Epitope binning of murine monoclonal antibodies by a multiplexed pairing assay

Critical reagent generation, characterization, handling and storage workflows: impact on ligand binding assays

The foundation of pharmacokinetics and antidrug antibodies assay robustness relies on the use of high-quality reagents. Over the past decade, there has been increasing interest within the pharmaceutical industry, as well as regulators, on defining best practices and scientific approaches for generation, characterization and handling of critical reagents. In this review, we will discuss current knowledge and practices on critical reagent workflows and state-of-the-art approaches for characterization, generation, stability and storage and how each of these steps can impact ligand-binding assay robustness.

Using multiple platforms for critical reagents selection process to support pharmacokinetic ligand-binding assay development

We have evaluated the utility of epitope binning on biolayer interferometry (BLI) as a strategy to funnel the selection of candidate pairs suitable for pharmacokinetic assay development. Totally, 8 anti-Idiotypic monoclonal antibodies in 64 possible combinations were tested by BLI, ELISA and Gyrolab^®. Two epitope binning approaches were utilized, in-tandem and classic sandwich. Both formats identified four mutually exclusive bins providing 31 and 25 possible antibody pair combinations, respectively. In contrast, the ELISA and Gyrolab yielded 18 and 9 positive pairs, respectively, with only a partial correlation to the BLI results. Several positive pairs by ELISA and Gyrolab, screened negative by BLI. Just over half of the pairs predicted by BLI were positive on ELISA and less than a quarter were positive on Gyrolab. This evaluation showed, in our case, that BLI was limited in its ability to predict candidate pairs that would be successful in pharmacokinetic method development.

Epitope Binning of Novel Monoclonal Anti F1 and Anti LcrV Antibodies and Their Application in a Simple, Short, HTRF Test for Clinical Plague Detection

Mouse monoclonal antibodies were raised against plague disease biomarkers: the bacterial capsular protein fraction 1 (F1) and the low-calcium response—LcrV virulence factor (Vag). A novel tandem assay, employing BioLayer Interferometry (BLI), enabled the isolation of antibodies against four different epitopes on Vag. The tandem assay was carried out with hybridoma supernatants, circumventing the need for antibody purification. The BioLayer assay was further adopted for characterization of epitope-repetitive antigens, enabling the discovery of two unique epitopes on F1. The selected antibodies were purified and applied as “oligo-clonal” reagents for the immuno-detection of both biomarkers. The developed Homogenous Time Resolved Fluorescence (HTRF) tests were short (10 min) and simple (no washing steps), allowing for detection of 10 ng/mL F1 and 2.5 ng/mL Vag. The tests were successfully applied for detection of disease biomarkers produced by various Y. pestis strains during growth in blood culture vials.

Epitope Binning Assay Using an Electron Transfer-Modulated Aptamer Sensor

Surface plasmon resonance and quartz crystal microbalance are workhorses of protein-DNA interaction research for over 20 years, providing ways to quantitatively determine the protein-DNA binding. However, the cost, necessary technical expertise, and severe nonspecific adsorption poses barriers to their use. Convenient and effective techniques for the measurement of protein-DNA binding affinity and the epitope binning between DNA and proteins for developing highly sensitive detection platform remain challenging. Here, we develop a binding-induced alteration in electron transfer kinetics of the redox reporter labeled (methylene blue) on DNA aptamer to measure the binding affinity between prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and aptamer. We demonstrate that the binding of PSA to aptamer decreases the electron transfer rate of methylene blue for ∼45%. Further, we identify the best pairwise selection of aptamers for developing sandwich assay by sorting from 10 pairwise modes with the PSA detection limit of 500 ng/mL. Our study provides promising ways to analyze the binding affinity between ligand and receptor and to sort pairwise between aptamers or antibodies for the development of highly sensitive sandwich immunoassays.

Generation of a highly diverse panel of antagonistic chicken monoclonal antibodies against the GIP receptor

Raising functional antibodies against G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is challenging due to their low density expression, instability in the absence of the cell membrane's lipid bilayer and frequently short extracellular domains that can serve as antigens. In addition, a particular therapeutic concept may require an antibody to not just bind the receptor, but also act as a functional receptor agonist or antagonist. Antagonizing the glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide (GIP) receptor may open up new therapeutic modalities in the treatment of diabetes and obesity. As such, a panel of monoclonal antagonistic antibodies would be a useful tool for in vitro and in vivo proof of concept studies. The receptor is highly conserved between rodents and humans, which has contributed to previous mouse and rat immunization campaigns generating very few usable antibodies. Switching the immunization host to chicken, which is phylogenetically distant from mammals, enabled the generation of a large and diverse panel of monoclonal antibodies containing 172 unique sequences. Three-quarters of all chicken-derived antibodies were functional antagonists, exhibited high-affinities to the receptor extracellular domain and sampled a broad epitope repertoire. For difficult targets, including GPCRs such as GIPR, chickens are emerging as valuable immunization hosts for therapeutic antibody discovery.

The importance of epitope binning for biological drug discovery

The pharmaceutical industry is experiencing comeback sales growth due in large part to the industry’s R&D efforts that center on biologics drug development. To facilitate that effort, tools are being developed for more effective biologic drug development. At the forefront of this effort is epitope characterization, in particular epitope binning, primarily due to the role an epitope plays in drug function. Here we detail the financial advantages of epitope binning including (1) increased R&D productivity due to increased work in process, (2) reduced number of “dead-end”candidates, and (3) increasedability to reengineer antibodies based on the epitope. With the arrival of high throughput biosensors, this manuscript serves as a call to push epitope binning earlier in the biological drug discovery process.

Hapten mediated display and pairing of recombinant antibodies accelerates assay assembly for biothreat countermeasures

A bottle-neck in recombinant antibody sandwich immunoassay development is pairing, demanding protein purification and modification to distinguish captor from tracer. We developed a simple pairing scheme using microliter amounts of E. coli osmotic shockates bearing site-specific biotinylated antibodies and demonstrated proof of principle with a single domain antibody (sdAb) that is both captor and tracer for polyvalent Marburgvirus nucleoprotein. The system could also host pairs of different sdAb specific for the 7 botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) serotypes, enabling recognition of the cognate serotype. Inducible supE co-expression enabled sdAb populations to be propagated as either phage for more panning from repertoires or expressed as soluble sdAb for screening within a single host strain. When combined with streptavidin-g3p fusions, a novel transdisplay system was formulated to retrofit a semi-synthetic sdAb library which was mined for an anti-Ebolavirus sdAb which was immediately immunoassay ready, thereby speeding up the recombinant antibody discovery and utilization processes.