Development of a fetal renal function test using endogenous creatinine clearance

Quantification of Fetal Renal Function Using Fetal Urine Production Rate and Its Reflection on the Amniotic and Fetal Creatinine Levels During Pregnancy

Adequate prediction of fetal exposure of drugs excreted by the kidney requires the incorporation of time-varying renal function parameters into a pharmacokinetic model. Published data on measurements of fetal urinary production rate (FUPR) and creatinine at various gestational ages were collected and integrated for prediction of the fetal glomerular filtration rate (GFR). The predicted GFR values were then compared to neonatal values recorded at birth. Collected data for FUPR across different gestational ages using both 3D (N = 517) and 2D (N = 845) ultrasound methods showed that 2D techniques yield significantly lower estimates of FUPR than 3D (p < 0.0001). A power law function was shown to best capture the change in FUPR with fetal age (FA) for both 2D ( F U P R 2 D ( m L min ) = 0 . 000169     FA 2 . 19 ); and 3D ( F U P R 3 D   ( m L min ) =   3 . 21 × 1 0 - 7   FA 4 . 21 ) data. The predicted FUPR based on the observed 3D data was shown to be strongly linearly related (R ² = 0.95) to measured values of amniotic creatinine concentration (N = 664). The FUPR_3D data together with creatinine levels in the fetal urine and serum resulted in median predicted fetal GFR values of 0.47, 1.2, 2.5, and 4.9 ml/min at 23, 28, 33, and 38 weeks of fetal age (50% CV), respectively. These values are in good agreement with neonatal values observed immediately at birth. The derived FUPR and creatinine functions can be utilized to assess fetal renal maturation and predict fetal renal clearance.

Fetal lower urinary tract obstruction

The authors present an overview of the prenatal diagnosis, evaluation, contemporary intervention, and antenatal management of lower urinary tract obstruction. They review early experimental models that confirmed the relation between urinary tract obstruction and renal fibrocystic dysplasia and that early in utero relief of the obstruction could prevent irreversible renal injury. Subsequent studies of the electrolyte and protein concentrations in fetal urine from human cases established prognostic threshold values and helped to develop an algorithm to select candidates for antenatal therapy. Although shunting has improved survival, long-term morbidities remain a significant challenge.

Upper urinary tract dilatation: prenatal diagnosis, management and outcome

Upper urinary tract dilatation is one of the most common abnormalities detected on prenatal ultrasound scanning. It is commonly due to transient urine flow impairment (UFI) at the level of the pelvi-ureteric and vesico-ureteric junctions, which improves with time in most cases. It is usually in the neonatal period that the diagnosis is confirmed and during the first 18 months of life that the prognosis of the dilatation is defined.

Syndrome d’insuffisance rénale fœtale

Some anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract evolving in utero may compromise the renal function in the newborn. Early therapeutic options do exist, especially in obstructive nephropathies. The decision depends on a correct evaluation of the foetal enal function and prognosis, which is based on a range of methods: ultrasound echography, biochemical analysis of foetal urine, and, more recently, foetal serum markers such a beta-2 micro globulin. These methods are reviewed.

Animal models of fetal renal disease

Fetal models of urinary tract disease have been used for many years and have provided unique and important insights into the pathophysiology of these conditions. This review will summarize the principal model systems used and the current directions of investigation. These models (including rabbit, opossum, sheep and recently swine) have demonstrated that in utero obstruction of the urinary tract alters renal growth, differentiation and produces stereotypical patterns of tissue response, particularly fibrosis. New molecular understanding of these processes has identified specific mechanisms that may be key elements in the development of renal dysfunction due to obstruction. These factors include the renin-angiotensin system (RAS) and its interaction with TGF-beta in altering growth regulation and tissue fibrosis. These factors offer the prospect of clinical utility as markers of disease progression as well as pharmacologic therapy. Gene knockout systems have opened a new horizon of molecular models of congenital obstructive uropathy with insights into the role of the RAS in particular. It remains to be defined how closely these knockouts represent the human conditions they resemble. Continued application of fetal models of urinary obstruction, integrating large animal and knockout systems offers promise for improved diagnosis and treatment in these challenging conditions.

Invasive assessment of fetal renal abnormalities: urinalysis, fetal blood sampling and biopsy

There are a number of potential biochemical markers that may have some role in predicting renal function postnatally. These include urinary sodium, calcium and beta2-microglobulin. The latter may also be measured in fetal serum. However, the accuracy of these parameters at a point in time is far from perfect as urinary tract obstruction is a progressive disease which may be best defined by repeated observations throughout pregnancy.

Fetal interventions for obstructive uropathy

Obstructive uropathy is a significant source of morbidity and mortality in the neonate and infant, despite advances in postnatal management. Diagnosis is typically made early in the second trimester on the basis of sonographic measurements. In utero therapy holds promise for improved outcomes by preventing progressive urinary tract damage and permitting drainage of urine into the amniotic space to minimize the pulmonary sequelae of oligohydramnios. Multiple studies with animal models have showed the benefits of midgestational intervention, but large prospective, randomized studies have not yet been performed to confirm these findings in humans. Standardization of the diagnostic evaluation allows for refined patient selection, resulting in improved postnatal outcomes after fetal vesicoamniotic shunting. Research into the role of specific growth factors and immunoproteins in renal development and function may further improve patient selection and outcome. This article reviews diagnosis, technique, and outcomes for fetal treatment of obstructive uropathy.

Experimental vesicoureteral reflux in the fetus depends on bladder function and causes renal fibrosis

PURPOSE

Prenatal diagnosis allows the early detection of vesicoureteral reflux in an increasing number of newborns, some of whom are born with impaired kidney function. This situation challenges our current understanding of the pathophysiology, natural history and, therefore, treatment of reflux. We created a fetal sheep model of vesicoureteral reflux to study the mechanisms of fetal reflux nephropathy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Vesicoureteral reflux was induced in fetal sheep at 95 days of gestation (term 140 days) by open bladder incision of the intravesical ureteral tunnel. All animals underwent urachal ligation and in female subjects mild bladder outlet obstruction was created with a gold ring.

RESULTS

At term reflux was detected in 18 of 28 renal units by filling cystography. Refluxing kidneys were hydronephrotic and larger than normal. At term mean kidney weight was 21.1 gm. (range 12.2 to 35.0) in male subjects with reflux compared to 8.5 gm. (range 6.5 to 11.3) in normal male subjects (p <0.001) and 11.5 gm. (range 8.5 to 15.8) in male subjects with urachal ligation only (p = 0.035). In female subjects there was no change in renal weight. Renal histology revealed a thin, structurally normal cortex with small subcortical cysts and a hypoplastic medulla with mesenchymal tissue replacing normal ducts. Total mean renal collagen content was significantly increased to 51.7 mg. (range 35 to 81) in the refluxing kidneys of male animals, while it was 23.8 mg. (range 12.1 to 38.4) in normal male animals (p = 0.03). The fractional excretion of sodium was elevated in refluxing kidneys based on sodium-to-creatinine ratios in bladder urine.

CONCLUSIONS

In a novel model of fetal vesicoureteral reflux we showed that prenatal reflux nephropathy is characterized by altered renal growth regulation, structural maldevelopment without overt dysplasia, excess matrix deposition and impaired excretory function.

Effect of experimentally induced urethral obstruction and surgical decompression in utero on renal development and function in rabbits

To investigate the effect of urethral obstruction during late fetal life on renal development and function, we developed a rabbit fetal model of obstructive nephropathy to examine the pathological and biochemical consequences of urethral obstruction and beneficial effects of early surgical decompression. Animals were divided into four groups, i.e., obstructed, early decompressed, late decompressed, and control. Fetal renal development was evaluated by histological examination and counting the number of glomeruli in the four groups. The number of renal glomeruli correlated with gestational age in the normal fetus (r = 0.90, P < 0.0001). Urethral ligation on gestational day 25 (full-term, 31 days) resulted in thinning of the renal cortex and significantly decreased the number of renal glomeruli. The concentration of urinary microalbumin was higher when urethral obstruction was maintained for 3 days than 1 day after urethral obstruction, although urinary beta2- microglobulin, Na, Cl, and osmotic pressure did not change during this period. Decompression of urethral obstruction 1 day after induction of urethral obstruction resulted in improvement in the severity glomerular hypoplasia compared with late decompression (P < 0.01). Our results suggest that the rabbit fetal model simulates fetal urethral obstruction in humans, and indicates that early surgical decompression may be effective in restoration of normal renal function.

Renal preservation despite 35 days of partial bladder obstruction in the fetal lamb

To determine whether the increase in renal blood flow and preservation of renal function that we demonstrated after 10 days of chronic partial bladder obstruction in the third trimester fetal lamb also occur after earlier longer obstruction, we modified our preparation and studied the effects of 35 days of obstruction begun during the second trimester. Partial bladder obstruction was created in 10 fetal lambs at 90 days of gestation (term equals 147 days). At repeat surgical intervention 28 days later vascular catheters and a left renal artery flow transducer were placed, and catheters were externalized. We then studied renal blood flow and function at gestational ages 120 days and 125 days after 30 days and 35 days of obstruction, respectively. Tissue was obtained for histology at the time of sacrifice. Eight control fetal lambs without obstruction were studied in a similar way. Bilateral hydroureteronephrosis was noted in all fetal lambs after partial obstruction, whereas the kidneys and bladders of the control animals had a normal appearance. Renal blood flow was higher in the obstructed fetal lambs than in controls (20.2 +/- 4.9 versus 10.2 +/- 0.9 ml. per minute per kg., p < 0.05 after 30 days and 17.1 +/- 2.7 versus 9.7 +/- 0.9 per minute per kg., p < 0.05 after 35 days). There was no evidence of decreased renal function by any parameter and, in fact, glomerular filtration rate and urine volume were increased after 30 days of obstruction (1.59 +/- 0.32 versus 0.69 +/- 0.07 ml. per minute per kg., p < 0.05 and 15.7 +/- 4.3 versus 5.2 +/- 0.8 ml. per hour per kg., p < 0.05, respectively). Histological studies demonstrated normal architecture of the kidneys but thinned cortex. We conclude that the physiological responses of the fetus are such that partial lower urinary tract obstruction in our preparation results in a prolonged increase in renal blood flow and preservation of renal function.

Renal hemodynamic and functional effects of 10 days' partial urinary obstruction in the fetal lamb

We studied fetal lambs to define the renal pathophysiology of chronic in utero partial bladder outlet obstruction. These fetal lambs, 115 to 120 days gestation (term = 145 days), underwent urethral ligation, placement of a urachal catheter and positioning of an ultrasonic flow transducer around the left renal artery. Partial obstruction was created by placing a narrow connector between the urachal and an amniotic catheter. In control animals a large connector was placed to allow free drainage of the bladder into the amniotic cavity. Renal blood flow was measured daily, and urine was collected at days 5 and 10 to evaluate renal function. In control animals, no significant changes in any parameters were observed. In the partially obstructed fetal lambs, renal blood flow increased to 165% of baseline after 5 days; from 5 to 10 days, it decreased, but remained above baseline values through 10 days (128%). Urine production dropped significantly after 10 days (67%). Glomerular filtration rate increased slightly after 5 days (127%), but decreased after 10 (56%). Filtration fraction steadily decreased after 5 (70%) and 10 days (33%). Fractional and total sodium excretion did not change. Renal blood flow increases, filtration fraction decreases and renal function trends progressively diminish in response to partial bladder outlet obstruction over a period of 10 days in the fetal lamb.

Acute hemodynamic and endocrinological effects of partial fetal bladder obstruction

The pathophysiology of fetal urinary obstruction has not been elucidated. Using a unique, reproducible and easily reversible animal preparation, we studied the acute hemodynamic and endocrinological responses to partial fetal bladder obstruction in 16 ovine fetuses at 115 days of gestation (term 147 days). After partial obstruction blood pressure and renal weight increased significantly for at least 72 hours. Renal blood flow trended upwards, particularly from 24 to 72 hours, although this change was not statistically significant. Plasma renin activity was significantly increased during the first 24 hours after obstruction but it returned to baseline thereafter. Plasma cortisol or catecholamine concentrations remained unchanged. The time course and pattern of hemodynamic changes in this fetal sheep preparation of partial urinary obstruction differ significantly from those reported in other preparations.

Evaluation of fetal renal function: unreliability of fetal urinary electrolytes

In the fetus with bilateral hydronephrosis it has been reported that a normal volume of amniotic fluid, absence of renal cortical cysts, urinary sodium less than 100 mEq./l., chloride less than 90 mEq./l. and osmolarity less than 210 mOsm. are prognostic factors indicative of good renal function, whereas oligohydramnios, cortical cysts and higher urinary levels of sodium, chloride or osmolarity suggest irreversible renal dysplasia. We report 5 cases in which the fetal urinary electrolytes were not predictive of ultimate renal function. In 3 instances fetal urinary electrolytes and osmolarity were abnormally elevated but the infants survived without ventilatory support. In 2 of these 3 patients the volume of amniotic fluid was normal. Diagnoses included posterior urethral valves, prune belly variant and bilateral ureteropelvic junction obstruction. In 2 cases with oligohydramnios fetal urinary electrolytes were suggestive of satisfactory renal function but the infants died of pulmonary hypoplasia and had bilateral renal dysplasia, prune belly syndrome and urethral atresia. Presently, the volume of amniotic fluid remains the most important prognostic sign in the fetus with bilateral hydronephrosis. Further work is necessary to identify other factors that may be more reliable as prognostic indexes of fetal renal function.

Fetal intervention in obstructive uropathy: prognostic indicators and efficacy of intervention

Management of the fetus with bilateral hydronephrosis is controversial; ability to predict outcome and efficacy of prenatal intervention are unknown. We studied 40 fetuses referred for ultrasonography, examination of fetal urine, and possible therapy. We retrospectively assigned fetuses to a good prognosis group if fetal urine was hypotonic (sodium less than 100 mEq/L, chloride less than 90 mEq/L, osmolarity less than 210 mOsm/L) and there was no ultrasonographic evidence of dysplasia; we assigned fetuses to a poor prognosis group if even one criterion was abnormal. Survival was greater in the good prognosis group than in the poor prognosis group (81% vs 12.5%; 87% vs 30%, excluding abortions) (p less than 0.005). We then attempted to assess the efficacy of prenatal urinary decompression by comparing outcome within the good and poor prognosis groups. Survival with intervention was greater in both the good prognosis group and the poor prognosis group (89% vs 70% and 30% vs 0%). In 6 of the 8 survivors in the good prognosis group, severe oligohydramnios was reversed by decompression. We conclude the fetal urine electrolyte levels and ultrasonographic appear helpful in predicting residual fetal renal function and neonatal outcome and that prenatal decompression may prevent the development of fatal pulmonary hypoplasia.

Serial renal function in an ovine model of unilateral fetal urinary tract obstruction

Renal tubular and glomerular function following ovine fetal urinary tract obstruction has been studied predominantly in anesthetized, exteriorized fetuses immediately after relief of obstruction. Since surgery and anesthesia may alter fetal cardiovascular and renal physiology, we developed a chronically catheterized, ovine model of unilateral fetal urinary tract obstruction to compare function of the unobstructed and obstructed kidneys repeatedly after relief of obstruction. Split renal function of the previously obstructed kidneys and unobstructed kidneys was measured serially in 7 fetal sheep after obstruction at 55 to 85 days per 147 days of gestation for 30 to 49 days. Seventy-five split clearances were determined on days 1, 2, 3 to 4 and 5 to 6 postoperatively. Not every fetus was studied each day. By 2-way ANOVA, renal function was stable on day 1 after surgery and did not change with time. Previously obstructed kidneys had lower creatinine clearance (0.16 versus 0.71 ml. per minute, p equals 0.0001), higher fractional sodium excretion (33.04 versus 6.02 per cent, p equals 0.0001) and higher urine sodium/creatinine ratio (4.80 versus 0.90 mEq. per mg., p equals 0.0001). Urine flow in the unobstructed kidneys did not differ significantly from that of the obstructed kidneys (0.122 versus 0.083 ml. per minute, p equals 0.35). Obstruction reduced kidney weight (4.7 versus 9.7 gm., p equals 0.0006), cortical thickness (-39 per cent) and nephrogenic zone (-59 per cent), and it increased collecting duct dilatation and medullary fibrosis. No cysts or dysplasia was noted. Fetal urinary tract obstruction for 39.7 days alters renal histology, glomerular function and tubular function. Renal function is stable by 1 day after catheterization and does not change from days 1 to 6 following relief of obstruction.

Urinary obstruction reduces glomerulogenesis in the developing kidney: a model in the rabbit

To study the effect of unilateral ureteral obstruction upon the development of the kidney a fetal rabbit model was developed. A total of 27 rabbits underwent ureteral ligation in utero (24 days after conception) and 34 underwent ureteral ligation at term (30 days after conception). Two rabbits undergoing in utero ureteral ligation underwent decompression at term. Fetal development was evaluated by glomerular counts of mid sagittal sections of the kidney and compared to that of 67 normal rabbits, 43 littermates of rabbits undergoing surgery, 12 rabbits with missed ligation of the ureter and 4 whose ureters were ligated after the period of nephrogenesis had ended (57 days after conception). In the normal rabbit term occurred at 31 days after conception but nephrogenesis continued until 48 days when the cortical glomerular count reached approximately 650. Ligation of the ureter at 24 days led to a rapid decrease in cortical glomerular counts in the obstructed kidney but glomeruli developing within the nephrogenic cap were more resistant to the effects of the obstruction. Glomerular counts in the nonobstructed kidney were similar to those of littermates. Ligation of the ureter at 30 days produced similar findings. All operated fetuses and their littermates showed glomerular counts less than that of normal animals of the same age. In the 2 fetuses who underwent ureteral ligation at 24 days after conception and decompression at 30 days after conception sacrifice at 42 days after conception revealed that glomerular counts that had been reduced by 95 per cent by the obstruction showed 80 per cent recovery after decompression. It appears that renal development can be quantified by glomerular counts in the rabbit. Obstruction during fetal development reduces these counts while in a limited sample decompression of the obstructed kidney partially restores them. This model appears to be suitable for the study of the effects of fetal surgery upon renal function.

Prenatal diagnosis and management of bilateral hydronephrosis

This report reviews the management of the fetus with congenital hydronephrosis (CH), a challenging diagnostic and therapeutic problem. Experimental models of obstructive uropathy have produced histologic changes similar to those seen in kidneys of human neonates with congenital hydronephrosis. Relief of obstruction in utero in these models has been shown to prevent some of the dysplastic changes caused by obstruction. These studies have formed the theoretical basis for in utero decompression to restore amniotic fluid dynamics to prevent death from pulmonary hypoplasia, and reverse or arrest dysplastic morphogenesis. The development of prognostic criteria has greatly aided in selection of appropriate fetuses for intervention. These criteria include: (1) Na less than 100 mEq/l; (2) Cl less than 90 mEq/l; (3) osmolarity less than 210 mosmol; (4) sonographic appearance of the fetal kidneys; (5) amniotic fluid status; (6) urine output at fetal bladder catheterization. All fetuses should have ultrasonography to exclude other anomalies, and karyotype analysis to exclude chromosomal abnormality. If amniotic fluid volume is normal, the pregnancy is followed with serial ultrasound examinations. If oligohydramnios develops, a prognostic evaluation is performed, including fetal bladder catheterization. If the fetus has poor residual renal function, on the basis of prognostic criteria, appropriate counseling may be given. If the fetus has good residual renal function, depending on lung maturity, it can be delivered early for corrective surgery. If diagnosed prior to lung maturity in utero, decompression by either vesicoamniotic shunting or open fetal surgery may be attempted in the highly selected case.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Caution in antenatal intervention

We assessed 18 fetuses who harbored a urinary tract malformation that was diagnosed by antenatal sonography. The antenatal diagnosis corresponded to the postnatal diagnosis in 66 per cent of the cases. We review the course of 6 fetuses who had catheters placed percutaneously to drain dilated urinary tracts that were believed to be caused by posterior urethral valves (5) or an obstructed megaureter (1). Only 2 of these fetuses exhibited valves postnatally. No fetus had any recognized benefit from the antenatal intervention. We found that sonography may not readily differentiate fetuses with hydronephrosis with obstruction from those without obstruction. From this experience we conclude that intervention in pregnancies suspected of harboring a fetus with a malformed urinary tract should be done cautiously. Antenatal sonography is useful to identify the fetus with a dilated urinary tract. This identification permits perinatal specialists to be alerted so that preparations for reconstructive surgery in such cases can be made early postpartum.

Fetal hydronephrosis: selection and surgical repair

Newly developed diagnostic techniques allowed us to select a fetus with potentially reversible renal damage from the usually fatal group with bilateral hydronephrosis and severe oligohydramnios early in gestation. Fetal surgery to marsupialize the fetal bladder at 24 weeks gestation restored normal amniotic fluid dynamics and allowed sufficient pulmonary and renal development to insure survival after delivery near term.

Recent advances in prenatal diagnosis and treatment

This article is a summary of the prenatal and perinatal management of a variety of congenital lesions as practiced by the fetal treatment program at the University of California in San Francisco. Emphasis is placed on those lesions that are amenable to fetal intervention.