self-assembled peptide nanoparticles and their use in vaccine design in recent studies. Additionally, principles for their design and the application of computational approaches to vaccine design are summarized.

Searching for the Pareto frontier in multi-objective protein design

The goal of protein engineering and design is to identify sequences that adopt three-dimensional structures of desired function. Often, this is treated as a single-objective optimization problem, identifying the sequence-structure solution with the lowest computed free energy of folding. However, many design problems are multi-state, multi-specificity, or otherwise require concurrent optimization of multiple objectives. There may be tradeoffs among objectives, where improving one feature requires compromising another. The challenge lies in determining solutions that are part of the Pareto optimal set-designs where no further improvement can be achieved in any of the objectives without degrading one of the others. Pareto optimality problems are found in all areas of study, from economics to engineering to biology, and computational methods have been developed specifically to identify the Pareto frontier. We review progress in multi-objective protein design, the development of Pareto optimization methods, and present a specific case study using multi-objective optimization methods to model the tradeoff between three parameters, stability, specificity, and complexity, of a set of interacting synthetic collagen peptides.

Benchmarking a computational design method for the incorporation of metal ion-binding sites at symmetric protein interfaces

The design of novel metal-ion binding sites along symmetric axes in protein oligomers could provide new avenues for metalloenzyme design, construction of protein-based nanomaterials and novel ion transport systems. Here, we describe a computational design method, symmetric protein recursive ion-cofactor sampling (SyPRIS), for locating constellations of backbone positions within oligomeric protein structures that are capable of supporting desired symmetrically coordinated metal ion(s) chelated by sidechains (chelant model). Using SyPRIS on a curated benchmark set of protein structures with symmetric metal binding sites, we found high recovery of native metal coordinating rotamers: in 65 of the 67 (97.0%) cases, native rotamers featured in the best scoring model while in the remaining cases native rotamers were found within the top three scoring models. In a second test, chelant models were crossmatched against protein structures with identical cyclic symmetry. In addition to recovering all native placements, 10.4% (8939/86013) of the non-native placements, had acceptable geometric compatibility scores. Discrimination between native and non-native metal site placements was further enhanced upon constrained energy minimization using the Rosetta energy function. Upon sequence design of the surrounding first-shell residues, we found further stabilization of native placements and a small but significant (1.7%) number of non-native placement-based sites with favorable Rosetta energies, indicating their designability in existing protein interfaces. The generality of the SyPRIS approach allows design of novel symmetric metal sites including with non-natural amino acid sidechains, and should enable the predictive incorporation of a variety of metal-containing cofactors at symmetric protein interfaces.

A critical analysis of computational protein design with sparse residue interaction graphs

Protein design algorithms enumerate a combinatorial number of candidate structures to compute the Global Minimum Energy Conformation (GMEC). To efficiently find the GMEC, protein design algorithms must methodically reduce the conformational search space. By applying distance and energy cutoffs, the protein system to be designed can thus be represented using a sparse residue interaction graph, where the number of interacting residue pairs is less than all pairs of mutable residues, and the corresponding GMEC is called the sparse GMEC. However, ignoring some pairwise residue interactions can lead to a change in the energy, conformation, or sequence of the sparse GMEC vs. the original or the full GMEC. Despite the widespread use of sparse residue interaction graphs in protein design, the above mentioned effects of their use have not been previously analyzed. To analyze the costs and benefits of designing with sparse residue interaction graphs, we computed the GMECs for 136 different protein design problems both with and without distance and energy cutoffs, and compared their energies, conformations, and sequences. Our analysis shows that the differences between the GMECs depend critically on whether or not the design includes core, boundary, or surface residues. Moreover, neglecting long-range interactions can alter local interactions and introduce large sequence differences, both of which can result in significant structural and functional changes. Designs on proteins with experimentally measured thermostability show it is beneficial to compute both the full and the sparse GMEC accurately and efficiently. To this end, we show that a provable, ensemble-based algorithm can efficiently compute both GMECs by enumerating a small number of conformations, usually fewer than 1000. This provides a novel way to combine sparse residue interaction graphs with provable, ensemble-based algorithms to reap the benefits of sparse residue interaction graphs while avoiding their potential inaccuracies.

Computational structure-based protein design algorithms have successfully redesigned proteins to fold and bind target substrates in vitro, and even in vivo. Because the complexity of a computational design increases dramatically with the number of mutable residues, many design algorithms employ cutoffs (distance or energy) to neglect some pairwise residue interactions, thereby reducing the effective search space and computational cost. However, the energies neglected by such cutoffs can add up, which may have nontrivial effects on the designed sequence and its function. To study the effects of using cutoffs on protein design, we computed the optimal sequence both with and without cutoffs, and showed that neglecting long-range interactions can significantly change the computed conformation and sequence. Designs on proteins with experimentally measured thermostability showed the benefits of computing the optimal sequences (and their conformations), both with and without cutoffs, efficiently and accurately. Therefore, we also showed that a provable, ensemble-based algorithm can efficiently compute the optimal conformation and sequence, both with and without applying cutoffs, by enumerating a small number of conformations, usually fewer than 1000. This provides a novel way to combine cutoffs with provable, ensemble-based algorithms to reap the computational efficiency of cutoffs while avoiding their potential inaccuracies.

Incorporating an allosteric regulatory site in an antibody through backbone design

Allosteric regulation underlies living cells' ability to sense changes in nutrient and signaling-molecule concentrations, but the ability to computationally design allosteric regulation into non-allosteric proteins has been elusive. Allosteric-site design is complicated by the requirement to encode the relative stabilities of active and inactive conformations of the same protein in the presence and absence of both ligand and effector. To address this challenge, we used Rosetta to design the backbone of the flexible heavy-chain complementarity-determining region 3 (HCDR3), and used geometric matching and sequence optimization to place a Zn²⁺ -coordination site in a fluorescein-binding antibody. We predicted that due to HCDR3's flexibility, the fluorescein-binding pocket would configure properly only upon Zn²⁺ application. We found that regulation by Zn²⁺ was reversible and sensitive to the divalent ion's identity, and came at the cost of reduced antibody stability and fluorescein-binding affinity. Fluorescein bound at an order of magnitude higher affinity in the presence of Zn²⁺ than in its absence, and the increase in fluorescein affinity was due almost entirely to faster fluorescein on-rate, suggesting that Zn²⁺ preorganized the antibody for fluorescein binding. Mutation analysis demonstrated the extreme sensitivity of Zn²⁺ regulation on the atomic details in and around the metal-coordination site. The designed antibody could serve to study how allosteric regulation evolved from non-allosteric binding proteins, and suggests a way to designing molecular sensors for environmental and biomedical targets.

Computational design of an epitope-specific Keap1 binding antibody using hotspot residues grafting and CDR loop swapping

Therapeutic and diagnostic applications of monoclonal antibodies often require careful selection of binders that recognize specific epitopes on the target molecule to exert a desired modulation of biological function. Here we present a proof-of-concept application for the rational design of an epitope-specific antibody binding with the target protein Keap1, by grafting pre-defined structural interaction patterns from the native binding partner protein, Nrf2, onto geometrically matched positions of a set of antibody scaffolds. The designed antibodies bind to Keap1 and block the Keap1-Nrf2 interaction in an epitope-specific way. One resulting antibody is further optimised to achieve low-nanomolar binding affinity by in silico redesign of the CDRH3 sequences. An X-ray co-crystal structure of one resulting design reveals that the actual binding orientation and interface with Keap1 is very close to the design model, despite an unexpected CDRH3 tilt and V_H/V_L interface deviation, which indicates that the modelling precision may be improved by taking into account simultaneous CDR loops conformation and V_H/V_L orientation optimisation upon antibody sequence change. Our study confirms that, given a pre-existing crystal structure of the target protein-protein interaction, hotspots grafting with CDR loop swapping is an attractive route to the rational design of an antibody targeting a pre-selected epitope.

Peptide binding landscapes: Specificity and homophilicity across sequence space in a lattice model

Peptide aggregation frequently involves sequences with strong homophilic binding character, i.e., sequences that self-assemble with like species in a crowded cellular environment, in the face of a multitude of other peptides or proteins as potential heterophilic binding partners. What kinds of sequences display a strong tendency towards homophilic binding and self-assembly, and what are the origins of this behavior? Here, we consider how sequence specificity in oligomerization processes plays out in a simple two-dimensional (2D) lattice statistical-thermodynamic peptide model that permits exhaustive examination of the entire sequence and configurational landscapes. We find that sequences with strong self-specificities have either alternating hydrophobic and hydrophilic residues or short patches of hydrophobic residues, both which minimize intramolecular hydrophobic interactions in part due to the constraints of the 2D lattice. We also find that these specificities are highly sensitive to entropic and free energetic features of the unbound conformational state, such that direct binding interaction energies alone do not capture the complete behavior. These results suggest that the ability of particular peptide sequences to self-assemble and aggregate in a many-protein environment reflects a precise balance of direct binding interactions and behavior in the unbound (monomeric) state.

Massively parallel sampling of lattice proteins reveals foundations of thermal adaptation

Evolution of proteins in bacteria and archaea living in different conditions leads to significant correlations between amino acid usage and environmental temperature. The origins of these correlations are poorly understood, and an important question of protein theory, physics-based prediction of types of amino acids overrepresented in highly thermostable proteins, remains largely unsolved. Here, we extend the random energy model of protein folding by weighting the interaction energies of amino acids by their frequencies in protein sequences and predict the energy gap of proteins designed to fold well at elevated temperatures. To test the model, we present a novel scalable algorithm for simultaneous energy calculation for many sequences in many structures, targeting massively parallel computing architectures such as graphics processing unit. The energy calculation is performed by multiplying two matrices, one representing the complete set of sequences, and the other describing the contact maps of all structural templates. An implementation of the algorithm for the CUDA platform is available at http://www.github.com/kzeldovich/galeprot and calculates protein folding energies over 250 times faster than a single central processing unit. Analysis of amino acid usage in 64-mer cubic lattice proteins designed to fold well at different temperatures demonstrates an excellent agreement between theoretical and simulated values of energy gap. The theoretical predictions of temperature trends of amino acid frequencies are significantly correlated with bioinformatics data on 191 bacteria and archaea, and highlight protein folding constraints as a fundamental selection pressure during thermal adaptation in biological evolution.

Principles and Overview of Sampling Methods for Modeling Macromolecular Structure and Dynamics

Investigation of macromolecular structure and dynamics is fundamental to understanding how macromolecules carry out their functions in the cell. Significant advances have been made toward this end in silico, with a growing number of computational methods proposed yearly to study and simulate various aspects of macromolecular structure and dynamics. This review aims to provide an overview of recent advances, focusing primarily on methods proposed for exploring the structure space of macromolecules in isolation and in assemblies for the purpose of characterizing equilibrium structure and dynamics. In addition to surveying recent applications that showcase current capabilities of computational methods, this review highlights state-of-the-art algorithmic techniques proposed to overcome challenges posed in silico by the disparate spatial and time scales accessed by dynamic macromolecules. This review is not meant to be exhaustive, as such an endeavor is impossible, but rather aims to balance breadth and depth of strategies for modeling macromolecular structure and dynamics for a broad audience of novices and experts.

Why reinvent the wheel? Building new proteins based on ready-made parts

We protein engineers are ambivalent about evolution: on the one hand, evolution inspires us with myriad examples of biomolecular binders, sensors, and catalysts; on the other hand, these examples are seldom well-adapted to the engineering tasks we have in mind. Protein engineers have therefore modified natural proteins by point substitutions and fragment exchanges in an effort to generate new functions. A counterpoint to such design efforts, which is being pursued now with greater success, is to completely eschew the starting materials provided by nature and to design new protein functions from scratch by using de novo molecular modeling and design. While important progress has been made in both directions, some areas of protein design are still beyond reach. To this end, we advocate a synthesis of these two strategies: by using design calculations to both recombine and optimize fragments from natural proteins, we can build stable and as of yet un-sampled structures, thereby granting access to an expanded repertoire of conformations and desired functions. We propose that future methods that combine phylogenetic analysis, structure and sequence bioinformatics, and atomistic modeling may well succeed where any one of these approaches has failed on its own.

Mutational scanning reveals the determinants of protein insertion and association energetics in the plasma membrane

Insertion of helix-forming segments into the membrane and their association determines the structure, function, and expression levels of all plasma membrane proteins. However, systematic and reliable quantification of membrane-protein energetics has been challenging. We developed a deep mutational scanning method to monitor the effects of hundreds of point mutations on helix insertion and self-association within the bacterial inner membrane. The assay quantifies insertion energetics for all natural amino acids at 27 positions across the membrane, revealing that the hydrophobicity of biological membranes is significantly higher than appreciated. We further quantitate the contributions to membrane-protein insertion from positively charged residues at the cytoplasm-membrane interface and reveal large and unanticipated differences among these residues. Finally, we derive comprehensive mutational landscapes in the membrane domains of Glycophorin A and the ErbB2 oncogene, and find that insertion and self-association are strongly coupled in receptor homodimers.

Improving Binding Affinity and Selectivity of Computationally Designed Ligand-Binding Proteins Using Experiments

The ability to de novo design proteins that can bind small molecules has wide implications for synthetic biology and medicine. Combining computational protein design with the high-throughput screening of mutagenic libraries of computationally designed proteins is emerging as a general approach for creating binding proteins with programmable binding modes, affinities, and selectivities. The computational step enables the creation of a binding site in a protein that otherwise does not (measurably) bind the intended ligand, and targeted mutagenic screening allows for validation and refinement of the computational model as well as provides orders-of-magnitude increases in the binding affinity. Deep sequencing of mutagenic libraries can provide insights into the mutagenic binding landscape and enable further affinity improvements. Moreover, in such a combined computational-experimental approach where the binding mode is preprogrammed and iteratively refined, selectivity can be achieved (and modulated) by the placement of specified amino acid side chain groups around the ligand in defined orientations. Here, we describe the experimental aspects of a combined computational-experimental approach for designing-using the software suite Rosetta-proteins that bind a small molecule of choice and engineering, using fluorescence-activated cell sorting and high-throughput yeast surface display, high affinity and ligand selectivity. We illustrated the utility of this approach by performing the design of a selective digoxigenin (DIG)-binding protein that, after affinity maturation, binds DIG with picomolar affinity and high selectivity over structurally related steroids.

A human transcription factor in search mode

Transcription factors (TF) can change shape to bind and recognize DNA, shifting the energy landscape from a weak binding, rapid search mode to a higher affinity recognition mode. However, the mechanism(s) driving this conformational change remains unresolved and in most cases high-resolution structures of the non-specific complexes are unavailable. Here, we investigate the conformational switch of the human mitochondrial transcription termination factor MTERF1, which has a modular, superhelical topology complementary to DNA. Our goal was to characterize the details of the non-specific search mode to complement the crystal structure of the specific binding complex, providing a basis for understanding the recognition mechanism. In the specific complex, MTERF1 binds a significantly distorted and unwound DNA structure, exhibiting a protein conformation incompatible with binding to B-form DNA. In contrast, our simulations of apo MTERF1 revealed significant flexibility, sampling structures with superhelical pitch and radius complementary to the major groove of B-DNA. Docking these structures to B-DNA followed by unrestrained MD simulations led to a stable complex in which MTERF1 was observed to undergo spontaneous diffusion on the DNA. Overall, the data support an MTERF1-DNA binding and recognition mechanism driven by intrinsic dynamics of the MTERF1 superhelical topology.

Mutation-Guided Unbiased Modeling of the Fat Sensor GPR119 for High-Yield Agonist Screening

Recent benchmark studies have demonstrated the difficulties in obtaining accurate predictions of ligand binding conformations to comparative models of G-protein-coupled receptors. We have developed a data-driven optimization protocol, which integrates mutational data and structural information from multiple X-ray receptor structures in combination with a fully flexible ligand docking protocol to determine the binding conformation of AR231453, a small-molecule agonist, in the GPR119 receptor. Resulting models converge to one conformation that explains the majority of data from mutation studies and is consistent with the structure-activity relationship for a large number of AR231453 analogs. Another key property of the refined models is their success in separating active ligands from decoys in a large-scale virtual screening. These results demonstrate that mutation-guided receptor modeling can provide predictions of practical value for describing receptor-ligand interactions and drug discovery.

Metal Stabilization of Collagen and de Novo Designed Mimetic Peptides

We explore the design of metal binding sites to modulate triple-helix stability of collagen and collagen-mimetic peptides. Globular proteins commonly utilize metals to connect tertiary structural elements that are well separated in sequence, constraining structure and enhancing stability. It is more challenging to engineer structural metals into fibrous protein scaffolds, which lack the extensive tertiary contacts seen in globular proteins. In the collagen triple helix, the structural adjacency of the carboxy-termini of the three chains makes this region an attractive target for introducing metal binding sites. We engineered His3 sites based on structural modeling constraints into a series of designed homotrimeric and heterotrimeric peptides, assessing the capacity of metal binding to improve stability and in the case of heterotrimers, affect specificity of assembly. Notable enhancements in stability for both homo- and heteromeric systems were observed upon addition of zinc(II) and several other metal ions only when all three histidine ligands were present. Metal binding affinities were consistent with the expected Irving-Williams series for imidazole. Unlike other metals tested, copper(II) also bound to peptides lacking histidine ligands. Acetylation of the peptide N-termini prevented copper binding, indicating proline backbone amide metal-coordination at this site. Copper similarly stabilized animal extracted Type I collagen in a metal-specific fashion, highlighting the potential importance of metal homeostasis within the extracellular matrix.