Proposed local diagnostic reference levels in angiography and interventional neuroradiology and a preliminary analysis according to the complexity of the procedures

Effective and organ doses in patient undergoing interventional neuroradiology procedures: A multicentre study

PURPOSE

Radiation doses to adult patients submitted to cerebral angiography and intracranial aneurysms treatments were assessed by using DICOM Radiation Dose Structured Reports (RDSR) and Monte Carlo simulations. Conversion factors to estimate effective and organ doses from Kerma-Area Product (PKA) values were determined.

METHODS

77 cerebral procedures performed with five angiographic equipment installed in three Italian centres were analyzed. Local settings and acquisition protocols were considered. The geometrical, technical and dosimetric data of 16,244 irradiation events (13305 fluoroscopy, 2811 digital subtraction angiography, 128 cone-beam CT) were extracted from RDSRs by local dose monitoring systems and were input in MonteCarlo PCXMC software to calculate effective and organ doses. Finally, conversion factors to determine effective and organ doses from PKA were determined. Differences between centres were assessed through statistical analysis and accuracy of dose calculation method based on conversion factors was assessed through Bland-Altman analysis.

RESULTS

Large variations in PKA (14-561 Gycm2) and effective dose (1.2-73.5 mSv) were observed due to different degrees of complexity in the procedures and angiographic system technology. The most exposed organs were brain, salivary glands, oral mucosa, thyroid and skeleton. The study highlights the importance of recent technology in reducing patient exposure (about fourfold, even more in DSA). No statistically significant difference was observed in conversion factors between centres, except for some organs. A conversion factor of 0.09 ± 0.02 mSv/Gycm2 was obtained for effective dose.

CONCLUSIONS

Organ and effective doses were assessed for neuro-interventional procedures. Conversion factors for calculating effective and organ doses from PKA were provided.

Cumulative Effective Dose During Fluoroscopically Guided Interventions (FGI): Analysis of More Than 5000 FGIs in a Single European Center

BACKGROUND

The number of fluoroscopically guided interventions (FGI) has increased significantly over time. However, little attention has been paid to possible stochastic radiation effects. The aim of this retrospective study was to investigate the number of patients who received cumulative effective doses over 100 mSv during FGI procedures.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Five thousand five hundred and fifty four classified FGI procedures were included. Radiation dose data, retrieved from an in-house-dose-management system, was analysed. Effective doses and cumulative effective doses (CED) were calculated. Patients who received a CED > 100 mSv were identified. Radiology reports, patient age, imaging and clinical data of these patients were used to identify reasons for CED ≥ 100 mSv.

RESULTS

One Hundred and thirty two (41.1% female) of 3981 patients received a CED > 100 mSy, with a mean CED of 173.5 ± 84.5 mSv. Mean age at first intervention was 66.1 ± 11.7 years. 81 (61.4%) of 132 were older than 64 years, one patient was < 30 years. 110 patients received ≥ 100 mSv within one year (83.4%), through FGIs: EVAR, pelvic/mesenteric interventions (stent or embolization), hepatic interventions (chemoembolization, TIPSS), embolization of cerebral aneurysms or arterio-venous-malformations.

CONCLUSIONS

Substantial CED may occur in a small but not ignorable fraction of patients (~ 3%) undergoing FGIs. Approximately 2/3rd of patients may most likely not encounter radiation-related stochastic effects due to life-threatening diseases and age at first treatment > 65 years but 1/3rd may. Patients undergoing more than one FGI (77%) carry a higher risk of accumulating effective doses > 100 mSv. Remarkably, 23% received a mean CED 162.2 ± 72.3 mSv in a single procedure.

Radiation Dose and Fluoroscopy Time of Extracranial Carotid Artery Stenting : Elective vs. Emergency Treatment Including Combined Mechanical Thrombectomy in Tandem Occlusion

PURPOSE

Fluoroscopically guided endovascular carotid artery stenting (CAS) of extracranial carotid stenosis (ECS) is a reasonable alternative to carotid endarterectomy in selected patients. Diagnostic reference levels (DRL) for this common neurointervention have not yet been defined and respective literature data are sparse. We provide detailed dosimetrics for useful expansion of the DRL catalogue.

METHODS

A retrospective single-center study of patients undergoing CAS between 2013 and 2021. We analyzed dose area product (DAP) and fluoroscopy time considering the following parameters: indications for CAS, semielective/elective versus emergency including additional mechanical thrombectomy (MT) in extracranial/intracranial tandem occlusion, etiology of ECS (atherosclerotic vs. radiation-induced), periprocedural features, e.g., number of applied stents, percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) and MT maneuvers, and dose protocol. Local DRL was defined as 75% percentile of the DAP distribution.

RESULTS

A total of 102 patients were included (semielective/elective CAS n = 75, emergency CAS n = 8, CAS + MT n = 19). Total median DAP was 78.2 Gy cm2 (DRL 117 Gy cm2). Lowest and highest median dosimetry values were documented for semielective/elective CAS and CAS + MT (DAP 49.1 vs. 146.8 Gy cm2, fluoroscopy time 27.1 vs. 43.8 min; p < 0.005), respectively. Dosimetrics were significantly lower in patients undergoing 0-1 PTA maneuvers compared to ≥ 2 maneuvers (p < 0.05). Etiology of ECS, number of stents and MT maneuvers had no significant impact on dosimetry values (p > 0.05). A low-dose protocol yielded a 33% reduction of DAP.

CONCLUSION

This CAS study suggests novel local DRLs for both elective and emergency cases with or without intracranial MT. A dedicated low-dose protocol was suitable for substantial reduction of radiation dose.

Comparing Radiation Dose of Cerebral Angiography Using Conventional and High kV Techniques: A Retrospective Study on Intracranial Aneurysm Patients and a Phantom Study

Evaluation of patient radiation dose after the implementation of a high kV technique during a cerebral angiographic procedure is an important issue. This study aimed to determine and compare the patient radiation dose of intracranial aneurysm patients undergoing cerebral angiography using the conventional and high kV techniques in a retrospective study and a phantom study. A total of 122 cases (61 cases with conventional technique and 61 cases with high kV technique) of intracranial aneurysm patients, who underwent cerebral angiographic procedure and met the inclusion criteria, were recruited. The radiation dose and the angiographic exposure parameters were reviewed retrospectively. The radiation dose in the phantom study was conducted using nanoDot^TM optically stimulating luminescence (OSLD), which were placed on the scalp of the head phantom, the back of the neck, and the phantom skin at the position of the eyes. The standard cerebral angiographic procedure using the conventional and high kV techniques was performed following the standard protocol. The results showed that the high kV technique significantly reduced patient radiation dose and phantom skin dose. This study confirms that the implementation of a high kV technique in routine cerebral angiography for aneurysm diagnosis provides an effective reduction in radiation dose. Further investigation of radiation dose in other interventional neuroradiology procedures, particularly embolization procedure, should be performed.

Radiation dose and fluoroscopy time of aneurysm coiling in patients with unruptured and ruptured intracranial aneurysms as a function of aneurysm size, location, and patient age

PURPOSE

Endovascular treatment of unruptured intracranial aneurysms (UIAs) requires a risk-benefit analysis and adherence to diagnostic reference levels (DRLs). The national DRL (250 Gy·cm2) is only determined for intracranial aneurysm coiling in general, including ruptured intracranial aneurysms (RIAs). This study aims to investigate the dose in the treatment of UIAs and RIAs separately.

METHODS

In a retrospective study design, dose area product (DAP) and fluoroscopy time (FT) were assessed for all patients undergoing intracranial aneurysm coiling between 2010 and 2021. DRL was set as the 75th percentile of the dose distribution. A multivariable linear regression analysis was performed to investigate DAP and FT for the two groups, UIA and RIA adjusted for patient age, aneurysm size, and location.

RESULTS

583 (414 females, mean age 56.5 years, 311 UIAs) are included. In the overall population, DAP (median (IQR)) is 157 Gy·cm2 (108-217) with a median FT of 32.7 min (IQR 24.0-47.0). Local DRL is 183 Gy·cm2 for UIAs and 246 Gy·cm2 for RIAs. After adjustment for the other variables, the UIA and RIA groups have a significant effect on both DAP (p < 0.001; 95% CI - 68.432 - - 38.040) and FT (p < 0.001; 95% CI - 628.279 - - 291.254). In general, both DAP and FT increase significantly with patient age and aneurysm size, whereas the location of the aneurysm did not significantly change neither DAP (p = 0.171; 95% CI - 5.537-31.065) nor FT (p = 0.136; 95% CI - 357.391-48.508).

CONCLUSION

Both aneurysm size and patient age were associated with increased DAP, whereas aneurysm location did not significantly change DAP or FT. The increased dose in patients with RIAs is likely equivalent to additional diagnostic cerebral four-vessel angiography performed in this group.

Typical doses and typical values for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures

To implement typical doses (TD) and typical values (TV) for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures. A total of 3811 fluoroscopic procedures performed within 34 months on three devices were included in this retrospective study. Dose-, patient- and procedure-related information were extracted using the institutional dose management system (DMS). TD/TV were defined as median dose and calculated for the five most frequent procedures per device for dose area product (DAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK) and fluoroscopy time (FT). National diagnostic reference levels and other single facility studies were compared to our results. Additionally, the five procedures with the highest doses of each device were analysed. To evaluate the data coverage of the DMS compared to the picture archiving and communication system (PACS), procedure lists were extracted from the PACS and compared to the procedure information extracted from the DMS. TD/TV for 15 procedures were implemented. Among all devices, TD for DAP ranged between 0.6 Gycm²for port catheter control (n= 64) and 145.9 Gycm²for transarterial chemoembolisation (n= 84). TD for CAK ranged between 5 mGy for port catheter control and 1397 mGy for aneurysm treatment (n= 129) and TV for FT ranged between 0.3 min for upper cavography (n= 67) and 51.4 min for aneurysm treatment. TD for DAP and CAK were lower or within the range of other single facility studies. The five procedures with the highest median DAP per device were identified, 6 of 15 procedures were also found to be among the most frequent procedures. Data coverage of the DMS compared to the PACS ranged between 71% (device 2, stroke treatment) and 78% (device 1, lower limb angiography) for the most common procedure per device. Thus, in 22%-29% of cases dose data of the performed procedure was not transferred into the DMS. We implemented TD/TV for fluoroscopic diagnostic and interventional procedures which enable a comprehensive dose analysis and comparison with previously published values.

Low-Dose Three-Dimensional Rotational Angiography for Evaluating Intracranial Aneurysms: Analysis of Image Quality and Radiation Dose

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the image quality and dose reduction of low-dose three-dimensional (3D) rotational angiography (RA) for evaluating intracranial aneurysms.

Materials and Methods

We retrospectively evaluated the clinical data and 3D RA datasets obtained from 146 prospectively registered patients (male:female, 46:100; median age, 58 years; range, 19–81 years). The subjective image quality of 79 examinations obtained from a conventional method and 67 examinations obtained from a low-dose (5-seconds and 0.10-µGy/frame) method was assessed by two neurointerventionists using a 3-point scale for four evaluation criteria. The total image quality score was then obtained as the average of the four scores. The image quality scores were compared between the two methods using a noninferiority statistical testing, with a margin of -0.2 (i.e., score of low-dose group – score of conventional group). For the evaluation of dose reduction, dose-area product (DAP) and air kerma (AK) were analyzed and compared between the two groups.

Results

The mean total image quality score ± standard deviation of the 3D RA was 2.97 ± 0.17 by reader 1 and 2.95 ± 0.20 by reader 2 for conventional group and 2.92 ± 0.30 and 2.95 ± 0.22, respectively, for low-dose group. The image quality of the 3D RA in the low-dose group was not inferior to that of the conventional group according to the total image quality score as well as individual scores for the four criteria in both readers. The mean DAP and AK per rotation were 5.87 Gy-cm² and 0.56 Gy, respectively, in the conventional group, and 1.32 Gy-cm² (p < 0.001) and 0.17 Gy (p < 0.001), respectively, in the low-dose group.

Conclusion

Low-dose 3D RA was not inferior in image quality and reduced the radiation dose by 70%–77% compared to the conventional 3D RA in evaluating intracranial aneurysms.

Diagnostic reference levels for fluoroscopically guided procedures in a South African tertiary hospital

BACKGROUND

The burgeoning usage and complexity of fluoroscopically guided procedures (FGPs) contribute to extended examination times and increased risk of adverse radiation effects. Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) play a pivotal role in dose optimization. There are limited DRL data for FGPs in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).

PURPOSE

To determine local DRLs (LDRLs) for common FGPs in the South African (SA) context and compare these with published international data.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A three-year, retrospective study of the 15 most frequently performed FGPs at a SA institution. For each procedure, the 50th and 75th percentiles of kerma area product (KAP), reference point air kerma (K_a,r), and fluoroscopy time data were derived. Published international FGP DRL data were collated and compared with the 75th percentiles of local institutional dosage parameters.

RESULTS

The commonest FGPs were aorto-bifemoral diagnostic angiography (n = 590), aorto-bifemoral interventional angiography (n = 287), nephrostomy (n = 265), and bronchial arterial embolization (BAE) (n = 208). Selective abdominal vessel interventional angiography (KAP = 170 Gy . cm²; K_a,r = 877 mGy) recorded the highest LDRL dosages; BAE was the longest procedure (LDRL = 38 min). Nephrostomies achieved the lowest LDRLs across all parameters (KAP = 10 Gy . cm²; K_a,r = 63 mGy, fluoroscopy time = 4.3 min). All Tygerberg Hospital LDRLs with comprehensive comparable data were within or below published ranges.

CONCLUSION

This study advances international radiation protection initiatives, addresses the paucity of LMIC DRL data, demonstrates broad alignment of Tygerberg Hospital FGP practice with international norms and highlights areas for optimization of institutional practice.

Radiation Dose and Fluoroscopy Time of Endovascular Treatment in Patients with Intracranial Lateral Dural Arteriovenous Fistulae

Purpose

Intracranial lateral dural arteriovenous fistula (LDAVF) represents a specific subtype of cerebrovascular fistulae, harboring a potentially life-threatening risk of brain hemorrhage. Fluoroscopically guided endovascular embolization is the therapeutic gold standard. We provide detailed dosimetry data to suggest novel diagnostic reference levels (DRL).

Methods

Retrospective single-center study of LDAVFs treated between January 2014 and December 2019. Regarding dosimetry, the dose area product (DAP) and fluoroscopy time were analyzed for the following variables: Cognard scale grade, endovascular technique, angiographic outcome, and digital subtraction angiography (DSA) protocol.

Results

A total of 70 patients (19 female, median age 65 years) were included. Total median values for DAP and fluoroscopy time were 325 Gy cm² (25%/75% percentile: 245/414 Gy cm²) and 110 min (68/142min), respectively. Neither median DAP nor fluoroscopy time were significantly different when comparing low-grade with high-grade LDAVF (Cognard I + IIa versus IIb–V; p > 0.05, each). Transvenous coil embolization yielded the lowest dosimetry values, with significantly lower median values when compared to a combined transarterial/transvenous technique (DAP 290 Gy cm² versus 388 Gy cm², p = 0.031; fluoroscopy time 85 min versus 170 min, p = 0.016). A significant positive correlation was found between number of arterial feeders treated by liquid embolization and both DAP (r_s = 0.367; p = 0.010) and fluoroscopy time (rs = 0.295; p = 0.040). Complete LDAVF occlusion was associated with transvenous coiling (p = 0.001). A low-dose DSA protocol yielded a 20% reduction of DAP (p = 0.021).

Conclusion

This LDAVF study suggests several local DRLs which varied substantially dependent on the endovascular technique and DSA protocol.

High-Dose Fluoroscopically Guided Procedures in Patients: Radiation Management Recommendations for Interventionalists

The article is part of the series of articles on radiation protection. You can find further articles in the special section of the CVIR issue. In addition to the risks from fluoroscopic-guided interventional procedures of tissue injuries, recent studies have drawn attention to the risk of stochastic effects. Guidelines exist for preprocedural planning and radiation management during the procedure. The concept of a substantial radiation dose level (SRDL) is helpful for patient follow-up for tissue injury. The uncommon nature of tissue injuries requires the interventionalist to be responsible for follow-up of patients who receive substantial radiation doses. Dose management systems for recognizing and avoiding higher patient exposures have been introduced. The European Directive provides a legal framework and requirements for equipment, training, dose monitoring, recording and optimization that are helpful in radiation risk management.

Investigating the parameters that affect the radiation exposure and establishing typical values based on procedure complexity for cerebral angiography and brain aneurysm embolization

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to investigate the parameters that affect the radiation exposure and to establish typical values (TV) based on procedure complexity for cerebral angiography (CA) and brain aneurysm embolization (BAE).

METHODS

Clinical parameters and exposure data were retrospectively reviewed for 348 examinations performed between March 2016 and December 2019 at a single specialized neuroradiology center. TV were derived as the median value of the distribution of exposure parameters such as total air kerma area product (P_KA,T), air kerma at the patient entrance reference point, fluoroscopy time, and number of frames. A statistical analysis was conducted to investigate the exposure variability with patient's gender, number of treated vessels during CA and patient gender, aneurysm location and dimension, and treatment strategies during BAE.

RESULTS

Patient gender was associated with a significant increase in the exposure level for both CA and BAE. For CA, TV were in term of P_KA,T of 52 Gycm² for male vs. 28 Gycm² for female patients. For BAE, these were 113 Gycm² for male vs. 75 Gycm² for female patients. Exposure levels increased significantly with the number of treated vessels in CA. TV were 20 Gycm² for one vessel vs. 77 Gycm² for 5-6 vessels CA. For BAE, aneurysm location was also a key factor that affects the patient exposure. TV were 55 Gycm² for aneurysms grouped in location 1 vs. 105 Gycm² for those grouped in location 2.

CONCLUSION

Male gender, number of treated vessels, and aneurysm location are key parameters affecting patient exposure during CA and BAE procedures.

Feasibility of low-dose digital subtraction angiography protocols for the endovascular treatment of intracranial dural arteriovenous fistulas

BACKGROUND

Among neurointerventional procedures, the embolization of complex shunt lesions usually requires more radiation dose. We aimed to evaluate the procedural outcome and safety in using low-dose DSA protocols for intracranial dural arteriovenous fistula (AVF) embolization treatment.

METHODS

Between January 2014 and July 2018, 55 patients with dural AVFs who underwent endovascular treatment were included in the study. The low-dose group (n = 27) included from January 2016 used various low-dose DSA protocols made by modifying the thickness of the copper filter or the detector entrance dose. We compared radiation dose metrics, such as air-kerma, kerma-air product (KAP), and fluoroscopy time, as well as clinical and imaging outcomes with the conventional-dose group (n = 28) included before January 2016.

RESULTS

The total KAP was 40.1% lower in the low-dose group (87.9 vs. 146.7 Gy cm², p = 0.002). The average number of DSA runs (25.1 vs. 25.5, p = 0.86) and fluoroscopy times (77.4 vs. 69.7 min, p = 0.48) were similar between the groups. An immediate favorable occlusion rate (total or near total occlusion) was achieved in 41 (74.5%) patients. Ten patients (18.2%) underwent additional procedures due to residual (n = 6) and/or recurrent (n = 5) lesions. At a median of 10 months follow-up, 45 patients (86.5%) had achieved favorable occlusion. Treatment outcomes showed no significant between-group differences. There was one case (1.8%) of procedure-related complications in the low-dose group. All but one patient showed favorable clinical outcomes (modified Rankin score ≤ 2).

CONCLUSION

The low-dose protocols were feasible by showing significant radiation dose reduction and acceptable procedural outcome.

Impact of Cone-Beam Computed Tomography Angiography on Visualization of Sylvian Veins

BACKGROUND

A detailed understanding of the anatomy of Sylvian veins preoperatively is needed for venous-preserving Sylvian dissection. Better visualization of the venous architecture will facilitate surgical strategies for Sylvian dissection. This study evaluated and compared the image quality of the Sylvian veins and their tributaries using high-resolution cone-beam computed tomography angiography (CBCT-A) and three-dimensional computed tomography angiography (3D-CTA).

METHODS

Twenty-four patients who underwent 3D-CTA and CBCT-A as a preoperative simulation for clipping of unruptured intracranial aneurysms were retrospectively reviewed. In comparisons with intraoperative inspections, 3 raters evaluated the image quality of the Sylvian veins by 3D-CTA and CBCT-A with a 5-point scale. Visualization of the Sylvian veins and their tributaries by the 2 imaging modalities was compared using Wilcoxon signed rank test.

RESULTS

CBCT-A showed superior image quality to 3D-CTA in evaluations of the discrimination of adjacent superficial Sylvian veins (2.8 ± 0.80 vs. 4.6 ± 0.37, P < 0.0001), adjacent Sylvian veins at the sphenoid wing (3.1 ± 0.71 vs. 4.1 ± 0.56, P = 0.0001), and visualization of the tributaries of the Sylvian veins (2.5 ± 0.70 vs. 4.4 ± 0.37, P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

CBCT-A was superior to 3D-CTA for visualizing the Sylvian veins and their tributaries. CBCT-A will provide important information on the anatomy of the Sylvian veins preoperatively.

Radiation dose and fluoroscopy time of modern endovascular treatment techniques in patients with saccular unruptured intracranial aneurysms

Objectives

Modern endovascular treatment of unruptured intracranial aneurysms (UIAs) demands for observance of diagnostic reference levels (DRLs). The national DRL (250 Gy cm²) is only defined for coiling. We provide dosimetric data for the following procedures: coiling, flow diverter (FD), Woven EndoBridge (WEB), combined techniques.

Methods

A retrospective single-centre study of saccular UIAs treated between 2015 and 2019. Regarding dosimetric analysis, the parameters dose area product (DAP) and fluoroscopy time were investigated for the following variables: endovascular technique, aneurysm location, DSA protocol, aneurysm size, and patient age.

Results

Eighty-seven patients (59 females, mean age 54 years) were included. Total mean and median DAP (Gy cm²) were 119 ± 73 (89–149) and 94 (73; 130) for coiling, 128 ± 53 (106–151) and 134 (80; 176) for FD, 128 ± 56 (102–153) and 118 (90; 176) for WEB, and 165 ± 102 (110–219) and 131 (98; 209) for combined techniques (p > .05). Regarding the aneurysm location, neither DAP nor fluoroscopy time was significantly different (p > .05). The lowest and highest fluoroscopy times were recorded for WEB and combined techniques, respectively (median 26 and 94 min; p < .001). A low-dose protocol yielded a 43% reduction of DAP (p < .001). Significantly positive correlations were found between DAP and both aneurysm size (r = .320, p = .003) and patient age (r = .214, p = .046).

Conclusions

This UIA study establishes novel local DRLs for modern endovascular techniques such as FD and WEB. A low-dose protocol yielded a significant reduction of radiation dose.

Key Points

• This paper establishes local diagnostic reference levels for modern endovascular treatment techniques of unruptured intracranial aneurysms, including flow diverter stenting and Woven EndoBridge device.

• Dose area product was not significantly different between endovascular techniques and aneurysm locations, but associated with aneurysm size and patient age.

• A low-dose protocol yielded a significant reduction of dose area product and is particularly useful when applying materials with a high radiopacity (e.g. platinum coils).

NATIONAL DIAGNOSTIC REFERENCE LEVELS IN INTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY SUITES IN LEBANON: A MULTICENTER SURVEY

Air kerma-area product (PKA), cumulative air kerma at patient entrance reference point, fluoroscopy time and number of images were retrospectively collected from 15 hospitals in Lebanon for 11282 fluoroscopically-guided interventional (FGI) procedures between March 2016 and November 2018. National diagnostic reference levels (NDRLs) were established based on the third quartile of the distribution of median values of exposure parameters per department for 27 types of FGI procedures. NDRLs were in line with international DRLs except for coronary angiography (CA), percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) and transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) which require optimisation. Additionally, following the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements report 168, PCI, TAVI, triple chamber pacemaker implantation, endovascular aortic repair, nephrostomy, kyphoplasty and percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage were classified as potentially high-dose procedures with >5% of the patients with PKA exceeding 300 Gycm2. The established NDRLs will promote dose optimisation and patient radiation protection.

Practical Dose Parameter Values for the Prediction of the Adverse Effect of Neurointerventional Radiation: Relationship Between the Dose Parameters and Temporary Alopecia After Intracranial Coil Embolization

OBJECTIVE

To present values for the dose parameters predictive of alopecia as an adverse effect induced by neuroembolization using a biplane fluoroscopy.

METHODS

This study included a total of 151 patients (52 men, mean age of 55.1 ± 12.2 years) treated for intracranial neuroembolization between 2014 to 2018 with the following criteria: 1) obtainable dose report with digital subtraction angiographic image records, 2) no history of radiation exposure 6 months prior to the first procedure, and 3) and clinical follow-up performed through 12 months following the procedure. Patients were divided into 2 groups according to their presentation of alopecia during the follow-up period.

RESULTS

Eighteen (11.9%) patients developed alopecia 10 to 30 days after the procedure (average: 18.5 ± 5.3 days). Sixteen (88.9%) patients in the alopecia group were affected by projection of the A-plane fluoroscopy. Area under the receiver operating characteristic analysis curves of 0.865 (P = 0.000) and 0.831 (P = 0.000) were used to compute the optimal A-plane dose area product (255.4 Gy-cm²; sensitivity: 0.875; specificity: 0.805; Youden J = 0.682) and cumulative dose (4437.5 mGy; sensitivity, 0.750; specificity, 0.805; Youden J = 0.556) cutoff values, respectively, capable of distinguishing patients with alopecia (n = 16) from subtotal patients (n = 149).

CONCLUSIONS

The dose area product and the cumulative dose may be useful, intuitive factors for predicting the adverse effects of the neurointerventional radiation. Further multicenter research should be performed to confirm the efficacy and utility of the reference values of dose area product and cumulative dose for preventing excessive irradiation during neurointerventional procedures.

Image Quality of Low-Dose Cerebral Angiography and Effectiveness of Clinical Implementation on Diagnostic and Neurointerventional Procedures for Intracranial Aneurysms

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Awareness of the potential for exposure to high doses of radiation from interventional radiologic procedures has increased. The purpose of this study was to evaluate image quality and dose reduction of low-dose cerebral angiography during diagnostic and therapeutic procedures for intracranial aneurysms.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of 1137 prospectively collected patients between January 2012 and June 2014 was performed. Beginning in April 2013, a dose-reduction strategy was implemented. Subjective image-quality assessment of 506 standard and 540 low-dose cerebral angiography images was performed by 2 neuroradiologists using a 5-point scale and was tested using noninferiority statistics. Radiation dose-area product and air kerma of 1046 diagnostic and 317 therapeutic procedures for intracranial aneurysms were analyzed and compared between groups before (group 1) and after (group 2) clinical implementation of a dose-reduction strategy.

RESULTS

The image quality of the low-dose cerebral angiography was not inferior on the basis of results from the 2 readers. For diagnostic cerebral angiography, the mean dose-area product and air kerma were 140.8 Gy×cm² and 1.0 Gy, respectively, in group 1 and 82.0 Gy×cm² and 0.6 Gy in group 2 (P < .001, P < .001). For the neurointerventional procedure, the mean dose-area product and air kerma were 246.0 Gy×cm² and 3.7 Gy, respectively, in group 1 and 169.8 Gy×cm² and 3.3 Gy in group 2 (P < .001, P = .291).

CONCLUSIONS

With low-dose cerebral angiography, image quality was maintained, and implementation of dose-reduction strategies reduced radiation doses in patients undergoing diagnostic and neurointerventional procedures for intracranial aneurysms.

[The First Step in the Optimization of Radiation Protection of Patients in Cerebral Angiography: Investigate the Possibility of Constructing the Diagnostic Reference Level by Imaging Objective/Disease Group Using Display Value of the Blood Vessel Imaging Apparatus]

To optimize the radiation protection of patients, we investigated the possibility of constructing the diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) by imaging objective/disease group using display value of the blood vessel imaging apparatus (air kerma-area product: P_KA, air kerma at the patient entrance reference point: K_{a, r}) in cerebral angiography. We used P_KA and K_{a, r} recorded during surgery of 997 patients at our hospital, and classified them according to the purpose of imaging (diagnostic cerebral angiography or neuro interventional radiology) and disease group. Neuro interventional radiology (P_KA: 268±155 Gy・cm², K_{a, r}: 2420±1462 mGy) was significantly higher than that of diagnostic cerebral angiography (P_KA: 161±70 Gy・cm², K_{a, r}: 1112±485 mGy), (Mann-Whitney test, P<0.01). Significant difference was found between P_KA and K_{a, r} for imaging purpose and disease group (Kruskal-Wallis test, P<0.05). It is highly probable that the DRL for cerebral angiography can be constructed by imaging purpose/disease group using display value (P_KA, K_{a, r}) of the blood vessel imaging apparatus.

Spot fluoroscopy: a novel innovative approach to reduce radiation dose in neurointerventional procedures

Background

Increased interest in radiation dose reduction in neurointerventional procedures has led to the development of a method called “spot fluoroscopy” (SF), which enables the operator to collimate a rectangular or square region of interest anywhere within the general field of view. This has potential advantages over conventional collimation, which is limited to symmetric collimation centered over the field of view.

Purpose

To evaluate the effect of SF on the radiation dose.

Material and Methods

Thirty-five patients with intracranial aneurysms were treated with endovascular coiling. SF was used in 16 patients and conventional fluoroscopy in 19. The following parameters were analyzed: the total fluoroscopic time, the total air kerma, the total fluoroscopic dose-area product, and the fluoroscopic dose-area product rate. Statistical differences were determined using the Welch’s t-test.

Results

The use of SF led to a reduction of 50% of the total fluoroscopic dose-area product (CF = 106.21 Gycm², SD = 99.06 Gycm² versus SF = 51.80 Gycm², SD = 21.03 Gycm², p = 0.003884) and significant reduction of the total fluoroscopic dose-area product rate (CF = 1.42 Gycm²/min, SD = 0.57 Gycm²/s versus SF = 0.83 Gycm²/min, SD = 0.37 Gycm²/min, p = 0.00106). The use of SF did not lead to an increase in fluoroscopy time or an increase in total fluoroscopic cumulative air kerma, regardless of collimation.

Conclusion

The SF function is a new and promising tool for reduction of the radiation dose during neurointerventional procedures.

Reduced Patient Radiation Exposure during Neurodiagnostic and Interventional X-Ray Angiography with a New Imaging Platform

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Advancements in medical device and imaging technology as well as accruing clinical evidence have accelerated the growth of the endovascular treatment of cerebrovascular diseases. However, the augmented role of these procedures raises concerns about the radiation dose to patients and operators. We evaluated patient doses from an x-ray imaging platform with radiation dose-reduction technology, which combined image noise reduction, motion correction, and contrast-dependent temporal averaging with optimized x-ray exposure settings.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this single-center, retrospective study, cumulative dose-area product inclusive of fluoroscopy, angiography, and 3D acquisitions for all neurovascular procedures performed during a 2-year period on the dose-reduction platform were compared with a reference platform. Key study features were the following: The neurointerventional radiologist could select the targeted dose reduction for each patient with the dose-reduction platform, and the statistical analyses included patient characteristics and the neurointerventional radiologist as covariates. The analyzed outcome measures were cumulative dose (kerma)-area product, fluoroscopy duration, and administered contrast volume.

RESULTS

A total of 1238 neurointerventional cases were included, of which 914 and 324 were performed on the reference and dose-reduction platforms, respectively. Over all diagnostic and neurointerventional procedures, the cumulative dose-area product was significantly reduced by 53.2% (mean reduction, 160.3 Gy × cm²; P < .0001), fluoroscopy duration was marginally significantly increased (mean increase, 5.2 minutes; P = .0491), and contrast volume was nonsignificantly increased (mean increase, 15.3 mL; P = .1616) with the dose-reduction platform.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant reduction in patient radiation dose is achievable during neurovascular procedures by using dose-reduction technology with a minimal impact on workflow.

Patient radiation doses and reference levels in pediatric interventional radiology

OBJECTIVES

To describe, in a multicentric paediatric population, reference levels (RLs) for three interventional radiological procedures.

METHODS

From January 2012 to March 2015, children scheduled for an interventional radiological procedure in two French tertiary centres were retrospectively included and divided into four groups according to age: children younger than 2 years (A1), aged 2-7 years (A5), 8-12 years (A10) and 13-18 years (A15). Three procedures were identified: cerebral digital subtraction angiography (DSA), brain arteriovenous malformation (bAVM) embolization, and head and neck superficial vascular malformation (SVM) percutaneous sclerotherapy. Demographic and dosimetric data, including dose area product (DAP), were collected.

RESULTS

550 procedures were included. For DSA (162 procedures), the proposed RL values in DAP were 4, 18, 12 and 32 Gy∙cm² in groups A1, A5, A10 and A15, respectively. For bAVM embolization (258 procedures), values were 33, 70, 105 and 88 Gy∙cm² in groups A1, A5, A10 and A15, respectively. For SVM sclerotherapy (130 procedures), values were 350, 790, 490 and 248 mGy∙cm² in groups A1, A5, A10 and A15, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Consecutive data were available to permit a proposal of reference levels for three major paediatric interventional radiology procedures.

KEY POINTS

• We determined reference levels (RLs) for bAVM embolization, DSA and SVM sclerotherapy. • The proposed RLs will permit benchmarking practice with an external standard. • The proposed RLs by age may help to develop paediatric dose guidelines.

Radiation Exposure during Neurointerventional Procedures in Modern Biplane Angiographic Systems: A Single-Site Experience

Background and Purpose

Per the ALARA principle, reducing the dose delivered to both patients and staff must be a priority for endovascular therapists, who should monitor their own practice. We evaluated patient exposure to radiation during common neurointerventions performed with a recent flat-panel detector angiographic system and compared our results with those of recently published studies.

Methods

All consecutive patients who underwent a diagnostic cerebral angiography or intervention on 2 modern flat-panel detector angiographic biplane systems (Innova IGS 630, GE Healthcare, Chalfont St Giles, UK) from February to November 2015 were retrospectively analyzed. Dose-area product (DAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK) per plane, fluoroscopy time (FT), and total number of digital subtraction angiography (DSA) frames were collected, reported as median (interquartile range), and compared with the previously published literature.

Results

A total of 755 consecutive cases were assessed in our institution during the study period, including 398 diagnostic cerebral angiographies and 357 interventions. The DAP (Gy × cm²), fontal and lateral CAK (Gy), FT (min), and total number of DSA frames were as follows: 43 (33-60), 0.26 (0.19-0.33), 0.09 (0.07-0.13), 5.6 (4.2-7.5), and 245 (193-314) for diagnostic cerebral angiographies, and 66 (41-110), 0.46 (0.25-0.80), 0.18 (0.10-0.30), 18.3 (9.1-30.2), and 281 (184-427) for interventions.

Conclusion

Our diagnostic cerebral angiography group had a lower median and was in the 75th percentile of DAP and FT when compared with the published literature. For interventions, both DAP and number of DSA frames were significantly lower than the values reported in the literature, despite a higher FT. Subgroup analysis by procedure type also revealed a lower or comparable DAP.

Patient Radiation Exposure During Diagnostic and Therapeutic Procedures for Intracranial Aneurysms: A Multicenter Study

PURPOSE

To assess patient radiation doses during cerebral angiography and embolization of intracranial aneurysms across multi-centers and propose a diagnostic reference level (DRL).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We studied a sample of 490 diagnostic and 371 therapeutic procedures for intracranial aneurysms, which were performed at 23 hospitals in Korea in 2015. Parameters including dose-area product (DAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK), fluoroscopic time and total angiographic image frames were obtained and analyzed.

RESULTS

Total mean DAP, CAK, fluoroscopy time, and total angiographic image frames were 106.2 ± 66.4 Gy-cm(2), 697.1 ± 473.7 mGy, 9.7 ± 6.5 minutes, 241.5 ± 116.6 frames for diagnostic procedures, 218.8 ± 164.3 Gy-cm(2), 3365.7 ± 2205.8 mGy, 51.5 ± 31.1 minutes, 443.5 ± 270.7 frames for therapeutic procedures, respectively. For diagnostic procedure, the third quartiles for DRLs were 144.2 Gy-cm(2) for DAP, 921.1 mGy for CAK, 12.2 minutes for fluoroscopy times and 286.5 for number of image frames, respectively. For therapeutic procedures, the third quartiles for DRLs were 271.0 Gy-cm(2) for DAP, 4471.3 mGy for CAK, 64.7 minutes for fluoroscopy times and 567.3 for number of image frames, respectively. On average, rotational angiography was used 1.5 ± 0.7 times/session (range, 0-4; n=490) for diagnostic procedures and 1.6 ± 1.2 times/session (range, 0-4; n=368) for therapeutic procedures, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Radiation dose as measured by DAP, fluoroscopy time and image frames were lower in our patients compared to another study regarding cerebral angiography, and DAP was lower with fewer angiographic image frames for therapeutic procedures. Proposed DRLs can be used for quality assurance and patient safety in diagnostic and therapeutic procedures.

MULTICENTRE COMPARISON OF IMAGE QUALITY FOR LOW-CONTRAST OBJECTS AND MICROCATHETER TIPS IN X-RAY-GUIDED TREATMENT OF ARTERIOVENOUS MALFORMATION IN THE BRAIN

The treatment of brain arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) can be performed as a minimally invasive X-ray-guided procedure using a microcatheter for navigation to reach the target site. The performance of the interventional vascular surgery devices used for AVM was compared in four hospitals. The relation between image quality and the entrance surface air kerma (ESAK) was assessed for the default protocols for digital subtraction angiography (DSA) and fluoroscopy. A custom phantom, built with PMMA and aluminium plates was used to mimic the attenuation properties of the patient head. Image quality was assessed using low-contrast objects and catheters embedded in two phantoms. Differences were found in the ESAK values, especially for the fluoroscopy, whereas for DSA, the ESAK values were similar. The differences in image quality can be related to acquisition parameters, such as kV and filtration, and post-processing. The proposed method can be used to optimise the existing AVM protocols.

Radiation Doses in Patient Eye Lenses during Interventional Neuroradiology Procedures

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Eye lenses are among the most sensitive organs to x-ray radiation and may be considered at risk during neurointerventional radiology procedures. The threshold dose to produce eye lens opacities has been recently reduced to 500 mGy by the International Commission on Radiologic Protection. In this article, the authors investigated the radiation doses delivered to patients' eyes during interventional neuroradiology procedures at a university hospital.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Small optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters were located over patients' eyes during 5 diagnostic and 31 therapeutic procedures performed in a biplane x-ray system. Phantom measurements were also made to determine the level of radiation to the eye during imaging runs with conebeam CT.

RESULTS

The left eye (located toward the lateral C-arm x-ray source) received a 4.5 times greater dose than the right one. The average dose during embolization in the left eye was 300 mGy, with a maximum of 2000 mGy in a single procedure. The patient who received this maximum eye dose needed 6 embolization procedures to treat his high-volume AVM. If one took into account those 6 embolizations, the eye dose could be 2-fold. Sixteen percent of the embolizations resulted in eye doses of >500 mGy.

CONCLUSIONS

A relevant fraction of patients received eye doses exceeding the threshold of 500 mGy. A careful optimization of the procedures and follow-up of these patients to evaluate potential lens opacities should be considered.

Estimates of diagnostic reference levels for pediatric peripheral and abdominal fluoroscopically guided procedures

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to survey radiation dose indexes of pediatric peripheral and abdominal fluoroscopically guided procedures from which estimates of diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) can be proposed for both a standard fluoroscope and a novel fluoroscope with advanced image processing and lower radiation dose rates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Radiation dose structured reports were retrospectively collected for 408 clinical pediatric cases: Half of the procedures were performed with a standard imaging technology and half with a novel x-ray technology. Dose-area product (DAP), air Kerma (AK), fluoroscopy time, number of digital subtraction angiography images, and patient mass were collected to calculate and normalize radiation dose indexes for procedures completed with the standard and novel fluoroscopes.

RESULTS

The study population was composed of 180 and 175 patients who underwent procedures with the standard and novel technology, respectively. The 21 different types of pediatric peripheral and abdominal interventional procedures produced 408 total studies. Median ages, mass and body mass index, fluoroscopy time per procedure, and total number of recorded images for the standard and novel technologies were not statistically different. The area of the x-ray beams was square at the level of the patient with a dimension of 10-13 cm. The dose reduction achieved with the novel fluoroscope ranged from 18% to 51% of the dose required with the standard fluoroscope. The median DAP and AK patient dose indexes were 0.38 Gy · cm(2) and 4.00 mGy, respectively, for the novel fluoroscope.

CONCLUSION

Estimates of dose indexes of pediatric peripheral and abdominal fluoroscopically guided, clinical procedures should assist in the development of DRLs to foster management of radiation doses of pediatric patients.

Patient radiation dose in diagnostic and interventional procedures for intracranial aneurysms: experience at a single center

Objective

To assess patient radiation doses during cerebral angiography and embolization of intracranial aneurysms in a large sample size from a single center.

Materials and Methods

We studied a sample of 439 diagnostic and 149 therapeutic procedures for intracranial aneurysms in 480 patients (331 females, 149 males; median age, 57 years; range, 21-88 years), which were performed in 2012 with a biplane unit. Parameters including fluoroscopic time, dose-area product (DAP), and total angiographic image frames were obtained and analyzed.

Results

Mean fluoroscopic time, total mean DAP, and total image frames were 12.6 minutes, 136.6 ± 44.8 Gy-cm², and 251 ± 49 frames for diagnostic procedures, 52.9 minutes, 226.0 ± 129.2 Gy-cm², and 241 frames for therapeutic procedures, and 52.2 minutes, 334.5 ± 184.6 Gy-cm², and 408 frames for when both procedures were performed during the same session. The third quartiles for diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) were 14.0, 61.1, and 66.1 minutes for fluoroscopy time, 154.2, 272.8, and 393.8 Gy-cm² for DAP, and 272, 276, and 535 for numbers of image frames in diagnostic, therapeutic, and both procedures in the same session, respectively. The proportions of fluoroscopy in DAP for the procedures were 11.4%, 50.5%, and 36.1%, respectively, for the three groups. The mean DAP for each 3-dimensional rotational angiographic acquisition was 19.2 ± 3.2 Gy-cm². On average, rotational angiography was used 1.4 ± 0.6 times/session (range, 1-4; n = 580).

Conclusion

Radiation dose in our study as measured by DAP, fluoroscopy time and image frames did not differ significantly from other reported DRL studies for cerebral angiography, and DAP was lower with fewer angiographic image frames for embolization. A national registry of radiation-dose data is a necessary next step to refine the dose reference level.

Radiation dose in neuroangiography using image noise reduction technology: a population study based on 614 patients

Introduction

The purpose of this study was to quantify the reduction in patient radiation dose by X-ray imaging technology using image noise reduction and system settings for neuroangiography and to assess its impact on the working habits of the physician.

Methods

Radiation dose data from 190 neuroangiographies and 112 interventional neuroprocedures performed with state-of-the-art image processing and reference system settings were collected for the period January–June 2010. The system was then configured with extra image noise reduction algorithms and system settings, which enabled radiation dose reduction without loss of image quality. Radiation dose data from 174 neuroangiographies and 138 interventional neuroprocedures were collected for the period January–June 2012. Procedures were classified as diagnostic or interventional. Patient radiation exposure was quantified using cumulative dose area product and cumulative air kerma. Impact on working habits of the physician was quantified using fluoroscopy time and number of digital subtraction angiography (DSA) images.

Results

The optimized system settings provided significant reduction in dose indicators versus reference system settings (p<0.001): from 124 to 47 Gy cm² and from 0.78 to 0.27 Gy for neuroangiography, and from 328 to 109 Gy cm² and from 2.71 to 0.89 Gy for interventional neuroradiology. Differences were not significant between the two systems with regard to fluoroscopy time or number of DSA images.

Conclusion

X-ray imaging technology using an image noise reduction algorithm and system settings provided approximately 60% radiation dose reduction in neuroangiography and interventional neuroradiology, without affecting the working habits of the physician.

Patient radiation dose management in the follow-up of potential skin injuries in neuroradiology

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Radiation exposure from neurointerventional procedures can be substantial, with risk of radiation injuries. We present the results of a follow-up program applied to potential skin injuries in interventional neuroradiology based on North American and European guidelines.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The following guidelines approved in 2009 by SIR and CIRSE have been used over the last 2 years to identify patients with potential skin injuries requiring clinical follow-up: peak skin dose >3 Gy, air kerma at the patient entrance reference point >5 Gy, kerma area product >500 Gy · cm(2), or fluoroscopy time >60 minutes.

RESULTS

A total of 708 procedures (325 in 2009 and 383 in 2010) were included in the study. After analyzing each dose report, 19 patients (5.9%) were included in a follow-up program for potential skin injuries in 2009, while in 2010, after introducing several optimizing actions and refining the selection criteria, only 4 patients (1.0%) needed follow-up. Over the last 2 years, only 3 patients required referral to a dermatology service.

CONCLUSIONS

The application of the guidelines to patient radiation dose management helped standardize the selection criteria for including patients in the clinical follow-up program of potential skin radiation injuries. The peak skin dose resulted in the most relevant parameter. The refinement of selection criteria and the introduction of a low-dose protocol in the x-ray system, combined with a training program focused on radiation protection, reduced the number of patients requiring clinical follow-up.