Hyperacetylation of core histones does not cause unfolding of nucleosomes. Neutron scatter data accords with disc shape of the nucleosome

Milestones in transcription and chromatin published in the Journal of Biological Chemistry

During Herbert Tabor's tenure as Editor-in-Chief from 1971 to 2010, JBC has published many seminal papers in the fields of chromatin structure, epigenetics, and regulation of transcription in eukaryotes. As of this writing, more than 21,000 studies on gene transcription at the molecular level have been published in JBC since 1971. This brief review will attempt to highlight some of these ground-breaking discoveries and show how early studies published in JBC have influenced current research. Papers published in the Journal have reported the initial discovery of multiple forms of RNA polymerase in eukaryotes, identification and purification of essential components of the transcription machinery, and identification and mechanistic characterization of various transcriptional activators and repressors and include studies on chromatin structure and post-translational modifications of the histone proteins. The large body of literature published in the Journal has inspired current research on how chromatin organization and epigenetics impact regulation of gene expression.

Histones: annotating chromatin

Chromatin is a highly regulated nucleoprotein complex through which genetic material is structured and maneuvered to elicit cellular processes, including transcription, cell division, differentiation, and DNA repair. In eukaryotes, the core of this structure is composed of nucleosomes, or repetitive histone octamer units typically enfolded by 147 base pairs of DNA. DNA is arranged and indexed through these nucleosomal structures to adjust local chromatin compaction and accessibility. Histones are subject to multiple covalent posttranslational modifications, some of which alter intrinsic chromatin properties, others of which present or hinder binding modules for non-histone, chromatin-modifying complexes. Although certain histone marks correlate with different biological outputs, we have yet to fully appreciate their effects on transcription and other cellular processes. Tremendous advancements over the past years have uncovered intriguing histone-related matters and raised important related questions. This review revisits past breakthroughs and discusses novel developments that pertain to histone posttranslational modifications and the affects they have on transcription and DNA packaging.

Functions of site-specific histone acetylation and deacetylation

Histone acetylation regulates many cellular processes, and specific acetylation marks, either singly or in combination, produce distinct outcomes. For example, the acetylation pattern on newly synthesized histones is important for their assembly into nucleosomes by histone chaperones. Additionally, the degree of chromatin compaction and folding may be regulated by acetylation of histone H4 at lysine 16. Histone acetylation also regulates the formation of heterochromatin; deacetylation of H4 lysine 16 is important for spreading of heterochromatin components, whereas acetylation of this site serves as a barrier to this spreading. Finally, histone acetylation is critical for gene transcription, but recent results suggest that deacetylation of certain sites also plays an important role. There are many histone acetyltransferases (HATs) and deacetylases, with differing preferences for the various histone proteins and for specific sites on individual histones. Determining how these enzymes create distinct acetylation patterns and regulate the functional outcome is an important challenge.

Dynamics of histone acetylation in vivo. A function for acetylation turnover?

Histone acetylation, discovered more than 40 years ago, is a reversible modification of lysines within the amino-terminal domain of core histones. Amino-terminal histone domains contribute to the compaction of genes into repressed chromatin fibers. It is thought that their acetylation causes localized relaxation of chromatin as a necessary but not sufficient condition for processes that repackage DNA such as transcription, replication, repair, recombination, and sperm formation. While increased histone acetylation enhances gene transcription and loss of acetylation represses and silences genes, the function of the rapid continuous or repetitive acetylation and deacetylation reactions with half-lives of just a few minutes remains unknown. Thirty years of in vivo measurements of acetylation turnover and rates of change in histone modification levels have been reviewed to identify common chromatin characteristics measured by distinct protocols. It has now become possible to look across a wider spectrum of organisms than ever before and identify common features. The rapid turnover rates in transcriptionally active and competent chromatin are one such feature. While ubiquitously observed, we still do not know whether turnover itself is linked to chromatin transcription beyond its contribution to rapid changes towards hyper- or hypoacetylation of nucleosomes. However, recent experiments suggest that turnover may be linked directly to steps in gene transcription, interacting with nucleosome remodeling complexes.

Histone acetylation and deacetylation: identification of acetylation and methylation sites of HeLa histone H4 by mass spectrometry

The acetylation isoforms of histone H4 from butyrate-treated HeLa cells were separated by C(4) reverse-phase high pressure liquid chromatography and by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Histone H4 bands were excised and digested in-gel with the endoprotease trypsin. Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry was used to characterize the level of acetylation, and nanoelectrospray tandem mass spectrometric analysis of the acetylated peptides was used to determine the exact sites of acetylation. Although there are 15 acetylation sites possible, only four acetylated peptide sequences were actually observed. The tetra-acetylated form is modified at lysines 5, 8, 12, and 16, the tri-acetylated form is modified at lysines 8, 12, and 16, and the di-acetylated form is modified at lysines 12 and 16. The only significant amount of the mono-acetylated form was found at position 16. These results are consistent with the hypothesis of a "zip" model whereby acetylation of histone H4 proceeds in the direction of from Lys-16 to Lys-5, and deacetylation proceeds in the reverse direction. Histone acetylation and deacetylation are coordinated processes leading to a non-random distribution of isoforms. Our results also revealed that lysine 20 is di-methylated in all modified isoforms, as well as the non-acetylated isoform of H4.

Residue-specific mass signatures for the efficient detection of protein modifications by mass spectrometry

Currently available mass spectrometric (MS) techniques lack specificity in identifying protein modifications because molecular mass is the only parameter used to characterize these changes. Consequently, the suspected modified peptides are subjected to tandem MS/MS sequencing that may demand more time and sample. We report the use of stable isotope-enriched amino acids as residue-specific "mass signatures" for the rapid and sensitive detection of protein modifications directly from the peptide mass map (PMM) without enrichment of the modified peptides. These mass signatures are easily recognized through their characteristic spectral patterns and provide fingerprints for peptides containing the same content of specific amino acid residue(s) in a PMM. Without the need for tandem MS/MS sequencing, a peptide and its modified form(s) can readily be identified through their identical fingerprints, regardless of the nature of modifications. In this report, we demonstrate this strategy for the detection of methionine oxidation and protein phosphorylation. More interestingly, the phosphorylation of a histone protein, H2A.X, obtained from human skin fibroblast cells, was effectively identified in response to low-dose radiation. In general, this strategy of residue-specific mass tagging should be applicable to other posttranslational modifications.

Retinoblastoma protein transcriptional repression through histone deacetylation of a single nucleosome

The retinoblastoma protein, pRb, controls transcription through recruitment of histone deacetylase to particular E2F-responsive genes. We determined the acetylation level of individual nucleosomes present in the cyclin E promoter of RB(+/+) and RB(-/-) mouse embryo fibroblasts. We also determined the effects of pRb on nucleosomal conformation by examining the thiol reactivity of histone H3 of individual nucleosomes. We found that pRb represses the cyclin E promoter through histone deacetylation of a single nucleosome, to which it and histone deacetylase 1 bind. In addition, the conformation of this nucleosome is modulated by pRb-directed histone deacetylase activity. Thus, the repressive role of pRb in cyclin E transcription and therefore cell cycle progression can be mapped to its control of the acetylation status and conformation of a single nucleosome.

Intrinsically disordered protein

Proteins can exist in a trinity of structures: the ordered state, the molten globule, and the random coil. The five following examples suggest that native protein structure can correspond to any of the three states (not just the ordered state) and that protein function can arise from any of the three states and their transitions. (1) In a process that likely mimics infection, fd phage converts from the ordered into the disordered molten globular state. (2) Nucleosome hyperacetylation is crucial to DNA replication and transcription; this chemical modification greatly increases the net negative charge of the nucleosome core particle. We propose that the increased charge imbalance promotes its conversion to a much less rigid form. (3) Clusterin contains an ordered domain and also a native molten globular region. The molten globular domain likely functions as a proteinaceous detergent for cell remodeling and removal of apoptotic debris. (4) In a critical signaling event, a helix in calcineurin becomes bound and surrounded by calmodulin, thereby turning on calcineurin's serine/threonine phosphatase activity. Locating the calcineurin helix within a region of disorder is essential for enabling calmodulin to surround its target upon binding. (5) Calsequestrin regulates calcium levels in the sarcoplasmic reticulum by binding approximately 50 ions/molecule. Disordered polyanion tails at the carboxy terminus bind many of these calcium ions, perhaps without adopting a unique structure. In addition to these examples, we will discuss 16 more proteins with native disorder. These disordered regions include molecular recognition domains, protein folding inhibitors, flexible linkers, entropic springs, entropic clocks, and entropic bristles. Motivated by such examples of intrinsic disorder, we are studying the relationships between amino acid sequence and order/disorder, and from this information we are predicting intrinsic order/disorder from amino acid sequence. The sequence-structure relationships indicate that disorder is an encoded property, and the predictions strongly suggest that proteins in nature are much richer in intrinsic disorder than are those in the Protein Data Bank. Recent predictions on 29 genomes indicate that proteins from eucaryotes apparently have more intrinsic disorder than those from either bacteria or archaea, with typically > 30% of eucaryotic proteins having disordered regions of length > or = 50 consecutive residues.

Salt-induced conformation and interaction changes of nucleosome core particles

Small angle x-ray scattering was used to follow changes in the conformation and interactions of nucleosome core particles (NCP) as a function of the monovalent salt concentration C(s). The maximal extension (D(max)) of the NCP (145 +/- 3-bp DNA) increases from 137 +/- 5 A to 165 +/- 5 A when C(s) rises from 10 to 50 mM and remains constant with further increases of C(s) up to 200 mM. In view of the very weak increase of the R(g) value in the same C(s) range, we attribute this D(max) variation to tail extension, a proposal confirmed by simulations of the entire I(q) curves, considering an ideal solution of particles with tails either condensed or extended. This tail extension is observed at higher salt values when particles contain longer DNA fragments (165 +/- 10 bp). The maximal extension of the tails always coincides with the screening of repulsive interactions between particles. The second virial coefficient becomes smaller than the hard sphere virial coefficient and eventually becomes negative (net attractive interactions) for NCP(145). Addition of salt simultaneously screens Coulombic repulsive interactions between NCP and Coulombic attractive interactions between tails and DNA inside the NCP. We discuss how the coupling of these two phenomena may be of biological relevance.

Dissecting long-range transcriptional mechanisms by chromatin immunoprecipitation

Analysis of physiological mechanisms that control transcription often requires extrapolation of in vitro measurements into in vivo mechanisms. This extrapolation is complex, as mammalian genes are commonly organized into broad chromosomal domains, and such domains cannot be readily reconstituted in vitro. Thus, the nucleoprotein structure of chromosomes constitutes a considerable impediment to elucidating transcriptional mechanisms. The development of assays to measure protein-DNA interactions and chromatin structure in living cells has greatly facilitated progress in understanding physiological transcriptional mechanisms. Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) is a powerful approach that allows one to define the interaction of factors with specific chromosomal sites in living cells, thereby providing a snapshot of the native chromatin structure and factors bound to genes in different functional states. ChIP involves treating cells or tissue briefly with formaldehyde to crosslink proteins to DNA. An antibody against a protein suspected of binding a given cis-element is then used to immunoprecipitate chromatin fragments. Polymerase chain reaction analysis of the immunoprecipitate with primers flanking the cis-element reveals whether a specific DNA sequence is recovered in an immune-specific manner and therefore whether the protein contacted the site in living cells. The central focus of this review is the use of ChIP to study transcriptional activation over long distances on chromosomes.

Histone acetylation beyond promoters: long-range acetylation patterns in the chromatin world

Histone acetylation is an important regulatory mechanism that controls transcription and diverse nuclear processes. While great progress has been made in understanding how localized acetylation and deacetylation control promoter activity, virtually nothing is known about the consequences of acetylation throughout entire chromosomal regions. An increasing number of genes have been found to reside in large chromatin domains that are controlled by regulatory elements many kilobases away. Recent studies have shown that broad histone acetylation patterns are hallmarks of chromatin domains. The purpose of this review is to discuss how such patterns are established and their implications for regulating gene expression.

The structure of the nucleosome core particle of chromatin in chicken erythrocytes visualized by using atomic force microscopy

The structure of the nucleosome core particle of chromatin in chicken erythrocytes has been examined by using AFM. The 146 bp of DNA wrapped twice around the core histone octamer are clearly visualized. Both the ends of entry/exit of linker DNA are also demonstrated. The dimension of the nucleosome core particles is approximately 1-4 nm in height and approximately 13-22 nm in width. In addition, superbeads (width of approximately 48-57 nm, height of approximately 2-3 nm) are occasionally revealed, two turns of DNA around the core particles are also detected.

The site of binding of linker histone to the nucleosome does not depend upon the amino termini of core histones

Using nucleosomes reconstituted on a defined sequence of DNA, we have investigated the question as to whether the N-terminal tails of core histones play a role in determining the site of binding of a linker histone. Reconstitutes used histone cores of three types: intact, lacking the N-terminal H3 tails, or lacking all tails. In each case the same, single defined position for the histone core was observed, using high-resolution mapping. The affinity for binding of linker histone H1(o) was highest for the intact cores, lowest for the tailless cores. However, the location of the linker histone, as judged by micrococcal nuclease protection, was exactly the same in each case, an asymmetric site of about 17 bp to one side of the core particle DNA.

Effect of in vivo histone hyperacetylation on the state of chromatin fibers

We evaluated the contribution of in vivo histone acetylation to the folding of chromatin into its higher-order structures. We have compared high-order folding patterns of hyperacetylated vs. unmodified chromatin in living green monkey kidney cells (CV1 line) using intercalator chloroquine diphospate to induce alterations in the twist of internucleosomal linker DNA. We have shown that histone hyperacetylation induced by antibiotic Trichostatin A significantly alters intercalator-mediated chromatin folding pattern.

Histone acetylation is required to maintain the unfolded nucleosome structure associated with transcribing DNA

Nucleosomes associated with transcribing chromatin of mammalian cells have an unfolded structure in which the normally buried cysteinyl-thiol group of histone H3 is exposed. In this study we analyzed transcriptionally active/competent DNA-enriched chromatin fractions from chicken mature and immature erythrocytes for the presence of thiol-reactive nucleosomes using organomercury-agarose column chromatography and hydroxylapatite dissociation chromatography of chromatin fractions labeled with [3H]iodoacetate. In mature and immature erythrocytes, the active DNA-enriched chromatin fractions are associated with histones that are rapidly highly acetylated and rapidly deacetylated. When histone deacetylation was prevented by incubating cells with histone deacetylase inhibitors, sodium butyrate or trichostatin A, thiol-reactive H3 of unfolded nucleosomes was detected in the soluble chromatin and nuclear skeleton-associated chromatin of immature, but not mature, erythrocytes. We did not find thiol-reactive nucleosomes in active DNA-enriched chromatin fractions of untreated immature erythrocytes that had low levels of highly acetylated histones H3 and H4 or in chromatin of immature cells incubated with inhibitors of transcription elongation. This study shows that transcription elongation is required to form, and histone acetylation is needed to maintain, the unfolded structure of transcribing nucleosomes.

Interaction between N-terminal domain of H4 and DNA is regulated by the acetylation degree

To study whether the acetylation of one or more of the four acetylatable lysines of histone H4 affects its binding to DNA, we have designed a protection experiment with a model system consisting in phage lambda DNA as substrate, StuI as restriction endonuclease and histone H4 with different degrees of acetylation as the protective agent. It can be deduced from the experimental data that the protection afforded by the histone is not dependent on the number of positive charges lost by acetylation. Thus, non-acetylated H4 and mono-acetylated H4 cause similar protection, while di-acetylation of the histone seems to be the crucial step in significantly weakening the interaction between H4 and DNA. This is confirmed by the results obtained in protection experiments carried out using H4 peptide (1-24) with different degrees of acetylation as the protecting agent. As restriction enzyme can imitate any trans-acting factor with sequence recognition, the di-acetylated isoform of histone H4 can be the starting point, through acetylation, to unmask DNA sequences, allowing the accessibility of regulatory factors to DNA in the chromatin.

Reconstitution of hyperacetylated, DNase I-sensitive chromatin characterized by high conformational flexibility of nucleosomal DNA

Increased acetylation at specific N-terminal lysines of core histones is a hallmark of active chromatin in vivo, yet the structural consequences of acetylation leading to increased gene activity are only poorly defined. We employed a new approach to characterize the effects of histone acetylation: A Drosophila embryo-derived cell-free system for chromatin reconstitution under physiological conditions was programmed with exogenous histones to assemble hyperacetylated or matching control chromatin of high complexity. Hyperacetylated chromatin resembled unmodified chromatin at similar nucleosome density with respect to its sensitivity toward microccal nuclease, its nucleosomal repeat length, and the incorporation of the linker histone H1. In contrast, DNA in acetylated chromatin showed an increased sensitivity toward DNase I and a surprisingly high degree of conformational flexibility upon temperature shift pointing to profound alterations of DNA/histone interactions. This successful reconstitution of accessible and flexible chromatin outside of a nucleus paves the way for a thorough analysis of the causal relationship between histone acetylation and gene function.

Alpha-(Ac)AKRHRKV, a model of the histone H4 amino terminus, uses an unprotonated histidine in phosphate binding

The 1H NMR spectrum of the title peptide at pH 3.3 in 90% H2O was assigned by HOHAHA and NOESY 2D methods. Titration studies in D2O at 300 MHz indicated a histidine side-chain pKa of 6.3. Peptide backbone NH resonances were studied in 90% H2O at 500 MHz as a function of pH and added phosphate. In acidic solution the peptide was free from conventional secondary structural elements, but near neutrality the valine amide proton resonance remained a sharp doublet, which suggests that it may form a hydrogen bond with some backbone carbonyl group. The other amide resonances broadened and showed significant saturation transfer from the water signal indicating that they exchange with solvent although not all to the same extent. Marked changes in the chemical shift of the histidine aromatic protons in the presence of phosphate and a 70-fold increase in the 31P line width of inorganic phosphate in the presence of peptide only at pH values above the pKa (6.3) of the histidine imidazole side-chain implied that the unprotonated imidazole group is specifically involved in phosphate binding. The peptide binds inorganic phosphate with a dissociation constant of 1.6 x 10(-5) M(-1) at pH 7.4.

High resolution microanalysis and three-dimensional nucleosome structure associated with transcribing chromatin

The nucleosome is the ubiquitous and fundamental DNA-protein complex of the eukaryotic chromosome, participating in the packaging of DNA and in the regulation of gene expression. Biophysical studies have implicated changes in nucleosome structure from chromatin that is quiescent to active in transcription. Since DNA within the nucleosome contains a high concentration of phosphorus whereas histone proteins do not, the nucleosome structure is amenable to microanalytical electron energy loss mapping of phosphorus to delineate the DNA within the protein-nucleic acid particle. Nucleosomes associated with transcriptionally active genes were separated from nucleosomes associated with quiescent genes using mercury-affinity chromatography. The three-dimensional image reconstruction methods for the total nucleosome structure and for the 3D DNA-phosphorus distribution combined quaternion-assisted angular reconstitution of sets of single particles at random orientations and electron spectroscopic imaging. The structure of the active nucleosome has the conformation of an open clam-shell, C- or U-shaped in one view, elongated in another, and exhibits a protein asymmetry. A three-dimensional phosphorus map reveals a conformational change in nucleosomal DNA compared to DNA in the canonical nucleosome structure. It indicates an altered superhelicity and is consistent with unfolding of the particle. The results address conformational changes of the nucleosome and provide a direct structural linkage to biochemical and physiological changes which parallel gene expression.

Influence of core histone acetylation on SV40 minichromosome replication in vitro

We have used the SV40 in vitro replication system to analyze the replication efficiencies of SV40 minichromosomes associated with normal or hyperacetylated histones. We found that elongation of replication occurs with higher efficiency in hyperacetylated minichromosomes in comparison with normal minichromosomes. Our results indicate that the movement of the replication machinery through nucleosomal DNA is facilitated by charge neutralization due to acetylation of the histone tails.

Histone structure and the organization of the nucleosome

Chromatin structure is now believed to be dynamic and intimately related with cellular processes such as transcription. Over the past few years, high-resolution structures for the histones have become available. These structures and their implications for nucleosome organization are reviewed here.

Activity banding of human chromosomes as shown by histone acetylation

The expression of genes in mammalian cells depends on many factors including position in the cell cycle, stage of differentiation, age, and environmental influences. As different groups of genes are expressed, their packaging within chromatin changes and may be detected at the chromosomal level. The organization of DNA within a chromosome is determined to a large extent by the positively charged, highly conserved histones. Histone subtypes and the reversible chemical modifications of histones have been associated with gene activity. Active or potentially active genes have been associated with hyperacetylated histones and inactive genes with nonacetylated histones. Sodium butyrate increases the acetylation levels of histones in cell cultures and acts as both an inducer of gene activity and as a cell-cycle block. We describe a method to label the interphase distribution of DNA associated with various histone acetylation stages on chromosomes. Nucleosomes from untreated and butyrate-treated HeLa cells were fractionated by their acetylation level and the associated DNA labeled, and hybridized to normal human chromosomes. In the sodium butyrate-treated cells the resulting banding patterns of the high- and low-acetylated fractions were strikingly different. DNA from low-acetylated chromatin labeled several pericentric regions, whereas hybridization with DNA from highly acetylated chromatin resulted in a pattern similar to inverse G-bands on many chromosomes. The results from noninduced cells at both high and low acetylation levels were noticeably different from their induced counterparts. The capture and hybridization of DNA from interphase chromatin at different acetylation states provides a "snapshot" of the distribution of gene activity on chromosomes at the time of cell harvest.

Modulation of chromatin folding by histone acetylation

A homogeneous oligonucleosome complex was prepared by reconstitution of highly hyperacetylated histone octamers onto a linear DNA template consisting of 12 tandemly arranged 208-base pair fragments of the 5 S rRNA gene from the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus. The ionic strength-dependent folding of this oligonucleosome assembly was monitored by sedimentation velocity and electron microscopy. Both types of analysis indicate that under ionic conditions resembling those found in the physiological range and in the absence of histone H1, the acetylated oligonucleosome complexes remain in an extended conformation in contrast to their nonacetylated counterparts. The implications of this finding in the context of a multistate model of chromatin folding (Hansen, J. C., and Ausio, J. (1992) TIBS 197, 187-191) as well as its biological relevance are discussed.

Unfolded structure and reactivity of nucleosome core DNA-histone H2A,H2B complexes in solution as studied by synchrotron radiation X-ray scattering

It has been previously found using different physicochemical techniques [Aragay, A., Diaz, P., & Daban, J.-R. (1988) J. Mol. Biol. 204, 141-154] that histones H2A,H2B in the absence of H3,H4 can associate with nucleosome core DNA (146 base pairs). Here we describe a synchrotron X-ray scattering study of core DNA-(H2A,H2B) complexes in solution. Our results obtained using different histone to DNA weight ratios and ionic conditions ranging from very low ionic strength to 0.2 M NaCl show that histones H2A,H2B are unable to fold core DNA. Model calculations indicate that histones H2A,H2B produce very elongated structures even when the reconstituted complexes are prepared at physiological ionic strength. In contrast, our scattering data indicate that the reconstituted complexes prepared at physiological salt concentration either with the four core histones or with histones H3,H4 without H2A,H2B are completely folded particles with a radius of gyration similar to that corresponding to the native nucleosome core (4.2 nm). Furthermore, our results show that the DNA of the extended complexes containing histones H2A,H2B becomes completely folded after the histone pair exchange reaction that occurs spontaneously between preformed DNA-(H2A,H2B) and DNA-(H3,H4) complexes. These observations, together with our previous studies, suggest that the open conformation of DNA-(H2A,H2B) complexes facilitates the involvement of this structure as a transient intermediate in the reaction of nucleosome formation at physiological ionic strength.

Chromatin dynamics and the modulation of genetic activity

Chromatin, the genetic material of eukaryotes, is a dynamic macromolecular assembly that continuously changes its composition and conformation to accommodate different stages of genetic activity, e.g. transcription and replication. Evidence is accumulating that the dynamic behavior of chromatin has important functional roles in the modulation of genetic activity, largely due to the intrinsic properties of arrays of nucleosome cores.

Histone H4 isoforms acetylated at specific lysine residues define individual chromosomes and chromatin domains in Drosophila polytene nuclei

Histone H4 isoforms acetylated at lysines 5, 8, 12, or 16 have been shown, by indirect immunofluorescence with site-specific antisera, to have distinct patterns of distribution in interphase, polytene chromosomes from Drosophila larvae. H4 molecules acetylated at lysines 5 or 8 are distributed in overlapping, but nonidentical, islands throughout the euchromatic chromosome arms. beta-Heterochromatin in the chromocenter is depleted in these isoforms, but relatively enriched in H4 acetylated at lysine 12. H4 acetylated at lysine 16 is found at numerous sites along the transcriptionally hyperactive X chromosome in male larvae, but not in male autosomes or any chromosome in female cells. These findings support the hypothesis that H4 molecules acetylated at particular sites mediate unique and specific effects on chromatin function.

Reversible histone modifications and the chromosome cell cycle

During the eukaryotic cell cycle, chromosomes undergo large structural transitions and spatial rearrangements that are associated with the major cell functions of genome replication, transcription and chromosome condensation to metaphase chromosomes. Eukaryotic cells have evolved cell cycle dependent processes that modulate histone:DNA interactions in chromosomes. These are; i) acetylations of lysines; ii) phosphorylations of serines and threonines and iii) ubiquitinations of lysines. All of these reversible modifications are contained in the well-defined very basic N- and C-terminal domains of histones. Acetylations and phosphorylations markedly affect the charge densities of these domains whereas ubiquitination adds a bulky globular protein, ubiquitin, to lysines in the C-terminal tails of H2A and H2B. Histone acetylations are strictly associated with genome replication and transcription; histone H1 and H3 phosphorylations correlate with the process of chromosome condensation. The subunits of histone H1 kinase have now been shown to be cyclins and the p34CDC2 kinase product of the cell cycle control gene CDC2. It is probable that all of the processes that control chromosome structure:function relationships are also involved in the control of the cell cycle.

Histone hyperacetylation does not alter the positioning or stability of phased nucleosomes on the mouse mammary tumor virus long terminal repeat

Activation of mouse mammary tumor virus transcription by the hormone-bound glucocorticoid receptor results in disruption of a nucleosome that is specifically positioned on the promoter. Limited treatment of cells with the histone deacetylase inhibitor sodium butyrate prevents receptor-dependent promoter activation and nucleosome disruption [Bresnick, E. H., John, S., Berard, D. S., LeFebvre, P., & Hager, G. L. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 3977-3981]. On the basis of this observation, we undertook a series of experiments to compare the structure of normal and hyperacetylated mouse mammary tumor virus chromatin. Although butyrate prevents hormone-induced restriction enzyme cutting specifically in the B nucleosome region, chromatin containing hyperacetylated histones does not differ from normal chromatin in general sensitivity to restriction enzymes. Indirect end-labeling analysis of micrococcal nuclease digested chromatin reveals that nucleosomes are identically phased on the mouse mammary tumor virus long terminal repeat in normal and hyperacetylated chromatin. A synthetic DNA fragment spanning the B nucleosome region was reconstituted into a monosome by using core particles containing normal or hyperacetylated histones. Analysis of the structure of reconstituted monosomes by nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, salt stability, thermal stability, restriction enzyme accessibility, and exonuclease III or DNase I footprinting reveals no effect of histone hyperacetylation on monosome structure. These observations suggest that histone hyperacetylation does not induce a major change in the structure of mouse mammary tumor virus chromatin, such as nucleosome unfolding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A NMR study of mobility in the histone octamer

The histone octamer from chicken erythrocytes was studied in 2 M NaCl using 500 mHz 1H NMR spectroscopy. We compared the spectrum of control octamers with that of octamers isolated from trypsinized nucleosome core particles. We observe that the sharp resonances found in the spectrum of the native octamer disappear completely after trypsinization. Therefore, within the time frame of the NMR experiment, all of the mobile amino acid residues in the histone octamer are found in the well defined trypsin sensitive domains. These results indicate that there is a very clear structural demarcation between the random coil N- and C-terminal tails and the globular domains of the histones.

Interactions of acetylated histones with DNA as revealed by UV laser induced histone-DNA crosslinking

The interaction of acetylated histones with DNA in chromatin has been studied by UV laser-induced crosslinking histones to DNA. After irradiation of the nuclei, the covalently linked protein-DNA complexes were isolated and the presence of histones in them demonstrated immunochemically. When chromatin from irradiated nuclei was treated with clostripain, which selectively cleaved the N-terminal tails of core histones, no one of them was found covalently linked to DNA, thus showing that crosslinking proceeded solely via the N-terminal regions. However, the crosslinking ability of the laser was preserved both upon physiological acetylation of histones, known to be restricted to the N-terminal tails, and with chemically acetylated chromatin. This finding is direct evidence that the postsynthetic histone acetylation does not release the N-terminal tails from interaction with DNA.

Change in the pattern of histone binding to DNA upon transcriptional activation

Patterns of histone binding to DNA of transcriptionally active D. melanogaster hsp70 genes within the nuclei have been analyzed by two methods of histone-DNA chemical cross-linking. When cross-linking is restricted to the central, "globular" regions of histones, it drops most for H1, to an intermediate extent for H2A and H2B, and least for H3 and H4 in transcriptionally active versus transcriptionally silent chromatin. When it occurs via histone terminal regions as well, cross-linking is quantitatively similar for active and inactive chromatin. Neither cross-linking method detects histones on the hsp70 promoter region. It appears that chromatin activation decreases histone binding to DNA via the "globular" regions, known to be essential for the folding of nucleosomes and the 30 nm chromatin fibril, but does not significantly affect the interaction of flexible and loosely bound histone "tails" with DNA. The role of these histone-DNA interaction changes in the unfolding of active chromatin and RNA polymerase reading through histone-bound DNA is discussed.

Histone acetylation reduces nucleosome core particle linking number change

Nucleosome core particles differing in their levels of histone acetylation have been formed on a closed circular DNA that contains a tandemly repeated 207 bp nucleosome positioning sequence. The effect of acetylation on the linking number per nucleosome particle has been determined. With increasing levels of acetylation, the negative linking number change per nucleosome decreases from -1.04 +/- 0.08 for control to -0.82 +/- 0.05 for highly acetylated nucleosomes. These results indicate that histone acetylation has the ability to release negative supercoils previously constrained by nucleosomes into a closed chromatin loop and in effect function as a eukaryotic gyrase.

An estimate of the extent of folding of nucleosomal DNA by laterally asymmetric neutralization of phosphate groups

We attempt quantitative implementation of a previous suggestion that asymmetric charge neutralization of DNA phosphate groups may provide part of the driving force for nucleosome folding. Polyelectrolyte theory can be used to estimate the effective compressive force acting along the length of one side of the DNA surface when a fraction of the phosphate groups are neutralized by histones bound to that side. A standard engineering formula then relates the force to the bending amplitude caused by it. Calculated bending amplitudes are consistent with the curvature of nucleosomal DNA and the overall extent of charge neutralization by the histones. The relation of the model to various aspects of nucleosome folding, including the detailed path of core-particle DNA, is discussed. Several other DNA-protein complexes are listed as examples of possible asymmetric charge-induced bending.

Towards an understanding of the biological function of histone acetylation

A model is presented which explains the biological function of posttranslational acetylation of core histones in chromatin. Along the lines of this model histone acetylation serves as a general mechanism to destabilize nucleosome core particles during various processes occurring in chromatin. Acetylation acts as a signal that modulates histone-protein and histone-DNA interactions and finally leads to the displacement of particular histones from nucleosome cores. The high specificity of the acetylation signal for different processes (DNA replication, transcription, differentiation-specific histone replacement) is achieved by site specificity and asymmetry of acetylation in nucleosomes. The essential features of this model are in accord with the more recent results on histone acetylation.

Treatment with sodium butyrate inhibits the complete condensation of interphase chromatin

The effects of histone hyperacetylation on chromatin fiber structure were studied using direct observations with the electron microscope. Histone hyperacetylation was induced in HeLa cells by treatment with sodium butyrate, and the ultrastructure of control and of acetylated chromatin fibers examined after fixation at different stages of compaction. No differences between control and acetylated chromatin were seen when the fibers were partially unfolded (10 mM NaCl, 20 mM NaCl, 50 mM NaCl), but in 100 mM NaCl, control chromatin showed further compaction to the "30 nm" fiber, while hyperacetylated chromatin failed to undergo this final compaction step. These results strongly suggest that histone acetylation causes a moderate "relaxation" rather than complete decondensation of interphase chromatin fibers. The relationship of these findings to the increased DNase I sensitivity of acetylated chromatin, and to transcription and replication, is discussed.

Thermal denaturation of mononucleosomes in the presence of spermine, spermidine, N1-acetylspermidine, N8-acetylspermidine or putrescine: implications for chromosome structure

Putrescine (a diamine) raises the thermal denaturation temperature of mononucleosomes but produces only minor changes in the overall shape of the thermal denaturation curve. This is similar to the effect of sodium ions and is consistent with nonspecific binding to the DNA of the nucleosome. At very low levels of spermidine or spermine the same simple rise in thermal denaturation temperature is seen but at higher levels (above 1 microM for total spermidine concentration) the thermal denaturation curve becomes substantially sharper and the premelt region of the curve diminishes in area. The acetylspermidines display intermediate effects. The change in shape of the thermal denaturation curve was resolved into components (R1 and R2) due to mononucleosomes in their original conformation plus a component (T) induced by the presence of spermidine or spermine. The proportion of component T was substantially reduced with acetylspermidine, compared to equivalent concentrations of spermidine. Hence, we suggest that spermidine acetylation in vivo has the potential to partially destabilise the nucleosome structure, possibly in coordination with histone acetylation.