Bilateral Wilms' tumour: An international comparison of treatments and outcomes

A Single Center Experience With Bilateral Wilms Tumor

BACKGROUND

Wilms tumor (WT) is the most common pediatric renal malignancy and bilateral disease (BWT) occurs in 5% of cases and is associated with poor outcomes. Management of BWT includes chemotherapy and oncologic resection while preserving renal function. Previous literature has demonstrated variable approaches in BWT treatment. The aim of this study was to examine a single institution experience and outcomes with BWT.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was performed for all patients with WT treated at a free-standing tertiary children's hospital between 1998 and 2018. Patients with BWT were identified and treatment courses were compared. Outcomes of interest included need for dialysis post-operatively, need for renal transplantation post-operatively, disease recurrence, and overall survival.

RESULTS

Of 120 children with WT, 9 children (6F:3M) of median age 32 months (IQR: 24-50 months) and median weight 13.7 kg (IQR: 10.9-16.2 kg) were diagnosed with and treated for BWT. Pre-operative biopsies were obtained in 4/9 patients, 3 of whom received neoadjuvant chemotherapy and 1 who underwent radical nephrectomy. Of the 5 patients who did not undergo biopsy, 4/5 were treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy, and 1/5 underwent upfront nephrectomy. Post-operatively, 4/9 children required dialysis, of whom 2 subsequently underwent renal transplantation. Two patients were lost to follow-up, and of the remaining 7 patients, disease recurrence occurred in 5/7 children and overall survival was 71% (n=5).

CONCLUSION

Management of BWT varies regarding the use of pre-operative biopsy, neoadjuvant chemotherapy, and extent of disease resection. Further guidelines on treatment protocols may optimize outcomes in children with BWT.

Advances in the clinical management of high-risk Wilms tumors

Outcomes are excellent for the majority of patients with Wilms tumors (WT). However, there remain WT subgroups for which the survival rate is approximately 50% or lower. Acknowledging that the composition of this high-risk group has changed over time reflecting improvements in therapy, we introduce the authors' view of the historical and current approach to the classification and treatment of high-risk WT. For this review, we consider high-risk WT to include patients with newly diagnosed metastatic blastemal-type or diffuse anaplastic histology, those who relapse after having been initially treated with three or more different chemotherapeutics, or those who relapse more than once. In certain low- or low middle-income settings, socio-economic factors expand the definition of what constitutes a high-risk WT. As conventional therapies are inadequate to cure the majority of high-risk WT patients, advancement of laboratory and early-phase clinical investigations to identify active agents is urgently needed.

Advances in the clinical management of high-risk Wilms tumors

Outcomes are excellent for the majority of patients with Wilms tumors (WT). However, there remain WT subgroups for which the survival rate is approximately 50% or lower. Acknowledging that the composition of this high-risk group has changed over time reflecting improvements in therapy, we introduce the authors' view of the historical and current approach to the classification and treatment of high-risk WT. For this review, we consider high-risk WT to include patients with newly diagnosed metastatic blastemal-type or diffuse anaplastic histology, those who relapse after having been initially treated with three or more different chemotherapeutics, or those who relapse more than once. In certain low- or low middle-income settings, socio-economic factors expand the definition of what constitutes a high-risk WT. As conventional therapies are inadequate to cure the majority of high-risk WT patients, advancement of laboratory and early-phase clinical investigations to identify active agents is urgently needed.

Bench surgery with autotransplantation for bilateral Wilms tumor-A feasible technique for renal sinus invasion

Purpose

Bilateral Wilms tumor (BWT) with renal sinus invasion requires extremely difficult surgical care. This study presents an alternative strategy for tumor removal while at the same time preserving the renal parenchyma.

Materials and methods

In total, 9 cases of synchronous BWT were admitted to our hospital between May 2016 to Aug 2020. We retrospectively reviewed the clinical data, surgical technique, and functional and oncological outcomes of these cases.

Results

The 9 cases included 3 males and 6 females, with a median age of 12 months at surgery (range 7-40). A total of 14 kidney units had renal sinus invasion (77.8%), whereas multifocal neoplasms were observed in 7 units (38.9%). The local stage distribution revealed 1 kidney with stage I, 10 kidneys with stage II, and 7 kidneys with stage III. Nephron-sparing surgery was performed on 15 kidney units (83.3%), among which 13 (72.2%) underwent bench surgery with autotransplantation (BS-AT), whereas 2 (11.1%) were subjected to tumor enucleation in vivo. Urinary leakage was the most prevalent postoperative complication. We observed negative margins. During the mean follow-up of 28.4 months, 2 patients (22.2%) succumbed from sepsis and renal failure, respectively, whereas the other 7 (77.8%) survived without recurrence. Survivors experienced an estimated glomerular filtration rate of 81 ± 15.4 ml/(min × 1.73 m²). The endpoint renal volume of 9 renal units receiving BS-AT significantly increased (P = 0.02).

Conclusions

In summary, the surgical management of bilateral Wilms tumor requires meticulous operative approach and technique. Besides, BS-AT provides a viable alternative to nephron-sparing surgery for BWT patients with renal sinus invasion.