Polymerase chain reaction diagnosis in fungal keratitis caused by Alternaria alternata

Evaluation of a commercial NGS service for detection of bacterial and fungal pathogens in infectious ulcerative keratitis

OBJECTIVES

To compare results from a commercial next-generation sequencing (NGS) service to corneal cytology and culture for identification of causative organisms in veterinary patients presenting for infectious ulcerative keratitis (IUK).

PROCEDURE

Swabs for corneal aerobic and fungal cultures and DNA swabs for NGS were submitted for canine and equine normal controls (n = 11 and n = 4, respectively) and IUK patients (n = 22 and n = 8, respectively) for which microbrush cytology specimens confirmed the presence of infectious organisms. The sensitivity of the NGS results was compared with bacterial and fungal culture results. Concordance between the NGS and culture results was determined.

RESULTS

The NGS results were positive for bacterial and fungal organisms in 5 and 1 normal and 18 and 1 IUK cases, respectively. Bacterial and fungal cultures were positive for 7 and 2 normal and 20 and 5 IUK cases, respectively. Sensitivity of NGS was 82.14% (95% confidence interval (CI), 63.11% to 93.94%) and specificity was 76.47% (95% CI, 50.10% to 93.19%). Concordance (complete and partial) between identified bacterial and fungal organisms was found in 79% and 100% of cases, respectively. NGS identified organisms in 3 culture-negative IUK samples.

CONCLUSION

A commercial NGS service may be useful in the identification of causative agents in IUK cases with a sensitivity greater than the sensitivity previously reported for aerobic culture. Further testing is needed to determine the clinical significance of additional organisms isolated by NGS from infected cases, as well as organisms isolated from normal corneas.

Filamentous fungal infections of the cornea: a global overview of epidemiology and drug sensitivity

Fungal keratitis is a serious suppurative, usually ulcerative corneal infection which may result in blindness or reduced vision. Epidemiological studies indicate that the occurrence of fungal keratitis is higher in warm, humid regions with agricultural economy. The most frequent filamentous fungal genera among the causal agents are Fusarium, Aspergillus and Curvularia. A more successful therapy of fungal keratitis relies on precise identification of the pathogen to the species level using molecular tools. As the sequence analysis of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of the ribosomal RNA gene cluster (rDNA) is not discriminative enough to reveal a species-level diagnosis for several filamentous fungal species highly relevant in keratitis infections, analysis of other loci is also required for an exact diagnosis. Molecular identifications may also reveal the involvement of fungal species which were not previously reported from corneal infections. The routinely applied chemotherapy of fungal keratitis is based on the topical and systemic administration of polyenes and azole compounds. Antifungal susceptibility testing of the causal agents is of special importance due to the emergence and spread of resistance. Testing the applicability of further available antifungals and screening for new, potential compounds for the therapy of fungal keratitis are of highlighted interest.

Clinical characteristics of alternaria keratitis

Purpose. Alternaria spp. are an uncommon cause of mycotic keratitis. Previous studies on Alternaria keratitis have generally been limited to case reports. We examined the clinical characteristics of Alternaria keratitis in this study. Methods. The characteristics and outcomes of 7 patients with culture-proven Alternaria keratitis treated in our hospital were compared with 25 previously reported cases. Results. The risk factors for Alternaria keratitis were trauma in 5 patients and soft contact lenses in 1 patient. Six patients with early diagnosis (<2 weeks) were cured with medical antimicrobial treatment; a patch graft was required in 1 patient with perforation. When incorporated with previous reports on Alternaria keratitis (n = 32), 14 (44%) infections followed trauma, 10 (31%) were associated with preexisting corneal disease or previous ocular surgery, and 5 (16%) occurred in soft contact lens wearers. Successful medical treatment was achieved in 23 (72%) patients, including 10 out of 21 eyes (48%) treated with natamycin and/or amphotericin B. Therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty was performed in 9 (28%) cases. Conclusions. Alternaria keratitis is generally associated with specific risk factors and responds to medical treatment when early diagnosis is performed and prompt antifungal treatment is initiated.

PCR for the molecular diagnosis of mycotic keratitis

Mycotic keratitis, an infection of the cornea caused by fungi, is a medical emergency, with patients presenting with considerable pain and distress. For effective management of the condition, a specific diagnosis must be made rapidly to permit early initiation of antifungal therapy. Currently, direct microscopic examination and culture of corneal material constitute the 'gold standard' for diagnosis. However, rapid, sensitive yet specific tests are needed to detect a small number of, or nonviable, fungi. PCR has many potential advantages when used as a diagnostic aid for mycotic keratitis; the present review covers these advantages, and possible limitations. An expert assessment is also made of studies that have used PCR for the diagnosis of mycotic keratitis. The review concludes with a Five-year view of the potential impact of PCR in management of mycotic keratitis.

Prospective comparison between conventional microbial work-up vs PCR in the diagnosis of fungal keratitis

PURPOSE

The PCR was compared with routine microbial studies for the detection of fungal pathogens in clinically suspected fungal keratitis.

METHODS

A prospective nonrandomized study was undertaken at a tertiary eye care centre to evaluate 30 eyes of 30 patients with presumed fungal keratitis, both fresh and treated. Corneal scrapings were performed on each patient. The specimens were analysed by a semi-nested PCR assay using fungal-specific primers. PCR products were cloned and sequenced for identification, and compared with a conventional microbial work-up (smear and culture).

RESULTS

Of the 30 samples, the PCR showed positivity in 93.3%, culture in 40%, and potassium hydroxide in 20%. Of the 28 PCR-positive cases, 12 were culture-positive and 16 were culture-negative. Two samples were both PCR and culture test negative. Culture-negative samples were PCR-positive in 16 of 18 (88.9%) cases. The PCR did not yield any false-negative findings in a culture-positive specimen. Both common and uncommon aetiologic fungi have been identified by DNA sequencing analysis.

CONCLUSION

The PCR was able to detect fungal DNA in a high proportion of culture-negative cases. Technical considerations of the PCR process include extraction of artifacts and amplification of non-pathogenic DNA. Nonetheless, our findings suggest that the PCR can be a useful adjunct to smear and culture in the rapid diagnosis of fungal keratitis, particularly in cases of failed detection from routine procedures.

Evaluation of molecular diagnosis in fungal keratitis. Ten years of experience

Purpose

The aims of this study were to assess the utility of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in diagnosing fungal keratitis in the last decade in our center and to review the molecular diagnosis of mycotic keratitis.

Methods

A retrospective nonrandomized investigation was undertaken at Vissum Corporación Instituto Oftalmologico de Alicante to evaluate 27 corneal samples of 20 patients with proven fungal keratitis from January 2000 to December 2009. Corneal samples (21 corneal scrapings, 5 biopsies, and 1 cornea) were evaluated by Gram stain or calcofluor stain, culture, and PCR. The detection and molecular identification were carried out by DNA amplification and sequencing of the internal transcribed spacer and 5.8S rRNA region from the corneal samples.

Results

PCR detected all the samples that were positive by conventional methods. Four samples were positive by PCR and showed negative results by culture and stain. Combination of microscopy and culture gave positive results in 21 of the 27 samples of patients with mycotic keratitis. Stains showed a 66.7% of positive results, culture showed 59.3%, and PCR showed 92.6%. The time taken for PCR assay was 4 to 8 h whereas positive fungal cultures took 1 to 35 days. Identification at species level by molecular methods was possible in all cases except one. Identification at species level by conventional methods only was possible in eight cases.

Conclusions

PCR not only proved to be an effective rapid method for the diagnosis of fungal keratitis but was also more sensitive than stain and culture methods. Fungal PCR must be added as the screening diagnosis test when an early mycotic keratitis is suspected. Molecular identification is the gold standard technique for the identification of corneal fungal pathogens.

Molecular characterization of Alternaria alternata causing ocular infection: detection of IGS-RFLP intraspecific polymorphism

A case of fungal keratitis is presented in which corneal scrapings were obtained for microbiological studies, including morphological identification and molecular characterization of the etiologic agent. Comparative sequence analyses of the Internal Transcribed Spacer domain of 5.8S and 26S regions of nuclear rDNA showed 100% identity with different species of Alternaria and PCR-RFLP analysis of Intergenic Spacer regions revealed intraspecific variation. The combination of morphological and molecular characters resulted in the unambiguous identification of the causal agent as Alternaria alternata. Treatment with antifungals contributed to the improvement in the patient's lesions.

Sensitive and rapid polymerase chain reaction based diagnosis of mycotic keratitis through single stranded conformation polymorphism

PURPOSE

To report a method for early and correct diagnosis of mycotic keratitis.

DESIGN

Clinical laboratory diagnostic study.

METHODS

Corneal scraping of all the four patients were processed for DNA extraction which were amplified by fungal specific primers of internal transcribed spacer region I (ITS1). These products were sequenced and analyzed by single stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) for species identification.

RESULTS

The DNA samples from corneal scrapings of all the four patients were successfully amplified by the primer pair ITS1 and ITS2 and similarity/dissimilarity were established by Jaccard's coefficient. Patient isolate 1 was identified as Nectria hematococca, isolate 2 as Candida albicans, and isolates 3 and 4 were identified as Bipolaris papendorfii. This led to prompt initiation of antifungal therapy in all the four cases where useful vision could be restored.

CONCLUSIONS

Early and correct diagnosis of mycotic keratitis by polymerase chain reaction could be obtained in all the four cases compared with conventional methods, which helped in the prompt initiation of antifungal therapy in patients.

Use of PCR targeting of internal transcribed spacer regions and single-stranded conformation polymorphism analysis of sequence variation in different regions of rrna genes in fungi for rapid diagnosis of mycotic keratitis

The increased incidence of fungal infections in the recent past has been attributed to the increase in the number of human immunodeficiency virus-positive and AIDS patients. Early diagnosis of mycoses in patients is crucial for prompt antifungal therapy. Immunological methods of diagnosis have not been found to be satisfactory, and recent research has been diverted to the use of PCR for the sensitive and early diagnosis at the molecular level. In the present study we targeted different regions of the rRNA gene to diagnose cases of mycotic keratitis and identify the causal agents. Six fungus-specific primers (primers ITS1, ITS2, ITS3, ITS4, invSR1R, and LR12R) were used, and the amplified products were analyzed by single-stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis. Dendrograms of these SSCP patterns, prepared on the basis of Jaccard's coefficient, indicated that the PCR products obtained with primer pair ITS1 and ITS2 were the best for the identification of fungi. The results were confirmed by sequencing of the PCR products, and the approach was successfully tested experimentally for the detection of mycotic keratitis caused by Aspergillus fumigatus and was used for the diagnosis of fungal corneal ulcers in patients.

Antifungal therapy for keratomycoses

Keratomycoses have recently emerged as an important cause of ocular morbidity, especially in third-world countries. Available antifungal agents are limited in their efficacy, due to limited penetration into the cornea, the fungistatic nature and the development of drug resistance. Effective usage of the available drugs is hampered by the inefficiency of currently available antibiotic sensitivity tests for fungal organisms. There is also limited knowledge regarding the ideal combination(s) of antifungal agents, including issues of synergism and antagonism. Despite these problems, recent publications indicate encouraging outcomes in the treatment of a large series of fungal keratitis. Advances include better drug formulations, new agents and novel methods of drug delivery into the eye. As our ability to deal with advanced fungal keratitis remains limited, the importance of early diagnosis has been stressed and molecular biological techniques may play an important role in the future. This article summarises the important new advances in these areas in the past 2 years and provides guidelines for the management of these serious corneal infections.

Fungal infections of the cornea

PURPOSE

To describe key aspects of fungal infections of the cornea, which constitute an important eye problem in outdoor workers in tropical and subtropical regions.

METHODS

Review of published studies and personal observations.

OBSERVATIONS

Fungal infections of the cornea are frequently caused by species of Fusarium, Aspergillus, Curvularia, and Candida. Trauma is the most important predisposing cause; ocular and systemic defects and prior application of corticosteroids are also important risk factors. Culture remains the cornerstone of diagnosis; direct microscopic detection of fungal structures in corneal scrapes or biopsies permits a rapid presumptive diagnosis. A variety of antifungals have been evaluated in therapy of this condition. Natamycin can only be given topically, while amphotericin B, miconazole, ketoconazole, itraconazole, and fluconazole can be administered by various routes. Topical amphotericin B (0.1-0.3%) is frequently the treatment of choice for infections due to Candida and related fungi, while topical natamycin (5%) is the choice for keratitis due to filamentous fungi. Medical therapy may fail, necessitating surgical intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

Fungal infections of the cornea continue to be an important cause of ocular morbidity, particularly in the agricultural communities of the developing world. A proper understanding of agent and host factors involved in these infections will improve the outcome of this condition.

Current perspectives on ophthalmic mycoses

Fungi may infect the cornea, orbit and other ocular structures. Species of Fusarium, Aspergillus, Candida, dematiaceous fungi, and Scedosporium predominate. Diagnosis is aided by recognition of typical clinical features and by direct microscopic detection of fungi in scrapes, biopsy specimens, and other samples. Culture confirms the diagnosis. Histopathological, immunohistochemical, or DNA-based tests may also be needed. Pathogenesis involves agent (invasiveness, toxigenicity) and host factors. Specific antifungal therapy is instituted as soon as the diagnosis is made. Amphotericin B by various routes is the mainstay of treatment for life-threatening and severe ophthalmic mycoses. Topical natamycin is usually the first choice for filamentous fungal keratitis, and topical amphotericin B is the first choice for yeast keratitis. Increasingly, the triazoles itraconazole and fluconazole are being evaluated as therapeutic options in ophthalmic mycoses. Medical therapy alone does not usually suffice for invasive fungal orbital infections, scleritis, and keratitis due to Fusarium spp., Lasiodiplodia theobromae, and Pythium insidiosum. Surgical debridement is essential in orbital infections, while various surgical procedures may be required for other infections not responding to medical therapy. Corticosteroids are contraindicated in most ophthalmic mycoses; therefore, other methods are being sought to control inflammatory tissue damage. Fungal infections following ophthalmic surgical procedures, in patients with AIDS, and due to use of various ocular biomaterials are unique subsets of ophthalmic mycoses. Future research needs to focus on the development of rapid, species-specific diagnostic aids, broad-spectrum fungicidal compounds that are active by various routes, and therapeutic modalities which curtail the harmful effects of fungus- and host tissue-derived factors.

Rapid molecular diagnosis of posttraumatic keratitis and endophthalmitis caused by Alternaria infectoria

The first case of Alternaria infectoria ocular infection is reported. Keratitis and endophthalmitis developed after eye-perforating trauma from a lemon tree branch. Two months after surgery and empirical steroid and antibiotic treatment, diagnosis by molecular methods was performed. PCR amplification was positive for a fungus after 4 h. Antifungal treatment with amphotericin B and fluconazole was initiated immediately. DNA sequence analysis showed Alternaria infectoria to be the causal agent. After topical and systemic administration of antifungal treatment, ocular inflammation disappeared and visual acuity improved. DNA typing was found to be a useful tool to achieve early identification of the causal agent.