Quantification of zinc toxicity using neuronal networks on microelectrode arrays

Developmental conditions and culture medium influence the neuromodulated response of in vitro cortical networks

Goal of this work is to show how the developmental conditions of in vitro neuronal networks influence the effect of drug delivery. The proposed experimental neuronal model consists of dissociated cortical neurons plated to Micro-Electrode Arrays (MEAs) and grown according to different conditions (i.e., by varying both the adopted culture medium and the number of days needed to let the network grow before performing the chemical modulation). We delivered rising amount of bicuculline (BIC), a competitive antagonist of GABAA receptors, and we computed the firing rate dose-response curve for each culture. We found that networks matured in BrainPhys for 18 days in vitro exhibited a decreasing firing trend as a function of the BIC concentration, quantified by an average IC50 (i.e., half maximal inhibitory concentration) of 4.64 ± 4.02 µM. On the other hand, both cultures grown in the same medium for 11 days, and ones matured in Neurobasal for 18 days displayed an increasing firing rate when rising amounts of BIC were delivered, characterized by average EC50 values (i.e., half maximal excitatory concentration) of 0.24 ± 0.05 µM and 0.59 ± 0.46 µM, respectively.Clinical Relevance- This research proves the relevance of the experimental factors that can influence the network development as key variables when developing a neuronal model to conduct drug delivery in vitro, simulating the in vivo environment. Our findings suggest that not considering the consequences of the chosen growing conditions when performing in vitro pharmacological studies could lead to incomplete predictions of the chemically induced alterations.

Modularity and neuronal heterogeneity: Two properties that influence in vitro neuropharmacological experiments

Introduction

The goal of this work is to prove the relevance of the experimental model (in vitro neuronal networks in this study) when drug-delivery testing is performed.

Methods

We used dissociated cortical and hippocampal neurons coupled to Micro-Electrode Arrays (MEAs) arranged in different configurations characterized by modularity (i.e., the presence of interconnected sub-networks) and heterogeneity (i.e., the co-existence of neurons coming from brain districts). We delivered increasing concentrations of bicuculline (BIC), a neuromodulator acting on the GABAergic system, and we extracted the IC₅₀ values (i.e., the effective concentration yielding a reduction in the response by 50%) of the mean firing rate for each configuration.

Results

We found significant lower values of the IC₅₀ computed for modular cortical-hippocampal ensembles than isolated cortical or hippocampal ones.

Discussion

Although tested with a specific neuromodulator, this work aims at proving the relevance of ad hoc experimental models to perform neuropharmacological experiments to avoid errors of overestimation/underestimation leading to biased information in the characterization of the effects of a drug on neuronal networks.

The Effects of Acute GABA Treatment on the Functional Connectivity and Network Topology of Cortical Cultures

γ-Aminobutyric acid (GABA) is an inhibitory transmitter, acting on receptor channels to reduce neuronal excitability in matured neural systems. However, electrophysiological responses of whole neuronal ensembles to the exposure to GABA are still unclear. We used micro-electrode arrays (MEAs) to study the effects of the increasing amount of GABA on functional network of cortical neural cultures. Then the recorded data were analyzed by the cross-covariance analysis and graph theory. Results showed that after the GABA treatment, the activity parameters of firing rate, bursting rate, bursting duration and network burst frequency in neural cultures decreased as expected. In addition, the functional connectivity also decreased in similarity, network density, and the size of the largest component. However, small-worldness was not found to be influenced by the acute GABA treatment. Our results support the position that using graph theory to evaluate the functional connectivity of neural cultures may enhance understanding of the pharmacological impact of neurotransmitters on neuronal networks.

Effects of antiepileptic drugs on hippocampal neurons coupled to micro-electrode arrays

Hippocampal networks exhibit spontaneous electrophysiological activity that can be modulated by pharmacological manipulation and can be monitored over time using Micro-Electrode Arrays (MEAs), devices composed by a glass substrate and metal electrodes. The typical mode of activity of these dissociated cultures is the network-wide bursting pattern, which, if properly chemically modulated, can recall the ictal events of the epileptic phenotypes and is well-suited to study the effects of antiepileptic compounds. In this paper, we analyzed the changes induced by Carbamazepine (CBZ) and Valproate (VPA) on mature networks of hippocampal neurons in “control” condition (i.e., in the culturing medium) and upon treatment with the pro-convulsant bicuculline (BIC). We found that, in both control and BIC—treated networks, high doses (100 μM–1 mM) of CBZ almost completely suppressed the spiking and bursting activity of hippocampal neurons. On the contrary, VPA never completely abolish the electrophysiological activity in both experimental designs. Interestingly, VPA cultures pre-treated with BIC showed dual effects. In fact, in some cultures, at low VPA concentrations (100 nM–1 μM), we observed decreased firing/bursting levels, which returned to values comparable to BIC-evoked activity at high VPA concentrations (100 μM–1 mM). In other cultures, VPA reduced BIC-evoked activity in a concentration-independent manner. In conclusion, our study demonstrates that MEA-coupled hippocampal networks are responsive to chemical manipulations and, upon proper pharmacological modulation, might provide model systems to detect acute pharmacological effects of antiepileptic drugs.

d-Methionine protects against cisplatin-induced neurotoxicity in cortical networks

Cisplatin is a platinum-based chemotherapeutic agent widely used for the treatment of various types of cancer. Patients undergoing cisplatin treatment often suffer from a condition known as "chemobrain", ototoxicity, peripheral neuropathy, weight loss, nausea, vomiting, nephrotoxicity, seizures, hearing loss and tinnitus. d-Methionine (d-Met), a sulfur-containing nucleophilic antioxidant, has been shown to prevent cisplatin-induced side effects in animals without antitumor interference. In this study, we have used an in vitro model of cortical networks (CNs), enriched in auditory cortex cells; to quantify cisplatin neurotoxicity and the protective effects of d-Met. Dissociated neurons from auditory cortices of mouse embryos were grown on microelectrode arrays with 64 transparent indium-tin oxide electrodes, which enabled continuous optical and electrophysiological monitoring of network neurons. Cisplatin at 0.10-0.25 mM induced up to a 200% increase in spontaneous spiking activity, while concentrations at or above 0.5mM caused irreversible loss of neuronal activity, accompanied by cell death. Pretreatment with d-Met, at a concentration of 1.0mM, prevented the cisplatin-induced excitation at 0.10-0.25 mM, caused sustained excitation without occurrence of cell death at 0.5mM, and delayed cell death at 0.75 mM cisplatin. l-Methionine, the optical isomer, showed lower potency and less efficacy than d-Met, was less protective against 0.1mM cisplatin, and proved ineffective at a concentration of 0.5mM cisplatin. Pre-exposure time of d-Met was associated with the protective effects at 0.1 and 0.5mM cisplatin, with longer pre-exposure times exhibiting better protection. This study quantifies as a function of concentration and time that d-Met protects central nervous system tissue from acute cisplatin toxicity.

Microfabricated electrochemical cell-based biosensors for analysis of living cells in vitro

Cellular biochemical parameters can be used to reveal the physiological and functional information of various cells. Due to demonstrated high accuracy and non-invasiveness, electrochemical detection methods have been used for cell-based investigation. When combined with improved biosensor design and advanced measurement systems, the on-line biochemical analysis of living cells in vitro has been applied for biological mechanism study, drug screening and even environmental monitoring. In recent decades, new types of miniaturized electrochemical biosensor are emerging with the development of microfabrication technology. This review aims to give an overview of the microfabricated electrochemical cell-based biosensors, such as microelectrode arrays (MEA), the electric cell-substrate impedance sensing (ECIS) technique, and the light addressable potentiometric sensor (LAPS). The details in their working principles, measurement systems, and applications in cell monitoring are covered. Driven by the need for high throughput and multi-parameter detection proposed by biomedicine, the development trends of electrochemical cell-based biosensors are also introduced, including newly developed integrated biosensors, and the application of nanotechnology and microfluidic technology.

Measurement of synchronous activity by microelectrode arrays uncovers differential effects of sublethal and lethal glutamate concentrations on cortical neurons

We grew cultures of rat cortical cells on microelectrode arrays to investigate the effects of glutamate-mediated neurotoxicity as a model of traumatic brain injury. Treatment with two different concentrations of glutamate, 175 and 250 μM, led to different outcomes. Cultures treated with 250 μM glutamate suffered a loss in overall activity that was not seen in cultures treated with 175 μM glutamate. An analysis of the changes in the synchronization of action potential firing between electrodes, however, revealed a loss of synchronization in subsets of electrode pairs treated with both the higher and lower concentrations of glutamate. We found that this loss of action potential synchronization was dependent on the initial amount of synchronization prior to injury. Finally, our data suggest that the synchronization of electrical activity as well as the susceptibility to loss of firing synchrony is independent of the distance between neurons in a network.

Feasibility Assessment of Micro-Electrode Chip Assay as a Method of Detecting Neurotoxicity in vitro

Detection and characterization of chemically induced toxic effects in the nervous system represent a challenge for the hazard assessment of chemicals. In vivo, neurotoxicological assessments exploit the fact that the activity of neurons in the central and peripheral nervous system has functional consequences. And so far, no in vitro method for evaluating the neurotoxic hazard has yet been validated and accepted for regulatory purpose. The micro-electrode array (MEA) assay consists of a culture chamber into which an integrated array of micro-electrodes is capable of measuring extracellular electrophysiology (spikes and bursts) from electro-active tissues. A wide variety of electrically excitable biological tissues may be placed onto the chips including primary cultures of nervous system tissue. Recordings from this type of in vitro cultured system are non-invasive, give label free evaluations and provide a higher throughput than conventional electrophysiological techniques. In this paper, 20 substances were tested in a blinded study for their toxicity and dose-response curves were obtained from fetal rat cortical neuronal networks coupled to MEAs. The experimental procedure consisted of evaluating the firing activity (spiking rate) and modification/reduction in response to chemical administration. Native/reference activity, 30 min of activity recording per dilution, plus the recovery points (after 24 h) were recorded. The preliminary data, using a set of chemicals with different mode-of-actions (13 known to be neurotoxic, 2 non-neuroactive and not toxic, and 5 non-neuroactive but toxic) show good predictivity (sensitivity: 0.77; specificity: 0.86; accuracy: 0.85). Thus, the MEA with a neuronal network has the potency to become an effective tool to evaluate the neurotoxicity of substances in vitro.

Development of micro-electrode array based tests for neurotoxicity: assessment of interlaboratory reproducibility with neuroactive chemicals

Neuronal assemblies within the nervous system produce electrical activity that can be recorded in terms of action potential patterns. Such patterns provide a sensitive endpoint to detect effects of a variety of chemical and physical perturbations. They are a function of synaptic changes and do not necessarily involve structural alterations. In vitro neuronal networks (NNs) grown on micro-electrode arrays (MEAs) respond to neuroactive substances as well as the in vivo brain. As such, they constitute a valuable tool for investigating changes in the electrophysiological activity of the neurons in response to chemical exposures. However, the reproducibility of NN responses to chemical exposure has not been systematically documented. To this purpose six independent laboratories (in Europe and in USA) evaluated the response to the same pharmacological compounds (Fluoxetine, Muscimol, and Verapamil) in primary neuronal cultures. Common standardization principles and acceptance criteria for the quality of the cultures have been established to compare the obtained results. These studies involved more than 100 experiments before the final conclusions have been drawn that MEA technology has a potential for standard in vitro neurotoxicity/neuropharmacology evaluation. The obtained results show good intra- and inter-laboratory reproducibility of the responses. The consistent inhibitory effects of the compounds were observed in all the laboratories with the 50% Inhibiting Concentrations (IC(50)s) ranging from: (mean ± SEM, in μM) 1.53 ± 0.17 to 5.4 ± 0.7 (n = 35) for Fluoxetine, 0.16 ± 0.03 to 0.38 ± 0.16 μM (n = 35) for Muscimol, and 2.68 ± 0.32 to 5.23 ± 1.7 (n = 32) for Verapamil. The outcome of this study indicates that the MEA approach is a robust tool leading to reproducible results. The future direction will be to extend the set of testing compounds and to propose the MEA approach as a standard screen for identification and prioritization of chemicals with neurotoxicity potential.

Application of micro-electrode arrays (MEAs) as an emerging technology for developmental neurotoxicity: evaluation of domoic acid-induced effects in primary cultures of rat cortical neurons

Due to lack of knowledge only a few industrial chemicals have been identified as developmental neurotoxicants. Current developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) guidelines (OECD and EPA) are based entirely on in vivo studies that are both time consuming and costly. Consequently, there is a high demand to develop alternative in vitro methods for initial screening to prioritize chemicals for further DNT testing. One of the most promising tools for neurotoxicity assessment is the measurement of neuronal electrical activity using micro-electrode arrays (MEAs) that provides a functional and neuronal specific endpoint that until now has been used mainly to detect acute neurotoxicity. Here, electrical activity measurements were evaluated to be a suitable endpoint for the detection of potential developmental neurotoxicants. Initially, primary cortical neurons grown on MEA chips were characterized for different cell markers over time, using immunocytochemistry. Our results show that primary cortical neurons could be a promising in vitro model for DNT testing since some of the most critical neurodevelopment processes such as progenitor cell commitment, proliferation and differentiation of astrocytes and maturation of neurons are present. To evaluate if electrical activity could be a suitable endpoint to detect chemicals with DNT effects, our model was exposed to domoic acid (DomA), a potential developmental neurotoxicant for up to 4 weeks. Long-term exposure to a low concentration (50nM) of DomA increased the basal spontaneous electrical activity as measured by spike and burst rates. Moreover, the effect induced by the GABA(A) receptor antagonist bicuculline was significantly lower in the DomA treated cultures than in the untreated ones. The MEA measurements indicate that chronic exposure to DomA changed the spontaneous electrical activity leading to the possible neuronal mal functioning. The obtained results suggest that the MEAs could be a useful tool to identify compounds with DNT potential.

Free zinc ions outside a narrow concentration range are toxic to a variety of cells in vitro

The zinc(II) ion has recently been implicated in a number of novel functions and pathologies in loci as diverse as the brain, retina, small intestine, prostate, heart, pancreas, and immune system. Zinc ions are a required nutrient but elevated concentrations are known to kill cells in vitro. Paradoxical observations regarding zinc's effects have appeared frequently in the literature, and often their physiological relevance is unclear. We found that for PC-12, HeLa and HT-29 cell lines as well as primary cultures of cardiac myocytes and neurons in vitro in differing media, approximately 5 nmol/L free zinc (pZn = 8.3, where pZn is defined as--log(10) [free Zn(2+)]) produced apparently healthy cells, but 20-fold higher or (in one case) lower concentrations were usually harmful as judged by multiple criteria. These results indicate that (1) the free zinc ion levels of media should be controlled with a metal ion buffer; (2) adding zinc or strong zinc ligands to an insufficiently buffered medium may lead to unpredictably low or high free zinc levels that are often harmful to cells; and (3) it is generally desirable to measure free zinc ion levels due to the presence of contaminating zinc in many biochemicals and unknown buffering capacity of many media.

Microelectrode arrays: a physiologically based neurotoxicity testing platform for the 21st century

Microelectrode arrays (MEAs) have been in use over the past decade and a half to study multiple aspects of electrically excitable cells. In particular, MEAs have been applied to explore the pharmacological and toxicological effects of numerous compounds on spontaneous activity of neuronal and cardiac cell networks. The MEA system enables simultaneous extracellular recordings from multiple sites in the network in real time, increasing spatial resolution and thereby providing a robust measure of network activity. The simultaneous gathering of action potential and field potential data over long periods of time allows the monitoring of network functions that arise from the interaction of all cellular mechanisms responsible for spatio-temporal pattern generation. In these functional, dynamic systems, physical, chemical, and pharmacological perturbations are holistically reflected by the tissue responses. Such features make MEA technology well suited for the screening of compounds of interest, and also allow scaling to high throughput systems that can record from multiple, separate cell networks simultaneously in multi-well chips or plates. This article is designed to be useful to newcomers to this technology as well as those who are currently using MEAs in their research. It explains how MEA systems operate, summarizes what systems are available, and provides a discussion of emerging mathematical schemes that can be used for a rapid classification of drug or chemical effects. Current efforts that will expand this technology to an influential, high throughput, electrophysiological approach for reliable determinations of compound toxicity are also described and a comprehensive review of toxicological publications using MEAs is provided as an appendix to this publication. Overall, this article highlights the benefits and promise of MEA technology as a high throughput, rapid screening method for toxicity testing.

A new target for amyloid beta toxicity validated by standard and high-throughput electrophysiology

Background

Soluble oligomers of amyloid beta (Aβ) are considered to be one of the major contributing factors to the development of Alzheimer's disease. Most therapeutic development studies have focused on toxicity directly at the synapse.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Patch clamp studies detailed here have demonstrated that soluble Aβ can also cause functional toxicity, namely it inhibits spontaneous firing of hippocampal neurons without significant cell death at low concentrations. This toxicity will eventually lead to the loss of the synapse as well, but may precede this loss by a considerable amount of time. In a key technological advance we have reproduced these results utilizing a fast and simple method based on extracellular electrophysiological recording of the temporal electrical activity of cultured hippocampal neurons using multielectrode arrays (MEAs) at low concentrations of Aβ (1–42). We have also shown that this functional deficit can be reversed through use of curcumin, an inhibitor of Aβ oligomerization, using both analysis methods.

Conclusions/Significance

The MEA recording method utilized here is non-invasive, thus long term chronic measurements are possible and it does not require precise positioning of electrodes, thus it is ideal for functional screens. Even more significantly, we believe we have now identified a new target for drug development for AD based on functional toxicity of hippocampal neurons that could treat neurodegenerative diseases prior to the development of mild cognitive impairment.

Agarose microwell based neuronal micro-circuit arrays on microelectrode arrays for high throughput drug testing

For cell-based biosensor applications, dissociated neurons have been cultured on planar microelectrode arrays (MEAs) to measure the network activity with substrate-embedded microelectrodes. There has been a need for a multi-well type platform to reduce the data collection time and increase the statistical power for data analysis. This study presents a novel method to convert a conventional MEA into a multi-well MEA with an array of micrometre-sized neuronal culture ('neuronal micro-circuit array'). An MEA was coated first with cell-adhesive layer (poly-D-lysine) which was subsequently patterned with a cell-repulsive layer (agarose hydrogel) to both pattern the cell adhesive region and isolate neuronal micro-circuits from each other. For a few weeks, primary hippocampal neurons were cultured on the agarose microwell MEA and the development of spontaneous electrical activities were characterized with extracellular action potentials. Using neurotransmission modulators, the simultaneous monitoring of drug responses from neuronal micro-circuit arrays was also demonstrated. The proposed approach will be powerful for neurobiological functional assay studies or neuron-based biosensor fields which require repeated trials to obtain a single data point due to biological variations.

Magnetic stimulation and depression of mammalian networks in primary neuronal cell cultures

For transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), the coupling of induced electric fields with neurons in gray matter is not well understood. There is little information on optimal stimulation parameters and on basic cellular mechanisms. For this reason, magnetic stimulation of spontaneously active neuronal networks, grown on microelectrode arrays in culture, was employed as a test environment. This allowed use of smaller coils and the continual monitoring of network action potential (AP) activity before, during, and for long periods after stimulation. Biphasic, rectangular, and 500 micros long pulses were used at mean pulse frequencies (MPFs) ranging from 3 to 100 Hz on both spinal cord (SC) and frontal cortex (FC) cultures. Contrary to stimulation of organized fiber bundles, APs were not elicited directly. Responses were predominantly inhibitory, dose dependent, with onset times between 10 s and several minutes. Spinal networks showed a greater sensitivity to activity suppression. Under pharmacological disinhibition, some excitation was seen at low pulse frequencies. FC cultures showed greater excitatory responses than SC networks. The observed primary inhibitory responses imply interference with synaptic exocytosis mechanisms. With 20,000 pulses at 10 Hz, 40% inhibition was maintained for over 30 min with full recovery, suggesting possible application to nonchemical, noninvasive pain management.