Mitigation of arsenic toxicity and accumulation in hydroponically grown rice seedlings by co-inoculation with arsenite-oxidizing and cadmium-tolerant bacteria

Remediation of isoproturon-contaminated soil by Sphingobium sp. strain YBL2: Bioaugmentation, detoxification and community structure

The widely used phenylurea herbicide isoproturon (IPU) and its residues can inhibit the growth of subsequently planted crops. However, reports on bioremediation of IPU-contaminated soil are scarce. In this study, Sphingobium sp. strain YBL2-gfp (a derivative of the IPU-degrading Sphingobium sp. strain YBL2 isolated by our lab) was constructed to bioremediate IPU-contaminated soil. In pot experiments, strain YBL2-gfp colonized the roots of wheat and eliminated IPU residues in the soil within 21 d, effectively alleviating its toxicity and restoring wheat growth. IPU treatment reduced the richness and diversity of soil bacteria, while inoculation YBL2-gfp mainly affected richness with less impact on diversity. The high concentrations of IPU and inoculation of YBL2-gfp alone reduced the soil microbial community connections, while bioaugmentation treatment enhanced the soil microbial community connections. Additionally, strain YBL2-gfp stimulated the metabolic capacity of the indigenous microbes, promoting the degradation of IPU and reducing the negative impact of high concentrations of IPU on microbial community. Taken together, this study offers relatively comprehensive insights into the practical application of bioaugmentation, demonstrating that strain YBL2 has the potential to remediate IPU-contaminated soils.

As(III)-oxidizing and plant growth-promoting bacteria increase the starch biosynthesis-related enzyme activity, 2-AP levels, and grain quality of arsenic-stressed rice plants

BACKGROUND

Grain quality is an important index of rice production, particularly when plants are grown under stress. Arsenic (As) contamination in paddy fields severely affects rice grain yield and quality. Here, the effects of As and combinations of As(III)-oxidizing bacteria (Pseudomonas stutzeri 4.25, 4.27, and 4.44) and plant growth-promoting bacteria (Delftia acidovorans KKU2500-12 and Cupriavidus taiwanensis KKU2500-3) on enzymes related to starch accumulation in grains and the grain quality of Khao Dawk Mali 105 rice cultivated in As-contaminated soil under greenhouse conditions were investigated.

RESULTS

Arsenic affected the activities of starch biosynthesis-related enzymes, and decreases of up to 76.27%, 71.53%, 49.74%, 73.39%, and 47.46% in AGPase, SSS, GBSS, SBE, and SDBE activities, respectively, and 9.42-61.07% in starch accumulation in grains were detected after growth in As-contaminated soil. However, the KKU2500-3/4.25 and KKU2500-3/4.44 combinations yielded the greatest enzyme activities in grains, and compared with the results observed in uninoculated seedlings, increases in starch accumulation of up to 51.16% and 23.81% were found in the inoculated seedlings after growth in medium- and high-As-contaminated soils, at 10-17 and 10-24 days after anthesis, respectively. The bacteria increased the 2-AP content in rice under As stress, possibly via the induction of proline, a 2-AP substrate. Bacterium-inoculated rice had significantly greater 2-AP levels than uninoculated rice, and 2.16-9.93% and 26.57-42.04% increases were detected in rice plants grown in medium- and high-As-contaminated soils, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Arsenic toxicity can be mitigated in rice growing under greenhouse conditions by maintaining starch biosynthesis, accumulating amylose, and increasing 2-AP content. The effectiveness of these bacteria should be validated in paddy fields; hence, safe rice grains with a good starch content and aroma could be produced.

A meta-analysis on crop growth and heavy metals accumulation with PGPB inoculation in contaminated soils

Plant growth-promoting bacteria (PGPB) offer a promising solution for mitigating heavy metals (HMs) stress in crops, yet the mechanisms underlying the way they operate in the soil-plant system are not fully understood. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis with 2037 observations to quantitatively evaluate the effects and determinants of PGPB inoculation on crop growth and HMs accumulation in contaminated soils. We found that inoculation increased shoot and root biomass of all five crops (rice, maize, wheat, soybean, and sorghum) and decreased metal accumulation in rice and wheat shoots together with wheat roots. Key factors driving inoculation efficiency included soil organic matter (SOM) and the addition of exogenous fertilizers (N, P, and K). The phylum Proteobacteria was identified as the keystone taxa in effectively alleviating HMs stress in crops. More antioxidant enzyme activity, photosynthetic pigment, and nutrient absorption were induced by it. Overall, using PGPB inoculation improved the growth performance of all five crops, significantly increasing crop biomass in shoots, roots, and grains by 33 %, 35 %, and 20 %, respectively, while concurrently significantly decreasing heavy metal accumulation by 16 %, 9 %, and 37 %, respectively. These results are vital to grasping the benefits of PGPB and its future application in enhancing crop resistance to HMs.

As(III)-Oxidizing Bacteria Alleviate Arsenite Toxicity via Reducing As Accumulation, Elevating Antioxidative Activities and Modulating Ionome in Rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Paddy rice trends to accumulate more arsenic (As) from soils than other terrestrial crops. The toxicity and mobility of As mainly depend on its chemical species. Transformation of arsenite [As(III)] into arsenate [As(V)] would be a promising method to mitigate As toxicity. In the current study, As(III)-oxidizing strain SMS11 isolated from As-contaminated soils was employed for As remediation. Co-cultured with SMS11 alleviated As(III) stress to the rice plants by increasing the length and biomass of rice shoots up to 10% and 15%, respectively. Evaluation of oxidative stress indices showed that the activity of catalase in the rice shoots was weakened when exposed to As(III), increasing the risk of hydroxyl radical (·OH) formation. When co-cultivated with the bacteria, ·OH formation was significantly inhibited in the rice shoots. The ionomes of the rice plants were impacted by the external conditions. As(III) stress significantly disturbed ionome homeostasis in the rice plants. Uptake of As simultaneously elevated the levels of macro and nutrient elements such as Mg, P, K, Ca, and Zn in the rice shoots. The ionomic variation in the rice plants under As(III) stress was mitigated by inoculated with SMS11. The results represented that the As(III)-oxidizing bacteria alleviated external As(III) stress to the rice plants through elevating antioxidative activities and modulating ionome homeostasis.

The alleviating effects and underlying mechanisms of exogenous selenium on both Sb(III) and Sb(V) toxicity in rice seedlings (Oryza sativa L.)

Selenium (Se) has been used to detoxify various heavy metals in plants. However, the effects and underlying mechanisms of exogenous Se application on the toxicity of antimonite [Sb(III)] and antimonate [Sb(V)] in crops are still poorly understood. Therefore, the potential alleviating roles of Se on the plant growth, antioxidant system, uptake and subcellular distribution of Sb, and expression of Sb-related genes were comprehensively investigated in rice seedlings (Oryza sativa L.) under both Sb(III) and Sb(V) stress conditions. The results showed that high concentrations of Sb(III) (100 µM) and Sb(V) (300 µM) caused a significant decrease in plant growth parameters, photosynthetic pigments and relative water content in rice seedlings. In contrast, the addition of Se (20 or 2 µM) improved rice growth, decreased Sb accumulation, and reduced oxidative stress in rice seedlings when exposed to 100 µM Sb(III) and 300 µM Sb(V), respectively. Furthermore, Se application could effectively improve the physiological adaptability of rice seedlings under Sb(III) and Sb(V) stress by regulating enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidant systems, Sb subcellular distribution and transcription levels of Sb-related genes, including in antioxidant response (OsCuZnSOD2, OsCATA and OsGSH1), detoxification (OsPCS1, OsPCS2 and OsABCC1) and Sb transport and sequestration (OsLsi1 and OsWAK11). Moreover, we also discovered that the mitigation effect of Se was dose-dependent and depended on Sb valence states. Thus, these findings contribute to our understanding of the mechanisms underlying Se-Sb antagonism in rice, offering a potentially useful method for producing both safe and Se-rich crops.

Repeated inoculation of antimony resistant bacterium reduces antimony accumulation in rice plants

Applying beneficial bacteria in rice rhizosphere to manage heavy metal behaviour in soil-plant system is a promising strategy. However, colonization/domination of exogenous bacteria in rhizosphere soils remains a challenge. In this study, a bacterium Ochrobactrum anthropi, which showed the potential of transforming soluble Sb^III into Sb₂O₃ mineral, was repeatedly inoculated into the rice rhizosphere weekly throughout the rice growth period, and the colonization of this bacterium in rice rhizosphere soils and its effect on Sb accumulation in rice plants were investigated. Results showed that repeated inoculants changed the native bacterial community in rhizosphere soils in comparison with the control, but the inoculated O. anthropi was not identified as an abundant species. With weekly inoculation, the decrease in Sb in rice roots and straws was maintained throughout the rice growth period, with decrease percentages ranging from 36 to 49% and 33-35%. In addition, decrease percentages of Sb in husks and grains at the maturing stage obtained 34 and 37%, respectively. Furthermore, the XRD identified the formation of valentinite (Sb₂O₃) on rice root in inoculation treatment, and the decrease percentages in aqueous Sb^III in rhizosphere were 53-100% through the growth period. It demonstrated that weekly inoculants performed their temporary activity of valentinite formation, and reduced Sb accumulation in rice plants efficiently. This study suggests that regardless of successful colonization, repeated inoculation of beneficial bacteria is an option to facilitate the positive effects of inoculated bacteria in the management of heavy metal behaviour.

Arsenic (As) resistant bacteria with multiple plant growth-promoting traits: Potential to alleviate As toxicity and accumulation in rice

A currently serious agronomic concern for paddy soils is arsenic (As) contamination. Paddy soils are mostly utilized for rice cultivation. Arsenite (As(III)) is prevalent in paddy soils, and its high mobility and toxicity make As uptake by rice substantially greater than that by other food crops. Globally, interest has increased towards using As-resistant plant growth-promoting bacteria (PGPB) to improve plant metal tolerance, promote plant growth, and immobilize As to prevent its uptake and accumulation in the edible parts of rice as much as possible. This review focuses on the As-resistant PGPB characteristics influencing rice growth and the mechanisms by which they function to alleviate As toxicity stress in rice plants. Several recent examples of mechanisms responsible for decreasing the availability of As to rice and coping with As stresses facilitated by the PGPB with multiple PGP traits (e.g., phosphate and silicate solubilization, the production of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate deaminase, phytohormones, and siderophore, N₂ fixation, sulfate reduction, the biosorption, bioaccumulation, methylation, and volatilization of As, and arsenite oxidation) are also reviewed. In addition, future research needs about the application of As-resistant PGPB with PGP traits to mitigate As accumulation in rice plants are described.

Mitigation of arsenic toxicity in rice by the co-inoculation of arsenate reducer yeast with multifunctional arsenite oxidizing bacteria

The study aimed to explicate the role of microbial co-inoculants for the mitigation of arsenic (As) toxicity in rice. Arsenate (AsV) reducer yeast Debaryomyces hansenii NBRI-Sh2.11 (Sh2.11) with bacterial strains of different biotransformation potential was attempted to develop microbial co-inoculants. An experiment to test their efficacy (yeast and bacterial strains) on plant growth and As uptake was conducted under a stressed condition of 20 mg kg-1 of arsenite (AsIII). A combination of Sh2.11 with an As(III)-oxidizer, Citrobacter sp. NBRI-B5.12 (B5.12), resulted in ∼90% decrease in grain As content as compared to Sh2.11 alone (∼40%). Reduced As accumulation in rice roots under co-treated condition was validated with SEM-EDS analysis. Enhanced As expulsion in the selected combination under in vitro conditions was found to be correlated with higher As content in the soil during their interaction with plants. Selected co-inoculant mediated enhanced nutrient uptake in association with better production of indole acetic acid (IAA) and gibberellic acid (GA) in shoot, support microbial co-inoculant mediated better biomass under stressful condition. Boosted defense response in association with enhanced glutathione-S-transferase (GST) and glutathione reductase (GR), activities under in vitro and in vivo conditions were observed. These results indicated that the As(III) oxidizer-B5.12 accelerated the As detoxification property of the As(V) reducer-Sh2.11. Henceforth, the results confer that the coupled reduction-oxidation process of the co-inoculant reduces the accumulation of As in rice grain. These co-inoculants can be further developed for field trials to achieve higher biomass with alleviated As toxicity in rice.

As(III) oxidation and kinetic analysis by Herminiimonas arsenicoxydans-loaded electrospinning activated carbon fiber biofilms

In this study, an integrated and assembled recyclable biofilm material was prepared by loading Herminiimonas arsenicoxydans (H. arsenicoxydans) onto electrospun biomass-activated carbon nanofibers (denoted as H. arsenicoxydans-BACFs films). The H. arsenicoxydans-BACFs biofilms showed an approximately 50% increase in As(III) removal rate for 50 mg/L during a 48-h incubation. Furthermore, the biofilms demonstrated satisfactory biocompatibility, ideal catalytic As(III) oxidation and excellent recyclability in cyclic reactions (at least 5 runs). The improved catalytic efficiency is mainly due to a large amount of biomass accumulation and biofilms formation on the surface of the BACF films. More important, the BACF films as an electron transport medium from an oxidized state to a reduced state promote the electron transfer of As(III) oxidation of H. arsenicoxydans. The dual factors can synergistically promote As(III) oxidation efficiency. The oxidation process of As(III) in the H. arsenicoxydans-BACFs composite biofilm reactor was more in line with the first-order kinetic equation, and the oxidation rate of As(III) by H. arsenicoxydans-BACF_0.4 was the fastest. The H. arsenicoxydans-BACF films outperformed conventional catalytic materials and could represent biomaterials for the remediation of As(III)-contaminated wastewater.

A cadmium-tolerant endophytic bacterium reduces oxidative stress and Cd uptake in KDML105 rice seedlings by inducing glutathione reductase-related activity and increasing the proline content

The effect of the endophytic Cupriavidus taiwanensis KKU2500-3 on the Cd toxicity of KDML105 rice seedlings was investigated in a 10 μM CdCl2 hydroponic system. As demonstrated after bacterial inoculation of germinating rice seeds, KKU2500-3 colonized all rice plant parts. In RB (Rice + KKU2500-3) and RBC (Rice + KKU2500-3+Cd), KKU2500-3 effectively colonized and was detected at a markedly higher number in the root surface and interior than in shoots and leaves. The activities of antioxidant enzymes ascorbate peroxidase (APOX), glutathione reductase (GR), and superoxide dismutase (SOD) and the proline content in inoculated rice were higher in roots and aboveground tissues. RBC exhibited a higher reduced-to-oxidized glutathione ratio in roots and leaves (3-55%) but a lower malondialdehyde content (8-78%). Phytochelatins (PCs) were detected in all rice tissues, but their levels in RBC were 13-70% lower than those in RC (Rice + Cd), demonstrating that the induction of PCs in rice was unrelated to KKU2500-3. The Cd levels in roots and shoots were lower in RBC than RC, and the root-to-shoot Cd translocation factor was 0.6-62.2% lower. At 30 DAT, the Cd levels in RBC roots and shoots were 30.2% and 73.7% lower, respectively, than those in RC. Colonized KKU2500-3 activated GR and increased the proline content to overcome rice Cd toxicity. These effects may trap Cd in plant cells and reduce its translocation. Hence, KKU2500-3 synergistically interacts with rice to detoxify Cd at early growth stages, and KDML105 rice grains with low Cd accumulation could be produced if this interaction is maintained until late growth stages.

Responses to arsenic stress of rice varieties coinoculated with the heavy metal-resistant and rice growth-promoting bacteria Pseudomonas stutzeri and Cupriavidus taiwanensis

Arsenic (As)-contaminated rice paddy fields are spreading globally, and thus, rice grains with low As accumulation at a safe level for consumption is profoundly needed. Rice is highly susceptible to As accumulation, and the responses to As vary among rice varieties. Here, combinations of the As^III-oxidizing bacteria Pseudomonas stutzeri strains 4.25, 4.27, or 4.44 and Cupriavidus taiwanensis KKU2500-3 were investigated with respect to their responses to As toxicity and rice growth promotion during the early growth stage. All bacterial strains enhanced antioxidant enzyme activities, including SOD, CAT, APX, GPX, and GR, under As stress in vitro. Uninoculated and coinoculated rice seedlings of three rice varieties (KDML105, RD6, RD10) were cultivated in hydroponic solution without and with a combination of toxic As^III and less toxic As^V for 30 days. Compared with uninoculated seedlings, the inoculated seedlings showed higher growth parameters and lower As contents in roots, shoots and throughout the plants. The bioconcentration factor (BCF) and translocation factor were reduced in inoculated seedlings. The effective response of rice to As toxicity influenced by bacteria was highest in KDML105, followed by RD6 and RD10. The root sulfide content was correlated with As accumulation in roots, shoots, and total seedlings and the BCFs. P. stutzeri 4.44 and C. taiwanensis KKU2500-3 were the most promising combinations for application in KDML105 cultivation under As-contaminated conditions. Understanding the basic response of rice coinoculated with effective bacteria at the early stage will provide guidelines for rice cultivation under As conditions at other scales.

Arsenic: A Global Environmental Challenge

Arsenic is a naturally occurring metalloid and one of the few metals that can be metabolized inside the human body. The pervasive presence of arsenic in nature and anthropogenic sources from agricultural and medical use have perpetuated human exposure to this toxic and carcinogenic element. Highly exposed individuals are susceptible to various illnesses, including skin disorders; cognitive impairment; and cancers of the lung, liver, and kidneys. In fact, across the globe, approximately 200 million people are exposed to potentially toxic levels of arsenic, which has prompted substantial research and mitigation efforts to combat this extensive public health issue. This review provides an up-to-date look at arsenic-related challenges facing the global community, including current sources of arsenic, global disease burden, arsenic resistance, and shortcomings of ongoing mitigation measures, and discusses potential next steps.

Bioaugmentation with As-transforming bacteria improves arsenic availability and uptake by the hyperaccumulator plant Pteris vittata (L)

Inorganic arsenic (As) is a toxic and carcinogenic pollutant that has long-term impacts on environmental quality and human health. Pteris vittata plants hyperaccumulate As from soils. Soil bacteria are critical for As-uptake by P. vittata. We examined the use of taxonomically diverse soil bacteria to modulate As speciation in soil and their effect on As-uptake by P. vittata. Aqueous media inoculated with Pseudomonas putida MK800041, P. monteilii MK344656, P. plecoglossicida MK345459, Ochrobactrum intermedium MK346993 or Agrobacterium tumefaciens MK346997 resulted in the oxidation of 5-30% As(III) and a 49-79% reduction of As(V). Soil inoculated with P. monteilii increased extractable As(III) and As(V) from 0.5 and 0.09 in controls to 0.9 and 0.39 mg As kg^-1 soil dry weight, respectively. Moreover, and P. vittata plants inoculated with P. monteilii, P. plecoglossicida, O. intermedium strains, and A. tumefaciens strains MK344655, MK346994, MK346997, significantly increased As-uptake by 43, 32, 12, 18, 16, and 14%, respectively, compared to controls. The greatest As-accumulation (1.9 ± 0.04 g kg^-1 frond Dwt) and bioconcentration factor (16.3 ± 0.35) was achieved in plants inoculated with P. monteilii. Our findings indicate that the tested bacterial strains can increase As-availability in soils, thus enhancing As-accumulation by P. vittata. Novelty statement Pteris vittata, a well-known As-hyperaccumulator, has the remarkable ability to accumulate higher levels of As in their above-ground biomass. The As-tolerant bacteria-plant interactions play a significant role in bioremediation by mediating As-redox and controlling As-availability and uptake by P. vittata. Our studies indicated that most of the tested bacterial strains isolated from As-impacted soil significantly enhanced As-uptake by P. vittata. P. monteilii oxidized 20% of As(III) and reduced 50% of As(V), increased As-extraction from soils, and increased As-uptake by 43% greater compared with control. Therefore, these strains associated with P. vittata can be used in large-scale field applications to remediate As-contaminated soil.

Unraveling the heavy metal resistance and biocontrol potential of Pseudomonas sp. K32 strain facilitating rice seedling growth under Cd stress

Heavy metal and metalloid toxicity in agricultural land needs special attention for crop production essential to feed increasing population globally. Plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) are native biological agents that have tremendous potential to augment crop production in contaminated fields. This study involves selection and identification (through 16S rRNA gene sequence and FAME analysis) of a potent Pseudomonas sp. (strain K32) isolated from a metal-contaminated rice rhizosphere, aimed to its application for sustainable agriculture. Apart from multi-heavy metal(loid) resistance (Cd²⁺, Pb²⁺ and As³⁺ upto 4000, 3800, 3700 μg/ml respectively) along with remarkable Cd bioaccumulation potential (∼90%), this strain showed IAA production, nitrogen-fixation and phosphate solubilization under Cd stress. This bioaccumulation efficiency coupled with PGP traits resulted in the significant enhancement of rice seedling growth under Cd stress. This positive impact of K32 strain was clearly manifested in morphological and biochemical improvements under Cd stress including successful root colonization with rice roots. Cd uptake was also reduced significantly in seedlings in presence of K32 strain. Together with all mentioned properties, K32 showed bio-control potential against plant pathogenic fungi viz. Aspergillus flavus, Aspergillus parasiticus, Paecilomyces sp., Cladosporium herbarum, Rhizopus stolonifer and Alternaria alternata which establish K32 strain a key player in effective bioremediation of agricultural fields. Biocontrol potential was found to be the result of enzymatic activities viz. chitinase, β-1,3-glucanase and protease which were estimated as 8.17 ± 0.44, 4.38 ± 0.35 and 7.72 ± 0.28 U/mg protein respectively.

Arsenate-reducing bacteria affect As accumulation and tolerance in Salix atrocinerea

Arsenic (As)-reducing bacteria are able to influence As-speciation and, in this way, change As bio-availability. In consequence, this has an impact on As uptake by plants growing on polluted soil and on the effectiveness of the phytoremediation process. To be able to efficiently utilize these bacteria for As-phytoremediation in the field, a better understanding of the plant-bacterial interactions involved in As-tolerance or toxicity is needed. In this work, seedlings of a clone of Salix atrocinerea derived from a specimen naturally growing on an As-polluted brownfield were grown under gnotobiotic conditions exposed to As, and in the presence or absence of two of its field-associated and in vitro characterized plant growth-promoting (PGP) bacteria. The inoculation with Pantoea sp., induced a moderate reduction of AsV to AsIII in the exposure medium that, together with a coordinated plant response of As uptake, chelation and sequestration, increased As accumulation in roots; which is reflected into a higher phytostabilization. However, inoculation with Rhodococcus erythropolis due to a higher disproportionate reduction of AsV to AsIII in the medium caused less As accumulation in roots that non-bioaugmented plants and despite the lower As content, the concentrations of AsIII present in the medium and the damage suffered in roots and leaves, indicated that As tolerance mechanisms (such as prevention of AsIII uptake and efflux) did not occur in time to avoid physical disturbance and plants growth reduction. Interestingly, by two different metabolic pathways -coordinated by different key transporters mediating As uptake, tolerance, distribution and vacuolar accumulation at the roots- both bacteria limited As accumulation in Salix shoots. Our results provide for the first time a detailed insight in the plant-bacterial responses and physiological changes contributing to As tolerance in S. atrocinerea, that will facilitate the design of effective strategies for exploitation of plant-associated microorganisms for phytoremediation.

Inorganic arsenic toxicity and alleviation strategies in rice

Direct or indirect exposure to inorganic arsenic (iAs) in the forms of AsIII (arsenite) and AsV (arsenate) through consumption of As-contaminated food materials and drinking water leads to arsenic poisoning. Rice (Oryza sativa L.) plant potentially accumulates a high amount of iAs from paddy fields than any other cereal crops. This makes it to be a major source of iAs especially among the population that uses it as their dominant source of diet. The accumulation of As in human bodies poses a serious global health risk to the human population. Various conventional methods have been applied to reduce the arsenic accumulation in rice plant. However, the success rate of these techniques is low. Therefore, the development of efficient and effective methods aimed at lowering iAs toxicity is a very crucial public concern. With the current advancement in technology, new strategies aimed at addressing this concern are being developed and utilized in various parts of the world. In this review, we discuss the recent advances in the management of iAs in rice plants emphasizing the use of nanotechnology and biotechnology approaches. Also, the prospects and challenges facing these approaches are described.