Study on surgical treatment of intractable childhood epilepsy

Epilepsy surgery in pediatric intractable epilepsy with destructive encephalopathy

Background and Purpose:

The aim of the current study is to review the clinical features, surgery outcomes and parental satisfaction of children with destructive encephalopathy who underwent epilepsy surgery due to medically intractable seizures.

Methods:

48 patients who underwent epilepsy surgery from October 2003 to August 2011 at Severance Children’s Hospital have been reviewed. The survey was conducted for functional outcomes and parental satisfaction at least 1 year after the surgery.

Results:

Epileptic encephalopathy including Lennox-Gastaut syndrome and infantile spasms was more prevalent than symptomatic focal epilepsy. Hypoxic ischemic injury accounted for most of the underlying etiology of the destructive encephalpathy, followed by central nervous system infection and head trauma. 27 patients (56.3%) underwent resective surgery and 21 patients (43.7%) underwent palliative surgery. 16 patients (33.3%) achieved seizure free and 27 parents (87.5%) reported satisfaction with the outcome of their children’s epilepsy surgery. In addition, 14 parents (77.8 %) whose children were not seizure free reported satisfaction with their children’s improvement in cognitive and behavior issues.

Conclusions:

Epilepsy surgery in destructive encephalopathy was effective for controlling seizures. Parents reported satisfaction not only with the surgical outcomes, but also with improvement of cognitive and behavior issues.

Cognitive outcome after epilepsy surgery in children

The ultimate goal of epilepsy surgery in young children is to stop seizures, interrupt the downhill course of the epileptic encephalopathy, and improve developmental capacities. Postoperative outcome after childhood epilepsy surgery should therefore not only be expressed in terms of seizure freedom, cognitive outcome is an equally important outcome measure. Insight in the mutually dependent variables that can determine pre and postoperative cognitive developmental abilities will improve prediction of outcome and presurgical counseling of parents. The purpose of this review is to discuss the literature regarding cognitive outcome and the predictors of postoperative cognitive functioning after epilepsy surgery in children, particularly those with "catastrophic" epilepsy. There are only few studies in which the relation between possible determinants and cognitive outcome or change was statistically tested in a multivariable manner. Duration of epilepsy, presurgical Developmental Quotient (DQ) or Intelligence Quotient (IQ), and postoperative seizure freedom were the only factors reported in different studies to be independently related to eventual cognitive outcome after epilepsy surgery. Underlying etiology, gender, age at surgery, presurgical DQ/IQ, postoperative seizure freedom, cessation of antiepileptic medication, and follow-up interval have all been described in different surgical cohorts to be independently related to a postoperative change of IQ or DQ scores. To appreciate how each of the pre-epileptic, presurgical, and postoperative variables may independently influence eventual cognitive outcome and postoperative cognitive improvement, we need multicenter studies with large homogenous surgical populations, using standardized tests and multivariable analyses.

Seizure outcomes after resective surgery for extra-temporal lobe epilepsy in pediatric patients

While temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is the most common epilepsy syndrome in adults, seizures in children are more often extratemporal in origin. Extra-temporal lobe epilepsy (ETLE) in pediatric patients is often medically refractory, leading to significantly diminished quality of life. Seizure outcomes after resective surgery for pediatric ETLE vary tremendously in the literature, given diverse patient and epilepsy characteristics and small sample sizes. The authors performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies including 10 or more pediatric patients (age ≤ 19 years) published over the last 20 years examining seizure outcomes after resective surgery for ETLE, excluding hemispherectomy. Thirty-six studies were examined. These 36 studies included 1259 pediatric patients who underwent resective surgery for ETLE. Seizure freedom (Engel Class I outcome) was achieved in 704 (56%) of these 1259 patients postoperatively, and 555 patients (44%) continued to have seizures (Engel Class II-IV outcome). Shorter epilepsy duration (≤ 7 years, the median value in this study) was more predictive of seizure freedom than longer (> 7 years) seizure history (odds ratio [OR] 1.52, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.07-2.14), suggesting that earlier intervention may be beneficial. Also, lesional epilepsy was associated with better seizure outcomes than nonlesional epilepsy (OR 1.34, 95% CI 1.19-1.49). Other predictors of seizure freedom included an absence of generalized seizures (OR 1.61, 95% CI 1.18-2.35) and localizing ictal electroencephalographic findings (OR 1.55, 95% CI 1.24-1.93). In conclusion, seizure outcomes after resective surgery for pediatric ETLE are less favorable than those associated with temporal lobectomy, but seizure freedom may be more common with earlier intervention and lesional epilepsy etiology. Children with continued debilitating seizures despite failure of multiple medication trials should be referred to a comprehensive pediatric epilepsy center for further medical and surgical evaluation.

Approach to pediatric epilepsy surgery: State of the art, Part II: Approach to specific epilepsy syndromes and etiologies

The second of this 2-part review depicts the specific approach to the common causes of pediatric refractory epilepsy amenable to surgery. These include tumors, malformations due to abnormal cortical development, vascular abnormalities and certain epileptic syndromes. Seizure freedom rates are high (usually 60-80%) following tailored focal resection, lesionectomy, and hemispherectomy. However, in patients in whom the epileptogenic zone overlaps with unresectable eloquent cortex, and in certain epileptic syndromes, seizure freedom may not be achievable. In such cases, palliative procedures such as callosotomy, multiple subpial transections and vagus nerve stimulation can achieve reduction in seizure severity but rarely seizure freedom. Integration of the new imaging techniques and the concepts of neuronal plasticity, the epileptogenic lesion, the ictal onset, symptomatogenic, irritative, and epileptogenic zones is an expanding and dynamic process that will allow us, in the future, to better decide on the surgical approach of choice and its timing.

Surgically amenable epilepsies in children and adolescents: clinical, imaging, electrophysiological, and post-surgical outcome data

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

A large number of patients with epilepsy in the pediatric population have medically intractable epilepsy. In this age group seizures are usually daily or weekly, and response to antiepileptic therapy is poor, especially for those with neurological abnormalities and symptomatic epilepsies. However, several authors have already demonstrated similarly favorable long-term post-surgical seizure control when comparing pediatric and adult populations. In this article we aim to report the experience of the Ribeirão Preto Epilepsy Surgery Program in pediatric epilepsy surgery.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We analyzed 107 patients with medically intractable epilepsy operated on between July 1994 and December 2002, considering age at surgery, seizure type, pathological findings, and seizure outcome. All data were prospectively collected according to protocols previously approved by the institution ethics committee.

RESULTS

We analyzed a total of 115 operations performed in 107 patients. There was no difference in sex distribution. Complex partial seizures occurred in 31.4% of the patients, followed by tonic seizures (25.9%), focal motor seizures (15.4%), and infantile spasms (13.3%). The most common etiologies were cortical developmental abnormalities (25.2%), tumors (16.8%), mesial temporal sclerosis (15.9%), Rasmussen syndrome (6.5%), and tuberous sclerosis (6.5%). Overall post-surgical seizure outcome showed 67.2% of the patients within Engel classes I and II, reaching 75.0% when patients with callosotomies were excluded.

CONCLUSIONS

Post-surgical seizure control in the pediatric population is similar to that in adult patients, despite the fact that epilepsies in this age group are more frequently of extratemporal origin, suggesting that surgery should be considered in children as soon as intractability is determined.

Cognitive Function in Preschool Children after Epilepsy Surgery: Rationale for Early Intervention

PURPOSE

The detrimental effect of frequent early seizures on the cognitive potential of children is a significant clinical issue. Epilepsy surgery in childhood offers a good prognosis for seizure control and improved developmental outcome. We studied the postoperative outcome and the developmental velocity after surgery and analyzed risk factors for developmental delay in 50 consecutive preschool children treated surgically for severe epilepsy at ages 3 to 7 years.

METHODS

Pre- and postoperative developmental quotients (DQs) were analyzed with analysis of variance; stepwise linear regressions were performed on preoperative DQs and on a difference score between post- and preoperative DQs to determine risk factors for preoperative development and factors influencing postoperative development.

RESULTS

Of the 50 patients, 70% were retarded, with IQ < 70; 16% were of average intelligence, with IQ ranging from 85 to 115. Age at seizure onset and extent of lesion were predictive variables for preoperative cognitive development. Six to 12 months after surgery (early postoperative phase), 66% were seizure free (Engel outcome class I), 26% had substantial to worthwhile seizure reduction (classes II and III), and 8% were unchanged (class IV). Forty-one (82%) children showed stable velocity of development; three children showed gains of >/=15 IQ points; three had developmental decline (loss of >/=10 IQ points), which was transient in two children; and three children moved from not assessable to assessable. At last follow-up (6 months to 10 years after surgery), 11 children showed IQ/DQ gains of >/=15 IQ points. Gains in IQ were observed only in seizure-free children and were stable over time. Shorter duration of epilepsy was significantly associated with a postoperative increase in DQ.

CONCLUSIONS

(a) Substantial global mental delay is common in young children treated for epilepsy with surgery; (b) In most patients, postoperative development proceeded at a stable velocity; (c) Catch-up development may occur but only in seizure-free patients; (d) Substantial cognitive losses were noted in only one child. and (e) Early seizure control stabilized developmental velocity in this patient cohort.

Cortical laminar disorganization is correlated with severity of the cortical dysplasia and surgical outcome—experience with 150 cases

The aim of this study is to evaluate that the cortical laminar disorganization (CLD) and its correlation with the severity of the cortical dysplasia (CD) and surgical outcome. The cohort consists of 150 patients (101 males and 49 females) who underwent surgical resection of the epileptic area due to medically intractable epilepsy. Histologically, the CLD was divided into three grades according to the degree of disarrangement of the clear-cut six-layered cortex and the pathological features on MAP2 and NeuN immunostaining; normal to mild, moderate and severe CLD in 58 (38.7%), 47 (31.3%) and 45 (30.0%) cases, respectively. The histopathological grading of CLD had significant correlation with severity of CD (p<0.001), number of single heterotopic neurons in white matter (p=0.009), presence of neurons in molecular layer (p<0.001), persistent subpial granular cells (p=0.017), cytomegalic neurons (p<0.001) and balloon cells (p<0.001), and gray-white matter blurring (p<0.001), and had inverse correlation with surgical outcome (<0.001). Since statistically correlated with the known parameters of CD and surgical outcome, the grading of CLD could be used as another histological parameter for CD.

Clinical study of catastrophic infantile epilepsy with focal seizures

This study investigated clinico-electrical and etiologic characteristics of catastrophic infantile epilepsy with focal seizures developed in early infancy. The patients included 15 children who fulfilled the following criteria: seizure onset before 12 months of age, presence of daily focal or secondarily generalized seizures resistant to antiepileptic drugs for at least 3 months, and exclusion of Ohtahara and West syndromes. Patients were classified into three subgroups. Three patients demonstrated progressively deteriorating neurologic symptoms associated with progressive cerebral atrophy and multifocal seizure onset. Three other children were characterized by hemiparesis and exclusively lateralized seizure onset because of focal cortical dysplasia in the contralateral hemisphere. The remaining nine children did not demonstrate any rapidly progressive neurologic deterioration or increasing cerebral atrophy and exhibited multifocal seizure onset. At the last examinations, all except one patient demonstrated moderate to severe psychomotor retardation. Catastrophic infantile epilepsy with focal seizures tended to demonstrate multifocal seizure onset and a deleterious clinical course with numerous focal seizures regardless of etiology. Because migratory focal seizures appear to be common in these infants, we have to search for the underlying etiopathogenesis of these patients, including not only metabolic errors but also localized or lateralized structural abnormality.

Operative results without invasive monitoring in patients with frontal lobe epileptogenic lesions

PURPOSE

To further explore the still controversial issues regarding whether all or most candidates for epilepsy surgery should be investigated preoperatively with invasive long-term video-EEG monitoring techniques (ILTVE).

METHODS

We studied five patients with intractable seizures since early childhood using the same protocol: clinical evaluation, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequences, long-term video-EEG (LTVE) monitoring with scalp electroencephalogram (EEG), interictal single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), positron emission tomography (PET), and neuropsychological testing. The patients' seizures had clinical features suggesting a frontal lobe (FL) origin. MRI scans revealed focal cortical dysplasia (CD) in four patients and a probable gliotic lesion in the fifth. The findings in both PET and SPECT images were congruent with those of the MRI. Scalp LTVE failed to localize the ictal onset, although the data exhibited features suggestive of both CDs and FL seizures. On the basis of these results, surgery was performed with intraoperative corticography, and the cortical area exhibiting the greatest degree of spiking was ablated.

RESULTS

Histopathologic study of four of the resected specimens confirmed the presence of CD, whereas in the fifth, there were features consistent with a remote encephaloclastic lesion. There were no postoperative deficits. Seizures in three of the patients were completely controlled at 2-3.5 years of follow-up; a fourth patient is still having a few seizures, which have required reinstitution of pharmacotherapy, and the fifth has obtained > or =70% control. All patients have had significant improvement in psychosocial measures. For comparison, five patients with generally similar clinical and neuroradiologic features to the previous group underwent preoperative ILTVE monitoring. The surgical outcomes between the two groups have not differed significantly.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that patients with FL epilepsies may be able to undergo successful surgery without preoperative ILTVE monitoring, provided there is high concordance between neuroimaging tests (MRI, SPECT, PET) and the seizure phenotypes, even when routine EEGs and scalp LVTE fail to localize ictal onset unambiguously. The surgical outcomes of these patients generally paralleled those of the other subjects who also had FL epilepsy but who were operated on only after standard ILTVE monitoring.

Surgical treatment of medically refractory epilepsy in childhood

Twenty-five percent of children with epilepsy continue to seize despite the best medical management and may be defined as medically refractory. Many children with medically refractory localization-related epilepsy, i.e. seizures which originate in a particular area of the brain and secondarily spread to involve other brain regions, may benefit from a variety of surgical treatments including hemispherectomy, corpus callosotomy, focal cortical resection of the temporal lobe, focal cortical resection of extratemporal regions of the brain, and multiple subpial resections. A successful outcome from epilepsy surgery is generally defined as a seizure-free state with no imposition of neurologic deficit. In order to achieve these twin goals two criteria must be fulfilled. First, precise localization of the epileptogenic zone in the brain is necessary. The epileptogenic zone may be defined as the region of epileptogenic cerebral cortex whose removal will result in a seizure-free state. Second, one must determine the anatomic localization of eloquent cortex in the brain in order to spare these areas during any planned cortical excision of epileptogenic cortex. Several diagnostic measures may be used to achieve a successful surgical outcome. A clinical history to ascertain the earliest symptom in the clinical progression of the seizure (semiology) is imperative as is ictal and interictal scalp EEG, neuropsychological testing, magnetic resonance imaging, positron emission tomography, single photon emission computerized tomography, and interictal magnetoencephalography. In the typical child undergoing evaluation for epilepsy surgery, if the clinical, neuropsychological, EEG, and radiological data are all concordant and point to the same area of epileptogenicity in the brain, cortical excision of the suspected epileptogenic zone is undertaken. However, if the data are discordant, and/or the epileptogenic zone resides wholly or in part within eloquent cortex, invasive intracranial monitoring from depth and/or subdural electrodes during a seizure is required to map out the areas of epileptogenicity in the brain. The assessment of potential risks and benefits for this type of epilepsy surgery in children involves complex age-related issues, including the possible impact of uncontrolled seizures, medication, or surgery on learning and development.

Surgical indication for refractory childhood epilepsy

Recent progress in surgical intervention for medically refractory epilepsy has helped to shed light on more complex epileptogenic problems in children and infants. Surgical treatment increasingly is being used in pediatric patients, but the indications for surgery in this age group have not been well defined. The developing child with a seizure disorder has several problems that are different from adults, such as neural plasticity, deleterious effects of seizures on developmental status, and spontaneous resolution of epilepsy. The critical age for irreversible brain dysfunction and the timing of surgery are the main issues for the treatment of children. Thus, earlier surgical intervention is generally recommended to prevent further detrimental seizure effects, but we still do not know the optimal age. Until the establishment of guidelines for pediatric epilepsy surgery, surgical indications should be determined by the prognosis and the presence of a resectable epileptogenic focus, which in turn are based on the localization of the epileptic focus, seizure frequency, severity, and cognitive function of each case, rather than just the patient's age.

Surgery for malformations of cortical development causing epilepsy

Malformations of cortical development (MCD) are responsible for many cases of refractory epilepsy in adults and children. The results of surgical treatment are difficult to assess from the published literature. Judging from the limited number of adequately reported cases, approximately 40% of all cases of MCD treated surgically may be rendered seizure-free over a minimum 2-year follow-up period. This figure is the same for focal cortical dysplasia (FCD), the most common variety of MCD in surgical reports. In comparison with outcome for epilepsy associated with hippocampal sclerosis, this figure is low. Part of the difference may be artificial and related to limited reporting. Much of the difference is likely to relate to the complex underlying biology of MCD. Analysis of epileptogenesis in MCD has been undertaken. Different types of MCD have different sequelae. Some varieties are intrinsically epileptogenic; these include FCD and heterotopia. Although in most cases, the visualized MCD lies within the region of brain responsible for generating seizures (the epileptogenic zone), it may not constitute the entire epileptogenic zone in all cases. For polymicrogyria and schizencephaly in particular, the visualized abnormalities are probably not the most important component of the epileptogenic zone. There is evidence that the epileptogenic zone is spatially distributed and also, in some cases, temporally distributed. These findings may explain poor surgical outcome and the inadequacy of current presurgical evaluative methods. New preoperative techniques offer the opportunity of improved presurgical planning and selection of cases more likely to be rendered seizure-free by current surgical techniques. Of paramount importance is improved reporting. The establishment of a central registry may facilitate this aim. Specific recommendations are made for surgical strategies based on current experience and understanding.

Disorders of cortical development

It is only a decade since the realization (facilitated by magnetic resonance imaging) in early 1990s that disorders of cortical development occupy an important place in the aetiologic categorization of epilepsy. Since then research has demonstrated the intrinsic epileptogenicity of disorders of cortical development, their genetic bases and their functional properties. Some of the key points of this most exciting medical and scientific enterprise are reviewed here, with an emphasis in the advances seen within the past 2 years.

Monitoring and management of the paediatric neurosurgical patient

Head injury remains the most common cause of death in children, and tumours of the central nervous system are the most common solid tumour encountered. There is little class 1 evidence on which to base the monitoring and management of the paediatric patient with these conditions, management strategies commonly being extrapolated from those in use for adults. However, the clinical outcome for these conditions appears to be improving, with evidence suggesting that this improvement is being achieved by the management of these children in specialist centres.

Multimodal imaging in psychiatry: the electroencephalogram as a complement to other modalities

The use of different imaging modalities provides the clinician and researcher with different views of anatomy and physiology at unprecedented levels of detail. Multimodal imaging allows for noninvasive measurement of structure and function in humans during complex behavior, and thus provides information about the inner workings of the brain previously unavailable. The present paper examines the various imaging techniques available, and describes their application to the clinic-in the case of epilepsy-and to research-in the case of schizophrenia. Because the electroencephalogram has a dynamic response in milliseconds, it provides the best temporal sensitivity of functional measures of brain activity. When coupled with high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging measures of brain structure, this multimodal approach provides a powerful tool for understanding brain activity. Clinically, the use of multimodal imaging has provided greater precision in localization of the epileptogenic focus. For researchers attempting to determine the underlying causes of schizophrenia, the use of multimodal imaging has helped lead the field away from a specific lesion view to a more distributed system abnormality view of this disorder.