Data to inform counseling on parathyroidectomy for secondary hyperparathyroidism of renal origin

Predictive Risk Score for Postparathyroidectomy Hungry Bone Syndrome in Patients With Secondary Hyperparathyroidism

PURPOSE

Secondary hyperparathyroidism (SHPT) frequently affects patients with end-stage renal disease. Hungry bone syndrome (HBS) is a common complication among patients who undergo parathyroidectomy for SHPT and may cause prolonged hospitalization or require intensive care. The objective of this study is to develop a scoring system to stratify patients according to their risk of developing HBS.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was performed using the US Renal Data System (2010-2021). Univariable and multivariable logistic regression models were developed and weighted β-coefficients from the multivariable model were used to construct a risk score for the development of HBS. Positive and negative predictive values were assessed.

RESULTS

Of 17 074 patients who underwent parathyroidectomy for SHPT, 19.4% developed HBS. Intensive care unit admission was more common in patients who developed HBS (33.5% vs 24.6%, P < .001). On multivariable logistic regression analysis, younger age, renal osteodystrophy, longer duration of dialysis, longer duration of kidney transplant, and higher Elixhauser score were significantly associated with HBS. A risk score based on these clinical factors was developed, with a total of 6 possible points. Rates of HBS ranged from 8% in patients with 0 points to 44% in patients with 6 points. The risk score had a poor positive predictive value (20.3%) but excellent negative predictive value (89.3%) for HBS.

CONCLUSION

We developed a weighted risk score that effectively stratifies patients by risk for developing HBS after parathyroidectomy. This tool can be used to counsel patients and to identify patients who may not require postoperative hospitalization.

A Novel Risk Score to Predict Hungry Bone Syndrome After Parathyroidectomy for Renal Hyperparathyroidism

OBJECTIVE

Hungry bone syndrome (HBS) is a known complication of parathyroidectomy. Patients with renal hyperparathyroidism are particularly vulnerable to HBS because of their prolonged exposure to electrolyte abnormalities and elevated parathyroid hormone (PTH). However, in-depth characterization of predictive factors for HBS in these patients is lacking.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was performed of patients with renal hyperparathyroidism who underwent parathyroidectomy at a single institution from 2011-2021. Patient demographics, clinical characteristics, and biochemical data were collected and analyzed. Boruta and binary logistic regression analyses were used to develop a scoring system.

RESULTS

Thirty-three patients were identified; 16 (48%) developed HBS. Patients with HBS had significantly higher preoperative levels of serum PTH (mean difference [MS] = 2167.2 pg/mL, P <.001), phosphorus (MD = 3.5 mg/dl, P <.001), and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) (MD = 344.2 U/L, P =.002) and significantly lower levels of preoperative serum calcium (MD = -0.96 mg/dL, P =.004). Stepwise regression analysis identified elevated ALP (>150 U/L) and markedly elevated PTH (>1000 pg/mL) as positive predictors of HBS. A two-point scoring system with these 2 variables had overall diagnostic accuracy of 96.8% (sensitivity 100% and specificity 94.1%) with 1 point conferring 93.8% positive predictive value and 2 points conferring 100% positive predictive value.

CONCLUSION

Preoperative serum PTH and ALP are significantly associated with HBS in patients with renal hyperparathyroidism undergoing parathyroidectomy for renal hyperparathyroidism. A scoring system with these 2 variables may be of clinical utility in predicting patients at high risk of HBS.

Forestalling Hungry Bone Syndrome after Parathyroidectomy in Patients with Primary and Renal Hyperparathyroidism

Hungry bone syndrome (HBS), severe hypocalcemia following parathyroidectomy (PTX) due to rapid drop of PTH (parathormone) after a previous long term elevated concentration in primary (PHPT) or renal hyperparathyroidism (RHPT), impairs the outcome of underlying parathyroid disease.

OBJECTIVE

overview HBS following PTx according to a dual perspective: pre- and post-operative outcome in PHPT and RHPT. This is a case- and study-based narrative review.

INCLUSION CRITERIA

key research words "hungry bone syndrome" and "parathyroidectomy"; PubMed access; in extenso articles; publication timeline from Inception to April 2023.

EXCLUSION CRITERIA

non-PTx-related HBS; hypoparathyroidism following PTx. We identified 120 original studies covering different levels of statistical evidence. We are not aware of a larger analysis on published cases concerning HBS (N = 14,349). PHPT: 14 studies (N = 1545 patients, maximum 425 participants per study), and 36 case reports (N = 37), a total of 1582 adults, aged between 20 and 72. Pediatric PHPT: 3 studies (N = 232, maximum of 182 participants per study), and 15 case reports (N = 19), a total of 251 patients, aged between 6 and 18. RHPT: 27 studies (N = 12,468 individuals, the largest cohort of 7171) and 25 case reports/series (N = 48), a total of 12,516 persons, aged between 23 and 74. HBS involves an early post-operatory (emergency) phase (EP) followed by a recovery phase (RP). EP is due to severe hypocalcemia with various clinical elements (<8.4 mg/dL) with non-low PTH (to be differentiated from hypoparathyroidism), starting with day 3 (1 to 7) with a 3-day duration (up to 30) requiring prompt intravenous calcium (Ca) intervention and vitamin D (VD) (mostly calcitriol) replacement. Hypophosphatemia and hypomagnesiemia may be found. RP: mildly/asymptomatic hypocalcemia controlled under oral Ca+VD for maximum 12 months (protracted HBS is up to 42 months). RHPT associates a higher risk of developing HBS as compared to PHPT. HBS prevalence varied from 15% to 25% up to 75-92% in RHPT, while in PHPT, mostly one out of five adults, respectively, one out of three children and teenagers might be affected (if any, depending on study). In PHPT, there were four clusters of HBS indicators. The first (mostly important) is represented by pre-operatory biochemistry and hormonal panel, especially, increased PTH and alkaline phosphatase (additional indicators were elevated blood urea nitrogen, and a high serum calcium). The second category is the clinical presentation: an older age for adults (yet, not all authors agree); particular skeleton involvement (level of case reports) such as brown tumors and osteitis fibrosa cystica; insufficient evidence for the patients with osteoporosis or those admitted for a parathyroid crisis. The third category involves parathyroid tumor features (increased weight and diameter; giant, atypical, carcinomas, some ectopic adenomas). The fourth category relates to the intra-operatory and early post-surgery management, meaning an associated thyroid surgery and, maybe, a prolonged PTx time (but this is still an open issue) increases the risk, as opposite to prompt recognition of HBS based on calcium (and PTH) assays and rapid intervention (specific interventional protocols are rather used in RHPT than in PHPT). Two important aspects are not clarified yet: the use of pre-operatory bisphosphonates and the role of 25-hydroxyitamin D assay as pointer of HBS. In RHPT, we mentioned three types of evidence. Firstly, risk factors for HBS with a solid level of statistical evidence: younger age at PTx, pre-operatory elevated bone alkaline phosphatase, and PTH, respectively, normal/low serum calcium. The second group includes active interventional (hospital-based) protocols that either reduce the rate or improve the severity of HBS, in addition to an adequate use of dialysis following PTx. The third category involves data with inconsistent evidence that might be the objective of future studies to a better understanding; for instance, longer pre-surgery dialysis duration, obesity, an elevated pre-operatory calcitonin, prior use of cinalcet, the co-presence of brown tumors, and osteitis fibrosa cystica as seen in PHPT. HBS remains a rare complication following PTx, yet extremely severe and with a certain level of predictability; thus, the importance of being adequately identified and managed. The pre-operatory spectrum of assessments is based on biochemistry and hormonal panel in addition to a specific (mostly severe) clinical presentation while the parathyroid tumor itself might provide useful insights as potential risk factors. Particularly in RHPT, prompt interventional protocols of electrolytes surveillance and replacement, despite not being yet a matter of a unified, HBS-specific guideline, prevent symptomatic hypocalcemia, reduce the hospitalization stay, and the re-admission rates.