Differentiation of functional venous insufficiency and leg lymphedema complicated by functional venous insufficiency using subcutaneous tissue ultrasonography

Detection and quantitation of venous leg edema with the edema ruler and ultrasound

Objective: Lower extremity edema is characteristic of C3 chronic venous disease. We developed a new clinical and duplex ultrasound (DUS) methodology for the detection and quantification of leg edema and prospectively evaluated its usefulness. Methods: Forty-seven venous patients (94 legs) were evaluated for ankle edema using an Edema RulerTM and DUS using a modified Suehiro grading scale. Results: Interobserver reliability for the use of the Edema RulerTM was 0.985 (p < .001) and 0.883 (p < .001) for the Modified Suehiro Grade. The Edema RulerTM had stronger significant correlations with Edema rVCSS (0.842; p < .001) compared to DUS: (0.474;p < .001) with Edema rVCSS. There were significant differences between the edema pitting depth in CEAP classification of C1 and C2 compared to C3, C4a, and C4c. DUS analysis only had significant differences between CEAP classification C2 and C4a. Conclusions: The Edema RulerTM provides a quantitative measurement of lower extremity edema with high reliability which can be easily integrated into clinical practice. While both methods had good inter-observer reliability, the Edema RulerTM had stronger correlations to Edema rVCSS and showed significant differences in pitting depths between lower CEAP scores (C1-2) compared to higher CEAP scores (C3-4c).

Ultrasonographic study of the effects of compressive stockings on legs with venous edema

OBJECTIVES

The occurrence of leg edema in patients with chronic venous disease (CVD) is currently evaluated by visual inspection, palpation, and measurement of limb circumference. The changes of soft tissues morphology in swollen legs have been poorly investigated by ultrasonography (US) in the past. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of medical compression stockings (MCS) on the US morphology of the cutaneous and subcutaneous layers (CL and SCL, respectively) in legs with venous edema.

METHODS

The morphology of the cutaneous and subcutaneous layers (CL and SCL) was evaluated by US in 18 swollen legs with chronic venous disorders (CVD), before and after 4 weeks of treatment with MCS. Skin morphology was evaluated by using an 8-14 MHz probe with a dedicated setting, 5 cm above the medial malleolus.

RESULTS

MCS provoked both quantitative and qualitative changes. A reduction of CL/SCL thickness greater than 20% was observed in 16/18 legs. A reduction of the SCL echogenicity was observed in 14/18 legs. Nine out of 12 legs which showed abnormalities of the CL before treatment showed a structural rearrangement of the dermis and the reappearing of the dermo-hypodermic junction.

CONCLUSIONS

The reduction of the SCL thickness is to be ascribed to the increase of veno-lymphatic drainage promoted by MCS. The reduction of tissue echogenicity by MCS is a quite innovative concept and it is suggestive for an anti-inflammatory action of MCS on skin tissues.

Real-time image-sharing to educate a patient with lymphoedema on self-care: a case study

INTRODUCTION

Compression therapy is important in oedema control in lymphoedema. However, some patients have difficulties starting compression therapy because standard self-care education does not enable them to fully understand lymphoedema and recognise it as their problem. To overcome this, real-time image-sharing education, using a combination of indocyanine green lymphography (ICG) and ultrasonography, may be used to educate patients. In this case study, real-time image-sharing education promoted decision-making and behaviour change in a patient with lower extremity lymphoedema so she would wear elastic stockings.

CASE

A 51-year-old woman with a BMI of 31.7 kg/m² and secondary lower extremity lymphoedema following cervical cancer surgery did not adhere to self-care instructions regarding wearing elastic stockings for 5 years. The oedema worsened, her limb circumference increased and she had two episodes of cellulitis within a year. Because the patient had a negative attitude towards elastic stockings, real-time image-sharing education was used to promote recognition of illness using ICG and an understanding of the condition of lymphoedema using ultrasonography. After the images were shared and explained, the patient discussed her recognition and understanding of lymphoedema, then decided to use compression stockings. She continued to wear them for 4 months, and her limb circumference decreased.

CONCLUSION

Real-time image-sharing education using ICG and ultrasonography as self-care support for a lymphoedema patient who would not start compression therapy could result in behavioural changes and the patient starting and continuing to wear elastic stockings.

Hardness Sensed by Skin Palpation in Legs with Lymphedema Is Predominantly Correlated with Dermal Thickening

Background: We aimed to clarify whether pathological changes in skin and subcutaneous tissue with lymphedema affected the skin hardness sensed by palpation. Methods and Results: In 50 patients with unilateral legs with lymphedema (LE), the skin hardness of the lower inner thigh and lower inner calf was determined using a scale ranging from 1 (softest) to 7 (hardest) based on palpation. Then, the skin hardness was correlated with the measurements of skin/subcutaneous tissue ultrasonography images obtained from the palpated parts. Multivariate logistic regression analysis demonstrated that dermal thickness was a significant factor that affected the difference in skin hardness between the LE and the contralateral asymptomatic leg for both thigh (p < 0.05) and calf (p < 0.01). When the thigh and calf in the LE were individually studied, subcutaneous echogenicity (p < 0.05), indicating subcutaneous inflammation/fibrosis, and subcutaneous thickness (p < 0.01) also seemed to affect skin hardness, respectively. Conclusions: The skin hardness sensed in the LE seemed to be affected predominantly by dermal thickening. In addition, the pathological changes in the subcutaneous tissue caused by LE seemed to have an impact on skin hardness. Clinical Trial Registration number 2020-150.

Association of Dermal Hypoechogenicity and Cellulitis History in Patients with Lower Extremity Lymphedema: A Cross-Sectional Observational Study

Background: Recurrent cellulitis has high impact on physical, psychological, and social aspects for lymphedema patients. We speculated that identification of characteristics of skin and subcutaneous adipose tissue with cellulitis history can help considering new approach for prevention of recurrent cellulitis in lymphedema patients. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to noninvasively identify the ultrasonographic features of skin and subcutaneous tissue of lymphedema in patients with a cellulitis history. Method and Results: This was a cross-sectional study, and all data were collected from patients' medical records. We assessed ultrasonographic images of the lower extremity of patients with lymphedema that were obtained in a lymphedema clinic. The ultrasonographic images were analyzed on the basis of the following five features: dermal hypoechogenicity, unclear dermal border, unclear superficial fascia, increased subcutaneous echogenicity, and subcutaneous cobblestone appearance. Fifty-two ultrasonographic images from 19 female patients with lower extremity lymphedema, including 8 with and 11 without a cellulitis history, were analyzed. The proportion of dermal hypoechogenicity on the upper leg was significantly higher in the patients with than in those without a cellulitis history (75.0% vs. 9.1%, p = 0.006). Conclusion: Cellulitis history in lymphedema patients appears to be associated with dermal hypoechogenicity, particularly in the proximal lower extremity. This finding suggests that it may be the initial step to consider new approach for prevention of recurrent cellulitis in lymphedema patients.

Noninvasive, objective evaluation of lower extremity lymphedema severity using shear wave elastography: A preliminary study

BACKGROUND

Increased skin and subcutaneous tissue stiffness in patients with early-stage lymphedema has been reported. The purpose of this study was to examine the use of shear wave elastography (SWE) for evaluating lower extremity lymphedema (LEL).

METHODS

For 10 lower extremities of normal controls and 72 limbs of patients with gynecological cancer whose lymphatic function was categorized into six stages based on the range of dermal backflow (DBF) observed in indocyanine green (ICG) lymphography, SWE was performed and shear wave velocity (SWV) of the dermis and three layers of subcutaneous tissue at the thigh and calf were recorded. Twenty-five patients underwent thigh tissue histological and dermal thickness examinations.

RESULTS

The strongest correlation between the ICG DBF stage and SWV during SWE was observed on the dermal layer of the thigh (p < 0.01, R = 0.67). There was a significant correlation between the dermal thickness of the thigh and the ICG DBF stage (p < 0.01, R = 0.87) and also between the dermal thickness of the thigh and SWV (p < 0.01, R = 0.73).

CONCLUSION

Noninvasive, objective evaluation of LEL severity using SWE was well correlated with lymphatic function as determined by ICG lymphography. The DBF changes in the dermis of the thigh best reflected the changes in lymphatic function. Dermal thickness variations may partially account for differences in SWV.

Use of ultrasound imaging software to differentiate venous and lymphatic edema in lower limbs

BACKGROUND

Lower limb edema has both systemic and local causes. Using software to differentiate the origin of edema in ultrasound images is an innovation.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the parameters for using software to differentiate edema of venous and/or lymphatic origin in ultrasound images of the lower limbs.

METHOD

This is a cross-sectional, quantitative, analytical study with non-probabilistic sampling by convenience. Data were collected by patient interview, physical examination, ultrasound examination, and analysis of software for tissue characterization in ultrasound image by means of quantification of echogenicity and Gray Scale Median (GSM).

RESULTS

The sample comprised 42 lower limbs with venous edema, 35 with lymphatic edema, 14 with mixed edema, and 11 control limbs. The distributions of pixels in echogenicity intervals by group was as follows. In the venous edema group, 88.31% were distributed from hypoechogenic interval IV to echogenic interval III; in the lymphatic edema group 71.73% were from hypoechogenic interval II to echogenic interval I; in the mixed edema group 76.17% were from hypoechogenic interval III to echogenic interval II; and in the control group 84.87% were distributed from echogenic interval II to hyperechogenic interval I. Mean and standard deviation of GSM values showed statistical differences between groups.

CONCLUSION

The CATUS software enabled differentiation of the type of lower limb edema, facilitating diagnosis of edema type and, consequently, choice of the best therapeutic option.

Perioperative variations in indices derived from noninvasive assessments to detect postmastectomy lymphedema

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to clarify the variations in indices derived from noninvasive assessments for the early detection of postmastectomy lymphedema (LE) from 1 month preoperatively until 2 years postoperatively.

METHODS

In total, 120 patients who underwent surgery for breast cancer in our institution were prospectively followed up with a questionnaire for arm swelling as well as with tape measurements, bioimpedance analysis (BIA), and skin and subcutaneous tissue ultrasound at 1 month before and 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Ninety-seven patients completed the study. Among 93 patients who did not present with LE, 9% complained of arm swelling even before surgery, and the incidence peaked at 17% at 6 months after surgery. There were no differences in the circumferences of the upper arm, forearm, and hand between sides throughout the study period. However, the postoperative circumference values of the upper arm only on the operation side were slightly increased compared with the preoperative values. The mean excess fluid in the arm on the operation side compared with the contralateral side, as assessed by BIA, was nearly zero throughout the study period. There were no differences in subcutaneous echogenicity or skin and subcutaneous thicknesses between the sides throughout the study period. However, time-dependent increases in subcutaneous thicknesses were noticed on both sides. Four patients (4.1%) developed LE. In three of these patients, abnormality in the BIA was recorded 6 to 12 months before presentation. Immediately after presentation, the common findings included BIA abnormality and increased subcutaneous echogenicity and skin thickness in the medial forearm.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, a complaint of arm swelling was not sensitive enough for detection of the early onset of LE because a certain number of patients constantly complained of this symptom. Measurements of circumference might help in the diagnosis of LE onset, but this method is not specific enough because these measurements are also affected by various factors. However, BIA and skin and subcutaneous ultrasound were identified as potential tools for the early detection of LE.

Interrater and Intrarater Reliability of Subcutaneous Echogenicity Grade and Subcutaneous Echo-Free Space Grade in Breast Cancer-Related Lymphedema

Background: Subcutaneous echogenicity grade (SEG) and subcutaneous echo-free space (SEFS) grade allow semiquantitation of nonspecific subcutaneous tissue inflammation and fluid accumulation in breast cancer-related lymphedema. However, inter- and intrarater reliability of SEG and SEFS is yet to be reported. The objective of this study is to assess inter-rater and intrarater reliability of SEG and SEFS in patients with breast cancer-related lymphedema. Methods and Results: Two physiatrists performed SEG and SEFS grade to determine inter-rater and intrarater reliability. Inter-rater reliability for SEG and SEFS was excellent (Kappa [K] = 0.836, weighted Kappa [K_w] = 0.85; K = 0.884, K_w = 0.92). K and K_w values of SEG and SEFS grading systems indicated excellent intrarater reliability (K = 0.81, K_w = 0.83; K = 0.798, K_w = 0.82). This trial is registered with Clinicaltrials.gov, under number NCT03559296. Conclusions: Based on the findings of this study, SEG and SEFS demonstrated acceptable reliability. SEG and SEFS appear to be reliable and useful grading systems for the assessment of breast cancer-related lymphedema.

Aggressive Decongestion in Limbs with Lymphedema without Subcutaneous Echo-Free Space

BACKGROUND

To study the impact of aggressive decongestion in limbs with lymphedema without subcutaneous echo-free space (SEFS) in subcutaneous tissue ultrasonography.

METHODS

In 13 patients with arm lymphedema (ALE) (13 arms) and 16 patients with leg lymphedema (LLE) (18 legs) without SEFS, an aggressive decongestion was performed as the first phase of complex decongestive therapy. Measurements of circumference and calculation of limb volume were performed before and after the treatment.

RESULTS

In ALE, no significant reduction in arm volume (median -63 [range -251 to 176] mL) or edema ratio (-4 [-15 to 12]%) was confirmed. On the other hand, a small but significant reduction in leg volume (-207 [-834 to 131] mL, P < 0.001) and edema ratio (-4 [-14 to 2]%, P < 0.01) was confirmed in LLE.

CONCLUSION

In limbs with lymphedema without SEFS, the impact of aggressive decongestion seemed limited.

Local Echo-Free Space in a Limb with Lymphedema Represents Extracellular Fluid in the Entire Limb

BACKGROUND

We previously reported that local subcutaneous echo-free space (SEFS) in the leg was stirringly correlated with extracellular fluid (ECF) status in the same part of the leg when assessed using bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). In this study, we examined whether local SEFS represents the ECF status in the entire limb.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In 51 legs and 40 arms with lymphedema (LE), subcutaneous tissue ultrasonography was performed to determine SEFS severity (range, 0-2). BIA was also performed to calculate the L-Dex^® score (LDS), which is a BIA-derived parameter to represent ECF status, for the arm and modified LDS (mLDS) for the leg (the right arm was used as a reference instead of the contralateral leg). SEFS severity in any part of the leg showed good correlation with mLDS, but that in the lateral lower calf showed the strongest correlation (ρ = 0.86). In contrast, only SEFS severity in the medial forearm showed good correlation with LDS (ρ = 0.74).

CONCLUSIONS

Local SEFS may represent ECF status in the entire limb in both the leg and arm LE.

Objective assessment of leg edema using ultrasonography with a gel pad

Ultrasonography (US) is useful for visual detection of edematous tissues to assess subcutaneous echogenicity. However, visualization of subcutaneous echogenicity is interpreted differently among operators because the evaluation is subjective and individual operators have unique knowledge. This study objectively assessed leg edema using US with a gel pad including fat for normalization of echogenicity in subcutaneous tissue. Five younger adults and four elderly people with leg edema were recruited. We compared assessments of US and limb circumference before and after the intervention of vibration to decrease edema in younger adults, and edema prior to going to sleep and reduced edema in the early morning in elderly people. These assessments were performed twice in elderly people by three operators and reliability, interrater differences, and bias were assessed. For US assessment, echogenicity in subcutaneous tissue was normalized to that of the gel pad by dividing the mean echogenicity of subcutaneous tissue by the mean echogenicity of the gel pad. In younger adults, the normalized subcutaneous echogenicity before the intervention was significantly higher than that after the intervention. In elderly people, echogenicity indicating edema was significantly higher than that after edema reduction. Edema was detected with accuracy rates of 76.9% in younger adults and 75.0% in elderly people. Meanwhile, limb circumference could be used to detect edema in 50.0% of healthy adults and 87.8% of elderly people. The intra-reliability was excellent (intraclass correlation coefficient > 0.9, p < 0.01), and the inter-reliability was good (intraclass correlation coefficient > 0.7, p < 0.01) for normalized subcutaneous echogenicity. Bland-Altman plots revealed that inter-rater differences and systematic bias were small. Normalized subcutaneous echogenicity with the pad can sensitively and objectively assess leg edema with high reliability. Therefore, this method has the potential to become a new gold standard for objective assessment of leg edema in clinical practice.