Oligonucleotide trapping method for transcription factor purification systematic optimization using electrophoretic mobility shift assay

A genetic biosensor for identification of transcriptional repressors of target promoters

Transcriptional repressors provide widespread biological significance in the regulation of gene expression. However, in prokaryotes, it is particularly difficult to find transcriptional repressors that recognize specific target promoters on genome-scale. To address this need, a genetic biosensor for identifying repressors of target promoters was developed in Escherichia coli from a de novo designed genetic circuit. This circuit can convert the negative input of repressors into positive output of reporters, thereby facilitating the selection and identification of repressors. After evaluating the sensitivity and bias, the biosensor was used to identify the repressors of scbA and aco promoters (PscbA and Paco), which control the transcription of signalling molecule synthase genes in Streptomyces coelicolor and Streptomyces avermitilis, respectively. Two previously unknown repressors of PscbA were identified from a library of TetR family regulators in S. coelicolor, and three novel repressors of Paco were identified from a genomic library of S. avermitilis. Further in vivo and in vitro experiments confirmed that these newly identified repressors attenuated the transcription of their target promoters by direct binding. Overall, the genetic biosensor developed here presents an innovative and powerful strategy that could be applied for identifying genome-wide unknown repressors of promoters in bacteria.

Purification and characterization of transcription factors

Transcription factors (TFs) are essential for the expression of all proteins, including those involved in human health and disease. However, TFs are resistant to proteomic characterization because they are frequently masked by more abundant proteins due to the limited dynamic range of capillary liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry and protein database searching. Purification methods, particularly strategies that exploit the high affinity of TFs for DNA response elements (REs) on gene promoters, can enrich TFs prior to proteomic analysis to improve dynamic range and penetrance of the TF proteome. For example, trapping of TF complexes specific for particular REs has been achieved by recovering the element DNA-protein complex on solid supports. Additional methods for improving dynamic range include two- and three-dimensional gel electrophoresis incorporating electrophoretic mobility shift assays and Southwestern blotting for detection. Here we review methods for TF purification and characterization. We fully expect that future investigations will apply these and other methods to illuminate this important but challenging proteome.

Proteomic methodologies to study transcription factor function

Transcription factors regulate transcription by binding to regulatory regions of genes including the promoter. Few of the transcription factors are well characterized, and few promoters have been described in detail. New methods have been developed to improve both transcription factor and promoter characterization, some of which are discussed here. Trapping methodology applicable to both individual transcription factors and intact transcription complexes are described, as well as 2D gel electrophoresis, Southwestern blotting, and basic liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry methodology. These methods have proved useful in the study of transcriptional regulation.

Transcription factor proteomics: identification by a novel gel mobility shift-three-dimensional electrophoresis method coupled with southwestern blot and high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray-mass spectrometry analysis

Transcription factor (TF) purification and identification is an important step in elucidating gene regulatory mechanisms. In this study, we present two new electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA)-based multi-dimensional electrophoresis approaches to isolate and characterize TFs, using detection with either southwestern or western blotting and HPLC-nanoESI-MS/MS analysis for identification. These new techniques involve several major steps. First, EMSA is performed with agents that diminish non-specific DNA-binding and the DNA-protein complex is separated by native PAGE gel. The gel is then electrotransferred to PVDF membrane and visualized by autoradiography. Next, the DNA-protein complex, which has been transferred onto the blot, is extracted using a detergent-containing elution buffer. Following detergent removal, concentrated extract is separated by SDS-PAGE (EMSA-2DE), followed by in-gel trypsin digestion and HPLC-nanoESI-MS/MS analysis, or the concentrated extract is separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (EMSA-3DE), followed by southwestern or western blot analysis to localize DNA binding proteins on blot which are further identified by on-blot trypsin digestion and HPLC-nanoESI-MS/MS analysis. Finally, the identified DNA binding proteins are further validated by EMSA-immunoblotting or EMSA antibody supershift assay. This approach is used to purify and identify GFP-C/EBP fusion protein from bacterial crude extract, as well as purifying AP1 and CEBP DNA binding proteins from a human embryonic kidney cell line (HEK293) nuclear extract. AP1 components, c-Jun, Jun-D, c-Fos, CREB, ATF1 and ATF2 were successfully identified from 1.5 mg of nuclear extract (equivalent to 3×10(7) HEK293 cells) with AP1 binding activity of 750 fmol. In conclusion, this new strategy of combining EMSA with additional dimensions of electrophoresis and using southwestern blotting for detection proves to be a valuable approach in the identification of transcriptional complexes by proteomic methods.

Purification and identification of a transcription factor, USF-2, binding to E-box element in the promoter of human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT)

Controversy remains about the identity of the transcription factor(s) (TFs), which bind to the two E-box elements (CACGTG, proximal and distal) of the human telomerase (hTERT) gene promoter, the essential elements in the regulation of telomerase. Here, systematic oligonucleotide trapping supplemented with 2-DE and proteomic methods was used to identify E-box binding TFs. Although insufficient purity was obtained from the proximal E-box element trapping, further fractionation provided by 2-DE and specific identification from Southwestern blotting analysis allow us to clearly identify an E-box binding TF. The protein spot was cut from 2-DE and in-gel digested with trypsin for LC-nanospray ESI-MS/MS analysis. This identified upstream stimulatory factor 2 (USF2). Western blotting analysis with specific antibodies clearly shows USF2 present in the purified fraction and USF2 antibody supershifts the specific DNA-binding complex on non-denaturing gels. Furthermore, a novel method was developed in which the specific DNA-TF complex was separated on a non-denaturing gel, the band was cut and applied to SDS-PAGE for a second dimension. Western blots of this second gel also confirmed the presence of USF2.

Methods for proteomic analysis of transcription factors

Investigation of the transcription factor (TF) proteome presents challenges including the large number of low abundance and post-translationally modified proteins involved. Specialized purification and analysis methods have been developed over the last decades which facilitate the study of the TF proteome and these are reviewed here. Generally applicable proteomics methods that have been successfully applied are also discussed. TFs are selectively purified by affinity techniques using the DNA response element (RE) as the basis for highly specific binding, and several agents have been discovered that either enhance binding or diminish non-specific binding. One such affinity method called "trapping" enables purification of TFs bound to nM concentrations and recovery of TF complexes in a highly purified state. The electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) is the most important assay of TFs because it provides both measures of the affinity and amount of the TF present. Southwestern (SW) blotting and DNA-protein crosslinking (DPC) allow in vitro estimates of DNA-binding-protein mass, while chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) allows confirmation of promoter binding in vivo. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis methods (2-DE), and 3-DE methods which combines EMSA with 2-DE, allow further resolution of TFs. The synergy of highly selective purification and analytical strategies has led to an explosion of knowledge about the TF proteome and the proteomes of other DNA- and RNA-binding proteins.

Two-dimensional southwestern blotting and characterization of transcription factors on-blot

Two-dimensional Southwestern blotting (2D-SW) described here combines several steps. Proteins are separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and transferred to nitrocellulose (NC) or polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membrane. The blotted proteins are then partially renatured and probed with a specific radiolabeled oligonucleotide for Southwestern blotting (SW) analysis. The detected proteins are then processed by on-blot digestion and identified by LC-MS/MS analysis. A transcription factor, bound by a specific radiolabeled element, is thus characterized without aligning with protein spots on a gel. In this study, we systematically optimize conditions for 2D-SW and on-blot digestion. By quantifying the SW signal using a scintillation counter, the optimal conditions for SW were determined to be PVDF membrane, 0.5% PVP40 for membrane blocking, serial dilution of guanidine HCl for denaturing and renaturing proteins on the blot, and an SDS stripping buffer to remove radiation from the blot. By the quantification of the peptide yields using nano-ESI-MS analysis, the optimized conditions for on-blot digestions were found to be 0.5% Zwittergent 3-16 and 30% acetonitrile in trypsin digestion buffer. With the use of the optimized 2D-SW technique and on-blot digestion combined with HPLC-nano-ESI-MS/MS, a GFP-C/EBP model protein was successfully characterized from a bacterial extract, and native C/EBP beta was identified from 100 microg of HEK293 nuclear extract without any previous purification.

Enhancement of lipid production using biochemical, genetic and transcription factor engineering approaches

This paper compares three possible strategies for enhanced lipid overproduction in microalgae: the biochemical engineering (BE) approaches, the genetic engineering (GE) approaches, and the transcription factor engineering (TFE) approaches. The BE strategy relies on creating a physiological stress such as nutrient-starvation or high salinity to channel metabolic fluxes to lipid accumulation. The GE strategy exploits our understanding to the lipid metabolic pathway, especially the rate-limiting enzymes, to create a channelling of metabolites to lipid biosynthesis by overexpressing one or more key enzymes in recombinant microalgal strains. The TFE strategy is an emerging technology aiming at enhancing the production of a particular metabolite by means of overexpressing TFs regulating the metabolic pathways involved in the accumulation of target metabolites. Currently, BE approaches are the most established in microalgal lipid production. The TFE is a very promising strategy because it may avoid the inhibitive effects of the BE approaches and the limitation of "secondary bottlenecks" as commonly observed in the GE approaches. However, it is still a novel concept to be investigated systematically.

SurR: a transcriptional activator and repressor controlling hydrogen and elemental sulphur metabolism in Pyrococcus furiosus

This work describes the identification and characterization of SurR, Pyrococcus furiosus sulphur (S(0)) response regulator. SurR was captured from cell extract using promoter DNA of a hydrogenase operon that is downregulated in the primary response of P. furiosus to S(0), as revealed by DNA microarray experiments. SurR was validated as a sequence-specific DNA binding protein, and characterization of the SurR DNA binding motif GTTn(3)AAC led to the identification of several target genes that contain an extended motif in their promoters. A number of these were validated to contain upstream SurR binding sites. These SurR targets strongly correspond with open reading frames and operons both up- and downregulated in the primary response to S(0). In vitro transcription revealed that SurR is an activator for its own gene as well as for two hydrogenase operons whose expression is downregulated during the primary S(0) response; it is also a repressor for two genes upregulated during the primary S(0) response, one of which encodes the primary S(0)-reducing enzyme NAD(P)H sulphur reductase. Herein we give evidence for the role of SurR in both mediating the primary response to S(0) and controlling hydrogen production in P. furiosus.

Purification and identification of positive regulators binding to a novel element in the c-Jun promoter

A putative response element, GAGCCTC, was observed years ago in footprinting analysis of the c-jun promoter, and here we investigate its function in regulating c-jun expression and identify a protein complex that binds there. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays demonstrate a sequence-specific binding complex with this element in HEK293 cells. Additionally, unlabeled consensus AP-1 element DNA, but not a similar NF-jun element DNA, competes with complex formation. Mutations of this element decrease c-jun promoter reporter activity by nearly 5-fold in HEK293 cells. A new, two-step oligonucleotide trapping technique was developed to purify the element binding proteins. LC-nanospray-ESI-MS/MS identification and Western blotting show that the purified complex contains Ku80 and c-jun, which was further confirmed by antibody supershift, by immunoprecipitation with Southwestern blot or with UV cross-linking analysis in vitro as well as chromatin immunoprecipitation in vivo. c-Jun promoter activity and c-jun expression were decreased by Ku80 siRNA introduction. A mutant Ku80 plasmid with normal amino acid sequence but immune to the siRNA recovers c-jun promoter activity from siRNA inhibition. Similarly, Ku70 wild type transfection can also upregulate c-jun promoter activity. Thus, Ku80-c-jun activates c-jun expression by binding to this GAGCCTC element in the c-jun promoter and Ku70 may also serve a role.

Trapping of transcription factors with symmetrical DNA using thiol-disulfide exchange chemistry

Green fluorescent protein (GFP) fused to the C-terminal 100 amino acids of CAAT enhancer binding protein (C/EBP) also containing an N-terminal (His)(6) tag (GFP-C/EBP) was used as a transcription factor model to test whether thiol-disulfide exchange reactions could be used to successfully purify transcription factors. A symmetrical dithiol oligonucleotide with dual CAAT elements was constructed with 5' and 3' thiols. Upon reduction, circular dichroism confirms it spontaneously anneals with its internally complementary sequence to form the hairpin structure: 5'-HS-GCAGATTGCGCAATCTGC 3'-HS-CGTCTAACGCGTTAGACG The specific GFP-C/EBP protein-DNA complex, formed in solution at nM concentrations, could then be recovered (trapped) via thiol-disulfide exchange with a disulfide thiopropyl-Sepharose and eluted with dithiothreitol. GFP-C/EBP was isolated from crude bacterial extract treated with iodoacetamide; DNA binding by GFP-C/EBP was unaltered by carboxyamidomethylation. Eluted GFP-C/EBP was of high purity by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). The protein, after in-gel digestion with trypsin, was also characterized by capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography-nano-electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry and the results analyzed using MASCOT software searching of the non-redundant protein database. A score of 1874 with a sequence coverage of 51% encompassing both termini and internal sequences for the match with GFP-C/EBP confirms its identity and sequence. The method has high potential for the identification and characterization of transcription factors and other DNA-binding proteins.

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis for identifying proteins that bind DNA or RNA

Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs) are commonly used to analyze nucleic acid-protein interactions. When nucleic acid is bound by protein, its mobility during gel electrophoresis is reduced. Similarly, the final position of protein within a complex is shifted when compared to its free state. Here we provide a protocol for a simple approach that uses these mobility differences to identify nucleic acid-binding proteins. Following EMSA, denaturing gel electrophoresis is implemented to provide a second dimension of separation. Protein that binds a specific nucleic acid is identified as a spot(s) whose presence at a particular position(s) is dependent on nucleic acid within the initial binding reaction. The polypeptide in a spot can be subsequently identified by mass spectrometry. As EMSAs can be performed using partially purified or cell extracts, this approach substantially reduces the need for protein purification. It should facilitate the identification of a nucleic acid-binding protein within approximately 4 d.

Cyanogen bromide-activated coupling: DNA catalytic chromatography purification of EcoRI endonuclease

A method to purify enzymes utilizing their specific biological affinity and catalytic specificity is described. For this chromatographic technique, an enzyme binds immobilized substrate coupled to a column in the absence of a cofactor required for catalysis but permissive for substrate binding. After washing, the missing cofactor is added to the column mobile phase, and the enzyme converts substrate into product and elutes from the column. A single-step purification of EcoRI endonuclease using a sequence-specific DNA column (containing the GAATTC motif coupled to cyanogen bromide-activated Sepharose 4B) binds EcoRI in the absence of Mg2+ and elutes when Mg2+ is applied in a highly purified state. Although the method described is specific for EcoRI, it can be readily modified for the purification of DNA polymerases and other enzymes. Furthermore, many of the same materials are also used for transcription factor purification. This protocol can be completed within 4-6 d.

Promoter trapping of c-jun promoter-binding transcription factors

A new method called promoter trapping was developed to purify promoter-protein complex using the c-jun promoter (-200+81) as a model, which was shown to have significant promoter activity. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR), lambda exonuclease digestion combined with (AC)(5)-Sepharose DNA affinity chromatography were used to produce c-jun promoter with a (GT)(5) tail at each 3' end. The intact promoter and different length pieces with one or two (GT)(5) tails had almost the same capacity to bind with (AC)(5)-Sepharose. In solution, tailed c-jun promoter (60 nM) and competitor poly dI:dC (30 ng/microl) was incubated with crude HEK293 nuclear extract to form a large protein-promoter complex, and the complex was then trapped by (AC)(5)-Sepharose by centrifugation or on a column. Compared with a popular alternative method, called here the immobilized promoter method, the products of promoter trapping were purer. The preinitiation complex purified by promoter trapping had the expected components including RNA polymerase II, TATA-box binding protein (TBP), TFIIF subunit RAP74, and transcription factor SP1, and transcribed RNA in vitro. Thus, the promoter trapping approach provides a useful tool for the purification and investigation of transcription complexes.