Studies on the Interaction between Regulatory Enzymes and Effectors

Kinetic study on the dimer-tetramer interconversion of glycogen phosphorylase a

Kinetic theory of dissociating enzyme systems has been applied to a study of the dimer-tetramer interconversion of glycogen phosphorylase a. All kinetic constants for the dissociating-associating reaction of phosphorylase a have been determined. The results indicate that (a) the presence of glucose-1-phosphate has no influence on either the rate of dissociation or the rate of association, and hence does not shift the dimer-tetramer equilibrium of phosphorylase a; (b) the binding og glycogen to the enzyme decreases the association rate of the dimer to form the tetramer, but has no effect on the dissociation rate of the tetramer; (c) both the dimeric and tetrameric form of phosphorylase a can bind glycogen, but the tetrameric form has a lower affinity for glycogen and is catalytically inactive.

Structural mechanism for glycogen phosphorylase control by phosphorylation and AMP

The crystal structures of activated R state glycogen phosphorylase a (GPa) and R and T state glycogen phosphorylase b (GPb) complexed with AMP have been solved at 2.9 A, 2.9 A and 2.2 A resolution, respectively. The structure of R state GPa is nearly identical to the structure of sulphate-activated R state GPb, except in the region of Ser14, where there is a covalently attached phosphate group in GPa and a non-covalently attached sulphate group in GPb. The contacts made by the N-terminal tail residues in R state GPa at the subunit interface of the functionally active dimer are similar to those observed previously for T state GPa. The quaternary and tertiary structural changes on the T to R transition allow these interactions to be relayed to the catalytic site in R state GPa. The transition from the T state GPb structure to the R state GPa structure results in a change in the N-terminal residues from a poorly ordered extended structure that makes intrasubunit contacts to an ordered coiled conformation that makes intersubunit contacts. The distance between Arg10, the first residue to be located from the N terminus, in R state GPa and T state GPb is 50 A. One of the important subunit-subunit interactions in the dimer molecule involves contacts between the helix alpha 2 and the cap' (residues 35' to 45' that form a loop between the 1st and 2nd alpha helices, alpha 1' and alpha 2' of the other subunit. The prime denotes residues from the other subunit). The interactions made by the N-terminal residues induce structural changes at the cap'/alpha 2 helix interface that lead to the creation of a high-affinity AMP site. The tertiary structural changes at the cap (shifts 1.2 to 2.1 A for residues 35 to 45) are partially compensated by the quaternary structural change so that the overall shifts in these residues after the combined tertiary and quaternary changes are between 0.5 and 1.3 A. AMP binds to R state GPb with at least 100-fold greater affinity and exhibits four additional hydrogen bonds, stronger ionic interactions and more extensive van der Waals' interactions with 116 A2 greater solvent accessible surface area buried compared with AMP bound to T state GPb.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

AMP interaction sites in glycogen phosphorylase b. A thermodynamic analysis

The binding of AMP to activator site N and to inhibitor site I in glycogen phosphorylase b has been characterized by calorimetry, potentiometry and ultracentrifugation in the pH range 6.5-7.5 at 25 degrees C (mu = 0.1). Calorimetric titration data of phosphorylase b with adenosine 5'-phosphoramidate are also reported at pH 6.9 (T = 25 degrees C, mu = 0.1). Calorimetric curves have been analyzed on the basis of potentiometric and sedimentation velocity results to determine thermodynamic quantities for AMP binding to the enzyme. The comparison of calorimetric titration data of AMP and adenosine 5'-phosphoramidate at pH 6.9 supports the hypothesis previously suggested that the dianionic phosphate form of the nucleotide preferentially binds to the allosteric activator site. The thermodynamic parameters for AMP binding to site N are as follows: delta G0 = -22 kJ mol-1, delta H0 = -34 kJ mol-1 and delta S0 = -40 J mol-1 K-1. The binding of the nucleotide to site I was found to be strongly dependent on the pH. This behaviour may be explained in terms of coupled protonations of three groups having pKa values of 6.0, 6.0 and 6.1 in the unbound form and 7.0, 7.5 and 7.2 in the enzyme-nucleotide complex. The thermodynamic parameters for nucleotide binding to site I for the enzymatic form in which all the modified groups are completely deprotonated or protonated have been calculated to be: delta G0 = -7.7 kJ mol-1, delta H0 = -28 kJ mol-1 and delta S0 = -68 J mol-1 K-1 and delta G0 = -28 kJ mol-1, delta H0H = -10 kJ mol-1 and delta S0H = 61 J mol-1 K-1, respectively. These results suggest that attractive dispersion forces are of primary significance for AMP binding to activator site N, although electrostatic interactions act as a stabilizing factor in the nucleotide binding. The protonation states of those residues of which the pKa values are modified by AMP binding to site I highly influence the thermodynamic parameters for the nucleotide binding to this site.

Comparison of AMP and NADH binding to glycogen phosphorylase b

The binding sites for the allosteric activator, AMP, to glycogen phosphorylase b are described in detail utilizing the more precise knowledge of the native structure obtained from crystallographic restrained least-squares refinement than has hitherto been available. Localized conformational changes are seen at the allosteric effector site that include shifts of between 1 and 2 A for residues Tyr75 and Arg309 and very small shifts for the region of residues 42 to 44 from the symmetry-related subunit. Kinetic studies demonstrate that NADH inhibits the AMP activation of glycogen phosphorylase b. Crystallographic binding studies at 3.5 A resolution show that NADH binds to the same sites on the enzyme as AMP, i.e. the allosteric effector site N, which is close to the subunit-subunit interface, and the nucleoside inhibitor site I, which is some 12 A from the catalytic site. The conformations of NADH at the two sites are different but both conformations are "folded" so that the nicotinamide ring is close (approx. 6 A) to the adenine ring. These conformations are compared with those suggested from solution studies and with the extended conformations observed in the single crystal structure of NAD+ and for NAD bound to dehydrogenases. Possible mechanisms for NADH inhibition of phosphorylase activation are discussed.

The thermodynamics of nucleotide binding to proteins

Models describing the interaction of a small molecule with a protein are typically couched in terms of the stoichiometry, cooperativity, and binding free-energy change. These parameters are readily available from equilibrium dialysis experiments (or appropriate variations). With the recent advent of extremely sensitive calorimeters, it is possible to obtain thermal data for the binding reaction and, thus, the entire set of thermodynamic parameters, delta G', delta H', delta S', delta C', become readily available. This review is limited to the binding of nucleotides and nucleotide analogs to proteins for which complete thermal data are available. While the majority of such systems have been characterized by calorimetry, we have not excluded, per se, van't Hoff enthalpy determinations. The systems we have considered include, but are not limited to, thymidylate synthetase, phosphorylase, several dehydrogenases, aldolase, glutamine synthetase, hemoglobin, asparate transcarbamylase, and ribonuclease. A variety of forces contribute to the total free-energy change upon ligand binding. These forces include ionic, van der Waals, hydrogen bond, and hydrophobic. In several cases, properly designed experiments have allowed a partial resolution of the individual contributions of these various forces. Variation of easily accessible conditions such as temperature, pH, ionic strength, or solvent third component produce changes in the set of thermodynamic parameters which lead to the resolution of the forces. The generality of heat effects makes this method very useful for studying the involvement of protons in binding reactions. The variation in the magnitude and direction (release or uptake) of the proton flux is readily studied by determining the apparent heat of reaction at constant pH, ionic strength, and temperature in two or more buffers of differing heat of ionization. This application has been exploited in several cases and is examined in great detail. An overview of the results in these systems to date suggests that several trends observed in the thermodynamic parameters need to be confirmed by further experimentation and, if they hold, an appropriate theoretical basis must be developed to aid in their interpretation.

Thermodynamics of nucleotides binding to phosphorylase b

The effects of several chemical modifications in the AMP molecule on its interaction with phosphorylase b are examined by microcalorimetry, equilibrium dialysis, light scattering and ultracentrifuge experiments. In this work we report the results obtained for eight AMP analogues corresponding to different substituents in the puric base or in the ribose, or to different positions of the phosphate. The thermodynamic properties of the interaction between the phosphorylase b and the above mentioned nucleotides are also reported. The following conclusions were obtained: a) Except for IMP and 2'dIMP all the nucleotides studied clearly show two types of binding sites in the enzyme. b) The interaction of the nucleotide with its weaker affinity binding site is highly dependent upon chemical alterations in the puric base. c) Both the amino group in C(6) and the N(1) of the adenine in the AMP seem to play an important role in the conformational transitions induced by the nucleotide on the enzyme. d) The tetramerization of phosphorylase b in the presence of 10(-2) M AMP and in the conditions of the ultracentrifuge experiments is drastically affected by modifications in the ribose-phosphate part of the AMP molecule.

Comparative study of the effect of 5' AMP and its analogs on rabbit glycogen phosphorylase b isoenzymes

A comparative study of the effect of AMP and other nucleotides on the different rabbit glycogen phosphorylase b isoenzymes has been made: muscle, brain, liver isoenzymes, and the hybrid species between muscle and brain isoenzyme. We have studied either the direct kinetic effect of the different nucleotides or the action of the nucleotides on the b to a conversion rate. Muscle, brain, and muscle--brain isoenzymes are very strongly and very specifically activated by AMP and its analogs, whereas liver isoenzyme is not very sensitive to the nucleotides. However, muscle, brain and muscle--brain isoenzymes show slight but very interesting differences in their kinetic properties. These differences allow some speculations about the conformational state of these different isoenzymes.

Conformations of purine ribosyl 5'-nucleotides bound to glycogen phosphorylase b. A proton T2 relaxation time investigation

The conformation of 5'-nucleotides in the active site of glycogen phosphorylase b has been deduced from linewidth measurements of protons H-1', H-8 and H-2. It is shown by selective deuteration of the purine ring in position 8 that the orientation of the base is anti in the case of strong activators like AMP and syn in that of weak activators like IMP. The orientation correlation time of the nucleotides in the active site is nearly that of the enzyme, i.e. 160 ns at 21 degrees C.

AMP analogs: their function in the activation of glycogen phosphorylase b

A series of AMP analogs has been selected in order to better understand the structural requirements (a) for the efficient binding of the activator molecule at the correct site on phosphorylase b from rabbit skeletal muscle and (b) for the activation which is observed. Two types of activation are known, according to Black and Wang [J. Biol. Chem. 243, 5892-5898 (1968)]: either a cooperative response with respect to the activator concentration (like the one which is obtained for AMP itself) or a non-cooperative response observed in the case of IMP. It is shown that the 5'-phosphate moiety is absolutely required for the analog to bind at the correct site (adenine or adenosine bind at another enzymic site), and that the free enthalpy, delta G, corresponding to the association process varies in a complex manner with respect to the substitution of the different positions of the AMP molecule. Moreover, the differences delta G (analog) - delta G (AMP) = delta G obtained for two types of substitution separately do not add up to the same energy difference as the one obtained when the two substitutions are made simultaneously on the AMP molecule. It appears that all the mononucleotides which have been tested up to now may be divided into two classes. Class I (AMP class) is characterized, apart from a strong activation, by the following features: (a) one molecule of analog expels two molecules of bound glucose 6-phosphate as it binds on the enzyme; (b) bound analog protects slowly one crucial cysteinyl residue against attack by 5,5'-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) at 4 degrees C; (c) association of two molecules of dimer is strengthened at 4 degrees C in the presence of the analog. Class II (IMP class) is associated with a weak activation and with the following set of properties: (a) a single molecule of bound glucose 6-phosphate is released as the first molecule of analog binds on the dimer; (b) two slowly reacting cysteinyl residues per subunit are immediately protected against 5,5'-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) by the binding of the analog at 4 degrees C; (c) the analog dissociates the low amount of tetramer which is present at 4 degrees C in the absence of AMP into two molecules of dimer. These results are discussed according to a plausible scheme of transconformations taking place in glycogen phosphorylase b, a model which has been derived earlier by relaxation studies.

Structural and enzymatic properties of adenine 1-oxide nucleotides

We decribed the preparation of adenine 1-oxide nucleotides by oxidation of the natural compounds with monopermaleic acid in aqueous solutions at neutral pH, with an overall yield after chromatographic purification between 75 and 80%. If irradiated, the adenine 1-oxide nucleotides undergo a photochemical rearrangement reaction, the main photoproducts in aqueous solution at alkaline pH being the corresponding isoguanine nucleotides. The modified ring vibration pattern of the 1-oxide analogues as well as the 13C chemical shift indicate a loss of aromaticity as compared to the natural compounds. Coupling constant measurements show that the dihedral angle between the 31POC and OC13C planes is around 180degree, i.e., trans, as in the natural adenine nucleotides. The modified adenine nucleotides were tested as potential substrates and/or inhibitors of mitochondrial processes, as substrates of varous phosphotransferases from mitochondria or cytosol, and as allosteric effectors in the reactions catalyzed by glutamate dehydrogenase and phosphofructokinase. Although the adenine 1-oxide nucleotides are not recognized by the translocase system of the inner mitochondrial membrane, they are good substrates for mitochondrial phosphotransferases located in the intermembrane space. Similarly, they participate in the phosphoryl group transfer reactions catalyzed by pyruvate kinase, phosphofructokinase, and hexokinase. As allosteric effectors, the modified nucleotides are less active than the natural compounds, probably because of a lower binding capacity to the allosteric sites of the regulatory enzymes.