Is size-consistency possible with density functional approximations?

Møller-Plesset Adiabatic Connection at Large Coupling Strengths for Open-Shell Systems

We study the adiabatic connection that has as weak-coupling expansion the Møller-Plesset perturbation series, generalizing to the open-shell case previous closed-shell results for the large-coupling limit. We first focus on the hydrogen atom with fractional spins, providing results along the adiabatic connection from small to large coupling strengths. We reveal an intriguing phase diagram and an equation for the large-coupling leading order that has closed-form solutions for specific choices of its relevant quantum numbers. We then show that the hydrogen atom results provide variational estimates for the large-coupling leading terms for the general many-electron open-shell case in terms of functionals of the Hartree-Fock α-spin and β-spin densities.

DFT exchange: sharing perspectives on the workhorse of quantum chemistry and materials science

In this paper, the history, present status, and future of density-functional theory (DFT) is informally reviewed and discussed by 70 workers in the field, including molecular scientists, materials scientists, method developers and practitioners. The format of the paper is that of a roundtable discussion, in which the participants express and exchange views on DFT in the form of 302 individual contributions, formulated as responses to a preset list of 26 questions. Supported by a bibliography of 777 entries, the paper represents a broad snapshot of DFT, anno 2022.

Hybrid functionals with local range separation: Accurate atomization energies and reaction barrier heights

Range-separated hybrid approximations to the exchange-correlation density functional mix exact and semi-local exchange in a position-dependent manner. In their conventional form, the range separation is controlled by a constant parameter. Turning this constant into a density functional leads to a locally space-dependent range-separation function and thus a more powerful and flexible range-separation approach. In this work, we explore the self-consistent implementation of a local range-separated hybrid, taking into account a one-electron self-interaction correction and the behavior under uniform density scaling. We discuss different forms of the local range-separation function that depend on the electron density, its gradient, and the kinetic energy density. For test sets of atomization energies, reaction barrier heights, and total energies of atoms, we demonstrate that our best model is a clear improvement over common global range-separated hybrid functionals and can compete with density functionals that contain multiple empirical parameters. Promising results for equilibrium bond lengths, harmonic vibrational frequencies, and vertical ionization potentials further underline the potential and flexibility of our approach.

Local and global interpolations along the adiabatic connection of DFT: a study at different correlation regimes

Interpolating the exchange-correlation energy along the density-fixed adiabatic connection of density functional theory is a promising way to build approximations that are not biased toward the weakly correlated regime. These interpolations can be performed at the global (integrated over all spaces) or at the local level, using energy densities. Many features of the relevant energy densities as well as several different ways to construct these interpolations, including comparisons between global and local variants, are investigated here for the analytically solvable Hooke's atom series, which allows for an exploration of different correlation regimes. We also analyze different ways to define the correlation kinetic energy density, focusing on the peak in the kinetic correlation potential.

Restoring Size Consistency of Approximate Functionals Constructed from the Adiabatic Connection

Approximate exchange-correlation functionals built by modeling in a nonlinear way the adiabatic connection (AC) integrand of density functional theory have many attractive features, being virtually parameter-free and satisfying different exact properties, but they also have a fundamental flaw: they violate the size-consistency condition, crucial to evaluate interaction energies of molecular systems. We show that size consistency in the AC-based functionals can be restored in a very simple way at no extra computational cost. Results on a large set of benchmark molecular interaction energies show that functionals based on the interaction strength interpolation approximations are significantly more accurate than second-order perturbation theory.

Hartree and Exchange in Ensemble Density Functional Theory: Avoiding the Nonuniqueness Disaster

Ensemble density functional theory is a promising method for the efficient and accurate calculation of excitations of quantum systems, at least if useful functionals can be developed to broaden its domain of practical applicability. Here, we introduce a guaranteed single-valued "Hartree-exchange" ensemble density functional, E_{Hx}[n], in terms of the right derivative of the universal ensemble density functional with respect to the coupling constant at vanishing interaction. We show that E_{Hx}[n] is straightforwardly expressible using block eigenvalues of a simple matrix [Eq. (14)]. Specialized expressions for E_{Hx}[n] from the literature, including those involving superpositions of Slater determinants, can now be regarded as originating from the unifying picture presented here. We thus establish a clear and practical description for Hartree and exchange in ensemble systems.

A Diagonally Updated Limited-Memory Quasi-Newton Method for the Weighted Density Approximation

We propose a limited-memory quasi-Newton method using the bad Broyden update and apply it to the nonlinear equations that must be solved to determine the effective Fermi momentum in the weighted density approximation for the exchange energy density functional. This algorithm has advantages for nonlinear systems of equations with diagonally dominant Jacobians, because it is easy to generalize the method to allow for periodic updates of the diagonal of the Jacobian. Systematic tests of the method for atoms show that one can determine the effective Fermi momentum at thousands of points in less than fifteen iterations.

Exchange-Correlation Functionals via Local Interpolation along the Adiabatic Connection

The construction of density-functional approximations is explored by modeling the adiabatic connection locally, using energy densities defined in terms of the electrostatic potential of the exchange–correlation hole. These local models are more amenable to the construction of size-consistent approximations than their global counterparts. In this work we use accurate input local ingredients to assess the accuracy of a range of local interpolation models against accurate exchange–correlation energy densities. The importance of the strictly correlated electrons (SCE) functional describing the strong coupling limit is emphasized, enabling the corresponding interpolated functionals to treat strong correlation effects. In addition to exploring the performance of such models numerically for the helium and beryllium isoelectronic series and the dissociation of the hydrogen molecule, an approximate analytic model is presented for the initial slope of the local adiabatic connection. Comparisons are made with approaches based on global models, and prospects for future approximations based on the local adiabatic connection are discussed.

Exchange-correlation energy from pairing matrix fluctuation and the particle-particle random phase approximation

Despite their unmatched success for many applications, commonly used local, semi-local, and hybrid density functionals still face challenges when it comes to describing long-range interactions, static correlation, and electron delocalization. Density functionals of both the occupied and virtual orbitals are able to address these problems. The particle-hole (ph-) Random Phase Approximation (RPA), a functional of occupied and virtual orbitals, has recently known a revival within the density functional theory community. Following up on an idea introduced in our recent communication [H. van Aggelen, Y. Yang, and W. Yang, Phys. Rev. A 88, 030501 (2013)], we formulate more general adiabatic connections for the correlation energy in terms of pairing matrix fluctuations described by the particle-particle (pp-) propagator. With numerical examples of the pp-RPA, the lowest-order approximation to the pp-propagator, we illustrate the potential of density functional approximations based on pairing matrix fluctuations. The pp-RPA is size-extensive, self-interaction free, fully anti-symmetric, describes the strong static correlation limit in H2, and eliminates delocalization errors in H2(+) and other single-bond systems. It gives surprisingly good non-bonded interaction energies--competitive with the ph-RPA--with the correct R(-6) asymptotic decay as a function of the separation R, which we argue is mainly attributable to its correct second-order energy term. While the pp-RPA tends to underestimate absolute correlation energies, it gives good relative energies: much better atomization energies than the ph-RPA, as it has no tendency to underbind, and reaction energies of similar quality. The adiabatic connection in terms of pairing matrix fluctuation paves the way for promising new density functional approximations.

Charge density reconstitution from approximate exchange-correlation holes

The electronic charge density and the expectation of any monoelectronic operator can be reconstructed by a density-weighted integral of the exchange-correlation hole. This property can be used to test and improve approximate holes that are not spherically averaged. As an example, we test the Becke–Roussel exhange-hole model in its nonspherical formulation on small atoms, finding that it accurately reproduces the density in the core region, while missing some of the features of the valence and core-valence regions. The same test on the local-density approximation shows poor results, as expected.

Potential-Driven Adiabatic Connection in Density Functional Theory

As density functional theory conventionally assumes that the density of a chosen model system (e.g., the Kohn-Sham system) is the same as the exact one, one might expect that approximations to the exact density introduce supplementary errors by falsifying the density. In fact, this is not true: by modeling the exchange-correlation holes for all densities, density functional approximations avoid this problem. The technique used to show it is a potential-driven adiabatic connection which hopefully will also permit constructing new approximations in the spirit of DFT.

Electronic Zero-Point Oscillations in the Strong-Interaction Limit of Density Functional Theory

The exchange-correlation energy in Kohn-Sham density functional theory can be expressed exactly in terms of the change in the expectation of the electron-electron repulsion operator when, in the many-electron Hamiltonian, this same operator is multiplied by a real parameter λ varying between 0 (Kohn-Sham system) and 1 (physical system). In this process, usually called adiabatic connection, the one-electron density is kept fixed by a suitable local one-body potential. The strong-interaction limit of density functional theory, defined as the limit λ→∞, turns out to be like the opposite noninteracting Kohn-Sham limit (λ→0) mathematically simpler than the physical (λ = 1) case and can be used to build an approximate interpolation formula between λ→0 and λ→∞ for the exchange-correlation energy. Here we extend the systematic treatment of the λ→∞ limit [Phys. Rev. A 2007, 75, 042511] to the next leading term, describing zero-point oscillations of strictly correlated electrons, with numerical examples for small spherical atoms. We also propose an improved approximate functional for the zero-point term and a revised interpolation formula for the exchange-correlation energy satisfying more exact constraints.