Effects of measurement methods for tibial rotation axis on the morphometry in Korean populations by gender

A Validated, Automated, 3-Dimensional Method to Reliably Measure Tibial Torsion

BACKGROUND

Tibial torsion is a twist in the tibia measured as an angle between a proximal axis line and a distal axis line. Abnormal torsion has been associated with a variety of painful clinical syndromes of the lower limb. Measurements of normal tibial torsion reported by different authors vary by 100% (ranging from 20° to 42°), making it impossible to determine normal and pathological levels.

PURPOSE

To address the problem of unreliable measurements, this study was conducted to define an automated, validated computer method to calculate tibial torsion. Reliability was compared with current clinical methods. The difference between measurements of torsion generated from computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans of the same bone, and between males and females, was assessed.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Previous methods of analyzing tibial torsion were reviewed, and limitations were identified. An automated measurement method to address these limitations was defined. A total of 56 cadaveric and patient tibiae (mean ± SD age, 37 ± 15 years; range, 17-71 years; 28 female) underwent CT scanning, and 3 blinded assessors made torsion measurements by applying 2 current clinical methods and the automated method defined in the present article. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) values were calculated. Further, 12 cadaveric tibiae were scanned by MRI, stripped of tissue, and measured using a structured light (SL) scanner. Differences between torsion values obtained from CT, SL, and MRI scans, and between males and females, were compared using t tests. SPSS was used for all statistical analysis.

RESULTS

When the automated method was used, the tibiae had a mean external torsion of 29°± 11° (range, 9°-65). Automated torsion assessment had excellent reliability (ICC, 1), whereas current methods had good reliability (ICC, 0.78-0.81). No significant difference was found between the torsion values calculated from SL and CT (P = .802), SL and MRI (P = .708), or MRI and CT scans (P = .826).

CONCLUSION

The use of software to automatically perform measurements ensures consistency, time efficiency, validity, and accuracy not possible with manual measurements, which are dependent on assessor experience.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

We recommend that this method be adopted in clinical practice to establish databases of normal and pathological tibial torsion reference values and ultimately guide management of related conditions.

Morphologic difference and size mismatch in the medial and lateral tibial condyles exist with respect to gender for unicompartmental knee arthroplasty in the Korean population

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to characterize the geometry of the proximal tibia in both genders in the Korean population. Anthropometric data on the medial and lateral tibial condyles of the osteoarthritic knees of 149 males and 814 females were obtained using three-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging.

METHODS

In the medial and lateral proximal tibial condyles, the anteroposterior (AP) dimension, widest dimension (WD) at defined points, and condylar aspect ratio were evaluated. These measurements were compared with similar dimensions of the tibial components from five commonly used unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) designs in Korea.

RESULTS

Both the AP dimension and WD in the medial and lateral tibial condyles of the male patients were significantly greater than those of the female patients (P < 0.05). In addition, the AP dimension and WD were greater in the medial than in the lateral tibial condyle (P < 0.05). There was WD overhang in three and two prostheses in the medial and lateral tibial condyles, respectively. A decrease in the condylar aspect ratio with an increasing AP dimension was found in the medial and lateral tibial condyles for both the male and female patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Smaller medial and lateral tibial condylar dimensions are more frequent in Korean women than in Korean men. This study highlights the finding that conventional UKA designs lead to size mismatch in the Korean population and may indicate an important guideline on proper gender-specific UKA tibial prostheses with different WD/AP dimension aspect ratios. In addition, this study suggests that the shape of the medial tibial plateau is different to that of the lateral plateau, which can lead to a mediolateral overhang for medial UKA in an attempt to optimize the AP coverage.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Morphometric study of gender difference in osteoarthritis posterior tibial slope using three-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging

Posterior tibial slope (PTS) is an important parameter of sagittal alignment associated with postoperative stability and kinematics after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, data are limited regarding the innate gender differences in PTS in Koreans. The current study separately measured the PTS of the medial and lateral tibial plateau on magnetic resonance images of 511 patients with knee joint osteoarthritis who had Kellgren and Lawrence grade 3 and 4 (430 women, 81 men) and compared the measurements between and within the genders. The tibia was then rotated to the tibial plateau with the tibial centroid axis and the PTS was evaluated from best-fit planes on the surface of the proximal tibia and individually for the medial, lateral, and overall plateaus. The average overall PTS was 10.0° ± 3.5°. The average overall PTS of the female and male patients was 10.2° ± 3.4° and 8.8° ± 4.0°, respectively. The average medial PTS was 10.4° ± 4.0°, significantly greater than the mean lateral PTS of 8.7° ± 3.9° (P < 0.05). The average medial and lateral tibial slopes for female patients were 10.7° ± 3.8° and 8.8° ± 3.8°, respectively, while the average medial and lateral tibial slopes for male patients were 8.9° ± 4.8° and 7.9° ± 4.7°, respectively. The medial and overall PTS were significantly greater in female patients than in male patients (P < 0.05). The results showed a gender difference in PTS and that medial PTS was greater than lateral PTS. These findings have clinical relevance in knee reconstructive surgery for determining ideal placement of the posterior slope tibial component. Surgeons should be aware of variability and gender differences in the tibial slope of patients undergoing TKA.

Prediction of wear performance in femoral and tibial conformity in patient-specific cruciate-retaining total knee arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Articular surface curvature design is important in tibiofemoral kinematics and the contact mechanics of total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Thus far, the effects of articular surface curvature have not been adequately discussed with respect to conforming, nonconforming, and medial pivot designs in patient-specific TKA. Therefore, this study evaluates the underlying relationship between the articular surface curvature geometry and the wear performance in patient-specific TKA.

METHODS

We compare the wear performances between conventional and patient-specific TKA under gait loading conditions using a computational simulation. Patient-specific TKAs investigated in the study are categorized into patient-specific TKA with conforming articular surfaces, medial pivot patient-specific TKA, and bio-mimetic patient-specific TKA with a patient's own tibial and femoral anatomy. The geometries of the femoral components in patient-specific TKAs are identical.

RESULTS

The anterior-posterior and internal-external kinematics change with respect to different TKA designs. Moreover, the contact pressure and area did not directly affect the wear performance. In particular, conforming patient-specific TKAs exhibit the highest volumetric wear and wear rate. The volumetric wear in a conforming patient-specific TKA is 29% greater than that in a medial pivot patient-specific TKA.

CONCLUSION

The findings in this study highlight that conformity changes in the femoral and tibial inserts influence the wear performance in patient-specific TKA. Kinematics and contact parameters should be considered to improve wear performance in patient-specific TKA. The conformity modification in the tibiofemoral joint changes the kinematics and contact parameters, and this affects wear performance.

Influence of Preservation of Normal Knee Contact Stress on Other Compartments with respect to the Tibial Insert Design for Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty

Recent advances in imaging technology and additive manufacturing have led to the introduction of customized unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) that can potentially improve functional performance due to customized geometries, including customized sagittal and coronal curvature and enhanced bone preservation. The purpose of this study involved evaluating the biomechanical effect of the tibial insert design on the customized medial UKA using computer simulations. We developed sagittal and coronal curvatures in a native knee mimetic femoral component design. We utilized three types of tibial insert design: flat, anatomy mimetic, and conforming design. We evaluated contact stress on the tibial insert and other compartments, including the lateral meniscus and articular cartilage, under gait and squat loading conditions. For the conforming UKA design, the tibial insert and lateral meniscus exhibited the lowest contact stress under stance phase gait cycle. However, for the conforming UKA design, the tibial insert and lateral meniscus exhibited the highest contact stress under swing phase gait cycle. For the flat UKA design, the articular cartilage exhibited the lowest contact stress under gait and squat loading conditions. The anatomy mimetic UKA design exhibited the most normal-like contact stress on the other compartments under gait and squat loading conditions. The results reveal the importance of conformity between the femoral component and the tibial insert in the customized UKA. Based on the results on the femoral component as well as the tibial insert in the customized UKA, the anatomy mimetic design preserves normal knee joint biomechanics and thus may prevent progressive osteoarthritis of the other knee compartments.

Gender differences in morphology exist in posterior condylar offsets of the knee in Korean population

PURPOSE

This study aimed to analyze the morphometric data from magnetic resonance images of arthritic knees in Korean adults, and to identify the existence of morphological differences of femoral posterior condylar offset (PCO) between genders.

METHODS

The differences in anthropometric PCO data in 975 patients (825 female and 150 male) were evaluated. The distances from the anterior and posterior femoral shaft cortex line to the most posterior femoral condyle tangent line were defined as the anterior-posterior dimension (AP) and the PCO. The PCO ratio (PCOR) was calculated as PCO/AP.

RESULTS

The medial PCO was greater than the lateral PCO (26.3 ± 2.2 vs. 24.3 ± 2.3 mm, p < 0.01). This difference was observed in both female patients (medial: 26.2 ± 2.2 mm vs. lateral: 24.2 ± 2.2 mm, p < 0.01) and male patients (medial: 26.8 ± 2.3 mm vs. lateral: 24.8 ± 2.4 mm, p < 0.01). The medial and lateral PCO values were also greater in male patients than in female ones (p < 0.01). In contrast, PCOR was greater in female patients than in male ones, both in the medial and lateral femoral condyles (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

It was shown that medial and lateral PCO and PCOR were asymmetric, and that there was gender difference in Korean population in our study. In addition, our data showed that the PCOR of contemporary TKAs may be small for Asian patients that may not be sufficient to meet the needs of the Korean patient population. These results confirm that a gender-specific femoral component design is necessary to recreate the PCO for male and female Asian populations.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Non-consecutive patients, Level III.

Prediction of Wear on Tibial Inserts Made of UHMWPE, PEEK, and CFR-PEEK in Total Knee Arthroplasty Using Finite-Element Analysis

The wear of tibial inserts in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) remains a major limitation of longevity. However, wear tests are expensive and time-consuming. Computational wear prediction using a finite-element (FE) model followed by validation through comparison with experimental data is effective for assessing new prosthetic designs or materials prior to functional testing and surgical implementation. In this study, the kinematics, volumetric wear, and wear depth of tibial inserts made of different materials (ultrahigh-molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE), polyetheretherketone (PEEK), and carbon fiber-reinforced PEEK (CFR–PEEK)) in TKA were evaluated by employing FE models and analysis. The differences among the materials were evaluated using adaptive wear modeling to predict the wear depth, volumetric wear, and kinematics under a gait loading condition. The volumetric wear and wear depth of the CFR–PEEK decreased by 87.4% and 61.3%, respectively, compared with those of the UHMWPE, whereas the PEEK exhibited increased volumetric wear and wear depth. These results suggest that CFR–PEEK is a good alternative to UHMWPE as a promising and suitable material for tibial inserts used in TKA. However, orthopedic research should be performed to evaluate the threshold conditions and appropriate applications for the newly developed and introduced biomaterial.

Computational analysis of customized cruciate retaining total knee arthroplasty restoration of native knee joint biomechanics

The purpose of this study was to verify if customized prosthesis better preserves the native knee joint kinematics and provides lower contact stress on the polyethylene (PE) insert owing to the wider bone preservation than that of standard off-the-shelf prosthesis in posterior cruciate-retaining type total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Validated finite element (FE) models for were developed to evaluate the knee joint kinematics and contact stress on the PE insert after TKA with customized and standard off-the-shelf (OTS) prostheses as well as in normal healthy knee through FE analysis under dynamic loading conditions. The contact stresses on the customized prosthesis decreased by 18% and 8% under gait cycle loading conditions, and 24% and 9% under deep-knee-bend loading conditions, in the medial and lateral sides of the PE insert, respectively, compared with the standard OTS prosthesis. The anterior-posterior translation and internal-external (IE) rotation in customized TKA were more similar to native knee joint behaviors compared with standard OTS TKA under gait loading conditions. The difference from normal knee kinematics was lower for femoral rollback and IE rotation in customized TKA than in standard OTS TKA in the deep-knee-bend condition. In general, customized prostheses achieve kinematics that are close to those of the native healthy knee joint and have better contact stresses than standard OTS prostheses in gait and deep-knee-bend loading conditions.

Effect of Post-Cam Design for Normal Knee Joint Kinematic, Ligament, and Quadriceps Force in Patient-Specific Posterior-Stabilized Total Knee Arthroplasty by Using Finite Element Analysis

The purpose of this study is to investigate post-cam design via finite element analysis to evaluate the most normal-like knee mechanics. We developed five different three-dimensional computational models of customized posterior-stabilized (PS) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) involving identical surfaces with the exception of the post-cam geometry. They include flat-and-flat, curve-and-curve (concave), curve-and-curve (concave and convex), helical, and asymmetrical post-cam designs. We compared the kinematics, collateral ligament force, and quadriceps force in the customized PS-TKA with five different post-cam designs and conventional PS-TKA to those of a normal knee under deep-knee-bend conditions. The results indicated that femoral rollback in curve-and-curve (concave) post-cam design exhibited the most normal-like knee kinematics, although the internal rotation was the closest to that of a normal knee in the helical post-cam design. The curve-and-curve (concave) post-cam design showed a femoral rollback of 4.4 mm less than the normal knee, and the helical post-cam design showed an internal rotation of 5.6° less than the normal knee. Lateral collateral ligament and quadriceps forces in curve-and-curve (concave) post-cam design, and medial collateral ligament forces in helical post-cam design were the closest to that of a normal knee. The curve-and-curve (concave) post-cam design showed 20% greater lateral collateral ligament force than normal knee, and helical post-cam design showed medial collateral ligament force 14% greater than normal knee. The results revealed the variation in each design that provided the most normal-like biomechanical effect. The present biomechanical data are expected to provide useful information to improve post-cam design to restore normal-like knee mechanics in customized PS-TKA.